@@larrypeden9729 Hey man, THAT is a perfect song also! No doubt! I always thought "Smoke from a distant fire" was another one. How about " Don't worry baby" by the Beach Boys?
@@keithgillum3414 I was just starting to do the exact same calculation. I guess if you lived through these times, you'd immediately see the b.s., but the real question is...why???
That’s funny. I am 71 as well and I’ve enjoyed this song ever since it came out when I was 23. I guess harrystevens9564 has a really impressive time machine.
I’ve actually cried listening to this song and I’ve probably heard it hundreds of times in my youth. I was 18 when it was released. It is a beautiful, mysterious timepiece and most surely a classic. Thank you Al and the members of your band for giving us such beauty right into the palms of our hands. Peace to you always.
The 70's were the greatest and most magical decade for both pop and rock music. You'd never hear a Top 40 hit with instrumental passages and solos like this in the 80's or any other decade.
The seventies seemed like a time when you could just go on n on with a jam and it was always was fantastic. New rifts and chord combos you never heard before..all made your sense go crazy and to hear them today they still do...
+Tom Johnson Awesome. Never saw Casablanca, wondering if it's romantic. Gonna try to find it now. My idea of a good time is parking in the middle of nowhere on a moonlit night, with someone very special, and a song like this comes on the radio.
+Tom Johnson If you watch the live version Al Stewart, Year Of The Cat, Royal Albert Hall, May 16 2015, he explains where the song came from, the significance of the piece from Casablanca and the title of the song. Maybe not as good a version as this one but I've yet to hear Al Stewart sing this song badly. Inspired and inspirational music. It's not easy to say what is my favourite song of all time but God, this one is right up there along with Time Passages.
Beats "You go strolling through the crowd like Dick Cheney contemplating a crime" all to hell! (Yes, Al actually has sung it that way live sometimes...)
I really believe this is QUITE POSSIBLY the most perfect song EVER written about the “human experience”. EVERY time I hear it I’m convinced even more..
I was going through my early teens when this came out. The beauty, and allure of the song continues to this day, and is in fact enhanced knowing what an incredible piece of musical composition this is. Just sublimely as beautiful as being 13 all over again.
79 I graduated & left for the USN. The song followed me, right up to today @ 63 yrs old. The piano & solo guitar does send chills. And that saxophone is a killer again as in Time Passengers.
What's amazing about listening to a song over 4 decades old, is it makes you see how much of the old world has utterly changed forever, over and over, and it also lets you see the part of yourself that hasn't changed at all
The imagery created in the song reaches into your heart creating both happiness and a melancholy feeling about inability to change circumstances beyond your control, but also the importance of embracing the moment.
Me, absolutely. I heard Al Stewart for the first time on this very tour and I'm still his fan. You don't find that kind of music today with all the techno shit. Fortunately, he still has a lot of airplay here in the north of Germany
Do you think these guys had any idea we will be watching and enjoying to tears this show after thirty plus years? Great version. I love the flavor that every instrument brings to the mix. Great piano intro, great sax solo and the guitar is second to none. The melody simply creates an atmosphere. It's raining like it's the end of the world. Thanx, and greetings from Buin, Chile.
+Luis Flores I see Al Stewart live pretty much every year. He tours with guitarist Dave Nachmanoff, and the two man show plays very small (200-300 people) venues in the US. Dave is incredibly good. The first time I went I thought I might be a tiny bit disappointed not to have the full band. Not at all. Dave and Al make enough sound for 4 guitars. I go for the music, of course, but also for Al's stories and musings. He spends almost as much time talking to the audience as he does playing. He talks to folks, I've had my picture taken with him before a show when I found myself standing in the lounge next to him. It's always just such a wonderful evening. At this point, I almost feel like I know the man. (Almost) I can tell you that he often says that he is indeed amazed and appreciative that we still listen to his music. :)
+Dave Thompson Saw him two weeks ago in Washington. Yep. Live in California, retired. He plays in the state often. Going to try to make more of his shows.
Very cool, flatchyu. I recently relocated from Atlanta to Michigan and I have tickets to see him this summer in Chicago. WooHoo! Thankfully he likes to work!
1977 had so much great talent, and we listened to lots of it. This is a great, great song, and I am glad I was growing up at the time. The guitar solo always gave me chills, and it still has the power.
I agree, can you imagine someone writing Year of the Cat, Roads to Moscow, Soho (Needless to say), Time Passages, On the Border, Nostradamus, etc today. They all tell such powerful stories. Rick Beato has just released a video talking about the lack of lyrics in modern music.
I still remember the first time I heard it on the radio. There was something distinctive, unusual and mysterious about it. No doubt one of the best songs of the 20th century.
There are no more poetic lyrics in rock than the first few lines of Year of the Cat ... "In a country where they turn back time... You go strolling through the crowd like Peter Lorre contemplating a crime." "She comes out of the sun in a silk dress running like a watercolor in the rain." --- It doesn't get better than that. It just doesn't. Couple that with seamless guitar-sax transition and you have a timeless classic. Every year becomes The Year of the Cat.
