Roundabout Bass Cover
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- www.buymeacoff...
www.yesphotoboo...
A friend of a friend has written a book on YES which is comprised of exclusive interviews with every member of the band, past and present, as well as never before published photos. Looks exciting.
Some might consider this to be "the" quintessential prog-rock bass line of all time.
I'm using my trusty SansAmp Bass Driver for a bit of grind.
Definitely in over my head on this song and had to make some modifications to play it finger style, although I do a bit of spastic picking towards the end of the song.
I've gotten a lot of comments about not using the Ric for this song so I'll address that here instead of repeating myself.
The Ric needs a string change and with that always comes a neck adjustment as I'm getting rid of those awful Rotosounds I put on. Overall it's a pretty fussy instrument and demands constant attention. I think I like the idea of owning a Rickenbacker more than actually playing one. I think they're gorgeous and sound great for some things......but awful on other stuff. I actually haven't played it in months and like the Geddy Lees so much that I got a second one. Also, I'm recording with someone tomorrow and thought it was a perfect opportunity to take advantage of the fresh set of strings on this bass.
You're cocky little attitude I'm going to give you a heads up for your cocky little attitude is if you f****** know this like a chef sit down b****
But you'll never be Chris and how dare you even emulate that
schizophrenia?
@@phillydee666 what the fucks your problem?
Speak English next time.
pin of shame lmao
Thanks.
I've done my fair share of live/real world playing and I'm happy where I am. For five or ten minutes at a time, I'm playing with some of the greatest bands in the world with none of the hassles associated with playing in a band. The drummers never go out of time, the guitarists are never drunk or out of tune (same goes for the singers), the soundmen always pay careful attention to the bass in the mix, I'm home in bed before 4am...I could go on and on.
I play because I love to play.
we all appreciate you sharing what you do with us my dude
TJH3113 you are truly amazing. May your accomplishments never go unappreciated.
A good bass playing friend of mine shared this comment with me. I cannot tell you how much this resonated with me. I've been following your channel for awhile now. I'm a full-time drummer and teacher and I've used your covers to actually learn drum parts where the mix is so bad. Your bass parts are so precise I can use them to figure out kick patterns. Plus I'm a huge horror movie fan so there's no way I can't like your channel!
I've been playing music full-time since 1998. In 2003 when my son was born I transitioned from gigging 80% of the time and teaching 20% of the time to the other way around. At first it was great. Then the grind started setting in. I've never grown weary of teaching but I was growing weary of the gig grind. I decided during this pandemic when the gigs were locked down to semi-retire from live performance and just focus on teaching 100%. I've had more fun practicing stuff I want to work on (rather than learning covers I hate) and playing the music I want to play!
Your comment was not only a catalyst for me but it was encouraging for me as well to know others felt the way I did. Especially players of your caliber. Many folks think that you can't truly blossom as a musician unless you play with others. I think we each need to find our own paths. Thank you for your passion and dedication to your craft. Thank you also for your wisdom.
I started out playing bass and did fair. Mixing sound and configuring sound system is something I became successful at. The most difficult thing is the bass guitar being heard consistently in tone and in the mix at all seats. My efforts have paid off and get to work with the best and if I’m home by 11PM, it is a good day.
Best wishes
You're like the ONE guy on RUclips who does the bass line completely, let alone well. Serious props, man!!
Thanks. It's a bit sloppy in spots.
Not too many 2:33 - :34 where it glides up to the B is a little square but still a great bass-player. Now that I'm retired Im gonna put some YES up here too. Great tone. My Jazz is a '94
sloppy? really, I aspire to be that sloppy. I look on in awe of your yes and rush covers, you have given me the inspiration to play again
TJH3113 is the flourish at the end of each main riff stanza supposed to be D9~D7 A9~A7 A7~A5 A0 E0?
Only other person I've ever seen cover the bassline properly is Geddy Lee.
Holy crap, My man played that WITHOUT a pick!!!!
gbear 4 bass players typically don't use picks, we use our index and middle fingers to pluck instead, it's much more efficient and you get a more bassy "thump" out of the instrument.
Bee bons This is also typical in classical guitar. That's how I easily picked up the bass because I began on guitar, but not just to strum.
cruentus Also its easier to play certain things with picks. A lot of Megadeth bass lines are similar
I used to try using picks because I lacked dexterity, but all in all using a pick takes much more effort (in my opinion). Also, this guy is a legend.
