Why Boneworks is Better Than Bonelab - Comparison Video

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 июл 2024
  • These videos are funded by the community. If you want to support the channel consider subscribing to my Patreon or becoming a youtube member for as little as $1 per month. Thankyou for your support
    Patreon - / virtualinsider
    RUclips Membership - / @virtualinsider
    Discord - / discord
    0:00 Intro
    0:10 Weight Simulation
    3:55 Melee Combat
    5:10 Guns
    6:50 Enemy AI
    10:00 Climbing and Movement
    11:30 Graphics
    12:15 Campaign
    14:05 SPOILERS
    17:40 Extra Modes
    18:00 Mod Support
    19:10 Conclusion
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 415

  • @virtualinsider
    @virtualinsider  Год назад +14

    These videos are funded by the community. If you want to support the channel consider subscribing to my Patreon or becoming a youtube member for as little as $1 per month. Thankyou for your support
    Patreon - www.patreon.com/VirtualInsider
    RUclips Membership - ruclips.net/channel/UCJFSq0-05sUbvgJYV8biODgjoin
    Discord - discord.gg/BBj5zMsHrs

  • @mamefan
    @mamefan Год назад +455

    When you showed the Boneworks vs Bonelab graphics comparison, I was strongly in favor of Boneworks. I was thinking "How the hell does he prefer that fog?" then I remembered you saying it was beautiful in Valheim during fog, and then I read this: "Fog is one of the most common weather conditions in the UK."

    • @virtualinsider
      @virtualinsider  Год назад +110

      Who doesnt love a good bit of fog

    • @mamefan
      @mamefan Год назад +22

      @@virtualinsider Fog is a very rare thing where I live, and I hate it. Can't see a damn thing.

    • @ethans2393
      @ethans2393 Год назад +41

      @@virtualinsider I'm a big fan of fog in games as well. Makes them more atmospheric in my opinion.

    • @deathvideogame
      @deathvideogame Год назад +2

      @@virtualinsider me tbh

    • @libertarianterminator
      @libertarianterminator Год назад +6

      @@ethans2393 fog is cool, but only sometimes. If it is everywhere everytime it just makes me think it is to cover up the bad graphics. When I first got Bonelab I just turned every option as high as I could and I wondered why it looked so out of focus and foggy.

  • @Me.61
    @Me.61 10 месяцев назад +9

    Honestly, they should keep the mag grabbing for pistols. H3VR doesn't let you pull out most pistol mags manually and personally, it kinda sucks.

  • @SpoonDiceMusic
    @SpoonDiceMusic Год назад +59

    honestly i remember my only complaints with Bonelab were that 1, the lighting felt too saturated and bright. and 2, the levels felt more linear, more like its telling you exactly where to go and how. boneworks felt more free, the levels were open and just felt more free. yeah it still guided you somewhat to the next part, but it didnt feel too much like it was doing that.

    • @ree-ih9yg
      @ree-ih9yg Год назад

      I still think the lighting was better than boneworks atleast in the first level in the cave it looked really good

    • @BobBob-io2hi
      @BobBob-io2hi 6 месяцев назад

      I’ve talked to a ton of quest players and they all say they either loved Bonelab while pcvr players all have complaints for the game

    • @DoggyDude_VR
      @DoggyDude_VR 11 дней назад

      Patch 4 helped

  • @cattysentertainment4895
    @cattysentertainment4895 Год назад +91

    I beat bonelab yesterday and I gotta say, I loved everything about it. I think I liked it because I had no expectations and didn't find it until last week. The climbing was fun to me (except the acid pool, but I just used the tall avatar to get past using the side monkey bars)

    • @Hman555
      @Hman555 Год назад +5

      Ye he was a bit stupid at the acid pit

    • @mightymouseblogs7387
      @mightymouseblogs7387 Год назад +1

      Yeah I used tall but the vision broke and oh my god I felt like I was gonna end up in hospital from the sickness and nausea it gave me. I’m also very scared of the lava and such so you fall into anything like that and you hate it just close your eyes for a second or two. Also if the guy breaks the vision for you too just use light and use the barrel.

    • @kaeden5940
      @kaeden5940 Год назад

      @@mightymouseblogs7387you wouldn’t go to the hospital for that, bone lab isn’t for new vr users. You’re supposed to be experienced

    • @mightymouseblogs7387
      @mightymouseblogs7387 Год назад +2

      @@kaeden5940 I said felt like not that I would

    • @1x1boop28
      @1x1boop28 Год назад

      With nothing in your mind to compare it to there is nothing to be upset about realizing you have played for over 2 hours.

  • @Plumtopia
    @Plumtopia Год назад +82

    One thing about climbing you didn't mention:
    In boneworks you can only grab the top of already grabbable material
    In bonelab you can grab the top of any platform, even if it's metal or concrete. This makes pulling yourself up to it without falling off much easier
    Also one thing about the small guy: on the moon if you crouch down and swing your arms back it propels you forward which is much easier in my opinion and actually a fun way to navigate that level

    • @Ashley-1917
      @Ashley-1917 Год назад +5

      Yeah on the moon I spawned in a rifle and used it like a pogo stick- pushing against the ground and went way faster.
      That level was by far the worst level of any campaign I've ever played.

    • @thelelanatorlol3978
      @thelelanatorlol3978 Год назад

      @@Ashley-1917 I feel like once fully immersive VR is a thing, a moon level would legitimately be very fun.

