The whole fraternal twin sibling\brother\sister inside joke today was on point. And I particularly lost it at the "I must" and "I must not" tattoos implying "you two brothers have some extremely different philosophies". I genuinely a spit take.
This is the best edited video in 3 years, just them laughing about their own nuances and jokes while coming up with the most random and comical things, I was dying of laughter, make them longer and just leave all these little humor side run offs in, we don’t even need the quiz. 😂
Or post 2 videos. One like this, edited down to be a decently short video (is 30+ considered short?). Then a longer edited one that's an extended version with all the side track and jokes. But still edited down with effects and cutting out what isn't needed.
C'mon! Y'all don't remember Willderoy Slinkheart, Gilderoy Lockhart's identical cousin? He wrote "Thursday Night with a Thestral"!! His autobiography focusing on his relationship with his cousin "Wagical We" was bestselling!
@@JustTommyBoy No no- your thinking of gilderoy their distingushig fetuere is that wilderoys memory charm DID NOT backfire and he acctually obliviated won measley and parry hotter!
@@neilmartinoconnor Even without seeing the basilisk, you'd think they'd at least see Ginny writing on the walls in blood. The only possible answer is that there aren't portraits on every wall or in every corridor. And Tom was smart enough not to have the messages written on walls where portraits could see it being done.
Why didn't they ghosts? Why didn't Myrtle, who we know has been in the pipes. It's because the basilisk was hibernating. He can only stop hibernating when the heir allows it
They could honestly make a 50 question mega quiz about St. Mungo's and still wouldn't cover everything that could be asked about a place that is visited for 1 chapter
Ok hot take: Harry should’ve been a DADA professor when he graduated. He was good at teaching it, as evidenced by everyone flourishing under his guidance. He would be the type of man to want to give kids a home and make them feel supported and loved which is great for a teacher especially somewhere where the professors do more than just teach. The curse would be broken after Voldemort died. Also, I feel like Harry would get tired of fighting bad guys and hunting them down and want some peace and quiet in his life.
Grats Ben!! It's nice to see the underdog win for once... has anyone else noticed that when J even comes close to losing, he always tries to justify how he was almost right!? 😝
I've noticed that when it's something that you are normally hyped up as the best for, like people always talk about how good you are at something, then you lose to family or close friends who are usually the ones doing the hyping, it is really hard to accept. At least it is that way for me and I've been aware of it and tried to improve on that character flaw. I am completely fine at losing at things and couldn't care less most of the time, but when everyone is always like "he's sooo freaking good at this" or "I'm definitely going to lose because he always wins at such and such", it is like the pressure is on and if I lose it's almost like a personal attack. I bet it's similar with J. He is always "supposed" to win, so when he doesn't it's hard to accept. I know that doesn't excuse it. It's a bad trait to have, but I think it is more of a subconscious thing that you can do without realizing you are. It took me awhile to realize that I could do that. Having said all that, I also think he had a point this time. He lost by two. One of those were him saying Deepest Blue, instead of Midnight Blue on a robe color. Another point Ben literally would not have gotten because he was stuck, and J slipped up and gave him the answer. With how often J wins vs Ben, the gracious thing would have been to drop it and let Ben have this, but he did have a point. I just think that goes back to what I said above and how he probably doesn't even realize how much it affects him.
As an underdog supporter seeing Ben win was an incredibly rewarding feeling, beyond proud. However, whatever happens I am always a supercarlinbrothers supporter and you always do a whole lot better than me I need to refresh my brain on those books but keep up the good work and the J Vs Ben videos they will always be my favourites 🫶
I got like two thirds of the way through before caving and looking through the comments to see if he won since he was in the lead. Yasssss! It's such a joy to see Ben know things that J doesn't remember.
Also J is kind of a sore loser this time around. Like you got the midnight blue question wrong. Ben has gotten even closer before and not been given the point and didn’t harp on about it
Right, who doesn't remember that touching scene? And Neville is just leading him out of the room, whispering, "Gran, she did it again, call the Obliviators..."
