You can see why it's number 1 in the UK. Looks alone, quality ingredients, And superbly cooked. And a lot cheaper than I expected, the owners must be superproud of such an accomplishment 👏👏
Gary should be knighted for his services to getting people back to eating out and supporting businesses. I used to eat out a lot but not so much any more. Watching reviews like this get me in the mood to get my backside up and get out there and see what’s on offer. Thanks mate. You are doing a great job.
Hub and me used to eat out three times a week, but a lot of the time, the food was mediocre and very overpriced. We rarely go out now. I don't miss it tbh. I cook at home. So much nicer and probably healthier and a lot, lot cheaper for sure.
Yes, I agree. Whilst I can't afford to eat out every day, Gary has inspired me to try different restaurants & cuisines, rather than sticking to my usual go-to establishments. Well done, Gary. 👏🏻👏🏻
@@GaryEats thanks for asking! Very tiring 🤣 I’m a plasterer so got a full bathroom done today! Waiting for some home cooked shepherds pie and veg whilst watching the latest vid!! 🙏🏻
Ashamed to say that living in Edinburgh, I have probably walked past here loads of times but never gone in. Thanks to your review I will need to change that (and fast!). Hope you had a great time, brilliant to see you up here
Ime sure the food is as good as you and many say! But it spells obvious as to why many pass by without a second look, front of house enticement has about as much invite as a run down cheap MOT station! How are the WC's😅😅
It’s so great to see you in Scotland Gary. The contrasts in the eatery’s you review are absolutely top drawer. As a proud Scot I’m so glad your enjoying it here .❤️🏴❤️
Well things must have changed in 15 years when I drove 3500 miles from Essex round every inlet in Scotland. NOT ONE DECENT MEAL ANYWHERE! In several restraints the sauce in the starter was the same as the main!! In anything that resembles a restaurant the prices were outrageous for rubbish. Given the wonderful coast - no fish! Best was a smokie in a cafe. So to see this is no longer the case in wonderful Scotland.
Some of these so called celebrity chefs restaurants could learn a lot from a place like this when they charge extortionate prices for very poor quality food and treat people like mugs ,such an enjoyable review to watch gary you nailed that one number one restaurant number one reviewer keep up the good work
I dont think i have ever seen you react like this gary, you actually didn't even need to speak did you, your expressions said it all, that place looks incredible, Drambuie on chicken , sounds like heaven! And that lamb, wow. Glad you enjoyed. Have to say gary, defo my favourite RUclips channel of 2024, absolutely brilliant, thank you
I am EdInburgh based. Passed this place, but never been. Will definitely ‘give it a go’ now. By the way, brave of you to sit outside in Edinburgh in November.
I can see why it's No.1, food looks delicious and the presentation is good. All restaurants should have more than 1 option for mash, it benefits from adding other ingredients and goes so well with sauces and gravy
I found the crisp sandwich I was tucking into there watching your review become even tastier elevating it to an 8.5 even without smelle-vision. Your enthusiasm is infectious, always enjoy watching you enjoy good food glad Edinburg delivered. 👍
Try a pickled onion Monster Munch sandwich - open a corner of the bag enough to vent it (cm or so), crush the MM almost to powder and stick it between generously buttered slices of WHITE bread. You can add a twist of black pepper to elevate it even further!
It's also busy because (apart from the fab food) it's on the Mound which is the main thoroughfare between the Old Town and the New Town so they get loads of tourist traffic. It's well deserved too for good, simple cooking.
That’s food that will stick to your ribs, and the fact that it’s so delicious just makes it wonderful. The Scots know how to feed folk! They’re very good hosts. xx
£23 for that lamb shank was incredible value and equally £18 for the chicken , both dishes looked unbelievable , Mr Stein and Mr Ramsey look and learn because that is how you do it , 10* so easily deserved Gary , great review as usual my friend 👍
Not cheap for Edinburgh......but massive portion... I hardly eat out anymore because the prices are ridiculous...But I would pay 23 quid for that lamb. Compare that to what you would get for the same price at the average mediocre pub chain tho...lol.
Brill! I love how authoritative you were about not having had a lamb shank on the channel before! Pulling the lamb off the bone was the meat equivalent of the chocolate flake ad back in the day. Great close ups. My head starts moving involuntarily to the screen on these shots. Lovely video ❤
Happily for me, I live in Edinburgh. I've seen a few stellar reviews of this place, and I'm looking forward to visiting soon. Loved your enthusiasm Gary.
Edinburgh is my favorite city in europe and i have visited a lot of cities! So i love when Gary trying places there so i know where to go to next time ! Love it you are there !
Gary, I have to say that both the lamb and chicken look to be the most delicious meals I’ve ever seen on your channel. What I can’t comprehend is how your son is able to keep calm and stable while filming. I have been fortunate enough to visit Edinburgh three times, and must confess it’s the most beautiful and culturally historical city I’ve ever seen! This restaurant is just off the Royal Mile, a short walk from the magnificent St Giles Cathedral. Great to see you in other cities of the UK, really and truly enjoyed this one. Take good care Gary and looking forward to your next culinary adventure. Kind regards, Rob.
