We have some exciting news! We’re launching channel Memberships for just $0.99 a month. You’ll get access to members-only posts and videos, live Q&As with Bloomberg reporters, business trivia, badges, emojis and more. Join us: ruclips.net/user/bloombergjoin
That's why it's important to vote out the inept, inutile politicians & their cronies who are brown nosing to china, expecting to be rewarded by the communists.
@@RedNeckAmericans I love how you are not knowledgeable with the past testings that occurred 50 years ago and the American public knew about the testing. Only reason its not a talkative subject bc it occurred 50 years ago. Know one in this generation know about the testings.
@@RedNeckAmericans yeah I’m sorry they were “tested” but there were like hundreds of people living in the Marshall Islands. China Buliding military bases on reefs can affect the whole ecosystem in the South China Sea which can result in fish dying out or moving out from that part of the ocean and will effect millions of people that depend on fishing starve and so on. Reefs are important more than ever including the rise of climate change. We need to be more aware than ever and try to do our parts.
@@gabrielarquillo3355 that's true on the part of China asserting it's power and we should condemn also equally can we also condemn USA for atrocities committing in middle East???
@@RedNeckAmericans but the Middle East is a waste land, I’m not trying to defend the US. The US has its own problems but China really building on reefs that can affect everyone like literally everyone is a problem. The Middle East has nothing, its just a war zone.
Tbh Most SEA countries just want to have their local fishermen freely do their livelihood without chinese military spraying jets of water to them and anything violent.
Try to fish next to a USA military ship or base anywhere in the world, you see how fast you get bombed to particles. Most Asian countries cared less about China until USA and UK placed pressure on them "to protest". China never had colonizing intentions, while our governments in the west still do.
@@Naxafa You are right. It wouldn't be useful. No, it would be horrible! We haven't seen a semetical war since, when? WWII? The Korean war? And what is the worst of it is, both sides have the nuclear option. If a war breaks out it would be a brand new kind of horrible.
@@jackrabbit4421 Yes. It would be heartbreaking and horrible, very sad. I said "useful" as a term putting myself in the shoes of someone who considers war as an option (not me). I hope for the best... I don't want to come to this video in a future and feel sad or disappointed. I hope for no wars. Humankind... I really hope we don't do the same mistakes. Thanks for your comment.
@@cephalonbob15 Actually once there’s no a country called India, British unified and colonized many countries in southwest Asia and named their colonies in one--which called India.
Dude seems like Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia and Singapore need to strengted their navy to protecting Strait of mallaca, Or maybe have a Military cooperation there, Like navy drill or something ... Because Strait of mallaca is So much important, Most important of all in fact
Me before watching the vid : can't all these countries just navigate and fish in this vast ocean Narator mention Oil and gas Me " ah never mind seems like am gonna have a world War in my lifetime after all "
nah no can't do even just fish alone can lead to international dispute, please search cod war between uk and iceland second it is indeed about territory border claim but it happen on sea kick china aside just among ASEAN country its problem already a headache
The narrative that just cuz China is stronger, their claims are void, is such broken logic. In fact, Taiwan's claims are the same as mainland China's even to this day. The 9 dash line originated from the ROC when they still controlled the Chinese mainland before the CCP took over after 1949. The USA has military bases all around China. Should and China just let USA surround them and do nothing? :) The 9 dash line is not a no enter zone. 12NM from the island is no enter zone territory and 200 nm out from each island is the exclusive economic zone.
@@zszs100 Its not that China is not stronger, its because UNCLOS, in which China is a signatory of has basically indicated where china's nautical territory is supposed to be.
@@neroxr4141 this is the main reason why people of today are not growing, why cant we all just leave everything from the past, share lands equally, and follow today's laws and standards?
@@lay-2356 What if about the same thing happen to your country? Will you still say the same words? Someone asks you and your country to just leave everything from the past, share lands equally? In fact, there is no absolute right or wrong in this matter, it is just a pure conflict of interest.
Every Southeasterns shared the resources until 1 came and wanted it all by itself. Greedy.... They come and say " this is named by our country. Get lost". Southeast Asia: check what you've signed 75 years ago....
China: We are reclaiming our rightful place as owners of the South China Sea. All foreigners must pay tribute for permission of safe passage! India: Okay, we'll do the same with the Indian Ocean now. China: Surprised Pikachu face
So what? Indians have been sailing in the Indian Ocean for as long as China has been sailing in the South China Sea. If China gets to claim an ocean, why shouldn't India also get to claim one?
@@Andrew-jh5kj china did not claim scs because she sail there. Its that china was the first to discover, survey, mapped and stone marked them as terra nullius and claim right up to after ww2where japan return to china in the sino japan peace treaty.
@@PatrickBatefan Wait, are you sure? All I know is that Myanmar, Thailand, and Vietnam don't like each other historically. Now the US want all these countries to be US' allies to fight against China?
@@PatrickBatefan No one has contained China in history (Do not forget China is the only surviving ancient civilization without interruption, not India, not Egypt, not Sumer). The Quad is useless: A big US hooligan with three little thugs. I view the US is the biggest threat to the safety of other countries who don't follow it.
@@PatrickBatefan Well, regarding India, it was conquered by multiple foreign powers which changed India drastically, the Aryans invasion from Persian gave the caste system, Turks, then Mughal, eventually the British, nothing resembling the early Indus civilization left. It was the British who united the whole India subcontinent, not the Indian themselves. China developed its infrastructures on their own before 1980s and continues the constructions to today, and Chinese finally rise again as world power, which scares the hell of USA.
You can’t just decide you own an entire sea just because you want to have full control over all trade that goes through that region. It’s like 90% of the worlds trade that travels through that area. It needs to be freely navigated
What promises exactly??? And you think your American country hasn’t broken any promises? Y’all have broken promises ever sense y’all began your shitty country.
Everyone talks about China's 9 dash lines, but Vietnam's claim is equally ridiculous. Philippines, Malaysia, Brunei and Indonesia's claims are "decent" compared to those 2. Oh wait, there is still ROC, not gonna talk about that, hahah.
It is on the demonize level to discuss that if China will become the dominant power in Asia because it is a Pseudo-proposition. China has made a continued policy to treat other countries in a civilized manner. Most Chinese are disinterested in the debate about a new shifting of world power or power competition in the traditional sense which applied to the context of game theory. The ignorance makes people ignored the international law and blind to see the historical evidence of China's sovereignty over the South China Sea according to the 1943 Potsdam Proclamation and Cairo Declaration. China has indisputable sovereignty over Nansha Island and adjacent waters, backed by historical and legal evidence. The construction of China's own territory is not against international law. Philippines' arbitration request is not meant to resolve disputes, but to negate China's right. The most important thing for international law is who defines the international law. and about the South China Sea, you cannot find the sovereignty from the map related to the Philippines and its history or other countries. According to its proponents, China’s claim stood relatively undisputed until the 1930s. From this time onwards, Western colonial forces and an increasingly assertive Imperial Japan recognized and sought to utilize the strategic value of the Nansha Islands (Spratlys) in particular. In 1939, Japan occupied parts of the archipelago in an attempt to control Southeast Asia and prepare for an invasion of Australia. Upon Japan’s defeat in 1945, it was stripped of the area it had occupied in the South China Sea. Although post-war ownership of the islands remains disputed, both Mainland China and Taiwan have adopted the position that rather than creating a “void,” the areas have been restored to Chinese ownership. these declarations emphasize that areas once held by Japan in the South China Sea would no longer be part of that country’s post-war sovereign territory, and that territories Japan has stolen from the Chinese, such as Manchuria, Formosa, and the Pescadores, shall be restored to the Republic of China.” Ownership is deemed to have been implicitly accepted by Western powers (notably the United States) in their failure to object to repeated assertions by (initially) Taiwan over South China Sea sovereignty. As part of the Chinese claim, Taiwan has maintained a presence on Taiping Island (the largest island of the Nansha Islands Archipelago) since 1946. To Beijing’s understanding the status of the islands was seemingly acknowledged as Chinese territory through U.S. requests to the Taiwanese authorities for permission to perform aerial surveys in the region between 1957 and 1961., constitutes a territory that cannot be divided on an island-to-island basis. By recasting the case as one fundamentally challenging Chinese sovereignty over the Nansha Islands, China believes the case constitutes an infringement of Chinese territorial integrity. More than just an infringement of territory, “The UNCLOS did not provide rules for the issue of territorial sea baselines for continental countries’ archipelagos; nor did it provide rules for historic rights, although it affirmed their status in international law.” China believes the court has no jurisdiction to decide on the matter. As such, it rejects the case and will not accept or participate in the arbitration. As discussed in the Chinese government’s Position Paper, two reasons for rejection stand out. First, on August 25, 2006, China deposited, as permitted under Article 298 of UNCLOS, a statement that China will not accept compulsory dispute settlement procedures (including compulsory arbitration) concerning maritime delineation. Second, China rejects the court’s authority; Upon ratification of the UNCLOS on 7 June 1996, Declaration made after ratification (25 August 2006) and Declaration under article 298:The Government of the People's Republic of China does not accept any of the procedures provided for in Section 2 of Part XV of the Convention with respect to all the categories of disputes referred to in paragraph 1 (a) (b) and (c) of Article 298 of the Convention. The United States is not the signatory on The UNCLOS so that they should not make any comment on the issues unless they put the signature on the UNCLOS.
at least china could stick to the belt and road initiative and be a chill major economic power, trading with its surrounding neighbours only the western countries would care about human right problems but no china must be a party crasher and ruin all the fun its neighbours could have had now even vietnam, another authoritarian country, couldnt tolerate china anymore
@@bard2746 with this logic Russia needs to claim entire arctic, India entire Indian Ocean, Portugal entire Atlantic Ocean, just coz they were once dominating power in the respective region.
@@mr.n0ne U DID NOT UNDERSTOOD MY POINT ITS THE HYPOCRISY THAT PREEVAILS IN WEST,GREECE IS ALREADY CLAIMING THE ENTIRE AEGEAN SEA,BUT STILL TURKEY IS WRONG🤣
"China and the South Asian nations got along fine..." China was claiming islands on the other end of the sea, "got along fine" was one way to put it :)
@@eastsouth9548 Historical rights my ass. Rome had conquered entire Europe and North Africa at one point, you don't see the Italians going on about historical rights.
@@Fabian-cv9yl you have probably no clue what a marvellous machine the american army is, China would stand no chanche, they don't even know how to do a modern war plus all their neighbors won't support them at all given how they behave.
