I can't believe how amazing it would have been with Mitch fronting them. I'm also really glad he's got his head on straight and in a good place. Seems like a great dude.
I think that he and Gary are closer in tone atm in the studio…..but we shall know. I think VH wouldn’t have had another badly mixed album…or Mitch gets fired? lol. Missing VH…
OMG!!! That was incredible!!! 😳😳😲😲😲 I've seen Mitch Malloy's name pop up numerous times, but I've never heard him sing before. He's got some serious chops. 🤘🤘 I'm guessing this must've been around the time Sammy left; and before Gary Cherone?? 🤔🤔
he is a good Vocalist but he didn't fit himself in a proper band ... for me he Should have a big name with a good musicians around him ... he was lucky he worked with Eddie
Yes, I believe he was brought in for the Greatest Hits album before they decided on bringing DLR back for the two new tracks. Poor guy found out he wasnt in the band when he saw them on the MTV awardsd with Dave. Then after all that they went with Gary.
he should have a chance for one album ... but mitch never wanted to be in the band thats what i have heard ... he had a great vocals on that time and he was good for van halen.
I met Mitch a couple times when he was going through this. I went to college with his cousin (she was smokin hot too). They were from Dickinson, ND. We went to UND (Go Sioux!) I always felt so bad for him for all this BS he went through. Glad he at least got a chance to play with the great VH.
I've been in the music industry now a little over 45yrs and it's a shame that everyone says that they didn't like which directions the band was going. I loved Dave and Sammy but Malloy would have fit right in Perfect with his voice. You could tell right when he hit the first note with Eddie playing WOW what could of been
He’s got the right look, the right voice, can cover original and Sammy VH, but his songwriting, lyrics and hooks are pretty bland. Maybe with songwriting help it could have worked?
Eddie gave this song to Mitch with no vocals 9n it, after Mitcy turned down being in Van Halen. Van Halen took DLR to MTV that year and DLR ran his mouth off about recording new songs with VH for the greatest hits. Mitch saw that and turned down being in Van Halen. This track without the vocals, Eddie gave to Mitch and Mitch finished the song. This would have been a number 1 if they had released it. It's easy to hear Eddie's signature playing on this track. R.I.PM Eddie, ypu will always be remembeted. 😢
That didn’t suck. They need to release all demos and “nearly done” songs in the arsenal. For the almost done, get somebody in there and mix it and get it finished. It would sell 10 M and go diamond in no time.
Eddie made so many tunes according to his vocalist ... but i think he should have released one more album with gary cherone ... but critics were stupid.
his departure is sad for the real rock listeners ... he was a legendary guitarist with a creative mind to created some mind blowing riffs and solo ... he is still my favorite guitarist
This sounds like the song playing during an 80s movie montage when the “ugly girl“ takes off her glasses and shakes out her ponytail and she’s like knock out gorgeous
My friend i like the every tune of Eddy , i dont care who is on vocals , but the fact is that his melodic experiments with sammy Mitch and Gary were not good , Actually they were released on time when grunge Alternative Rock Nu metal came to scenes ... but i salute Eddy for making such a beautiful songs between those tough years ...
i think mitch was in his own Groove ... most vocals had that thing ... he should have worked with great musicians around him ... he is a quality vocalist
Mitch left because of the DLR “reunion”. Eddie didn’t discuss that with Mitch and he essentially learned about it from tv. All Mitch saw was that they were going to get back together with Dave so he decided to leave them to it. Plus I’m sure he didn’t want to be a part of any drama.
They were Surrounded by controversies ... Eddie wanted to work but his health and some of the vocalist had LSD issues ... he wanted to work with gary cherone but critics were crazy
Interesting, but it’s missing the VH sizzle. Where are Michael Anthony’s Vocals, Alex’s drum sounds, a blistering EVH solo? It seems like a throwaway demo and was never given much thought. It could have been better. It’s a VERY safe pop/rock song with no flair. I think Mitch Malloy is a very good vocalist, and maybe it could have worked had the missing VH ingredients been there, but they aren’t there.
@@80sRockheavymetal2it’s an interesting “could have been,” and I’d like to hear more. It does fall into the “safe” world of corporate rock that VH became with Sammy, but it is intriguing, nonetheless. Mitch’s style may have opened up a few areas that VH hadn’t explored at the time. Oh, well.
I LOVE this F'ing Lost VH song with Mitch's great vocals...Lyrics good as well...I'm glad I finally got to hear it complete...Sammy was right that that 1996 VH Greatest Hits compilation should have never happened especially with 2 new mediocre songs with Dave included (I never bothered buying it...)...It caused the band to fall apart...Who wrote these lyrics?