This is a real contrast to the M&C video I watched earlier, the value for money is outstanding in comparison. As always, lovely to see an honest view on these places.
I’m over pond in North Carolina watching this amazing review and just itching to get on a plane and visit the UK. Yesterday I was watching Gary eat the best fish and chips and now this. Too good.
Quality food and no celebrity chef. Comprehensive honest review as ever. Glad such a restaurant is receiving the recognition it deserves. Thanks for taking us along. All the best Pete 👍
Last review it was a Glasgow “budget”meal this time an Edinburgh Award winning restaurant and how does Gary approach his reviews ,with the exact same non bias and enthusiasm and rating the food and establishments openly and honestly. Another enjoyable review.
Gary, that was impressive. The quality of the lamb and chicken dishes were outstanding. How tender and flaking were the meats!!! Portions perfect, price of the meals 👌 Fully deserved your 10☆ rating. Beautiful restaurant. Thank you for sharing with us Gary, much appreciated. A real blessing and treat for us 🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶
Your reviews are ALWAYS from the heart, and having just viewed this straight after The Witchery, it absolutely speaks volumes that your value of memorable food sees through where it is served (gorgeous surroundings vs outside terrace of a small set up).There is a reason people rate you - honesty, being genuine, and knowing that if you rate it - we are likely to as well. Thank you.
Hiya Gary.. yeah the food looked great.. and it's always a joy to watch you share not only the food but also you and your joyful persona.. cheers mate!
What a stunning review Gary! Oh my - those two meals looked gorgeous - and obviously tasted amazing! what a treat for you that was. A very well deserved top score!
As a proud Ulster Scot, I am envious. 1. You're in Scotland 2. You're in my home from home, Edinburgh. 3. You're eating what I probably would've chosen and loving it. Edinburgh has always had a great drinking and eating out scene and I'm very pleased to see you enjoying it so much. 😋
Gary I've been to this place back in 2021 and my experience then was incredible and one of the best meals I've ever eaten. Also had to have a cheeky whiskey on the side while I was there. Cant wait to return to Edinburgh and go back here. Great review.
Wow! What a fantastic review. That all looked amazing. Smoked cheesy mash. Yum! And the quality of that lamb and your description of the gravy was definitely the next best thing to smellyvision. Thankyou Gary. I think you deserve 10 ⭐️ for the great way you describe everything and your obvious enjoyment when it’s so good.
Looks incredible Gary and really enjoyed your vivid descriptions. I felt like I was eating it! 😊 Your ability to describe food is the best I have ever seen.
One of my favourite cities. I was there in 2016 and always said I would return. Another great review Gary. Thank you so much. The lamb and the chicken both looked delicious. Love the way you can choose the mash to compliment the main dish.
The Lamb Shank looked amazing. The presentation and colours on the plate could have been a still life painting. Gary Never seen you so delighted by a meal before. Truly a 10. Shame we did not get to see the inside of the restaurant but understand as they were so busy. Truly enjoyable video. Thanks Gary
Looked at another reviewer's video of a restaurant in Italy where the bill came to 590 euros per couple (200 euro min/person) and the meal was so small and bad that the reviewer left there still hungry.This restaurant in Edinburgh shows that simplicity is what we as customers value more than decor and fancy presentation. Definitely deserving of the national and world rating and there are many many more places like that in Scotland just waiting to be sampled. Loved the review and your 10* rating was spot on!!!!!
I have been binge watching your channel since I subscribed. I am from Canada and love all your work and the way you light up when you have had some amazingly good food! Keep up your brilliant work with the same humility and grace that you show on every video!
Edinburgh is a beautiful place, crumbs your getting around. I thank the day, you started making videos. Your happy engaging personality, makes these videos a thing of greatness. Mr Cameraman, always does an incredible job too. Like that food a lot.
🎉🎉 Congratulations 🎉🎉 180k Subscribers!! Fantastic channel & totally well deserved, the rise of Gary Eats has been tremendous mate. Well done & all the very best!
Thank you Terry for encouraging me to join Gary's channel. It's a wonderful place to be and there are some lovely people on here. 180k is fantastic. Brilliant xx 😘
I'm so pleased I totally wore you down, & bullied you into it Maria 😂 It definitely puts the other channel we used to follow together, slightly on the back foot nowadays... Gary has set a high standard, for others to try to follow.! Glad you're enjoying it, & yes it's a truly amazing community! With so many wonderful people, which I think we're all proud of, I've definitely met some lovely friends on the channel. 200k before Christmas I'm guessing, which will be amazing for our lovely Gary and the most famous Cameraman in the world 😊 Hope you're having a superb week & thanks for the lovely comment as always Maria! Take care & we'll catch up again soon 😘 xx
@@TelThePower you didn't bully me lol 🤣 I was very happy to be introduced to Gary and his community and haven't looked back since. Yes Gary's put the other food review channels to shame . He's the only one that tries to respond to all of us and he's a gentleman too. Very kind to his subscribers and honest and transparent. The Dad and Son partnership is beautiful so that makes the videos extra special too and Gary's humble and real which makes all the difference. 200k definitely by the end of December, I hope. My week isn't too bad thank you . I hope yours is going well too. Thank you for responding to me . Have a lovely week and evening sweet xx 😘
So good to see an independent restaurant being acknowledged world wide. Uncontaminated by celebrity nonsense and certainly not a tourist trap. What a wonderful city Edinburgh is too. The presentation of each dish was simple yet pleasing on the eye. (They say you eat with your eyes). The key words here Gary are flavour, flavour, flavour ! Top drawer and a 10/10 from me. Dare I say, it's probably the best review on your channel to date..
