SteelDive VS Addiesdive | SD-1975 vs MY-H5 | Short review | Price and Quality comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 95

  • @yafaiish
    @yafaiish Год назад +25

    Was waiting for someone to compare Addiesdive to steeldive tuna. Good job buddy

  • @sebastiannix5033
    @sebastiannix5033 11 месяцев назад +11

    When I built my own Tuna I ordered the case from Ali Express. The seller offered three different case backs to choose from: Steeldive, Addiesdive and Heimdallr (no difference in price)
    So at least the cases are probably made by the same manufacturer...

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  11 месяцев назад +2

      Can you share the link to the store, please? Interesting

    • @sebastiannix5033
      @sebastiannix5033 11 месяцев назад +2

      @@ShortBetter I'm sorry but that was almost 2 years ago. I can't find it anymore. But it was interesting indeed. They also offered a 300m water resistant version. I didn't knew any of those brands back then. So I opted for the Heimdallr case back because I liked the shark logo the most...

  • @andrewlevett4274
    @andrewlevett4274 Год назад +11

    I have the Steeldive I use as a work watch. The build quality is outstanding for the price, it's built like a £300 watch at least. Bought mine for £70 delivered. I guess I prefer the black date wheel and black on the second hand. Not really a deal breaker though.

    • @TheAvalist
      @TheAvalist Год назад

      did you noticed that seiko asked for them arround 599 €? that the drive cames as a mod of (NH35 / NH36 (4R35 / 4R36)?
      that seiko produced in china an malaysia and korea? the case glasses are not "seiko"
      buy a iphone for 1300 €. made for 80 € in china by foxconn. you had written that it isn't a dealbreaker.
      yes it is ! if seiko had made this. the watch cost 2 - 3000 €.

    • @idizzzful
      @idizzzful 11 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@TheAvalistyes the glass is mineral o seiko and on these is sapphire, thanks seiko for you shitty price tags

  • @HarryFlashmanVC
    @HarryFlashmanVC 2 месяца назад +2

    I just got the SD one... VERY VERY impressed

  • @lew9223
    @lew9223 Год назад +3

    Nice video, I picked up the Addiesdive a little while back, lovely watch.
    Thanks

  • @grrfy
    @grrfy Год назад +9

    I bought the Steeldive,just becuse they offered a colourway that addies didnt,but I am kind of regretting paying the premium ovr the addies dive,but I bought the addies 1000m Puck as wel for a ridiculously good pricel so shouldnt be unhappy really lol

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  Год назад +4

      Puck will be in the next review🤣🤣

    • @grrfy
      @grrfy Год назад

      Got it for under £70 , amazing value at the moment
      @@ShortBetter, looking forward to the review
      🖖

    • @grrfy
      @grrfy Год назад

      mine has just arrived,very nice, but... there seems to be something odd with the calendar window and lower dial and the position of the date nubers,I swear this one something is slightly out,numbers slighty to the right of the window, defo noticeable on 8, 11 etcand mebbe the half marker slightly to left of window,or slightly skewed? OR it could just be my eyes, but I really looking square one etc be interested to see yours @@ShortBetter EDIT TO ADD.. alsothis defo has mono colour lume, not the blue bezel green markers /hands,are there 2 versions of this?

    • @grrfy
      @grrfy Год назад

      Yes, my 6 oclock half marker is placed to the left slightly, not in the middle between the adjacent marker dots or directly under the calendar window.Not sure what to do now as once seen I cant unsee it, but is isn't major as such.But it will really annoy me,sigh.

    • @gazzertrn
      @gazzertrn Месяц назад +1

      Just ordered the puck .

  • @dominicsmith7793
    @dominicsmith7793 9 месяцев назад

    Great video, many thanks! Did you notice any horizontal play in the bezels? If I press down on mine, there is tiny bit of play and a click.

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  9 месяцев назад

      I had this issue with a couple of other watches! But these two were good, no problems with the bezel

  • @allthingsgood156
    @allthingsgood156 Год назад +15

    blk date window wins

    • @WATCH-4U
      @WATCH-4U 4 месяца назад +1

      Totally 100%

    • @JohanDee
      @JohanDee 3 месяца назад

      I like the black backside of the seconds hand also more.

