that definitely doesn’t determine that she’s the best vocalist between these 4, as i studied vocal pedagogy vocally it’s actually 1. uji 2. tae 3. solar 4. solji.
SOLJI ...100% she is the VOCAL TRAINER... she is queen of king of masked singer in pilot ep and recently she is with most singing experience among all of the rest .
For this videoTaeyeon is the best followed by Uji with Solji and Solar just behind them. A4 - Uji>Taeyeon>Solji>Solar Bb4 - Uji>Taeoyeon>Solar>Solji B4 - Taeyeon>Solji/Solar>Uji C5 - Taeyeon>Uji>Solji>Solar C#5 - Taeyeon>Uji>Solar>Solji D5 - Taeyeon>Uji>Solar>Solji Eb5 - Taeyeon>Solji>Solar>Uji E5 - Solar/Taeyeon>Uji>Solji F5 - Taeyeon>Uji>Solar>Solji F#5 - Solji>Solar>Taeyeon>Uji G5 - Solji/Taeyeon>Uji>Solar G#5 - Solji>Taeyeon>Uji
Before the 3 member out from exid (yuji,dami,haeryeong), Solji is the vocal trainer exid, and when they out, she become exid member too #sorryformyenglish
@@Lucas-or1ic I think he has not overcome, solji has much more potential, watch his new videos. ruclips.net/video/O9InLQtXQsA/видео.html ruclips.net/video/MaoHjWQ6enA/видео.html ruclips.net/video/ArT0fX7yTag/видео.html
When you start off with a Queen of high notes and singing “Ailee” my opinion 1. Solji, Taeyeon 2.Uji 3. Solar Fun Fact: If you guys didn’t know, Solji debuted before SNSD and a lot of other girl groups and she’s also coming back from her treatment after being diagnosed with hyperthyroidism, EXID comeback as 5 members, if Solji didn’t have this disease she would probably be able to sing to good better than now
Well, I don't think time of debut automatically makes someone a better vocalist... other factors have to be taken into account. There are many new vocalists that have better technique compared to those who may have debuted before them. Also, I don't know how long Solji was a trainee or how long she's been training to be a singer, but Taeyeon has taken professional vocal lessons since she was in middle school.
Even if my ult bias is solji, Taeyeon no doubt wins here. It's weird that on solji's case, she sounds so much better on the higher note but kinda strained on the lower note. How's that even possible lol
@IDGAF HOE Solji and Taeyeon have most support up until their 4th octave. Though Taeyeon seems to have more resonance in her lower-mid range versus Solji, who can go higher than Taeyeon.
@@izonexbae Most of her notes above a C5 are either a bit strained or have very little resonance. And as far as range goes, Uji may have a higher range compared to Taeyeon, but Solji and Uji have pretty similar ranges and even then, Solji has more resonance compared to Uji.
A4-Taeyeon Bb4-Uji/Taeyeon B4-Solar (this resonance)/Taeyeon C5-Taeyeon C#5-Taeyeon (Uji's runs though she did THAT) D5-Taeyeon/Uji (Tae is more consistent on this note but Uji notes were quite nice, I really like her vibrato) Eb5-Taeyeon because she's the only one who ever supported this note even if it is not consistent After this, it's really subjective~ E5-Taeyeon, Uji's E5 are kind of a mess but anyway I like those F5- Uji sounded the more comfortable F#5-Solji G5-Solji G#5-Solji/Uji Objectively talking: Taeyeon> U.Ji> Solar/> Solji My opinion: Uji> Taeyeon> Solar/Solji, Solji's vibrato kind of limits her resonance it's too fast and Taeyeon strain is not agreable to listen. U.Ji is my bestie though lol
That was long lol but worth it to hear them I have to say it would be TAEYEON>UJI/SOLJI>SOLAR but tbh they are all great and the difference is not much at all
1. Solji 2. Taeyeon 3. Uji 4. Solar But this is just based on my personal preference, I just feel Solji can transmit such feelings like no other and she could make me cry no matter what she sings(? And with Taeyeon is the same but not with every kind of song. But damn that girl Uji she's AMAZING. I think they all are in the same level. But you know Solji is my one and only.
Also about Solar I wasn't aware of her damn great voice. I knew she was good but in this video she surprised me. Definitively I will check them all better.