Love a good peppercorn sauce Gary. Lovely review love the way you interact with staff your a gent. A genuine review love watching you take care you two Safe travels as always 😊
Truly looked Amazing Gary.... My oh my ..... Lamb Shank.... Looked delicious.... Regardless of Anne-Marie`s status... Even she exclaimed how wonderful the two dishes were.... (No Mushrooms Lol) Really enjoying your journey North.... Edinburgh looks Wonderful.... Enjoy your time Gary !!!!
Going by presentation, quality and quantity that is one of the best selection of dishes of any restaurant by any food reviewer I have seen this year. Well done to the team.
Brilliant and reasonable prices, I am up in Edinburgh in the new year will definitely pay a visit. Also noticed on the menu kids portions are £7, bargain
I remember before the days of BSE my dad could get a whole pile of lambs necks from the butcher for next to nothing and make lambs neck stew. The best bit for us kids was sucking out the bone marrow. It's sad we don't have local butchers anymore and even if we did spinal bone marrow is banned.
Hi Gary. I haven’t commented for some time because I’m sitting here getting jealous! This one sir is probably one of the best eateries I’ve seen on your channel. 200 k looming ! Well done. All the best Dave.
for real i never watch food channels but hes are just chilled and he doesnt over do it and just try too hard to be intresting. he comes across as genuine and im glad his channel is doing well now
Everything that I saw on the menu looked delicious. That lamb shank looked tasty. Great video Gary. Love how you critique every style, price and location of restaurants in your everyman way.
Hi Gary! How lovely to see you in Edinburgh. I have such fond memories of visiting there myself. That is an incredible rating for a restaurant! I was thinking at the start, please don't let this be a let-down for you. 🙏 Seconds before you said "Loads of you are gonna say, not lamb again "... I said to myself, I bet Gary orders the lamb! Lol! 😅 Fantastic sounding menu & the dishes looked amazing. How the meat fell away from the bone & the sauces! Yum!! Beautiful, flavourful meals. The chicken would probably be my personal preference & I'd make short work of it too. 😋 That was gorgeous, what a tantalising review. I felt it had to be a 10/10. As you said, simple cooking done to perfection. Take care Gary & Mr C. It looks like you're having a wonderful time in Scotland. See you on the next one. 🌷💙
That looked spectacular and the use of ramekins was a great aesthetic idea. I think it's fitting that the best restaurant should reside in the UK's most beautiful city. Thank you Gary !
For me you are absolutely the number 1 content creator on YT. You could review anything from bog roll to super yachts- I’d watch it and enjoy every second Cheers Gary !
another fantastic review where I'm literally drooling at the screen. My wife asked me what I want for Christmas and I'm swaying towards a Gary Eats sweater , she thinks I'm mad but she has no idea how much we all adore Gary and how he continues to keep us entertained.
No offence to Danny as he seems a lovely chap but there’s only so much of that wayhaying and sped-up singing I could handle before I got a bit tired of it. I never miss a GaryEats video though. I just think his words have a bit more depth to them
You can see why it's number 1 in the UK.
Looks alone, quality ingredients, And superbly cooked. And a lot cheaper than I expected, the owners must be superproud of such an accomplishment 👏👏
It looked incredible to me Chris, 180k subscribers by Thursday mate 😉
All the best to you and the family ☺️
It's utterly brilliant Chris. Please don't start making anymore predictions you two! lol
@TelThePower
Nah Buddy, but Friday's looking good 😃🫢
Sorry didn't see the big at the bottom 😅 all the best to you guys also
@@GaryEats Yep - they're both wrong, you've already hit 180k. Congratulations Gary (and cameraman) - well deserved !
Thank you to all.
This is what review channels should be about. This is exactly the type of business that deserves to be elevated. Good job on the review.
That’s very kind, thank you very much
Gary should be knighted for his services to getting people back to eating out and supporting businesses. I used to eat out a lot but not so much any more. Watching reviews like this get me in the mood to get my backside up and get out there and see what’s on offer. Thanks mate. You are doing a great job.
That’s very very kind thank you
Absolutely. More worthwhile than every politician that's ever been knighted.
Hub and me used to eat out three times a week, but a lot of the time, the food was mediocre and very overpriced. We rarely go out now. I don't miss it tbh. I cook at home. So much nicer and probably healthier and a lot, lot cheaper for sure.
Most definitely. Also, highlighting how bad some of the celebrity owned, chains and fast food places can be.