My favourite parts are the incredibly seamless handover from Al's guitar to Adam's at 5:05 (before I saw this clip I thought it was all done on one guitar), and the equally seamless handover from Adam's guitar to Bryan's sax at 7:46. Both give me goosebumps every time. I must have played this a hundred times but I never tire of it.
After analyzing all the versions ever made of this song, I must concur that this is the best live version ever made. The perfect harmony of the instruments and people (including the crowd) makes it magical. They all play their part well even the lady with the tambourine and the bassist. My favourite player is the saxophonist...it is hard to cast the proper saxophonist for this song, especially when the part differs from one video to another. The saxophone version of this song was more elaborate, swave and profound. I liked the liberty Al gave to the guitarist and saxophonist. The mellotron piano was sublime. The keyboardist really enjoyed this session and you can see it in his smiles here and there. What a bliss!
Funny thing is, this is an almost completely different set of musicians to those who played on the Year of the Cat studio album 3 years earlier. It's: Adam Yurman on guitar instead of Tim Renwick Harry Stinson on drums instead of Stuart Elliot Robin Lamble on bass instead of George Ford Robert Alpert on piano instead of Peter Wood Bryan Savage on saxophone instead of Phil Kenzie Krysia Kristianne on backing vocals instead of David Pack & others Only Al (of course) and Peter White played on the studio version.
*Robert Alpert he said at the intro to the song, not Herb Alpert. I would have been very surprised if they had Herb Alpert on the piano, given that he's a trumpet player.
Hmm, I don't see (or hear) it. I find the Old Grey Whistle Test live one from 1976 far superior. From the better piano playing to the audio balance to the saxophone solo's, I think the 1976 performance stands out more. I still like hearing every version of this song though, it never gets old.
To think of how such a composition originated, materializing from the brilliant mind of Stewart. The progression, the lyrics, the instrumental parts; all so eerily captivating and beautiful. It reminds me of distant lands and experiences which have yet to exist.
Thanks for that. As someone else said, this could be the greatest song of all time. A bold statement when you consider what other well composed and crafted songs there are (e.g. American Pie/Hotel California etc, etc, etc) but it has to be right up there
One of the greatest songs ever written. A masterpiece that evokes space and time - stirs memories of when life was easy, yet hidden with unknowns. The grand rhythm and sound remains as fresh as ever ! Love it.
A estas alturas de mi vida (55 años) puedo decir que esta es mi canción favorita. Siempre me gustó desde adolescente. Me produce una sensación deliciosa al escucharla
@Byron Galvez: I couldn't agree with you more. This was a song that was a great part of my youth and is now ( Largely due to the internet ) a great part of my old age. Peace to you Byron and may our Lord grant you many more years to enjoy.
I love watching how musicians communicate on stage. Watch at 7:28, how the sax player just gives the smallest glance with his head toward Al to hand off the solo, and then Al turns to the guitar player to pass it on. I also love how the sax player matches the high note at the end of the guitar solo at 7:47 and takes it from there. This is an awesome performance. I just want it to keep going on and on...
MR AL STEWART & BAND MATES HAVE BEEN " PERFORMING" W/ME SINCE EARLY 70"S, STARTING W/"CAT"( NEVER HAD A FELINE TILL I MARRIED-MANY SINCE, THRU TODAY.ONLY MY SHELTY SHEPARD MIX " TIPPY" LOVED MY PLAYING & WOULD CLIMB THE UPPER SCALE TO HIGH F# W/ME, WHILE MOM("WINDY"-SHELTY) RAN DOWN THE STAIRS TO ESCAPE. NO ACCOUNTING FOR TASTE AMONG DOGS.
“Handing off” the solo is a time honored and respected stage technique that quality musicians in all genres employ to ensure the audience can follow the performers with their eyes” with the help of a glance and slight nod for entertainment purposes.
This is so technically perfect and disgustingly good. I am in total awe. Its like watching a great movie. Ive watched it six times in two days to make sure I didn't miss anything.
Al Stewart's Year of the Cat LP (as well as the next release, Time Passages) came out when I was age 15 and 16 respectively and was a huge influence on me to learn to play guitar. I remember hearing the song "Time Passages" on a Christmas morning and it was just beautiful feelings all day. Thanks Al, you and the band are awesome.
It's hard to describe how much this song has meant to me since March of 1977. Simply, it was beyond perfection to a young 23 year old and means more now to an aging, reflective 68 year old. It's a Van Gogh set to music!
@@carolinegodden4364 I've met Al a couple of times after concerts, and he is a totally humble, approachable genius. That's exactly what I expected from such a thoughtful lyricist. He is just the best storyteller ever. He must be a blast to even be around. Best wishes to you and your family! Give Al my highest regards!
I'd be honored if some Al Stewart & late 70s fans would take a listen to my acoustic piano & vocal performances of TIME PASSAGES and WHAT A FOOL BELIEVES by Michael McDonald on my YT channel in tribute to a couple of the true masters of melodic lyricism and composition. Live acoustic with no autotune or digital editing. Thanks and peace.
