THE CLOSENESS OF PAUL AND HIS DAD

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 дек 2024

Комментарии • 224

  • @Lily_The_Pink972
    @Lily_The_Pink972 Год назад +32

    Paul bought his dad a house in Heswall across the River Mersey from Liverpool on the Wirrall. My auntie lived round the corner. Paul and the family still own the house.

    • @parabot2
      @parabot2 8 месяцев назад

      HE never put a head stone on his mothers grave , very odd that .

    • @TheBeatlesMan96
      @TheBeatlesMan96 Месяц назад +1

      @@parabot2Paul’s brother himself stated that there is no headstone so it didn’t become a shrine from fans, that makes sense.

    • @DavidMcdonald-df8tb
      @DavidMcdonald-df8tb 2 дня назад +1

      ​@@TheBeatlesMan96I don't care whether they put one there or not but I will point out that when his mom died Paul was not famous ❤

  • @evathetraveler
    @evathetraveler Год назад +49

    Sounds like a very honorable man. Great dad, great son.

  • @walterevans2118
    @walterevans2118 Год назад +61

    LOVELY to hear how Paul’s DAD lived to see his son develop into one of the best songwriters that has ever lived….And how Paul when he was famous went on to help Dad after he suffered the tragedy of losing Paul’s Mum.

    • @simontaylor2319
      @simontaylor2319 11 месяцев назад +2

      He bought him a house & his father James remarried & had a daughter Ruth. We never hear about Ruth

    • @mdoreenbarrett8728
      @mdoreenbarrett8728 11 месяцев назад +5

      Really. Paul's mom died when Paul was only 14.

  • @The5Leeses
    @The5Leeses Год назад +11

    So adorable!!! Paul got his dads eyebrows !Bless his ❤️!

  • @martifingers
    @martifingers Год назад +21

    One of the insights of the Get Back documentary was the basic simple goodness of everyone, how the kids were indulged and cherished, how the Beatles just larked about - there is a rather touching scene where Linda and Yoko are simply enjoying each others company. This video confirms this perception and fills in some of the background.
    Being stratospherically famous brought its own pressures no doubt but the humanity and love evident in their early lives perhaps found its way into the music and that may be one of the reasons it touched so many?

  • @christophermorgan3261
    @christophermorgan3261 Год назад +15

    When I find myself in times of trouble mother Mary comes to me speaking words of wisdom let it be. . .

    • @jurepotokar9068
      @jurepotokar9068 Год назад +4

      Father McCartney (McKenzie)

    • @nielszindel1151
      @nielszindel1151 Год назад +2

      Lovely song and one I dedicate to my now deceased mum. Delia Morris

  • @ChipsAplentyBand
    @ChipsAplentyBand Год назад +63

    Thank you so much for this video! A lingering, burning question for me is how Paul's dad reacted to The Beatles' success and fame. I would think it might have been overwhelming for him and for the other's families too. How nice that Paul made a point to take care of his dad too. I'm sorry that Paul's son never got to meet his paternal grandfather. If memory serves, all three generations were named 'James.'

    • @docsavage8640
      @docsavage8640 Год назад +4

      4 generations: James, Jim, James Paul, and James.

    • @jacenoley2597
      @jacenoley2597 Год назад +13

      Paul's dad was thrilled with Paul's success. Paul said he was out with his father at a restaurant and Jim said to Paul that everyone was looking at them and was more excited and happy about Paul being the center of attention than Paul himself.

    • @silvialeprattomazza6214
      @silvialeprattomazza6214 Месяц назад

      All Beatles took care of their parents and in John's case, his aunt, when they became famous. Good sons.

  • @WilliamDilbeck
    @WilliamDilbeck Год назад +10

    Gail here ! Fan since Feb. 1964 ! Paul is and always has been my favorite !

  • @diane1390
    @diane1390 Год назад +9

    What a lovely family. I wish that I could have had such a loving family. ❤

  • @maxwellfan55
    @maxwellfan55 Год назад +16

    Very well presented. Shows Paul was very considerate, generous and organised in how he did things and treated people. Which couldn't have been easy with such a demanding career.

  • @nielszindel1151
    @nielszindel1151 Год назад +6

    Even now you can see Paul's very good social upbringing, he is lucky to have had such lovely parents, but so sad he lost his mum early. Delia Morris

  • @janewilmer6396
    @janewilmer6396 2 месяца назад +2

    Good dads are so important in the raising of children.