Using a pick takes more effort for some pieces, less for others. For instance at a lower level of skill I find the pick makes it relatively easy to hold steady quavers with a hard attack, while if I play the same notes with my fingers there is a softer deeper attack (less important) and a tendancy to play either the on-beats or off-beats a little differently in some way. Each of those is perfect for some pieces (usually written by a guy that favored the same style) and not quite right for others. The startling thing here is that this is a song written by Chris Squier, who was a very technical player who always used a pick. Playing it with fingers is expected to sound off, and usually does. Hence the remark - performing this song is difficult, performing it with fingerpicking and still sounding right is doubly so. See ruclips.net/video/0zoZiZ7_4VA/видео.html for comparison.
Literally the only video on RUclips with the correct bass line
It's not the best or cleanest, but I seem to be the only one who acknowledges the elephant in the room. Not sure why that is.
Feels very accurate to my ears and the tone is replicated nicely.
no kidding... this is by far the best cover on youtube
I'm glad that you think so.
Yeah, he actually boosts the BASS for a BASS cover instead of trying to blend it into the audio.
Guys remember, Troy has studied Geddy's old technique very thoroughly, and Geddy has been influenced by Chris Squire's technique, and Geddy doesn't use a pick, which Troy doesn't use either. So to try and sound like they're using one, they hit hard, which is good enough for this song.
He's playing that bass with hamon
You even played the flashy parts in the beginning, nobody ever does that! Also, congrats on doing this so well finger style! Chris' sound is so hard to match without a pick. Is that a Geddy Lee Jazz?
Thanks. Yes, it's a GL Signature.
I'm going to throw my guitar collection in the fireplace. I'll never be this good.
+heckfarr
that was hilarious!! hahaha!
Ha Ha, my sentiments exactly
stop collecting and start practicing!
You'll be as good as your practice , you'll always be better (than someone else). Hope you have found another way to supply your fireplace...
No no no. You could practice 7 hrs a day for years and still be nowhere near this kind of flawless playing! This is extraordinarily gifted, plus years of training. But still. Those of us that surf the utube bass players rarely see this level of skill. I mean, come on now. Even the tone is so spot on. How many could get that fender to sound like that? The choices of covers from the simple, were all alone, to over the top yyz are enuff to makes us all smile and dream of playing at such a level. You looked so relaxed playin. How about that bass collection ....shit. I love the bass. I have 4 that I play equally bad. But it still fun. Thanks for the post
Is there a stone mask in that collection too?
epic reference
we all seek to refuse our humanity
You rad, jack
Epic reference indeed. Still here for it
I don't understand any of this.😂
You're Next Line Is "What A Great Cover"!
+Spooked Solid What a great cove-huh?!! B-bakana!
What a great cov... NANI?!??!
What A Great Cover!
-???????
What A Great Cover
BAKADA!
Kaiser Kevin what a great cover. NANI?
You have committed the cardinal sin for Yes fans like me. Playing a fender on this song (not your Ric) and playing finger style and not with a pick? Sacrilege! All said though you have earned your cape! This is extraordinarily good. You have all of Chris Squire's punchiness and have executed this absolutely perfectly. My hat off to you sir!
+David Williams Thanks.
Playing with a pick is boring
+Krist Novoselic You obviously don't play bass.
+Krist Novoselic Uhm, Chris Squire, the bass genius who WROTE this bass line and many more (some more complicated), used a pick.
+Krist Novoselic Also, Paul McCartney -and many other greats -used picks.
Never surprises me anymore. Every single song he plays, he literally plays perfect.
Aw... too kind. Thanks.
THIS GUYS A FREAKING BEAST JESUS CHRIST
Thanks.
I'm glad to hear you're making a comeback. At this point, I play for my own enjoyment only and derive a lot of satisfaction from it.
I don't have a "real" amp either. I'm playing through a little Fender SP-10 guitar amp that suits my needs just fine.
Take care.
Had to come back to this. This channel is such an inspiration for me.
Thanks so much.
Who are the 6 morons that gave this a thumbs down? This cover is excellent.
Thanks.
Damian Berry Jealousy.
DAMNED FINE COVER!!! WOW!! Without a pick, you still NAILED the attack... Simply awesome!!!
Exactly 10 seconds in I knew I had found the BEST Roundabout bass cover on YT. All your covers are exceptional!
