You were my professor at McGill in the early 2000s, I took your Chemistry of Food course. It was was one of the most fascinating and engaging courses I took. ✨ Could electrolysis be effective in producing the Hydrogen and its theorised benefits?
Hey Doc! Can you do a segment on selenium sulfide? Cheers! I have read online that it is carcinogenic. Is this true? It seems to work wonders for my dandruff and helping with itchy skin issues. I was told to switch to selenium sulfide as opposed to head and shoulders as a pharmacist told me the latter can cause irritation for some people.
You sitting here and simply speculating is exactly what quackery is. Hydrogenated water is not made by adding native Mg to water, it is made using electrolysis.
@@MrJerry8159until it was proven it was only a placebo effect then it'd stop working. It's a strange one the placebo effect it's actually fascinating.
Makes sense…this guy is representing a newspaper. Prob paid off to make people believe anything natural that’s healthy is quackery. I mean he even has the duck, so he can use that term. That bought and paid Drs and media personnel have used for decades. If anything this strengthens my belief in it.
The only true hydrogenated water comes from the water being electrolyzed; not by having magnesium added, and I have the Kangen vwater machine that does just that. I have used it for 5 years and it does exactly what they say it can do. It revitalizes every organ in your body and gives you energy galore. Arthritis pain slowly disappears. Spectacular water because its like nature in a box, no added chemicals.
Hydrogen is very soluble in water under normal air pressure, elevation and room temperature up to 1.6ppm or 1600ppb in fact. Electrolysis is a much preferred process to metallic tasting magnesium tablets with toxic coatings. Studies have been conducted in Asia foe my than half a century, in fact, the government is official supporting and funding many of those studies which have been published in nature and other very reputable publications. Some of the people involved have been awarded with noble prices because of the contribution they made to science and human health. If 99% of the molecules in our bodies are water molecules and a water molecule is one oxygen atom and two hydrogen atoms, it becomes quickly apparent that hydrogen had a very important role for us. Oxygen is sufficiently available in the air, hydrogen is not.
I have been working for years with electrolysis, and it's easy to do in a dy project, but no commercial 😢and the hard part is to hold the hydrogen because it can go through easy. But the fact is that water has the hydrogen in their composition, and it can hold no more. Just like he said in the video, it will evaporate .😅 Maybe if you sniff at the moment that it's processing, but before you try it, grab the gas and send for a test. 😅
Honest question here, do you think you drank the same amount of water prior to this? I'm quite intrigued by this but with anything, I am skeptical so I'm trying to find some answers from those who have used it.
@@Rangpariyapriyanshu I have taken magnesium for decades with improvements in my health. 350-400 enzymatic processes in your body need magnesium to work properly.
Why not drink water enhanced with KOH or NaOH? Drinking water slightly basic would have much more hydrogen atoms that could be achieved with a magnesium stick.
Don't throw out the dog along with the baby in the bathwater. Use a sieve! Also if you drink allot of hydrogenated water, don't smoke. Remember the Hindenburg.
😂😂😂. he basically is saying: “ i saw the studies, scientific studies. But i think it’s quackery “. He gives no arguments, no real reasons why he dislikes it. he just pulls his opinion out of his a**. I think he is the quack. 😂😂
You should research it a little more if you don’t mind me saying so. Gary Breka and professor Andrew Huberman have done extensive studies. I am living proof as I have suffered and do suffer with chronic inflammatory disease and since I drank this my CRP dropped immediately xx
WAIT-A-Minuet............ Maybe we should be drinking the baby's bath water because anyone with a degree in plumbing knows that your water heater has a magnesium anode rod in it, so there is no need to purchase anything else. Bonus points for electric water heaters because you end up with a bit of electrolysis going too!
This is a very limitted and non conclussive review by someone with limitted knowledge on the subject and kitchen methods of determining what is what.. There are over 130 studies that prove the benefits. I would not be too quick to listen to this man on this subject and most definately listen to more qualified experts if you want the whole truth.