Sorry but everyone denying Uji isn't best sounds so retarded here. It's literally just vocal technique and range, Uji is the best at these, you don't have to think her voice is pretty sounding to acknowledge this fact
IDGAF HOE i didn’t know abt Uji’s lower register being that low(with support) so she’s the best here but we can’t ignore the fact that 2nd and early 3d gen had the best vocals
it’s because you can see she’s a trained vocalist, she’s the second best between these 4 so it’s understandable why you would like her higher register😂
Wow Solji’s first C#5 was pleasant(but no one beats Taeyeon on this note from here). Overall I think Taeyeon leads but Uji is a bit behind due to her lack of resonance above C5 and consistency. Solji and Solar are quite even but I think solar needs to be a bit less chesty and solji’s resonance could be way bigger if she was more open. Btw plz could you make a studio vs live high note video for Hyorin? Great vid tho❤️
They are good singers, their high notes are good. But, I prefer Taeyeon and Solji both are good on high notes. But, Uji and Solar are good too, but I can't see a stable high note from B4 to G#5 Also, I love them:) Good Luck my girls ♥✨
1. Taeyeon: Her tone is the most desireable. Her technique is good. She tends to be airy when she ascends while belting but not much of an issue. Emotional appeal like come on, Taeyeon slaps you with emotions. But yeah, her voice can be a bit airy (maybe she is just exhausted?) Because there are instances her voice is swallowed with playback or background but in this clip she nailed it. 2. Solji: Her Agility and Musicianship is incredible. Her head voice isn't that great but her falsetto is audible enough. Her technique is very pushed and throaty so she strains alot but she kills the fifth octave with her tone but she needs to be more free/open in her technique. She sustains C5 well but she strained. One thing I like about her is that she can sustain and be able to rise it up a notch. Her vocal acrobats are life (she' a vocal coach after all). I love her more fore hitting flat or sharp notes with clarity and ughh. 3. Uji: I don't know much of her technique but she strains most of the fifth octave and she has that shouty factor. Her resonance and vibratos are almost unaudible. 4. Solar: She pushes her voice too much so she strains. She is very throaty but her breathing technique and lung capacity is fzcking insane that's why she sustains them. Personal opinion though.
Taeyeon is the best voice for me. Others just can be rookie for her. She sings amazing and difficult song since her debut. And she is a singer for 12 years.
They all sound amazing, so talented~😮 I prefer Taeyeon's voice simply because there's something (smoother? More effortless? Perhaps soothing is the right word) about it. It's really down to personal preference, all these girls are so incredible. 😍❤❤❤
I have my opinion and you can fight me about it all you want . . . . . . . I think all of them are amazing, personally solji tickles my emotions the most but they’re all incredible!
*My personal opinion.* 1. Taeyeon/Solji (I honestly couldn't choose between them so yep.) 2. Uji/Solar Honestly all of them are top notch vocalists! Like all of them have amazinggggg highnotes and emotion in their voice! This ranking was pretty hard to make for me since all of them are talented.
Comments majority will say Taeyeon/Solji/Mamamoo as they are extremely well-known. U.Ji is seriously one of the most underrated vocalists out there, she shouldn't be discounted because she is unpopular.
why taeyeon's voice is very comforting and satisfying to listen :) not to mention that her voice is the distinct one for me,the others are just almost the same in my ears and they got this husky voice :') i think maybe i'm not in that kind of voice
Taeyeon is the best for me because her voice has proper technique and her vocal color is so pretty, her voice is also unique. I like Uji 2nd cause her voice is also supported and her vocal color is pretty too. I like Solar's voice the 3rd and Solji Last. I LOVE ALL OF THEM THO
To me the best is Solar. She 's voice is more mature than others. She's also so comfortable with this notes. She's voice is more stable. The others are so good also but Solar's technic and maturity got me :) I recommend you Mamamoo - Love Story Of A Girl. Solar's 8 seconds long high note :D 5:03 start from there :D
These 4 vocal divas are the best of KPOP industry at present, It's not fair to say who is the winner but they could slay on the stage whenever where they are, that's my opinion. Thanks for making this great video, well done.
Why would you all not think solji is first just watch it again , let's not compare the highest note, in the middle around d#-E part ; those high note some of them are already standing still and focusing on reaching the note whole solji is still dancing and still reach it without problem
@@yuankent9 and yet, I still prefer her voice to Solar and Uji. Don't get me wrong, I love Solar's voice. Mamamoo's vocal line is outstanding. I find Uji sometimes borders on screaming. Taeyeon is always so stable and has an amazing range, love her! But Solji managed to get emotions through like no other when she sings. And emotions are a big part of enjoying music. Technique is one thing, but it's not everything.
@@carinedemolin7832 emotions is also one thing, not everything. Yes emotions can help you become famous but can it give you longevity in vocal health? Of course not. If you have proper technique, you'll be able to do stylistic singing to add more color and emotions to your voice without risks why? Because then, you know how to control everything you do compared to singers who only focus on styles and bringing emotions
Mina's right foot glass slipper i’m giving props to Solji for singing the same way for almost 10 years so she actually knows what she’s doing. Yes she can improve but she has a supported range that is actually way wider than most idols esp of these past generations(3 and 4th)
I think all these singer are awesome and they're able to reach that high notes with their powerhouse vocals. However, i can't feel the emotion from those singer except from solji and taeyeon and for me thats the most important. How the feeling and emotion tranfered from singer to the audience. These 2 are on another level. The type of singer that can make people happy, uplifting, sad, or even cry...
