Man City vs Premier League: Who ACTUALLY Won?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 окт 2024

Комментарии • 134

  • @RGSneaks
    @RGSneaks 11 дней назад +55

    Finally a helpful explanation 👍 The Prem has embarrassed itself

  • @SophiaSmith24
    @SophiaSmith24 11 дней назад +77

    I’m a Everton fan, I believe the club wrote a letter to support City

    • @wayneholness6090
      @wayneholness6090 11 дней назад

      Wa@kers

    • @paulbrickland9625
      @paulbrickland9625 11 дней назад +12

      Yes they did thank you

    • @michellemaggs75
      @michellemaggs75 11 дней назад +2

      Thanks a lot 😮

    • @kiwitintinscott
      @kiwitintinscott 11 дней назад +4

      As a life long City fan, thank you, Newcastle & others gor your support. Good luck for the rest of the season and beyond 🫡👍👋

    • @raymondcochrane8617
      @raymondcochrane8617 11 дней назад +5

      Everton actually apologised to City for the things they stated after Everton were fined by the EPL. Then they realised they were taken in by the red cartel and their American owners and now they are supporting City.

  • @BrendaSimmons-v9p
    @BrendaSimmons-v9p 11 дней назад +27

    This is a good start. Hope springs eternal. In no other business sphere would success be so attacked. Keep up the great work Jonny. BLUEMOON PHIL

  • @MAN_CITY-p7d
    @MAN_CITY-p7d 11 дней назад +44

    The Newcastle fans are getting behind city.

    • @stekam79
      @stekam79 11 дней назад +6

      Never trust newcastle and their fans plenty of them were shouting the 115 or cooking the books jibes .....never forget ever

    • @MAN_CITY-p7d
      @MAN_CITY-p7d 11 дней назад +3

      @@stekam79 I know. Now it's different. They all love city now. 🤣

    • @drdassler
      @drdassler 11 дней назад

      @@stekam79 then they used their brains.

    • @DELUSIONALDANNYG
      @DELUSIONALDANNYG 11 дней назад +4

      @@stekam79Newcastle fans have always wanted city to win the case, the real Newcastle fans who actually go the games have always wanted city to win the case because of how much the PL are trying to stop them progressing.
      Every fanbase has twitter fans where they will do anything to wind other fans up. These are the fans that shout “PENALDO” and “PESSI” for Ronaldo and messi getting a penalty etc. it’s pathetic however real match going Newcastle fans have wanted city to win from the very start.
      The premier league didn’t care when Mike Ashley allowed Newcastles highest transfer to be £16M (Michael Owen) from 2005-2019, yes FOURTEEN YEARS of spending no more than £16M on a player. The PL didn’t care then but now cause Newcastle want to spend money they want to hold them back.

    • @shanty4590
      @shanty4590 11 дней назад

      🤷🏼‍♂️👁️👨🏼‍🦲

  • @glacousxx
    @glacousxx 11 дней назад +25

    Manchester city are way too intelligent for the rivals unfortunately for them😂.
    This makes the prem look so embarrassing.
    It seems the rivals have lost their enthusiasm again.
    The corrupt prem and UEFA and fifa have always been the same .
    It's just we're more informed now.
    6:00 the goldbridge roast was very very much needed .

    • @gssf.gr29
      @gssf.gr29 10 дней назад

      That's exactly the point. Masters and co. thought they were too big and too powerful for anybody to take on and expected every club they took on to roll over and do as they are told. They were totally oblivious to the fact that the people who run Manchester City are renowned and highly respected international businessmen dealing in contracts worth billions that make the PL look like a corner shop. Even now you can see from their response that the penny hasn't quite dropped, they haven't been able to grasp the meaning of the word "UNLAWFUL". The PL are completely out of their depth and they're being found out bit by bit, one case at a time, and they still haven't quite realised that they're just a bunch of nobodies who are completely out of their depth.