Gary Cherone said he didn't even like Van Halen Growing up . He was more of a Led Zeppelin / The Who kind of Guy Growing up . Gary purely got with VH for the money . If Mitch could have bought THIS kind of Lyric Writing to VH in 1998 ? VH iII would have been a 5 th Consecutive Number One Album straight for VH . 🚨👀🔥💥🤦💯😶🌫️🥰✨🌟⚡💫🤯🧐😳🫢🫡😵😉🤔🫣🤨🙊🙉🙈😍
i will disagree with that , mitch never wanted to be a band member , he wanted to get the fame through as solo artist , you know LSD case was common in Mitch ... he is a good vocalist but wasted himself with his own ego ..the melodies which Eddie Created with Gary in VHIII were amazing ... Songs like Once , From a Far , Josephina , Year of the day , believe me dave sammy neither mitch can hit those high notes vocals .... Eddie explored his vocal potential and he was happy to work with him ... in Several interviews Eddie said with Gary i have more range to create such songs which he wanted ...
@@80sRockheavymetal2 I'm one of the few that really liked that album. If there was ever an Eddie Van Halen solo record, that was it. It was such a departure from everything else that Van Halen did, I thought it was great. I know Eddie was going through some tough shit back then, I'd like to hear what they wrote for the second one, I know it's out there somewhere. I'll ask Nuno about it next time I see him.
@@80sRockheavymetal2 And trust me, RUclips comments are brutal. I used to just disregard them, now I go back at'em. Haha, great site man. I just subscribed.
David got limited range with his vocals and songs were on one pattern ... Gary Cherone and Sammy were Versatile in the vocal range so for me Eddie was Genius he used his vocals according to his composition needs.
@@80sRockheavymetal2 By 1996 Dave was mentally and vocally FINISHED...At his live solo shows in the 90s on he was awful and didn't even try to sing the songs correctly...Dave was finished after "Skyscraper"...Ironically the Skyscaper Tour was my favorite live all time show to see...
@@CrazyCooter-ld6sz LOL... He has a wife who's brother is both Van Halen's & Extreme's manager (at the time). Safe to assume that he would benefit from pulling strings and getting his client the gig.
Mitch was a good vocalist but he wasn't a proper band material like he always he had lead singer disease and thats why he wasted his voice ... i love his vocals but he couldn't justified it with his personal goals
VH is my favorite band, and EVH is the guy who inspired me to play guitar, and I think that while Malloy fits the band vocally, my understanding is that he's a pretty straight arrow. The band, on the other hand, was a total mess at the time. This wouldn't have worked long-term.
Band Wasn't it was record label issue , you know grunge and alternative rock was newly in the scene and producers managers were interested to promote that music ... on that time musicians like EVH struggles cause they had to make their music on their own also for promotion there was no proper social media platform the one we have nowadays ... whatever EVH recorded i love that
I like how Alex and Eddie try to make simple powerful licks...but subtlety throw progressive beat turn around. They want to stay "radio" while throwing a bone to the groove and musicians. This could have turned out to be a good band mix. Singer is good. The subject of the lyrics is a little cheesy. Should have changed the words to sometime more unique. But great nonetheless
Here’s a nice tip I learnt from my days songwriting. You should SHOW the listener instead of TELLING them. Create images, and let the listener use his own imagination to connect with what you are trying to say. This song is too level one. “The time is right now, are you happy in life? What about right now? There is no better time.” Yawn. Maybe why MM had no major hits on his own? He would do much better with Desmond Child writing his songs, and MM performing them. My 2 cents
It has promise, but VH needed another veteran rock singer-songwriter to take this further. Hagar might have been able to elevate it but that ship had sailed. Ed's issues aside, an Alex/Ed "solo" effort with guests might have been a better move than competing with their godlike legacy.
Eddie Experimented with is Vocals , After sammy , Gary cherone was perfect ... but lots of people didn't liked like him ... but that album VHIII was a masterpiece for me.
I wonder who might have been the perfect follow up to Hagar? Who, amongst veteran singers, could have been the right fit at the time? An interesting question to ponder.
@thelastperfectman4139 Aerosmith briefly considered Lenny Kravitz (and Hagar lol). That would've been a solid pick. Phenomenal singer who definitely could help finish songs. A consistent story is that singers turned them down because of too much drama and too big of a legacy to live up to
@@thelastperfectman4139 Gary cherone was perfect his vocal range suits for van halen sound but those critics were cruel ... otherwise we would few albums of VH with gary cherone ... VHIII was a masterpiece of Eddie.