Hydrogen is best to breathe in, there are already hundreds of studies on this topic with positive results. People have always had a negative attitude towards all new products ; )
The bubbles certainly are highly flammable. I had one of these hydrogen cells pumping the gas into my cars intake manifold. It increased my milage and kept my engine spotlessly clean.
What do you mean a "few questionable human studies"? I can see many studies from reputable universities that are randomized double-blind and placebo-controlled. And from many different countries. It's important to note that the mechanism by which such small concentrations of hydrogen (parts per billion) can affect the body is not yet fully understood. This has led to some skepticism in parts of the scientific community. However, dismissing the potential benefits based solely on the low concentration may be premature, as there are other examples in biology where trace amounts of substances can have significant effects.
To come here and Quack is not helping,Get Hydrogen water study it ,drink it then come back here and tell us facts of what it does to you cause if many people including myself say to you, the effects of Hydrogen water is immense and has everlasting benefits then what do you have to say to that.?🤔🙄
This was the most unscientific review from someone who thinks he's smart for reading something and not actually testing it. If the science has been tested and is sound, everything that came out of your mouth is "quakery"
Very sober analysis doc.Not ready to have a lot of faith in its efficacy,but in theory they are able to entertain positive results but seems too negligible at this point.
Somehow I picked up some vibes somewhere that this guy likes rubber ducks :) But seriously, between this stick, and the other "hydrogen water" sales forces out there, there is nothing but a lot of hot air.....er......hydrogen gas......floating around in this marketing ploy, and it goes back to the old "a fool and his money are soon parted" saying.
I’ve taken chemistry years ago. Hydrogen and oxygen bond to form water. It is about as perfect a bond you can get. So I’ve questioned if you can even get extra hydrogen this way. It sounds like a lot BS to me. Seen one man claim it adds an extra hydrogen to the water molecule. May need someone with more chemistry knowledge, but I don’t think that is possible. Maybe better off saving your money.
Molecular hydrogen (h2) is not elemental hydrogen (h1)……… if you took chemistry- you know this… all any of these tools do is create h2 gas which can then be consumed through drinking.
Looks like you need to go back to school if you don’t understand. Plus there’s a bunch of ways to test for the hydrogen in the water. You sound like an idiot
There are over 2500 peer-reviewed scientific articles and many well-controlled human studies on the benefits of hydrogen consumption, some published in prestigious journals like Nature Medicine. Despite this, he refuses to adapt and sounds like a quack.
@@Ashes-bi4ig and how many of these papers have u read yourself? Just bcos there are 2000+ research papers does not make them true! If this thing was truly effective, I know one thing.. it will not be out there easily! It would be suppressed!
I see a lot of negative reviews here, but one thing I noticed is that people are not good at listening! This man mentioned one very important point which anyone with a brain should be concerned! Hydrogen is NOT SOLUBLE in water! Wow! Then my friends who use these bottles, how then do you take in the generated hydrogen molecules which by the way would have escaped 90%???? Ok lets even assume you are able to get it into your system,. them how will it be absorbed into your blood since its water insoluble????? I think something else is going on with these bottles! We need truthful investigation to actually know whats happening!
Wouldn’t be better just to take magnesium supplements and drink regular water?
That's a lot more expensive long term
We are all lacking in magnesium and iodine. Just take the supplements and use Reverse osmosis to clean your water.
would it be better to put a pinch of celtic salt in your glass of water ,as this salt has 3 molecules of magnesium,helping the body to absorb water
You were my professor at McGill in the early 2000s, I took your Chemistry of Food course. It was was one of the most fascinating and engaging courses I took. ✨ Could electrolysis be effective in producing the Hydrogen and its theorised benefits?
Can you add magnesium to your water in trace amounts and would that work better?
You actually DID throw the baby out with the bath water. 100% opinion… zero research.