ASEAN needs to get its act together first as its member nations have overlapping claims among themselves. They are just shelving that and trying to agree a 'unified' stance on something which is not unified. It's like trying to build on sand and it prevents others who have a strong interest in the area - but no claims themselves - like fellow ASEAN member Thailand, Australia and India from being able to back anyone fully.
China wants a bilateral agreement with its neighbors in the SCS. China and the Philippines have a joint venture agreement. The Philippines will take 60 percent and China will take 40 percent in any oil and gas found in SCS.
The South China sea was originally named the Champ Sea, which was named after the ancient kingdom in current central Vietnam. Vietnamese already continuously administrated both of 2 these islands since 17th century and no single country except VN claimed those at that time. Both of Paracel and Spratly were belong to Indochina/Annam colony of France, so after getting independence, Vietnam had full right to take these 2 islands back obviously. And South Vietnam did that and exercised legal control over these 2 islands until China came illegally in 1974 and 1988. And I want to make it clear that Vietnam does not claim entire SCS, we only claim our 200 nautical mile EEZ + our these 2 islands which lay outside of our EEZ( but as I said EEZ can't apply for islands). Even a lot of messy problems arising until now after Chinese came and some other countries claimed based on EEZ, hope Vietnam and other countries involving can avoid conflict as much as possible More detail about San Francisco Conference : The conference was joined by 51 countries around the world. This is the piece treaty of UN attempt to return all colonies to its initial country after WW2, and as a result, this treaty formed hundred of nowadays countries in the world. In the treaty Japan had to return all colonies back to original countries, which include Paracel and Spratly islands controlled by French. Both of China and Vietnam asserted their claim on Hoàng Sa( Paracel Islands ) and Trường Sa ( Spratly Islands ) but China's claim was rejected by 45 out of 51 countries whereas Tran Van Huu, Prime Minister of Bao Dai’s government of Vietnam stated that “in order to annul the seeds of possible disputes, we claim our sovereignty over Hoang Sa and Truong Sa archipelagos”. No objections were raised nor any reservations made against his statement at the conference. France, in the victory side, also asserted the sovereignty of both of Paracel and Spratly Islands are belong to Annam of Vietnamese because Japan took over them from France. Hoàng Sa and Trường Sa was belong to South Vietnam from 1956 to 1974 and the entire UN, except China nor Russia, recognized and didn't oppose to them. In 1974 China illegally fought and invaded Hoàng Sa ( Paracel Islands) and fought Trường Sa (Spratly Islands) in 1988, but it could only occupy small part of Spratly Islands.
How the hell is america staying strong when half there people voted a tottery old man that can't do his own shoe laces up can't control his words how sad 😭 he is so disabled he would say what is that red button for and start pressing it how can half the population be so fkn stupid an old man that's ready for the old age home are they fairdinkum geez are they really do dumb fck
One of china's big problems is access to the open seas. They are largely a land-locked country, and their coastline is surrounded by other island nations. If war broke out, they could be relatively easily cut off from the rest of the world, denying them shipping and supplies.
What China had done in the SCS is defending its right of passage (to ensure freedom of navigation) for its imports and exports passing through the SCS and Indian Ocean.
@Donna Duns Yes but you do know India doesn't claim the entire stretch of ocean between the mainland and the andaman and nicobar islands right? China is literally claiming the entire sea for itself.
Conflict in this sea is mainly between Vietnam and China. China took vietnamese islands in the 1988 short war. Every year, chinese ships (warship or coast guard ship) shoot vietnamese fishing boats.
@Fenimore Jhno uhhh so big nations can do whatever they want? even China wont like that statement, as that would apply to the US too. I am certain that China doesnt what to do anything with the US.
CCP: Signed UNCLOS. Also CCP: Ignore UNCLOS. CCP: Militarize West Philippine Sea/East Sea. Also CCP: Do not militarize! CCP: Provoke other countries. Also CCP: Do not provoke!
It's not called "south CCP sea" at all... Why people are endocrine to use this self made term... By using the term it is unfair to all neighboring countries who has rights over it...
So this is the East American Sea or the South British Sea. This may be fair, because the United Kingdom still considers Hong Kong as its colonial area.
@@恐怖现实的小宇宙 They are not reconigzed as islands yet. And the argument is the same as with China, with the difference that japan is not building military bases or harassing local fishermen.
@@lesterhorton4807 lol they are not bullies they just doing whats china deserves infact the bullied are china because china abuse smone country with small military!
@@karlolimbaro6528 When China is a country, the Southeastern Asia is nothing. And, you must accept that it's China which firstly claim the sovereign right to South China Sea. As the sea law accepted generally, most of South China Sea belong to China.
United States cannot claim Russia and China to be in violation of a treaty that it is not a party to. When UNCLOS was initially signed in 1982, the Reagan administration refused to accede based on disagreements regarding deep seabed mining. Despite revisions to the treaty in 1994, the Senate refused to hold hearings on the matter.
In the last few decades they pulled a billion people out of poverty increased their gdp by an exponential amount, modernized their infrastructure. While other countries like India are not even close. Their yuan has not been devalued like the US dollar which will help them in the longer term. China has become second largest economy in the world which will likely pass the US. To achieve such astonishing results only in a few decades takes a extreme amount organizing and intelligence.
@@jordyj4126 Yeah China a country which has disputes with every neighbour ie 17countries and can use only one logic since ancient times and selectively use Ching and Ming Dynasty maps. By that logic China should also give up land to Mongolia or the world should fall under Greek or Mongol Empire. CCP is a curse and would lead to the next WW for sure if the PLA learns to fight instead of reading CCP conscripts
Those were all purchased and nobody had pledges not to militarize the South China Sea. China pledged not to, and still did. That's why it's a big deal.
This will lead to a South China Sea version of NATO. US and it’s Pacific allies such as Japan and Australia should help in integrating ASEAN’s military capabilities.
Asean countries does not want a war with china. Instead peaceful coexsistence with COC to be establish to avoid war. Go fight china alone with your bloody 5 eyes that had colonislise and harmed cointries all over the world. The day will come you will be punish for all your sins. Asean cointries will not alliance with Demon.
@@a_ericjuanaprasetyo5503 just philipine alone, spain , japan and usa killed millions of philipinos. Usa alone kill more than one million. They took philipines too. I can list many more what usa and allies had done to qualify them as demon.
Lol it’s funny how propaganda can sway people so easily. Its called the South China Sea for a reason. If other countries disputed this as much as america, id believe it. Enjoy your propoganda Same for Muslims in China lol, since when did America care about Muslims? Its so laughable to think you guys believe this nonsense
@@markkelly5900 The Chinese need the west to fire the first shot and galvanize the Chinese people. Their country is coming unglued thanks to food shortages, corruption and factories leaving their people unemployed. China needs a war to make sure the people are angry at something other than the Chinese Communist Party. If we wait them out, the Chinese people themselves will likely revolt against the communists. Then we gain allies within China. If we fire the first shot, however, or at least the Chinese people believe we fire the first shot, they may turn on us. This is why the tension is high right now.
China has to move first, the islands in dispute are not theirs and are therefore on the defensive end of the conflict. Taiwan and Guam are not going to attack China. China wants the islands and they know that they'll have to fight the US and our allies in order to take them. As you've said time doesn't appear to be on their side as they seem to be losing grip on things within its own borders. The Soviets fell without a war, maybe the CCP will too.
@@mikehunt69981 I agree. The only way we could screw this up is if we shoot first. That would likely galvanize the Chinese people behind the CCP. If, however, the Chinese attack first, that might do the opposite, especially as supply lines are cut off, leaving the Chinese people without enough food or possibly even power.
@@sn0wdon sending military vessels in other nation’s backyard is not really appropriate even if they are technically allowed to do so, it’s a bit like, why the US was so quick to try and invade Cuba when it was in their full right to be armed with nuclear missile that, might hit us cites when war is declared
its funny how this guy talked about Chinese history in the 1900s, he mentioned France, Japan but he did not mention the Eight-Nation Alliance that invaded Beijing and committed numerous crimes...
fidel jr passion, I sense you are anxious to ask your government to send few battalions of canoes and kayaks to confront China. When war breaks out, you will be lay down and play dead.
Literally Indonesia on 2018: "Sir. China claims some of our EEZ in north of Natuna Islands." "Okay then." Several moments later, Indonesian government be like: "Now, we announce that sea up north of Natuna Islands which name as we already know, South China Sea now we changing the name to be North Natuna Sea." ASEAN: *confuses pikachu face* China: *angry noises*
Of course, everyone you disagree with is trolls. How pitiful and weak must your position be for you to have to use such a banal demogological trick - argumentum ad hominem - to defend it?
3:15 You forgot Indonesia's Riau and Natuna islands are located in the area too. So Indonesia also need to defend it's sovereignty in south chinese sea.
@@John-us9rm Apa maksud mu? Apa kamu tidak tahu apa saja yang china komunis lakukan di lautan Indonesia beberapa bulan terakhir dari mengirim penjaga pantainya ke wilayah laut Indonesia sampai kapal mata-matanya yang belum lama ini terjadi?
@42nd Street Donald Trump gave us this impression that the US wouldn't defend us if it didn't meet the American' s interests. We have been with our historical ally from the start but it's disturbing to hear Pompeo or whoever said it, that they'd drop us anytime they wanted if we didn't do as they say
@@mephisto5856you can keep slandering where the pandemic came from but the covid 19 will never be stopped if you keep doing stupid things. Anti this against that is not the solution for the problem.
@Cody J Falkand island is much more closer to Argentina but it's still belonged to UK so Spartly archipelago is closer to Philippines doesn't mean it is belonged to Philipines. Vietnam has historical evidence to prove that Vietnam has has already owned Spartly archipelago and Paracel archipelago in 18th century during Later Le dynasty.
What China had done in the SCS is defending its right of passage (to ensure freedom of navigation) for its imports and exports passing through the SCS and Indian Ocean.
@@traaotuong6107 And Vietnam didn't even attend the arbitration in 2016. Only the Philippines. Vietnam can't even back their claims with evidence while the Philippines presented theirs. Huh.
If the US leaves the South China Sea, China will complete it’s intimidating of all other neighboring countries and make war inevitably. Spice in a complete assault and war over Taiwan.
@Covert Puppy Two So US is in International waters? Let's move some of the Russian & Chinese military equipment near New York & Washington by the international waters. Oh boy I wouldn't want to guess how US would react to that. They would go insane warmode.
@@mattno100 I don't understand what you just said. Please explain in more detail. Iran shot down US drone, nothing happened. US is aware that there is no winners with getting into war with China. It will never happen. This is all politics to get your attention away how bad the situation is inside the US. I'm just here to open your eyes, nothing else.