There's a few rough spots deeper into the song but I did the best with what I had. Thanks a lot.
I think it's just a matter of preference, most of my favorite players use a pick and if I could, I would.
This cover is just SICK!!! Really amazing man. I see all over the internet people saying that is IMPOSSIBLE to play this song without a pick. You put all of them to shame. Congrats!
How the hell’d you do that without a pick! Shit, you’re the one cover I’ve seen that doesn’t need the pick! Props man, this was awesome!
It wasn't easy. Thanks!
"I think I like the idea of owning a Rickenbacker more than actually playing one."
That sums it up quite nicely. I like the tone and attacking it with fingers as opposed to using a plectrum...very daring! Kudos, sir. That was quite rocking.
Thanks.
I am but a humble amateur drummer, but I noticed that this is one of the rare bass covers that properly addresses all the bass notes within the first 20 seconds of the song, and I love it for that
You can hear it too? I don't understand why everyone leaves it out.
It would be easier for me to collect those masks than master this selection with the same finesse.
Masks... wait a sec thats a Joj-
Hey. It's been a while. How are things comin' with that finesse ???
The first guy who plays it correctly. Thank you
Great job. VERY involved bass line and you did a great job.
Thanks.
TJH3113 Any bassist who can cover Chris Squire is aces in my book. Awesome job.
Many years ago, like in the early 1970s, I spent many an evening jamming to Yes Roundabout. Most excellent rock! This bass cover totally slays it.
Very cool! Thank you very much!
Yeah, I'm still here. Good to hear from you again. congratulations on the T-Bird.
There are lots of cover bass players out there. But this guy... this is a separate level of quality and selection of songs. Mind blown.
Aw, thank you so much for the very kind words. I appreciate them.
A well-defined Bass line makes me instantly like a music. I don't get why people usually underestimate this instrument. Along with the drums, it's a music pulsing core!
I agree!
this is the first single record I ever bought in my life ...was nine when it came out and is what made me love music. Have been a bassist on & off since the late '70's / 80's (took a near 20 yr hiatus from practicing,learning, gigging to raise a family) and always struggled with the opening main riff of this tune. Thanks for posting and with your help.. have finally gotten a better grasp on it. have ever been a major prog guy - Squire,Lee, Blacky of Voivod and inspired by Julie Slick.
I loved the collection and bass!
Inarguably the best bass cover of this anywhere. Very few players can pull off that intro fill right before the words, outstanding 👏 🔥
Thanks!
That part was actually a guitar on the recording. In the multitrack stems it's a second guitar track. I always thought it was a bass though because Chris typically played it live an octave down.
Dude, you nailed it. Great job! I also feel the same way as you do on the Rickenbacker.
Thanks.
I enjoy looking at them everyday.
Thank you.
I had to look up Perpetual Change. They played that one when I saw them a month or so ago - sounded really good. Since a lot of Yes stuff is out of reach for me playing-wise, I never followed them nearly as closely as I did Rush.
Thanks.
I dont think anything is out of your range
I could watch this ALL DAY! Great job and a classic YES song! Love it
Thank you.
To be continued
One of the greatest bass line of all time! Amazing job friend as usual! Your the best!
It is, isn't it? Thanks so much.
+TJH3113 Great cover and nice tone!!!!! yeaa
Thanks.
Amazing technique and performance. Always a pleasure to watch/listen to your covers.
I know you usually don't take requests, but given the recent passing of Chris Squire, would you consider doing something crazy like covering "The Fish"? I know Squire laid down like 10 different tracks to make that whole glorious sound come alive, but maybe you could demonstrate each new part as it enters and then move to the next. Or maybe another Squire classic? Heart of the Sunrise? Long Distance Runaround?Thanks for your consideration and have a great night!
anthony22bob I'll give it some thought.
Yeah you should
yes, started back about 1 1/2 ago with conviction and am back playing with a band again. Thanks much and keep the video's coming..quite enjoy them.
Geez, I hate all the critics nitpicking TJH3113. He played it with his FINGERS. Anyone that knows YES knows Chris Squire played with a pick. A true bassist does not use a pick, but that is where Chris got his unique tone from.
Believe me, if I could play with a pick, I would. I just try to make do with what I've got.