    • @NoNonsense316
      @NoNonsense316 9 дней назад

      I'm thinking about picking up the (blue) AddiesDive and spending an extra $17 for a color-matched _luminous_ date wheel. It's not hard to swap out. Just need some basic watch tools: Jewelers screwdriver, case back wrench or ball, hand removal tool, hand setting tool, bulb (squeeze) blower for dust removal.
      I was also thinking that if I'm going to open the watch anyway, I might try to track down a lumed chapter ring, too... Make it into a lume-monster!
      I've seen both lumed mods, plus the most awesome dial I've ever seen, for the Capt. Willard homage, which is also NH35-based.

  • @thomasstratford6227
    @thomasstratford6227 7 месяцев назад +4

    Wouldn’t be surprised if they come out of the same Chinese factory!

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  6 месяцев назад +1

      Everything is possible

  • @GavinKohAquascaping
    @GavinKohAquascaping Год назад +1

    It looks like the Addisdive has a blue AR coating on the crystal vs the steeldive. Can you confirm?

    • @fieldpictures1306
      @fieldpictures1306 11 месяцев назад +3

      I have the Steeldive, it also has a blue AR coating

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  10 месяцев назад +1

      thanks!:)

  • @ShortBetter
    @ShortBetter  Год назад +8

    Guys, the prices are crazy now.. Addies Tuna only 45usd hahaha - s.click.aliexpress.com/e/_DDjgbft

    • @maalemkbir202
      @maalemkbir202 Год назад

      😂 thanks , 50€

    • @Drega84
      @Drega84 Год назад

      Yeah! Bought one too, 50€! Hell of a price! 😜

    • @cherchil
      @cherchil Год назад

      They dont deliver to serbia.. cheapest for me is 60 for addiesdive and steeldive fot 65, which is better buy?

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  Год назад

      @@cherchil they are literally the same, but I would stick to SteelDive. I just trust it more, that's it

  • @tigerbalm666
    @tigerbalm666 7 месяцев назад +2

    Steeldive dial font numbers are thicker.

  • @1mrgoodman
    @1mrgoodman 4 месяца назад

    Excellent. This is the video I was looking for! Cheers!

  • @charleshwang01
    @charleshwang01 Год назад +3

    I think all the part come form same manufacturer but just assembled by their own factory

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  Год назад

      At least the case seems to be identical, but the hands are different

  • @yongsoon3133
    @yongsoon3133 Год назад +1

    Thanks for the sharing, Amazing Review !

  • @ayupmeducks7609
    @ayupmeducks7609 Год назад +3

    I got the Steeldive and also the capt Willard.

  • @TheGutsygames
    @TheGutsygames Год назад

    Hi 5:24, May I know the country of origin for Addiesdive?

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  Год назад +3

      It's a Chinese brand, as well as SteelDive 😊

  • @billienomates1606
    @billienomates1606 5 месяцев назад

    Do they have the same quartz movement?

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  5 месяцев назад +1

      Quartz in tuna case? Not that I know about it. SteelDive doesn't have such 100%

    • @Sokol10
      @Sokol10 5 месяцев назад +1

      Both Addiesdive and Steeldive use Seiko NH-35 automatic movement, almost a standard in Chinese watches in their price range.
      There's cheap versions of this Tuna watch, under "brands" like Lige, Foxbox, QuingXiya... these use Chinese Sheng Long SL-28 Quartz movement, a low cost copy/clone of the cheap (Citizen) Miyota 2115.
      SL-28 was nicknamed by Asian guys as "the tin machine" or "the tin mechanism", due this similarity can replace the SL-28 with Miyota 2115 "plug and play" in those watches.

    • @bigriceburner
      @bigriceburner 4 месяца назад

      @@Sokol10good to know. Thank you.

  • @EinsteinsTrousers
    @EinsteinsTrousers 7 месяцев назад +1

    Every time those hardened caliper jaws came down on the watch, I winced.😖

  • @GuySasha2022
    @GuySasha2022 9 месяцев назад +1

    Addiesdive I ordered dead on arrival 😭 I always had good luck with Steeldive.