Yes, I agree. Whilst I can't afford to eat out every day, Gary has inspired me to try different restaurants & cuisines, rather than sticking to my usual go-to establishments. Well done, Gary. 👏🏻👏🏻
proper calm, relaxing videos to watch after a long days work! love it
Glad you enjoyed! How was your day at work?
@@GaryEats thanks for asking! Very tiring 🤣 I’m a plasterer so got a full bathroom done today! Waiting for some home cooked shepherds pie and veg whilst watching the latest vid!! 🙏🏻
The perfect meal, great stuff hope you enjoy it!
Yes I put Garys vids on after work with a cuppa nice to unwind to
Edinburgh born and bred here will need to go there pronto. Delighted you liked my city. Haste yea back!
Give it a go Paul
Ashamed to say that living in Edinburgh, I have probably walked past here loads of times but never gone in. Thanks to your review I will need to change that (and fast!). Hope you had a great time, brilliant to see you up here
It is definitely worth a visit and I had a brilliant time in Edinburgh
This place is on my way to work, didn't give it a second thought
Same, I always assumed it was just some fast food place. I will check it out some time.
As a local I've never been able to get in because it's always booked up solid. Shows how popular it's become.
Ime sure the food is as good as you and many say! But it spells obvious as to why many pass by without a second look, front of house enticement has about as much invite as a run down cheap MOT station! How are the WC's😅😅
Thanks Gary! Great video as always. I’m in Edinburgh in a few weeks for my birthday and have now booked here!! X
I really appreciate that, thank you so much. Give it a go Kelly!
Nice one!
It’s so great to see you in Scotland Gary. The contrasts in the eatery’s you review are absolutely top drawer. As a proud Scot I’m so glad your enjoying it here .❤️🏴❤️
Thank you very much and I do not blame you, you are very lucky to have these types of restaurants
Well things must have changed in 15 years when I drove 3500 miles from Essex round every inlet in Scotland. NOT ONE DECENT MEAL ANYWHERE! In several restraints the sauce in the starter was the same as the main!! In anything that resembles a restaurant the prices were outrageous for rubbish. Given the wonderful coast - no fish! Best was a smokie in a cafe. So to see this is no longer the case in wonderful Scotland.
I feel sorry for guy with camera
Don't Dominic he's a pain lol (also my son)
@@mikeriley6073I’m not sure where you went? Edinburgh is and always has been one of the poshest cities in Europe 😂😂😂 food is always good
What a genuinely wonderful and nice wholesome Channel. Gary is a national treasure, we must protect him at all cost!
That’s very very kind Tommy thank you
A big hearted welcome to Scotland Gary, thanks for the genuine respect you show our Wee nation and its ingredients and people.
I love the people and food in Scotland absolutely amazing 🏴🏴🏴
Looked amazing. Who needs ‘fine dining’ when you can get this level of ‘everyday’ cooking. Great video Gary 👏🏼👍🏼👏🏼
I have to agree completely
Some of these so called celebrity chefs restaurants could learn a lot from a place like this when they charge extortionate prices for very poor quality food and treat people like mugs ,such an enjoyable review to watch gary you nailed that one number one restaurant number one reviewer keep up the good work
I couldn’t agree more Stephen
I also hate celebrity resturants. Over priced, under portioned arty farty crap.
I think that’s not really the norm. In 99% of the places where you pay more the services is better. The service is oftentimes dreadful in cheap places
@@debbieball900what’s the obsession with portion size? Are you malnourished?
@@hmu05366 You're not eating the service. I care more about the food.
I can't believe watching someone eat food is so mesmerising. You certainly enjoyed that one Gary! Keep up the excellent work.
Thanks so much Steven 👍
I dont think i have ever seen you react like this gary, you actually didn't even need to speak did you, your expressions said it all, that place looks incredible, Drambuie on chicken , sounds like heaven! And that lamb, wow. Glad you enjoyed. Have to say gary, defo my favourite RUclips channel of 2024, absolutely brilliant, thank you
I really appreciate that, thank you so much!!
I am EdInburgh based. Passed this place, but never been. Will definitely ‘give it a go’ now. By the way, brave of you to sit outside in Edinburgh in November.
I have to say, the weather was truly amazing
Weather's better the now than it was in the summer
@@jameshepburn81 very true actually. Changes next week.
@@pmcg001 Same here, Will be going in two weeks time. Food looks amazing. Probably won't sitting outside then.
Gary - your genuine nature and enthusiasm just shines through. You're a star mate. Thanks for checking this place out.
Thank you very much. You're a star for this comment!
I can see why it's No.1, food looks delicious and the presentation is good. All restaurants should have more than 1 option for mash, it benefits from adding other ingredients and goes so well with sauces and gravy
Well said David. Utterly brilliant!
Looked absolutely superb. No frills but cooking at its best. Just how restaurants and pubs should be.
Hear hear
It's all about the food but I bet its great for an evening out too on a Fri or Sat it's looks so buzzy
Totally agree Duncan
200k subscribers here you come! Thoroughly deserved
I really appreciate that, thank you so much!!
@@Taffam absolutely agree💯
Best food reviewer by a country mile. 1/4 million subscribers is easily achievable and deserved
Looks like something you try not to step on.