I knew Mrs Weasley saw Fred and George because the boggart showed them dead together, which means even in her worst nightmares she never imagined one twin would die and the other would live….
ben losing the answer on the second question and being able to pull it back is a good sign for team ben! normally he just stares at the desk for a few minutes then gets mad cause he shouldve known it
With these new findings, do I hear a theory about Willdelory Slinkhart's life? His rivalry with the more astounding brother Gildelory Lockhart? How people assume they are identical but they are not, as midnight blue could never be identical to deepest blue!
I’ve been binging these recently and after watching a new video by another one of my favorite creators this was an amazing treat. Thank you guys for making my day better!
I have finally started Reading the Books at the start of this year, after being a Harry potter fan as Long as i can remember. These videos made me actually start Reading then.
Congratulations Ben! Thank you Kat, Riley and Ethan for all of your hard work to keep the Carlins Super! Happy Holidays everyone! ⛄🎄🎁🎉 Stay warm and safe!
6:28 my brother is Robert and I am 10 years older then him. So his entire childhood I referred to him as Robbie Dobs, Robbie Dobby, Rob Dob or Dobby Bobby. At like age 17, he kindly asked me to stop. I still call him rob dobs to his face, when no one else is around… ❤️
This was hilarious, as always - can’t wait to find out more when it comes to Willderoy Slinkheart and his bestselling books (Wagical We and Tea with a Thungarian Thorntail) 🤣
"...will get I Must Not Tell Lies tattooed on their hand." Me: And so it was spoken, so it was writte-uh....tattooed!!!! "Just kidding." Also me: But....but it was spoken.
Fun fact, in my copy of POA, there is a typo where Adalbert Waffling is listed as the author of A History of Magic. I was so confused when I got to later books and they said Bathinda Bagshot was the author.
Same. I'm currently reading deathly hallows and there is an interview with Rita Skeeter in the prophet about her Dumbledore biography. The name of the interviewer is mentioned only twice and she never gets much attention so her name would be a really difficult question for them
I have an idea also for a what if. What if Petunia had also been a Witch like Lily? How would Harry's life have been different? Would Dumbledore have been able to influence and manipulate Harry's life as much if Petunia was a witch and raised him?
Someday they will have a quiz (possibly april fools) for their own creations Ike Lazerbeam Wilderoy And many more I don't remember or haven't been created yet
Bring it! I was so proud during the last trivia. I got Dudley's four pound tongue, right. It was all downhill from there, but I think that's the only one I've ever been able to get that you guys didn't. So, thanks for letting me feel good about myself for twenty seconds.
I thought J said that it was tricky to answer who told them about the Room of Requirement because technically Dumbledore told Harry about it before (which is how Harry confirms to Hermione that it exists)
Dude I was just watching the fifth movie and I caught a moment I've never caught before, and it absolutely broke me.... In the scene where Harry and Cho kiss, just before that when all of the DA is leaving through the door, you see poor Ginny looking back at Harry going to Cho. And her face man, that poor girl...
A fun "punishment" game would involve, say, a punishments wheel. Nothing bad but it could be something like "do ten push-ups", "eat a bean", or "do a dare". Or you could do something like gamble with candy/chocolate/fake coins and keep adding to the pile until someone loses a point at which case the winner gets the lot.
3:19 it depends if you're from the south or north of england, im from up north so we pronounce 'auld' the exact same as 'old', the southern preference is to elongate the vowel so its more like 'grimawld' (dont ask me how the scots or welsh pronounce it lol)
Mulan is next!? That’s so cool! Can’t wait to see the design for her candle!!! Also, what ever happened to the art contest in October? When will we see what art goes on the wall?
The whole fraternal twin sibling\brother\sister inside joke today was on point.
And I particularly lost it at the "I must" and "I must not" tattoos implying "you two brothers have some extremely different philosophies".
I genuinely a spit take.