  • @duanecolegrove
    @duanecolegrove Год назад +9

    Amazing story Paul had a wonderful father

  • @OnePost909
    @OnePost909 Год назад +25

    The fundamental difference between Paul and John is, Paul had a dad he loved and respected and John did not.

    • @andyscott6315
      @andyscott6315 11 месяцев назад +3

      One of the few differences between them.

    • @AndyMann-vs3sf
      @AndyMann-vs3sf Месяц назад

      Fundamental difference is that John was John and William was Paul.

    • @OnePost909
      @OnePost909 Месяц назад

      @@AndyMann-vs3sf How about this for a conspiracy theory: the Faul thing is a plot by Apple to keep Paul's name out there and sell records. Refute that one, "Andy."

    • @meeeka
      @meeeka 11 дней назад

      But John had an Uncle who did his best to fill the father role.

  • @carlcushmanhybels8159
    @carlcushmanhybels8159 Год назад +9

    Thanks! Excellent! I happen to know Paul's reason why he deliberately flubbed his Liverpool Cathedral Choir audition as a kid: From "McCartney" by Mr. Norman: Paul thought Liverpool Cathedral... too posh. Therefore, uncomfortable. Rather, Paul auditioned and joined a choir in Allerton, the village he lived in, part of wider Liverpool.

  • @Jarrard68
    @Jarrard68 Год назад +18

    Can't wait for part 2. By the way, you have a lovely voice.

  • @marymcleod8930
    @marymcleod8930 Год назад +11

    I truly enjoyed this film. Paul's work ethic is a true testimony to his Father, Mary in Boone

  • @gcrichman53
    @gcrichman53 Год назад +10

    Paul McCartney inherited his father Jim McCartney's ( who as you correctly said Paul was named after,Paul is his middle name,and he named his only son,James after his father) natural music talent but to an extreme rare degree,his father was a self taught jazz pianist, at 10 he broke one of his eardrums,and by 14 taught himself to play the piano and he was the leader of his own jazz band Jim Mac's Band who were popular in Liverpool clubs.
    But his father wasn't a poet, and Paul can and did write great lyrics but even when he did,it was his music composing and bass and just about anything else playing that was the most outstanding.

    Jim even wrote a really good 1920's jazz instrumental,Walking In The Park With Eloise that Paul and other musicians recorded in 1974 and it's on the 1976 Wings At The Speed of Sound album and it's on youtube.
    Paul's father's father,also was naturally musically talented and he played brass in a band,and is to have had a very good singing voice which is where Paul also got his once great singing voice for rock,love songs and everything in between.
    Paul has been in The Guinness Book Of World Records since 1979 as the most successful song writer of all time,Paul was also given an honorary doctorate in music from Sussex University in 1988,and another one from Yale University in 2008.
    Paul even helped his younger brother Michael with his once only somewhat successful music career,but his brother gave it up and was a better photographer instead. Paul is such a rare natural music genius that he woke up with this beautiful masterpiece in his head at only the age of 22 with a piano by his bed. Paul wasn't sure that he wrote it at first so he went around singing it to a lot of different people and asked them if they had of it before and they all said no and then Paul realized he wrote it.
    Here in this great TV Guide interview from May 2001 he talks about how he likely wrote Yesterday subconsciously about the sad death of his mother Mary who was a nurse and a midwife and she died of breast cancer at only the age of 47 when Paul was only 14 and his brother was only 12. Paul also said he has music in his genes from his Dad. Paul said that he realized as a kid that he couldn't sing and play trumpet at the same time.
    John inherited his mother Julia's natural music talent because she was a self taught banjo player and as Paul said which was unusual in the 1950's for a woman and she sang too. John's paternal grandfather sang in a band so that must be where John inherited his unique strong beautiful singing voice.

  • @johnledingham852
    @johnledingham852 Год назад +26

    A very nice reflection on those tender early years in the life of Paul. And the type of family he was a part of. It explains to me why Paul always
    seemed to be the most level headed member of the fad four. I look forward to more of your research coming out in future videos.

    • @docsavage8640
      @docsavage8640 Год назад +5

      Also explains his fondess for entertaining and amusing children

  • @tonykehoe123
    @tonykehoe123 Год назад +9

    The first set of photographs are from western avenue . I lived in a house adjacent and our garden backed onto The McCartney’s . ( although they had moved when we lived there ) my grandmother knew Mary McCartney quite well . Mrs Carney moved into the house when they left and my sister was a friend of her daughters and would often be a visitor to their house at 72 western avenue. Stockton wood primary school was just around the corner .