@@NormanStanleyNew Not to everyone's look, but if one is blind,then its all about the taste...🍽
I found the crisp sandwich I was tucking into there watching your review become even tastier elevating it to an 8.5 even without smelle-vision. Your enthusiasm is infectious, always enjoy watching you enjoy good food glad Edinburg delivered. 👍
Love a crisp sandwich. My favourite is to stuff cheese and onion crisps into a cheese and tomato sandwich.
Try a pickled onion Monster Munch sandwich - open a corner of the bag enough to vent it (cm or so), crush the MM almost to powder and stick it between generously buttered slices of WHITE bread. You can add a twist of black pepper to elevate it even further!
@@EliteRock, you’d get a fortune off Ramsey for that recipe 😂🤣.
No gimmicks, it does what it says on the tin.....great place with good value and above all among the best in Edinburgh.
Congrats Gary🙏🙏
Thank you very much and you are right, Michael
It's also busy because (apart from the fab food) it's on the Mound which is the main thoroughfare between the Old Town and the New Town so they get loads of tourist traffic. It's well deserved too for good, simple cooking.
Yep! Well said
Welcome to Edinburgh, so glad you could make it, hope you really enjoy your visit.
Thank you very much David. This is a brilliant brilliant city
That’s food that will stick to your ribs, and the fact that it’s so delicious just makes it wonderful. The Scots know how to feed folk! They’re very good hosts. xx
Unpretentious superb food!
£23 for that lamb shank was incredible value and equally £18 for the chicken , both dishes looked unbelievable , Mr Stein and Mr Ramsey look and learn because that is how you do it , 10* so easily deserved Gary , great review as usual my friend 👍
@@Deano4322 iceland and asda have a chuckle
It was top end quality at a good price, fantastic and well said Deano
Not cheap for Edinburgh......but massive portion... I hardly eat out anymore because the prices are ridiculous...But I would pay 23 quid for that lamb. Compare that to what you would get for the same price at the average mediocre pub chain tho...lol.
@@elky1883 Iceland no longer offers good value
Mr Stein & Ramsey aren’t listening to some random guy on the RUclips comments section.
Chill out
Brill! I love how authoritative you were about not having had a lamb shank on the channel before! Pulling the lamb off the bone was the meat equivalent of the chocolate flake ad back in the day. Great close ups. My head starts moving involuntarily to the screen on these shots. Lovely video ❤
Thank you very much... I think I may have had it before!
@@GaryEats You def have Gary!
Happily for me, I live in Edinburgh. I've seen a few stellar reviews of this place, and I'm looking forward to visiting soon. Loved your enthusiasm Gary.
You are very lucky and thank you
Now that's how to present food on a plate! Simple but elegant!!
Looks amazing!
Well said Paul
A plate helps definitely 😅 ( Agree with you)
Edinburgh is my favorite city in europe and i have visited a lot of cities! So i love when Gary trying places there so i know where to go to next time ! Love it you are there !
I love Scotland and Edinburgh. Great people and some amazing places to eat
It's a wonderful city
Gary, I have to say that both the lamb and chicken look to be the most delicious meals I’ve ever seen on your channel. What I can’t comprehend is how your son is able to keep calm and stable while filming.
I have been fortunate enough to visit Edinburgh three times, and must confess it’s the most beautiful and culturally historical city I’ve ever seen!
This restaurant is just off the Royal Mile, a short walk from the magnificent St Giles Cathedral.
Great to see you in other cities of the UK, really and truly enjoyed this one. Take good care Gary and looking forward to your next culinary adventure.
Kind regards, Rob.
He is a good boy and lets daddy enjoy…..if you believe that 😂😂😂
That looked wholesome in every way. No flash, just a great meal. I enjoyed watching you enjoy that!
Glad you enjoyed it
I did, too❣️ He was literally bouncing 😂
This is heaven on a plate for me. Nothing pretentious, just good tasting hone cooked food. Nice one Gary.
Glad you enjoyed it Lisa!
@@LisaLisa-in4vw from iceland micro wave four mins cost a fiver max ... disillusioned brain washed
@@LisaLisa-in4vw yup straight in microwavefrom iceland ...come on get real
@elky1883 not sure which Iceland you go to mister, get real 😜
Every one loves hone cooked food!
This is a real contrast to the M&C video I watched earlier, the value for money is outstanding in comparison.
As always, lovely to see an honest view on these places.
M&C is far too overpriced now
Wow that looked superb Gary, and very reasonably priced. In Edinburgh too..one of my favourite cities.
Great review as always, Gary and cameraman 👍
Thank you Phil, it's a magnificent city
I’m over pond in North Carolina watching this amazing review and just itching to get on a plane and visit the UK. Yesterday I was watching Gary eat the best fish and chips and now this. Too good.
That’s very kind 🇺🇸🇺🇸
Quality food and no celebrity chef. Comprehensive honest review as ever. Glad such a restaurant is receiving the recognition it deserves. Thanks for taking us along. All the best Pete 👍
Thank you as always Pete
Last review it was a Glasgow “budget”meal this time an Edinburgh Award winning restaurant and how does Gary approach his reviews ,with the exact same non bias and enthusiasm and rating the food and establishments openly and honestly. Another enjoyable review.
