Octane Vs Redshift - Which RENDER ENGINE right for you?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 сен 2019
- IG📸: / theo_kerr_
Tweet Me: tr_kerr_?lang=en
MY classes 🔥: theokerr.art/classes
LUTS For VFX artists and colorist!www.theokerr.art/color
PROJECT FILES! gum.co/Rmjrb
------------------// Thanks for watching! \\----------------------
Subscribe to stay UPDATED !!!!!
ruclips.net/user/TKIII?sub_c... 
Развлечения
![PIECE BY PIECE - Official Trailer [HD] - Only In Theaters October 11](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7Bc6trBc1kc/mqdefault.jpg)
I liked that you kept it short and straight to the point.
I've been using Octane for 4 years, it's great for small and simple (or _VERY_ well optimized) scenes - beyond that it crashes constantly.
damn the sound quality in the intro is amazingly good
i have been using octane for about 2 years now and really do love but but recently added redshift and really loving that i love the speed redshift brings but then i love octane and its ease of use lol thanks for the video
I used Octane for 1.5 years and then moved to Redshift, at first out of curiosity (still loyal to Octane). I stayed w/ Redshift because the developer activity is totally insane (in a good way). They seriously listen to their customers and are super responsive. I once had a bug I pointed out in the forums addressed in the next build release 1 week later. And yes, it is more stable than what I remember from Octane, but it's not totally crash-proof. One of the things they're addressing in the upcoming version 3.0 (which has alpha build releases in the forums if you're a customer) is the need to "dig really deep into settings" for certain results. They're working on greatly simplifying that. The biggest thing I had missed from Octane was the post effects (bloom/glare) which they thankfully added earlier this year, and it's actually better than what I remember from Octane! But I am holding on to my Octane v4 license, just cuz :)
It's about the developers for me!
thank you very much.... they way you talk is amazing ( nice and calm ).
Yes absolutely we do like these kinds of talks and info
This was really helpful, thank you
Thank you for this comparison!
Exactly the video I was looking for. Came straight from Andrey Lebrov :D
What about u-render compared to these 2?
And resuming your video, it means that octane is better for beginners to get results?
Theo - appreciate cool video :) helped a lot. One question - which software easier to learn understand Octane Standalone vs C4D Octane Plugin? HUGE thanks for your answer.
the music is fire
Thanks for the heads up on OCTANE & RTX.
I was looking at buying two RTX 2080ti for OCTANE 2019 but sadly they pushing it already too long...
Subscribed!
which version of octane support RTX Graphics cards?
I would seriously appreciate some Redshift stuff from you.
@@THEOexr Amazing! yea this Greyscale course I find sooo tedious and dull. I wish it was more... fun!
@@THEOexr lol! Fucking hours of beer can droplits, woohoo! ... Honesty not much else apart from a couple utube channels, namely Five31 and Blue Fox Creation. There is also Helloluxx's Redshift courses which i found alot better for someone starting out as apposed to the GSG one.
I've been using Arnold for 3 years until COVID arrived to our lives, during the lockdowns I started to use Octane and I looooove it, yeah it crashes a lot, but hopefully sometime in the near future Mr Otoy will help us with that inconvenient...I love the lighting system and nodes editor, it is a render to have fun with...we need a stable version, that's it!
looking forward to render architecture projects in short time for each frame and don't necesserly need photorealistic, just shorter time than Vray based on CPU. is a Gtx 1060 6gb good for octane on C4d?
Also, why does Octane Crash? Is there a reason?
I'm confused by OTOY's sale model. Redshift's model seems better, you own the software & get a years worth of support and upgrades.
Render time is super important. I rendered an animation in vray, it took 10 hours pr. frame, so I looked for an alternative, it was fstorm, it took 10 min pr. frame and looked better right out of the box!
Hey theo, great video. Keep it up.