Hey Doc! Can you do a segment on selenium sulfide? Cheers! I have read online that it is carcinogenic. Is this true? It seems to work wonders for my dandruff and helping with itchy skin issues. I was told to switch to selenium sulfide as opposed to head and shoulders as a pharmacist told me the latter can cause irritation for some people.
I have used my new Hydrogen water bottle several times but I get very dehydrated. Could this be due to my taking Magnesium twice a day?.
It's probably because you are using a cheap hydrogen water bottle that produces Chlorine
You sitting here and simply speculating is exactly what quackery is. Hydrogenated water is not made by adding native Mg to water, it is made using electrolysis.
Is this so difficult to actually add what you’ve just bought to a glass of water and measure the hydrogen content?
It's a known fact that the placebo effect can improve your health.
Even if it is only a placebo effect, you would feel just as good as if it worked. Not saying it's a placebo effect but what is the problem if it was?
@@MrJerry8159 Exactly!
@@MrJerry8159until it was proven it was only a placebo effect then it'd stop working. It's a strange one the placebo effect it's actually fascinating.
Plus it may help you drink more water. I guess its not bad if it doesn't cost much and doesn't harm you.
Makes sense…this guy is representing a newspaper. Prob paid off to make people believe anything natural that’s healthy is quackery. I mean he even has the duck, so he can use that term. That bought and paid Drs and media personnel have used for decades.
If anything this strengthens my belief in it.
Thank you for your time, most of the reviews iv`e seen were from companies selling a product of course its going to save humanity.
What about hydrogen tablets?
The only true hydrogenated water comes from the water being electrolyzed; not by having magnesium added, and I have the Kangen vwater machine that does just that. I have used it for 5 years and it does exactly what they say it can do. It revitalizes every organ in your body and gives you energy galore. Arthritis pain slowly disappears. Spectacular water because its like nature in a box, no added chemicals.
Sorry but it sounds to good to be true.
They said the same thing about Radithor
All QUACKERY
I Have also Kangen water machine, but doesn't have feature H2, and Kangen water machine only makes Alkaline Ionized Water.
You should have all gotten a Tyent!
Hydrogen is very soluble in water under normal air pressure, elevation and room temperature up to 1.6ppm or 1600ppb in fact. Electrolysis is a much preferred process to metallic tasting magnesium tablets with toxic coatings. Studies have been conducted in Asia foe my than half a century, in fact, the government is official supporting and funding many of those studies which have been published in nature and other very reputable publications. Some of the people involved have been awarded with noble prices because of the contribution they made to science and human health.
If 99% of the molecules in our bodies are water molecules and a water molecule is one oxygen atom and two hydrogen atoms, it becomes quickly apparent that hydrogen had a very important role for us. Oxygen is sufficiently available in the air, hydrogen is not.
Couldn’t you just drink more water if you want more hydrogen?
I have been working for years with electrolysis, and it's easy to do in a dy project, but no commercial 😢and the hard part is to hold the hydrogen because it can go through easy. But the fact is that water has the hydrogen in their composition, and it can hold no more. Just like he said in the video, it will evaporate .😅
Maybe if you sniff at the moment that it's processing, but before you try it, grab the gas and send for a test. 😅
Quackery? Proof in the pudding. I've noticed better clarity an sleep (BEFORE I KNEW WHAT THE BENEFITS ARE) ... think you missed it on this one Doc
can I ask what bottle you use? There are so many to choose from :)
I use Ocemida and it’s one of the few that are tested and backed by a hydrogen scientist group. It’s quite amazing.
@@heatherjennings3516 I can second Ocemida. I did a lot of research and it works well for me.
He's obviously not a doctor or even a scientist for that matter. A fraud.
Honest question here, do you think you drank the same amount of water prior to this? I'm quite intrigued by this but with anything, I am skeptical so I'm trying to find some answers from those who have used it.
What about taking magnesium as a dietary supplement?
