When Tarkin Demoted Darth Vader back to a Padawan(Canon) - Star Wars Comics Explained

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 31 май 2020
  • A grand conflict came between two of Palpatine's greatest proteges and now one of them would come out victorious as Sidious was put between Tarkin and Vader to choose.
    SWC Shop: teespring.com/stores/swcomics...
    T-shirt Design: / thanksman_design
    Apply and join the team: docs.google.com/forms/d/1xfC-...
    Instagram: / star.wars.comics
    Support the Channel: / bessy
    Join the Discord: / discord
    Follow me on Twitter: / bessyswc
    Darth Vader Explained:
    • Darth Vader KILLED Clo...
    The Forbidden Force Powers Series:
    • The Forbidden Force Po...
    All the Lightsabers Series:
    • What Happened to Yoda'...
    May the Force be with YOU.... Always!
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 230

  • @DarkEinherjar
    @DarkEinherjar 4 года назад +504

    Tarkin: "It's over, Lord Vader. I have the hierarchical high ground."

    • @kindafunnyvoiceactor6438
      @kindafunnyvoiceactor6438 4 года назад +7

      As always in star wars the high ground is usually the answer

    • @DarkEinherjar
      @DarkEinherjar 3 года назад +1

      @@kindafunnyvoiceactor6438 Only if Vader is involved. Against everyone else, it's nowhere nearly as funny.

    • @LordSesshomaru86
      @LordSesshomaru86 3 года назад +1

      Hierarchical ground would've been funny enough

    • @kindafunnyvoiceactor6438
      @kindafunnyvoiceactor6438 3 года назад

      @@DarkEinherjar did you know in the third movie Darth tells luke that obi-1-cannoli taught him well but if you look closer you'll notice Luke has The high ground so somewhere in the first movie obi-1-cannoli told him that trick to use the high ground

    • @buttstick7357
      @buttstick7357 3 года назад +1

      Well in my perspective you have the lava ground

  • @loanan100
    @loanan100 4 года назад +331

    Tarkin: Vader, you're now a padawan.
    Vader: *stabs himself*

    • @jw1415
      @jw1415 4 года назад +4

      😂🤣😂...

    • @JediMasterZim
      @JediMasterZim 4 года назад +4

      @The Keeper of the High Ground Does that mean Vader has to slaughter himself?

    • @tomskowski6239
      @tomskowski6239 4 года назад +2

      @@JediMasterZim Possibly.

    • @rooroo9216
      @rooroo9216 3 года назад +4

      Meanwhile on the battlefield:
      Rebel: “hey wtf why does this stormtrooper have a lightsab - aaaaacccooooughgjfrhehejefnfnsnsjdndaaahhhhh”
      *drops dead

    • @cakearcher1080
      @cakearcher1080 3 года назад +1

      Master Tarkin there are to many of them what are we going to do?

  • @magnol1a_
    @magnol1a_ 4 года назад +412

    I feel like the Emperor did this on purpose to anger Vader, to get him to rebel, because the Emperor once said; the Sith are born in defiance

    • @JediMasterZim
      @JediMasterZim 4 года назад +37

      I always had the impression Palpatine did it just to be a jerk to Vader for its own sake. Then again, you may well be right, it certainly is possible knowing the Sith in general. Palpatine and Vader are hardly the only Sith master-student pair with a very antagonistic, tense relationship to put it mildly.

    • @masterexploder9668
      @masterexploder9668 4 года назад +15

      After New Hope Palpatine was pissed and he was venting on Vader but here it's probably a combination of being jerk, but also testing Vader. Palpatine felt that Vader post-Mustafar never exactly lived up to who he could really become so maybe he was trying to "motivate" him.

  • @rau1488
    @rau1488 4 года назад +561

    Tarkin: "Take a seat"

  • @TotallyNotGRF
    @TotallyNotGRF 4 года назад +127

    "You are in this Empire, but we do not Grant you the rank of Darth."

    • @the9revan933
      @the9revan933 3 года назад +16

      Vader: This is OuTrAgEoUs!!!

    • @jest3r_crusher751
      @jest3r_crusher751 3 года назад +11

      "NOOOOOOOOO"

    • @sync5043
      @sync5043 3 года назад +9

      HOW CAN YOU BE A SITH AND NOT BE A MASTER???