Cool pfp 😅
An ”I must not tell” tatoo would be something for Hagrid… 😏
shouldn’t ave told you that
"Shouldn't have said that I should not have said, I shouldn't have said that"
This is the best edited video in 3 years, just them laughing about their own nuances and jokes while coming up with the most random and comical things, I was dying of laughter, make them longer and just leave all these little humor side run offs in, we don’t even need the quiz. 😂
Or post 2 videos. One like this, edited down to be a decently short video (is 30+ considered short?). Then a longer edited one that's an extended version with all the side track and jokes. But still edited down with effects and cutting out what isn't needed.
I think the one where it’s showing the Hogwarts Professors winning the Witch Weekly’s Most Charming Smile award.
C'mon! Y'all don't remember Willderoy Slinkheart, Gilderoy Lockhart's identical cousin? He wrote "Thursday Night with a Thestral"!! His autobiography focusing on his relationship with his cousin "Wagical We" was bestselling!
"Wagical We" almost sounds like something Waluigi would write, hee hee.
@@LamanKnight Wa-Ha-Ha!!
😂☠️ imma need that book I’m missing one obviously 😂
I was very upset when his Wemory charm backfired and he ended up in St. Wungo's
@@JustTommyBoy No no- your thinking of gilderoy their distingushig fetuere is that wilderoys memory charm DID NOT backfire and he acctually obliviated won measley and parry hotter!
Can I request a theory on why the Hogwarts paintings never saw the Basilisk? That's always bothered me.
Because the snake is so big I like to imagine it went outside and peered through the window
🏰🐍
Same reason a person can’t. It’s in the walls. Is there a specific place where an attack occured where a painting was present?
@@neilmartinoconnor but its only on the staircase that the portraits are in massive numbers.
@@neilmartinoconnor Even without seeing the basilisk, you'd think they'd at least see Ginny writing on the walls in blood. The only possible answer is that there aren't portraits on every wall or in every corridor. And Tom was smart enough not to have the messages written on walls where portraits could see it being done.
Why didn't they ghosts? Why didn't Myrtle, who we know has been in the pipes. It's because the basilisk was hibernating. He can only stop hibernating when the heir allows it
Having not actually read the books, I am constantly amazed by how many questions they come up with about the same hospital
They could honestly make a 50 question mega quiz about St. Mungo's and still wouldn't cover everything that could be asked about a place that is visited for 1 chapter
@@shade7033 2 chapters, but still.
read them
12:00 All time moment for Team Ben
Word for word alley between magnolia whatever and wisteria way was soooo cool
I love when a one off joke carries through the whole vid naturally 😂 Gilderoy and Wilderoy will forever be in my heart 😂😂
I hope this isn't the last we've heard of Wilderoy (whose favorite color is puce).
Ok hot take:
Harry should’ve been a DADA professor when he graduated. He was good at teaching it, as evidenced by everyone flourishing under his guidance. He would be the type of man to want to give kids a home and make them feel supported and loved which is great for a teacher especially somewhere where the professors do more than just teach. The curse would be broken after Voldemort died. Also, I feel like Harry would get tired of fighting bad guys and hunting them down and want some peace and quiet in his life.
well apperently he didn't see himself as a teacher otherwise he would have become one :P
I've always had the same thought
I totally would love for Harry to be the defense against the dark arts teacher
Maybe later on in his life. Like when he wants to stop being an auror maybe he will become a professor.
@@fidelianerina agreed, also an option
Grats Ben!! It's nice to see the underdog win for once... has anyone else noticed that when J even comes close to losing, he always tries to justify how he was almost right!? 😝
He’s always such a sore loser 😂
I love watching them both, but it's kinda annoying how J is somewhat of a sore loser
J can't take it!! 🤣
It's all fun though
Sibling dynamics.
