It's been three years since it appeared, so there has been some time to test it, it has a proven engine that is used in Jags, LR, Citroens and Pugs and that has been upgraded over the years especially in terms of reliability, it has the best 'generic' gearbox on the market... Of course, nobody can claim it will be bulletproof 10 years from now, but that stands for every car ever made.
@@tovarisch3039 hahaha, nice. Well, even though it's not as simple as 'you're covered for 25 years' (read into it a bit and you'll see what I mean), Toyota is definitely miles ahead of Land Rover in terms of reliability. Nobody ever said otherwise. I wasn't talking about Toyota vs LR in terms of reliability, that would be stupid. I was talking about LR3/4 vs LR5.
Excellent review, I’m torn between getting defender or discovery. But i liked the comments at the end. The price quickly adds up. But I’m pleased with the review and I will base my purchase if it’s a discovery on this review. This was one of the best review because it answered a lot of questions 👍👍
Great review Amelia and Car Tell TV. Its good to hear from someone with previous knowledge of the past generations. The Discovery 5 that you tested has the same motor as the LR4 and LR3 other then capacity and a few other slight changes. The Lion Motor is a good motor but JLR skimped out on the quality. That's why I got the petrol LR3. When JLR's new inline 6 Inginiam motor comes out can you please test and compare this? Be interesting to see the difference.
The 2.0 litre option was created decades back by Land Rover, for the Italian market, due to heavy taxation on larger capacity engines. It remains viable in that market and may also be attractive in other countries with harsh taxes on engines with piston displacement exceeding 2.0 litres.
The new defender due to be launched at the end of the year is based on this vehicle and will most likely have a electic hybrid gear box version for the eco outback enthusiasts
Over $130,000 no thanks! That’s where the Discovery has lost market share & customers in a nut shell!!! I had the last of the Discovery 4 & Landrover tried to tempt me into the Disco 5, it was going to cost over $20,000 more to get the same specs as my Disco 4 in the new one! So after owning 4 Landrover Discoveries I went to Toyota & spent less buying a dual cab 79 Series Landcruiser that included $30,000 worth of extras, fitting it out as the ultimate RELIABLE touring vehicle. Something that no Landrover will ever be unfortunately. And I can now keep the Cruiser out of warranty & know it won’t cost me the earth to maintain!
yeah great compromise.. 80's technology for $80K entry price with bugger all safety other than traction control, ABS and a couple of airbags. Then you need to spend another $30K on suspension, correcting rear wheel track, canopy / decent tray oh and as mine does, use 16L/100K on mostly freeway use 160K's daily. Where as my twin turbo i4 Velar uses 6.3L so I can expect that the Disco with the same or V6 engine will be slightly more thirsty. The 79 is hardly comparable in any way to a Discovery. Horses for courses of course.
4x4 Nut no they are not comparable at all? That’s not my point? One is a great 4x4 when everything is working, the other is a truck. I now own a truck! To compare a Discovery to a 79 Cruiser is insane? The point I make is reliability & access to parts & service. A trait that’s more difficult to achieve in a Landrover across the more remote regions of Australia. My other choice was a 200 Series, now then you could run a comparison to the Discovery but not with a 79 dual cab. I’m just saying at $130,000 Landrover have priced the Discovery out of the market? Even the basic 5 seat V6 I priced up was $107,000? Again way to expensive for a Discovery! That’s why sales will have fallen off the cliff!
I’ve owned many if not every model of landrover I’ve had good ones that did 300,000 miles disco 2003 TD5 Ps still in family Range rovers had a issue with 1 only. So overall I’ve been lucky with reliability.. I’m no longer a Landrover owner due to there prices far to expensive.. They do loss a lot of money also,as I purchased new ones. Yes most vehicles loss lots.. I currently own a Mercedes Vito commercial dualliner absolutely fantastic.. Loss about £4000 per year. Also a Porsche macan GTs for the gaffer in the house lol.. The Porsche losses about £8000 per year The new discovery would loss about £12000 per year Based on 4 year ownership.. I though can’t wait to see the new defender
We love our 2018 🇺🇸 Discovery with its turbocharged diesel. No problems at all. Looks like they put the steering wheel on the wrong side with this particular vehicle though 🤓.