That’s very kind thank you 🙏
Gary, that was impressive. The quality of the lamb and chicken dishes were outstanding. How tender and flaking were the meats!!! Portions perfect, price of the meals 👌 Fully deserved your 10☆ rating. Beautiful restaurant. Thank you for sharing with us Gary, much appreciated. A real blessing and treat for us 🫶🫶🫶🫶🫶
I really appreciate that, thank you so much and hope you are doing well!
Your reviews are ALWAYS from the heart, and having just viewed this straight after The Witchery, it absolutely speaks volumes that your value of memorable food sees through where it is served (gorgeous surroundings vs outside terrace of a small set up).There is a reason people rate you - honesty, being genuine, and knowing that if you rate it - we are likely to as well.
Thank you.
That’s a really wonderful comment thank you Andrew
Hiya Gary.. yeah the food looked great.. and it's always a joy to watch you share not only the food but also you and your joyful persona.. cheers mate!
Hiya/ Thank you very much
You had me at the mash!!!! Cheese mash, 😋 and lamb! Perfect combo, once again a brilliant review and actually not too pricey. Thanks again Gary x
Thank you Mandy!
💯 mash and gravy with anything is a winner in my books.
What a stunning review Gary! Oh my - those two meals looked gorgeous - and obviously tasted amazing! what a treat for you that was. A very well deserved top score!
Thank you very much, Carol x
Attention to detail so important ❤These guys care that's what you need
That's the most important factor!
Honest cooking at it's Best! Perfect Gary !!
Well said!
@@GaryEats Sometimes big cities,for example London are big culinary traps !!
As a proud Ulster Scot, I am envious. 1. You're in Scotland 2. You're in my home from home, Edinburgh. 3. You're eating what I probably would've chosen and loving it. Edinburgh has always had a great drinking and eating out scene and I'm very pleased to see you enjoying it so much. 😋
I have to say, Mike I was very, very lucky 🏴🏴🏴
Gary I've been to this place back in 2021 and my experience then was incredible and one of the best meals I've ever eaten. Also had to have a cheeky whiskey on the side while I was there. Cant wait to return to Edinburgh and go back here. Great review.
Thank you so very much and I'm so delighted to hear you say that
Wow! What a fantastic review. That all looked amazing. Smoked cheesy mash. Yum! And the quality of that lamb and your description of the gravy was definitely the next best thing to smellyvision. Thankyou Gary. I think you deserve 10 ⭐️ for the great way you describe everything and your obvious enjoyment when it’s so good.
Thank you so very much Amelia
Looks incredible Gary and really enjoyed your vivid descriptions. I felt like I was eating it! 😊 Your ability to describe food is the best I have ever seen.
Thank you so very much
We just watched this after dinner and somehow it’s made us hungry again! Big fan of your work Gazza ❤
I really appreciate that, thank you so much Sarah
Love this channel. Honest . What a refreshing change !
i live in Edinburgh and assumed this place was probably just okay but popular because of tourists. Now I really have to try it.
Same! - and have just booked it now!
Please give it a go, you will love it
@@GaryEats I shall
Brilliant review Gary.
Thank you very much Judith
One of my favourite cities. I was there in 2016 and always said I would return. Another great review Gary. Thank you so much. The lamb and the chicken both looked delicious. Love the way you can choose the mash to compliment the main dish.
Glad you enjoyed it Susan. It's a beautiful city I must say
Food looked amazing.
Love Edinburgh 😊
Easily THE best review on the channel. My mouth and everything else was watering watching you eat the delicious food ❤
Thank you very much ❤️
The Lamb Shank looked amazing. The presentation and colours on the plate could have been a still life painting. Gary Never seen you so delighted by a meal before. Truly a 10. Shame we did not get to see the inside of the restaurant but understand as they were so busy. Truly enjoyable video. Thanks Gary
I have to say, I was blown away by the quality Martin
Looked at another reviewer's video of a restaurant in Italy where the bill came to 590 euros per couple (200 euro min/person) and the meal was so small and bad that the reviewer left there still hungry.This restaurant in Edinburgh shows that simplicity is what we as customers value more than decor and fancy presentation. Definitely deserving of the national and world rating and there are many many more places like that in Scotland just waiting to be sampled. Loved the review and your 10* rating was spot on!!!!!
That is very pricy Ron, needs to be top drawer at that price!
Agree. That video was _"I Survived a Nightmare in Italy's #1 Tourist Trap!"_ on the "Guga" channel.
@@GaryEats ....they were basically paying for the view.
A brand new reaction..
Leaning backwards eyes up in amazement…
Lol oh not another Garyism
@@GaryEats You've nicked it off of Bald Foodie Guy Gareth!!😂
Without a shadow of a doubt
You excelled today, Gary . Those dishes were truly mouth water . I'm glad to see you in my beautiful hometown .You are always welcome .
Thank you Alec 🏴
Good on ya Gaz👍
Always a pleasure when a Gary Eats notification pops up. Looking forward to the review. Hope everyone is having a great day.