A4 - best is Uji Bb4 - Solar B4 - Solar, I mean that resonance C5 - Solar C#5 - Solar and Taeyeon D5 - Taeyeon Eb5 - Taeyeon and Uji E5 - Solji... F5 - I think Solar F#5 - Taeyeon G5 - Uji G#5 - I think Solji That's my opinion, based on the best note of each note. I believe Solar is the most consistent through all the range in the video, Solji would be the least.
they are all great and have different voices which makes it hard to choose who's the best but I'll choose taeyeon cause she can control her voice and pull it off amazingly and next is solar,solji and uji..
@@lovelyyukari9042 don't be too biased lol . Maybe you haven't watch solji king of masked singer yet . Taeyeon is good but saying others useless is stupid .
Lovely Yukari We know you’re a fan of taeyeon that’s why you said she’s the best vocalist but you didn’t even listen to the remaining girls. Sis you better keep your mouth shut if you haven’t heard them :))
When Taeyeon sing high note, it doesn't even heard like a high note..but when others idol sing the same note, they are like struggle to hit it..maybe taeyeon voice is soft..
@@smellycat5329 who cares? Because Uji is better than Solji now. It goes Uji>Taeyeon>Solar/Solji Your idea that just because Solji taught Uji means that Uji can never surpass her is incredibly stupid
@@randomsheep1165 fair point. But it does not change my ranking. Taeyeon and Uji strain a lot in upper 5th octave, even though they have better resonance than Solji in lower notes. Solji is also more agile than both of them and has better runs. and Solar... well she's amazing and i love her tone but she's a pusher (imo she isnt even technically the best in mamamoo.) i guess some might put solji after uji, but NEVER after taeyeon. i LOVE her, am a proud sone (actually not even a leggo) but she strains so much in her upper range sometimes, i actually get worried for her.
@@smellycat5329 Taeyeon being smart vocalist, she try to sing in her range which why she keep improving through the years. Solji clearly struggling those notes. She push those notes and become more strained and throaty above D5. It may sounds pleasant to you but it damaging her vocal cords because almost of the time she sings outside of her supported range. While Taeyeon resonate up to D5 and has shown a lot of supported Eb5's now. Overall Taeyeon is a better vocalist. Taeyeon and Uji definitely win this
lol really? Uji *surpassed her* where did u get the fact? and also Uji is not a student. Vocal Trainer and Teacher are different ok? and Solji will be always better than Uji. Uji cannot be better than Solji if Solji was her vocal trainer so it means Solji is a better vocalist and higher vocalist level than Uji.
_jungeunbi_ lol Uji has better technique maybe she was worse but now she's better than Solji and i'm gonna argue with you cuz we're both Loona stans xD
In this world.. the vocal trainer would always have a better technique than a normal singer bc a normal singer would have to train their vocal bc they maybe need a training to improve so to make a normal singer better at singing we hired a vocal trainer that is better than her if Solji wasn't better than her she might not be her Vocal Trainer. And as i said b4 Uji cannot be better than Solji if Solji was her vocal trainer. and loona are not part of our conversation ok?
That's such a lie omg there's so many vocalists who are better than her. Maybe if you only listen to 3rd gen groups you would think she's the best (even though there are a handful of 3rd gen singers who are better than her)
@bob Hertz "I don't know anything about Solji" apart from standing EXID since debut but whatever floats your boat. Just because someone is "respected in the industry" doesn't mean they're actually the best singer. There are many extremely underrated vocalists out there who people don't even know of. Just because IU is "respected in the industry" does that make her one of the best vocalists? Lol no Me looking at the vocal technique of a singer and being objective isn't "laughable". What is "laughable" is seeing someone being branded as something they're not and then falling for it brainlessly. Solji is a good vocalist in kpop but there are many other main vocalists who are much better than her
@bob Hertz hello, actually you can determine when someone is a better singer than another by analysing their vocal technique. This has nothing to do with artistry, this is cold hard objective facts. You believe Solji is the best singer but this is solely down to artistry. You "like" her vocal tone the best, you believe she conveys emotions the best. But these are all subjective measures, unlike vocal technique.
