This is the he type of movie they should remake. Underrated, and full of action that would look great in live action. We don't need remakes of whimsical Disney classics
@@westinjohnson that is not the point, Drake is in his 30s so to accurately portray him the actor should be in his 30s as well unless you want to make the movie a sequel to the games
Honestly, yeah, Alfred Molina fits pretty well into that sort of character. I was thinking that if Bill Murray still had a gut, he could pull it off pretty well (he played that type of menacing scumbag turned hesitant (grand)parental figure in St. Vincent), but he doesn’t have that build anymore and looks much older than he did in his “fat Bill Murray” days. I could also kinda picture Brendan Frasier, if he’s be open to taking on that sort of action role again (yes, he’s a super sweet man and you might think of him as too nice to play that kind of character these days, but he is an actor, and a very good one), I think he could pull off the intimidating leader with a secret soft side. That, and I kinda just want the best roles for Brendan Frasier in his much deserved return to the spotlight.
It’s their best film in my opinion, followed by Atlantis and the Hunchback. It isn’t a cliché princess story, it isn’t a cliché “hero’s journey”, it’s a story about the importance of a father figure for young men. It takes something that was already good in Treasure Island, stages it within their most creative original universe and uses the characters to make something relatable to young boys who’s dads weren’t always there.
I think this might be your best recasting yet! If even 80 percent of the people you cast were hired on for this film I think it would be a really good movie
@@aspiringjoker2883 , many thought of Brendan Gleeson, because of Mad Eye Moody. But I personally think that won't be good to just type-cast. One alternate I thought of was Andy Serkis. Aside from his mo-cap roles, this guy has done villains. But I'm looking at his role in Adventure Of Tintin where he plays Captain Haddock. I can see him going from former captain to going rogue. Another alternate would be Clancy Brown. Despite his age, this guy nails villain roles, like Lex Luthor, but I'm looking to his video game role as Hank Anderson in Detroit: Become Human. He even is psychically able to pull some badass action. And last can be Russell Crowe. Mainly for Master and Commander and The Nice Guys.
Yeah, and for Silver, another alternate would be Clancy Brown. Despite his age, this guy nails villain roles, like Lex Luthor, and has the pirate accent from voicing Mr Krabs, but I'm looking to his video game role as Hank Anderson in Detroit: Become Human. He even is psychically able to pull some badass action.
My uni professor worked on this film. He said the team wanted it to come out for the spring/ summer instead Disney made it came out in December the same time week as the first Harry Potter film. Disney knew what they were doing.
The choice of casting for both Jim and his mother are ✨PERFECT ✨ they both look EXACTLY like the animation characters and it still baphels (baffels???) me how well the actor and actress of those roles fit perfectly for them.
Has always been my favorite cartoon movie since I was 8, I am 26 now. To me as a kid it was the first time I was seeing CGI, even if partially in a movie, I have no idea why people never liked Treasure Planet, but watching the sequel that was called off back in the day has always been a dream.
I just watched this movie and really, really liked it. Tanner Buchanan was my first choice for Jim. As for the rest, Brendan Gleeson as John Silver Hayley Atwell as Captain Amelia Alan Tudyk as B.E.N. Bill Nighy as Scroop Kelsey Grammer as Dr. Doppler Laurence Fishburne as Mr. Arrow Linda Cardinelli as Sarah Hawkins Yeah, recast Spider-Man.
When you finish running through Disney movies you should do a casting for Robert Kirkman’s Invincible! You could get at least 3 or 4 videos out of it between all the major and side characters.
Okay okay.. I don't get how a masterpiece like this wasn't more popular. I remember the MacDonald toys of the little squishy jelly creature. I faintly remember watching it as a kid. But rewatching it as a young adult who had barely any memories of it I quite enjoyed it! I love any movie that is basically adventure. So this was a blast, good characters, an intriguing world, dramatic moments, amazing animation and VA. Its got it all.
I love fancasts and usually people are so overly swayed in who is a big name -- totally agree with your Tom Holland opinion -- but yours are so thoughtful and genuinely take into consideration age, style, appearance. Smashing job!
I'd like to see you attempt casting something historical one day, it could be something different and interesting. Also, a lot of people seem to be asking for Narnia, which I'd also like to see.