4x4’s aren’t meant for cities, and city vehicles should never be taken into the bush to be destroyed. 4x4’s should be cheap and easy to repair, because they will get bashed around in the bush. Fancy looking 4x4’s won’t look to fancy after a couple of rocks and trees hit the side panels. Not only have JLR destroyed the Disco, for those that live in the country, they have destroyed the most capable and tough Defender. It’s a bit ridiculous. That much tech that JLR can’t even maintain it themselves. But I guess they’ll pick up sales with the posh city dwellers that can afford the repairs and maintenance costs and the country people will continue to maintain their old rigs as they always have. Not many sales to be made when people take care of and maintain their own vehicles.
Great video! Very professional! When do we see you guys in tv? Btw I made pasta while watching this video and it became al dente! Thought I let you know!
Bohica Johnson The Discovery has a range of roughly 1,000-1,100 kms per tank. A Landcruiser Prado has roughly over 1,600 km range per tank. This matters when hoing on trips over a few days or weeks. Remember, when towing, the MPG on SUVs drops significantly.
@@user2144 there are very few places in Australia that are a thousand k's between servos. Particularly where owners of these Disco's will go. For those that really want more range the aftermarket will sort them out.
JLR cars still have a ton of issues. There are many RUclips videos of Range Rover owners experiencing various issues so I doubt this car would be any different when it's the cheaper car in JLR line up.
@@vkdlvkdl Interesting how we choose our cars and then become loyal to the brand. I, for instance, would never choose to own a French car due to their perceived unreliability. Equally, although I have owned many German cars in the past, I would never have another because they are so boring. I like Land Rovers and Skodas and Hyundais and Alfa Romeos et al because the are a bit quirky and as a result become controversial. Actually, I did have a Peugeot once. Most of its electrics failed.
@@vkdlvkdl In fact, all Land rover car owners are really lucky cause its a reliable car.Honestly i own a discovery sport and had done 39k miles without a single repair till....
Nice review, but why not mention that the Discovery 5 has engine oil dilution problems due to the diesel particulate filter location. This causes reduced oil service intervals, so instead of a 16,000 mile oil change, you might need one every 5,000 miles. I was going to buy a Discovery 5, but this problem put me off. Do your own research, there's lots on the internet about it. UK dealers deny that there is a problem, but there is.
i dunno, where i go that paint is going to get damaged, one cannot chop every bit of branch outta the way, but all those jeeps are heaps owners, cruiser owners are just envious, never bought a new vehicle in my life yet and anyone who parts with so much Arthur Ash, is either a showoff or has too much do ray me, good review though gal, give me a bell, I'll show you the outback
How could you make any claim regarding its reliability when the model is brand new? If anything, Land Rovers and Range Rovers have a persistently horrendously track record when it comes to reliability.
It's been three years since it appeared, so there has been some time to test it, it has a proven engine that is used in Jags, LR, Citroens and Pugs and that has been upgraded over the years especially in terms of reliability, it has the best 'generic' gearbox on the market... Of course, nobody can claim it will be bulletproof 10 years from now, but that stands for every car ever made.
Yep....way way over priced JLR not making SUv's & cars for the common man anymore they are getting into the super rich bracket...I had a Range Rover & swapped for a Mercedes...yeah a Mercedes ...you would have never done that a few years ago that's how much JLR have slapped onto the price tag & for my money are now pricing themselves out of the market...again unless you are super rich.
rock crawl, i never use it, it needs a hand throttle screw knob, as trying to control the fwds advance speed is hard and a wee squeeze on the pedal produces a big leap fwds, i have had in my long life series 1 2 3 td5 and d4 a toyota will never climb a slippery grass incline like a d4
Land Rover had a dedicated design. But now, it turned out to be a very ugly version of Range Rover. What a pitty that Tata seems to get all designs away from traditional British that we used know. All Land Rover cars now a weird mixture of Japanese and Chinese...
