Harley Davidson Nightster VS Nightster S

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 дек 2024

Комментарии • 106

  • @JaysonBucy
    @JaysonBucy Год назад +37

    Nice starter bikes but I still think they're about $5k over priced

    • @throttleblip9854
      @throttleblip9854  Год назад +7

      Agreed. I'll be honest when I rode the Special for another review I REALLY liked it which surprised me. That said it's a tough sell for me at 15. 12500 would be the top.

    • @borealmetalworx
      @borealmetalworx Год назад +7

      I agree HD would kill the imports in volume sales if this was priced more like an entry level bike. It would set the hook for future sales when an upgrade to an M8 is is someone’s plans.

    • @ZKTheGreat
      @ZKTheGreat Год назад +2

      Facts

    • @jayteesgear
      @jayteesgear Год назад

      Fully agree and I cant figure out why brands like Kawasaki offer very similar for so much less! Indian has increased prices too. If they could bring it down to like $12.5 it would be cool.

  • @stevenlawrence2790
    @stevenlawrence2790 Год назад +13

    Man... Gotta say: I definitely prefer the look all the older engines vs the new

  • @ericknapp3114
    @ericknapp3114 Год назад +4

    have to agree if you’re looking at one of these, it’s an easy choice to pick nightster S for $1,500 more. price separation probably should be a little wider, with nightster coming in a little lower.

  • @maxholes2703
    @maxholes2703 7 месяцев назад +1

    Got a regular nightster last week as my first bike and I like the look and style of the regular nightster way more. I wouldn't use many of the features of the nightster S anyways so I'm happy with the standard one

  • @CantTreadOnMe
    @CantTreadOnMe Год назад +3

    The base Nightster has the wheels I prefer by far.

  • @darryllyles4019
    @darryllyles4019 6 месяцев назад +1

    The MSRP sounds Okay until you start adding thousands of junk fees until you are over 20k. Harley Davidson dealership old school car dealer tactics. doc fee, setup fee, surcharge, freight, top off tank with gas fee, paint protection, pinstriping, low jack, alarm system, lot rot prevention fee, fee to jump start dead battery on showroom floor and miscellaneous fees. Some registration and title fees and sales tax and fees for filing.

  • @bikerbeliever8169
    @bikerbeliever8169 Год назад +1

    The special is nicer but both cost way too much. They need to start at $10k then $11.5k for the special

    • @ed.t.hansen6499
      @ed.t.hansen6499 Год назад

      Need to add more data like bmw and increase the price

  • @AlmostLakai94
    @AlmostLakai94 Год назад +3

    I might be extremely dumb but if i can make it work financially (I'd prefer to buy a bike outright) I might make a Nightster S my first bike sometime in the future 🤔 I really dig the look and with a nice bar on the back itd be my style..

  • @DanielKulka
    @DanielKulka 5 месяцев назад +1

    I'd like to get a nightster but the bikers I know are going to Indian because of the way they were treated by the dealership. I don't trust any dealership that don't post the $ price!!!

  • @lizardsonofanakie
    @lizardsonofanakie Год назад +2

    You forgot about the Handlebar Risers . I looked at the Nightster last year was disappointed it did not have the features I wanted . When I seen the Nightster Special was released with all those features I wanted I ordered one 2 days later . Have clocked up over 6000km already. Did 2000km trip in 2 days . In Australia they have dropped the Nightster Model already can only buy the Nightster Special here now. People complain about the pricing and say why buy a Nightster Special when a 114 Street bob is same price . Simple the Nightster Special will out run, out brake & out corner the 114 Street bob and has far more tech on it .

    • @throttleblip9854
      @throttleblip9854  Год назад

      Dang it. And for me thats a big one. Good catch. Now it's going to bug me that I didn't point that out. People give the Nightster models and the Sportster S a hard time but they really do preform great. I wish the Sportster S was more like the FTR but I get why they didn't do that.

    • @lizardsonofanakie
      @lizardsonofanakie Год назад

      @Throttle Blip Harley Davidson have hurt themselves which stupid mistakes on releasing the Sportster S , Nightster and Nightster Special . I know so many people who wanted the Bronx . Accessories for them are in short supply and take up to 3 months wait . Not listed for 2023 model but listed for 2022 model . Is the bike .l have spent $5000 on Accessories that Harleys website says that will not fit yet fit perfectly. Someone is not doing their job . I have upset so many so many CVO owners who have done engine modifications that everytime they look in their mirrors l am still there. They are calling it the Pocket Rocket .