Why not. If you want to get respiratory arrest, surely you can drink magnesium and water
I drink magnesium 17 years already@@Rangpariyapriyanshu
@@JohnsonJ-ds1dyIt’s great., I take citrate magnesium “ Calm” after dinner, and it relaxes Me✨🙏
@@Rangpariyapriyanshu I have taken magnesium for decades with improvements in my health. 350-400 enzymatic processes in your body need magnesium to work properly.
Why not drink water enhanced with KOH or NaOH? Drinking water slightly basic would have much more hydrogen atoms that could be achieved with a magnesium stick.
The humour peaked:-
Last 10 secs: and where you are supposed to stick it.
🙌🏻
How do you get extra hydrogen from water to make water hydrogen rich with those hydrogen water bottles, it makes little sense
Electrolysis. It’s actually quite simple if you’re not an idiot
@@SauerkrautX Wow! You could have just answered the question without the insult.
@SauerkrautX so why bother with the process, just drink more water, get more hydrogen
I highly recommend doing further study and research on your own without relying on this man's opinion or credentials!! Your health is worth it.
Don't throw out the dog along with the baby in the bathwater. Use a sieve! Also if you drink allot of hydrogenated water, don't smoke. Remember the Hindenburg.
i’m sorry could you elaborate here?
" if you drink allot of hydrogenated water, don't smoke "
Why ? It's antioxydant...
What of swallowing that magnesium rod and drink water
Tablets ?
😂😂😂. he basically is saying: “ i saw the studies, scientific studies. But i think it’s quackery “. He gives no arguments, no real reasons why he dislikes it. he just pulls his opinion out of his a**. I think he is the quack. 😂😂
He gave his arguments. “The placebo effect were not properly controlled”.
Use one of those hydrogen cups that adds 5000ppm of hydrogen to your water. That might be better then the magnesium stick
You should research it a little more if you don’t mind me saying so. Gary Breka and professor Andrew Huberman have done extensive studies. I am living proof as I have suffered and do suffer with chronic inflammatory disease and since I drank this my CRP dropped immediately xx
if you don't mind.
which product do you use?
Can you name the Product you use?
@@larryzeka5011 the answer is no ig.
Dude, both are scams. Fraud. Huberman speaks about nutrition, fasting, etc. wth harmful advices, while he is neurobiologist. Different field.
I always find it amusing when self-styled debunkders don't bother to learn about the actual scientific research.
Thanks 🙏
He’s lying. It’s so healing. Look into Brown’s Gas.
Hydrogen water heals, and it's amazing!
WAIT-A-Minuet............ Maybe we should be drinking the baby's bath water because anyone with a degree in plumbing knows that your water heater has a magnesium anode rod in it, so there is no need to purchase anything else. Bonus points for electric water heaters because you end up with a bit of electrolysis going too!
This is a very limitted and non conclussive review by someone with limitted knowledge on the subject and kitchen methods of determining what is what.. There are over 130 studies that prove the benefits. I would not be too quick to listen to this man on this subject and most definately listen to more qualified experts if you want the whole truth.
Studies on rats not humans
@@Jdkgndkh Ah you read all...over 130... Sorry if i don;t believe that.
@@iJay073 a simple google search could help you read less
Sorry but this info is not accurate on hydrogen water It’s a very real thing.
Hydrogen is best to breathe in, there are already hundreds of studies on this topic with positive results.
People have always had a negative attitude towards all new products ; )
Question, isn't hydrogen flammable?
Hydrogen is flammable at temperatures exceeding 500 degrees Celsius, but it is not flammable in water.
The bubbles certainly are highly flammable. I had one of these hydrogen cells pumping the gas into my cars intake manifold. It increased my milage and kept my engine spotlessly clean.
Spring water is the best.
I just love the way you explained this subject...Thank you very much Dr....
Didn’t really answer the question. We all know it imparts some hydrogen to the water. So what?
how about drinking hydrogen peroxide? would that have any effect?