If that’s have just gone forward from here they’d have done all right - but the asshole manager often to get David Lee Roth back (.which would have also been all right) but for only a sales pitch for the greatest hits record and poor Mitch ran for the hills … A Brilliant pile of talents… so poorly managed…
agreed with you ... managers weren't taking any risk cause that time grunge and nu metal started the scene ... thats why mitch and gary cherone were rejected by poor critics and brainless reviews ... for me VHIII is a masterpiece of Eddie and he claims in his interviews that there was nothing wrong with the album and songs but that album came in the wrong Era where Nu metal and grunge already grown up .... Eddie Explored the potential of Gary Cherone ... we know Gary is a Versatile singer ... Eddie wanted to work with Gary in the another cd in year between 2014 but his health was not that good .... About mitch such a great vocalist but couldnt made a mainstream impact ...
Malloy was a corny AI version of a front man. Everything too perfect, no hard edges. Looks like he spends all day on his hair. We didn't miss anything.
Agreed 100% Regardless of what people think of DLR...he brought out soemthing in the band that made them dangerous in a very unique way...they played with so much fire. After 1985...VH just felt very safe. Of course the playing was top shelf...it just didn't have any edges to it. Sammy is a better technical vocalist than DLR...but Dave's lyrics and showmanship crushed anything Sammy or Gary (or Mitch) brought to the table. I was lucky enough to see them in 81, 84, 88, 91, 96, 98, 07, 08, 12 and 15. So I saw them with all 3 singers and the early shows were hands down the best....and honestly the show with Gary was better than the Sammy shows because they played songs from the entire catalog which they barely touched when Sammy was in the band. I never cared to see or hear There's only One Way to Rock...or any of Sammy's solo songs for that material but they always stuck at least 1 of his tracks in the set. Just my opinion but the classic line up will always be the best
@@warborn_inc. you were lucky you saw them ... wow thats great , my personal opinion I wanted more albums with gary cherone on vocals but critics with their brainless issues ... david is a good vocalist but you will see one dimensional vocals ... no ballads no melody ... thats why with him VH never made a single ballad ....... gary cherone is a versatile vocalist that's why eddie brought him and he knew he is best for future albums .... but sad stupid brainless review people stops the work of Eddie.
Not a fan of vocals that blend into the guitar especially during the chorus They cancel each other out THAT'S why DLR will always be the best singer for the VH sound - his vocals stood out & the music held it's own So this song is a .05 on a 1-10 scale
in Some context i am agreed about david lee roth ... but david got limited range of vocals .. no melody in it , thats why he never made a quality single ballad ... cause his vocals range doesn't meet the requirements ... Sammy and Gary they are versatile Vocalists , that's why Eddie wanted to experiment with new sound with new vocalists ... i am giving you example of two songs from VH3 , once & From A far ... david dont have skills to provide quality vocals for songs like these .... i am not against him , i like his vocals but he is not a complete singer and its a fact.
@@80sRockheavymetal2 VH never did any ballads w DLR but it wasn't bcz of his voice It was bcz DLR didn't like being all lovey dovey He knew the band was about partying and having fun so that's why he wrote all those classics Ain't talking about love - Jamie's crying - on fire - atomic punk - mean streets - hear about it later - hang em high - the cradle will rock - running w the devil - girl gone bad - jump - panama - drop dead legs - so this is love He didn't give a flying F about romance bcz none of them did while they were together Had they never broke up we would have had & loved another five albums and never missed a ballad The closest VH came to anything resembling a relationship was Everybody Wants Some 😉 I call the Hagar era the gay era going ultra soft
@@tobiasfunke9473 Everybody got own likes and dislikes ... if you heard the interview of Eddie he said Gary is a flexible person who understands quickly that what i wanted to make , he said VH3 is a perfect album but critics and wanna be fans of David doesn't like that album ... for your information last album of Van halen with David .... he called gary to make one more album with him ... they recorded some demos and in future they will be out .... Eddie was a Van halen , david was just a singer , and Eddie knew what kind of vocalist he needs for specific songs ... thats why he wanted to record the album with gary in 2014-2015 ... he wanted to shape the different sound of Van halen with a flexibility in vocals .... but you are a fan of David it will be hard for you ... for me whatever Eddie played with his vocalists , i love his Each an single song or demo. for me they are gems in these days.