Thank you very much Bino
I have been binge watching your channel since I subscribed. I am from Canada and love all your work and the way you light up when you have had some amazingly good food! Keep up your brilliant work with the same humility and grace that you show on every video!
That’s so very kind and appreciated 🇨🇦🇨🇦
Edinburgh is a beautiful place, crumbs your getting around. I thank the day, you started making videos. Your happy engaging personality, makes these videos a thing of greatness. Mr Cameraman, always does an incredible job too. Like that food a lot.
It's stunning. The architecture is breathtaking
Yay, Edinburgh. Looking forward to this one. 7.13 am here in New Zealand. Go Gary. Damn that food looks amazing. Right up my street.
Very early Jen, thanks for tuning in
The lamb must come from NZ to be that good!
@@patrickwalker2509 Scottish lamb is more tender than New Zealand lamb fact !
@jpj-pl7jx your opinion
...your facts?
🎉🎉 Congratulations 🎉🎉
180k Subscribers!!
Fantastic channel & totally well deserved, the rise of Gary Eats has been tremendous mate.
Well done & all the very best!
Thank you so much. You're a smashing guy Tel 😀
@GaryEats
As always..... Thanks Gary.
Just following in your footsteps mate 😉 👍🏻
Thank you Terry for encouraging me to join Gary's channel. It's a wonderful place to be and there are some lovely people on here.
180k is fantastic. Brilliant xx 😘
I'm so pleased I totally wore you down, & bullied you into it Maria 😂
It definitely puts the other channel we used to follow together, slightly on the back foot nowadays...
Gary has set a high standard, for others to try to follow.!
Glad you're enjoying it, & yes it's a truly amazing community! With so many wonderful people, which I think we're all proud of, I've definitely met some lovely friends on the channel.
200k before Christmas I'm guessing, which will be amazing for our lovely Gary and the most famous Cameraman in the world 😊
Hope you're having a superb week & thanks for the lovely comment as always Maria!
Take care & we'll catch up again soon 😘 xx
@@TelThePower you didn't bully me lol 🤣 I was very happy to be introduced to Gary and his community and haven't looked back since.
Yes Gary's put the other food review channels to shame . He's the only one that tries to respond to all of us and he's a gentleman too. Very kind to his subscribers and honest and transparent.
The Dad and Son partnership is beautiful so that makes the videos extra special too and Gary's humble and real which makes all the difference.
200k definitely by the end of December, I hope.
My week isn't too bad thank you .
I hope yours is going well too.
Thank you for responding to me . Have a lovely week and evening sweet xx 😘
So good to see an independent restaurant being acknowledged world wide. Uncontaminated by celebrity nonsense and certainly not a tourist trap. What a wonderful city Edinburgh is too.
The presentation of each dish was simple yet pleasing on the eye. (They say you eat with your eyes). The key words here Gary are flavour, flavour, flavour ! Top drawer and a 10/10 from me. Dare I say, it's probably the best review on your channel to date..
You are completely right, Robert. It’s great that independent restaurants are getting recognised now. That is very kind to say thank you.
It's the best place to eat in Edinburgh. Veggie options are amazing. I recommend it to everyone who asks for a recommendation.
Thank you
Love a good peppercorn sauce Gary. Lovely review love the way you interact with staff your a gent. A genuine review love watching you take care you two Safe travels as always 😊
My pleasure and I was a bit mean to this guy lol
@@GaryEats forgot to say presentation was ace and your never mean Gary 😂
Truly looked Amazing Gary.... My oh my ..... Lamb Shank.... Looked delicious.... Regardless of Anne-Marie`s status... Even she exclaimed how wonderful the two dishes were.... (No Mushrooms Lol) Really enjoying your journey North.... Edinburgh looks Wonderful.... Enjoy your time Gary !!!!
I had a great time and please send my regards to Anne-Marie
Oh , that lamb obviously made Gary very happy ! Another brilliant video 🌟
Thanks David 👍
Amazing review Gary as always.....and that food looked absolutely delicious
Thank you kindly Paul
Going by presentation, quality and quantity that is one of the best selection of dishes of any restaurant by any food reviewer I have seen this year. Well done to the team.
I agree with you completely, thank you
Brilliant and reasonable prices, I am up in Edinburgh in the new year will definitely pay a visit. Also noticed on the menu kids portions are £7, bargain
It is definitely worth a visit, David
Love your honestly pal ,great video.
Much appreciated Rob, top man
Your reviews get better and better. Always cheers up my day. Wonderful.
Wow, thank you!
Wow, looked amazing, will deffo give it a go if I'm ever up in Edinburgh again, thanx for the video, cheers
Thank you very much and please do
It may be crass, but sucking out the bone marrow on a lamb shank is a must.
Eat food how you want!
I’d do it off camera 😹
My dog would have loved that bone.. 😮
I remember before the days of BSE my dad could get a whole pile of lambs necks from the butcher for next to nothing and make lambs neck stew. The best bit for us kids was sucking out the bone marrow. It's sad we don't have local butchers anymore and even if we did spinal bone marrow is banned.