No money these days . Young people are spending it in different ways. This is just brilliant, would have just loved being there..I like to know more about the pianist. The story of how this song was written is fascinating.
@@Dmab661 "Herbert Smith so true! It’s now a pool of nothingness!!" 50 years ago we loved the music of the moment imagining how great it would be in 50 years. WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED????????
It's different now, neither better or worse. We're just much, much older now, and nothing will vibrate the heart strings quite the same again as when we were much, much younger. That said, check out NPR's Tiny Desk Music. You might be surprised.
This music came out many years before I was born.. but I gotta agree with you. this song is SOOOOOO beautiful..... even makes me think of life with beautiful nature as listening to this music.. btw pardon me to be random.. I love my CAT at home.. Meow... :-P
I play music in local venues, bars, restaurants, etc. and I always enjoy playing this song. It’s been a personal favorite of mine since it’s release in the 70’s. I love when people of my generation remember it and especially when young people respond to it and recognize it as the masterpiece it is.
This isn't just a song, it's a hymn. Knowing it since the late 70s, it was a great honor to me me, when I really met Al Stewart (in 2008) and even talked to him. (He also signed a CD cover.) Great gentleman and unbelieveable talent...
Listening this eternal melody, sat on my private room, eating dark cocoa without sugar, the mind flies so far, years in a second, and I only can feel a deep love and be grateful to the life. 🥲❤
Esta versión en vivo me sacude el alma cuando el pianista hace el intro de "As Time Goes By", sólo un melómano sensible puede percibir lo bellísima de esta versión...
7:52 - that merge from solo guitar to solo sax - staggering genius within an entire band obviously enjoying their craft. Wow and thankyou for posting the entire clip of such a legendary song :)
One of the best Art Bell Coast to Coast AM bumper songs. From the great American southwest I bid you all a good evening, good morning, wherever you may be.
4:36 when you first realize that the guy who wrote one of the most beautiful, iconic songs in a lifetime and has one of the most unique singing voices also happens to be capable of taking a pretty sweet lead guitar solo.
Sounds similar to Jerry Rafferty, similar to Baker Street! Two fabulous Artists, and great songs too!! I had their disks which I played on my Pioneer 1040 receiver, and my Dual 1229 turntable!
This song always reminds me of my beloved father who has passed on! I remember this song being on the radio while we were fishing one summer. It was the only time we both went out on my boat!
I will never tire from this tune.. we use to wake up and get ready for school and get to listen to the radio before we walk out the door. Truly a time capsule of the 70s.
I’m a young 70 AND STILL DANCE TO THIS SONG!!! What a classic tune. As soon as you hear the intro of the piano you know the song right away. My mind goes way back to my youth, where I was, what I was doing in my life & of course who was in my life at the time. Just great memories when this was out, nothing like it ever since. Thanks for my walk down memory lane. 🫶
This music will never get forgotten.my son is 37 years old. This song came out7 years before he was born and him and his children listen to this and love it
I went to a small concert he held around 2000, when I was living in Reading, UK. It was a nice intimate affair, and at the end of the concert, Al stood at the door talking to anyone who wanted to say hello along with signing his merch. He didn’t leave until everyone who wanted to say hello had their chance.
It was filmed in the TV studios of Radio Bremen where the Beat-Club was filmed a few years earlier. These studios were torn down three or four years ago.
Born in 58, graduated high school 1976, the music in the 60's, 70's is amazing. So much talent. Good radios and tape decks in my cars as a young adult. Vinyl records in my room at home. Concerts, what a great time for amazing bands.
CHECK OUT "JOHNNY ALMOND'S " GOING TO CALIFORNIA"; "SO HARD TO SHARE" . "ROXANNE", IN JOHN MAYALL'S BLUES BREAKERS " AT THE FILLMORE" ; THEN "PAUL DESMOND"(ALTO)IN DAVE BRUBECK'S " TAKE FIVE";ANYTHING W/" BOBBY KEYS"(JOE COCKER & LEON RUSSEL, THE STONES, ON & ON), & STUART MATHEWMEN IN "SADE'S" "JEZEBEL" & " IS IT A CRIME".
If I knew how to post a link, I'd post one with Michael Lington playing an amazing break in Bobby Caldwell's video "What You Won't Do For Love" so I'll just suggest you Google it. ruclips.net/video/RzfQBDBUh-U/видео.html starts at 2:57 (after Bobby starts with his red keytar).
I have always said that this is the most perfect song I ever heard. You can listen to this a million times and it never gets old. Thanks Al!
Correct. In that regard, this song is perfection!
I agree . my friends think I am crazy for thinking so
What about What Does It Take by Junior Walker and the Allstars!
@@larrypeden9729 Hey man, THAT is a perfect song also! No doubt! I always thought "Smoke from a distant fire" was another one. How about " Don't worry baby" by the Beach Boys?
Yes its the perfect song.
I love this song when i was 17... 71 now and still loving it. Im getting old, this song is not. Never will.