  • @TerryMcQ79
    @TerryMcQ79 4 года назад +113

    And yet Palpatine blamed Vader for the DS1 disaster....the duplicity of the Sith is Legendary

    • @TheGhostDogg100
      @TheGhostDogg100 4 года назад +9

      Well it was Vader's idea to let the Princess escape with the codes to find the Rebels so it is atleast partially his fault

  • @TheSOADMezmerize
    @TheSOADMezmerize 4 года назад +101

    Grand Moff Tarkin: “We stand here admist MY ACHIEVEMENT, NOT YOURS!”

  • @aquadragon_157
    @aquadragon_157 4 года назад +43

    Tarkin: I demoted Darth Vader back to Padawan
    Mace Windu: Take a seat Darth Vader

  • @marcomcdowell8861
    @marcomcdowell8861 4 года назад +26

    In the end Vader was right. The Death Star paled in comparison to the Force. Wilhuff realized that right before it exploded lol

  • @flakcannonhans6170
    @flakcannonhans6170 4 года назад +43

    Imagine how happy Vader was when he died. I can imagine Vader smiling under his mask

    • @d4rksonic474
      @d4rksonic474 4 года назад +8

      Dude, he wanted to see him dead since Ahsoka was imprisoned. He was laughing of hateful joy.

    • @moviefanattic4246
      @moviefanattic4246 4 года назад +1

      D4rkSonic She was imprisoned???

    • @d4rksonic474
      @d4rksonic474 4 года назад +1

      Movie& TV Fanatic StarWars,Marvel & DC Fan! She was suspected of committing crimes against the Jedi temple (which were actually committed by Bariss) and therefore locked up. When Anakin wanted to visit her, the access to her cell was denied - through an order given by admiral Tarkin.

  • @videocrowsnest5251
    @videocrowsnest5251 4 года назад +197

    Tarkin is just busy demoting everyone lately. I bet soon there will be a story about how Tarkin is going to demote Palpatine back into Sheev.

    • @JediMasterZim
      @JediMasterZim 4 года назад +24

      Before you know it, Tarkin will demote himself. ;)

    • @imperialhighcommand8535
      @imperialhighcommand8535 4 года назад +15

      Or the Senate.

    • @masterexploder9668
      @masterexploder9668 4 года назад +5

      Tarkin in New Hope says that Imperial Senate was disbanded so... Tarkin demoted Palpatine or maybe Palps just demoted himself lol.

    • @milesemil1800
      @milesemil1800 3 года назад +3

      "Demotion is taking ovaaa"

    • @zacharyboyd7493
      @zacharyboyd7493 2 года назад +1

      I want to see a Donald trump meme with tarkin “firing” people

  • @k9cobra728
    @k9cobra728 4 года назад +49

    Tarkin: we put you in the empire but deny you the rank of Master and Knight

    • @JediMasterZim
      @JediMasterZim 4 года назад +8

      Tarkin: Keep this up, and we'll demote you to youngling too, Padawan Vader.

  • @themutualfriend5286
    @themutualfriend5286 4 года назад +18

    "The force is all the authorisation I require" what a beast.

  • @0predaking0
    @0predaking0 4 года назад +57

    It's quite interesting, after all both of them even in the books they looks each other with respect and treat some quite in good terms

    • @thewarner2139
      @thewarner2139 4 года назад +21

      It's a major inconsistency in their relationship, but that's because this issue was written by Chuck Wendig, a piece of slime who is notorious for contradicting preexisting lore. He used this entire comic as a poor attempt to trample established canon from both the Tarkin and Catalyst novels.

  • @ketchuphater445
    @ketchuphater445 4 года назад +86

    I’m sorry, when was Darth Vader demoted?

    • @Chinstrap-99
      @Chinstrap-99 4 года назад +24

      Yeah it was never mentioned?

    • @Thetazord
      @Thetazord 4 года назад +17

      I know. Did no one else catch that besides us?