When will Southeast Asian countries be able to seize China's islands? Besides, how can the United States not condemn so many hooligans? Some countries in Southeast Asia do not have the potential of a superpower, but have the ambition of a superpower
The southern half of the sea should be named “Inter-Malaysian Sea”. Even “Southeast Asian Sea” sounds better and more appropriate than South China Sea..
It was the Obama administration's (in)actions towards the Scarborough Shoal incident that left the door wide open for China to militarise islands in the South China Sea. The US at the time made it very clear they were more interested in Middle Eastern oil than backing up ASEAN allies like the Philippines against Chinese aggression and landgrabs. I wonder what Obama 2.0 admin is going to do this time? Probably won't back Japan up when Chinese ships fire on coast guard vessels around Senkaku. "Pivet to Asia" my ass.
@@Bobbyjonesyrrr It's their (China) neighbourhood and they are going to help themselves to what ever resources they can lay their hands on. They also have a population five times the size of the US and an economy growing at a staggering rate.
@@Bobbyjonesyrrr why would China fire upon japanese ships and senkaku?arent China and japanese the best of friends?i heard a long time ago like somewhere between 1937 and 1941 the japanese sent an entourage to Nanking to commemorate qing shi huang's birthday no and celebrate chinese new year?
So what? China doesnt rights to defend its own teritory? Ha ha western double standards. Western democracy supported with NATO pirate army goes into countries rich with natural resorses to overthrow legal governments and instal thiers puppies... USA sinking very fast... RIP USA
@@stephenjenkins7971 You deeply do not know, before and after the defeat of Japan, what are all those history that happened w/n Japan fall to the hands of the US/ BRITISH, Japan can embrace any kind of attempt suicide as the Bushido, Kamikaze, etc cause they will not Surrender, whatever will be, will be, even Harry Truman have said, If You Do Not Accept Our Terms, You will Expect a Rain of Ruin of a Hot Rain, The like You Have Never Seen on This Earth (Aug.6, 1945 ) and exactly after that warning The Atomic Nuclear Bomb drop to Nagasaki and Hiroshima. The US tell the truth, that Emperor Hirohito surrendered Japan. In spite of this, the Japanese Soldier doesnt want to gave up, mostly commit suicide. You have also to know how many people died at every country have conquered, Mostly the way they killed citizen people is to cut your head either you are civilian or any catigory of military you are, you are not considered as a Prisoner of War. These lesson the Japanese got to the US, is now their Boss that will do everything to be side to the US/ Britain even to kiss forever the ass of its dominator
Don't make any noise and blow his cover or you'll hear a radio call "Dammit Fischer, the mission is over" P.S. Damn I could still hear his voice in my head after reading that lol
Xi jin ping literally told Obama and his whole cabinet that China will not militarize the south China sea if America withdrawals its aircraft carriers from the area back in 2014... What did Obama do? He sent more fking carriers... So guess why chinas militarizing the scs right now. The average person doesn't have the mental capacity or IQ to do any real research on this topic so people just think "oh wow China bad China expanding China evil". It's so idiotic
You have to research in the library before speeching on CCP's claim on the South China Sea. The dash line was initially posted by Kuomintang of ROC after the WW2, which was called 11 dash line at that time. All the countries around South China Sea did not object this claim and this China's territory was printed in maps of all the counties, including USA, Canada, Vietnam. When was 11 dash line was replaced by 9 dash line? Vietnam war. When US was involved in Vietnam war again the Vietnam communist party in the north, CCP decided to help Vietnam and borrowed an island to Vietnam for establishing the radar base at the northwest of South China Sea. So, two dashes were deleted in this area. Actually, Vietnam did not give that island back to China after the war. So, you have ask Taiwan for the reason why there is a line in South Chian Sea. Another important issue I need to mention is the islands in South China Sea were discovered before Christ by the Chinese. Ancient Chinese fishermen were used for rest and supply, which recorded even in history 2000 years ago. At that time, only a few primitive tribes existed on the land around South China Sea. I really do not know can anybody claim others' land because you are close to mine. If in that case, China should claim lands from Vietnam, Philippine, Malasia, because your land is too close to mine.
@@31873015 China as of 2018 has not filed a formal and specifically defined claim to the area with in the dashes. So no one could possibly object to this. In 2016 the permanent court of arbitration ruled that China has no legal basis to claim historic rights with in the nine dash line. Your propaganda does not work on me. Now go back to my original statement and prove me wrong.
@@yin6287 There is no two China. Taiwan is only a government in exile. Once Kuomintang can defect the CCP and control the mainland of China, ROC will be a representative government of China. Taiwan will never be a country or another China, which is decided by its constitution.
If we all base on history, then everybody has their own history base on what everybody wants to tell you about his story telling. If no man can claim this entire world base on history alone then history claims are no basis. That is why the world needs international laws in order to have international and common orders and that every body should participate & committed for the sake of long lasting peace
The South China sea was originally named the Champ Sea, which was named after the ancient kingdom in current central Vietnam. Vietnamese already continuously administrated both of 2 these islands since 17th century and no single country except VN claimed those at that time. Both of Paracel and Spratly were belong to Indochina/Annam colony of France, so after getting independence, Vietnam had full right to take these 2 islands back obviously. And South Vietnam did that and exercised legal control over these 2 islands until China came illegally in 1974 and 1988. And I want to make it clear that Vietnam does not claim entire SCS, we only claim our 200 nautical mile EEZ + our these 2 islands which lay outside of our EEZ( but as I said EEZ can't apply for islands). Even a lot of messy problems arising until now after Chinese came and some other countries claimed based on EEZ, hope Vietnam and other countries involving can avoid conflict as much as possible More detail about San Francisco Conference : The conference was joined by 51 countries around the world. This is the piece treaty of UN attempt to return all colonies to its initial country after WW2, and as a result, this treaty formed hundred of nowadays countries in the world. In the treaty Japan had to return all colonies back to original countries, which include Paracel and Spratly islands controlled by French. Both of China and Vietnam asserted their claim on Hoàng Sa( Paracel Islands ) and Trường Sa ( Spratly Islands ) but China's claim was rejected by 45 out of 51 countries whereas Tran Van Huu, Prime Minister of Bao Dai’s government of Vietnam stated that “in order to annul the seeds of possible disputes, we claim our sovereignty over Hoang Sa and Truong Sa archipelagos”. No objections were raised nor any reservations made against his statement at the conference. France, in the victory side, also asserted the sovereignty of both of Paracel and Spratly Islands are belong to Annam of Vietnamese because Japan took over them from France. Hoàng Sa and Trường Sa was belong to South Vietnam from 1956 to 1974 and the entire UN, except China nor Russia, recognized and didn't oppose to them. In 1974 China illegally fought and invaded Hoàng Sa ( Paracel Islands) and fought Trường Sa (Spratly Islands) in 1988, but it could only occupy small part of Spratly Islands.
@台湾蛙🐸来对线 Why some Chinese are still obsessed too much with historical events. Qing Dynasty already collapsed. If you want to talk about the history, you should belong to Mongolian because you was a part of that. If you claim that South China Sea, why you signed UNCLOS in December 1982. Can you explain why?
Humans are a malevolent species. They need war, conflict and hostility with each other over resources needed for survival. It has always been that way and will always be that way. Other animals also mark out the territory.
Why do people keep calling it South China Sea? It is not a property of China. Philippines won the International Arbitral Tribunal so it is called West Philippine Sea.
@楼鸢 These south east asian countries also has become independent countries which have their own water territories. And those are what china tries to claim
What's more ridiculous is that some people have ignored China's strength and its history in this area. If you think that China is not so powerful, you should think about why the United States has not directly attacked China.This world is the world of the jungle!Why didn't you condemn the United States when it invaded other countries? Are they really so noble for democracy and freedom?
Yo. They making bases near my country (Philippines). Our current President (Duterte) thinks that China/CCP are our friends.... Hahahahahahahahaha. We dead.
No, he just understands that you are either a puppet of China or you are the trash of America and her allies. Either way, you're going to be abused lol
@@cassinitakano5736 Considering how the built fake islands in the South China Sea it does not take much imagination to consider that China might try to do the same in the Arctic.
This downplays the real situation that is developing in the region, the amount of money behind this area of water is unparalleled to any water of similar size. It’s scary how careless the general population is over this whole situation. Water will be the cause of the next wars. As China chokes the Mekong and half of those country’s are put under the boot of China, war will be too late. China in all aspects is trying to expand and will achieve it because the government operates if someone is starving their country of water
The more combative the PRC becomes, the more retaliation they'll see from the US, present and future US allies. And at scale that will give the PRC pause.
If China can claim places based on history, the UK can claim 1/3 of the world I need to remember to never make political jokes, even if they’re barely political. Ever. Or comment on a political Video. Ever. Deep regrets
The British empire is officially over decades ago, thus no other countries being support its imperialism, in short UK is too weak to annex any land alone.
@@leonleon2021 of course but I think their point was more about how china's "historical" claims are bullshit and hold no water, just like if the UK was to try and claim such territories today.
@@leonleon2021 not if the US pokes it's nose in for whatever reasons they come up with. economy wise the two are neck and neck with China starting to pull ahead but military wise China is just a little bit outclassed. Best analogy I could give you is that China is around Vietnam era/early gulf war in terms of military tech and the US is present day if you were to compare the difference.
@@War_Daddy103 are u sure about what u said?? have you watched the 70th Anniversary about China? they showed plenty of great weaponries tho. if China is REALLY that weak and obsolete, USA would just invade China just as they did to IRAQ. You ur basis are nothing but blind and biased.
Some of them actually believe that, and THAT will start a war that would most likely result in their destruction and much of the rest of the World as well.
From what I can see is that the increase in US Military presence in south asia has caused China to set up defensive positions, maybe I am wrong but between the USA and China who do you think is the most likely to start or want a conflict!!!
@Georgia Kidd Taiwan is historical problem, it was civil war. KMT lost and retreat to Taiwan until now. For India, China has released the footage. Indian army are building tents opposite the river and then cross the river first and being offensive before Chinese repel them. For Australia, Scomo thought he is Trump, but he is not leading America 😂 Back to the topic, isn't it a coincidence that the countries that you mentioned causing the problems (China, Russia and Iran) are rival of America? Is it so happen that the problematic countries are rival of Murica or it's just geopolitics and media at play here? US is not a regional country, its located far away and should have no say over the region, yet they are going for "freedom of navigation". They are not UNCLOS signatory country, yet asking for other countries to obey to UNCLOS. 😂
We have some exciting news! We’re launching channel Memberships for just $0.99 a month. You’ll get access to members-only posts and videos, live Q&As with Bloomberg reporters, business trivia, badges, emojis and more.