I'm no mathematician but this song came out in 1976. If you were 17 when it cam out, you'd have been born in 1959, which would make you 65 now.
@@keithgillum3414 I was just starting to do the exact same calculation. I guess if you lived through these times, you'd immediately see the b.s., but the real question is...why???
It's only our bodies that get old.
Not that it ain't an issue, anyway... 😅
That’s funny. I am 71 as well and I’ve enjoyed this song ever since it came out when I was 23. I guess harrystevens9564 has a really impressive time machine.
It appears I'm not the only one who thought your claim didn't sound right.
I’ve actually cried listening to this song and I’ve probably heard it hundreds of times in my youth. I was 18 when it was released. It is a beautiful, mysterious timepiece and most surely a classic. Thank you Al and the members of your band for giving us such beauty right into the palms of our hands. Peace to you always.
Thanks Linda. I have cried so many times. OMG. Even wrote a short story about it1
You are certainly not alone...
much better than his lesser known hit "the year of the possum"
I'm from that era as well and this song conjures up fond memories of my youth. A timeless classic.
@@kbtube8125 🤣🤣🤣
It was my anthem to my girlfriend. She's still around 48 years later............our sons nicknamed her the Cat.
Yes. Simply, yes.
The 70's were the greatest and most magical decade for both pop and rock music. You'd never hear a Top 40 hit with instrumental passages and solos like this in the 80's or any other decade.
No you wouldn't. The path music has taken saddens me deeply.
there were solos in the 1990s all the time.
@@monetarnie3841
In pop songs?
ELO comes to mind, I believe they had quite a few post '70s but definitely one of the exceptions.
The seventies seemed like a time when you could just go on n on with a jam and it was always was fantastic. New rifts and chord combos you never heard before..all made your sense go crazy and to hear them today they still do...
this is not just a song
its a little victory of the human being against eternity
@Z Thank you !
pequeña victoria del ser humano contra la eternidad. How beauty that is!
Ramiro......Damn , that is profound. Is it you or something you heard once?
@@shanemiller9000 Its just me Shane, so thank you :) I guess this excellent music just gets the best out of everyone. Saludos !
I totally agree. It fulfills me everytime I listen.
I like how the pianist starts out playing "as time goes by", right out of a Bogart movie.
Tom Johnson
Me too. That is one of the best versions of that song ever. I wish this version was officially released
+Tom Johnson dumb me didn't get that.
+Tom Johnson Awesome. Never saw Casablanca, wondering if it's romantic. Gonna try to find it now. My idea of a good time is parking in the middle of nowhere on a moonlit night, with someone very special, and a song like this comes on the radio.
+Tom Johnson He is a wonderful pianist. and someone very dear to my heart for 30 plus years. Glad you enjoyed his talent.
w
+Tom Johnson If you watch the live version Al Stewart, Year Of The Cat, Royal Albert Hall, May 16 2015, he explains where the song came from, the significance of the piece from Casablanca and the title of the song. Maybe not as good a version as this one but I've yet to hear Al Stewart sing this song badly. Inspired and inspirational music. It's not easy to say what is my favourite song of all time but God, this one is right up there along with Time Passages.
"She comes out of the sun in a silk dress running, like a watercolor in the rain..."
One of my favorite lyrics ever, the first time I heard it in 1979 through right now.
The imagery of this lyric is limitless
@@timothyjepson6457 Yep. You can almost see her.
Beats "You go strolling through the crowd like Dick Cheney contemplating a crime" all to hell! (Yes, Al actually has sung it that way live sometimes...)
Such a vivid description you can’t help but see it all in one’s imagination.
I really believe this is QUITE POSSIBLY the most perfect song EVER written about the “human experience”. EVERY time I hear it I’m convinced even more..
There is another competitor 'The last time I saw her Face, Gordon Lightfoot
There are a ton of people who feel exactly that way as do I!!
Yes it IS!! so beautiful.
I agree with you one hundred percent!
One of the very few songs that I never tire of listening to. Quite simply, a masterpiece.
I was going through my early teens when this came out. The beauty, and allure of the song continues to this day, and is in fact enhanced knowing what an incredible piece of musical composition this is. Just sublimely as beautiful as being 13 all over again.
"She comes out of the sun in a silk dress running like a watercolor in the rain"
That is just about my favorite line of any song ever made
My thoughts exactly.
Women n water mmmmmm
The best lyric ever!
My senses discovered the complexity of a woman wearing patchouli in 1976 when the album first came out. (If ya know what I mean)
It is as surreal as it is literal
79 I graduated & left for the USN.
The song followed me, right up to today @ 63 yrs old.
The piano & solo guitar does send chills.
And that saxophone is a killer again as in Time Passengers.
Yep……same age and feeling here…..
What's amazing about listening to a song over 4 decades old, is it makes you see how much of the old world has utterly changed forever, over and over, and it also lets you see the part of yourself that hasn't changed at all
So true!
Wise words, my soulmate. Very wise words.
And reminds us that the world has been changing like this since ever since
Your comment is nearly as good as the song.