    • @Ashley-1917
      @Ashley-1917 Год назад +2

      @@thelelanatorlol3978 I mean it could totally be done with present hardware. It's not the hardware, it's the map. Better textures, colors, lighting, terrain, normal maps etc would all be a massive improvement. VR is an immersive technology already- we just need immersive software

    • @crimblr
      @crimblr Год назад +2

      also when you pull yourself up in bonelab, you get a speed boost for some reason which can sometimes help in parkour maps but can be annoying when trying to climb onto a narrow ledge

    • @drmikehuntphd7905
      @drmikehuntphd7905 Год назад +1

      I didn't even realize this until I finished the game because they don't tell you.

  • @mackboatwright5875
    @mackboatwright5875 Год назад +65

    The part with the pool of acid and the barrel was hard because you were using the wrong avatar, they give no prompt at all but you’re supposed to use the tall avatar

    • @nedireland-dr6sd
      @nedireland-dr6sd Год назад +2

      exactly

    • @canada8574
      @canada8574 Год назад +4

      But that is part of the puzzle

    • @bossSHREDDER210
      @bossSHREDDER210 Год назад +10

      yeah they dont need to tell you maybe instead of hopping on a barrel you switch to THE character that is literally called "Tall"... this guy is just a fool half the time he was whining about his own incompetence

    • @dizzyndead
      @dizzyndead Год назад +10

      @@bossSHREDDER210 yeah half of his complaints were just skill issues 😭😭

    • @Neutral_Nightmare
      @Neutral_Nightmare 5 месяцев назад +1

      it was pain ful to watch

  • @Judie-Nator
    @Judie-Nator Год назад +56

    I actually really like the climbing in Boneworks. While it's jank and I hate getting over ledges, I found it quite thrilling a fun. I really got lost in those moments.

    • @Themountain6197
      @Themountain6197 Год назад +4

      Boneworks actually has good climbing because it doesn't move your legs for you while bonelab does and while I understand the appeal I like that boneworks let's you have complete control over your body

    • @ImJustLayZ
      @ImJustLayZ Год назад

      @@Themountain6197 stupid the leg movement is so that you don't look janky

  • @Valcuda
    @Valcuda 11 месяцев назад +36

    The worst part about BoneLab, is how, as a player, you can tell there's a ton of potential, and can't wait to see it utilized.
    Yet the devs seemingly couldn't.
    That idea of slowly unlocking avatars would've been so cool! And it would've been a way better method of showing off the system!
    It would make it feel like you're escaping somewhere, trying to make do with what you can find, rather than just running around aimlessly!

    • @FakeCMD28
      @FakeCMD28 6 месяцев назад

      According to developers of the game, one of them said something like that: "We don't want players. We want developers." Bonelab is meant to modders. For mods. Thats mostly why it has official mod support.

    • @squid8420
      @squid8420 6 месяцев назад +4

      @@FakeCMD28when people bought the game they expected something like boneworks, a full campaign with sandbox and every else to the side. They could have added better modding implementation with the better story mode

    • @STEFANGIREA-uv1ky
      @STEFANGIREA-uv1ky 3 месяца назад

      Bonelab has better story mod and better psyhics

    • @squid8420
      @squid8420 3 месяца назад +4

      @@STEFANGIREA-uv1ky it objectively has a worse story

    • @DownFallsHell
      @DownFallsHell 2 месяца назад +1

      @@STEFANGIREA-uv1ky The story mode of boneworks was the best vr experience ever, (imo) and bonelabs was very underwhelming

  • @MrGunzngirlz
    @MrGunzngirlz Год назад +14

    I'd argue that the steel skeleton and mage skeleton count as new enemies. As well as the fireball slinging and turret omni rollers.

  • @froggygun
    @froggygun Год назад +8

    5:43 I dont think they should remove the grabbing. They could just change what grip button you press to grab the magazine and a different one to grab the pistol. If they removed the grabbing magazine I would just feel like its less realistic and it would bother me alot if I couldent grab the magazine.

  • @Favmir
    @Favmir Год назад +46

    Would really love some AI updates. I know it's really hard, but it's such a important part!

    • @pablo-fg3mo
      @pablo-fg3mo Год назад +4

      Blade and sorcery nailed it and its still a work in progress

    • @TenHampters
      @TenHampters Год назад

      @pablo it's not as physics based in blade and sorcery if we are talking about slopes if you look at them they kinda just float up stairs blade an sorcery is a great game but it does cheat a little with slopes maybe bone lab should do the same I don't.
      Ok but another thing i think is bonelabs needs to merge the perfect avatar system and npc modding system like npcs are a little limited and I know the sdk is in beta but I wanna fight character like the iron giant or heavy avatar just have a full boss fight but they do need to fix the slope thing in bonelab I'm OK with npcs not understanding how to get around movable objects but they already bump into the objects only boneworks so if we just increase the strength and weight of the npc body they can move it again another reason to have the avatar stats system bur also maybe make the intelligence stat do something if the slopes problem is fixes maybe make it a feature so if an npc has low iq stat they just fall over and have trouble navigating mazes and obstacles don't know it would add alot of depth and challenge to the game