Join us: ruclips.net/user/bloombergjoin
More western imperialist propaganda, thumbs down
NO CHINESE AND MOSCOWA IT'S NOT
NO CHINA'S AND NO MOSCOWA IT'S NOT
NUMBER THEN CHINA'S NO IT'S NOT
We do not want an animal system like China and we should gather together to teach China to become more human.
Me who realize that I live in the Philippines which is in the middle of these two superpowers.. *"Guess ill die"*
That's why it's important to vote out the inept, inutile politicians & their cronies who are brown nosing to china, expecting to be rewarded by the communists.
Join the military.
@@Lord_Reeves That's a cruel joke.
you mean they will dropped bomb accidentally... that's must be scary af 😂
Yea right bro! we got you
Just a look at China's claim on the map and it immediately looks ridiculous to anyone
Just a look at how US military vessels placed on the map and it immediately looks ridiculous to anyone in the same way.
@@dillontuan121 U.S. should have nothing to do about it. It's only china and ASEAN countries problem.
@@dillontuan121 Just look at how greedy and evil is China for claming the sea. They are bullying the entire South East Asian
@@dillontuan121 so what? what does it have to do with the reasonableness of China’s territorial claim in the south china sea?
@@Windows11Official It is the ordinary routine for the last thousand year of this area, so wish USA live long and prosper.
I love how no one talks about China building military bases on reefs.
@@RedNeckAmericans I love how you are not knowledgeable with the past testings that occurred 50 years ago and the American public knew about the testing. Only reason its not a talkative subject bc it occurred 50 years ago. Know one in this generation know about the testings.
@@gabrielarquillo3355 testing was done 50 years ago but people are still suffering... They need justice.
@@RedNeckAmericans yeah I’m sorry they were “tested” but there were like hundreds of people living in the Marshall Islands. China Buliding military bases on reefs can affect the whole ecosystem in the South China Sea which can result in fish dying out or moving out from that part of the ocean and will effect millions of people that depend on fishing starve and so on. Reefs are important more than ever including the rise of climate change. We need to be more aware than ever and try to do our parts.
@@gabrielarquillo3355 that's true on the part of China asserting it's power and we should condemn also equally can we also condemn USA for atrocities committing in middle East???
@@RedNeckAmericans but the Middle East is a waste land, I’m not trying to defend the US. The US has its own problems but China really building on reefs that can affect everyone like literally everyone is a problem. The Middle East has nothing, its just a war zone.
Tbh Most SEA countries just want to have their local fishermen freely do their livelihood without chinese military spraying jets of water to them and anything violent.
Look at Map, fiery reef , spartly tell me the logic to fish there?.
Where theres HUGE territorial areas to fish..peacefully.
Try to fish next to a USA military ship or base anywhere in the world, you see how fast you get bombed to particles. Most Asian countries cared less about China until USA and UK placed pressure on them "to protest". China never had colonizing intentions, while our governments in the west still do.
Sorry. They're bad neighbors right now.
@@thetruthalwaysscary that a lie I'm from this asean country, most have trouble dealing with them because of power difference
@@thetruthalwaysscary So why are the Chinese building weapon bases in international waters if it's not blatant aggression?
I've been personally keeping an eye on this issue for years and it's just getting more unstable...
So war in 2021 or just a show off military superiority??
Perhaps the CCP are testing how fast is the response of the taiwanese
@@pholiux1418 I hope there are no wars, I don't think it would be useful for anyone. 🤔 China is stronger in the place.
Same here.
@@Naxafa You are right. It wouldn't be useful. No, it would be horrible! We haven't seen a semetical war since, when? WWII? The Korean war? And what is the worst of it is, both sides have the nuclear option. If a war breaks out it would be a brand new kind of horrible.
@@jackrabbit4421 Yes. It would be heartbreaking and horrible, very sad. I said "useful" as a term putting myself in the shoes of someone who considers war as an option (not me). I hope for the best... I don't want to come to this video in a future and feel sad or disappointed. I hope for no wars. Humankind... I really hope we don't do the same mistakes. Thanks for your comment.
what happens when India blocks a Chinese ship saying India owns the Indian ocean?
India did not even call the Indian Ocean, the Indian Ocean pretty sure the Indian Ocean was named by the British or something
@@cephalonbob15 Actually once there’s no a country called India, British unified and colonized many countries in southwest Asia and named their colonies in one--which called India.
That’s why Xi push the belt and road initiative
@@philipkong9755 India has been a concept for thousands of years and has existed for hundreds
except China never blocks a foreign ship in the South China Sea... guess who put this idea in your mind?
i’m from malaysia. and about 2 days ago supercarrier uss nimitz just passed through the straits of malacca towards scs
Keep hoping for chinas failure but if it happens usa wouldnt doubt to exterminate every single one of you.
@@r.282 wtf
@@r.282 That makes no sense since the US engaged with East Asia peacefully since the end of the Cold War.
Then you should sleep well at night. If that carrier is CCP then you better stay awake
Dude seems like Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia and Singapore need to strengted their navy to protecting Strait of mallaca, Or maybe have a Military cooperation there, Like navy drill or something
...
Because Strait of mallaca is So much important, Most important of all in fact
All world is ours since ancient time except corona -🇨🇳 winne the pooh
Me before watching the vid : can't all these countries just navigate and fish in this vast ocean
Narator mention Oil and gas
Me " ah never mind seems like am gonna have a world War in my lifetime after all "
nah no can't do
even just fish alone can lead to international dispute, please search cod war between uk and iceland
second it is indeed about territory border claim but it happen on sea kick china aside just among ASEAN country its problem already a headache
@@aswiran of mm
Maybe omkmk
Oomm
@@aswiran keep nom
I am not suprised...Every major powerful country does that....
The narrative that just cuz China is stronger, their claims are void, is such broken logic. In fact, Taiwan's claims are the same as mainland China's even to this day. The 9 dash line originated from the ROC when they still controlled the Chinese mainland before the CCP took over after 1949. The USA has military bases all around China. Should and China just let USA surround them and do nothing? :)
The 9 dash line is not a no enter zone. 12NM from the island is no enter zone territory and 200 nm out from each island is the exclusive economic zone.
@@zszs100 Its not that China is not stronger, its because UNCLOS, in which China is a signatory of has basically indicated where china's nautical territory is supposed to be.
We China has been owning China south sea from Ming Dynasty
@@neroxr4141 this is the main reason why people of today are not growing, why cant we all just leave everything from the past, share lands equally, and follow today's laws and standards?
@@lay-2356 What if about the same thing happen to your country? Will you still say the same words? Someone asks you and your country to just leave everything from the past, share lands equally? In fact, there is no absolute right or wrong in this matter, it is just a pure conflict of interest.
Every Southeasterns shared the resources until 1 came and wanted it all by itself.
Greedy.... They come and say " this is named by our country. Get lost".
Southeast Asia: check what you've signed 75 years ago....
Sad :(
China: We are reclaiming our rightful place as owners of the South China Sea. All foreigners must pay tribute for permission of safe passage!
India: Okay, we'll do the same with the Indian Ocean now.
China: Surprised Pikachu face
Go learn the difference between ocesn and sea instead of making a fool of yourself here
@@John-us9rm its the same thing really if you can claim a sea because it has your name then India deserves the Indian ocean
@@joelGi nobody claim the whole ocean? Sea , yes. And also china did not claim scs because of the name .
So what? Indians have been sailing in the Indian Ocean for as long as China has been sailing in the South China Sea. If China gets to claim an ocean, why shouldn't India also get to claim one?
@@Andrew-jh5kj china did not claim scs because she sail there. Its that china was the first to discover, survey, mapped and stone marked them as terra nullius and claim right up to after ww2where japan return to china in the sino japan peace treaty.
Whole SEA is going to be a battlefield once again.
I approve your message: The every oceans in the world are battlefields in the eyes of US navy.
@@strongbrain3128 it's not just ocean , war is coming in SEA. Mayanmar is just the start. It will be 60s once again.
@@PatrickBatefan Wait, are you sure? All I know is that Myanmar, Thailand, and Vietnam don't like each other historically. Now the US want all these countries to be US' allies to fight against China?
@@PatrickBatefan No one has contained China in history (Do not forget China is the only surviving ancient civilization without interruption, not India, not Egypt, not Sumer). The Quad is useless: A big US hooligan with three little thugs. I view the US is the biggest threat to the safety of other countries who don't follow it.
@@PatrickBatefan Well, regarding India, it was conquered by multiple foreign powers which changed India drastically, the Aryans invasion from Persian gave the caste system, Turks, then Mughal, eventually the British, nothing resembling the early Indus civilization left. It was the British who united the whole India subcontinent, not the Indian themselves. China developed its infrastructures on their own before 1980s and continues the constructions to today, and Chinese finally rise again as world power, which scares the hell of USA.
Finally somebody brought this back up. 👀🗣️🛢️🌡️🚢
You can’t just decide you own an entire sea just because you want to have full control over all trade that goes through that region. It’s like 90% of the worlds trade that travels through that area. It needs to be freely navigated
Never trust the broken promises of Winnie the Pooh.
Hey man mind if you say the promise again?
What promises exactly??? And you think your American country hasn’t broken any promises? Y’all have broken promises ever sense y’all began your shitty country.
What did they promise?
@@Gongolongo They promised that they will not touch any islands. But THEY DID !
@@capricorn839 no they didn't
Everyone talks about China's 9 dash lines, but Vietnam's claim is equally ridiculous.
Philippines, Malaysia, Brunei and Indonesia's claims are "decent" compared to those 2.
Oh wait, there is still ROC, not gonna talk about that, hahah.
Well china is elephant huge on the map among asia, SCS is just the shadow of the elephant pond drinking site.
You are correct!
Vietnam need a kick in the ass like China and Taiwan!
Yeaaaaa no, China started building artificial islands and pushing their claims. This was not Obamas fault
Indonesia never claim anything, our Natuna Islands is there when we got Independence 1945
@@elcomodo1
Obama was a COWARD who did nothing and let it get to this level.
At least Trump tried
When there are no small fish left to bicker over it will then be the big fish
It leaves me wondering if the will use North Korea, like the russians used Vietnam.
All part of the plan right?
Well said! All countries are the same, only a matter of who is the most powerful.
It is on the demonize level to discuss that if China will become the dominant power in Asia because it is a Pseudo-proposition.
China has made a continued policy to treat other countries in a civilized manner. Most Chinese are disinterested in the debate about a new shifting of world power or power competition in the traditional sense which applied to the context of game theory.