I've been using Redshift for some time now, and I really love it. The performance is great, but the only problem is it supporting other plugins. I've had so many issues trying to use other plugins, and even some of 3DS Max own particle system. Right now from what I've tested, it old works with PFlow, the other particles systems won't render. And the biggest headache is dealing with volumetrics, especially plugins like FumeFX. After creating the simulation, you need to save and import the VDB file, but somehow it always gives me very different results. Redshift did say that it was because of it being a GPU render and the FumeFX being cpu based, so it can't flow together directly. I was wondering what about Octane? Does it support most of the plugins, especially like FumeFX? Thanks!
I'm using redshift. I'm interested in octane because of the desire to try. Should I move?
@@tompcg4675 I honestly can't tell you. Because I am still using Redshift and have never tried Octane. Maybe the others will be able to advice you.
I haven't worked on any of them yet but wanna learn it now for freelance projects. Which one should I start? Plzz suggest me so that my tume doesn't get wasted
The vast majority of artists on IG that i've talked to use octane. A blender here and there but pretty much mostly octane.
I used Redshift but switched to Octane yesterday, main reason: there's way more documentation/tutorials etc for Octane, and it's cheap (20$ each month).
Thijs, please could you tell me the way you switched to Octane with price $20 each month? Because at OTOY's official site the price is $265?
@@dvada8716 там можно выбрать за 16 евро в месяц, но только будет поддерживать 2 видеокарты
@@art_means_artificial Спасибо!
I love Octane a lot
I tried Vray, Corona and Arnold but then I tried Octane and i feel that this render which made for me.
Redshift is pretty friendly too but I still prefer Octane.
see the problem is once you get use to it with one particular Render, Software or System then it is little difficult to move for another.
for an example Cinema 4D User will get frustrated to use 3ds max the way interactive control are different
I use to be 3ds max artist but when i totally turn myself into cinama 4d and after 4 years later i am trying to model inside 3ds max it is very frustrated when I tried to model and interactive control like zoom pan is different.
Will octane run on AMD gpus..? Plz reply.... (love from INDIA )
Nice video thanx allot!!...well Octane vulkan is out by know so they came through, i use Nvidia though. I got the blender version I've been waiting for this to come out!!
may I ask what is your pc specific
Octane has crashed on me twice in a week. But that's just a small trade off for the speed it delivers.
Also congrats on the 1k subs! :D
@@THEOexr yeah, I'm fairly new to Octane. Hobbyist, building my portfolio. Chose octane over redshift. Keep those octane tutorials and tips coming!
I wish Octane would crash twice a week for me. For now I'll have to put up with twice an hour. Im so close to dropping Octane, I cant get any work done
@@tobyhallam4750 Damn, that's terrible. What specs are you running on?
@Lokesh I run 3x 1080Ti at home, and 3x RTX 2080Ti at work. I usually find it crashes when I’m changing / editing materials while in realtime preview.
@@tobyhallam4750 wow. That's a nice graphic setup. I've had similar issues with PT. Try DL instead that has never crashed when I edit the materials.
You haven't really tried redshift, but thanks for the info :)
thank you bra appreciate you
haha i love the crash ending hhhhha
I was running it in the background and working in c4d .. god i was shocked lol..
So if you want the content to look as realistic as possible then Octane is the way to go right? Like the 2007 movie Beowulf, if they had Octane we wouldn't be able to tell the difference between that and a live action? Right?
You're taking the piss, right ? If not, Beowulf was meant to be stylistic you fucking bell-end...
I'm wondering is Octane or redshift is better for a Mac Book pro with AMD Graphics card? as I saw that octane works with Nvidea
I think you cannot use octane with a AMD video card.
Octane is free for blender done , what else do you need ? :D
Nice ending! ))
The industry is moving towards redshift with most studios using that right now. I love octane because it's simple and quick to learn but am having to learn redshift now too.
@@THEOexr I've gone through a lot of Redshift training. Helloluxx Vol 1 & 2 is the best by far. It really helped me embrace what Redshift can do.