    • @pablo-fg3mo
      @pablo-fg3mo Год назад

      @Unmei the ai actually dodges

    • @pablo-fg3mo
      @pablo-fg3mo Год назад +1

      @Unmei we're talking about ai here tho

  • @Chdiskenbrnfidkdn
    @Chdiskenbrnfidkdn Год назад +7

    “I know, let’s put you on the fookin moon.” 😂😂

  • @Somegoy
    @Somegoy Год назад +10

    They need to make an update in bonelab that makes vaulting over edges way more fluent. It's so goofy trying to pull up on the stick and not just have my avatar in the fetal position hanging on a wall

    • @mightymouseblogs7387
      @mightymouseblogs7387 Год назад

      As a person who has made most hours of bonelab climbing and falling, i hear you

    • @envor_
      @envor_ 10 месяцев назад +2

      i can flawlessly climb all sorts of surfaces and edges without problems. I say its purely a skill issue but it sucks that most people are having problems with it because I find it really fun and smooth

  • @jordanspringer8
    @jordanspringer8 Год назад +13

    Great video, spot on with Bonelab's campaign. The most disappointing part was how they tried to integrate the level-select into the campaign by creating the hub. The hub is a great idea to have outside of the campaign. But making you try out each level, then put you into the avatar levels was just awful. The tower, mini kart race, and moon levels all fell flat, and some of the hub levels were void of content. Why put that in the story? Why not do what you did in Boneworks and keep them separate?
    I just want to play more campaign-style missions, which as of right now, is not really existent in the mod list. Just more weapons and avatars at the moment.

  • @travismarkz3444
    @travismarkz3444 Год назад +9

    Lol yeah, the whole orb situation was terrible. I played the level again too. Just to realized you had to pull it apart. I've also been holding the orbs I collected in a basket to realize there's no place to deposit it in the beginning.

    • @virtualinsider
      @virtualinsider  Год назад +2

      Glad I wasnt the only one

    • @dan3a
      @dan3a Год назад +3

      Actually, there was an explanation of what to do with the orbs at the very beginning, but it's just a decal on a wall right after the dungeon once you enter the modern looking room.

    • @virtualinsider
      @virtualinsider  Год назад

      When did you play it? I know they added some things after launch to make things alittle easier to understand like a map on the moon level with jump pads

    • @dan3a
      @dan3a Год назад

      @@virtualinsider Ah, I played it like a month ago I think.

  • @Xlxxl1999
    @Xlxxl1999 Год назад +8

    To be honest I am the weirdos who actualy like the Moon level. With the low gravity and small avatar I am able to fly while shooting 2 mp5 like iron man, the mobility + the map size make that level quite enjoyable and I end up messing around more than trying to progress the game.

    • @SalihAhmad597
      @SalihAhmad597 Год назад

      Yeah same I think the gravity and level over all is fun and now with the jump pads I don’t see a reason for people to complain since it tells you what to do

    • @mightymouseblogs7387
      @mightymouseblogs7387 Год назад

      Ok on the subject of the small guy being Fun I agree. BUT IF YOU EVER SAY MOON IS GOOD I WILL THROW YOUR QUEST/PCVR IN THE TRASH ON FIRE. Sorry just had to say it😅

  • @its_alex1621
    @its_alex1621 Год назад +15

    That’s exactly what I’ve been waiting for, thank you.

  • @Choccymilkman
    @Choccymilkman Год назад +3

    “Why a PCVR game is better than a standalone one”
    Seriously though this video is good.

    • @user-kd2op1lp7z
      @user-kd2op1lp7z 26 дней назад +1

      bonelab varies greatly on pcvr and standalone.

  • @itzkolkhov202
    @itzkolkhov202 Год назад +6

    I agree. Boneworks gave me a feeling like none other that I was fully capable of accomplishing literly anything within its world. Bonelab was good, but it made my feel confined in the world and the puzzle aspect lacked heavily and felt more like a limped scraped up last half scoop of ice cream at the bottom of the bucket and given to the quest 2 type game

  • @GameDevGoober
    @GameDevGoober Год назад +3

    So are we not gonna talk about the finger physics with the weight, thats so cool!

  • @hisdarkestfear
    @hisdarkestfear Год назад +9

    My biggest gripe with the climbing is that if you reach far past a ledge while climbing up it doesn't drag you on top as expected. Instead you have to keep your hands on the edge of the ledge and bring your hands to your hips. You can become VERY nimble with the climbing system but it is easily broken by people just using their intuition. I'm hoping they allow players to go prone in the future while climbing over ledges so that the movement feels much more free-form than it does now.

    • @SlushyIsMyName
      @SlushyIsMyName Год назад

      Well in real life you'd grab the edge instead of all the way back otherwise you're just not going to be able to pull yourself up. You don't have anything to leverage yourself, all you can do is hang there. This system is actually realistic which surprised me when i first played it.

    • @thelelanatorlol3978
      @thelelanatorlol3978 Год назад

      People using their intuition should realize that you're superhuman with most characters and so can even straight arm muscleup up and over ledges. full player 6dof is planned though, maybe not for bonelab but eventually.