    • @dustinhall4035
      @dustinhall4035 Год назад +1

      Thanks for pointing all that out. I pick up my nightster s next week. I will say I'm disappointed Vance and Hines didn't have a slip on our a runner for it that I can find.

    • @lizardsonofanakie
      @lizardsonofanakie Год назад

      @dustinhall4035 l have the S&S Slip on muffler works ok . There is videos on my channel about the modifications on my bike . Sounds better now that we removed the cat

    • @Disciple_of_the_36th
      @Disciple_of_the_36th 3 месяца назад

      Hi lizard, what about the fuel tank being under the seat , get off the bike to refuel isnt to annoying?

  • @sgt_sledge
    @sgt_sledge Год назад +5

    Nightster S is the same price as the Sportster S. Tech is the same. I can't see a reason to buy either Nightster over the Sportster S. The Nightster needs to be about $10.5k and the S about $12k to make either of them worth buying instead of upgrading. You can get the Softail Standard for less than the Nightster S.

    • @HaXaW5150
      @HaXaW5150 Год назад +1

      I like the Softail Standard. You fix 'em up to look awesome.

    • @anthonyrogers2579
      @anthonyrogers2579 7 месяцев назад

      Sportster S is $2.5k more.

    • @sgt_sledge
      @sgt_sledge 7 месяцев назад

      @@anthonyrogers2579 when I posted this comment the sportster s hadn't jumped up in price and the Nightster hadn't dropped in price. So no the sportster s wasn't 2.5k more. Either way the softail standard is a better cruiser and all around bike than either "sportster".

    • @anthonyrogers2579
      @anthonyrogers2579 7 месяцев назад

      @@sgt_sledge understood.

  • @genegoodwin8925
    @genegoodwin8925 Год назад

    I'm OLD and been riding since the 60's and feel I don't need all the gizmos of the Hightster S. Currently I own a HD Tri-GLide Ultra due to my wife's many health issues. On the Tri-Glide I never use the GPS, Radio, or blue tooth, I just ride. The only option on the Nightster S has that the Nightster doesn't have that I would miss is cruise control. I guess the crusie control has spoiled me.
    I would probably go with the Nightster and then add the travel's package (I don't recall the proper name for the package) but it cost around $2300.00 which gives you the windshield, passenger seat and pegs, saddlebags and a pssenger backrest. I would also add a luggage rack and a round top bag for the rack. I'm old and don't bend over as well asI use to so saddlebags might hold a lot of stuff, the top bag is handier. I guess the top trunk on the Tri-Glide has spoiled me once again.

  • @darichie2907
    @darichie2907 Год назад +1

    I only hope that these new digital displays are also waterproof! Harley hasn't managed to build waterproof analogue speedometers in recent years. Somehow almost everyone has problems with displays fogged up from the inside.

  • @Sarah_sprudel
    @Sarah_sprudel Год назад

    Hey Throttle, would you be interested in testing a bike phone mount?

  • @Heritagejim5339
    @Heritagejim5339 4 месяца назад

    FYI HD has some magnetic bolt covers for the leftover bag hardware. I like that metal velocity stack, nice windscreen. Those mirrors are sweet😎

  • @AyaWetts
    @AyaWetts Год назад +1

    I really wish on their newer engines they'd have made them look like air cooled vtwins, even if the heat sink fins were fake just for looks. There is just something cool about the look, and not so damn ugly like the new engines are. Besides that, the Nighster S is a nice bike.... if it looked slightly better, like the engine, I'd probably get one. The ugly exhaust I could fix myself, but can't do much with the engine.

  • @wally4342
    @wally4342 Год назад +1

    Like what Harley is doing…Profit margin needs to come down to make these bikes more affordable

  • @t_wallen
    @t_wallen Год назад +2

    I’ll keep my 07 Nightster 1275 Hammer stage 4 bike 😇

  • @HaXaW5150
    @HaXaW5150 Год назад +2

    I like the S, but I would take the seat and passenger pegs off. Plus maybe that fairing. I like the stripped down version best, but knowing I had the upgrades wouldn't hurt either.

    • @throttleblip9854
      @throttleblip9854  Год назад +1

      The screen on the special alone would be enough for me.

    • @HaXaW5150
      @HaXaW5150 Год назад

      @@throttleblip9854 yeah, no doubt. I like it too.

    • @johnh282
      @johnh282 Год назад +1

      @@throttleblip9854 I’ll be honest the screen is cool but that screen will never last like an analog gauge all these modern day electronics seem to be very hit or miss just my 2 penny’s.