@bob Hertz this is the problem. To you, a good singer is a singer that makes you feel a certain way. As a singer, Solji is one of the best performers and can convey a lot of emotions. But you are completely ignoring the fact that when I'm saying someone else is a "better singer" then this is because they have better vocal technique. This means they support more consistently at a wider range instead of straining, it means they have good breath control, it means their voice is agile and their registers are connected. These are what makes someone, on a technical level, a good singer. Just because someone has a pretty voice and they make you feel good that doesn't mean they are actually a stronger vocalist than another singer who may seem bland to you, but is objectively a more proficient vocalist.
taeyeon is by far the best, all of her notes up to Eb5 are supported at least in the video, followed by uji with D5, then solar with her C#5 and solji is the weakest, with support only at C5 and just one C#5, solji is also very tense and screams more than sings, solar is too much chesty, taeyeon has the most balanced mix even at E5-G#5 when she strains a lot... and her vibrato is just superior
Please no bashing or hateful comments towards any of the ladies featured, let's support all of them!
J'aimerais
I'm here because Solji 😀
Mee too
Solji of course . the current king of mask singer
@@LOL-dq9cl no it is the program name "king of mask singer"
@Raditya Prayogi no u r wrong she is the best of the best.
はは。 Read their vocal analyses and you would know how her technique is the worst among the four vocalists.
that definitely doesn’t determine that she’s the best vocalist between these 4, as i studied vocal pedagogy vocally it’s actually 1. uji 2. tae 3. solar 4. solji.
@@el.c.8858 Solji is the vocal coacher of Uji though.
SOLJI ...100%
she is the VOCAL TRAINER...
she is queen of king of masked singer in pilot ep and recently
she is with most singing experience among all of the rest .
@@sitikhadijah1476 uji got better technique from another teacher I'm pretty
Yeah. And she is the vocal teacher EXID before uji out from exid. And then solji in to EXID as leader
Don't Question lol how do you know?
@an Army , you're better googling. You will know all about Solji. Solji is the best one(not only one) leader/vocal high note.
Nia Larasati who are you talking to sis? i'm not replying to you and ofc ik all about solji-
Solji ❤️❤️☺️☺️
SOLJI 😍
Yeahhh!!!
Solji
For this videoTaeyeon is the best followed by Uji with Solji and Solar just behind them.
A4 - Uji>Taeyeon>Solji>Solar
Bb4 - Uji>Taeoyeon>Solar>Solji
B4 - Taeyeon>Solji/Solar>Uji
C5 - Taeyeon>Uji>Solji>Solar
C#5 - Taeyeon>Uji>Solar>Solji
D5 - Taeyeon>Uji>Solar>Solji
Eb5 - Taeyeon>Solji>Solar>Uji
E5 - Solar/Taeyeon>Uji>Solji
F5 - Taeyeon>Uji>Solar>Solji
F#5 - Solji>Solar>Taeyeon>Uji
G5 - Solji/Taeyeon>Uji>Solar
G#5 - Solji>Taeyeon>Uji
Solji !!
Solji for me (She isn't the current king of the masked singer for nothing "Dongmakgol Girl (?)")
Yepp that's her
Taeyeon Solji
fun fact: solji used to be uji's vocal trainer back when uji was in exid
Before the 3 member out from exid (yuji,dami,haeryeong), Solji is the vocal trainer exid, and when they out, she become exid member too #sorryformyenglish
Yep
really? she outdid her trainer. no offense
@@Lucas-or1ic I think he has not overcome, solji has much more potential, watch his new videos.
ruclips.net/video/O9InLQtXQsA/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/MaoHjWQ6enA/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/ArT0fX7yTag/видео.html
@IDGAF HOE tbh. Solji is much better
Solji’s runs after that F#5 on “Maria” were amazing omg
12:29
Solar. Her voice is so powerful and stable ❤️❤️
Solji tops at maintaining powerful but clean high notes even with climbing swirl.
SOLJI~
1. Solji
2.Taeyeon
3. Solar
5:05 7:46 and 10:42 wow got goosebumps. Taeyeon unni is definitely the best. Solar UJI and Solji are really good too
When you start off with a Queen of high notes and singing “Ailee” my opinion
1. Solji, Taeyeon
2.Uji
3. Solar
Fun Fact: If you guys didn’t know, Solji debuted before SNSD and a lot of other girl groups and she’s also coming back from her treatment after being diagnosed with hyperthyroidism, EXID comeback as 5 members, if Solji didn’t have this disease she would probably be able to sing to good better than now
Well, I don't think time of debut automatically makes someone a better vocalist... other factors have to be taken into account. There are many new vocalists that have better technique compared to those who may have debuted before them. Also, I don't know how long Solji was a trainee or how long she's been training to be a singer, but Taeyeon has taken professional vocal lessons since she was in middle school.
@@Lena-zn4re lol she didint talk about being debut early means she good....she just tell that she the most senior out of other singer here
@@ultrakill40 what is the purpose when we know Solji is senior here ?? Is she just tell that fact without any purpose ??? lol
@@Lena-zn4re that's true ! Technically singing Taeyeon is more skilled than Solji in term of mixed, head voice & agility.