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  9 месяцев назад +1

      Open the dispute and get your money back😊

    • @GuySasha2022
      @GuySasha2022 7 месяцев назад

      ​@@ShortBettersent it back had to show videos got a refund

  • @JAYEKAZE
    @JAYEKAZE Месяц назад

    their is subtle things between them but you did not mention any and the best comparison should be a full teardown

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  21 день назад

      It's hard to understand your comment

  • @Gundal66
    @Gundal66 10 месяцев назад

    Aren't basically the same brand?

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  10 месяцев назад +1

      Nope. After reviews + modifying both models, I can say that the case is the same. But the quality of the hands and dials in different. Steeldive is still better. But if you are just buying an everyday watch, then it won't be very different

  • @drebarthelotte5712
    @drebarthelotte5712 6 месяцев назад

    Lume pig says addiesdive regardless of hand colour and date.
    The lume is the big difference.

  • @deviklovecraft3835
    @deviklovecraft3835 7 месяцев назад +1

    Steeldive's hour hand looks smaller

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  6 месяцев назад +1

      They look the same to me, just different quality lume

    • @juanurp
      @juanurp 5 месяцев назад

      @@ShortBetter hows better?

    • @mmadchef808
      @mmadchef808 4 месяца назад +1

      The hands are clearly different. Different size. Lume is a different shade as well.

  • @karmicneurot9829
    @karmicneurot9829 Год назад +2

    How about someone do a pressure test between these different manufacturers. I have a few of these, but I don't really have the same faith in their depth rating that I do in my Seikos and Citizens.

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  Год назад +2

      Fair point. How deep do you dive? If they claimed this tuna is 300m waterproof, how deep most of people dive? 0-30m? And if they go deeper than 30m, would they even use this watch?😅 It's a good question... If the qualities they advertise are real, but do we really need it to be real?🤔🤔 Sorry, the philosopher woke up in me suddenly 😅😅

    • @karmicneurot9829
      @karmicneurot9829 Год назад +2

      @@ShortBetter The issue for me is not the depth per say, but the time under pressure. Maybe 30 meter sustained. I have had budget 200m stamped diver fail while working in water and another fail working in a river. The one big thing that name brands have is a long reputation for quality. We know a Seiko and a Citizen can and are truely rated.

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  Год назад

      @@karmicneurot9829 I understand you now

  • @christianpittiu7091
    @christianpittiu7091 2 месяца назад

    Sono fondamentalmente lo stesso prodotto , a parte la differenza del colore della lancetta secondi che nello steedive posteriormente è nera , il resto sono identici , fa pensare siano prodotti dalla stessa azienda ma con 2 loghi diversi , fa supporre per lo meno , anche se steeldive dipende dai periodi ma è sempre piu costoso parliamo di poca roba ma piu caro

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  2 месяца назад

      @@christianpittiu7091 the cases and the movements are identical. Everything else is different a bit

  • @ShortBetter
    @ShortBetter  5 месяцев назад

    Here are Aliexpress discount codes for the US
    (01.06.24 - 08.06.24)
    Spend 29, get 4$ off - BETTER4
    Spend 59, get 8$ off - BETTER8
    Spend 89, get 12$ off - BETTER12
    Spend 139, get 20$ off - BETTER20
    Spend 299, get 50$ off - BETTER50
    Spend 499, get 80$ off - BETTER80

  • @relojesatiempo
    @relojesatiempo 9 месяцев назад +1

    Cristian , la respuesta es no , el gas que usa Luminox es superior , incluso te cuento que hasta casi molesta en la noche . Ahora un Luminox Navi Seal debe andar cerca de los 400 dólares y el Addiesdive cercano a los 50 , el Lumen del Addiesdive es espectacular ,casi como el de mi Seiko Kinetic Prospect. Yo estoy ya listo para traer la marca Addiesdive a Chile , traer maquinaria Miyota si quieres hacer un upgrade y también cristal de Zafiro para adaptarle , voy a crear un monstruo de reloj , exclusivo para el mercado Chileno y a un precio súper ajustado . La marca me tiene muy conforme ,las adaptaciones las haré yo mismo y también se puede hacer algo personalizado .
    Encantado de responder tus preguntas y como siempre ,muchas gracias por tu comentario y por ver mis videos.
    Ya pronto subiré los nuevos capítulos de la temporada 2024 ,dónde hablaré de varios modelos después de un par de meses de uso .
    Saludos totales 🤠😎