@@80sRockheavymetal2 I totally get it The only thing I questioned about VH III was that many songs has the old DLR era sound and it didn't work w cherone very well From Afar was their best song Plus by that time, Eddie's mind was so fkd up w drugs He got so bad that Sammy found him one time so gone out of his mind that he looked like he'd been living on the streets he didn't shower and lost many teeth U can tell when he would pull himself together he could produce some good music but when his mind was replaced by drugs again all his stuff was gibberish No melody no harmony just trying to put together a blanket from different materials that didn't go together So when Eddie got together w Sammy at first Sammy was the best he could write w and create music w - the best fit ever Then w cherone he said the exact same thing Had he gotten Patty Smythe to record w them he would have said the exact same thing Bcz his brain was fried by then I think Eddie knew how much people hated VH III and was probably trying to redeem himself by trying to create something that would prove him right It's common and normal for people to want to rectify their mistakes
@@tobiasfunke9473 For me David Era got one pattern songs party and fun stuff no melody in it .... in VHIII you will find all kind of songs thats why for me that CD is special , personally i dont care for critics and those wannabe review makers ... if you are listener if a tone catches your attetion that all matters ... everybody got own likes and dislikes and we can't force people to follow your likes ... everybody got own fun for listening and seeing things . we have to respect each other choice ... you have your listening criteria and i have my own ... good thing is that we should enjoy listening if tone is good bringing you the vibe what you are looking for that all matter for me.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Awesome Thanks For Uploading My Friend. R.I.P Eddie Van Halen.☝️
Glad you enjoyed it ... no problem my friend
I can't believe how amazing it would have been with Mitch fronting them. I'm also really glad he's got his head on straight and in a good place. Seems like a great dude.
I couldn’t agree more! And I love this song!!
I think that he and Gary are closer in tone atm in the studio…..but we shall know.
I think VH wouldn’t have had another badly mixed album…or Mitch gets fired? lol. Missing VH…
Sorry, folks --- I love Gary Cherone but after hearing this, it's pretty obvious Mitch Malloy shoulda been the new VH singer in 1998! 🤘❤🤘❤
Choice does matter my friend ...
It wouldn't have worked either
Well, we can blame Alex and Eddie for that. Mitch was on board until that whole DLR-MTV fiasco.
Eh... These lyrics are generic as fuck I'm glad they went with Gary
Sorry Gary was better, this isn't good at all.
OMG!!! That was incredible!!! 😳😳😲😲😲 I've seen Mitch Malloy's name pop up numerous times, but I've never heard him sing before. He's got some serious chops. 🤘🤘
I'm guessing this must've been around the time Sammy left; and before Gary Cherone?? 🤔🤔
he is a good Vocalist but he didn't fit himself in a proper band ... for me he Should have a big name with a good musicians around him ... he was lucky he worked with Eddie
Yes, I believe he was brought in for the Greatest Hits album before they decided on bringing DLR back for the two new tracks. Poor guy found out he wasnt in the band when he saw them on the MTV awardsd with Dave. Then after all that they went with Gary.
@@drmusic3641 That just sounds diabolical. 🤔😳 Kinda feel bad for him now. It's like, so close yet so far. 😕😕
He had a solo hit called Anything At All. Go listen to the vocals on that!
@shereemoskow Sounds like a plan. I will. 🙂🙂 Thanks for the suggestion. 🤘🤘
That tension chord at 1:21. You don't hear that kind of melodicism in rock or pop anymore. What a special writer Ed was.
Very Nice!
I have respect for Malloy. He saw what a looney bin the Van Halen camp was and had the brains to steer clear of it.
This sounds great. My gosh how did this not get released? Excellent vocal, melodic, and perfect blend with Ed's guitar.
he should have a chance for one album ... but mitch never wanted to be in the band thats what i have heard ... he had a great vocals on that time and he was good for van halen.
Wow, this guy had a great sound for the band--certainly has a very Hagar-ish sound.
I met Mitch a couple times when he was going through this. I went to college with his cousin (she was smokin hot too). They were from Dickinson, ND. We went to UND (Go Sioux!) I always felt so bad for him for all this BS he went through. Glad he at least got a chance to play with the great VH.
Beautiful work Eddie!!!
God I wish Mitch would release this as a single.
I wish so too. Doubt Al VH would allow it. If I remember right I think Mitch put it on Spotify or some platform a few years ago and it was taken down.
Me too
He did. It's on iTunes.
Those good old times when Mitch and Michael were still in the band. Love the bridge at 02:10.
Proof that Mitch Malloy was a better fit than Gary Cherone
Gary Cherone is a perfect band member and also versatile vocalist ... But Mitch was a good choice too ... I respect all musicians
It wouldn't be hard cherone is average
Si podría haber sido
He was absolutely a better fit for the band. He is a great artist when he does what he does though.