  • @markmcintosh7095
    @markmcintosh7095 Год назад +1

    The younger crowd isn't going to pay 15,000 after tax license etc. They are 5,000 over priced like another person said. My local dealer has 3 that have been sitting for months.

  • @ed.t.hansen6499
    @ed.t.hansen6499 Год назад

    is this an old vdo or old bikes; the tft data/ screen is the same for both; same data !

  • @Underdog-2024
    @Underdog-2024 9 месяцев назад

    Is it possible to get the display and its features on the special onto the 2022 nightster, also I just wanted to add I think the overall look of the 2022 is far better than the 23 or the 24 especially the tank or should I say fake tank and the front end

  • @fabiopelegrini1738
    @fabiopelegrini1738 Год назад

    Hi. My name is Fabio Pelegrini. I'm from Brazil, live in São Paulo. I don't know how to ride a motorcycle, but I'm thinking of buying a HD. I'm in doubt between the Low Rider S and Nightster models. What do you think is the best bike? Thanks!

  • @ReinaldoVL
    @ReinaldoVL Год назад

    Could you compare Nightster and Fat Bob?

  • @jjaycook
    @jjaycook 5 месяцев назад

    Most of you have it backwards, the Special is a better bike than Harley’s that cost $5,000 more. My 2023 Special is an amazing bike, the first true sportbike for H-D. I can’t believe they sell it for the low price they’re going for. And if you missed the 2023 at $14,999 the 2024 MSRP dropped down to $13,499 and that’s for the Special. Killer deal.

  • @dansmusic5749
    @dansmusic5749 Год назад +4

    I think the Nightster demonstrates what traditional buyers dislike about the "new" Harleys. The pieces that make up the bike are of the mass produced "stamped" variety instead of the heavy, classy, well-made piece look of the traditional bikes. Harley has added a premium price to a bike that is not that premium.
    I was in a dealers showroom today and they had a Nightster S near two left over 48s. It looked kinda nice. The difference was profound, though. I like tech and Harley needs some more, but the dealer told me the new ones aren't selling and I am not surprised. Harley is a premium bike, anything else is a sham.
    The Sportster has always been a smaller Harley that is every bit a Harley. It is a bike that introduces Harley quality, style and type to customers used to Japanese bikes. While Japan has always produced very fine bikes, they represent a different market sphere that Harley should not compete in. IMHO the Motor Company does not have the financial resources nor the market cache to compete long in that realm.
    Why HD can't see that the public wants a more heavily updated traditional American Harley style? That could justify a higher price. The design could be very modern, but it must have obvious and strikingly evident high quality. The Pan America was probably a right move, but that is the only one. The reason they went this route may have to do with global market economics and ESG so a "stamped" world bike is it for now. 😷

    • @spartanx169x
      @spartanx169x Год назад +1

      Last time I was in a HD dealership, they wanted $5K over MSRP. THAT is why they are not selling, and they are not priced competitively. These will the V-Rod 2.0. Not priced and marketed appropriately, they don't sell, then the are discontinued. The paint schemes are atrocious. That Rainbow graphic looks horrible. They picked the worse shade of yellow imaginable and the blue is meh.

  • @eduardom3061
    @eduardom3061 Год назад

    MSRP, is? Other people outside the US looking at the comparison as well…

  • @a99miata
    @a99miata Год назад +1

    no aftermarket for these bikes......Way too costly for HD accessories.

  • @albodoin
    @albodoin Год назад

    I wonder if the clutch and brake levers could fit on a Softail street bob

  • @kenkenyon444
    @kenkenyon444 Год назад +3

    Yeah at least the air cooled sportsters were cheaper? Harley will miss the entry level bikes.

  • @Heritagejim5339
    @Heritagejim5339 4 месяца назад

    FYI HD has some magnetic bolt covers for the leftover bag hardware. I like that metal velocity stack, nice windscreen. Those mirrors are sweet😎 new sub

  • @SCBiker58
    @SCBiker58 Год назад +5

    Both are ugly as sin. The old 48 looks way more polished and I personally would take the 48, not even close. If they built a 48 but with a 4 gallon tank with the peanut shape I would probably have bought one. I once had a Buell XB12 Super TT and it’s a great engine the air cooled sportster . Don’t get me wrong I like water cooled engines and have ridden the PA at Timms when the HD rig was there. Great motor. I also owned a 2008 Night Rod Special that was purchased new at Timms so I like water cooled engines but these are just too expensive and too ugly. I think also the engines would look way better being black.