@@mailanapriyolestariyanto3740 the purpose is you to think....
Taeyeon doing the high notes wothout any problem she's the best
Even if my ult bias is solji, Taeyeon no doubt wins here.
It's weird that on solji's case, she sounds so much better on the higher note but kinda strained on the lower note. How's that even possible lol
And now that I look at it, ur just a Solji hater, so that makes ur opinion even less valid
moshisolji Uji has the widest supported range
@IDGAF HOE Solji and Taeyeon have most support up until their 4th octave. Though Taeyeon seems to have more resonance in her lower-mid range versus Solji, who can go higher than Taeyeon.
@@izonexbae Most of her notes above a C5 are either a bit strained or have very little resonance. And as far as range goes, Uji may have a higher range compared to Taeyeon, but Solji and Uji have pretty similar ranges and even then, Solji has more resonance compared to Uji.
Lena C but Uji supports way lower than all of them so that’s why her support is the widest. It’s not only about how high
They all have a good voice, but I think Taeyeon voice sounds more attractive and versatile.
A4-Taeyeon
Bb4-Uji/Taeyeon
B4-Solar (this resonance)/Taeyeon
C5-Taeyeon
C#5-Taeyeon (Uji's runs though she did THAT)
D5-Taeyeon/Uji (Tae is more consistent on this note but Uji notes were quite nice, I really like her vibrato)
Eb5-Taeyeon because she's the only one who ever supported this note even if it is not consistent
After this, it's really subjective~
E5-Taeyeon, Uji's E5 are kind of a mess but anyway I like those
F5- Uji sounded the more comfortable
F#5-Solji
G5-Solji
G#5-Solji/Uji
Objectively talking: Taeyeon> U.Ji> Solar/> Solji
My opinion: Uji> Taeyeon> Solar/Solji, Solji's vibrato kind of limits her resonance it's too fast and Taeyeon strain is not agreable to listen.
U.Ji is my bestie though lol
the flawless In this video Taeyeon did the best, but overall Uji is a more well rounded vocalist bc of her lower range.
the flawless one Uji is my bestie lol i see what you did there
Viral BloodStains lol no pun intended
The best of both is taeyeon, until A4-G5 always concistent, her resonant is best, but solar is good..
That was long lol but worth it to hear them
I have to say it would be TAEYEON>UJI/SOLJI>SOLAR
but tbh they are all great and the difference is not much at all
I'm sorry but taeyeon isn't better than uji
taeyeon is really great 💖
Solji taeyeon and solar 😍😍😍😍😍😍
1. Solji
2. Taeyeon
3. Uji
4. Solar
But this is just based on my personal preference, I just feel Solji can transmit such feelings like no other and she could make me cry no matter what she sings(? And with Taeyeon is the same but not with every kind of song. But damn that girl Uji she's AMAZING. I think they all are in the same level. But you know Solji is my one and only.
Also about Solar I wasn't aware of her damn great voice. I knew she was good but in this video she surprised me. Definitively I will check them all better.
Taeyeon
i choose solji💖
1 taeyeon
2 solji
3 solar
4 uji
IDGAF HOE
Cause it sounds open doesn’t mean that it’s supported!
Sorry but everyone denying Uji isn't best sounds so retarded here. It's literally just vocal technique and range, Uji is the best at these, you don't have to think her voice is pretty sounding to acknowledge this fact
IDGAF HOE
i didn’t know abt Uji’s lower register being that low(with support) so she’s the best here but we can’t ignore the fact that 2nd and early 3d gen had the best vocals
@@izonexbae I'm with you,gen 4 is a doodle
I think that Teyeon can control her voice better than the other so it is sound more stable :)
Taeyeon
Solji
Uji
Solar
I don't know why but Taeyeon's high note is really addicting.
Hafizh F You're not alone dude😂
it’s because you can see she’s a trained vocalist, she’s the second best between these 4 so it’s understandable why you would like her higher register😂
El. C. second?!
ριиктαи Yeah Uji is a bit better vocally but not by a lot
@@小说-g6j overall, uji comes first with her extremely well developed lower register but taeyeon is better when it comes to belting
Taeyon
Solji
Solar uji
1st taeyeon
2nd solji
3rd solar
4th uji
Solji NO.1
im back here again and as always i am so proud of solji :> welp everyone here is amazing here but i am still astounded by solji in koms 2018
Solji 😘❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Wow Solji’s first C#5 was pleasant(but no one beats Taeyeon on this note from here). Overall I think Taeyeon leads but Uji is a bit behind due to her lack of resonance above C5 and consistency. Solji and Solar are quite even but I think solar needs to be a bit less chesty and solji’s resonance could be way bigger if she was more open. Btw plz could you make a studio vs live high note video for Hyorin? Great vid tho❤️
I was waiting for a comment like this 🙂
ριиктαи 😘
They are good singers, their high notes are good. But, I prefer Taeyeon and Solji both are good on high notes. But, Uji and Solar are good too, but I can't see a stable high note from B4 to G#5
Also, I love them:) Good Luck my girls ♥✨
1. Taeyeon: Her tone is the most desireable. Her technique is good. She tends to be airy when she ascends while belting but not much of an issue. Emotional appeal like come on, Taeyeon slaps you with emotions. But yeah, her voice can be a bit airy (maybe she is just exhausted?) Because there are instances her voice is swallowed with playback or background but in this clip she nailed it.