  • @steveconn
    @steveconn Год назад +16

    A much more stable family environment and father figure than John had. Explains alot.

    • @docsavage8640
      @docsavage8640 Год назад +6

      It does indeed. And the poverty explains his thriftiness.

  • @AngierManNC
    @AngierManNC Год назад +16

    Your narration is the most pleasant to hear of all videos that I listen to. Thank you!

  • @johnbrereton5229
    @johnbrereton5229 День назад

    What a very interesting and touching video, which brought tears to my eyes. My own father died when i was 16 and he was 47, the same age as Pauls mum. 😢 Pauls was lucky to grow up in such a loving family and so was I.

  • @ronleight9341
    @ronleight9341 Год назад +15

    Fun fact, Paul's Dad shared the same birthday as Ringo!

    • @taragreenetarotastro
      @taragreenetarotastro 10 месяцев назад

      Cancerian emotional nurturing family and children oriented protective

  • @susanschaffner4422
    @susanschaffner4422 Год назад +5

    New to me all your insights, thanks. We see why Paul is so special.

  • @patorjk
    @patorjk Год назад +17

    These videos are always really informative, thank you for making them.

  • @trillioncrowns
    @trillioncrowns Год назад +12

    What a special channel! Nothing like this exists on the web! There no doubt in my mind that some of your subscribers could be people who actually knew the beatles or imagine paul or ringo have watched! Im 100% sure of this! Its just these vids are so heavy

  • @paulseano5100
    @paulseano5100 Год назад +14

    Thank you for sharing this video and insight. I just watched it last night and really enjoyed it. You really have shared quite a bit of info on the Beatles both as a band and them individually. Things some of us would have never known. Thank you. You should received some sort of accolade from You Tube for your video content. It’s very interesting and informative. You also seem to have a very loving and gentle spirit and your voice is enjoyable to listen to while we watch. Awesome to have the opportunity to listen. Thanks again and a Blessed Christmas to you and yours. Cheers!

    • @thebeatlesforever
      @thebeatlesforever  11 месяцев назад +1

      Thank you for your comments I appreciate it. Merry Christmas to you and your family too.

  • @simontaylor2319
    @simontaylor2319 11 месяцев назад +5

    Paul is fortunate (his brother also) they kept their hair; perhaps he followed his mother's side. I imagine James was extremely proud of his son's' huge success and diplomatic behaviour

    • @chrispavlich9656
      @chrispavlich9656 11 месяцев назад +1

      Male pattern baldness is inherited from the mother’s side of the family.

    • @simontaylor2319
      @simontaylor2319 11 месяцев назад +1

      what is male pattern baldness?

    • @chrispavlich9656
      @chrispavlich9656 11 месяцев назад +2

      @@simontaylor2319 It’s baldness that presents itself as either a receding hairline, loss of hair on the crown of the scalp or a combination of both.

  • @mailbox4820
    @mailbox4820 11 месяцев назад +2

    This is great! Thank you for creating this!

  • @teresahooks3746
    @teresahooks3746 Год назад +6

    I enjoyed this very much. I learned alot about his dad.I never knew he had a step sister. Thank you for this. 😊

    • @thebeatlesforever
      @thebeatlesforever  Год назад +3

      You are so welcome

    • @jackeppington6488
      @jackeppington6488 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@thebeatlesforever I wonder how they got on. I've heard stories that Paul was cheesed off that his father remarried, but eventually came around to the new wife and Ruth.

  • @ssmouse77
    @ssmouse77 Год назад +4

    Beautifully told. I love that this video is here. Thank you very much.

  • @jamesrobiscoe1174
    @jamesrobiscoe1174 10 месяцев назад +2

    I liked The Beatles but never bothered about biographical expositions. You hooked me with "Paul and his Dad." And opened a door to shad new light. So thank you.

  • @debradonato5659
    @debradonato5659 5 месяцев назад +2

    Jim raised Paul&Mike♥️♥️♥️

  • @chermarie332
    @chermarie332 Год назад +1

    thank you! I've been a long time fan of the Beatles. Great father and family!

  • @anneteller3128
    @anneteller3128 Год назад +7

    What a nice video! It's the best video I've seen of Paulie's childhood.