What do you mean a "few questionable human studies"? I can see many studies from reputable universities that are randomized double-blind and placebo-controlled. And from many different countries.
It's important to note that the mechanism by which such small concentrations of hydrogen (parts per billion) can affect the body is not yet fully understood.
This has led to some skepticism in parts of the scientific community. However, dismissing the potential benefits based solely on the low concentration may be premature, as there are other examples in biology where trace amounts of substances can have significant effects.
Should you believe fiji water and this actually have a ph of 9.0? Lol
To come here and Quack is not helping,Get Hydrogen water study it ,drink it then come back here and tell us facts of what it does to you cause if many people including myself say to you, the effects of Hydrogen water is immense and has everlasting benefits then what do you have to say to that.?🤔🙄
Never heard such rubbish, this man probably thinks homeopathy is placebo also!
This was the most unscientific review from someone who thinks he's smart for reading something and not actually testing it. If the science has been tested and is sound, everything that came out of your mouth is "quakery"
what the heck is it with all those ducks
Very sober analysis doc.Not ready to have a lot of faith in its efficacy,but in theory they are able to entertain positive results but seems too negligible at this point.
Ask Gary brecka lol
I use drops of hydrogen peroxide in my drinking water.
Drinking the hydrogenized water is only half the equation,try listening to 999hrtz frequency music to reap full benefits.
He is not a very smart man at all....
Thank you! Great video
Gary Brecka treated Dana White’s neurodegeneration to the point of zero symptoms. He must know sth
He got Dana to eat right exercise and lose weight. Ladifreaking da
Somehow I picked up some vibes somewhere that this guy likes rubber ducks :) But seriously, between this stick, and the other "hydrogen water" sales forces out there, there is nothing but a lot of hot air.....er......hydrogen gas......floating around in this marketing ploy, and it goes back to the old "a fool and his money are soon parted" saying.
I have not seen any sticks being sold, just expensive bottles! Good idea hahaha
Thank you sir
I’ve taken chemistry years ago. Hydrogen and oxygen bond to form water. It is about as perfect a bond you can get. So I’ve questioned if you can even get extra hydrogen this way. It sounds like a lot BS to me. Seen one man claim it adds an extra hydrogen to the water molecule. May need someone with more chemistry knowledge, but I don’t think that is possible. Maybe better off saving your money.
Molecular hydrogen (h2) is not elemental hydrogen (h1)……… if you took chemistry- you know this… all any of these tools do is create h2 gas which can then be consumed through drinking.
Looks like you need to go back to school if you don’t understand. Plus there’s a bunch of ways to test for the hydrogen in the water. You sound like an idiot
Love your style
I’m not sure why r we watching a Guy who is out of shape and has a opinion about health
There are over 2500 peer-reviewed scientific articles and many well-controlled human studies on the benefits of hydrogen consumption, some published in prestigious journals like Nature Medicine. Despite this, he refuses to adapt and sounds like a quack.
How's is he out of shape?
@@Ashes-bi4ig and how many of these papers have u read yourself? Just bcos there are 2000+ research papers does not make them true! If this thing was truly effective, I know one thing.. it will not be out there easily! It would be suppressed!
Classic bait and switch from a doctor past his prime and afraid of getting passed over by innovation.
I see a lot of negative reviews here, but one thing I noticed is that people are not good at listening! This man mentioned one very important point which anyone with a brain should be concerned! Hydrogen is NOT SOLUBLE in water! Wow! Then my friends who use these bottles, how then do you take in the generated hydrogen molecules which by the way would have escaped 90%???? Ok lets even assume you are able to get it into your system,. them how will it be absorbed into your blood since its water insoluble????? I think something else is going on with these bottles! We need truthful investigation to actually know whats happening!
Enjoyed
A bit like yourself a 🦆
You would think the World Governments would make the water companies provide it free if its miraculous🧐
@GaryBrecka