@@80sRockheavymetal2nope .Better song writer.
I've been in the music industry now a little over 45yrs and it's a shame that everyone says that they didn't like which directions the band was going. I loved Dave and Sammy but Malloy would have fit right in Perfect with his voice. You could tell right when he hit the first note with Eddie playing WOW what could of been
This guy was SO right for the band...
too cornball
Soooo cheesy 😂😂😂😂
He’s got the right look, the right voice, can cover original and Sammy VH, but his songwriting, lyrics and hooks are pretty bland. Maybe with songwriting help it could have worked?
Really great song!
Eddie gave this song to Mitch with no vocals 9n it, after Mitcy turned down being in Van Halen. Van Halen took DLR to MTV that year and DLR ran his mouth off about recording new songs with VH for the greatest hits. Mitch saw that and turned down being in Van Halen. This track without the vocals, Eddie gave to Mitch and Mitch finished the song. This would have been a number 1 if they had released it. It's easy to hear Eddie's signature playing on this track. R.I.PM Eddie, ypu will always be remembeted. 😢
whoever came in VH they got fame through eddie ... the skillful down to earth musician i ever know.
That would explain why they were so pissed at Dave
This would've been #1 ?
That didn’t suck.
They need to release all demos and “nearly done” songs in the arsenal. For the almost done, get somebody in there and mix it and get it finished.
It would sell 10 M and go diamond in no time.
This is the riff from That’s Why I Love You - unreleased track from VH3!
Eddie made so many tunes according to his vocalist ... but i think he should have released one more album with gary cherone ... but critics were stupid.
It wasnt the critics. It was the VH fans who derailed Gary's turn as vocalist.
A TV producer I work with in Daytona Beach just told me her best friend in HS married Mitch Malloy.
If only Ed would be around...imagine all the magic we would hear.
his departure is sad for the real rock listeners ... he was a legendary guitarist with a creative mind to created some mind blowing riffs and solo ... he is still my favorite guitarist
@@80sRockheavymetal2 mine too!!!🙂
I hear shades of “Top of the world” in this. Anyone else?
I hear more "That's Why I Love You"...
@@jbacker1190yes, same music different melody and lyrics
I love the music, the message, the vocals... everything!
Wow. Loved it. Its ashame it didnt last
This sounds like the song playing during an 80s movie montage when the “ugly girl“ takes off her glasses and shakes out her ponytail and she’s like knock out gorgeous
My friend i like the every tune of Eddy , i dont care who is on vocals , but the fact is that his melodic experiments with sammy Mitch and Gary were not good , Actually they were released on time when grunge Alternative Rock Nu metal came to scenes ... but i salute Eddy for making such a beautiful songs between those tough years ...
PERFECTO
This rhythm was definitely used in the first two tracks on Vanhalen 3.
Puzzling as to why Eddie didnt think this pairing would work.
i think mitch was in his own Groove ... most vocals had that thing ... he should have worked with great musicians around him ... he is a quality vocalist
I think it was the hair competition 😂
All Glam bands brought was same in 80's ... i still love that Era , Cause their music was True and original. @@mariateresasalvi9672
The band brought DLR to the MTV Music awards and Malloy bowed out of the deal.
Mitch left because of the DLR “reunion”. Eddie didn’t discuss that with Mitch and he essentially learned about it from tv. All Mitch saw was that they were going to get back together with Dave so he decided to leave them to it. Plus I’m sure he didn’t want to be a part of any drama.
❤❤❤
This is right
I suspect Eddie did all the instruments on this song. Just like he did everything on VHIII. It's a hit fo sho.
yeah in studio he created all that stuff ... he was a master and creative
❤🐀
It's a shame that the band took DLR to the MTV awards that year and gave Mitch Malloy a good reason to decline the offer.
They were Surrounded by controversies ... Eddie wanted to work but his health and some of the vocalist had LSD issues ... he wanted to work with gary cherone but critics were crazy
That's pretty great
There is another version of this song with diferent lyrics, but this one is way better!
👍🇹🇷👍nice😮
Interesting, but it’s missing the VH sizzle. Where are Michael Anthony’s Vocals, Alex’s drum sounds, a blistering EVH solo? It seems like a throwaway demo and was never given much thought. It could have been better. It’s a VERY safe pop/rock song with no flair. I think Mitch Malloy is a very good vocalist, and maybe it could have worked had the missing VH ingredients been there, but they aren’t there.