The ignorance makes people ignored the international law and blind to see the historical evidence of China's sovereignty over the South China Sea according to the 1943 Potsdam Proclamation and Cairo Declaration.
China has indisputable sovereignty over Nansha Island and adjacent waters, backed by historical and legal evidence. The construction of China's own territory is not against international law. Philippines' arbitration request is not meant to resolve disputes, but to negate China's right. The most important thing for international law is who defines the international law. and about the South China Sea, you cannot find the sovereignty from the map related to the Philippines and its history or other countries.
According to its proponents, China’s claim stood relatively undisputed until the 1930s. From this time onwards, Western colonial forces and an increasingly assertive Imperial Japan recognized and sought to utilize the strategic value of the Nansha Islands (Spratlys) in particular. In 1939, Japan occupied parts of the archipelago in an attempt to control Southeast Asia and prepare for an invasion of Australia. Upon Japan’s defeat in 1945, it was stripped of the area it had occupied in the South China Sea. Although post-war ownership of the islands remains disputed, both Mainland China and Taiwan have adopted the position that rather than creating a “void,” the areas have been restored to Chinese ownership. these declarations emphasize that areas once held by Japan in the South China Sea would no longer be part of that country’s post-war sovereign territory, and that territories Japan has stolen from the Chinese, such as Manchuria, Formosa, and the Pescadores, shall be restored to the Republic of China.” Ownership is deemed to have been implicitly accepted by Western powers (notably the United States) in their failure to object to repeated assertions by (initially) Taiwan over South China Sea sovereignty. As part of the Chinese claim, Taiwan has maintained a presence on Taiping Island (the largest island of the Nansha Islands Archipelago) since 1946. To Beijing’s understanding the status of the islands was seemingly acknowledged as Chinese territory through U.S. requests to the Taiwanese authorities for permission to perform aerial surveys in the region between 1957 and 1961., constitutes a territory that cannot be divided on an island-to-island basis. By recasting the case as one fundamentally challenging Chinese sovereignty over the Nansha Islands, China believes the case constitutes an infringement of Chinese territorial integrity. More than just an infringement of territory, “The UNCLOS did not provide rules for the issue of territorial sea baselines for continental countries’ archipelagos; nor did it provide rules for historic rights, although it affirmed their status in international law.”
China believes the court has no jurisdiction to decide on the matter. As such, it rejects the case and will not accept or participate in the arbitration. As discussed in the Chinese government’s Position Paper, two reasons for rejection stand out. First, on August 25, 2006, China deposited, as permitted under Article 298 of UNCLOS, a statement that China will not accept compulsory dispute settlement procedures (including compulsory arbitration) concerning maritime delineation. Second, China rejects the court’s authority;
Upon ratification of the UNCLOS on 7 June 1996, Declaration made after ratification (25 August 2006) and Declaration under article 298:The Government of the People's Republic of China does not accept any of the procedures provided for in Section 2 of Part XV of the Convention with respect to all the categories of disputes referred to in paragraph 1 (a) (b) and (c) of Article 298 of the Convention. The United States is not the signatory on The UNCLOS so that they should not make any comment on the issues unless they put the signature on the UNCLOS.
at least china could stick to the belt and road initiative and be a chill major economic power, trading with its surrounding neighbours
only the western countries would care about human right problems
but no
china must be a party crasher and ruin all the fun its neighbours could have had
now even vietnam, another authoritarian country, couldnt tolerate china anymore
Claiming an entire sea is ridiculous.
SO GREECE CAN CLAIM BUT NOT CHINA😂😂
@@bard2746 with this logic Russia needs to claim entire arctic, India entire Indian Ocean, Portugal entire Atlantic Ocean, just coz they were once dominating power in the respective region.
@@mr.n0ne
U DID NOT UNDERSTOOD MY POINT ITS THE HYPOCRISY THAT PREEVAILS IN WEST,GREECE IS ALREADY CLAIMING THE ENTIRE AEGEAN SEA,BUT STILL TURKEY IS WRONG🤣
@@bard2746 : Greece complies with the law, the CCP is breaking the law.
"China and the South Asian nations got along fine..." China was claiming islands on the other end of the sea, "got along fine" was one way to put it :)
other asean countries started it first, China just responds. China existed long before these other countries were even named, Historical rights.
@@eastsouth9548 Historical rights my ass. Rome had conquered entire Europe and North Africa at one point, you don't see the Italians going on about historical rights.
@@eastsouth9548 China should claim Covid-19 then
@@nevarran "conquered" difference. china was there staking claim before most of these nations even got names. so "found" & not "conquered".
@@eastsouth9548 Sure, there were no humans before the Chinese, they populated the planet.
Winnie the pooh wants everything
The future belongs to China, make no mistake
@@Fabian-cv9yl No, luckily not every American and European is as weak minded as you, we will never tolerate a regime.
@@Fabian-cv9yl Yeah we will become slavery, the end
@@kenvischi1047 you are simply deluding yourself
@@Fabian-cv9yl you have probably no clue what a marvellous machine the american army is, China would stand no chanche, they don't even know how to do a modern war plus all their neighbors won't support them at all given how they behave.
ASEAN needs to get its act together first as its member nations have overlapping claims among themselves. They are just shelving that and trying to agree a 'unified' stance on something which is not unified. It's like trying to build on sand and it prevents others who have a strong interest in the area - but no claims themselves - like fellow ASEAN member Thailand, Australia and India from being able to back anyone fully.
we ASEAN know how to determine what is to be set aside for the time being . . .
China wants a bilateral agreement with its neighbors in the SCS. China and the Philippines have a joint venture agreement. The Philippines will take 60 percent and China will take 40 percent in any oil and gas found in SCS.
The South China sea was originally named the Champ Sea, which was named after the ancient kingdom in current central Vietnam. Vietnamese already continuously administrated both of 2 these islands since 17th century and no single country except VN claimed those at that time. Both of Paracel and Spratly were belong to Indochina/Annam colony of France, so after getting independence, Vietnam had full right to take these 2 islands back obviously. And South Vietnam did that and exercised legal control over these 2 islands until China came illegally in 1974 and 1988. And I want to make it clear that Vietnam does not claim entire SCS, we only claim our 200 nautical mile EEZ + our these 2 islands which lay outside of our EEZ( but as I said EEZ can't apply for islands). Even a lot of messy problems arising until now after Chinese came and some other countries claimed based on EEZ, hope Vietnam and other countries involving can avoid conflict as much as possible
More detail about San Francisco Conference :
The conference was joined by 51 countries around the world. This is the piece treaty of UN attempt to return all colonies to its initial country after WW2, and as a result, this treaty formed hundred of nowadays countries in the world. In the treaty Japan had to return all colonies back to original countries, which include Paracel and Spratly islands controlled by French. Both of China and Vietnam asserted their claim on Hoàng Sa( Paracel Islands ) and Trường Sa ( Spratly Islands ) but China's claim was rejected by 45 out of 51 countries whereas Tran Van Huu, Prime Minister of Bao Dai’s government of Vietnam stated that “in order to annul the seeds of possible disputes, we claim our sovereignty over Hoang Sa and Truong Sa archipelagos”. No objections were raised nor any reservations made against his statement at the conference.
France, in the victory side, also asserted the sovereignty of both of Paracel and Spratly Islands are belong to Annam of Vietnamese because Japan took over them from France.
Hoàng Sa and Trường Sa was belong to South Vietnam from 1956 to 1974 and the entire UN, except China nor Russia, recognized and didn't oppose to them. In 1974 China illegally fought and invaded Hoàng Sa ( Paracel Islands) and fought Trường Sa (Spratly Islands) in 1988, but it could only occupy small part of Spratly Islands.
อย่าให้ชาติมหาอำนาจคอมฯทวีปเอเฃียครอบครองทะเลจีนใต้ได้เพราะภูมิภาคนี้จะไม่สงบสุข peace and liberty
wait am i reading that austrailia and india being in ASEAN correctly???
Southeast asia support U.S and Allies. China is more like japan in world war 2
Obviously you can't understand China's military power and strategy at your military understanding level
@@morgenarsenal27 yeah stupid military strategy. You want whole the world become your enemy? Its fine you will get it
agreed
@@a_ericjuanaprasetyo5503The right policy for small country to protect itself is absolutely not be used by a big country to fight another big country.
Ladies and gentlemen! The so-called "Chinese" sea is not meant to be private, but to be shared by all the countries around it!
Dainis yr 100 per cent spot on
How the hell is america staying strong when half there people voted a tottery old man that can't do his own shoe laces up can't control his words how sad 😭 he is so disabled he would say what is that red button for and start pressing it how can half the population be so fkn stupid an old man that's ready for the old age home are they fairdinkum geez are they really do dumb fck
@@garydixon9742 stop your rant you crazy old man go play sudoku
@@garydixon9742 Take your meds, for the sake of those around you that have to put up with you.
@@garydixon9742 not like trump was any better,
I’m definitely smelling some Vox vibe on this video
Can you explain what Vox means to you, and how it has a similarity to this video.
@AH S if your explanation is correct, Oprey is getting these rather rare vibes. But it's still not enough. I need a less vague explanation.
MooseMuffins they won't give you clear explanation because they have zero knowledge, lol.
@@Chromwel-A nice
@AH S 🤣🤣🤣🤣
One of china's big problems is access to the open seas.
They are largely a land-locked country, and their coastline is surrounded by other island nations.
If war broke out, they could be relatively easily cut off from the rest of the world, denying them shipping and supplies.
They dont need shipping and supplies,
@@wrathmachine7609 Oh yes they do: coal and iron ore for starters--as they have found to their chagrin in their trade war with Australia
@@bongosock damn so the coal reserves in the north was a joke then according to your theory
@linkzable China's navy would have no chance against the combined navies of Japan, Taiwan, Philippines, US, etc.
@linkzable if I had 1000 rubber ducks in the ocean and called them my ship I would have the largest navy too.
South "China" Sea
The ASEAN : *Now hold there boy*
With that logic Indian Ocean belongs to India
@Donna Duns But those islands are very close to the mainlands, China is building there’s in the middle of the South China Sea. Right in the middle
What China had done in the SCS is defending its right of passage (to ensure freedom of navigation) for its imports and exports passing through the SCS and Indian Ocean.
With that logic, Persian Gulf belongs to Iran.
@Donna Duns Yes but you do know India doesn't claim the entire stretch of ocean between the mainland and the andaman and nicobar islands right? China is literally claiming the entire sea for itself.
Conflict in this sea is mainly between Vietnam and China. China took vietnamese islands in the 1988 short war. Every year, chinese ships (warship or coast guard ship) shoot vietnamese fishing boats.