    • @jayteesgear
      @jayteesgear Год назад +1

      48 is one of THEE best looking Harleys of all time. Hands down

  • @grimeyhonkyracing3938
    @grimeyhonkyracing3938 2 месяца назад

    I really want the nightster but at these prices im limited to the pre-owned market for another bike. It's ok because there are plenty of Roadsters out there to be had but unfortunately Harley will also be pushing potential Sportster buyers into the Japanese middleweight naked sport bike market xsr/mt09/z900 etc.
    Nothing like ripping through the twisties on a sporty v-twin though!!

  • @gregrose6915
    @gregrose6915 Год назад

    If I had to choose it would be the S. Just for the extra stuff. Looks like heated grips also?
    I figured you would have had a vlog out on the rumored new Streetglide & RoadGlide fairing pictures circulating online.

    • @nathanabramyk6953
      @nathanabramyk6953 Год назад +1

      Though the Special comes with the button for heated grips, the heated grips themselves are not stock. I learned this the hard way.

  • @midlife-crysis
    @midlife-crysis Год назад +3

    Good bike….at half the price

  • @borealmetalworx
    @borealmetalworx Год назад

    Definitely like the more finished look of the S

  • @MrAndrew1953
    @MrAndrew1953 Год назад

    About $27K for a Sportster S in Australia,$25K for one of these. Huge difference in performance. I don't know why anyone would put down that sort of money for a Nightster.

    • @lizardsonofanakie
      @lizardsonofanakie Год назад

      I brought most likely the first Nightster Special in Australia. In Yellow was $26300 RRP on Road . As l had no trade in got it cheaper than that . But have put nearly $5000 of Accessories on it. It outruns,out breaks and out corners any harley softail or touring model so far . Pan American and Sportster S is a different story.

  • @Wicked_RotF30
    @Wicked_RotF30 Год назад

    Would have to spend coin on blacking out the S. I might as well just buy the street glide special since it's already blacked out.

  • @michaellyons9640
    @michaellyons9640 9 месяцев назад

    wheres the speakers if u can play music ?

  • @jessegehring4624
    @jessegehring4624 Год назад

    You like what you like but these bikes are in line with their market competition when it comes to price. They are not starter bikes and are not intended to be. I have liked Harley bikes but not enough to buy one. The Nightster s to me has the design, performance and features of a premium bike but retains a lot of the cruiser design and feel. Just put a down payment on one yesterday. Cheers and keep riding

  • @gpcbr1000
    @gpcbr1000 Год назад

    One thing I hate about the nightster S are those ugly ass graphics on the tank. Why can’t it be an option to just get the bar and shield?

  • @markhenry192
    @markhenry192 Год назад +5

    Better to buy a Honda and save 5k or so!

    • @ericknapp3114
      @ericknapp3114 Год назад +1

      haha! I think someone needs to come out with a good exhaust for the rev max platform or the whole project is going to flop. if they can really make it sound great, that would help get people a little more excited to pay big bucks for these entry level harleys
      -maybe…

    • @billwilliamson9842
      @billwilliamson9842 Год назад +1

      @@ericknapp3114 no exhaust can help the pitiful, make that horrible sound from the rev max. Heard a 2 into 1 that was slightly less terrible, but not by much. so high prices, terrible sound, so so stylin, and a used market overly plentiful with use evo sportys at cheap prices. Its pretty clear whats gonna happen.

  • @ZKTheGreat
    @ZKTheGreat Год назад +3

    Man I like this bike but it costs way to much. My local dealer had one up for $16k + fees. So you're looking at spending about $18k after dealer fees etc. Also the bike has so much more plastic parts then the previous Harley bikes. A honda rebel 1100 is $10k and has all these features and more. I think if this bike was like $10k more people would buy it, including me.

  • @WeatherManAP
    @WeatherManAP Год назад +1

    At 2:08 you talk about how the front of the Nightster looks unfinished with the wires exposed compared to the Nightster S. I think the one you had there is missing that front fairing. I have a picture of a Nightster from this past December at my Harley dealer before the Nightster S was announced and it has that front fairing piece.

  • @jackloberer
    @jackloberer Год назад

    i have a 2022 nightster 975 can it be upgraded to the new dash gauge

  • @tangerineRIDES13
    @tangerineRIDES13 Год назад +2

    So harley is copying honda now cuz the frame looks exactly like a rebel.

  • @ronaldlebowitz7409
    @ronaldlebowitz7409 Год назад

    yes the s is a much nicer bike and i rode one at the demo truck and was looking at the tank and could not see how to open the gas cap,must be a new design.