Mitch was lucky he worked with Eddie and yeah its a rough demo just to check his vocals , but mitch never wanted to be in the any band
@@80sRockheavymetal2it’s an interesting “could have been,” and I’d like to hear more. It does fall into the “safe” world of corporate rock that VH became with Sammy, but it is intriguing, nonetheless. Mitch’s style may have opened up a few areas that VH hadn’t explored at the time. Oh, well.
Definitely sounds like a throw away demo!
Oh man, what could have been.
OMG ❤
What might have been. 😢
I LOVE this F'ing Lost VH song with Mitch's great vocals...Lyrics good as well...I'm glad I finally got to hear it complete...Sammy was right that that 1996 VH Greatest Hits compilation should have never happened especially with 2 new mediocre songs with Dave included (I never bothered buying it...)...It caused the band to fall apart...Who wrote these lyrics?
Gary Cherone said he didn't even like Van Halen Growing up . He was more of a Led Zeppelin / The Who kind of Guy Growing up . Gary purely got with VH for the money . If Mitch could have bought THIS kind of Lyric Writing to VH in 1998 ? VH iII would have been a 5 th Consecutive Number One Album straight for VH . 🚨👀🔥💥🤦💯😶🌫️🥰✨🌟⚡💫🤯🧐😳🫢🫡😵😉🤔🫣🤨🙊🙉🙈😍
i will disagree with that , mitch never wanted to be a band member , he wanted to get the fame through as solo artist , you know LSD case was common in Mitch ... he is a good vocalist but wasted himself with his own ego ..the melodies which Eddie Created with Gary in VHIII were amazing ... Songs like Once , From a Far , Josephina , Year of the day , believe me dave sammy neither mitch can hit those high notes vocals .... Eddie explored his vocal potential and he was happy to work with him ... in Several interviews Eddie said with Gary i have more range to create such songs which he wanted ...
@@80sRockheavymetal2100% agree with your assessment.
@@DougCanney1 if critics were not cruel he would have recorded more albums with Gary.
@@80sRockheavymetal2 I'm one of the few that really liked that album. If there was ever an Eddie Van Halen solo record, that was it. It was such a departure from everything else that Van Halen did, I thought it was great. I know Eddie was going through some tough shit back then, I'd like to hear what they wrote for the second one, I know it's out there somewhere. I'll ask Nuno about it next time I see him.
@@80sRockheavymetal2 And trust me, RUclips comments are brutal. I used to just disregard them, now I go back at'em. Haha, great site man. I just subscribed.
Unpopular opinion but Mitch might be a better fit for the band than DLR himself
David got limited range with his vocals and songs were on one pattern ... Gary Cherone and Sammy were Versatile in the vocal range so for me Eddie was Genius he used his vocals according to his composition needs.
@@80sRockheavymetal2 By 1996 Dave was mentally and vocally FINISHED...At his live solo shows in the 90s on he was awful and didn't even try to sing the songs correctly...Dave was finished after "Skyscraper"...Ironically the Skyscaper Tour was my favorite live all time show to see...
What I understand, Extremes manager was Alex's brother in law and that's why Charone was favored for the gig.
Alex has a sister?
@@CrazyCooter-ld6sz
LOL... He has a wife who's brother is both Van Halen's & Extreme's manager (at the time). Safe to assume that he would benefit from pulling strings and getting his client the gig.
In another universe, where Ed overcomes his demons, Mitch would have given this band another successful run after Sammy.
Mitch was a good vocalist but he wasn't a proper band material like he always he had lead singer disease and thats why he wasted his voice ... i love his vocals but he couldn't justified it with his personal goals
VH is my favorite band, and EVH is the guy who inspired me to play guitar, and I think that while Malloy fits the band vocally, my understanding is that he's a pretty straight arrow. The band, on the other hand, was a total mess at the time. This wouldn't have worked long-term.
Band Wasn't it was record label issue , you know grunge and alternative rock was newly in the scene and producers managers were interested to promote that music ... on that time musicians like EVH struggles cause they had to make their music on their own also for promotion there was no proper social media platform the one we have nowadays ... whatever EVH recorded i love that
Why no Mikey singing the high harmonies?
Did Dave and Sammy have a kid??? Sounds like it!!
It actually sounds like Gary a bit.
Why didn't this guy join any way? Nice song but where was the guitar solo?