These are marque cars. Used for school runs and showing of to neighbours. If you really want an off road vehicle get an old Jeep, Toyota.. ......Land Rover. 😁
what a shitbox, how could you recommend this for anyone?? if I had a dollar for everytime i saw a landrover owner on the side of the road withe bonnet up scratching his head, ha ha ha
Only thing i hate about these land and range rovers is the stupid gear shift knob. only the range rover sport and the new mini discovery have the auto stick.
Most ugly discovery in history. Lose the Land Rover style and heritage in design. Failed sale in Australia. Not too many on the street after released for three years in Australia. Loyal Land Rover funs still love boxy style . Only new and young customer may like new ones. I owned discovery 4. Never want upgrades to this new ugly one.
I don't think the majority of Disco owners are going anywhere near the outback. Pretty much the same as most Cruisers too. But at least the cruiser is more reliable. I couldn't imagine somebody wandering in to LR and chosing the top spec Disco for outback travel lol.
the rear number plate placement though
How can take a brand new from a showroom and claim it's more reliable without owning the vehicle for 4-5 years
It's been three years since it appeared, so there has been some time to test it, it has a proven engine that is used in Jags, LR, Citroens and Pugs and that has been upgraded over the years especially in terms of reliability, it has the best 'generic' gearbox on the market... Of course, nobody can claim it will be bulletproof 10 years from now, but that stands for every car ever made.
@@bsjeran7352 You haven't heard of Toyota's legendary 25-year guarantee, have you?
@@tovarisch3039 hahaha, nice. Well, even though it's not as simple as 'you're covered for 25 years' (read into it a bit and you'll see what I mean), Toyota is definitely miles ahead of Land Rover in terms of reliability. Nobody ever said otherwise. I wasn't talking about Toyota vs LR in terms of reliability, that would be stupid. I was talking about LR3/4 vs LR5.
Because this review was paid and written by land rover
@@bsjeran7352 by that logic honda's 1.5L CVT engine is very established engine however the using that same engine in new CRV has caused lot of issues.
Excellent review, I’m torn between getting defender or discovery. But i liked the comments at the end. The price quickly adds up. But I’m pleased with the review and I will base my purchase if it’s a discovery on this review. This was one of the best review because it answered a lot of questions 👍👍
Great review Amelia and Car Tell TV. Its good to hear from someone with previous knowledge of the past generations. The Discovery 5 that you tested has the same motor as the LR4 and LR3 other then capacity and a few other slight changes. The Lion Motor is a good motor but JLR skimped out on the quality. That's why I got the petrol LR3. When JLR's new inline 6 Inginiam motor comes out can you please test and compare this? Be interesting to see the difference.
We are old land rover owners and would love the discover 5. Although Land Rover is still in our blood, ... the price knocks us out cold. What a shame!
The 2.0 litre option was created decades back by Land Rover, for the Italian market, due to heavy taxation on larger capacity engines. It remains viable in that market and may also be attractive in other countries with harsh taxes on engines with piston displacement exceeding 2.0 litres.
Trim levels being S, SE, HSE and 'HSE Luxury' count as 4 trim levels not 5.
I think there is a landmark aswell
AMELIA!!!!
the sd4 is about 20k cheaper than the sd6... thats a pretty good reason to opt for the 2 litre!
What's rims size?
Great review but I would enjoy them more with much quieter or no music.
You guys talk whatever you want
Me am buying this beautiful full option piece and thanks for the details. I will rewatch
Best car
The new defender due to be launched at the end of the year is based on this vehicle and will most likely have a electic hybrid gear box version for the eco outback enthusiasts
air suspension is costly once the warranty expires.
The steering wheel looks massive
Keep Up the good Work, looks great, greetings from Chile.
would have been much better to listen to without the constant and unnecessary background music. good review otherwise
The wheel looks so big for the present or. Also the wheel position looks very odd.
Excellent review....greetings from México...
Over $130,000 no thanks! That’s where the Discovery has lost market share & customers in a nut shell!!!