  • @PMQB
    @PMQB Год назад +3

    Thank you so very much for sharing Paul's life with we His fans
    JulieKilburn

  • @rleehall1
    @rleehall1 Год назад +3

    Excellent video, good Old Jim, and what a great son. Paul is a wonderful human being. I'm so glad that I got to see him at the Cow Palace in 1976.

    • @thebeatlesforever
      @thebeatlesforever  11 месяцев назад +1

      Thank you for your comment. I bet that was great to see Paul.

    • @rleehall1
      @rleehall1 11 месяцев назад +1

      It was great, and now to know that at the same time seeing Linda, the great Denny Laine, Jimmy McCulloch, and of course Joe English. Also, now out on the Deluxe Edition of Wings Over America Live album are a few songs recorded at the Cow Palace, so I may be a tad-bit of the roaring crowd etched in history of a wonderful concert.@@thebeatlesforever

  • @albertmontes11
    @albertmontes11 Год назад +3

    I hope to hear more about James and Paul McCartney!! Very informative and interesting.....thanks 😊😊😊

  • @pantone41
    @pantone41 Год назад +3

    Thanks for the background work.

  • @susancorgi
    @susancorgi Год назад +2

    So much interesting info here. wow thank you

  • @randilevson9547
    @randilevson9547 11 месяцев назад +1

    Great detailed information. Thank you.

  • @rogertinker1813
    @rogertinker1813 Год назад +4

    Thak you again , being a big beatle fan i always look forward to uou next installment, as i always learn grom you .

  • @NormanPeterson
    @NormanPeterson 2 месяца назад

    Awesome!!!

  • @johnurban7333
    @johnurban7333 6 месяцев назад

    Love your videos. You do a great thorough job. So all those people that think Paul died in 1966, I’m sure Paul’s dad wouldn’t go along with something like that because of the strong bond they had. You can’t grieve and carry on like nothings happened. No amount of money can replace a child you are that close too. Thanks for showing this but I’m afraid they still will believe what they want to believe

  • @tomball7009
    @tomball7009 Год назад +6

    The benefit of the being raised with an older persons wisdom.

  • @kimhayes3828
    @kimhayes3828 Год назад +1

    What a lovely video! Very enjoyable, thank you!

  • @Kelly-fk3oi
    @Kelly-fk3oi Год назад +3

    Always enjoy tuning into your informative Fab videos.👍PS Your voice is easy on the ears.👂👂

  • @favouritemoon4133
    @favouritemoon4133 Год назад +5

    Lovely video, info, pictures, etc. Thank you!

  • @griefwells
    @griefwells Год назад +7

    The Beatles Forever, Forever!!!!!

  • @simontaylor2319
    @simontaylor2319 11 месяцев назад +1

    Nice balastor blinds behind them at10:32 - they were made in Holland, the best blinds ever

  • @austinskaggs4184
    @austinskaggs4184 11 месяцев назад

    I love the passion you put into your videos. I can tell that you enjoy the process. Keep up the good work.
    I’m a John fan, but I’ll watch a Paul video every now and then. Learned some new things in this one!

  • @Mediawatcher2023
    @Mediawatcher2023 Год назад +1

    very good research all the best

  • @bodichair
    @bodichair Год назад +11

    Watch the dogs in the streets to learn about sex. That explains why he wrote Why dont we do it in the road 😅

  • @buttercup1765
    @buttercup1765 Год назад +5

    Paul got his dad's eyebrows, it looks like

  • @rodrobson
    @rodrobson Год назад +6

    Thanks for posting this video it's very interesting. I might be wrong but I think John and Paul lost their Dad's in the same year. They had a lot in common did John and Paul

    • @docsavage8640
      @docsavage8640 Год назад +4

      Yes, both died in 1976, but other than that no similarities in paternal relationships

    • @letitbe777
      @letitbe777 Год назад +3

      And both Paul and John lost their moms within 2 years of each other. All at such a very young age 💔

  • @TheTV1972
    @TheTV1972 Год назад +2

    Loved this - thank you❤

  • @matrox
    @matrox Год назад +5

    I like how Paul made sure his father's wife was not going to be a gold digger and rip him off so Paul kept a good accounting of the money.

    • @scottishlady1474
      @scottishlady1474 Год назад +6

      I read (I believe it was after his father died), they had a falling out because she was selling his personal belonging such as Paul's report cards, birth certificate etc.

