Kaname True enough. But singers can be very good at pointing out faults they have themselves. Plus in this instance Scotto manages to illustrate how one repeats the same pitch and not something to the south of it. With all that screaming it’s amazing Scotto lasted as long as she did. I think it was 1952 when she sang with Tebaldi in ‘La Wally’ at the Scala.
@@LalaMontenegro1 She missed her calling the poor dear. Should of retired early like The great lyric Soprano Cotrubas & became a very excellent voice instructor. Cotrubas never sang flat/ off key etc. Scottos face lift looks great 💆💙.
@@ransomcoates546 , in teatro aveva una voce stridula negli acuti e non era tutt'oro. Butterfly fu una grande delusione, la bambolina giapponese...proprio il contrario di ciò che Cio Cio San e'. In Norma, a Firenze, colo' a picco. Mi dispiace e che Anna Moffo non abbia dai mai dato masterclasse. Avrebbe detto tutto il contrario. Cordiali saluti. ( La Wally fu 7 dic 1953)
@@VeronicaBellSoprano певицы великие небыли никогда педагогамт Вокала, они обьясняли, и ты сама,, если есть мозги,,, дорабатывать должна, и это справедливо
И что эта за переводцица, агресивый голос перебивает даже страшно слушать кто ее допустил как она давит когда новорит по русский ей прокурором илм судьей роботать,,, или??
Sono due soprani diversi... Tenga presente che la Freni fu in voce fino a 60 anni e cantava opere intere, la Scotto è declinata piuttosto presto e tenga presente che io preferivo la scotto come timbro... Ma non poteva fare tutto come purtroppo ha fatto
Young singers are better off with a good voice coach. Young singers are usually intimidated by famous singers turned teachers. Famous singers don’t necessarily make good teachers.
La Scotto semble horrifiée par cette élève, mais c'est à juste titre. Les masterclass données avec des personnalités de ce calibre ne devraient pas être destinées à des chanteurs d'un si bas niveau technique et culturel.
La technique russe place toujours les voix plus « basse » et plus sombre, avec moins d’harmoniques aigus. Cela n’empêche pas toutefois les chanteuses d’avoir de beaux aigus. La preuve: Netrebko, qui, malgré une voix de paquebot, a pu chanter des rôles légers au tout début. Mais la technique ,le timbre et la couleur de sa voix sont indubitablement slaves. Cela ne plaît pas aux chanteuses italiennes devenues professeurs, Scotto et Freni par exemple. Ce qu’elles essaient de montrer à ces belles voix russes n’a pas grand chose à voir avec leur technique.
Master classes are basically a big waste of time. It just brings disability/ publicity & inflates the retired opera singers ego $$$ find yourself a good voice teacher end of discussion.
but tbh Scotto teaches pretty well here, unlike all those American “masters” who teach singers how to act/feel the role/express their emotions while their basic vocalization is horrendous
@@TarotAstrologerTHOMAS Why are you targeting American singers? I’ve been to many master classes. They are all pretty similar to Madame Scotto master class.
Tough but totally correct and accurate. RIP Renata. Grazie per tutto!
Grande Signora Scotto! tutto vero ciò che dice....grazie
Scotto is even more beautiful as an older woman than she was when younger.
She really aged beautifully!
For me she is a real beutiful woman, you can see what she did during her live. And as she worked on her skills.
Che gran signora, professionale, dolce e paziente
Grande cantante e grande maestra
Очень важное замечание!!
SCOTTO, Bellissima!
Scotto douceur 😊🍧🍨🌹🌸
RIP 🌹🌹🌹
Loving the translator.. x
Maravilhosa
Grande Grande Grande
Sono due do, Renata, ma ti adoriamo lo stesso
What a gracious way to tell the student she sings out of tune.
Well, she was rather infamous for being delusional and off key in her hey day... 😅😂
Kaname True enough. But singers can be very good at pointing out faults they have themselves. Plus in this instance Scotto manages to illustrate how one repeats the same pitch and not something to the south of it. With all that screaming it’s amazing Scotto lasted as long as she did. I think it was 1952 when she sang with Tebaldi in ‘La Wally’ at the Scala.
@@LalaMontenegro1 She missed her calling the poor dear. Should of retired early like The great lyric Soprano Cotrubas & became a very excellent voice instructor. Cotrubas never sang flat/ off key etc. Scottos face lift looks great 💆💙.