    • @mrsplashman8308
      @mrsplashman8308 3 года назад +5

      He wasn’t demoted to padawan but he used to be on even footing with tarkin and he was demoted to being under tarkin

    • @pinheadlarry7335
      @pinheadlarry7335 3 года назад

      It's around 4:00

    • @Tinman710
      @Tinman710 3 года назад

      Bait and switch

  • @steveawesome9538
    @steveawesome9538 3 года назад +5

    I would have killed Tarkin where he was standing, then the death troopers, in front of Palpatine. Then apologized for allowing my anger to control my emotions. To which Palpatine would have smiled, and then told me to go find Tarkin's replacement, and deal with the issue he had instructed him to deal with.
    Or I would have made Tarkin's life absolute hell, finding new ways to undermine him, letting him do all the work. And then killing him after The Emperor told me to escort him to the brig for his failure. And apologizing to Palpatine for allowing my anger to control my emotions. Which would have pleased him.

  • @jb57551
    @jb57551 4 года назад +12

    3:48 - 3:58 Explains why Vader obeyed Tarkin in A New Hope when Tarkin ordered Vader to release the guy he was choking.

  • @SamsonUno
    @SamsonUno 4 года назад +66

    How can you be a Sith Lord and be demoted?

    • @ere15xkmc74
      @ere15xkmc74 4 года назад +18

      Ask marvel, company that regurally steals people fan arts

    • @gravytube4099
      @gravytube4099 4 года назад +18

      @@ere15xkmc74 that has nothing to do with the question lol

    • @codyrawiri-pettit5526
      @codyrawiri-pettit5526 4 года назад +14

      Because Star wars is finished so they have to 'fill in the gaps' and make random stuff up that is classified as Canon so people can feel satisfied.

    • @ere15xkmc74
      @ere15xkmc74 4 года назад +6

      @@codyrawiri-pettit5526 and thats why only original vader marvel series is canon for me

    • @themutualfriend5286
      @themutualfriend5286 4 года назад +2

      Sith padawan 🤣

  •  3 года назад +7

    I always imagined the respect between Tarkin and Vader to have been hard earned and sincere. What one could show in prowess and sheer will in the Force, the other could show with his devious mind and willingness to go to the bitter ends of horror to accomplish the Empire's supremacy. It shall remain so in my head canon. I have spoken.

  • @meganbrady9789
    @meganbrady9789 4 года назад +93

    Bruh this is literally the same damn video from a year ago with like two minutes added

    • @diegogvelez1342
      @diegogvelez1342 4 года назад +4

      Youre right

    • @foxt.5043
      @foxt.5043 4 года назад +17

      This channel in a nutshell lol. Atleast someone else realized it xD

    • @beepbop9378
      @beepbop9378 4 года назад +7

      Really? Lol I guess that what happens when your whole channel is based around 1 IP

    • @Dragon-hu5ev
      @Dragon-hu5ev 4 года назад +1

      Ethan Smith Mhm, I remember that

    • @turkeyboy5174
      @turkeyboy5174 3 года назад

      Yeet

  • @thewarner2139
    @thewarner2139 4 года назад +24

    It's important to note this annual is often hand-waved due to the inconsistencies it creates with Catalyst, as well as Vader and Tarkin's preexisting relationship from the comics and Tarkin novel. The author of this abomination is Chuck Wendig, a trough-feeding swine who was officially dismissed from writing any future stories for Lucasfilm. So whatever intentions he had with this work will likely remain unresolved.

    • @aza3ful1
      @aza3ful1 4 года назад +4

      word, tarkin and vader respected each other, not like in this comic

  • @danjordan1
    @danjordan1 4 года назад +31

    It's Unfair!

    • @JediMasterZim
      @JediMasterZim 4 года назад +1

      Take a seat, young Vader.

    • @Higglewoggle
      @Higglewoggle 4 года назад +1

      JediMasterZim forgive me emperor

  • @Rafa-ix3eg
    @Rafa-ix3eg 4 года назад +11

    We have all seen the video about the woman vader wanted to penetrate most with his lightsaber. And now there is Tarkin.

  • @LatinoComedian
    @LatinoComedian 4 года назад +8

    Have you ever heard the story about that time Tarkin demoted Vader to Padawan? Neither have I, but I can tell you all about when he demoted some "6 Panel Character", and we never heard from him again.