@Fenimore Jhno which they failed, so China had to save face by claiming "victory".
Your point being?
@Fenimore Jhno ridiculous, Truong Sa and Hoang Sa belong to Vietnam
@Fenimore Jhno uhhh so big nations can do whatever they want? even China wont like that statement, as that would apply to the US too. I am certain that China doesnt what to do anything with the US.
CCP: Signed UNCLOS.
Also CCP: Ignore UNCLOS.
CCP: Militarize West Philippine Sea/East Sea.
Also CCP: Do not militarize!
CCP: Provoke other countries.
Also CCP: Do not provoke!
Art of warfare sun tzo
It's not called "south CCP sea" at all... Why people are endocrine to use this self made term... By using the term it is unfair to all neighboring countries who has rights over it...
A sea with no name.
So this is the East American Sea or the South British Sea. This may be fair, because the United Kingdom still considers Hong Kong as its colonial area.
中国最大的争议就是不是美国的盟友！ 日本的不到一平米的冲之鸟礁就能定义为岛屿~因为日本是美国的盟友！既然美国不讲道理~那就武力解决呗！
@@恐怖现实的小宇宙 They are not reconigzed as islands yet. And the argument is the same as with China, with the difference that japan is not building military bases or harassing local fishermen.
@@calimio6 你们永远都能说出不同种类的双重标准！但是没关系！就像沙特阿拉伯也不存在独裁一样！你们眼里没有正义，只有利益！所以来吧！跟中国打一仗，你们就知道什么是正义了！
Ah appeasement to illegal actions, I wonder what happens when you do that
Well, if history was anything to go by, we do have two World Wars as a lesson
@@Goatzies appeasement wasnt really a thing before ww1. Yea countries did negotiate but it wasnt one side trying to solely appease the other.
Literally
Vietnam,Malaysia,Indonesia,Brunei and Philippines (ASEAN) and US,Japan,Australia,France,Germany,UK
VS
China
They are a group of bullies to fight against China mainland.
@@lesterhorton4807 lol they are not bullies they just doing whats china deserves infact the bullied are china because china abuse smone country with small military!
@@karlolimbaro6528 When China is a country, the Southeastern Asia is nothing. And, you must accept that it's China which firstly claim the sovereign right to South China Sea. As the sea law accepted generally, most of South China Sea belong to China.
China is a bully, she claims islands that she didn't own and she uses her own standard like nine-dash line
@@lesterhorton4807 nine dash line is not bases to claim islands. West Philippines Sea's island is belong to the Philippines
United States cannot claim Russia and China to be in violation of a treaty that it is not a party to. When UNCLOS was initially signed in 1982, the Reagan administration refused to accede based on disagreements regarding deep seabed mining. Despite revisions to the treaty in 1994, the Senate refused to hold hearings on the matter.
All of this is ok, but the real news is, what did Kim Kardashian wear today?
😂😂😂 That's how USA is doing while China is building military base to the ocean
Who cares
issa joke
😂😂😂
The world underestimates China they have no idea how powerful China has Become and the brains behind it.
Im shaking in my space boots
Peace is only possible between two strongs.
yeh like the submarine tank. that was some real genius
@0-0-0-0 the ccp got a lot of power but hasn't got any BRAINS
In the last few decades they pulled a billion people out of poverty increased their gdp by an exponential amount, modernized their infrastructure. While other countries like India are not even close. Their yuan has not been devalued like the US dollar which will help them in the longer term. China has become second largest economy in the world which will likely pass the US. To achieve such astonishing results only in a few decades takes a extreme amount organizing and intelligence.
Love these geopolitical videos, excellent!
Lies again? Soccer Club
China has no claim.
Quite right 👍🏽
Lol india 😂🤮💩
@@jordyj4126 dude you have nothing to do here , you should rather make sure your country gets proper electricity
I know what happened in Lahore
@@premprasun1516 lahore? Lmao 😂😂
@@jordyj4126 Yeah China a country which has disputes with every neighbour ie 17countries and can use only one logic since ancient times and selectively use Ching and Ming Dynasty maps. By that logic China should also give up land to Mongolia or the world should fall under Greek or Mongol Empire.
CCP is a curse and would lead to the next WW for sure if the PLA learns to fight instead of reading CCP conscripts
Been a crazy week BUT hold onto ur GameStop shares, DON’T SELL
HOOOOOOLD
they will sell them all for you, LOL
@@JyahWayDong Hold and crash those rich hedge funds, once for all.
There is a name for this game HOT POTATO !!!!!
HOLD THE LINEEEE lmao
how about another article "The Militarization of the pacific"? to see how many military bases of the U.S in pacific.
Those were all purchased and nobody had pledges not to militarize the South China Sea. China pledged not to, and still did. That's why it's a big deal.
Spin the wheel: where will world war 3 start?
And when :/
Probably in Taiwan they already sent fighter jets into Taiwanese air space
@@anxyfromxy4386 technically it is Chinese Air space.
@@jimpad5608 yah Republic of China's air space
@@jimpad5608 true I just used Taiwanese cause its what Im used to I keep forgetting that its Peoples Republic of China and Republic of China.
This will lead to a South China Sea version of NATO. US and it’s Pacific allies such as Japan and Australia should help in integrating ASEAN’s military capabilities.
Asean countries does not want a war with china. Instead peaceful coexsistence with COC to be establish to avoid war.
Go fight china alone with your bloody 5 eyes that had colonislise and harmed cointries all over the world.
The day will come you will be punish for all your sins.
Asean cointries will not alliance with Demon.
@@John-us9rm lol U.S and Allies are demon? You wrong, The real demon is China.
@@a_ericjuanaprasetyo5503 just philipine alone, spain , japan and usa killed millions of philipinos. Usa alone kill more than one million.
They took philipines too.
I can list many more what usa and allies had done to qualify them as demon.
This needs to happen. Change the name of the South China Sea.
May be to Malaysia north sea
Lol it’s funny how propaganda can sway people so easily. Its called the South China Sea for a reason. If other countries disputed this as much as america, id believe it.
Enjoy your propoganda
Same for Muslims in China lol, since when did America care about Muslims? Its so laughable to think you guys believe this nonsense
We already call it West Philippine Sea in the Philippines
What about to China South Sea ?
It's Vietnam East Sea. 🇻🇳
Spartly archipelago and Paracel archipelago are belonged to Vietnam. 🇻🇳
The British and American navies have already stepped up cooperation efforts. US Marines are using British carriers these days.
war is on the way it wont be pretty
@@markkelly5900 The Chinese need the west to fire the first shot and galvanize the Chinese people. Their country is coming unglued thanks to food shortages, corruption and factories leaving their people unemployed. China needs a war to make sure the people are angry at something other than the Chinese Communist Party. If we wait them out, the Chinese people themselves will likely revolt against the communists. Then we gain allies within China. If we fire the first shot, however, or at least the Chinese people believe we fire the first shot, they may turn on us. This is why the tension is high right now.
China has to move first, the islands in dispute are not theirs and are therefore on the defensive end of the conflict. Taiwan and Guam are not going to attack China. China wants the islands and they know that they'll have to fight the US and our allies in order to take them. As you've said time doesn't appear to be on their side as they seem to be losing grip on things within its own borders. The Soviets fell without a war, maybe the CCP will too.
@@mikehunt69981 I agree. The only way we could screw this up is if we shoot first. That would likely galvanize the Chinese people behind the CCP. If, however, the Chinese attack first, that might do the opposite, especially as supply lines are cut off, leaving the Chinese people without enough food or possibly even power.
Dont hope for a war, USA civil war and balkanization will happen first
Why is it so hard for the US to give up its stronghold on the opposite side of the globe and at other people's front door?
Cause it’s the US
@@sn0wdon because if China don’t claim it, the us will and history can tell us that the USA is a MUCH bigger treat to global stability than China is
@@sn0wdon Because it’s China’s backyard? Why don’t you give up control of Gulf of Mexico?
@@sn0wdon great you got the message,now we only need to us to stop sending warships there
@@sn0wdon sending military vessels in other nation’s backyard is not really appropriate even if they are technically allowed to do so, it’s a bit like, why the US was so quick to try and invade Cuba when it was in their full right to be armed with nuclear missile that, might hit us cites when war is declared
Let's not forget and ignore the Philippines won an Arbitral Award over the China sea dispute
The arbitration result came from a false "court"! The court is not even a UN agency. Do you think a piece of waste paper can convince China?
@@helengyang im sorry but thats legal proceedings. Atleast we dont steal land, countries, resources, peoples freedom and resources :>
@@helengyang Only an idiot takes the UN seriously
@@alexanderchenf1 Then tell China to lose it’s seat in the the U.N
@@helengyang False court ? That is the internationally recognised court. Wake up from your little red book brain washing !
while the world is battling corona, china is out here building cities in the sea
shoot first ask questions later
fool
China was struggling pretty hard for a while itself.
Battling corona? The Chinese government is the virus!
@@nexult5439 brainwashed
its funny how this guy talked about Chinese history in the 1900s, he mentioned France, Japan but he did not mention the Eight-Nation Alliance that invaded Beijing and committed numerous crimes...
They dont want to show the truth about the west
we are not afraid going to war with the Chinese in a fight for West Philippines Sea and our Sovereignty . . !
fidel jr passion, I sense you are anxious to ask your government to send few battalions of canoes and kayaks to confront China. When war breaks out, you will be lay down and play dead.
@@dragondescendant1 we can afford war of words
“War, war never changes”
Fr bro
That quote is stupid because war does change over time.
@@AllMustJump no it don't, it never change it just the same killing everyone and bring horrors, the quote means that
@@nathanrodo1722 it could very soon be all robots....... so i think it does change....
@@BLUEGENE13 you don't get it don't ya?
First of all who controls the sky America who controls the sea America who have 800 bases America so do the math.
800 bases thats out of range
Nahh, china just pick the right spot to BLOCK all.. tiny weeny sand bank with AhSM 1000km radius.
Literally Indonesia on 2018:
"Sir. China claims some of our EEZ in north of Natuna Islands."
"Okay then."
Several moments later, Indonesian government be like:
"Now, we announce that sea up north of Natuna Islands which name as we already know, South China Sea now we changing the name to be North Natuna Sea."
ASEAN: *confuses pikachu face*
China: *angry noises*
careful, there are a lot of trolls in the comment section
Mostly angry stupid people that like to talk bullshit.
A lot of CCP bots
Of course, everyone you disagree with is trolls. How pitiful and weak must your position be for you to have to use such a banal demogological trick - argumentum ad hominem - to defend it?