I had the last of the Discovery 4 & Landrover tried to tempt me into the Disco 5, it was going to cost over $20,000 more to get the same specs as my Disco 4 in the new one! So after owning 4 Landrover Discoveries I went to Toyota & spent less buying a dual cab 79 Series Landcruiser that included $30,000 worth of extras, fitting it out as the ultimate RELIABLE touring vehicle. Something that no Landrover will ever be unfortunately. And I can now keep the Cruiser out of warranty & know it won’t cost me the earth to maintain!
yeah great compromise.. 80's technology for $80K entry price with bugger all safety other than traction control, ABS and a couple of airbags. Then you need to spend another $30K on suspension, correcting rear wheel track, canopy / decent tray oh and as mine does, use 16L/100K on mostly freeway use 160K's daily. Where as my twin turbo i4 Velar uses 6.3L so I can expect that the Disco with the same or V6 engine will be slightly more thirsty. The 79 is hardly comparable in any way to a Discovery. Horses for courses of course.
4x4 Nut no they are not comparable at all? That’s not my point? One is a great 4x4 when everything is working, the other is a truck. I now own a truck! To compare a Discovery to a 79 Cruiser is insane? The point I make is reliability & access to parts & service. A trait that’s more difficult to achieve in a Landrover across the more remote regions of Australia. My other choice was a 200 Series, now then you could run a comparison to the Discovery but not with a 79 dual cab. I’m just saying at $130,000 Landrover have priced the Discovery out of the market? Even the basic 5 seat V6 I priced up was $107,000? Again way to expensive for a Discovery! That’s why sales will have fallen off the cliff!
I’ve owned many if not every model of landrover
I’ve had good ones that did 300,000 miles disco 2003 TD5
Ps still in family
Range rovers had a issue with 1 only.
So overall I’ve been lucky with reliability..
I’m no longer a Landrover owner due to there prices far to expensive..
They do loss a lot of money also,as I purchased new ones.
Yes most vehicles loss lots..
I currently own a Mercedes Vito commercial dualliner absolutely fantastic..
Loss about £4000 per year.
Also a Porsche macan GTs for the gaffer in the house lol..
The Porsche losses about £8000 per year
The new discovery would loss about £12000 per year
Based on 4 year ownership..
I though can’t wait to see the new defender
So many haters? I could watch Amelia test drive a rock
Great review, your good at ya job.
Well done. Nice looking too...
The cars not bad either 🤔😂
Great joke, how original. 🥱
We love our 2018 🇺🇸 Discovery with its turbocharged diesel. No problems at all. Looks like they put the steering wheel on the wrong side with this particular vehicle though 🤓.
4x4’s aren’t meant for cities, and city vehicles should never be taken into the bush to be destroyed. 4x4’s should be cheap and easy to repair, because they will get bashed around in the bush. Fancy looking 4x4’s won’t look to fancy after a couple of rocks and trees hit the side panels. Not only have JLR destroyed the Disco, for those that live in the country, they have destroyed the most capable and tough Defender. It’s a bit ridiculous. That much tech that JLR can’t even maintain it themselves. But I guess they’ll pick up sales with the posh city dwellers that can afford the repairs and maintenance costs and the country people will continue to maintain their old rigs as they always have. Not many sales to be made when people take care of and maintain their own vehicles.
Good video
Do landrover build something that's practical and has a 3 to 4 tonne braked towing capabilities?
Great video! Very professional! When do we see you guys in tv? Btw I made pasta while watching this video and it became al dente! Thought I let you know!
Has Land Rover Discovery HSE swapped badges with TOYOTA FORTUNER or MERCEDES BENZ GLE 2020?
rough old badger, but strangely endearing
Maybe the $12,000 price difference between 4 and 6 cylinder of equal trim levels is a factor in the final choice? 🤦🏻♂️
85 litre fuel capacity is not enough. JLR should have addressed this issue with this upgrade. Needs a 100-120 litre tank.
With the economical 2L engine, it is plenty. I'd never buy one. I'll keep my 2003 Discovery!
Bohica Johnson The Discovery has a range of roughly 1,000-1,100 kms per tank. A Landcruiser Prado has roughly over 1,600 km range per tank. This matters when hoing on trips over a few days or weeks. Remember, when towing, the MPG on SUVs drops significantly.