I've noticed that when it's something that you are normally hyped up as the best for, like people always talk about how good you are at something, then you lose to family or close friends who are usually the ones doing the hyping, it is really hard to accept. At least it is that way for me and I've been aware of it and tried to improve on that character flaw. I am completely fine at losing at things and couldn't care less most of the time, but when everyone is always like "he's sooo freaking good at this" or "I'm definitely going to lose because he always wins at such and such", it is like the pressure is on and if I lose it's almost like a personal attack. I bet it's similar with J. He is always "supposed" to win, so when he doesn't it's hard to accept. I know that doesn't excuse it. It's a bad trait to have, but I think it is more of a subconscious thing that you can do without realizing you are. It took me awhile to realize that I could do that.
Having said all that, I also think he had a point this time. He lost by two. One of those were him saying Deepest Blue, instead of Midnight Blue on a robe color. Another point Ben literally would not have gotten because he was stuck, and J slipped up and gave him the answer. With how often J wins vs Ben, the gracious thing would have been to drop it and let Ben have this, but he did have a point. I just think that goes back to what I said above and how he probably doesn't even realize how much it affects him.
To see Ben actually win a quiz is heart warming.
As an underdog supporter seeing Ben win was an incredibly rewarding feeling, beyond proud. However, whatever happens I am always a supercarlinbrothers supporter and you always do a whole lot better than me I need to refresh my brain on those books but keep up the good work and the J Vs Ben videos they will always be my favourites 🫶
I always support Ben over J. J winning is far too common to get satifactiion out if.
I'm a sad J fan this week
I got like two thirds of the way through before caving and looking through the comments to see if he won since he was in the lead. Yasssss! It's such a joy to see Ben know things that J doesn't remember.
Also J is kind of a sore loser this time around. Like you got the midnight blue question wrong. Ben has gotten even closer before and not been given the point and didn’t harp on about it
I loved Ben's "50 Cent" joke at 25:00. Simple yet hilarious!
Right, who doesn't remember that touching scene? And Neville is just leading him out of the room, whispering, "Gran, she did it again, call the Obliviators..."
When he said 50 Cent referring to wrapper my brain was like ,,Welcome to the candy shop” 🤣🤣
I knew Mrs Weasley saw Fred and George because the boggart showed them dead together, which means even in her worst nightmares she never imagined one twin would die and the other would live….
And that sadly happen
I'd like to see some Aquarium trivia so Ben can dominate and we can be surprised by J's random guesses being right haha
These Harry Potter quizzes are my favorite ❤⚡️
I don’t know why, but I found it very funny when the editors (Kat, Riley and Ethan) slowly turned around each of their chairs to face Ben 🤣
What a Ben Win! #TeamBen! With the 2 perfect answers!
Also Wilderoy gag was gold 😂
18:11 It's also the song that plays when Ving Rhames' King Pin is introduced in the Daredevil movie
ben losing the answer on the second question and being able to pull it back is a good sign for team ben! normally he just stares at the desk for a few minutes then gets mad cause he shouldve known it
You GO Ben, you were on fire (pun definitely intended) today! Congrats 😁
I've been waiting for this for a long time! Very exciting episode!
Wait, what's the pun?
@@MIrfanPerdana I'd assume because the quiz is about Order of the Phoenix, and phoenixes=fire
@@Syngrafer Yeah, that's what I thought too, but it seemed like a bit of a leap to me haha
Awesome these quizzes are hard to find on this channel despite them practically being made every week
They have a playlist on their channel. That should help.
With these new findings, do I hear a theory about Willdelory Slinkhart's life? His rivalry with the more astounding brother Gildelory Lockhart? How people assume they are identical but they are not, as midnight blue could never be identical to deepest blue!
Lavender Blue, Dilly Dilly
I laughed so hard at the fraternal twins bit I gave myself an asthma attack, must be one of the best jokes ever lol
FINALLY THE UNDERDOG WINS 😭 I’ve been watching y’all for years but this is my first time seeing Ben win. I feel like a proud Auntie
This is the perfect JvsBen episode, not only because Ben won, but because it was hilarious as well
If we're thinking up alternative book titles, I propose "Therapy with a Thestral"
I’ve been binging these recently and after watching a new video by another one of my favorite creators this was an amazing treat. Thank you guys for making my day better!