    • @hisdarkestfear
      @hisdarkestfear Год назад

      @@thelelanatorlol3978 Yea I can see the 6dof being a solution, even using ragdoll mods right now allows for some better climbing moves :)

  • @rl_dvrk
    @rl_dvrk Год назад +1

    What I found out is the reason the fall after standing up is usually to do with the way they took damage to fall e.g head hits leg hits or lower torso hits

  • @grubskies4221
    @grubskies4221 11 месяцев назад +2

    Okay, so I found a way to make bonelab's weight simulation a lot more like boneworks, although it requires code mods.
    So, what I recommend doing is getting a avatar editor mod. Then, with that, your going to want to make your upper strength around 0.5 - 0.7. I found the sweet spot is about 0.6.5, but anything in that range with get you into the boneworks style strength.
    Also, this will make the recoil be more boneworks-style, with the movement you could see in boneworks.
    Along with that, this will make hand to hand or melee a lot more satisfying and realistic. Instead of just tossing enemies aside with little to no effort, you really need to shove like you would with a real person. The sledgehammer quickly has gone from my least favorite melee weapon to one of my favorites, as with this new lower strength you really need to follow through with your hits and it feels much more responsive and generally feels like you really need to think when fighting. You can't just find any old weapon in a level and say
    "Yeah, this will work."
    You need to look at that weapon, think about recoil, think about weight, and decide wether its going to be worth using. You may look at the sledgehammer and decide it's too clunky and will take you too long to properly swing, you might look at the knife and see it as a weightless yet weak option. Its no longer
    "What weapon will be the best for damage"
    It's now
    "What weapon can I use the best"
    If someone with more experience making avatars gave a crack at editing Ford, you could probably make everything feel almost completely like boneworks.

  • @justcallmexen
    @justcallmexen Год назад +2

    I find it strange the acid pool gave you so much trouble, as it was a climbing segment in the late game when you have all the avatars, like the Tall one, who was all about climbing and made that really easy. Sure there is not as much level design consistency, but you are canonically in VR, where that doesn't mean anything anyway.

  • @SoniXperias
    @SoniXperias Год назад +1

    Hey, this isn't hate at all I'm just telling you that most of those problems you had were your fault, like climbing on the barrel to get reach the swingy things when all you needed to do was switch to the large avatar etc. No hate at all, your video is great and super informative.

  • @Ze6rah
    @Ze6rah Год назад +4

    I agree with most of your points, exception is I find climbing ok

    • @Ze6rah
      @Ze6rah Год назад

      most frustrating thing for me was ladders, thankfully there aren't a lot of them in _labs

  • @vergil1943
    @vergil1943 Год назад +3

    Thank you for review. Helped me to postpone buying bonelab for while and continue 100%-ing boneworks.
    It will be awesome if you also do review of Hard Bullet (after physics update pretty much like boneworks but a little bit challenging Ai)

  • @ralphtgepengun3656
    @ralphtgepengun3656 11 месяцев назад +1

    About climbing in both games, the technique is not to grab the ledge but jump and just place your hands and push down then your character should just go up onto the ledge.

  • @jayjayvirtual
    @jayjayvirtual Год назад

    I was wondering the physics model differences between the Bone games after going back and forth myself. Thanks for asking and answering the real questions!

  • @psully212
    @psully212 Год назад +3

    My biggest gripe is they made it seem mod selection hub was going to be integrated into vanilla and why wasn't it??

    • @Podzuldude
      @Podzuldude Год назад

      it is?

    • @eggsalad4305
      @eggsalad4305 Год назад

      It is

    • @motorhead099
      @motorhead099 Год назад

      It is only problem is there just not approving or adding any mods. Unless you want like the couple shitty skins you can get, I was disappointed too I thought they’d start approving sick mods that make the game better but months later and there’s only 2 crappy ones. Really sucks, I’m not doing all the extra bs to integrate mods I wish they would just do there job lol

    • @eggsalad4305
      @eggsalad4305 Год назад

      @@motorhead099 it’s not that hard to integrate mods. Jus get the mod repository.

    • @motorhead099
      @motorhead099 Год назад

      @@eggsalad4305 I should of probably looked into it before I said anything, thought it was like most where it’s a huge pain to get mods to work. But alright I’ll try it out

  • @gh0ulwav3
    @gh0ulwav3 Год назад

    In the climbing and movement section for bonelab, what level was that map from? I don't seem to recognize it and it seems really cool.

  • @anran6425
    @anran6425 Год назад +4

    I got stuck 3 times during the campaign and had to restart. The campaign has some really cool levels but they are way too short.

    • @mightymouseblogs7387
      @mightymouseblogs7387 Год назад

      Yeah I played bonelab day one and got lost as to what to do, abandoned it for like a month came back and finished in a day. Ten chapters in one day. I was very disappointed with the number of hours and gameplay and for the hours we got very little of what we expected but maybe the game will get DLC. I played a Ford only run and while I know the game is a sequel to boneworks if you do ford only and think on the whole game is like a DLC for continuation of fords adventures.

  • @A-guy34
    @A-guy34 Год назад +4

    don't you just use the tall avatar to get over the acid pool ?

    • @MaxMonker
      @MaxMonker Месяц назад

      That's what I'm saying

  • @aperson-rq9hy
    @aperson-rq9hy Год назад +1

    I gotta say this because it bothered me. At 11:10 you were supposed to use the tall avatar, you can get across in about 10 seconds using him.

  • @timmtheguy
    @timmtheguy Год назад

    10:58 I know there is no one answer to each puzzle, but did you try taking another approach to this puzzle? the way that i solved this every time was to switch to the tall character then just climb over the acid. I'm not saying you are wrong, just maybe not trying things out enough.