@@cassinitakano5736 Wumao
@@Big_Sloppa if you cant tell the difference between a troll and someone who actually has an opinion in the matter then thats on you, not me
The Pooh has huge ambition.
@king fisher Has America ever claimed the islands as its own? What a dumb argument. False dichotomy.
Meanwhile Vietnam claim almost all of spraty and paracells because their Nguyễn dynasty has been looting the European crashed ships for 200 years
3:15 You forgot Indonesia's Riau and Natuna islands are located in the area too. So Indonesia also need to defend it's sovereignty in south chinese sea.
Yah, jauhkan penjajah dari tanah air Indonesia
@@estevanus china did not claim natuna but its indonesia that cannot EEZ into chinas sea that was claim by china prior to unclos.
@@John-us9rm Apa maksud mu? Apa kamu tidak tahu apa saja yang china komunis lakukan di lautan Indonesia beberapa bulan terakhir dari mengirim penjaga pantainya ke wilayah laut Indonesia sampai kapal mata-matanya yang belum lama ini terjadi?
@@estevanus mai yu ren zhi dao ni sia sen mo.
@@John-us9rm Dasar bot china kolang kaling nintau mo ator tuh kata-kata
India, Japan , USA , Taiwan, Vietnam, Korea, Philippine this 7 countries is enough to eradicate china in map
i mean south korea
Support From Australia !!
In Oz we have a handful of F-18 super hornets and few F35. Three small aircraft carriers and no nuclear weapons. We are the ones in real danger
Love from Chattisgarh india 😘❤️👍😘👍😘😘😘🇮🇳😁😁😁😁😁
We are spending more than 200 billion on our defence force over the next decade, half of which will be used to bulk up our navy.
@@4andronicus no nukes= no respect
@42nd Street Donald Trump gave us this impression that the US wouldn't defend us if it didn't meet the American' s interests.
We have been with our historical ally from the start but it's disturbing to hear Pompeo or whoever said it, that they'd drop us anytime they wanted if we didn't do as they say
The wheel spins toward confrontation
Actually it has been getting better. Most ASEAN countries are starting to keel over to China.
@@Gongolongo where is the getting better part begin. I doubt that is thar case of course.
@@Gongolongo: Rubbish. No Indo-Pacific nations have "keeled over" to the CCP . The CCP is in dispute with ALL it's neighbours.
The best way is all allies ships and navy turn up at once in the area and do nothing. Will test china's attitude.
There are Chinese ships and navy always in South China sea , if you want war let's play.
Yeah it will be a best chance to destroy USA and it's all allies with a nuke only 😂
Nuclear war, which your country doesn’t have any
@@xuwanglin154 says the country who unleashed this idiotic pandemic in the world. Disgusting.
@@mephisto5856you can keep slandering where the pandemic came from but the covid 19 will never be stopped if you keep doing stupid things. Anti this against that is not the solution for the problem.
5:25 key point of entire video.
This is the best video I have seen on this topic...very clear and informative. Well done!
Same.
It is not south China Sea. It is SEA sea🤣. South East Asia sea.
It's Vietnam East Sea. 🇻🇳
Spartly archipelago and Paracel archipelago are belonged to Vietnam. 🇻🇳
@Cody J We don't claim the whole South China Sea. We only rightfully claim our ownership to Spartly archipelago and Paracel archipelago.
@Cody J Falkand island is much more closer to Argentina but it's still belonged to UK so Spartly archipelago is closer to Philippines doesn't mean it is belonged to Philipines. Vietnam has historical evidence to prove that Vietnam has has already owned Spartly archipelago and Paracel archipelago in 18th century during Later Le dynasty.
What China had done in the SCS is defending its right of passage (to ensure freedom of navigation) for its imports and exports passing through the SCS and Indian Ocean.
@@traaotuong6107 And Vietnam didn't even attend the arbitration in 2016. Only the Philippines. Vietnam can't even back their claims with evidence while the Philippines presented theirs. Huh.
What is US doing there? What if Iran, China, Russia etc are all in Gulf of Mexico. How would US react?
If the US leaves the South China Sea, China will complete it’s intimidating of all other neighboring countries and make war inevitably. Spice in a complete assault and war over Taiwan.
We SEA have been keep china in check, china won't dare because it a fucking business highway. One mistake from china their trading highway gone
@@kingfisher1069 Oh so US doesnt intimidate it's neighbours, Columbia? Venezuela??? I wasn't born yesterday, I know how politics work
@Covert Puppy Two So US is in International waters? Let's move some of the Russian & Chinese military equipment near New York & Washington by the international waters. Oh boy I wouldn't want to guess how US would react to that. They would go insane warmode.
@@mattno100 I don't understand what you just said. Please explain in more detail. Iran shot down US drone, nothing happened. US is aware that there is no winners with getting into war with China. It will never happen. This is all politics to get your attention away how bad the situation is inside the US. I'm just here to open your eyes, nothing else.
China: claims south china sea because it has 'china' in its name.
India: Observes🤔
because before 100yrs ago, only China had technology and money to sail far enough.
lol the same process will repeat with us when we get economically stronger
When will Southeast Asian countries be able to seize China's islands? Besides, how can the United States not condemn so many hooligans? Some countries in Southeast Asia do not have the potential of a superpower, but have the ambition of a superpower
The southern half of the sea should be named “Inter-Malaysian Sea”.
Even “Southeast Asian Sea” sounds better and more appropriate than South China Sea..
I'm agree with naming the sea to the Southeast Asia Sea
in the philippines, we refer scs as west philippine sea
Indonesian called scs as North Natuna Sea
@@hirohunter2314 personally like "Sea of Southeast Asia" better
West philippine sea
Talk about trying to close the gate after the horse has bolted!.
It was the Obama administration's (in)actions towards the Scarborough Shoal incident that left the door wide open for China to militarise islands in the South China Sea. The US at the time made it very clear they were more interested in Middle Eastern oil than backing up ASEAN allies like the Philippines against Chinese aggression and landgrabs. I wonder what Obama 2.0 admin is going to do this time? Probably won't back Japan up when Chinese ships fire on coast guard vessels around Senkaku. "Pivet to Asia" my ass.
@@Bobbyjonesyrrr It's their (China) neighbourhood and they are going to help themselves to what ever resources they can lay their hands on. They also have a population five times the size of the US and an economy growing at a staggering rate.
@@Bobbyjonesyrrr why would China fire upon japanese ships and senkaku?arent China and japanese the best of friends?i heard a long time ago like somewhere between 1937 and 1941 the japanese sent an entourage to Nanking to commemorate qing shi huang's birthday no and celebrate chinese new year?
@@jont2576 is this supposed to be sarcasm?
@@jont2576
ahhaha xd
Great you are keeping an eye on this "hot" zone
lol what's funny is that China has only 4 overseas military bases while the US has around 5000, but nah China is aggressive and evil haha
hell yeah, just build our own military bases and hopefully build more on other nations like what the US did.
The pirate king (China)
And what nationality are you?
@@myroseaccount Looks to be a Flip? 🤔
Historical evidence shows its asean countries that is the pirate robbng chinas
So what? China doesnt rights to defend its own teritory? Ha ha western double standards. Western democracy supported with NATO pirate army goes into countries rich with natural resorses to overthrow legal governments and instal thiers puppies... USA sinking very fast... RIP USA
@@djole967 ? Huh? Are you stupid? Protecting thier not territory? I guess im dead before china invade my country.
As soon as he explained the active defense thing I thought of ww2 us and Japan, that’s what the us did
What? No, the US did not do anything like that in WW2.
@@stephenjenkins7971 You deeply do not know, before and after the defeat of Japan, what are all those history that happened w/n Japan fall to the hands of the US/ BRITISH, Japan can embrace any kind of attempt suicide as the Bushido, Kamikaze, etc cause they will not Surrender, whatever will be, will be, even Harry Truman have said, If You Do Not Accept Our Terms, You will Expect a Rain of Ruin of a Hot Rain, The like You Have Never Seen on This Earth (Aug.6, 1945 ) and exactly after that warning The Atomic Nuclear Bomb drop to Nagasaki and Hiroshima. The US tell the truth, that Emperor Hirohito surrendered Japan. In spite of this, the Japanese Soldier doesnt want to gave up, mostly commit suicide. You have also to know how many people died at every country have conquered, Mostly the way they killed citizen people is to cut your head either you are civilian or any catigory of military you are, you are not considered as a Prisoner of War. These lesson the Japanese got to the US, is now their Boss that will do everything to be side to the US/ Britain even to kiss forever the ass of its dominator
Someone give Sam Fischer a call. We need a job done.
P.S. Bring honey.
Don't make any noise and blow his cover or you'll hear a radio call
"Dammit Fischer, the mission is over"
P.S. Damn I could still hear his voice in my head after reading that lol
i love this
For you?
Xi jin ping literally told Obama and his whole cabinet that China will not militarize the south China sea if America withdrawals its aircraft carriers from the area back in 2014...
What did Obama do?
He sent more fking carriers...
So guess why chinas militarizing the scs right now.
The average person doesn't have the mental capacity or IQ to do any real research on this topic so people just think "oh wow China bad China expanding China evil". It's so idiotic
Support China 🇨🇳😘
"im the captain now"
Save everyone from China captian
Not yet.
Then go down with your ship
The only map with a nine dash line is made in CCP
You have to research in the library before speeching on CCP's claim on the South China Sea. The dash line was initially posted by Kuomintang of ROC after the WW2, which was called 11 dash line at that time. All the countries around South China Sea did not object this claim and this China's territory was printed in maps of all the counties, including USA, Canada, Vietnam. When was 11 dash line was replaced by 9 dash line? Vietnam war. When US was involved in Vietnam war again the Vietnam communist party in the north, CCP decided to help Vietnam and borrowed an island to Vietnam for establishing the radar base at the northwest of South China Sea. So, two dashes were deleted in this area. Actually, Vietnam did not give that island back to China after the war. So, you have ask Taiwan for the reason why there is a line in South Chian Sea. Another important issue I need to mention is the islands in South China Sea were discovered before Christ by the Chinese. Ancient Chinese fishermen were used for rest and supply, which recorded even in history 2000 years ago. At that time, only a few primitive tribes existed on the land around South China Sea. I really do not know can anybody claim others' land because you are close to mine. If in that case, China should claim lands from Vietnam, Philippine, Malasia, because your land is too close to mine.
@@31873015 Yeah it was ROC since they also had the same claim as PRC. So two China have the same claim.
@@31873015 China as of 2018 has not filed a formal and specifically defined claim to the area with in the dashes. So no one could possibly object to this.