Also I’m gonna crush the HBP quiz because it’s my favorite and I’m wayyyy too confident lol
You'd think after all these years of Harry Potter content J would know how to spell Ordre of teh Feenyks. 😉
I have finally started Reading the Books at the start of this year, after being a Harry potter fan as Long as i can remember. These videos made me actually start Reading then.
27:10 when Ben said "Wah-pah!" Chandler image appear in my mind
Congratulations Ben! Thank you Kat, Riley and Ethan for all of your hard work to keep the Carlins Super! Happy Holidays everyone! ⛄🎄🎁🎉 Stay warm and safe!
+
I feel like the boys got to an extra level of fun on this one. Hilarious! Very entertaining!
Tea with a Tungarian Torn Tail killed me.
Tattoos:
On one hand: I must not
On the other: SILENCIO BRUNO!
2:24 Not J checking the spelling of "Phoenix/Pheonix"
6:28 my brother is Robert and I am 10 years older then him. So his entire childhood I referred to him as Robbie Dobs, Robbie Dobby, Rob Dob or Dobby Bobby. At like age 17, he kindly asked me to stop. I still call him rob dobs to his face, when no one else is around… ❤️
No shade but is this like the 4th time Ben has ever won? I route for him every single time so I’m thrilled to finally see him win
This was hilarious, as always - can’t wait to find out more when it comes to Willderoy Slinkheart and his bestselling books (Wagical We and Tea with a Thungarian Thorntail) 🤣
I was just watching another J Vs Ben!! Perfect timing!
"...will get I Must Not Tell Lies tattooed on their hand."
Me: And so it was spoken, so it was writte-uh....tattooed!!!!
"Just kidding."
Also me: But....but it was spoken.
Wilderoy Slinkhart had me cackling the entire video 😂 My stomach hasn’t hurt from laughing like this in a long time!
This was a video not to be missed! 😂 Too many good inside jokes. Congrats Ben! #teamben
It's past three in the morning and I spent an hour hunting down this video just to laugh at the Wilderoy Slinkheart joke again :'D Time well spent
Alternate title:
Two Grown Men Cackle at Dr. Seuss Rhymes for 30 Minutes
Love your videos!! Order of the phoenix was my favorite book! Can’t wait to try to answer this trivia
Happy holidays you guys, this made me laugh so hard and I want to spread my appreciation towards the editors
Fun fact, in my copy of POA, there is a typo where Adalbert Waffling is listed as the author of A History of Magic. I was so confused when I got to later books and they said Bathinda Bagshot was the author.
IVE NEVER BEEN THIS EARLY! I love you guys. These videos bring me so much joy.
Someone sound the alarm, Ben won! 😂 I feel like a proud cousin
The editing on this episode was top notch. So much props
Really enjoyed laughing with you guys. I needed it.
Really enjoyed the giddiness that both J and Ben had on this episode. Can only imagine how much Reilly had to cut 🤣
I love when you guys do a J Vs B episode. 😁 Happy Holidays. 🎄
I’ve gotten to the point now that when I’m reading the HP books, I’m actively looking for J vs B questions 😂
Same. I'm currently reading deathly hallows and there is an interview with Rita Skeeter in the prophet about her Dumbledore biography. The name of the interviewer is mentioned only twice and she never gets much attention so her name would be a really difficult question for them
I have an idea also for a what if. What if Petunia had also been a Witch like Lily? How would Harry's life have been different? Would Dumbledore have been able to influence and manipulate Harry's life as much if Petunia was a witch and raised him?
Someday they will have a quiz (possibly april fools) for their own creations
Ike Lazerbeam
Wilderoy
And many more I don't remember or haven't been created yet
Love how the first princess candle is perfect for lunar new year🎉
Such a whimsical episode, I love Wilderoy Slinkheart
So excited for thissss
you guys seem so happy 🥲
I have a mertch idea. You could make bath robes for each house that look like the robes from the films.