The imagery created in the song reaches into your heart creating both happiness and a melancholy feeling about inability to change circumstances beyond your control, but also the importance of embracing the moment.
Who’s listening to this in 2024？
Me, me ! I was 17 when this song came out. Now I am about to turn 64 and still think it is an eternal song.
Myself
Me👍
When you compare it to new songs, You ll find it magical
Me, absolutely. I heard Al Stewart for the first time on this very tour and I'm still his fan. You don't find that kind of music today with all the techno shit. Fortunately, he still has a lot of airplay here in the north of Germany
Sublime, one of most beautiful songs ever written , deeply touches the heart.
After 39 years this song stills kick ass :D
You know it!
A lot!
you bet it does mate
You bet it does pal.
what you said :)
Do you think these guys had any idea we will be watching and enjoying to tears this show after thirty plus years? Great version. I love the flavor that every instrument brings to the mix. Great piano intro, great sax solo and the guitar is second to none. The melody simply creates an atmosphere. It's raining like it's the end of the world. Thanx, and greetings from Buin, Chile.
+Luis Flores I see Al Stewart live pretty much every year. He tours with guitarist Dave Nachmanoff, and the two man show plays very small (200-300 people) venues in the US. Dave is incredibly good. The first time I went I thought I might be a tiny bit disappointed not to have the full band. Not at all. Dave and Al make enough sound for 4 guitars. I go for the music, of course, but also for Al's stories and musings. He spends almost as much time talking to the audience as he does playing. He talks to folks, I've had my picture taken with him before a show when I found myself standing in the lounge next to him. It's always just such a wonderful evening. At this point, I almost feel like I know the man. (Almost) I can tell you that he often says that he is indeed amazed and appreciative that we still listen to his music. :)
Thanks, Dave for sharing such a great experience. I would love to see the guy live. We all envy you a bit.
+Luis Flores yes
+Dave Thompson Saw him two weeks ago in Washington. Yep. Live in California, retired. He plays in the state often. Going to try to make more of his shows.
Very cool, flatchyu. I recently relocated from Atlanta to Michigan and I have tickets to see him this summer in Chicago. WooHoo! Thankfully he likes to work!
A timeless masterpiece. It gave me goosebumps when it was released in the seventies and it gives me goosebumps today.
1977 had so much great talent, and we listened to lots of it. This is a great, great song, and I am glad I was growing up at the time. The guitar solo always gave me chills, and it still has the power.
Nice comment. The guitar and sax solos both do it for me!
The saxophone player adds another dimension to the song.
Bryan Savage is his name..
Superb!
Absolutely!
Sorry his raucous tone marrs the song for me or maybe my equipment?.Is it same player on record ?
I don't think anyone under age 25 is even capable writing a song like this today.
Try age "45"....
@@thebordernow How about you two compromise and say 33 & 1/3...
lil peep was great
I agree, can you imagine someone writing Year of the Cat, Roads to Moscow, Soho (Needless to say), Time Passages, On the Border, Nostradamus, etc today. They all tell such powerful stories. Rick Beato has just released a video talking about the lack of lyrics in modern music.
I still remember the first time I heard it on the radio. There was something distinctive, unusual and mysterious about it. No doubt one of the best songs of the 20th century.
My absolute favourite!!!
There are no more poetic lyrics in rock than the first few lines of Year of the Cat ... "In a country where they turn back time... You go strolling through the crowd like Peter Lorre contemplating a crime." "She comes out of the sun in a silk dress running like a watercolor in the rain." --- It doesn't get better than that. It just doesn't. Couple that with seamless guitar-sax transition and you have a timeless classic. Every year becomes The Year of the Cat.
Indeed my friend.
2022, and I’m still listening to this masterpiece, Al. It’s as beautiful today as ever.
When I take my first starship journey this tune will be along for the ride. Might be the only one I will need. Incredible!
My favourite parts are the incredibly seamless handover from Al's guitar to Adam's at 5:05 (before I saw this clip I thought it was all done on one guitar), and the equally seamless handover from Adam's guitar to Bryan's sax at 7:46. Both give me goosebumps every time.
I must have played this a hundred times but I never tire of it.
After analyzing all the versions ever made of this song, I must concur that this is the best live version ever made. The perfect harmony of the instruments and people (including the crowd) makes it magical. They all play their part well even the lady with the tambourine and the bassist. My favourite player is the saxophonist...it is hard to cast the proper saxophonist for this song, especially when the part differs from one video to another. The saxophone version of this song was more elaborate, swave and profound. I liked the liberty Al gave to the guitarist and saxophonist. The mellotron piano was sublime. The keyboardist really enjoyed this session and you can see it in his smiles here and there. What a bliss!
Funny thing is, this is an almost completely different set of musicians to those who played on the Year of the Cat studio album 3 years earlier. It's:
Adam Yurman on guitar instead of Tim Renwick
Harry Stinson on drums instead of Stuart Elliot
Robin Lamble on bass instead of George Ford
Robert Alpert on piano instead of Peter Wood
Bryan Savage on saxophone instead of Phil Kenzie
Krysia Kristianne on backing vocals instead of David Pack & others
Only Al (of course) and Peter White played on the studio version.