    • @matrox
      @matrox Год назад +3

      @@scottishlady1474 Golddigger as I expected.

  • @bastianray6334
    @bastianray6334 Год назад +6

    Paul's relationship with his dad as usual is totally the opposite relationship John had with his dad which John despised and disliked so much for having abandoned him .

    • @matrox
      @matrox Год назад +2

      John had it hard all the way around....his father left him, he saw his own mother get killed when hit by a car, then was forced to go live with his Aunt who had a bad attitude.

    • @docsavage8640
      @docsavage8640 Год назад +6

      His aunt didn't have a bad attitude. She did her best to raise an unruly confused boy.

    • @matrox
      @matrox Год назад +1

      🙄😒😔😭@@docsavage8640

    • @nielszindel1151
      @nielszindel1151 Год назад +1

      @@matrox . Aunt Mimi was a woman of that time, she did raise him single handed and she no doubt loved him, otherwise why would she bother? Delia Morris

  • @lorenzolocatelirossi
    @lorenzolocatelirossi Год назад +1

    Interesting thank you

  • @jerrytaliercio9087
    @jerrytaliercio9087 Год назад +2

    That was good stuff

  • @skywalkersbutido6375
    @skywalkersbutido6375 Год назад +2

    I love your channel.Every video is just amazing.

  • @chrissharkey9644
    @chrissharkey9644 Год назад +2

    Awesome deep dives that You do!

  • @PaulSmith-pz9eq
    @PaulSmith-pz9eq Год назад

    Yes , Thank you for this documentary.

  • @terencehennegan1439
    @terencehennegan1439 Год назад +3

    Great video 👍

  • @tpatrick44
    @tpatrick44 Год назад +2

    Good video! Thank you! ❤

  • @charclous2341
    @charclous2341 Год назад

    I'm glad I found your channel! Ill be watching from now on. Thank you.

    • @thebeatlesforever
      @thebeatlesforever  Год назад

      Thank you so much I appreciate it.

    • @justiceforjamespaulmccartney
      @justiceforjamespaulmccartney 11 месяцев назад

      James Paul McCartney died in car crash on September 11 1966 and was replaced by William (Billy). This is the truth no matter what!

  • @zdvxgf
    @zdvxgf Год назад +14

    For the people who will start an argument about why Paul wasn't able to attend his father's funeral (information from Keith Vernon Adagio):
    When his dad Jim McCartney died on March 18,1976, Wings was on the European leg of their world tour and in a troubled frame of mind, Paul was advised not to come for his dad's funeral by his stepmom saying that if he'll throw everything away and come up to Liverpool for the funeral it'll all be just a circus and definitely won’t bring his dad back. Paul then realized all the media and people that'll ruin his dad's solemn moment that he decided that what his stepmom had said makes sense after all. So he went on with the tour where they held their first performance for that year in Copenhagen, Denmark. Paul never saw his dad again, even for the very last time. That is the price of fame, and the show must go on. Paul McCartney went on and did what he was born to do. Carrying in his heart and mind the memories of his dad who has always been proud of him and his music.

    • @zdvxgf
      @zdvxgf Год назад +8

      Therefore, it's illogical for others to fabricate various tales or impose their interpretations on someone's personal life, especially when they are not a part of that private circle and lack a personal connection with those involved - A message for those PID freaks who can't just live and focus on their own lives instead.

    • @matrox
      @matrox Год назад +6

      Paul said he was glad he didn't go. He said he hated funerals and said he would not have been able to keep it together at his fathers funeral so he grieved in private.

    • @justiceforjamespaulmccartney
      @justiceforjamespaulmccartney 11 месяцев назад +2

      James Paul McCartney died in car crash on September 11 1966 and was replaced by William (Billy). This is the truth no matter what!

    • @zdvxgf
      @zdvxgf 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@justiceforjamespaulmccartney sorry for your own loss then.

    • @ranns2805
      @ranns2805 4 месяца назад

      @@justiceforjamespaulmccartneywhat? Never heard this information.

  • @ThePakw
    @ThePakw Год назад

    Lovely video, thanks. Many things I didn't know!

  • @lissielampika6151
    @lissielampika6151 Год назад

    Thank you so much for posting. I would love to get in touch with you. Have a lovely rest of your day. Best wishes

  • @allenmoses110
    @allenmoses110 Год назад +2

    Thank you Paul's dad!!