Also Charlie Day played Benny in The Lego Movie who is literally just Ben from Treasure Planet so yeah perfect casting there, plus I think he could really fix a lot of the more grating elements of the original performance.
Love the Charlie Day choice! He's the only actor who can do an absolutely insane character like that without making the audience hate him! I'd love to see you tackle the Dune Saga in the future! Provided this year's Dune does well, we'll be in for a long series of movies in that universe, and I'd love to see what you think of some of the great characters that aren't going to be in this first movie! Cheers!
Funny enough, until he said that, I was convinced there was no recasting Martin Short for the role. Instant realization when he mentioned Charlie Day that I was wrong!
I think Disney might actually have plans for that one. People keep saying they should do it without the Gargoyles, but I personally have to disagree, I say keep the Gargoyles as a serious subtext to show how isolated Quasi is, make it clear that they are only alive in his imagination! They can still serve comic relief, just go deeper with it, if you’re just going to give it a higher rating anyway (the animated movie was G… just a reminder for you), why not go all out and do a PG-13, at the very least, to give yourself more liberties than a modern PG would allow. Make it dark as hell! The whole point of the book was to help save and preserve Gothic Architecture, so make it as macabre as possible!
I do think that one aspect of Silver that I think you might have over looked is his... jolly-ness, for want of a better term. I dunno, I just remember watching this movie as a kid, and Silver had the air of a man who was super chill and happy with his life (even though that's not actually true) - his opening scene has him cooking a meal (since he's the ship's cook after all) and he looks like he's having the time of his life
With the budget of a live action remake they could have an amazing movie on their hands and this already amazing movie could finally see the light of fucking day that it deserves
I’ll be honest, I love Treasure Planet. It was one of my favourite movies growing up as a kid. So this film getting a live action adaptation would be a dream come true. It would give this film, a chance at redemption.
I literally was just thinking I couldn’t see anyone other than Martin Short for BEN, but then you cast Charlie Day and I INSTANTLY changed my mind, you nailed that one!
Love everyone! Martin Freeman as Doctor Doppler is PERFECTION! Always imagined Silver to be played by Robert De Niro tho, he just seems like he would be fantastic as him!
Only thing with Idris Elba is I can’t see him portraying that “boisterous uncle”-like jovial energy Silver has earlier in the film, especially during his introduction scene. I could imagine someone like Andy Serkis able to do that, alongside being a father figure and villain, though Andy Sirkis doesn’t quite have the presence of Idris Elba ofc
The visceral reaction I had to Charlie Day as B.E.N was insane like I literally gasped and grabbed my hair. I would LOVE to see your take on a live-action version of the reboot of She-Ra!
I keep finding myself trying to guess who you'll pick before you say it, coming up empty, and then once you reveal your pick nodding and saying "Oh yea that tracks."
Oh I would LOVE to see you do a Spider-Man Fancast in the same style of your Batman Fancast. Whether that be for the MCU going forward or your own series, I can’t say, I just know it’d be awesome to see
Good Cast man. Here is mine. Timothee Chamalet as Jim Hawkins. Jordan Pelee as John Silver. Scarlett Johansson as Captain Amelia. Jeff Goldblum as Dr. Delbert Doppler. Alan Tudyk as Morph. Rami Malek as B.E.N. Andy Serkis as Scroop. Marisa Tommei as Sarah Hawkins. Josh Brolin as Arrow. Benedict Cumberbatch as Billy Bones. And Bill Nighy as Captain Flint.
I really think Jason Momoa would be a really good John silver, you get that sense of menace in game of thrones, but you also get that softer/caring side in Dune. And of course he has the size and presence for the role. I think he’d be perfect
I really enjoy these casting videos for movies and franchises! I think it would also be cool if you picked a particular actor and discussed all the types of roles you think that person could play (and why). Kind of help us understand your process for making these choice.
The only issue I have with Idris Elba being silver is that he doesn't really have that comedic timing & zany enough personality to fully pull off the character. However, the rest of the casting choices could work well.