*Robert Alpert he said at the intro to the song, not Herb Alpert. I would have been very surprised if they had Herb Alpert on the piano, given that he's a trumpet player.
Oops yes, that was a word / brain association blip. I had meant Robert all along. Have corrected it now, thanks.
until I went back and watched it again I was all excited thinking "wait Herb Alpert plays piano too?!"
Hmm, I don't see (or hear) it. I find the Old Grey Whistle Test live one from 1976 far superior. From the better piano playing to the audio balance to the saxophone solo's, I think the 1976 performance stands out more. I still like hearing every version of this song though, it never gets old.
To think of how such a composition originated, materializing from the brilliant mind of Stewart. The progression, the lyrics, the instrumental parts; all so eerily captivating and beautiful. It reminds me of distant lands and experiences which have yet to exist.
+David Peterson Time Passages does the same for me
Mimi mami are you sure you were replying to my comment?
Thanks for that. As someone else said, this could be the greatest song of all time. A bold statement when you consider what other well composed and crafted songs there are (e.g. American Pie/Hotel California etc, etc, etc) but it has to be right up there
The thanks were to pykkervots
Mark Dallinger yes mark. A strong argument could be made as to how the song has held up over time; flawless in lyrics timing and arrangement.
One of the greatest songs ever written. A masterpiece that evokes space and time - stirs memories of when life was easy, yet hidden with unknowns. The grand rhythm and sound remains as fresh as ever ! Love it.
A estas alturas de mi vida (55 años) puedo decir que esta es mi canción favorita. Siempre me gustó desde adolescente. Me produce una sensación deliciosa al escucharla
@Byron Galvez: I couldn't agree with you more. This was a song that was a great part of my youth and is now ( Largely due to the internet ) a great part of my old age. Peace to you Byron and may our Lord grant you many more years to enjoy.
Siiii tal cual!!!
The piano intro is sublime. Always boosts my mood.
Darn right!!!! Even my cat loves this!!!!!
It is amazing indeed! Its one of the best piano riffs ever in my opinion!
Exactly. Sets the mood perfectly
Sublime. Vivan Los Gatos...
His song was meant to be a tribute to Casablanca. So the intro is not random.
I love watching how musicians communicate on stage. Watch at 7:28, how the sax player just gives the smallest glance with his head toward Al to hand off the solo, and then Al turns to the guitar player to pass it on. I also love how the sax player matches the high note at the end of the guitar solo at 7:47 and takes it from there.
This is an awesome performance. I just want it to keep going on and on...
+svyt Excellent observations and analyses!~~~ I can't agree with you more. :)
MR AL STEWART & BAND MATES HAVE BEEN " PERFORMING" W/ME SINCE EARLY 70"S, STARTING W/"CAT"( NEVER HAD A FELINE TILL I MARRIED-MANY SINCE, THRU TODAY.ONLY MY SHELTY SHEPARD MIX " TIPPY" LOVED MY PLAYING & WOULD CLIMB THE UPPER SCALE TO HIGH F# W/ME, WHILE MOM("WINDY"-SHELTY) RAN DOWN THE STAIRS TO ESCAPE. NO ACCOUNTING FOR TASTE AMONG DOGS.
The unspoken word is where it's at.
Retroceder hace daño a mi mente el yo era... menos años de todas maneras. YE MÜ GUAPA
“Handing off” the solo is a time honored and respected stage technique that quality musicians in all genres employ to ensure the audience can follow the performers with their eyes” with the help of a glance and slight nod for entertainment purposes.
These are the kind of moments I wish I could go back in time and enjoy.
As both an Al Stewart fan and fan of the film Casablanca... this is perfect
The 70's at their best. So glad I was in my teens and was able to hear it all!
Me too!
This is so technically perfect and disgustingly good. I am in total awe. Its like watching a great movie. Ive watched it six times in two days to make sure I didn't miss anything.
No , I get it 100% …it hit me square between the eyes as a 16 year old and still does to this very day..
The greatest song of the 20th century.
Agree!!!
YES YES 🙌
Al Stewart's Year of the Cat LP (as well as the next release, Time Passages) came out when I was age 15 and 16 respectively and was a huge influence on me to learn to play guitar. I remember hearing the song "Time Passages" on a Christmas morning and it was just beautiful feelings all day. Thanks Al, you and the band are awesome.
That guitar solo always gets me and the segue into the sax solo is just special.
Tutti pensiamo a quando eravamo giovani, poche canzoni come questa fanno ricordare con tanta nostalgia...
YES!
It's hard to describe how much this song has meant to me since March of 1977. Simply, it was beyond perfection to a young 23 year old and means more now to an aging, reflective 68 year old. It's a Van Gogh set to music!
Wonderful thought to share. Thank you, I will pass it onto Al. Little SiSTAR here. CJ x
@@carolinegodden4364 I've met Al a couple of times after concerts, and he is a totally humble, approachable genius. That's exactly what I expected from such a thoughtful lyricist. He is just the best storyteller ever. He must be a blast to even be around. Best wishes to you and your family! Give Al my highest regards!