  • @ronsilva516
    @ronsilva516 Год назад +3

    That was so interesting thank you👍😎

  • @m.b.calderhead268
    @m.b.calderhead268 Год назад +1

    Thank you for this. Really informative and sweet. I guess the apple doesn’t fall very far from the tree. What about Mike? And what about Ruth?

    • @thebeatlesforever
      @thebeatlesforever  Год назад +1

      You are welcome.
      I may see if I can find out information about Mike and Ruth

  • @Rebecca-kk3ig
    @Rebecca-kk3ig Год назад +2

    Great video!!!

  • @lotushealingsanctuary
    @lotushealingsanctuary Год назад +3

    ❤ how sweet 🩷

  • @SeltaebEht
    @SeltaebEht Год назад +1

    Paul didn't like Angie very much, but did like Ruth, her daughter.
    Ruth was very active on facebook up to a few years ago.

  • @DerGlaetze
    @DerGlaetze Год назад +1

    Is that Carol Kaye narrating? Hi Carol! Good job!

  • @michaelrochester48
    @michaelrochester48 Год назад +8

    Interesting that Paul did not attend his father’s funeral when he died in 1976 only a few days after John Lennon’s father died

    • @jugibur2117
      @jugibur2117 Год назад

      Maybe just rumors? Or did the relationship become worse in later years?

    • @michaelrochester48
      @michaelrochester48 Год назад

      @@jugibur2117 I know he was not too pleased with his father’s second wife.

    • @justiceforjamespaulmccartney
      @justiceforjamespaulmccartney 11 месяцев назад +2

      James Paul McCartney died in car crash on September 11 1966 and was replaced by William (Billy). This is the truth no matter what!

    • @malachy9400
      @malachy9400 9 месяцев назад +2

      It would have been difficult for Paul to attend his father Jims funeral considering he was dead since 1967. The other guy that replaced Paul might not have been welcome at Jims funeral.

    • @amyshehi4731
      @amyshehi4731 Месяц назад

      Maybe didn’t want the media circus that would ensue?

  • @concertsshowsmore
    @concertsshowsmore Год назад +1

    “No, actually, we’re just good friends.”

  • @duncangaryd
    @duncangaryd Год назад +4

    I still don’t understand that despite this closeness. Paul never attended Jim’s funeral. Wings were on tour, but it just seems sad to me Paul would stay on tour doing interviews.

    • @thebeatlesforever
      @thebeatlesforever  11 месяцев назад

      Paul's brother Michael said Paul just couldn't deal with the loss of his dad and it was too much for him.

    • @ronr.711
      @ronr.711 8 месяцев назад

      Just one problem with Paul not being able to handle Jim's death and not attending Jim's funeral. Paul is captured on video with Linda and Wings, a short time after Jim's death, joking it up.

    • @annafrancan
      @annafrancan 6 месяцев назад +1

      I always thought that Paul also didn’t want to draw unwanted attention to the funeral. Since him being who he is - press might’ve followed him there.
      Whatever the case, we shouldn’t judge a stranger on the decisions they make in moments of grief

  • @Monotostereoking
    @Monotostereoking Год назад +1

    Thank you for the video. Very interesting.

  • @paulinamccharmley
    @paulinamccharmley 11 месяцев назад

    The school photos - I presume you think that’s Paul & Mike but it’s not, the second boy is actually Peter Sissons.

  • @carminecupani2315
    @carminecupani2315 Год назад +2

    It’s great to see the real James Paul and the fact that you didn’t include pictures of Billy who of course is not he. This is easy to visually see but the younger generation can’t see it. I was fooled for a few years until it became clear. Good work. ❤

  • @lawreence13
    @lawreence13 Год назад +5

    In all this 'is it the real Paul malarkey' one odd thing does stand out. For all this closeness to his dad Paul never attended his funeral which I find odd

    • @justiceforjamespaulmccartney
      @justiceforjamespaulmccartney 11 месяцев назад

      James Paul McCartney died in car crash on September 11 1966 and was replaced by William (Billy). This is the truth no matter what!

  • @walterevans2118
    @walterevans2118 Год назад

    Ah NICE .

  • @rocktober1327
    @rocktober1327 6 месяцев назад +1

    About the talk, watch dogs do it in the street, now we know where, Why Don't We Do It In the Road came from.