  • @boogrt_music
    @boogrt_music Год назад +1

    11:05 you did the puzzle wrong, you were supposed to use the tall avatar. that's why it was so difficult

  • @I_Eated_The_Soap
    @I_Eated_The_Soap Год назад +1

    I have bonelab but not boneworks, is it worth spending the extra $30 to get that game or should I just wait for someone to port in every boneworks level/make a decent campaign?

  • @calemcmillan4950
    @calemcmillan4950 Год назад

    At 11:13 you showed the part in the campaign where you have to swing across the green lava type stuff, I just switched my avatar to tall.

  • @uromastix87
    @uromastix87 Год назад +2

    I had a lot of the same thoughts about the game. The pacing was bad. Unlocking one character after the next without getting to really play with them at all. Also, I'm reveling in our shared hatred for the moon level. Walking through those little tunnels with a trashcan lid and a shovel to fight those headcrabs was way better!

  • @Ryan-tn4gk
    @Ryan-tn4gk Год назад +4

    I completely agree. for the 70% I did play I was honestly just confused and thought "this is what I was hyped for?" multiple times. I haven't wanted to go back since.

    • @PinkManGuy
      @PinkManGuy Год назад

      I didn't even finish the intro. Every time I went to grab something my hand would clip through it before resetting into a grabbing position. My hand clipped into a wall and would not come out of it, tethering me to the wall indefinitely. I had to restart, but I just turned it off.
      I say this as a Quest owner but untethered Quest users ruin everything. First Onward and now this.

  • @nipcoyote1140
    @nipcoyote1140 Год назад +1

    I agree with most of your points, but I'd like to point out that I don't think you're supposed to use the barrel to climb over the vat of acid at 11:00.
    I think you're supposed to just change to Tall and then the ropes are in reach. Atleast that's how I did it.

    • @virtualinsider
      @virtualinsider  Год назад

      Yeah a few people have mentioned that. Honestly didnt even enter my mind, I saw the barrells and picked one up. Probably didnt help I literally had a few months gap from getting the key to doing that last section because I couldnt motivate myself to finish it.

  • @twisteddom
    @twisteddom 10 месяцев назад

    What's the song called that's being used

  • @kopow4320
    @kopow4320 Год назад

    This was a MUCH NEEDED video, thank you!

  • @AlissahKat
    @AlissahKat Год назад +5

    Yeah, I agree completely. Physics puzzles are awful, frustrating, and headache inducing. The combat sections of the campaign were great though. But just when the game was getting good (after you unlock all the avatars with these random ass tech demo feeling levels), it basically ends.
    It's like the game set up this amazing foundation, with the avatar switching mechanic, and amazing gunplay, but then never actually uses it properly...
    Btw, at the part where you tried standing on the barrel to get over the toxic sludge, you can just be tall dude and grab the pipes above with your hands.
    Just fighting in the arenas was honestly more fun than I had with the entire campaign, lmao.

    • @virtualinsider
      @virtualinsider  Год назад +2

      Completely slipped my mind I could just use the tall boy. All the barrells instantly made me think to stand on one.

    • @bugnoell
      @bugnoell Год назад +1

      @@virtualinsider lmao is was screaming when you where complaining about that.
      One problem i found was that the only avatar's you would need to beat the game are ford, tall and short. short for the vent in level 13, tall also for level 13 and ford because he's an all rounder and a chad. Everyone else is filler, fast is just tall but shorter and less athletic, light is shit, heavy i completely forgot about and strong is okay but tall still beats him and ford feels nicer to play as. Really hoped that level 13 would make use of all the characters but it struggled to even make me use anyone other than tall (aka best character)

  • @maxwll
    @maxwll Год назад +2

    “Utter tosh” love that 😂
    Great video tho, actually spitting facts

  • @clonetrooper8493
    @clonetrooper8493 7 месяцев назад +1

    11:34 you have to use the tall avatar

  • @scoutpandapal
    @scoutpandapal 6 месяцев назад

    10:18 Getting on top of objects is a million times easier if you crouch in real life and push the thumbstick down at the same time.

  • @ShounenN
    @ShounenN Год назад +1

    I wonder if they forgot to set "Affect Navigation" for the dynamic physics based objects..as they seem to not affect the AI path at all...weird

  • @MrHeadcrab
    @MrHeadcrab Год назад

    almost all these points are very valid but 11:00 oh boy
    you had just unlocked the tall boy avatar

  • @syphus130
    @syphus130 6 месяцев назад

    When climbing in bone Lab, I really found that it’s easier to just grab the very very edge of an object to climb on top of

  • @decimator8278
    @decimator8278 Год назад +1

    For that climbing section where you stacked a barrel on top to try and get access you would need to switch to tall to have an easier time swinging rope to rope to get across. Even then, there is an easier way to get across that gap without having to stack the barrel. Also the funky physics with the rope was a result of having your arm get caught on it. Its frustrating for it to happen, but I wouldn't really say that it is the games fault, rather just lack of awareness as it happens to me too, with the best fix for it being moving the rope out of the way. I think that BONELAB has great climbing (for the VR market, because lets be real it definitely can be better), and although I haven't tried dedicated climbing VR games yet, from my experience it has been the most understandable and easy climbing system.
    The games campaign though? I hate it with a burning passion. I was thinking that with this avatar swapping mechanic, physics based puzzles, climbing, and more physics based gadgets (like the jump pads and gravity pads near the end of the game) would make up the majority of the campaign, leading to something that is a very fun and refreshing experience. BONEWORKS had a really good foundation of a game, and I was waiting for something that would be like what Portal 2 is to Portal: the same game, but with a lot more to build on the concept. Those gravity pads catching the junk in that one level? Why not have a warehouse where you have to fight enemies while moving between gravity pads, using gunfire to propel yourself through the level. It would also give an excuse to use the light avatar as it would allow you to move faster when traveling through the gravity pads. I could give them so many ideas for good level design which is what I was hopping they would do, but they didn't. Was the good level design of the majority of BONEWORKS levels a fluke?