  • @damienledfurd
    @damienledfurd 4 года назад +28

    How can you do this?

  • @miles_09
    @miles_09 4 года назад +2

    I have really been liking the Darth Vader videos keep up the great work!

  • @JoniukasVader
    @JoniukasVader 4 года назад +17

    This is Outrageous!

  • @TastyTacoN1nja
    @TastyTacoN1nja 4 года назад +15

    You need a ghost writer

  • @basketbotmandem3676
    @basketbotmandem3676 4 года назад +2

    Congrats on 500K!

  • @privatename5788
    @privatename5788 4 года назад +4

    I've always hated this antagonistic relationship they keep forcing between Vader and Tarkin. It's not what we saw in the movie. They clearly had a respect and camaraderie between them, like people who have been working together a long time often do. The only thing these stories do is make Vader seem even more pathetic than the Prequels did.

  • @firepupu6546
    @firepupu6546 4 года назад +2

    Ayy you have 500k subs! Congrats!

  • @kinararazan8222
    @kinararazan8222 Год назад +1

    Tarkin: demoted vader to a padawan
    Vader: this place will be your grave😡😡😡😡😡

  • @kboctv9707
    @kboctv9707 4 года назад +7

    i cant believe you done this

  • @animagi6844
    @animagi6844 3 года назад +1

    tarkin: awful boss/manager
    vader: every underpaid/underappreciated/abused employee in a nutshell

    • @Elyseon
      @Elyseon 2 года назад

      Both are awful bosses.

  • @Lmuussi
    @Lmuussi 4 года назад +1

    CGRATSSS 500k subs !!!!!

  • @chasemorris2621
    @chasemorris2621 4 года назад +4

    someone stuttered when talking about tarkin so they said tark tarkin and i thought for 2 years that his first name was tark

  • @malcolmcurtis5323
    @malcolmcurtis5323 4 года назад

    Congrats on 500k

  • @thecube8583
    @thecube8583 3 года назад +1

    The force really is Darth Vader’s favorite excuse

  • @Tabth3778
    @Tabth3778 2 года назад

    "You are on this council, but we will not grant you the rank of master"

  • @poetscotty
    @poetscotty 4 года назад +3

    The disrespect man if he was a master this could of been prevented

  • @ere15xkmc74
    @ere15xkmc74 4 года назад +25

    Oh 3rd time vader was demoted by tarkin i hate marvel comics when vader goes to the loght side 3 times a week etc.

    • @ggt47
      @ggt47 4 года назад +3

      True, it is annoying ANZ makes him look like a push over.

    • @Artes451
      @Artes451 4 года назад +1

      Next time some toilet cleaner is going to demote Vader to youngling.......what tha hell these idiots are doing with star wars.

  • @joshuapvz2418
    @joshuapvz2418 4 года назад +5

    everyone gangsta until star wars is made by marvel
    4:17

    • @siyacer
      @siyacer 4 года назад

      marvel has been posting star wars videos on their channel for a while now

  • @Black_Mesa_Facility
    @Black_Mesa_Facility 4 года назад

    You call that a citadel *bursts laughing*

  • @umya9971
    @umya9971 3 года назад

    *THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS, ITS UNFAIR*

  • @quigonjin301
    @quigonjin301 4 года назад +2

    Uncle: and one more thing!

    • @McMalarky
      @McMalarky 3 года назад

      Stroomtrooper Fn-12080: and more died jedi like you

  • @14DaveHunter
    @14DaveHunter 3 года назад +1

    This says nothing about Tarkin making Vader a Padawan. It only reveals him demoting a Commander, to a Stormtrooper.

  • @sams.8514
    @sams.8514 4 года назад

    The way he says he did not force choke commander Jordo makes it seem like he can just force choke for no reason

  • @linewater2690
    @linewater2690 4 года назад +1

    I’m pretty sure Tarkin only had control over Vader in Death Star related projects. Other than that, Vader was second in command.

  • @darthplagueis3488
    @darthplagueis3488 Год назад

    Alternate timeline: Tarkin demotes Palpatine to senator.