@@THEOexr There's a tutorial series by Hellolux. Also, greyscale gorilla's redshift training. In terms of youtube tutorials, these are the good channels - Jesus Fernandez, LFO design, Cinema 4D Tutorials SV,
GBin Y, BLUE FOX Creation, Five31
, WINBUSH, Effect-A-Tron, You And Me Academy
@@TheEpicAB 谢谢
I have octane and gtx 1660 gpu, but octane does not work it says "there is no cuda device which is selected" tried everything out there but nothing works, can anyone please help me !!
Dude gtx 1660 only support octane 3.8 and above version. I have tried 3.7 many ways. Its no use. Try update your octane version. Thats the olny way to fix.
@@motiondeshahil okay, thank you very much
Dude you look like the next Airwolf Pilot.
Please made a video on how u create ur intro
5:34 exactly :))
Sorry, stupid question and probably not the place to ask, but do you use Mac or PC? I have 6K budgeted for a new machine to speed up render times, will I need a PC to run octane? It seems my current mac won't run it?
@@THEOexr thank you for confirming my suspicions!
I've been using Octane Render for 3 years now and I can count on one hand the amount of times it's crashed. It's one of the most stable render engines I've ever used.
@@THEOexr I was running Octane with 2 980tis on an older 4930k i7 and it constantly crashed. Even on simple scenes. Usually within the first 15 minutes of a long render. I recently upgraded to a 2990wx and so far... stable as can be. GPU temps seem to have a lot to do with it too. Got a few water-cooled cards as well and they are not only super stable, but they seem faster to boot.
@@devenjameslangston Using a GTX1070 & i7-8700k and I just save every 1-2 with the shortcut. Musclememory is real :P
@@Min3styl3r if you've already got the muscle memory it's a moot point but why not just turn on autosave?
I legit hate nodes lol. Like I really haven't even bothered with them. I just find my way around things and keep the camera back.
Can you recommend me which render is better for weak PCs?
for example:
CPU: Intel Celeron CPU G540 2.50GHz 2 cores
GPU: Geforce 9800 GT 1 gb 256 bit
RAM: 8 Gb
Don't use them if you have celeron, and 1gb of vram... just don't it'll max them out and you might crash
Thanks Matt Damon!
Octane is a beautiful renderer that I really wanted to use. However if your using it with Maya its absolutely rubbish, its good for making a few stills, it crashes non stop, you will run into so many brick walls with it, the support for it is absolutely rubbish and slow.
I tried taking on a small production with it and I just ran into way too many problems.
The support for Cinema 4D and octane is insane though so if your a cinema 4D user then Octane is a great choice however Maxon recently bought redshift so redshift will just get even better integration into cinema 4d in the future, Octane will have a hard time keeping up with the funding Redshift now has.
No, the plugin in cinema 4d is also way to unstable to use in production since v4. I love octane, but the constant crashes, slow updates, and the fact that you must use old drivers made me buy redshift.
And boy, do I love redshift, the stability and speed alone makes me never use octane. Its a shame, cause octane was great, till v4 that is, and i refuse to buy the 2019 update because they wont release a stable v4.
Doesn't take much effort to get realistic results from Redshift, so slightly biased (no pun intended lol) comparison. Used to use Octane, loved it. Moved to redshift and love it, very stable, and realistic results are achievable very quickly, with all the controls to make your renders very fast indeed. Red shift 3 takes this to a new level with RTX suppourt. Never looked back
Sean Tucker Too bad the nodes are so long and complicated to figure out. The UI and settings don’t make it user friendly.
ye, i want to move to redshift cus octane crushes alot
i am a begginer, dont know too much about this, but from my past experiences... redshift seems to be better for complex projects. at least for me... octane is nice when you start... you get that real look and its good if you post dayle stuff. if i tryed to work on texture nodes... most of the time after 20 min i get a crush...
Redshift is the future, all the major studios use Arnold and redshift. Octane is for the Instagram crowd.