    • @thelelanatorlol3978
      @thelelanatorlol3978 Год назад

      Boneworks set the foundational systems for the marrow engine, bonelab is designed to take what people did with boneworks (modding) and give them a proper interaction system so it works better. I'd wait for SLZ's next game if you want a narrative focused game with the marrow engine because bonelab just isn't that.

    • @decimator8278
      @decimator8278 Год назад

      @@thelelanatorlol3978 That's not the impression that I got from the trailers, especially the gameplay from the trailers, which is why it led to my utter hatred of the game's campaign. I thought there would be a much longer campaign that had ACTUAL campaign levels, but instead we just got a bunch of minigames disguised as campaign levels. I wouldn't have even been that mad if the campaign was still only 4 hours long (while BONEWORKS was comparatively 6-8), but I was mad that it was 4 hours long and shit, with at least 2.5 hours of the campaign just being minigames.
      After watching the Release Date trailer I thought that would be like a mid-game level. NOPE. 2nd to last level. It was also one of the few levels with a campaign-esque level design in mind. That's upsetting. The story can suck my balls like the last one*, I just want good gameplay which this campaign CERTAINLY did not deliver.
      *BONEWORKS didn't have bad story, but the way it was told was pretty bad. BONELAB had a bad story AND a bad way in how it was told. TBH I play neither of these games for the story for the most part, but it is interesting to know the backstory of each game.

  • @man3358
    @man3358 Год назад

    I couldnt even start bonelab because literally EVERY time i tried to use the crane it spawned in bugged. I thought i was doing something wrong before i looked up a tutorial, and i just had to play the first level through the level select screen. It was a bad start for me.

  • @parajared
    @parajared 23 дня назад

    I've never played either but hearing that the Boneworks campaign is included in Bonelab makes me want to get Bonelab.

  • @SpinnyDoesStuff
    @SpinnyDoesStuff 5 месяцев назад

    About the level design, it's smaller because BoneLab was optimized to be able to run in the quest 2, which is way more limited than other headsets, not hating on you, love this, but I thought I would say something. Keep up the good work

  • @thatkiddanny
    @thatkiddanny Год назад

    In that one climbing level with the barrel, you were supposed to use the tall avatar lol. (This time stamp lol 11:09)

  • @superboring
    @superboring Год назад +1

    10:55
    you were supposed to use the tall avatar

  • @atomic...
    @atomic... 10 месяцев назад +1

    Literally bought bonelab yesterday and immediately wanted a refund after about an hour-hour and a half of playing. There's just not a lot to do and the game doesn't tell you where you need to go to progress the story, think if I've somehow exceeded the two hour refund policy on the oculus store I'll just get a guide up and follow that then mod it. Was really excited to finally play it. guess that didn't last long which is a shame as combat is really good.

  • @doopoo1627
    @doopoo1627 Год назад

    People keep forgetting that the whole point of the game is the physics, they have a really good physics engine, and they were like "Lets make a game on this" its not supposed to be fully combat related. The whole point of the game is to play mini games and to mod for fun. They have things like tac trials for people that like combat. They whole point of the game is to make it a mystery, its supposed to be a big puzzle, revealing all the lore while progressing.

  • @dumbo21
    @dumbo21 Год назад +8

    I LOVED the campaign of boneworks and was a bit annoyed at how short the bonelab campaign was. Still lab had a lot of improvements but I would still recommend using a PC to play it if you're on quest because it makes it less glitchy and increase the graphics

  • @froggygun
    @froggygun Год назад +1

    I also do hope the devs update bonelab soon. Its been like 4 months and no full sdk. Neither a improved ai update.

    • @stevensonsteven5965
      @stevensonsteven5965 Год назад

      They said there were gonna have one sometime soon, although I doubt that they would improve the ai

  • @xenoxia
    @xenoxia 7 месяцев назад

    Honestly, bonelab just seems like a test to see whether boneworks could run on quest. Hopefully that means we will get a decent prequel

  • @japanboi6656
    @japanboi6656 Год назад

    On the rope puzzle you were meant to use the tall avatar to grab and climb around!

  • @Ironsnake345ify
    @Ironsnake345ify Год назад

    Taking a tally of all the points you've mentioned here...
    Melee physics: advantage bonelabs
    Gunplay: advantage bonelabs
    Enemy AI: about the same
    Physics puzzles: about the same
    Graphics: advantage bonelabs
    Campaign gameplay: advantage boneworks
    Campaign pacing: advantage boneworks
    Campaign fun level: advantage boneworks
    Post-game content: advantage bonelabs
    Community content: advantage bonelabs
    Overall, definitely see why you might prefer boneworks because of the campaign mode, but for me, I'm seeing more positive points on bonelabs, and I'm more into the mod scene anyway. Out of the two, I think I'm gonna buy bonelabs.