@@user2144 there are very few places in Australia that are a thousand k's between servos. Particularly where owners of these Disco's will go. For those that really want more range the aftermarket will sort them out.
big mistake altering gates, the lowered half gate makes a pickernic table:))
where is Doug
Believe in Truth he is using the b2b warranty
I really like the design but not particularly in these colours, also I would much prefer storage space than extra seats.
JLR cars still have a ton of issues. There are many RUclips videos of Range Rover owners experiencing various issues so I doubt this car would be any different when it's the cheaper car in JLR line up.
Mine doesn't. And it never has. I am one of the silent majority who will always drive Land Rovers because of their reliability.
@@thurstonhowell3569 You mean you are one of the lucky ones? All facts are against your claims of Land Rover being reliable.
@@vkdlvkdl Interesting how we choose our cars and then become loyal to the brand. I, for instance, would never choose to own a French car due to their perceived unreliability. Equally, although I have owned many German cars in the past, I would never have another because they are so boring. I like Land Rovers and Skodas and Hyundais and Alfa Romeos et al because the are a bit quirky and as a result become controversial. Actually, I did have a Peugeot once. Most of its electrics failed.
@@thurstonhowell3569 mine too.Its really relaible.
@@vkdlvkdl In fact, all Land rover car owners are really lucky cause its a reliable car.Honestly i own a discovery sport and had done 39k miles without a single repair till....
Nice review, but why not mention that the Discovery 5 has engine oil dilution problems due to the diesel particulate filter location. This causes reduced oil service intervals, so instead of a 16,000 mile oil change, you might need one every 5,000 miles. I was going to buy a Discovery 5, but this problem put me off. Do your own research, there's lots on the internet about it. UK dealers deny that there is a problem, but there is.
Mostly only with the 4 cylinder engine
Similar look of Tata Safari
i dunno, where i go that paint is going to get damaged, one cannot chop every bit of branch outta the way, but all those jeeps are heaps owners, cruiser owners are just envious, never bought a new vehicle in my life yet and anyone who parts with so much Arthur Ash, is either a showoff or has too much do ray me, good review though gal, give me a bell, I'll show you the outback
How could you make any claim regarding its reliability when the model is brand new? If anything, Land Rovers and Range Rovers have a persistently horrendously track record when it comes to reliability.
wwbdwwbd precisely what I was thinking.
I feel that was addressed.
It's been three years since it appeared, so there has been some time to test it, it has a proven engine that is used in Jags, LR, Citroens and Pugs and that has been upgraded over the years especially in terms of reliability, it has the best 'generic' gearbox on the market... Of course, nobody can claim it will be bulletproof 10 years from now, but that stands for every car ever made.
Land rovers are the same as any euro car for reliability. Better than BMW lol
@@bsjeran7352 , Do you work for Landrover?
No Jenny comments?
It looks like a rollerskate from the 1980's.
@J M haha, that was a clever remark, Did you think of that one yourself?
Is this an infomercial ?
Yankee Doodle seems so
It looks like the Indian Tata Safari.
where is Jenny?
Filmed in the USA and Australia, looked like some filemd Adelaide to me.
The LL3 is a beauty, the latest one looks like shit. The offset rear number plate looks terrible. Looks like a fat Ford Kuga!
have not seen how it goes in the mud yet...
Wait, so it’s not a 4wheel drive, how is it an off-roader then? Listen to this 4.24
It look like tata safari , if you look from side.
Amelia is very attractive and fun. For short stints of time
From a Land Rover Owner//// i stay with my Boxy LR Series ' Why ? ...
Because a Real Land Rover don t go Shopping ...
"There are 5 trims: S, SE, HSE and HSE Luxury" - err... OK.
"200 hundred kilos, that's 4 of me" - sure hun 😅
Rubbish styling which is badly imitating rubbish asian styling. Not really a Land Rover any more just another SUV clone at twice the price !
Land Rover discovery.....the best off-roader ever for wealthy soccer moms who never take them off-road
lol they're now reviewing it too
Becoz they are unreliable...
@@saauuzza rovers or soccer moms ;) ?
@@saauuzza which one have you owned?
@@saauuzza ok, which LR have you owned then to make this comment
She sure has a lot of faith in this Indian.