I’ve never even thought about doing that. I might have to try it. What does it taste like?
Cheers
I love Edinburgh, such a beautiful city. Great decor and ambience. Oh my that looks absolutely delicious. Thanks for lunch today.
You and me both it is a beautiful city
Hi Gary, those meals looked absobloodylutely fantastic. I was drooling just looking at them.
They tasted so good 😊
that score was well deserved. looked fantastic! I gotta make the trek up there.
Give it a go!
Thanks for highlighting this place, never even heard of the place before. I’m through Edinburgh next month so you’ve gained them a new booking
Please let me know your thoughts Thomas
Should have a 10* Gary Eats certificate in the window next to that TripAdvisor one. People see that, they know it's a quality establishment.
That’s a good idea
Yes❣️
That lamb & mash dish looked 'effin delicious 🤤🤤🤤 another fantastic review Gaz 🤌🏽
Thank you very much
I think you enjoyed that Gary never seen you so enthused about a meal it did look and sound amazing, another great review.
I did enjoy this one excellent quality Johny
UK (world's) best restaurant reviewer eating at UK best restaurant. The best of the best today.
Thank you very much that's very kind of you Patrick!
That's a natural!
Thanks!
Have a drink on me 😊
There is a very kind gesture, thank you very very much, Stephen
Thanks for drawing our attention to a high quality restaurant with affordable prices.
It's my pleasure
Great stuff as always brother x
Legend! x
Hi Gary. I haven’t commented for some time because I’m sitting here getting jealous! This one sir is probably one of the best eateries I’ve seen on your channel. 200 k looming ! Well done. All the best Dave.
Thank you so much Dave this was excellent quality for the money
These videos always improve my mood. “Gary Eats” is the channel of the year for me.
Thank you very much, you're very kind and I'm glad I help your mood
for real i never watch food channels but hes are just chilled and he doesnt over do it and just try too hard to be intresting. he comes across as genuine and im glad his channel is doing well now
Thank you very much
Oooh I do love Edinburgh. I'm so glad you came to Scotland Gary and cameraman 🏴🥳
Thank you Rosie, so far so good!
@@GaryEats My favourite city, although my Mum was Glaswegian ☺️
Everything that I saw on the menu looked delicious.
That lamb shank looked tasty. Great video Gary. Love how you critique every style, price and location of restaurants in your everyman way.
That is very kind to say thank you
Hi Gary! How lovely to see you in Edinburgh. I have such fond memories of visiting there myself.
That is an incredible rating for a restaurant! I was thinking at the start, please don't let this be a let-down for you. 🙏
Seconds before you said "Loads of you are gonna say, not lamb again "... I said to myself, I bet Gary orders the lamb! Lol! 😅
Fantastic sounding menu & the dishes looked amazing. How the meat fell away from the bone & the sauces! Yum!! Beautiful, flavourful meals. The chicken would probably be my personal preference & I'd make short work of it too. 😋
That was gorgeous, what a tantalising review. I felt it had to be a 10/10. As you said, simple cooking done to perfection.
Take care Gary & Mr C. It looks like you're having a wonderful time in Scotland. See you on the next one. 🌷💙
It's a wonderful city Erin. Truly exceptional experience and the restaurant was even better!
@@GaryEatsI'm glad to hear it Gary. It sounds like it's been a fantastic trip all-round. 💙
That looked spectacular and the use of ramekins was a great aesthetic idea. I think it's fitting that the best restaurant should reside in the UK's most beautiful city. Thank you Gary !
Thank you very much for your comment
For me you are absolutely the number 1 content creator on YT. You could review anything from bog roll to super yachts- I’d watch it and enjoy every second
Cheers Gary !
It’s so kind to say thank you so very very much, Chris
Love that you're enjoying Scotland so much, we've got so many great places to eat!
Absolutely love Scotland and the food 🏴🏴
Gary ur the best youtuber out there
Thank you very much Charlie
I wanna see Rate my Takeaway set up his little table outside this place😂
That might be a tad difficult lol
@GaryEats But it would be hilarious😆
That would be hilarious, let's get the knacker cracker away. 😂
Hehe now then!
@@louiseed1321 It wouldn't be as epic as when he set up his little table in front of Katz' deli in Manhattan. But it would be pretty funny lol
another fantastic review where I'm literally drooling at the screen. My wife asked me what I want for Christmas and I'm swaying towards a Gary Eats sweater , she thinks I'm mad but she has no idea how much we all adore Gary and how he continues to keep us entertained.
That’s so kind thank you both so very much Adam
When RateMyTakeAway and Gary release a video at the same time, you know where to come first!
Thank you but I do really like Danny
No offence to Danny as he seems a lovely chap but there’s only so much of that wayhaying and sped-up singing I could handle before I got a bit tired of it. I never miss a GaryEats video though. I just think his words have a bit more depth to them
Rate My Takeaway 🤣🤣🤣 only joking Gary
Neither am I. YOUR RIGHT. AND I LOVE FATE MY TAKE AWAY.
RateMyTakeAway is rubbish 😂
Good morning Gary from Aussie..
Good evening!