In 2016 the permanent court of arbitration ruled that China has no legal basis to claim historic rights with in the nine dash line.
Your propaganda does not work on me.
Now go back to my original statement and prove me wrong.
@@yin6287 There is no two China. Taiwan is only a government in exile. Once Kuomintang can defect the CCP and control the mainland of China, ROC will be a representative government of China. Taiwan will never be a country or another China, which is decided by its constitution.
If we all base on history, then everybody has their own history base on what everybody wants to tell you about his story telling. If no man can claim this entire world base on history alone then history claims are no basis. That is why the world needs international laws in order to have international and common orders and that every body should participate & committed for the sake of long lasting peace
The South China sea was originally named the Champ Sea, which was named after the ancient kingdom in current central Vietnam. Vietnamese already continuously administrated both of 2 these islands since 17th century and no single country except VN claimed those at that time. Both of Paracel and Spratly were belong to Indochina/Annam colony of France, so after getting independence, Vietnam had full right to take these 2 islands back obviously. And South Vietnam did that and exercised legal control over these 2 islands until China came illegally in 1974 and 1988. And I want to make it clear that Vietnam does not claim entire SCS, we only claim our 200 nautical mile EEZ + our these 2 islands which lay outside of our EEZ( but as I said EEZ can't apply for islands). Even a lot of messy problems arising until now after Chinese came and some other countries claimed based on EEZ, hope Vietnam and other countries involving can avoid conflict as much as possible
More detail about San Francisco Conference :
The conference was joined by 51 countries around the world. This is the piece treaty of UN attempt to return all colonies to its initial country after WW2, and as a result, this treaty formed hundred of nowadays countries in the world. In the treaty Japan had to return all colonies back to original countries, which include Paracel and Spratly islands controlled by French. Both of China and Vietnam asserted their claim on Hoàng Sa( Paracel Islands ) and Trường Sa ( Spratly Islands ) but China's claim was rejected by 45 out of 51 countries whereas Tran Van Huu, Prime Minister of Bao Dai’s government of Vietnam stated that “in order to annul the seeds of possible disputes, we claim our sovereignty over Hoang Sa and Truong Sa archipelagos”. No objections were raised nor any reservations made against his statement at the conference.
France, in the victory side, also asserted the sovereignty of both of Paracel and Spratly Islands are belong to Annam of Vietnamese because Japan took over them from France.
Hoàng Sa and Trường Sa was belong to South Vietnam from 1956 to 1974 and the entire UN, except China nor Russia, recognized and didn't oppose to them. In 1974 China illegally fought and invaded Hoàng Sa ( Paracel Islands) and fought Trường Sa (Spratly Islands) in 1988, but it could only occupy small part of Spratly Islands.
never knew Vietnam was called chimpanzee lol now I see why
@台湾蛙🐸来对线 Why some Chinese are still obsessed too much with historical events. Qing Dynasty already collapsed. If you want to talk about the history, you should belong to Mongolian because you was a part of that. If you claim that South China Sea, why you signed UNCLOS in December 1982. Can you explain why?
@不羁之风 thật lố bịch :)))
Why focus on China . In South China Sea Vietnam hold 28 islands while other countries such as China or Philippines only hold 8 islands
Can't they at least wait until 2022? Right now a WW3 does not fit my schedule. I am *not* amused.
Same here bro I still need to if ww3 can fits To may scadule currently im working on Zombie apocalypse 😂
stop calling it south china sea, call it south east asian sea instead
Lol，you dont like it?
I never thought that i would see a world war happenig in my lifetime...
More likely to be regional war
@@jamesgleeson6538 same with EU on the WW2, right?
More like a Cold War.
@@jamesgleeson6538 in the South China Sea? No way, this is the spark for global conflict.
Humans are a malevolent species. They need war, conflict and hostility with each other over resources needed for survival. It has always been that way and will always be that way. Other animals also mark out the territory.
Why do people keep calling it South China Sea? It is not a property of China. Philippines won the International Arbitral Tribunal so it is called West Philippine Sea.
China give us back our sea!! The Philippines ain't HAVING THIS ANYMORE
Unlucky it is how it is
It's South East Asia sea, not south china sea. The territories of vietnam, indonesia, thailand, philippines, cambodia, malaysia and brunei
抱歉这是中国南海
@Fenimore Jhno So china is the territory of japan and mongolia based on your "history" claim?
@Fenimore Jhno They did occupy huge part of the territories that china now claims as their own
@楼鸢 These south east asian countries also has become independent countries which have their own water territories. And those are what china tries to claim
This is the problem when you make the monster rich, now it tries to devour you.
well said ;)
biting the hand that feeds you never ends well either
i understand there is 11 billion barrels of oil under the South China sea.
Exactly
lets change the name of south china sea by ASIAN SEA..
Let’s call it the Hawaiian Sea of Japan.
@@dcho5057 Bot
Correction: ASEAN Sea
*South East Asian sea
SEA SEA
Its West Philippines Sea . The 9 dash line is too much. If it not take action it will become like falkland that cant be recovered.
When you give your enemy enough time to grow and gain the leverage to threaten you back in the future...
Exactly. China should’ve been stopped many years ago
@@tornadochaser7226 The Obama Administration did nothing to stop this
It's pretty hilarious how they try to claim territory right on Vietnam, Malaysia & Phillipines doorstep 🤦♂️
What's more ridiculous is that some people have ignored China's strength and its history in this area. If you think that China is not so powerful, you should think about why the United States has not directly attacked China.This world is the world of the jungle!Why didn't you condemn the United States when it invaded other countries? Are they really so noble for democracy and freedom?
@@ziranlan9780 is this video about the South Asian Sea or the US? 🙄
Vietnam is understandable because they are close to each other. But all the way to the Malaysia and Brunei water? That just insane.
@@Justin1an no. They can't claim Vietnam's entire ocean.
Yo. They making bases near my country (Philippines). Our current President (Duterte) thinks that China/CCP are our friends....
Hahahahahahahahaha. We dead.
No, he just understands that you are either a puppet of China or you are the trash of America and her allies. Either way, you're going to be abused lol
I live in china and it blew my mind when my one nationalistic chinese friend said. JAPAN BELONGS TO CHINA 😂
U R a liar. 🤥
Soon China will start claiming even my underwear
@@cassinitakano5736 China does claim its near Arctic State.
@@cassinitakano5736 Considering how the built fake islands in the South China Sea it does not take much imagination to consider that China might try to do the same in the Arctic.
I think he is just joking. Most people in China know Japan belong to America. US controls all the army and court also police in Japan.
This downplays the real situation that is developing in the region, the amount of money behind this area of water is unparalleled to any water of similar size. It’s scary how careless the general population is over this whole situation. Water will be the cause of the next wars. As China chokes the Mekong and half of those country’s are put under the boot of China, war will be too late. China in all aspects is trying to expand and will achieve it because the government operates if someone is starving their country of water
The more combative the PRC becomes, the more retaliation they'll see from the US, present and future US allies. And at scale that will give the PRC pause.
It’s also Japan, , India, Australia, who feel the same way as the US..
Don't speak on my or my country's behalf, who do you think you are?
Why is the US wasting tax payer dollars on this?
China: takes over South China Sea
Philippines: Guess I'll take all these Pacific Ocean myself
Not without a navy, it won't.
I hope super power countries will help us get our territories back to us Filipinos. 🇵🇭
First turn back territories illegally occupied/claimed during 1970s.
Philippines has nothing to claim. Almost everything was earned thru "gift". If you insist, are you ready to be the next Syria? Don't be fooled.
They won’t help you, they just want to own you the same way China does.
Do you think the United States will confront China directly for the sake of the Philippines?
If China can claim places based on history, the UK can claim 1/3 of the world
I need to remember to never make political jokes, even if they’re barely political. Ever. Or comment on a political Video. Ever. Deep regrets
The British empire is officially over decades ago, thus no other countries being support its imperialism, in short UK is too weak to annex any land alone.
@@leonleon2021 of course but I think their point was more about how china's "historical" claims are bullshit and hold no water, just like if the UK was to try and claim such territories today.
@@War_Daddy103 the major difference is China has the power to claim the lands back.
@@leonleon2021 not if the US pokes it's nose in for whatever reasons they come up with. economy wise the two are neck and neck with China starting to pull ahead but military wise China is just a little bit outclassed. Best analogy I could give you is that China is around Vietnam era/early gulf war in terms of military tech and the US is present day if you were to compare the difference.
@@War_Daddy103 are u sure about what u said?? have you watched the 70th Anniversary about China? they showed plenty of great weaponries tho. if China is REALLY that weak and obsolete, USA would just invade China just as they did to IRAQ.
You ur basis are nothing but blind and biased.
MY QUESTION IS THIS BEING HAPPENING FOR 10YEARS WHY DON'T WE DO SOMETHING BEFORE IT GETS WORSE.
BF4 Paracel Storm was so ahead of its time.
Lol yea
Begun the clone wars has...
Agree
yes commander clit
Chinese will do what they want... Nobody will stop them...
@Alfonso U nuclear them ,who cares
@@alleng9991 Pretty much. China should increase nuclear stockpiles to same as USA
Some of them actually believe that, and THAT will start a war that would most likely result in their destruction and much of the rest of the World as well.
@@richhagenchicago Don’t start a war with China then. If you destroy our home, why would we allow yours to exist? 🤔
@@jeanking2654 We won't , no one sane would want World War 3, but if they continue to take territory from other countries, war is inevitable.
From what I can see is that the increase in US Military presence in south asia has caused China to set up defensive positions, maybe I am wrong but between the USA and China who do you think is the most likely to start or want a conflict!!!
Actually it is China Russia and Iran causing all the hassle.
@@georgiakidd7818 I think it's the country that has the most bases around the globe causing all the hassle
Mate!!! Just google TAIWAN Strait incident ,ya get the picture...
@@TSRHelios China are trying to bully taiwan, India, Australia, yet you still blame it on America?
@Georgia Kidd Taiwan is historical problem, it was civil war. KMT lost and retreat to Taiwan until now.
For India, China has released the footage. Indian army are building tents opposite the river and then cross the river first and being offensive before Chinese repel them.
For Australia, Scomo thought he is Trump, but he is not leading America 😂
Back to the topic, isn't it a coincidence that the countries that you mentioned causing the problems (China, Russia and Iran) are rival of America? Is it so happen that the problematic countries are rival of Murica or it's just geopolitics and media at play here? US is not a regional country, its located far away and should have no say over the region, yet they are going for "freedom of navigation". They are not UNCLOS signatory country, yet asking for other countries to obey to UNCLOS. 😂