Fucking idiot
looks lame.compaired to the LR4. Rollerskate or a walnut on wheels.
50 kg? Damn...
2017 Ford F-150 Raptor has the trailer parking
Looks like a Ford Explorer.
300 kg max weight
Get the land wind. Lol
Music ruins video
Yep....way way over priced JLR not making SUv's & cars for the common man anymore they are getting into the super rich bracket...I had a Range Rover & swapped for a Mercedes...yeah a Mercedes ...you would have never done that a few years ago that's how much JLR have slapped onto the price tag & for my money are now pricing themselves out of the market...again unless you are super rich.
pop fake review, wouldnt mind an actual honest one ..
That's fuglyyy!
Land Rover reliable now? I think not, the people across the street have a new Evoque and the alarm is regularly going off for no reason.
what a stupid thing to put on here
So ugly...especially rear view.
A 2ltr engine my lawn mowers got more power than that!
No, it doesn't .
rock crawl, i never use it, it needs a hand throttle screw knob, as trying to control the fwds advance speed is hard and a wee squeeze on the pedal produces a big leap fwds, i have had in my long life series 1 2 3 td5 and d4 a toyota will never climb a slippery grass incline like a d4
Just not a true Land Rover !!!
why
Shape is horrible
I agree,Only the back face is really ugly.But front face and side face are really beautiful.
Discovery isn’t luxurious or plush... it’s a Land Rover, not a Range Rover.
you obviously have never owned a discovery
Land Rover had a dedicated design. But now, it turned out to be a very ugly version of Range Rover. What a pitty that Tata seems to get all designs away from traditional British that we used know. All Land Rover cars now a weird mixture of Japanese and Chinese...
Is it built by toyota hahahahaha
These are marque cars. Used for school runs and showing of to neighbours.
If you really want an off road vehicle get an old Jeep, Toyota.. ......Land Rover. 😁
Looks like a toyota fortuner
Its bigger than toyoto fortuner. It has a tremendous size of height, width and length with 22 inch wheels.
It is ugly! End of the story! Better to put my money on second hand LR4.
P.S. Extremely ugly :(
True
Land Rover messed up with the new Discovery. It looks like a mess.
what a shitbox, how could you recommend this for anyone??
if I had a dollar for everytime i saw a landrover owner on the side of the road withe bonnet up scratching his head, ha ha ha
You’d still be poor 😂👍🏻
Landrover is a joke. Always driven by small people with ego problems.
After 3 years and warrant is no longer in date, the unreliability issues will really ugly heads after all this is a Land Rover not a Toyota!
Most unreliable brand on the planet...crankshafts made from butter
Then you're made of cheese
First like.👍
Only thing i hate about these land and range rovers is the stupid gear shift knob. only the range rover sport and the new mini discovery have the auto stick.
Yeah, really bad. Really diminishes the feel
I,m first
Not the most pretty car of his segment. Drives OK when it is not broken.. Lol
What the hell
It looks like a Chinese version
Most ugly discovery in history. Lose the Land Rover style and heritage in design. Failed sale in Australia. Not too many on the street after released for three years in Australia. Loyal Land Rover funs still love boxy style . Only new and young customer may like new ones. I owned discovery 4. Never want upgrades to this new ugly one.
Nope. Still unreliable. JLR and electronics don’t get on well and they are adding more and more electronics.
and you say this from what experiance?
a woman reviewing a Land Rover.....groan
If you want to go to the outback take a land rover, If you want to make it home take a landcruiser
Why do you repeat something you've heard others say?Don't you have a mind of your own?
Because it's 100% valid and a little funny.
I don't think the majority of Disco owners are going anywhere near the outback. Pretty much the same as most Cruisers too. But at least the cruiser is more reliable. I couldn't imagine somebody wandering in to LR and chosing the top spec Disco for outback travel lol.
@@shanevonharten3100 and what Landrover have you ever owned to make this typical thick Australian comment?
@@PhilShenton and you know this how shit for brains?
the sd4 is about 20k cheaper than the sd6... thats a pretty good reason to opt for the 2 litre!