  • @minroad6202
    @minroad6202 Год назад

    11:26 did you sleep through half of the campaign? like 1/3rd of the game is unlocking avatars and putting them into your bodylog on your left arm. you're kinda supposed to switch your avatar there...

  • @SalihAhmad597
    @SalihAhmad597 Год назад

    I don’t know what to tell you but the gokart part was fun and pretty easy and you literally were just given the taller character so I don’t know what you were going on about with a barrel on the acid

  • @DaBarbeaqque
    @DaBarbeaqque Год назад

    "so janky" bro the pole was "stuck" because your arm was in the way

  • @souporwormgaming
    @souporwormgaming Год назад +1

    ok say what you will about either game but the bonelab soundtrack is enough for me

  • @Iron_Soil
    @Iron_Soil Год назад +1

    5:04 hell nah 💀

  • @NaughtyDoggo
    @NaughtyDoggo Год назад +1

    First i tought lol of Bonelab is better but now when i played Boneworks Boneworks is so much better

  • @H4MB0NE
    @H4MB0NE 9 месяцев назад +1

    i feel boneworks was more of a kill everyone game and bonelab was more of a puzzle solving sandbox make your own fun kill everyone game ya know and when he said you have to split the orbs you don’t if you throw it on the ground really hard they split open he complains that bonelab is a skill game that you have to figure out also the climbing mechanics aren’t bad in either games in my opinion they just take some getting used too i don’t know i just don’t like how he hates on bonelab when its a great game. Also he complained about them “ not telling you what to do with the gacha capsules “ YES THEY DO its called level 1 read dont just jump in. And he complains that you have to figure stuff out for yourself like DAWG their not just gonna hold you hand the whole way. he also complains about the moonbase level like all you have to do is grab a gacha capsule it took me like 10 mins to find it i thought it was very cool also he completely ignores the fact that this game is a sandbox game too not just bonelab boneworks too he ignores both of their sandbox modes and honestly sandbox is some of the funnest stuff ever

  • @davenortonsepicprankchannel
    @davenortonsepicprankchannel Год назад

    Remember, if you're ever having trouble with climbing:
    1. Do not grab, put your hands in a flat position and lay them on the thing you wish to climb on.
    2. Maintain your hands position ontop of whatever you are attempting to climb, and then lower your hands in the real world as you maintain the hand position in game, as if you were actually climbing.
    3. Put both of your hands behind you as if you were skating, and you should have succeeded in climbing over an object.
    Tip: Jump ingame AND in real life to gain an extra boost.

  • @ArthurFordBW
    @ArthurFordBW Год назад +1

    The bone works null bodies look cooler than bonelab and I wish they were in bonelab, it's just that transparent materials or wire frame things do a big impact performance wise (for me anyways, I still use quest 1 sadly. I don't have a good computer for games either)

    • @ree-ih9yg
      @ree-ih9yg Год назад

      They probably also changed it since the weird net around the null bodies could get super bugged, but the newer null bodies atleast have cool lighting effects when you look up close

  • @lolxd
    @lolxd Год назад

    11:05 you are supposed to switch to the tall guy and climb that way i dont know how this is such a complex concept to you but literally every other person ive seen play this game has no issues with climbing at all

  • @epickail1003
    @epickail1003 Год назад

    5:47, sorry i'm being picky but the thing at the top says it's boneworks when it's showing bonelab

  • @Neater1
    @Neater1 Год назад

    i'm still wondering why sometimes in specific maps some of the NPCs don't move, anyone know🧐🤨😑😐

  • @sawyergrimm287
    @sawyergrimm287 Год назад +5

    I was in awe and floored playing this game for the first time, I can't imagine how people find so many flaws with it.
    This is my favorite game of all time, it's one of the very few games that actually amazed me (bonelab, that is)

    • @lolxd
      @lolxd Год назад

      same bro bonelab has to be the most mind blowing game ever made

    • @makeshiftparadox
      @makeshiftparadox Год назад +5

      Allow me to explain: bonelab is the kind of game where you look at it and imagine how amazing it'd be if they were able to make a cohesive game around this essentially tech demo sandbox experience (that does have a small campaign slapped on).
      Then when you realize they made boneworks, which is a cohesive game with roughly the same physics you wonder how they got so much worse at designing and structuring a campaign.
      Bonelab is like if you took gmod, slapped a basic underbaked campaign on it and then market it as if it was half-life 2, a.k.a. a story-driven finely-crafted game with an amazing campaign.
      If you were truly in awe and floored when playing bonelab for the first time, that only really tells me you hadn't played boneworks before playing bonelab.

    • @Happyhenzo
      @Happyhenzo Год назад +1

      because you haven't played boneworks

    • @CLD296
      @CLD296 Год назад

      ​​@@makeshiftparadoxeah because not many people even have a pc to play boneworks 🤦 as they are trying to market bonelab to a whole different audience who hasn't been able to experience boneworks and as one of those players, i love bonelab

  • @riddle2110
    @riddle2110 Год назад

    All my homies want this game to be multiplayer without a mod

  • @ruith383
    @ruith383 28 дней назад

    allot of these complaints are just you not thinking hard enough or just being bad, i've have two runs through the game, one on quest and one on pc vr and i didnt have a single issue
    The only thing that i was confused on was how to open the quarantine door which took me about 10 minutes to figure out

  • @stevensonsteven5965
    @stevensonsteven5965 Год назад

    "The barrel kept falling over when I tried standing on it" dude, it's a physics game, if you try to jump on a barrel in real life, it would fall over

  • @CheeseMeat_
    @CheeseMeat_ 4 месяца назад

    14:41 You dont have to play through the modules all the way you just have to visit them

  • @anidiot4702
    @anidiot4702 Год назад

    11:00 You're meant to switch to the Tall (everyone forgets about him) to easily swing from those. I don't see the validity of this.