  • @TheAvalist
    @TheAvalist Год назад +3

    1st of all! if you measure from a different amgle - and if it is not a cyrcle there will be a distance.
    the same with the height.
    booth have a35 drive. but after a week i know that the steeeldive with the blackdacte is closer 2 the original.
    at 5:19 whats wrong with your eyes?
    watch the "addiesdive" addies lume is smaller an fat - he steeldive lume is more flat and wider.
    addies crown is fat and goes thin - steelwatch crown is a tube ...
    at 5:25 - addies anti reflecting coat is blue - steeldive not.
    at 5:33 take a lool at addies minute hand - and steeldive minute hand - they are diferent!

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  Год назад +3

      Please make a video review of these models. There are so many interesting details you've noticed. I think you can make it better😊😊 Waiting for the link🙏

    • @thebestfriendsever9150
      @thebestfriendsever9150 9 месяцев назад

      Bezel lume is better on the steeldive and if they wiped the smear off the steeldive crystal on this video you would notice the dial lume is the same.

    • @mrt8096
      @mrt8096 9 месяцев назад

      Which one do you prefer?

    • @bigriceburner
      @bigriceburner 4 месяца назад

      From my viewpoint I see the steel dive the winner. You can see in this video when you pause them side by side the SD has a better sheen on the brushing, as if it were done to a higher standard. I bought the steel dive Starbucks and the black SD Willard which blew me away. I can’t find much fault in them.

  • @bonobo8680
    @bonobo8680 Год назад +2

    ADDIESDIVE rubber bracelet look better imho

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  Год назад +1

      I didn't have one..

    • @bonobo8680
      @bonobo8680 Год назад +1

      Yep, it looks like original Seiko rubber like tuna or skx

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  Год назад

      @@bonobo8680 wow, I will need to try

  • @bernardomotard
    @bernardomotard 2 месяца назад

    Speed 1.25 is perfect 😂

  • @jackylam8232
    @jackylam8232 Год назад +1

    Nice video🙂🙂🙂

  • @ogneyar72
    @ogneyar72 Год назад

    Купил себе такие🎉

    • @alexs8335
      @alexs8335 7 месяцев назад

      Какие ты купил, братан? Я пытаюсь выбрать, не знаю стоит ли переплачивать за Steeldive.

    • @ogneyar72
      @ogneyar72 7 месяцев назад

      @@alexs8335 у меня Addiesdive, работают идеально.

  • @Illsamustache
    @Illsamustache 4 месяца назад

    Why not just buy a real Seiko Tuna? Neither of those options has a high torque quartz that keeps +/-1 sec per month, like my SBBN007 does.

    • @Sokol10
      @Sokol10 4 месяца назад +4

      Price and need. This "clo'mage" use (Seiko) NH-35, a good movement for the price.
      After all what difference make few seconds plus o minus for the typical wrist watch user? The seconds hand serves only as visual feedback that the watch is working.

  • @daddykool9507
    @daddykool9507 Год назад

    Rubbish watches! Why would you waste your money on them

    • @ShortBetter
      @ShortBetter  Год назад +10

      🤣🤣🤣

    • @ThePedroDB
      @ThePedroDB Год назад +16

      If you're so offended by them, why were you watching this review??? 🤔

    • @daddykool9507
      @daddykool9507 Год назад

      @@ThePedroDB I don’t! Just come to pissed you off 😜

    • @steveakka
      @steveakka Год назад +7

      Brilliant watch mate.. you're clueless 😂😂

    • @daddykool9507
      @daddykool9507 Год назад

      @@steveakka 🤮