What do you mean a "true bassist does not use a pick?" There are plenty of great bass players out there who use a pick, Chris Squire probably being the best one. Just because the bass was technically meant for fingerstyle, doesn't mean a pick is the "wrong" way to play.
It's really personal preference, along with the different sound you get.
***** Bonham didn't use sticks...loser
lmao! I think that was meant for another post, someone had said that during Bonhams drum solos it was all sticks, which he clearly was using his hands to play drums..lol sorry about that!
Paul McCartney plays with a pick---one of the finest bass players in the History of Rock. For some reason I just can't marry the idea of a bass played with a pick....
Wonderful. Powerful, driving sound. I’m envious. Time to park the Yamaha. Well done young man.
Don’t do that! Thank you very much.
There "is" an isolated version of this bass line on RUclips. Just search it.
Thanks.
I do not understand why no one else plays the entire thing, this man is the only one
To be honest, I don't understand it either. You hear it too, right?
@@TJH3113 yep, you're a legend
That's a fucking bass player boys! When he moves into my neighbourhood I'm sending over a beer truck. This fucking dude is who you want in your band, fuck me! Clean, he has groove, washes regularly, probably owns a Corvette, has awesome monster masks, hasn't slept with any of your exes, good to go.
😄😃😅😂
This is probably the fourth time I’ve watched this video and I love his approach and professionalism.(If that’s even a word.) I’d like to see him on a fretless. It’s the only logical next move to improve on this. Cheers
Awesome. Thanks.
a true bassist ?? , left a few notes out, ETC. the experts, the critics, and all the rest ~~~~!! the man covers are great .why not GET OFF HIS BACK & you post his covers the RIGHT WAY??,, Thanks again for sharing some nice work my friend..
I dont know why I waste my time even posting a comment, the haters & wannabe players will always be there with nothing else to do but say negative things about people that share what they have worked to present to others, only to have jelouse readers say stupid remarks.
Chris Squire was the the reason I started playing bass. Entwhistle was my favorite rock player of 70’s and 80’’s. Now I don’t have a favorite, but enjoy all great players. Thank you for your contribution!
Cool! Thanks, Steve.
only lack the demon mask. jojo's time
+Ernesto Ezequiel Pérez Glez Underrated comment
to be continued
Can’t tell if it’s real or wall paper
Brandon elliott it's real
it's a jojo reference
Indeed he does. It's really hard to tell because he's always so clean while playing.
Great job, although I seem to recall watching a video interview of Chris Squire and he was asked to play "Roundabout" (the main verse/riff) and it was just; E, F#, G to A and B to D and E.......he seemed to do it a lot simpler and he is the man who wrote it after all..... I will say again that your version does sound really accurate and good....
I just went back to 10 years old
BRILLIANT PLAYING!!
Been looking all over for this song. What are the tabs?
Thanks, Troy. Can't seem to figure this blankety-blank computer thing out and don't really want to post comments. But I think you're terrific. There's a difference between an artist and a technician: a technician knows how to do it, an artist knows why and has a passion for it. Methinks you are an artist. With care -- Janet
I enjoy the array of masks...I was wondering if it is just a collection or if you own them for another reason? I find them intriguing haha
When you hear a spot on cover...Not only does it make the hairs on your neck stand on end...But also dust off the guitar case or the album...Great Playing!!!
ouch..you're good... 10/10
Outstanding. You are the ONLY cover that got the early 2 sets of triplets. True to form!
Wow, thanks!
サムネ見た時石仮面でも飾ってるのかと思ったww
Man, to do that part from 5:26 on without a pick is totally insane.
You're a true genious.
It's a bit choppy, but necessity if the mother of invention. I assure you, I'm a safe distance from "genius" but thanks for the compliment.
It doesn't seem that there is any bass line that you can't play!
My brother surprised me by sending a Ken Smith Jazz Bass 4 years ago. And I recently stared to feel my way back to playing. It has been over 30 years. I am slowly getting back into play worthy mode. Thank you for responding. An honor
Wow! That's some surprise. I hope you enjoy every moment you get to play. My pleasure.
"I think I like the idea of owning a Rickenbacker more than actually playing one." holy shit way to just shit on everyone who dreams of owning even a real fender let alone a rick
The only person on the entire internet that does the rift at the beginning. Great cover, love your vids! They’ve inspired me to try and be a better player
What is up with that? Thanks a lot, I appreciate the kind words.
Little finger plays bass???
Thank you very much. I like a very small but varied field of music.