First time I heard this song was probably summer before turning 11 yo. Fell in love with Al Stewart as a musician. It’s a beautiful song.
I'm with you without a doubt my favorite song of all time
I agree with you Hal
This music is so happy, simple and captivating; at the end the sax is heart breaking. Simple songs last forever...
Daniele Rigo But it’s not such a simple song.
@@jimeiden2360 >> yes rather complex tune for sure.
@@marktrail8624 And yet Al can totally do these songs solo live and they feel complete...
that pianist is sensational!
There are some few songs that will last forever. This is one of them.
Love how the song progresses. Instrumentals are perfect. Great Piano intro. Just perfect!!!
one of the greatest songs of my life
Not just of Your life... ;-)
This song just goes through my soul, I've loved this song since I was 14 years old, BEAUTY til this day!💖
Wow great memories.
I was born in 1967 but remember this song..
😁
Same. Part of my youth and now I relate to it out of memories
From a time when recording artists were actual musicians...
Dang Skippy !
And a time when talent meant something.
I'd be honored if some Al Stewart & late 70s fans would take a listen to my acoustic piano & vocal performances of TIME PASSAGES and WHAT A FOOL BELIEVES by Michael McDonald on my YT channel in tribute to a couple of the true masters of melodic lyricism and composition. Live acoustic with no autotune or digital editing. Thanks and peace.
AMEN
@@JustMe-qo7yw and amazing song-writers
More proof how far popular music has fallen in the past 40 years.
Herbert Smith so true! It’s now a pool of nothingness!!
Thank you
No money these days . Young people are spending it in different ways. This is just brilliant, would have just loved being there..I like to know more about the pianist. The story of how this song was written is fascinating.
@@Dmab661
"Herbert Smith so true! It’s now a pool of nothingness!!"
50 years ago we loved the music of the moment imagining how great it would be in 50 years.
WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED????????
It's different now, neither better or worse. We're just much, much older now, and nothing will vibrate the heart strings quite the same again as when we were much, much younger. That said, check out NPR's Tiny Desk Music. You might be surprised.
The phrase," like the watercolors in the rain," is so beautiful. The whole song is a masterpiece.❤❤❤
Still my favourite song, musically and lyrically.
By any definition, a musical masterpiece!
Could be the greatest song of all time
+Zed That's been mine opinion for a long time
I'm agree. Great song, remains my childhood in school...
Har to tell but you are close.
This music came out many years before I was born.. but I gotta agree with you. this song is SOOOOOO beautiful..... even makes me think of life with beautiful nature as listening to this music.. btw pardon me to be random.. I love my CAT at home.. Meow... :-P
No.
Definitely one of the greatest of all time though.
I'm 35 and this is true talent overlooked.
I'm 57 and still this music never quits and yes overlooked, long live"The Year of the Cat"!
was on the charts in the day . a popular song!
I’m 78 and 😻
I play music in local venues, bars, restaurants, etc. and I always enjoy playing this song. It’s been a personal favorite of mine since it’s release in the 70’s. I love when people of my generation remember it and especially when young people respond to it and recognize it as the masterpiece it is.
My youth has slipped away. At least this beautiful masterpiece was part of it. Thank you Al. Tears of joy!!
This isn't just a song, it's a hymn.
Knowing it since the late 70s, it was a great honor to me me, when I really met Al Stewart (in 2008) and even talked to him.
(He also signed a CD cover.)
Great gentleman and unbelieveable talent...
Listening this eternal melody, sat on my private room, eating dark cocoa without sugar, the mind flies so far, years in a second, and I only can feel a deep love and be grateful to the life. 🥲❤
Nice comment, but please treat yourself to some sugar or even some beer! 😅
It is now 2023. I still listen to this as well as Time Passages. They are simply timeless pieces of art.
Wonderful, haunting song, with some of the most beautiful lyrics ever.
40 years now... and the song and sax are still 'killer' sounds !!
The transition from the solo lead guitar to saxophone ,,,PRICELESS !!!
Esta versión en vivo me sacude el alma cuando el pianista hace el intro de "As Time Goes By", sólo un melómano sensible puede percibir lo bellísima de esta versión...
Y ya perdí la cuenta de las veces que me emociona escuchar ese bello intro...
I agree with you. I had forgotten this song until I happened upon this quite by accident.
This is too good......whenever i need an attitude adjustment, this song does it for me!
The Saxophone is definitely the instrument of the black hole in this universe.
This tune casts a very charming,
enchanting spell over me. It touches the soul like no other song. The musical harmonies are unique and special.
Al Stewart such a poet!!! I love this song then and always!
This is one of those classic tunes that NEVER gets old. Love it!! 😊❤
Liked the song just fine, when I was a kid. Now I love this song. I guess it reminds me of so many good old memories. Thanks for posting it
And we didn't know this would be the look at if it. We thought there would be more.