I think this might be my favorite casting you've done. I agree with every single one and I could actually see myself watch this. Even though I usually do not bother with the live actions
Love your channel! I’ve never seen Treasure Planet before, but I involuntarily said yes out loud to both Martin Freeman and Hayley Atwell after your descriptions, and then again at the idea of them playing opposite each other! I would also love to see both Christopher Jackson and Michelle Monaghan get some more high-profile work!
I literally just watched this movie last night on Disney plus. It was great! I remember always seeing a cool trailer for the movie on one of my dvds that I watched all the time as a kid. It might’ve been Monsters Inc
Excellent video dude! As soon as I saw your first choice for Jim was Tanner Buchanan, I knew I was in for some good choices of casting. Really wish Treasure Planet gets a real life adaptation, the visuals would just be stunning!
I really love this casting. I wish this would blow up so Disney can get an idea on who to cast for s Treasure Planet live action if they're ever gonna push through with it.
One of my all time favourite Disney movies. I owned the audiobook as a kid, and listened to it every night. I love the characters, the story, the lore, the magic. So wonderful, so underrated! I would go with John Oliver for Doc but besides that good choices.
I think it would be nice to see you tackle some remakes of classic Hollywood movies just for fun... Something like Casablanca, Singin' in the rain, Psycho, 12 angry men, Roman Holidays and so on... But I don't know how many people would be interested in that besides me
Casting for a 12 Angry Men remake would be really interesting. The general archetypes of the characters would be the same, but you'd have to think about how the story would be reinterpreted in a modern context and how that would affect the characterization of each character, and pick an actor who fits based on that.
I never before thought about a life action treasure planet but this is cast looks amazing. I'd love to see what you'd come up for a Valiant Comics movie universe
This movie is one that deserves a live action remake. Imagine how shredded the solar surfing scene would be in life action.
Just as long as they don’t rely too much on CG and try to make it real and cool.
@@osmanyousif7849 I don't know about CGI, one of the cool things about the original IS the CGI, but yeah, trying to be all cool would be a problem
If Treasure Planet should be made into a live action remake who should be the Directors, Producers, and writers of this?
F**K NO !
@@yani2499 bruh, why
This is the he type of movie they should remake. Underrated, and full of action that would look great in live action. We don't need remakes of whimsical Disney classics
Exactly. Remake a lesser known movie to actually improve on it
Yes. Yes. Yes.
@@suzygirl1843 No please don't touch the Iron Giant
They should but Disney wouldn't touch treasure plant with a 10-ft pole.
They canceled the second movie The moment the numbers rolled in
@@gabrielberrios1306 so far we're safe. Warner Bros hasn't really seen a potential for a live-action iron Giant as far as I know of.
I am not kidding it is practically scary how much tanner looks like Jim from the movie as if he walked out of the screen into the real world.
And SOUNDS like him
DISNEY TAKE MY MONEY FOR THIS REMAKE. HIS CAST IS QUITE LITERALLY PERFECT
All will been soon)
Wow! The guy you cast as Jim seems perfect! He looks exactly like him
Ikr, his casting is always on point
Robbie from Cobra Kai yes looks just like him but have never been impressed by his acting
@@aleccampbell7707 Lol I've always said Robbie from Cobra Kai was Jim Hawkins too. I'm so happy I'm not the only person
@@aleccampbell7707 his acting js great
Typecast him as the abandoned child lol
Pls do Atlantis: The Lost Empire, your casting is so good and would love to see what you think about this
YES! Such an underrated movie!
Sup Chris, from MyCast
@@gmirkoi5067 Sup
Coming up next
Did you know there was going to be even a series call Team Atlantis which is a spin-off series on the crew? So much potential.
“Tom Holland doesn’t have that edge”
Casting Agents: let’s make him Nathan Drake
Did these people not think of Nathan Fillion for the role? He's much more the character than Tom.
@@osmanyousif7849 he's 50 tho
@@westinjohnson that is not the point, Drake is in his 30s so to accurately portray him the actor should be in his 30s as well unless you want to make the movie a sequel to the games
Tom Holland can do edge, watch The Devil All The Time.
@@osmanyousif7849 ikr! Nathan made a short video of him as drake and it’s pretty awesome
When i think of Disney's take on Silver, i think of Alfred Molina. He showed the exact same range in Spiderman 2.