  • @nomad2629
    @nomad2629 3 года назад

    Tarkin: take a seat young Skywalker
    The seat: take a seat on the ground young Padawan

  • @jaylutz8221
    @jaylutz8221 4 года назад

    Charming to the last

  • @swing2006
    @swing2006 4 года назад

    Tarkin is one helluva commander.

  • @hmaster4522
    @hmaster4522 3 года назад

    Darth Vader probably had a party with the 501st when tarkin died

  • @hawk7256
    @hawk7256 4 года назад +2

    WHO DOES TARKIN THINK HE IS TRYING TO COMMAND VADER! I’ve always hated Tarkin and he’s so annoying

  • @slaydad_3904
    @slaydad_3904 3 года назад

    Anyone else have a totally different video start playing in the end of it about the liberation of mon Cala

  • @doctorigp
    @doctorigp Год назад

    A few people here have been talking about how it made more sense for Tarkin an Vader to have a respectful relationship and I agree with this. One of my biggest problems with Vader, specifically in disney's writing, was that he just seemed like a mindless beast that wanted to kill everyone for even the slightest reasons. Thus, it's impossible for him to have any allies in the empire because he'll just kill them for even the most minor reasons. I much prefer the idea of him as a cold hearted yet logical character. If he thinks you're incompetent he'll kill you on the spot, but he's rational and has respect for those who have proven their worth.

  • @jw1415
    @jw1415 4 года назад +5

    Poor Vader can't catch a break😂🤣😂😂

  • @dekuboidonut4552
    @dekuboidonut4552 4 года назад +14

    I in they end Tarkin force slapped vader

  • @fpshightide
    @fpshightide 4 года назад +1

    Interesting interesting

  • @LooNey2357
    @LooNey2357 4 года назад +3

    Anakin will never be a master

  • @I86282
    @I86282 3 года назад +1

    Kind of makes you think. Darth Vader lead the death Star blow up on purpose.

  • @Lucas-hz4kl
    @Lucas-hz4kl 4 года назад

    Which comic is this?

  • @Dragon-hu5ev
    @Dragon-hu5ev 4 года назад +1

    2:06 Is it just me or does Vader looked confused as hell

  • @CharlotteGamesMC
    @CharlotteGamesMC Год назад

    When you realize Vader is a higher rank than Tarkin: what…?

  • @commanderfox2919
    @commanderfox2919 4 года назад +1

    yes

  • @mr.juniii5523
    @mr.juniii5523 3 года назад

    Well said vader the force helps him enter a strong hold room

  • @ItzJcey
    @ItzJcey 4 года назад +1

    i couldve swore i saw a video of palpatine demoting vader to anakin skywalker and now tarkin demoted him to padawan....wtf

  • @ayol1011
    @ayol1011 4 года назад

    Which star wars comic is this?

  • @rachelprighel4409
    @rachelprighel4409 3 года назад +1

    Good

  • @mr.lemons2309
    @mr.lemons2309 3 года назад

    At 2:08 the height difference between tarkin and Vader and tarkin still stands up to Vader

  • @justinkahm5936
    @justinkahm5936 4 года назад +2

    Certain things in the third canon Thrawn novel seem to contradict these events a bit.

  • @slanphere
    @slanphere 4 года назад +2

    The emperor should've demoted train

  • @Kaito-1412-
    @Kaito-1412- 4 года назад +1

    Funny...Tarkin respected Anakin and liked him, but Vader not

  • @luckylanno
    @luckylanno 4 года назад

    No wonder Stormtroopers are so useless. They're all depressed former commanders.

  • @SethBrundleify
    @SethBrundleify 4 года назад

    Tarkin and Dooku are old friends.

  • @pissedinyourcornflakes2939
    @pissedinyourcornflakes2939 4 года назад

    How are Imperial Officers so incompetent, like surely that had to start at the bottom lol

  • @ncc1701chris
    @ncc1701chris 3 года назад +1

    Enough of this..
    Vader! Release him.
    As you wish.

  • @takodawithers5637
    @takodawithers5637 4 года назад +1

    And because Tarkin didnt tell Vader about Project Stardust (i.e. also included that shaft to destroy the enitre station) the Death Star 1 was destroyed. So blame Tarkin. I also have never liked tarkin so😂

  • @medson71
    @medson71 4 года назад +1

    As canon as the other canon comics that had no impact in the movies...
    As a wise nameless stormtrooper once said, move along, move along...