I second this!! That would be super cool!
Making a harry potter quiz for the family so watching this to make notes
Good luck!
Thank you! They're all complete experts in this area, so I'm trying to find tricky questions so it's not a tie as it usually is! 😁
Checknout pottermore for some more questions!
How did it go?
@RinZ3993 really well! Doing another one this year :)
26:05 Love that the subtitles say "Grand Moth"
It legit looks like they're having so much fun😂
Always nice to watch this before going to bed
Merry Christmas everyone!
It’s been so long for a Ben win!!Team Ben rise up!!
This is one of your funniest videos yet.
Best one yet! Was so happy for Ben on question 3
Bring it! I was so proud during the last trivia. I got Dudley's four pound tongue, right. It was all downhill from there, but I think that's the only one I've ever been able to get that you guys didn't. So, thanks for letting me feel good about myself for twenty seconds.
Hagrid should get a "I must not tell" tattoo lol
Wow OK I don’t know why but you two seem so happy on this quiz! You made me laugh several times. Totally love watching you guys.
I thought J said that it was tricky to answer who told them about the Room of Requirement because technically Dumbledore told Harry about it before (which is how Harry confirms to Hermione that it exists)
I love how much fun they have making fun of Lockhart 🤣
Umbridge in Space exists already, go watch Louise Fletcher as Kai Winn on Star Trek Deep Space Nine.
On behalf of the Towel Section, thank you Kat, Riley, and Ethan. Happy Holidays.
I have never before posted a RUclips comment but Bens victory here is worth a congratulations 🎉
Wilderoy slinkheart is the best joke I’ve ever heard
And space umbridge
Claire’s 😂 this video is hilarious
Hey J and Ben I know you guys said you're going to play Hogwarts Legacy. So are you guy's going to stream it? Do separate play through's?
I’m sorry but tricking J into giving you the answer is top tier tactics!
I put a permanent marker of i shall not tell lies on the hand of the loser.
Was it really 10 Death Eaters that broke out of Azkaban, or was it 9 Death Eaters plus Stan Shunpike? Also, What you fall over for?
I love the J vs Ben videos but I have to say the ones with punishments are my favorite 😈
Dude I was just watching the fifth movie and I caught a moment I've never caught before, and it absolutely broke me.... In the scene where Harry and Cho kiss, just before that when all of the DA is leaving through the door, you see poor Ginny looking back at Harry going to Cho. And her face man, that poor girl...
18:06 The song is called “Lapdance” by N.E.R.D.
Look forward to these quiz's we love them, thanks guys
This J vs Ben is an absolute delight!
I see the title; instant reaction: IT'S A SWAN!
Yay Ben! I've been rooting for you for so long!
This was the best episode!
23:55 J WATCHES CYCLING!
A fun "punishment" game would involve, say, a punishments wheel. Nothing bad but it could be something like "do ten push-ups", "eat a bean", or "do a dare". Or you could do something like gamble with candy/chocolate/fake coins and keep adding to the pile until someone loses a point at which case the winner gets the lot.
These are fun, but my favorite videos are the what ifs
3:19 it depends if you're from the south or north of england, im from up north so we pronounce 'auld' the exact same as 'old', the southern preference is to elongate the vowel so its more like 'grimawld' (dont ask me how the scots or welsh pronounce it lol)
J spelling 'phoenix' wrong and Ben not calling it out is comical
Mulan is next!? That’s so cool! Can’t wait to see the design for her candle!!! Also, what ever happened to the art contest in October? When will we see what art goes on the wall?
The fact that Ethan found Claire's so funny was funnier than Claire's itself😂
Ben did not write Sheffins 😂 sat there for the whole time before he read it like “he surely didn’t think it was called that”
Yep. The penmanship says otherwise.