Fuck this is the first time i hear a better choice for a role than Bryan suggests
Agreed
He doesn’t scream pirate enough though….
Russell Crowe, Andy Serkis, or Clancy Brown are better.
Honestly, yeah, Alfred Molina fits pretty well into that sort of character. I was thinking that if Bill Murray still had a gut, he could pull it off pretty well (he played that type of menacing scumbag turned hesitant (grand)parental figure in St. Vincent), but he doesn’t have that build anymore and looks much older than he did in his “fat Bill Murray” days.
I could also kinda picture Brendan Frasier, if he’s be open to taking on that sort of action role again (yes, he’s a super sweet man and you might think of him as too nice to play that kind of character these days, but he is an actor, and a very good one), I think he could pull off the intimidating leader with a secret soft side. That, and I kinda just want the best roles for Brendan Frasier in his much deserved return to the spotlight.
Facts.
People who hate on Treasure Planet are just sad. This movie RULES, no doubt about it.
Yeah! It's totally radical!
It’s their best film in my opinion, followed by Atlantis and the Hunchback. It isn’t a cliché princess story, it isn’t a cliché “hero’s journey”, it’s a story about the importance of a father figure for young men.
It takes something that was already good in Treasure Island, stages it within their most creative original universe and uses the characters to make something relatable to young boys who’s dads weren’t always there.
Yes, one of my all time faves!
Never met Treasure Planet haters tho.
This recasting got me hyped for a movie we’re not getting 😫😫😫
This movie along with Atlantis: The Lost Empire are severely underrated, better than anything Disney are doing lately
I think this might be your best recasting yet! If even 80 percent of the people you cast were hired on for this film I think it would be a really good movie
I agree. I personally don't like the Silver casting, and I think Simon Pegg was born for the role of Doc Doppler, but everyone else is perfectly cast
@@aspiringjoker2883 , many thought of Brendan Gleeson, because of Mad Eye Moody. But I personally think that won't be good to just type-cast.
One alternate I thought of was Andy Serkis. Aside from his mo-cap roles, this guy has done villains. But I'm looking at his role in Adventure Of Tintin where he plays Captain Haddock. I can see him going from former captain to going rogue.
Another alternate would be Clancy Brown. Despite his age, this guy nails villain roles, like Lex Luthor, but I'm looking to his video game role as Hank Anderson in Detroit: Become Human. He even is psychically able to pull some badass action.
And last can be Russell Crowe. Mainly for Master and Commander and The Nice Guys.
Your casting for Jim is INCREDIBLE. Yes. 👏🏾
“You’ve got the makings of greatness in ya!”
These casting choices are superb!
I love the idea of Martin Freeman as the doctor but I’d go for Simon Pegg personally.
Yeah, and for Silver, another alternate would be Clancy Brown. Despite his age, this guy nails villain roles, like Lex Luthor, and has the pirate accent from voicing Mr Krabs, but I'm looking to his video game role as Hank Anderson in Detroit: Become Human. He even is psychically able to pull some badass action.
I do think you need to by tall and moderately thin build to accentuate all of his clumsy slapstick nature.
I had Simon Pegg for Ben and Nick frost for Mr arrow
Stellan Skarsgard would be a good fit for Doppler too. Yeah I get that he's in his 70s now but I think he'd a great fit as Doppler.
My uni professor worked on this film. He said the team wanted it to come out for the spring/ summer instead Disney made it came out in December the same time week as the first Harry Potter film. Disney knew what they were doing.
The choice of casting for both Jim and his mother are ✨PERFECT ✨ they both look EXACTLY like the animation characters and it still baphels (baffels???) me how well the actor and actress of those roles fit perfectly for them.
Has always been my favorite cartoon movie since I was 8, I am 26 now. To me as a kid it was the first time I was seeing CGI, even if partially in a movie, I have no idea why people never liked Treasure Planet, but watching the sequel that was called off back in the day has always been a dream.
I just watched this movie and really, really liked it. Tanner Buchanan was my first choice for Jim. As for the rest,
Brendan Gleeson as John Silver
Hayley Atwell as Captain Amelia
Alan Tudyk as B.E.N.