  • @lisas3545
    @lisas3545 Месяц назад

    Paul did not attend his father's funeral when he could have. Paul told Angie to order flowers for him and she did. Paul left Angie with the bill. Denny Laine found out about Jim's death on t.v. and said Paul showed no signs of grief. Angie wrote in her book several occasions where Paul was abusive to his father.

    • @thebeatlesforever
      @thebeatlesforever  Месяц назад +1

      Thank you for your comments. We get to see more of what may have happened during the sad time of Paul's Dad's death. I appreciate it.

    • @lisas3545
      @lisas3545 Месяц назад

      @@thebeatlesforever Thanks for being unbiased. 😊

  • @binxbolling
    @binxbolling Год назад +1

    Sounds like Paul's miserly nature surfaced early.

  • @justinherbert9146
    @justinherbert9146 Год назад +1

    Sounds like CAROL KAYE is the narrator

  • @walterevans2118
    @walterevans2118 Год назад +5

    Hearing some of the history here it makes me think when Paul wrote the lyrics of YESTERDAY possibly he was writing them about how his Father felt when he lost Paul’s Mother …’why she had to go, I don’t know , she wouldn’t say’ 😢😔

    • @docsavage8640
      @docsavage8640 Год назад +1

      Paul has said as much. His first response was "What will we do without her money?"
      "I said something wrong now I long for yesterday"

    • @walterevans2118
      @walterevans2118 Год назад +3

      @@docsavage8640 I feel sorry for Paul, seeing his Dad suffer when losing his Mother like that. In later days Paul did everything he could to help him out. It it must have been wonderful for his Dad seeing Paul evolve into one of the greatest songwriters ever. He must have been so proud of him.

    • @nielszindel1151
      @nielszindel1151 Год назад

      @@docsavage8640 .. they both sound badly affected..house is harder to make a home without Mum. Mary was a midwife so she would be a caring dedicated and clever woman...Delia Morris

  • @robsmith6087
    @robsmith6087 11 месяцев назад

    what happened to Angie and Ruth when Jim passed away ?

  • @rogertinker1813
    @rogertinker1813 Год назад

    Sorry for my bad spelling , its early

  • @PeoplePlacesRocknRoll
    @PeoplePlacesRocknRoll 2 месяца назад

    Ironically, the upright piano came from the Eptein's family music business!

  • @jeffparsons2744
    @jeffparsons2744 2 месяца назад +1

    It is good to see that some fans and observers believe their own eyes and perceive with their own intuition that there is falsehood in this story.

    • @twpsy634
      @twpsy634 15 дней назад

      No only you!

  • @praisethelord8592
    @praisethelord8592 Год назад

    I didn’t know all this very interesting. Thank you.

  • @deemika
    @deemika Год назад +1

    Paul made his step-mom submit receipts for every little thing they bought? Wow. How parsimonious of Paul.

    • @matrox
      @matrox Год назад +4

      He was looking out for his father and making sure the woman was not a gold digger.

    • @OakwiseBecoming
      @OakwiseBecoming Год назад +4

      @@matroxyeah but that sounds like it crossed the line into unreasonably controlling. Makes me wonder if there isn’t more to Heather Mills’ claims about her experience.

  • @Joaquinonbasstheelectriklovein
    @Joaquinonbasstheelectriklovein 6 месяцев назад

    When the elder McCartney died William,er,Paul was doing a tour in Australia & in an interview there expressed no grief or even concern.He did not attend Jim McCartney's funeral citing that it would cause a distraction despite claiming to have a close relationship with his father.The real reason is because the family would not have Billy attend & do not care for him as well.How could this happen? Remember these people are loyal subjects of the Crown & The Beatles were a majot economic driver for the country.

  • @macharper8214
    @macharper8214 Год назад +1

    I think John and Paul both lost their mothers like about less than a year apart or something.

  • @GEOFFREYGIULIANO
    @GEOFFREYGIULIANO Год назад +3

    Paul DID NOT attend Jim's funereal

    • @justiceforjamespaulmccartney
      @justiceforjamespaulmccartney 11 месяцев назад

      James Paul McCartney died in car crash on September 11 1966 and was replaced by William (Billy). This is the truth no matter what!

  • @timturner36
    @timturner36 Год назад +5

    Paul and Jim always had a wonderful relationship but Billy didn't even show up for Jim's funeral. There was Zero connection there.

    • @OakwiseBecoming
      @OakwiseBecoming Год назад +3

      I was watching to note if there were photos post 1966 of them together… I don’t want to believe it but it gnaws at me.