@@ransomcoates546 , in teatro aveva una voce stridula negli acuti e non era tutt'oro. Butterfly fu una grande delusione, la bambolina giapponese...proprio il contrario di ciò che Cio Cio San e'. In Norma, a Firenze, colo' a picco. Mi dispiace e che Anna Moffo non abbia dai mai dato masterclasse. Avrebbe detto tutto il contrario. Cordiali saluti. ( La Wally fu 7 dic 1953)
Renata mantém uma voz linda e presença irradiante. Verdadeira Prima Dona e eterna 👏👏👏👏
Uma vos estrana. 🐱🐭 la pobre Prima nulla.
Encantadora la Scotto. Todo una señora.
Adesso la Scotto dà una gomitata alla traduttrice per dirle di levarsi dal....
Переводчица ругается, совсем девушку запугала))
This girl sings good
RIP
Quando non sanno cosa dire si fissano su intonazione e portamento anche quando è tutto giusto, cosa si fa per dare lezioni a prezzi esorbitanti
The tongue should stay where the i vowel is. If you open to the E it will be flat.
Падает позиция и не поёт в линию. Красивый голос
Конечно не понимает! Скотт была великая певица,но объяснить как надо делать - это другая профессия. Она объясняет что, но не объясняет как.
@@VeronicaBellSoprano да. Потому что подключая челюсть в произношение мы и роняем позицию. Но тут коеечно надо комплексно работать
@@VeronicaBellSoprano певицы великие небыли никогда педагогамт Вокала, они обьясняли, и ты сама,, если есть мозги,,, дорабатывать должна, и это справедливо
И что эта за переводцица, агресивый голос перебивает даже страшно слушать кто ее допустил как она давит когда новорит по русский ей прокурором илм судьей роботать,,, или??
Che classe, altro che la Freni!
Sono due soprani diversi... Tenga presente che la Freni fu in voce fino a 60 anni e cantava opere intere, la Scotto è declinata piuttosto presto e tenga presente che io preferivo la scotto come timbro... Ma non poteva fare tutto come purtroppo ha fatto
Rip Renata Scotto.
Young singers are better off with a good voice coach. Young singers are usually intimidated by famous singers turned teachers. Famous singers don’t necessarily make good teachers.
Переводчик на русский, такая испуганная)
Era cursi de joven y sigue cursi. Pero vamos, el oído le funciona. ¿No había una estudiante que afinara un poquito mejor?
La Scotto semble horrifiée par cette élève, mais c'est à juste titre. Les masterclass données avec des personnalités de ce calibre ne devraient pas être destinées à des chanteurs d'un si bas niveau technique et culturel.
I missed the part in the video that shows her "low cultural level". 🤔
La technique russe place toujours les voix plus « basse » et plus sombre, avec moins d’harmoniques aigus. Cela n’empêche pas toutefois les chanteuses d’avoir de beaux aigus. La preuve: Netrebko, qui, malgré une voix de paquebot, a pu chanter des rôles légers au tout début. Mais la technique ,le timbre et la couleur de sa voix sont indubitablement slaves. Cela ne plaît pas aux chanteuses italiennes devenues professeurs, Scotto et Freni par exemple. Ce qu’elles essaient de montrer à ces belles voix russes n’a pas grand chose à voir avec leur technique.
У русакой школы не хваате техники. Позиция низкая , недостаточно потока воздуха и низкой опоры.
The Russian school has also included Wagnerian singers. This discussion deserves its own site
Она учит колхозницу? Она вообще понимает, что от неё хочет Скотто?
а ее педагоги? понимали? азы ведь
Beh...con maestre così...che c è da imparare?
Mmmmmmmmmm
0:14-0:23 not impressed...lol
Well the advice I would give this girl don't quit your day job. The look on Scottos face is somewhat surreal LOL
Damn! Scotto is nicer than I would be. This chick is doing everything wrong. Dreadful.
That translator is annoying 😅
Total lies and profanation! It's a shame for such great artists to deceive young singers who so need practical advice and not imitation actions !?
Master classes are basically a big waste of time. It just brings disability/ publicity & inflates the retired opera singers ego $$$ find yourself a good voice teacher end of discussion.
but tbh Scotto teaches pretty well here, unlike all those American “masters” who teach singers how to act/feel the role/express their emotions while their basic vocalization is horrendous
Who asked? 🙄
Le sta dicendo proprio i consigli giusti. Era intelligente anche come insegnante
@@TarotAstrologerTHOMAS
Why are you targeting American singers? I’ve been to many master classes. They are all pretty similar to Madame Scotto master class.
This is great teaching and valuable resource that can supplement your singing studies. What are you talking about??
Scotto douceur 😊🍧🍨🌹🌸