To be continued.
You guys....
TheLostAge Actually Roundabout is a well known song among prog rock fans. Its the opener for Fragile album and one hell of an opener
00:00
Finally someone who plays the fill during the verse! Thank you!
Haha... thanks!
don't be that guy who wears the shirt of the the bass that you are playing lol
John Snow Hes probably sponsored.. thats why he wears the t shirt of the guitar brand he is using
He does a lot of covers, and it's the first time I've noticed he does. Doesn't matter ... he can wear what he wants.
Don't be that guy criticizing dumb details.
He did a hell of a job on that cover. I know that line in and out, and have yet to see someone do the cover that well.
iS tHiS a JoJo'S rEfEReNcE?!
That seems to be the consensus.
Weebs only know this one Yes song
Nailed it.... note for note correctly done. Great job Troy. Cheers.
Thanks so much. It was close... I did the best I could. Take care!
Do you collect masks?
+Diego Medina What makes you think that?
+TJH3113 Not too sure really..
I think you play Bass so well to hide the fact you collect masks : )
Where's the stone mask?
He needs the red stone of Aja as well.
That's right... I just remembered reading an article where John Entwistle mentioned using a pick. Billy Sheehan was vehemently opposed to them; I believe he once said that playing with fingers is like "having 10 picks in your hands." Keep up the great work!
When people say to me that the Bass player is irrelevant to the band, I show them this video and it changes minds real fast.
You shouldn't be speaking with people who would say such things.
Amazing You really bring out the artistry of thease covers.
Thanks so much, Darren!
I'd just like to take this opportunity to thank you for all of your time. I truly enjoy watching your videos and learning from you. You're an incredibly talented bassist and I'm learning a lot. Thanks for your time...it's worthwhile for many of us. You're truly one of a kind.
You completely nailed it. Excellent.
Chris has been my favorite bassist for over 30 years, and I've always marveled at his ability, and wished there was a way to isolate just the bass. Very cool cover of one of the great bass riffs of all time.
I just restrung my Ric and set it up today. Sounds ok but slightly dull when compared to this bass. I've never played a Peavy bass after I got rid of my T-40 in the very early 80's. Thanks a lot, I'm glad you liked it.
this guys rockin.. its cool hearing someone else play other than myself.
This guy has talent. I can play a little Yes myself on Bass . However I am 50 years old and would be glad to take Bass lessons from this smart chap. Great Work Brother.!!!!
Glad I found it Troy. That cover is Epic dude. Very long ,hard, and technical. Good choice of bass too. Glad you turned me on to that.Bravo
Thanks. Glad you liked it.
I am clueless on music and how it works, but I love Bass - want to learn it - your videos are helping me to hear what I simply cannot grasp as something explained on paper. Thank You!
That's alright, I'm fairly clueless too. Great to hear - I do hope that you take it up!
This is the only cover I could find that was played without a pick. . .beautiful.
I tried... Thanks.
Awesome, Nice to hear some classic
Exquisite. One of the bass guitar holy grail tunes. Many thanks.
Thanks for listening!
You are the man. I really want to aspire to be as good as you on my bass. It shows that you've put in the time, and sweat into mastering your craft.
Thanks so much. With some time, patience, practice, and repetition you'll surpass anything that I've done, I'm sure of that.
Troy -- Still having trouble with sending messages. Not comfortable with this public stuff, but I guess it's the only way. You are a talented man. I know you feel the music. Otherwise you wouldn't play so well. Art of any kind comes from the heart and soul. Obviously, you have both. I'm grateful to have run across you and have the opportunity to hear your music. Take care -- Janet
Without question the best instructional on RUclips! F*cking perfection!
I'm glad you found it helpful. Thanks.
I want this bass ... love the tone.
Am I the only one that gets like A huge funk vibe from this song. Like just the punchyness and sporadic notes thrown in there screams old school funk man.
I wish you could see me playing along on my steering wheel like it’s the strings of the bass. Awesome job man. Make On
Playing the bass on the steering wheel used to me my test to see if I was ready to record a video or not. Thanks and take care!
playing this without a pick is hard asf, and this guy just nails it
Thanks Henrique.
You do extraordinary things with so much enjoyment, you can see that you enjoy every note. Professional works and thank you for showing. I'm retired right now, so I'm going to make sure my bass looks at least similar to your work.
Thank you very much!