@@justshady agree, i also will soon change my job and go in a studio where ppl use Arnold and Redshift. cant wait!!!
why is that ending the story of my life
octane
go for octane
it's easier
faster
and high quality
wrong question I use Corona renderer
great video, can you make a tutorial octane render for rhino?
Im Starting to feel like blenders cycles/cycles 4d is better than octane in too many ways such as it doesn't crash, it's unbiased as well, it's getting developed much faster, it supports amd and nivida cards, it can do out of core without loosing stability. Octane is still faster but lately it's started loosing it's edge it was known for
It seems like octane is faster but redshift is more powerful. Honestly i see redshift gaining traction more, its built for big productions and is somewhere in between the power of arnold and the speed of octane. And it looks just gorgeous
You MUST caution people for investing lots of money for GPUs when Windows 10 takes 20-25% of your VRAM, not a fixed number.
Так че лучше, пацаны?
I switched to Redshift, because it supports more features in Houdini and animations looks better/smoother for me. And support for other DCCs is a plus for one price. If you want to use Octane in other applications, you need to buy additional licenses and costs grows up.
@@THEOexr If I can help, I worked with octane for over a year on freelance work before buying a license of Redshift this summer. I bought GSG's redshift course at the end of the summer but I was unable to finish the playlist. I find the videos painful to watch. Now, it's been over 3 months that I use redshift, and the adaptation was pretty smooth. I still haven't touch the logic nodes, but for regular shaders using specular, diffuse, SSS, etc, it was pretty much similar to octane, so I wasn't lost and got the hang of it pretty fast. In comparison to Octane, I personally find Redshift to produce a more "high end" imagery. It's easier to have beautiful render, not sure how I can explain it without going too deep in my thoughts aha
The most important thing to know, and maybe the more complex to understand, is render optimization, which is completely different from Octane. Weirdly enough, GSG course didn't go through this most know feature, but a good friend of mine recommended this video, and seriously, after watching it, the concept was easily understood. ruclips.net/video/25YZ--F1aAQ/видео.html I highly recommend to watch at least the first 20min, afterward, it's a demonstration of the render optimization of a scene. The demonstration help a lot to understand what was explained before tho
I think it needs a little bit more tweaks here an there, mostly with sampling but overall it's not so hard to learn. Even that I found it sometimes easier than Octane. And I can agree with @@maximetruchon10, optimazition might be complex but onces you'll learn this, it will speed up your worflow and render times. I think it's the one of the biggest strenghts of Redshift. And also AOV system is pretty cool, you can customize many things there, more than in Octane, I think. I have two Redshift's courses form Rich Nosworthy on helloluxx - he's talking about optimazition too.
Maxime Truchon I’ll watch that video. I was thinking wether should I buy a license or not. But all the stuff I’ve seen for Houdini was made on redshift and I need it. I think
Speed out of the box is a bit of a moot point. Just set your Redshift up how you like it, i.e bells and whistles on GI etc and SAVE IT AS A PRESET. Done...
Octane only crashes on you once a week? Shit you got lucky, it crashes on me sometimes every hour
fstorm
Corona
Octane Win!
I'm a throw a monkey wrench in there and say use Unreal Engine to render 👊🏾
Something I really want to learn.
@@EAprima yea man its really cool. I have a bunch of C4D to Unreal tutorials on my channel and I'm currently working on a course as well.
@@JonathanWinbush Really? Then count me in on learning from you. I'll go check out your channel right now.
@@EAprima Awesome. Yea I was at Maxon today showing them some C4D to UE4 te hniques which went over really well so you'll see me on the NAB stream too showing more UE4 workflows.
@@JonathanWinbush Wonderful. Ok, going to check out your channel now.
Octane still op
octane tem que ser prosesado pelo blender ,,octane é pago 149$
All lecturers fail to deliver usefull information .... in a nut shell redshift is better.
You must be selling lots of NFT right now 😂
Bla-bla-bla. Where tests face to face exterior/interior scene, VFX scene?
LOL
Daddy