  • @AverageAwesomeDude
    @AverageAwesomeDude 3 года назад

    so this is not the first video featuring tarkin where someone brutally murders someone for an argument but it turns out it was all in his head. This video was vader, the other was tarkin going all shirtless and beating an officer to death

  • @Idkidkidk716
    @Idkidkidk716 Год назад

    Honestly if tarken was killed by Vader perhaps the civil war would have ended differently. Instead of wasting resources on the Death Star perhaps the resources would be invested into a Star fighter better at dealing with rebels

  • @Thetazord
    @Thetazord 4 года назад

    The demotion to padawan was never mentioned at all.

  • @ddoublejentertainment6415
    @ddoublejentertainment6415 4 года назад

    I would of take this demotion learn from my failure then survive the battle and then show Tarkin the mistake he made by demoting me

  • @nerdzunite2679
    @nerdzunite2679 3 года назад +1

    Nothing in this video says Tarken "demoted" Vader to a Padawan.

  • @hansdampf640
    @hansdampf640 Год назад

    ?
    it was absolut clear who´s in charge between them when the first star wars movie came out...

  • @liquidsleepgames3661
    @liquidsleepgames3661 4 года назад +8

    Tarkin now. Back to class young padawan.
    Vader:heavy breathing, what?
    Class young padawan go to it.
    This is outrageous how can i be a sith and not be a lord.

  • @VarjoFilosofi
    @VarjoFilosofi 4 года назад

    How Tarkin could be so sure that Darth Vader just wouldn't straight up murder him? Even if he knew he had Palpatine supporting him, it was foolish to antagonize Vader like that. Was he straight up told by Palpatine to do that or was he just insane enough to do it himself?

  • @MrMisterDerp
    @MrMisterDerp 4 года назад

    VADER! Enough!

  • @jamielishbrook2384
    @jamielishbrook2384 Год назад

    Why the choppy editing on this one?

  • @hampy9294
    @hampy9294 4 года назад +1

    Where the comics the battle of jabiim no-2

  • @nathanaelpineda8049
    @nathanaelpineda8049 2 года назад

    The fuk is three death troopers gonna do to Darth Vader
    Death Troopers:fuk

  • @elxr9434
    @elxr9434 2 года назад

    seems like he gets demoted a lot

  • @taemien9219
    @taemien9219 3 года назад +3

    This comic takes the relationship between Vader and Tarkin into something it shouldn't. In Clone Wars, Anakin and then Captain Tarkin got along quite well. Anikan admired Tarkin's leadership and even agreed that green Jedi shouldn't lead veteran soldiers. I don't see any reason why that relationship would change after he became Vader. As it was shown in A New Hope, Vader didn't argue with Tarkin or show any anger towards him.

    • @justinhamm6539
      @justinhamm6539 2 года назад

      I agree. It made Tarkin look petty, but the main arc was to show that Vader set events which lead to Erso's treason and the destruction of DS1. It could've been more subtle; a longer series of events based on Vaders respect, but lack of trust in Tarkin. Including Palpatine, they were a triumvirate of alpha killers, and it should be portrayed as a civil agreement in Mexican standoff sort of way.

  • @Stellar001100
    @Stellar001100 3 года назад

    Vader still had the last laugh I guess.

  • @BrickYoda5555
    @BrickYoda5555 4 года назад +4

    Grand Moff Windu

  • @DarthVader-Legend
    @DarthVader-Legend Год назад +1

    I Don't Care HE CANT DEMOTE ME The Emperor Wants to make me MAD HE DID

  • @jeffreyballinger133
    @jeffreyballinger133 4 года назад

    We all know Vader is a badass. But dang... Look up Tarkin and his definition would be " No f**ks given."

  • @dominicsansoni1611
    @dominicsansoni1611 3 года назад

    Good video but I was waiting for Tarkin to demote Vader to Padawan never happened

  • @briancolella6045
    @briancolella6045 4 года назад

    03:31
    06:50
    02:35

  • @emprodabob
    @emprodabob 3 года назад

    I feel Vader would have killed Tarkin for that... Foreal