2. Solji: Her Agility and Musicianship is incredible. Her head voice isn't that great but her falsetto is audible enough. Her technique is very pushed and throaty so she strains alot but she kills the fifth octave with her tone but she needs to be more free/open in her technique. She sustains C5 well but she strained. One thing I like about her is that she can sustain and be able to rise it up a notch. Her vocal acrobats are life (she' a vocal coach after all). I love her more fore hitting flat or sharp notes with clarity and ughh.
3. Uji: I don't know much of her technique but she strains most of the fifth octave and she has that shouty factor. Her resonance and vibratos are almost unaudible.
4. Solar: She pushes her voice too much so she strains. She is very throaty but her breathing technique and lung capacity is fzcking insane that's why she sustains them.
Personal opinion though.
No entiendo algo porque primero Taeyeon si dices más puntos positivos de Solji
Taeyeon is the best voice for me. Others just can be rookie for her. She sings amazing and difficult song since her debut. And she is a singer for 12 years.
Solji debut in 2006 lol whos the rookie now ?
@@no-gz2nb Taeyeon was featured in The One song in 2004. Sit down. Taeyeon has more experience. And she freaking strain her high notes.
@@AoDk673 she debuted early doesn’t mean she’s automatically good lol she can’t even hit her highnote properly on SNSD
I love the fact that taeyeon's clips are mostly from her concerts and not from tv/music shows. She is really more confident in front of us sones!!
Woooooooooooo Solji Solji Solji Solji of exid the soul full Solji woooooooo I hope you get better
Solji king of masked singer~ she`s Queen 👑 👑 👑 👑 👑
My opinion:
1. Solji
2. Taeyeon/Uji
3. Solar
At this moment, Uji will never be on Taeyeon’s level
@@kyliejenner4708 wrong she's better than Taeyeon now
They all sound amazing, so talented~😮 I prefer Taeyeon's voice simply because there's something (smoother? More effortless? Perhaps soothing is the right word) about it. It's really down to personal preference, all these girls are so incredible. 😍❤❤❤
Solji of course
Taeyeonnnn
Solji slaying the G5 in tears as if it’s nothing!
13:12
I think Solji is the best
I prefer Uji from A4-B4/C5, from that point Taeyeon wins everything until like... G5/G#5 where I like Uji's straining better lol
EXIDek solji’s G5 and G#5 were more pleasant to hear personally.
I have my opinion and you can fight me about it all you want
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I think all of them are amazing, personally solji tickles my emotions the most but they’re all incredible!
*My personal opinion.*
1. Taeyeon/Solji (I honestly couldn't choose between them so yep.)
2. Uji/Solar
Honestly all of them are top notch vocalists! Like all of them have amazinggggg highnotes and emotion in their voice! This ranking was pretty hard to make for me since all of them are talented.
Solji eomma😇
Comments majority will say Taeyeon/Solji/Mamamoo as they are extremely well-known. U.Ji is seriously one of the most underrated vocalists out there, she shouldn't be discounted because she is unpopular.
Taeyeon/Solji
Uji
Solar
Solji😘😍😍
1. Uji
2. Taeyon
3. Solar
4. Solji
Is about technic
I'd say it would be Taeyeon>U.Ji>Solar>Solji. Personal preference would be U.Ji>Taeyeon>Solar>Solji. Nice video as always!💕
why taeyeon's voice is very comforting and satisfying to listen :) not to mention that her voice is the distinct one for me,the others are just almost the same in my ears and they got this husky voice :') i think maybe i'm not in that kind of voice
TAEYEON cans control her voice very well but sometime she doesn't but it's fine 😉about her voice.
The problem is about her mic😉
Taeyeon is the best for me because her voice has proper technique and her vocal color is so pretty, her voice is also unique.
I like Uji 2nd cause her voice is also supported and her vocal color is pretty too.
I like Solar's voice the 3rd and Solji Last.