  • @ed.t.hansen6499
    @ed.t.hansen6499 Год назад

    Try starting at 21,000 usd in thailand

  • @jayteesgear
    @jayteesgear Год назад +1

    Im surprised to say, these are actually catching my eye lately

    • @throttleblip9854
      @throttleblip9854  Год назад +1

      The custom one they had those builders do when they launched them were awesome. Just needs some decluttering!

    • @jayteesgear
      @jayteesgear Год назад

      @@throttleblip9854 totally! Just basic tweaks.

  • @jeromeavila3195
    @jeromeavila3195 Год назад

    Great review!

  • @stevenrice8439
    @stevenrice8439 Год назад +1

    Spend an extra $750.00 and get the FTR Sport.

    • @throttleblip9854
      @throttleblip9854  Год назад +1

      I'll be honest been a real struggle for me to not buy a FTR. I'd wanna get the Carbon version though.

  • @GeorgeVrachliotis
    @GeorgeVrachliotis Год назад +1

    Plastic, plastic ... and then some more plastic! At 2x the price of the good, old sportie.. Well done, MoCo!

  • @checkmatwaterford
    @checkmatwaterford 6 месяцев назад

    HD was killed 😢😞

  • @ed.t.hansen6499
    @ed.t.hansen6499 Год назад

    clear that the SS needs the NS handlebars as SS can't be reached even going straight; at least 12" more neededon turns. How can anyone ride this sitting upright; forward controls; for feet and arms must be really stretched.

  • @ed.t.hansen6499
    @ed.t.hansen6499 Год назад

    Controller is archaic compared to bmw roller wheel. Takes such little space

  • @joemann3536
    @joemann3536 Год назад

    if I want a euro machine... yes, I will keep my lower tech 2018 Kawasaki zed 900 naked. It was the last year with less is better, no ABS or TRACTION, LEAN ANGLE computer control ALL un nessassary weight. but thats just me... if I can not use the clutch / throttle and brakes along with engine breaking then I should not be riding in the wind on two wheels.. I still keep a map folded in my leathers and I DISLIKE so-called smart... phones don't see anything smart about them. Still these look OK... THEY need to take a lesson from Indian on a smaller water cooling system. thanks for the review.

  • @garyehrhardt3136
    @garyehrhardt3136 Год назад

    Agree the S much nicer

  • @ed.t.hansen6499
    @ed.t.hansen6499 Год назад

    Has tire pressure readout!

  • @RayfordRaySiegel
    @RayfordRaySiegel Год назад +1

    Notquitester and Notquitester S

  • @ed.t.hansen6499
    @ed.t.hansen6499 Год назад

    power is much different; seating; peg both much different

  • @troy633
    @troy633 Год назад

    Nightster all day

  • @sharkboy_twentytwo8155
    @sharkboy_twentytwo8155 Год назад +2

    As long as those hideous leaf blower exhaust systems are on any of their models, just toss them in the dumpster along with the leaves. Just destroys the entire bike. Sorry guys…..I love my Harley, but cant get behind these. Especially being way overpriced.

    • @throttleblip9854
      @throttleblip9854  Год назад

      Agreed on the exhaust. That's the first to go. Luckily a few companies are making exhausts for them now. I've never bought a stock Harley that didn't need the exhaust changed so I'm used to it by now.

    • @bcbsilverhawk8426
      @bcbsilverhawk8426 Год назад +1

      Nice comparison. The S for the win. With that said both a way overpriced. Take care.

  • @ed.t.hansen6499
    @ed.t.hansen6499 Год назад

    All info foes nit say much?? Compare to a bmw 850gs readout

  • @carissafugle9898
    @carissafugle9898 Год назад

    Full Throttle Daddy

  • @LFGM24
    @LFGM24 Год назад +1

    Both are ugly but that’s just my opinion. No offense needs to be taken. I mean honestly…. The left side of this bike looks like the designer went to lunch and never came back

  • @robd1859
    @robd1859 Год назад

    The nightster special is pretty but it sounds like a busted fart.

  • @KevinFreist
    @KevinFreist Год назад +1

    everything harley sells is overpriced.

  • @OMGGITSDAVID
    @OMGGITSDAVID Год назад

    The graphics look ugly compared to previous years

  • @sonudas4260
    @sonudas4260 3 месяца назад

    I don't know why no one is talking about the logo of nightster s is shit.

  • @bdm3052
    @bdm3052 10 месяцев назад

    That logo on the nightster s looks like shit