  • @lllFOXlll1
    @lllFOXlll1 Год назад +1

    10:10 actually just push down that’s it push your hands down and you’ll be up try it in bonelab

  • @Koniving
    @Koniving Год назад

    You should have included the Omni projectors in that test for AI navigation. That's when you'll see some changes. Nullbodies and Fords are indicated to be very similar at the castle stained glass, with nullbodies becoming Fords.
    There it is. Projectors are supposed to be smart unlike the rest.

    • @Koniving
      @Koniving Год назад

      That's why we're mentioning the door won't open you have to kill everything in the room in order for it to open. It technically tells you on the wall.

  • @dumbo21
    @dumbo21 Год назад +1

    Bruh in bonelabs, in most of the parkour levels I am 100% sure that i completed them the wrong way. That level with the train cart and gate to open? I just climb up, activated a few buttons and Blew past the level.

  • @sussknord7761
    @sussknord7761 Год назад

    I had no issues in climbing except the leg part the acid pit is currently very good

  • @LukeyDukey36
    @LukeyDukey36 Год назад

    when you need to get over the green acid you are need to change to the tall avatar

  • @aussieyeet3494
    @aussieyeet3494 Год назад

    i didint beat boneworks to long ago now and i love it everything about it the 1 handed guns when ment to be 2 handed and when you fire it goes everywhere is more realistic making it awsome, the climbing being pretty good and melee like the sledge hammer could be worked on but all else melee is fine

  • @PatNoHat
    @PatNoHat Год назад

    At 14:00, where he talks about bonelab being broken, I want to make a comment on how this happened to me so many times, that I thought that I was doing something wrong. I had eventually caved in and watch a tutorial but it still didn't work. I reset my game and got back, it didn't work. I uninstalled the game and reinstalled it. It still didn't work. I ended up shooting myself through the door with the weird charge punch item thing, but the rest of the game was broken. I eventually gave up untill a few weeks later I saw an update had come out so I played up to there, and it worked. I also saw no documentation of this glitch at the time, so I thought I was the only one that got it

  • @stevenn110
    @stevenn110 Год назад

    the ford NPC is canonically getting more dumb every time another ford goes to the time tower and meets them

  • @lj22805
    @lj22805 Год назад

    I think you should have changed to the tall avatar to get across that acid part

  • @sawyergrimm287
    @sawyergrimm287 Год назад

    me watching someone play through levels the complete opposite way I did: 👁👄👁
    This is why I love this game, so many ways to play

  • @vincentsgames9876
    @vincentsgames9876 Год назад

    you gotta understand that for us quest 2 users this game was a godsent. nothing on the quest store quite matches it

  • @citrusparadox5831
    @citrusparadox5831 Год назад +1

    It is a shame Boneworks never made it to the Quest 2, as i thought bonelab was incredible. Im in the middle of creating content using Bonelab, as its really fast and easy to do so that being said, and has great mod support. Im having a shit ton of fun making my family and friends do missions i set up like "Rescue Saul goodman from the Xenomorph infested 7-11 basement" and other crazy assorted shit

    • @Wizardly27
      @Wizardly27 Год назад

      Quest 2 would not be able to run levels like sewers, runoff, streets, and of course STATION

    • @citrusparadox5831
      @citrusparadox5831 Год назад

      @@Wizardly27 Funny you should say this, as maps of those levels were recreated for the quest 2 - though i would imagine that they were downgraded for limitations

  • @chese_eter
    @chese_eter Год назад

    climbing a ledge
    you should grab on the ledge and pull you self up then pull your self in and stop grabbing the ledge then stand up
    now you've succesfully climed a ledge

  • @JaxsonTheGamerTv
    @JaxsonTheGamerTv 10 месяцев назад +1

    took me 3.2 hours to beat bonelab but boneworks it took me like around 7 hours

  • @bmackVR
    @bmackVR Год назад +1

    What good is mod support in a game like this when the enemy AI is so bad it can't walk up a hill or around a table? It's hilarious how in a few sentences you developed a better level structure and flow to the game's campaign than SL0 came up with in 3 years.

    • @virtualinsider
      @virtualinsider  Год назад +1

      Good point, the AI really needs a rework in this game

    • @bmackVR
      @bmackVR 11 месяцев назад

      @@AZlumpbox pretty sure that’s correct.

  • @Jimmy-xx2co
    @Jimmy-xx2co Год назад

    Your not supposed to climb on top of the barrel. Your supposed to turn into the tall avatar and swing across

  • @parkersworld9326
    @parkersworld9326 6 месяцев назад +1

    you guys forget bonelab has to be able to run on quest not only pcvr

    • @Loaf69420
      @Loaf69420 6 месяцев назад

      I KNOW!! So many people forget that!

  • @darealxbox
    @darealxbox 9 месяцев назад

    tbh SLZ didnt hype it up everyone else did the levels where linear due to quest limits and updates take time fnaf sb was bad due to it being rushed and I RLY dont want too many games to be like that