❤🎉😊
no escucho a Michael Anthony
Eddie’s coke tone
It would have been the Maloy era of VH
Good fit
I like how Alex and Eddie try to make simple powerful licks...but subtlety throw progressive beat turn around. They want to stay "radio" while throwing a bone to the groove and musicians. This could have turned out to be a good band mix. Singer is good. The subject of the lyrics is a little cheesy. Should have changed the words to sometime more unique. But great nonetheless
Not bad
Here’s a nice tip I learnt from my days songwriting. You should SHOW the listener instead of TELLING them. Create images, and let the listener use his own imagination to connect with what you are trying to say. This song is too level one. “The time is right now, are you happy in life? What about right now? There is no better time.” Yawn. Maybe why MM had no major hits on his own? He would do much better with Desmond Child writing his songs, and MM performing them. My 2 cents
Thankfully this lineup never happened. Have some cheese with your Van Halen 😆
It has promise, but VH needed another veteran rock singer-songwriter to take this further. Hagar might have been able to elevate it but that ship had sailed. Ed's issues aside, an Alex/Ed "solo" effort with guests might have been a better move than competing with their godlike legacy.
Eddie Experimented with is Vocals , After sammy , Gary cherone was perfect ... but lots of people didn't liked like him ... but that album VHIII was a masterpiece for me.
I wonder who might have been the perfect follow up to Hagar? Who, amongst veteran singers, could have been the right fit at the time? An interesting question to ponder.
@thelastperfectman4139 Aerosmith briefly considered Lenny Kravitz (and Hagar lol). That would've been a solid pick. Phenomenal singer who definitely could help finish songs. A consistent story is that singers turned them down because of too much drama and too big of a legacy to live up to
@@thelastperfectman4139 Gary cherone was perfect his vocal range suits for van halen sound but those critics were cruel ... otherwise we would few albums of VH with gary cherone ... VHIII was a masterpiece of Eddie.
Too pop. 😮
Once he starts singing, it's every generic 80s sitcom intro...
ruclips.net/video/0c2vcG4kV_o/видео.htmlsi=GyN9lCl7NDfmNZ0Q
zzzzz we didn't miss anything if you ask me
If that’s have just gone forward from here they’d have done all right - but the asshole manager often to get David Lee Roth back (.which would have also been all right) but for only a sales pitch for the greatest hits record and poor Mitch ran for the hills
…
A Brilliant pile of talents… so poorly managed…
agreed with you ... managers weren't taking any risk cause that time grunge and nu metal started the scene ... thats why mitch and gary cherone were rejected by poor critics and brainless reviews ... for me VHIII is a masterpiece of Eddie and he claims in his interviews that there was nothing wrong with the album and songs but that album came in the wrong Era where Nu metal and grunge already grown up .... Eddie Explored the potential of Gary Cherone ... we know Gary is a Versatile singer ... Eddie wanted to work with Gary in the another cd in year between 2014 but his health was not that good .... About mitch such a great vocalist but couldnt made a mainstream impact ...
Malloy was a corny AI version of a front man. Everything too perfect, no hard edges. Looks like he spends all day on his hair. We didn't miss anything.
As a lifelong VH fan, I never would’ve bought this.
I don’t believe any of this MM bs. Never heard anyone mention him but himself.
A good, generic singer. Too much pop, not enough rock
💯💩💩💩THIS SOUNDS HORRIBLE!! IM GLAD IT WASN'T RELEASED
Believe me its a worth listening than nowadays copycat bands ...
Phew, lucky Gary showed up, this is very 80's Winger/ Whitesnake cringey.
Sounds like Survivor. Decent song but not for Van Halen
Mitch got the vocals but he never wanted to be a band members ... he wanted to make his name as a solo artist .
Mediocre, there is no Van Halen like the original
Agreed with you
Agreed 100% Regardless of what people think of DLR...he brought out soemthing in the band that made them dangerous in a very unique way...they played with so much fire. After 1985...VH just felt very safe. Of course the playing was top shelf...it just didn't have any edges to it. Sammy is a better technical vocalist than DLR...but Dave's lyrics and showmanship crushed anything Sammy or Gary (or Mitch) brought to the table.
I was lucky enough to see them in 81, 84, 88, 91, 96, 98, 07, 08, 12 and 15. So I saw them with all 3 singers and the early shows were hands down the best....and honestly the show with Gary was better than the Sammy shows because they played songs from the entire catalog which they barely touched when Sammy was in the band. I never cared to see or hear There's only One Way to Rock...or any of Sammy's solo songs for that material but they always stuck at least 1 of his tracks in the set. Just my opinion but the classic line up will always be the best
@@warborn_inc. you were lucky you saw them ... wow thats great , my personal opinion I wanted more albums with gary cherone on vocals but critics with their brainless issues ... david is a good vocalist but you will see one dimensional vocals ... no ballads no melody ... thats why with him VH never made a single ballad ....... gary cherone is a versatile vocalist that's why eddie brought him and he knew he is best for future albums .... but sad stupid brainless review people stops the work of Eddie.