Bill Nighy as Scroop
Kelsey Grammer as Dr. Doppler
Laurence Fishburne as Mr. Arrow
Linda Cardinelli as Sarah Hawkins
Yeah, recast Spider-Man.
You forgot Morph….
@@osmanyousif7849 Indeed.
Shirley Henderson(Babu Frik from Rise of Skywalker) as Morph
@@thefilmwatcher1216 , that works. And what about Andy Serkis for Silver. I mean he did play Captain Haddock in Tintin.
@@osmanyousif7849 Yeah, that would be cool.
When you finish running through Disney movies you should do a casting for Robert Kirkman’s Invincible! You could get at least 3 or 4 videos out of it between all the major and side characters.
How can you make a live action Invincible without JK Simmons as Omni-Man? THINK MATT! THINK!
Would LOVE to see this! Ryan Potter for Mark Grayson would be a great casting imo.
@@legoharry100 I would totally be ok with that!
@@MrRobertGillan Beast Boy would also make a good Monkey D Luffy
Okay okay..
I don't get how a masterpiece like this wasn't more popular. I remember the MacDonald toys of the little squishy jelly creature.
I faintly remember watching it as a kid.
But rewatching it as a young adult who had barely any memories of it I quite enjoyed it!
I love any movie that is basically adventure. So this was a blast, good characters, an intriguing world, dramatic moments, amazing animation and VA.
Its got it all.
In light of Guardians of the Galaxy being very successful, I could imagine Treasure Planet being the next GoTG of sorts.
Favorite movie of all time!!! To this day I still listen to John Rzenik’s “ I’m still here “ and it gives me the chills
I love fancasts and usually people are so overly swayed in who is a big name -- totally agree with your Tom Holland opinion -- but yours are so thoughtful and genuinely take into consideration age, style, appearance. Smashing job!
I'd like to see you attempt casting something historical one day, it could be something different and interesting. Also, a lot of people seem to be asking for Narnia, which I'd also like to see.
I'd be down with historical stuff too. I once tried to cast every U.S. president lol
This is the best Silver fancast I have seen!
Also Charlie Day played Benny in The Lego Movie who is literally just Ben from Treasure Planet so yeah perfect casting there, plus I think he could really fix a lot of the more grating elements of the original performance.
Literally every casting was perfect!! Excellent!!!
Your photoshop skills have been getting waaaay better, -huge props.
Love the Charlie Day choice! He's the only actor who can do an absolutely insane character like that without making the audience hate him!
I'd love to see you tackle the Dune Saga in the future! Provided this year's Dune does well, we'll be in for a long series of movies in that universe, and I'd love to see what you think of some of the great characters that aren't going to be in this first movie! Cheers!
If humans would glitch just like robots do, Charlie Day its how it would look like xD
Funny enough, until he said that, I was convinced there was no recasting Martin Short for the role. Instant realization when he mentioned Charlie Day that I was wrong!
I'd like to see a series for Narnia so we can cover every single book.
For TV?
Netflix aquired the rights for it and is doing a show, apparently
Please do Hunchback of Notre Dame. That's another one that I really think could benefit from a live-action take.
YES!!!!!!!!
Lee Pace would make a good Frollo in my opinion. He has a similar looking nose to Frollo’s anyways.
@@sageturmelle Interesting. My ideal choice would be Alan Rickman if he was still alive.
I think Disney might actually have plans for that one. People keep saying they should do it without the Gargoyles, but I personally have to disagree, I say keep the Gargoyles as a serious subtext to show how isolated Quasi is, make it clear that they are only alive in his imagination! They can still serve comic relief, just go deeper with it, if you’re just going to give it a higher rating anyway (the animated movie was G… just a reminder for you), why not go all out and do a PG-13, at the very least, to give yourself more liberties than a modern PG would allow. Make it dark as hell! The whole point of the book was to help save and preserve Gothic Architecture, so make it as macabre as possible!