I LOVE ALL OF THEM THO
Solji♥️♥️♥️🍑🥳🤩🥰🤩
I thing is the best
I love exid forevery
To me the best is Solar. She 's voice is more mature than others. She's also so comfortable with this notes. She's voice is more stable. The others are so good also but Solar's technic and maturity got me :) I recommend you Mamamoo - Love Story Of A Girl. Solar's 8 seconds long high note :D 5:03 start from there :D
Indeed...when she reach high note it is Full NOT Thinning out, Consistent, Clean and with Emotions.
These 4 vocal divas are the best of KPOP industry at present,
It's not fair to say who is the winner but they could slay on the stage whenever where they are,
that's my opinion.
Thanks for making this great video, well done.
Taeyeon resonance is no joke in A4 ~ C#5 range, also that nice D5s & Eb5s.
Taeyeon/Uji >> Solar > Solji
Why would you all not think solji is first just watch it again , let's not compare the highest note, in the middle around d#-E part ; those high note some of them are already standing still and focusing on reaching the note whole solji is still dancing and still reach it without problem
Yes there are problems. And the problem is that solji is straining and pushing too much
@@yuankent9 and yet, I still prefer her voice to Solar and Uji. Don't get me wrong, I love Solar's voice. Mamamoo's vocal line is outstanding. I find Uji sometimes borders on screaming. Taeyeon is always so stable and has an amazing range, love her! But Solji managed to get emotions through like no other when she sings. And emotions are a big part of enjoying music. Technique is one thing, but it's not everything.
@@carinedemolin7832 emotions is also one thing, not everything. Yes emotions can help you become famous but can it give you longevity in vocal health? Of course not. If you have proper technique, you'll be able to do stylistic singing to add more color and emotions to your voice without risks why? Because then, you know how to control everything you do compared to singers who only focus on styles and bringing emotions
Mina's right foot glass slipper
i’m giving props to Solji for singing the same way for almost 10 years so she actually knows what she’s doing. Yes she can improve but she has a supported range that is actually way wider than most idols esp of these past generations(3 and 4th)
@@carinedemolin7832 you don't talk about emotion of it's not taeyeon. Lol. It's literally the biggest aspect of her voice. Emotion.
Seeing my username you might think I'll choose Solji but personally this is my ranking:
1. Taeyeon
2. Uji
3. Solji
4. Solar
TAEYEON❤️❤️❤️❤️
I think all these singer are awesome and they're able to reach that high notes with their powerhouse vocals.
However, i can't feel the emotion from those singer except from solji and taeyeon and for me thats the most important. How the feeling and emotion tranfered from singer to the audience. These 2 are on another level. The type of singer that can make people happy, uplifting, sad, or even cry...
I'm in love with Solar's high notes, just my opinion.
Taeyeon and Solji 💕💕
Taeyeon ❤
A4 - best is Uji
Bb4 - Solar
B4 - Solar, I mean that resonance
C5 - Solar
C#5 - Solar and Taeyeon
D5 - Taeyeon
Eb5 - Taeyeon and Uji
E5 - Solji...
F5 - I think Solar
F#5 - Taeyeon
G5 - Uji
G#5 - I think Solji
That's my opinion, based on the best note of each note. I believe Solar is the most consistent through all the range in the video, Solji would be the least.
Yes solar
Nobody beats Taeyeon in C#5
they are all great and have different voices which makes it hard to choose who's the best but I'll choose taeyeon cause she can control her voice and pull it off amazingly and next is solar,solji and uji..
Taeyeon is the legend vocalist
Uji is so underrated
This is my ranking:
1. Solgi
2-Uji
3-Solar
4-Taeyon
🇧🇷🇧🇷
😂😂😂😂 taeyeon is Queen of vocal she's most beautiful vocalist female idol OK solji uji solar is useless
@@lovelyyukari9042 don't be too biased lol . Maybe you haven't watch solji king of masked singer yet . Taeyeon is good but saying others useless is stupid .
@@lovelyyukari9042 This is MY ranking sis, not the REAL ranking, you don't need agree with me
Lovely Yukari We know you’re a fan of taeyeon that’s why you said she’s the best vocalist but you didn’t even listen to the remaining girls. Sis you better keep your mouth shut if you haven’t heard them :))
Taeyeon, solid and clear voice
When Taeyeon sing high note, it doesn't even heard like a high note..but when others idol sing the same note, they are like struggle to hit it..maybe taeyeon voice is soft..