@@80sRockheavymetal2 Van Halen and ballads should never be in the same discussion. Who the hell wants ballads from VH?
lyrics are terrible
eewwww! doesn't even sound like Van Halen.
First time I ever heard this sorry this guy cannot touch David Lee Roth or Sammy Hagar he is better than Gary Cherone
but Mitch never wanted to be in a Band , he always had LSD issue
This is the most generic Van Halen ever sounded. I'm glad this guy didn't get the job.
Not a fan of vocals that blend into the guitar especially during the chorus
They cancel each other out
THAT'S why DLR will always be the best singer for the VH sound - his vocals stood out & the music held it's own
So this song is a .05 on a 1-10 scale
in Some context i am agreed about david lee roth ... but david got limited range of vocals .. no melody in it , thats why he never made a quality single ballad ... cause his vocals range doesn't meet the requirements ... Sammy and Gary they are versatile Vocalists , that's why Eddie wanted to experiment with new sound with new vocalists ... i am giving you example of two songs from VH3 , once & From A far ... david dont have skills to provide quality vocals for songs like these .... i am not against him , i like his vocals but he is not a complete singer and its a fact.
@@80sRockheavymetal2 VH never did any ballads w DLR but it wasn't bcz of his voice
It was bcz DLR didn't like being all lovey dovey
He knew the band was about partying and having fun so that's why he wrote all those classics
Ain't talking about love - Jamie's crying - on fire - atomic punk - mean streets - hear about it later - hang em high - the cradle will rock - running w the devil - girl gone bad - jump - panama - drop dead legs - so this is love
He didn't give a flying F about romance bcz none of them did while they were together
Had they never broke up we would have had & loved another five albums and never missed a ballad
The closest VH came to anything resembling a relationship was Everybody Wants Some 😉
I call the Hagar era the gay era going ultra soft
@@tobiasfunke9473 Everybody got own likes and dislikes ... if you heard the interview of Eddie he said Gary is a flexible person who understands quickly that what i wanted to make , he said VH3 is a perfect album but critics and wanna be fans of David doesn't like that album ... for your information last album of Van halen with David .... he called gary to make one more album with him ... they recorded some demos and in future they will be out .... Eddie was a Van halen , david was just a singer , and Eddie knew what kind of vocalist he needs for specific songs ... thats why he wanted to record the album with gary in 2014-2015 ... he wanted to shape the different sound of Van halen with a flexibility in vocals .... but you are a fan of David it will be hard for you ... for me whatever Eddie played with his vocalists , i love his Each an single song or demo. for me they are gems in these days.
@@80sRockheavymetal2 I totally get it
The only thing I questioned about VH III was that many songs has the old DLR era sound and it didn't work w cherone very well
From Afar was their best song
Plus by that time, Eddie's mind was so fkd up w drugs
He got so bad that Sammy found him one time so gone out of his mind that he looked like he'd been living on the streets he didn't shower and lost many teeth
U can tell when he would pull himself together he could produce some good music but when his mind was replaced by drugs again all his stuff was gibberish
No melody no harmony just trying to put together a blanket from different materials that didn't go together
So when Eddie got together w Sammy at first Sammy was the best he could write w and create music w - the best fit ever
Then w cherone he said the exact same thing
Had he gotten Patty Smythe to record w them he would have said the exact same thing
Bcz his brain was fried by then
I think Eddie knew how much people hated VH III and was probably trying to redeem himself by trying to create something that would prove him right
It's common and normal for people to want to rectify their mistakes
@@tobiasfunke9473 For me David Era got one pattern songs party and fun stuff no melody in it .... in VHIII you will find all kind of songs thats why for me that CD is special , personally i dont care for critics and those wannabe review makers ... if you are listener if a tone catches your attetion that all matters ... everybody got own likes and dislikes and we can't force people to follow your likes ... everybody got own fun for listening and seeing things . we have to respect each other choice ... you have your listening criteria and i have my own ... good thing is that we should enjoy listening if tone is good bringing you the vibe what you are looking for that all matter for me.
Hell no, it sounds to hair metal........
Great decision not to use him
Thanks my friend
This is better than anything on the Cherone album
@@philipkarovski281 choice does matter , gary was good in VHIII but it came in wrong Era when grunge and Alternative rock was all over the scene.
Absolutely awful…This is not the Mighty Van Halen.
Awful
I personally dont like it.
Never heard of Mitch Malloy who was and is he ?? What other bands was he with ??