I do think that one aspect of Silver that I think you might have over looked is his... jolly-ness, for want of a better term. I dunno, I just remember watching this movie as a kid, and Silver had the air of a man who was super chill and happy with his life (even though that's not actually true) - his opening scene has him cooking a meal (since he's the ship's cook after all) and he looks like he's having the time of his life
With the budget of a live action remake they could have an amazing movie on their hands and this already amazing movie could finally see the light of fucking day that it deserves
I’ll be honest, I love Treasure Planet. It was one of my favourite movies growing up as a kid. So this film getting a live action adaptation would be a dream come true. It would give this film, a chance at redemption.
If it goes well, then it can become the next Guardians of the Galaxy to Atlantis doing the same for Aquaman.
Tanner as Jim is a masterstroke
road to el dorado is extremely underrated and isn't talked about enough! would love to see your castings!
A younger Jon Ham would be great as Tulio.
Yes!
I agree!!
Yeeeeeessssss!!!
" And they call us Miguel and Tulio "
My FAVORITE Disney movie! To this day! From start to finish it’s absolutely fantastic!
I literally was just thinking I couldn’t see anyone other than Martin Short for BEN, but then you cast Charlie Day and I INSTANTLY changed my mind, you nailed that one!
Perfect casting, I CAN ACTUALLY SEE IT. amazing
I'm so happy I'm not there only one who thought of Jim Hawkins when I seen Robbie in Cobra Kai lol Thank you so much for pointing it out
I’ve absolutely loved this movie since day ONE
Nice choices! This is one animated movie I’d like to see as a live action.
Love everyone! Martin Freeman as Doctor Doppler is PERFECTION!
Always imagined Silver to be played by Robert De Niro tho, he just seems like he would be fantastic as him!
This was a great one. Very spot on picks 👏
Why... WHY? ARE YOU NOT THE HEAD CASTING DIRECTOR OF ALL CASTING DIRECTORS IN HOLLYWOOD? Your Casting is SO SUPERB!
I could see Hugh Grant doing Dr. Doppler really well myself, and Emily Blunt as Captain Amelia.
I love your casting choices! They’re absolutely perfect. As soon as you showed Jim, I knew that this was absolutely perfect. 💕✌🏻
This is god tier casting. I was so excited when i saw the first one, ive been saying he would make a great jim since his appearance on cobra kai
Wow! Super impressed with your casting. Nice work!
This is all genuinely perfect. I loved this movie growing up and all of the actors you suggested fit immaculately! Great work!
Only thing with Idris Elba is I can’t see him portraying that “boisterous uncle”-like jovial energy Silver has earlier in the film, especially during his introduction scene. I could imagine someone like Andy Serkis able to do that, alongside being a father figure and villain, though Andy Sirkis doesn’t quite have the presence of Idris Elba ofc
Dude I could totally see Serkis. Didn't even think of that. I was thinking Javier Bardem or Jeffrey Dean Morgan
@@ethanconnor3485 Oh shit Javier Bardem would be really cool to see in that role lol
I could so see JDM playing silver
YES! I KNEW :D Hayley Atwell was going to be your pick for Captain Amelia! The rest of the cast sounds amazing!!
The visceral reaction I had to Charlie Day as B.E.N was insane like I literally gasped and grabbed my hair. I would LOVE to see your take on a live-action version of the reboot of She-Ra!
This is a live action remake I’d want to see before I die
I keep finding myself trying to guess who you'll pick before you say it, coming up empty, and then once you reveal your pick nodding and saying "Oh yea that tracks."
Oh I would LOVE to see you do a Spider-Man Fancast in the same style of your Batman Fancast. Whether that be for the MCU going forward or your own series, I can’t say, I just know it’d be awesome to see
Here's a challenge: Fan Cast of Disney's " Great Mouse Detective". Made in montion capture.
For me Javier is the only option for Silver. His voice, apperience, skills, charisma - everything is here. And Ed Helms as Delbert Doppler.
Dang that Jim casting is on point 👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼
Good Cast man. Here is mine.
Timothee Chamalet as Jim Hawkins.
Jordan Pelee as John Silver.
Scarlett Johansson as Captain Amelia.
Jeff Goldblum as Dr. Delbert Doppler.
Alan Tudyk as Morph.
Rami Malek as B.E.N.
Andy Serkis as Scroop.
Marisa Tommei as Sarah Hawkins.
Josh Brolin as Arrow.
Benedict Cumberbatch as Billy Bones.