J'aime 🎤
For me
1) Solji(Godess)
2)Taeyeon(Angel)
3) Solar(Queen)
4) Uji(Princess)
Ok but if we base it on vocal technique and supported range, switch Solji and Uji, and then your list makes sense
@@randomsheep1165 wtf, solji TRAINED uji.
its solji>uji>taeyeon>solar
@@smellycat5329 who cares? Because Uji is better than Solji now. It goes
Uji>Taeyeon>Solar/Solji
Your idea that just because Solji taught Uji means that Uji can never surpass her is incredibly stupid
@@randomsheep1165 fair point. But it does not change my ranking. Taeyeon and Uji strain a lot in upper 5th octave, even though they have better resonance than Solji in lower notes. Solji is also more agile than both of them and has better runs. and Solar... well she's amazing and i love her tone but she's a pusher (imo she isnt even technically the best in mamamoo.)
i guess some might put solji after uji, but NEVER after taeyeon. i LOVE her, am a proud sone (actually not even a leggo) but she strains so much in her upper range sometimes, i actually get worried for her.
@@smellycat5329 Taeyeon being smart vocalist, she try to sing in her range which why she keep improving through the years. Solji clearly struggling those notes. She push those notes and become more strained and throaty above D5. It may sounds pleasant to you but it damaging her vocal cords because almost of the time she sings outside of her supported range. While Taeyeon resonate up to D5 and has shown a lot of supported Eb5's now. Overall Taeyeon is a better vocalist. Taeyeon and Uji definitely win this
Taeyeon in my heart coz she has a unique voice not like others.. 😊
taeyeon is the best
1. Uji/Taeyeon
2. Solji
3. Solar
Lol you put Uji's Vocal Trainer on second?
_jungeunbi_ she was the group's vocal trainer but Uji surpassed her lol. The best case of the student surpassing his teacher xD
lol really? Uji *surpassed her* where did u get the fact? and also Uji is not a student. Vocal Trainer and Teacher are different ok? and Solji will be always better than Uji. Uji cannot be better than Solji if Solji was her vocal trainer so it means Solji is a better vocalist and higher vocalist level than Uji.
_jungeunbi_ lol Uji has better technique maybe she was worse but now she's better than Solji and i'm gonna argue with you cuz we're both Loona stans xD
In this world.. the vocal trainer would always have a better technique than a normal singer bc a normal singer would have to train their vocal bc they maybe need a training to improve so to make a normal singer better at singing we hired a vocal trainer that is better than her if Solji wasn't better than her she might not be her Vocal Trainer. And as i said b4 Uji cannot be better than Solji if Solji was her vocal trainer. and loona are not part of our conversation ok?
Taeyeon always the best consistent to B4 to D5
QUEEN Taeyeon
Taeyeon lead vocals of K-pop
태연 태연 태연 태연 태연 태연 태연 태연 태연 태연 태연 태연
Solji I love uuu 😍❤️
Solji is the best vocal of kpop industry for sure.
lina from the grace is
That's such a lie omg there's so many vocalists who are better than her. Maybe if you only listen to 3rd gen groups you would think she's the best (even though there are a handful of 3rd gen singers who are better than her)
@bob Hertz "I don't know anything about Solji" apart from standing EXID since debut but whatever floats your boat.
Just because someone is "respected in the industry" doesn't mean they're actually the best singer. There are many extremely underrated vocalists out there who people don't even know of. Just because IU is "respected in the industry" does that make her one of the best vocalists? Lol no
Me looking at the vocal technique of a singer and being objective isn't "laughable". What is "laughable" is seeing someone being branded as something they're not and then falling for it brainlessly. Solji is a good vocalist in kpop but there are many other main vocalists who are much better than her
@bob Hertz hello, actually you can determine when someone is a better singer than another by analysing their vocal technique. This has nothing to do with artistry, this is cold hard objective facts.
You believe Solji is the best singer but this is solely down to artistry. You "like" her vocal tone the best, you believe she conveys emotions the best. But these are all subjective measures, unlike vocal technique.
@bob Hertz this is the problem. To you, a good singer is a singer that makes you feel a certain way. As a singer, Solji is one of the best performers and can convey a lot of emotions. But you are completely ignoring the fact that when I'm saying someone else is a "better singer" then this is because they have better vocal technique. This means they support more consistently at a wider range instead of straining, it means they have good breath control, it means their voice is agile and their registers are connected. These are what makes someone, on a technical level, a good singer. Just because someone has a pretty voice and they make you feel good that doesn't mean they are actually a stronger vocalist than another singer who may seem bland to you, but is objectively a more proficient vocalist.
Taeyeon of course.
Solji ♥ solji ♥ solji ♥
SOLJI Queen 😍
1.taeyeon
2.solji
Soji
taeyeon is by far the best, all of her notes up to Eb5 are supported at least in the video, followed by uji with D5, then solar with her C#5 and solji is the weakest, with support only at C5 and just one C#5, solji is also very tense and screams more than sings, solar is too much chesty, taeyeon has the most balanced mix even at E5-G#5 when she strains a lot... and her vibrato is just superior
I agree with everything but Uji has better F5-G#5 in mix
I love that everyone is talking about solji. EXID is my bias group and I'm so happy