7:52 - that merge from solo guitar to solo sax - staggering genius within an entire band obviously enjoying their craft. Wow and thankyou for posting the entire clip of such a legendary song :)
Ear Candy,Friends......
This is a band of outstanding musos. The pianist is brilliant. The arrangement is out of sight.
One of the best Art Bell Coast to Coast AM bumper songs. From the great American southwest I bid you all a good evening, good morning, wherever you may be.
Its hard not to cry while listening to this awesome song. It brings back so many memories. Saw him live and backstage in Munich, Germany
Musical Magic Thank God it was captured live.
4:36 when you first realize that the guy who wrote one of the most beautiful, iconic songs in a lifetime and has one of the most unique singing voices also happens to be capable of taking a pretty sweet lead guitar solo.
Exactly what I thought !
Sounds similar to Jerry Rafferty, similar to Baker Street! Two fabulous Artists, and great songs too!! I had their disks which I played on my Pioneer 1040 receiver, and my Dual 1229 turntable!
This version is phenomenal.
Fantastic piece and concert that emblematically ended that extraordinary period of our 70s.
This song always reminds me of my beloved father who has passed on! I remember this song being on the radio while we were fishing one summer. It was the only time we both went out on my boat!
Takes me back to my teen in the 70s. Nostalgic! Al the great!
One of the most recognizable and famous sax riffs in all of music.
I will never tire from this tune.. we use to wake up and get ready for school and get to listen to the radio before we walk out the door. Truly a time capsule of the 70s.
I’m a young 70 AND STILL DANCE TO THIS SONG!!! What a classic tune. As soon as you hear the intro of the piano you know the song right away. My mind goes way back to my youth, where I was, what I was doing in my life & of course who was in my life at the time. Just great memories when this was out, nothing like it ever since. Thanks for my walk down memory lane. 🫶
When Musicians play live and it sounds like the Record-you know they’re at top of the game. Great Classic tune.
My favorite video of all time! What a great song and he even left in the incense and patchouli part! :)
Agreed!...Hey is That Rob Halpern From Judas Priest?
This music will never get forgotten.my son is 37 years old. This song came out7 years before he was born and him and his children listen to this and love it
I went to a small concert he held around 2000, when I was living in Reading, UK.
It was a nice intimate affair, and at the end of the concert, Al stood at the door talking to anyone who wanted to say hello along with signing his merch.
He didn’t leave until everyone who wanted to say hello had their chance.
Legendary song, and that pianist robert hartford is just pure genius.
Robert Alpert
THIS SONG WILL STILL THRILL US TILL THE END OF HUMAN EXISTENCE ON THIS PLANET
I'm so glad that I was in the TV studio when this was recorded! Thanks to Walter M.!
Lucky dog!!!!
It was filmed in the TV studios of Radio Bremen where the Beat-Club was filmed a few years earlier. These studios were torn down three or four years ago.
You do not need a lot of hits to be a famous pop star . You just need that one MEGA HIT and my friends this right here was a MONSTER HIT.....
Fender Strats Forever. Most beautiful, mellow sound. And when that Sax explodes, wow, makes the whole Orchestra come alive...
Born in 58, graduated high school 1976, the music in the 60's, 70's is amazing. So much talent. Good radios and tape decks in my cars as a young adult.
Vinyl records in my room at home. Concerts, what a great time for amazing bands.
During that era you could have your FM radio playing all day without hearing a bad song 👍
Los grandes clásicos jamás pasan de moda...pues la Musica es sublime pura y única...EL AÑO DEL GATO....INMORTAL CANCION.
One amongst the Most Beautiful Saxophone pieces in the world.
Phil Collins....in the original..version
CHECK OUT "JOHNNY ALMOND'S " GOING TO CALIFORNIA"; "SO HARD TO SHARE" . "ROXANNE", IN JOHN MAYALL'S BLUES BREAKERS " AT THE FILLMORE" ; THEN "PAUL DESMOND"(ALTO)IN DAVE BRUBECK'S " TAKE FIVE";ANYTHING W/" BOBBY KEYS"(JOE COCKER & LEON RUSSEL, THE STONES, ON & ON), & STUART MATHEWMEN IN "SADE'S" "JEZEBEL" & " IS IT A CRIME".
If I knew how to post a link, I'd post one with Michael Lington playing an amazing break in Bobby Caldwell's video "What You Won't Do For Love" so I'll just suggest you Google it. ruclips.net/video/RzfQBDBUh-U/видео.html starts at 2:57 (after Bobby starts with his red keytar).
@@margueritecrain2764 Phil Kenzie
Yes, along with "Jungleland" these sax solos should be in the hall of fame!
One of the best written songs out there. I never get tired of listening to this Al Stewart's classic.
what a beautiful song. just everything is so perfect .
Love how the piano solo starts with parts of the song from Casablanca. With Peter Lorrie contemplating a crime! Love the connection! Great song!❤
I saw Al Stewart and band live at the Kent Stage in Kent, OH. This was a year or two before COVID. It was magnificent.
Al with his angelic voice and pleasant Scottish lilt
Hmm he is from Bristol I think: Clifton in the Rain.