And
Bill Nighy as Captain Flint.
once again perfect casting.
I was sceptical but after cobra kai season 4 absolutely YES
I really think Jason Momoa would be a really good John silver, you get that sense of menace in game of thrones, but you also get that softer/caring side in Dune. And of course he has the size and presence for the role. I think he’d be perfect
I really enjoy these casting videos for movies and franchises! I think it would also be cool if you picked a particular actor and discussed all the types of roles you think that person could play (and why). Kind of help us understand your process for making these choice.
Elba as Silver is good. You are reading my mind
The casting is absolutely perfect
Young Decaprio will always forever be the best hypothetical fan casting for this role
My choice would be Michael Sheen as Dr Dobbler, but Martin freeman is just as good and fits very well.
The only issue I have with Idris Elba being silver is that he doesn't really have that comedic timing & zany enough personality to fully pull off the character. However, the rest of the casting choices could work well.
I really LOVE the choices you make, and how you go about them! I've commented before, but PLEASE do Danny Phantom?
damn. the actor you picked for Jim Hawkins is SPOT ON!
AWESOME! Love these picks!!
Jim is one of the sexier boy of Disney animation, the actor has to be amazing !
Your casting was PERFECT. If they don’t use these actors I’ll be so disappointed
This is my childhood favourite movie and I think the people you chose to play the characters are literally perfect!👌🏽🤙🏼
This movie was WAAYYYYYY UNDERRATED!
This cast is so on point is crazy, 10/10
Honestly straight off the bat I would not have picked Tanner for Jim but the more I look at him the more it WORKS.
I think this might be my favorite casting you've done. I agree with every single one and I could actually see myself watch this. Even though I usually do not bother with the live actions
I agree with each selection in this casting! I’d love to see this live action hopefully soon!
EFFING BRILLIANT AS ALWAYS!!!
everything about this casting is perfect
I'm telling you man it would be awesome to see you fancast invincible
The robot should be the only original actor taking back the role I really can't see anyone else voicing him
Love your channel! I’ve never seen Treasure Planet before, but I involuntarily said yes out loud to both Martin Freeman and Hayley Atwell after your descriptions, and then again at the idea of them playing opposite each other! I would also love to see both Christopher Jackson and Michelle Monaghan get some more high-profile work!
Great choices
They are all interesting and not necessarily the first people I would think of but I think they all fit very well
I literally just watched this movie last night on Disney plus. It was great! I remember always seeing a cool trailer for the movie on one of my dvds that I watched all the time as a kid. It might’ve been Monsters Inc
Whoa this is great casting!
2:07 I was thinking the exact same person at the moment 😂
You nailed it, I don’t want another highschool drama. I want this remake
Excellent video dude! As soon as I saw your first choice for Jim was Tanner Buchanan, I knew I was in for some good choices of casting. Really wish Treasure Planet gets a real life adaptation, the visuals would just be stunning!
I really love this casting. I wish this would blow up so Disney can get an idea on who to cast for s Treasure Planet live action if they're ever gonna push through with it.
One of my all time favourite Disney movies. I owned the audiobook as a kid, and listened to it every night. I love the characters, the story, the lore, the magic. So wonderful, so underrated!
I would go with John Oliver for Doc but besides that good choices.
Your casting choices are spot on. Now, we just need to convince Disney.
I think it would be nice to see you tackle some remakes of classic Hollywood movies just for fun... Something like Casablanca, Singin' in the rain, Psycho, 12 angry men, Roman Holidays and so on... But I don't know how many people would be interested in that besides me
Casting for a 12 Angry Men remake would be really interesting. The general archetypes of the characters would be the same, but you'd have to think about how the story would be reinterpreted in a modern context and how that would affect the characterization of each character, and pick an actor who fits based on that.
I never before thought about a life action treasure planet but this is cast looks amazing.
I'd love to see what you'd come up for a Valiant Comics movie universe
your casting is incredible, I really hope that they'll make this movie it's one of my favorites
Fist time watching Cobra kai and that dude pops up first glance and said to myself that's Jim Hawkins
Oh my god this is flawless
This movie was always one of my favorites growing up, also my Uncle looks EXACTLY like Silver which I always found to be pretty funny.