  • @free7816
    @free7816 11 дней назад +29

    This is when the Red Devils are not dangerous anymore, Gunners cannot shoot and those who will never walk alone started to walk alone. As a City fan I want the whole truth to come out, we have suffered in the hands of other teams fans, you can't even comment and if you comment they will reply you, (115 charges, cheaters, corrupt club fans, plastic fans) these people didn't put on field issues aside and off field issues aside, everywhere you go 115 charges is using. Is time we seek justice for our club and we the fans. The whole truth should come out otherwise it will still be there that we have use money to pay our way out.

    • @GoldenbanjoDJ
      @GoldenbanjoDJ 11 дней назад +1

      As a Newcastle fan I really bloody hope you and your lawyers go absolutely ham on the PL and make everything public

    • @kennyshortcake999
      @kennyshortcake999 10 дней назад

      Well put 👍🏼💎

    • @gssf.gr29
      @gssf.gr29 10 дней назад

      Totally agree, and I believe this case has gone a long way to proving to a lot of people, especially the neutrals, who the villains really are here. The report from the hearing PROVES not only that the PL's rules were unfair and unlawful, that they have abused their position, that they have broken their own rules by delaying their decision on City's latest sponsorship deal then wrongly denied it, that they are not fit for purpose and yet despite all of this, even now they're trying to justify and defend their position instead of accepting the position and acknowledging that they need to move on and revamp the rules. Their statement even had words to the effect that they were going to continue with the same rules in place. It's incompetence at best, and you cannot have that in an organisation responsible for overseeing millions of pounds worth of deals.
      People will still point to the 115, but what chance is there that the PL's claims have any credibility given the total shit-show that these latest cases are proving to be? (Most City fans already know there is little credence to them, it's not just blind support of the club as many rival fans seem to think). Remember this is the organisation that tried to fine Leicester when they weren't even in the PL at the time! Even after that case the PL admitted that their own rules were poor.

    • @Beachgirl1
      @Beachgirl1 10 дней назад +1

      The arrogance of city (and Everton) fans is absolutely hysterical.😂😂

    • @gssf.gr29
      @gssf.gr29 10 дней назад

      @@Beachgirl1 No, the arrogance of the PL is worse than hysterical. It has now been PROVEN by the country's top legal people that their rules are UNLAWFUL - Their words, not mine - yet they still try to claim the moral high ground and like the rest of you, still think City are in the wrong. Most clubs actually believe the rules are poor, only City had the balls to take them on, that's the reality.

  • @gruber1650
    @gruber1650 11 дней назад +14

    The premier league have been caught cheating making rules to suit the red cartel😂 hope City nail them to the door

  • @djn1856
    @djn1856 11 дней назад +11

    Finally the club is starting to speak out about whats happening. Let the prem roasting begin

  • @robertmclellan3658
    @robertmclellan3658 11 дней назад +9

    What an excellent vlog well done. City dealing with the crooks from the Premier League and the evil red cartel.

  • @adrianbennett3761
    @adrianbennett3761 11 дней назад +25

    It’s not clear who’s won this case but City have scored some important points. Interest free loans have been brought into focus. I expect that this will cause massive friction between Premier League clubs

    • @topoftheleague8814
      @topoftheleague8814 11 дней назад

      It is very CLEAR, legal argument has only to be proved.... Either a set of rules are legal in entirety or however little they may be proved to be unlawful, then the whole set are unlawful!
      There is no legal world where lets say a set of 10 rules are still legal, just because 9 are legal! If one is unlawful, then that makes the whole set unlawful! wakey wakey...

    • @paulbrickland9625
      @paulbrickland9625 11 дней назад

      @@adrianbennett3761 it is clear city will get compensation because they were discriminated against

    • @adrianbennett3761
      @adrianbennett3761 11 дней назад

      @@paulbrickland9625 I hope so as deals with Etihad and Bank of Abu Dhabi weren’t allowed to happen

    • @MickkimUK79
      @MickkimUK79 11 дней назад +5

      It’s completely irrelevant, all we had to do is prove one part of it was unlawful in law, then the rules they have put in place are completely un-forceable

    • @paulbrickland9625
      @paulbrickland9625 10 дней назад

      @@adrianbennett3761 that was one of the things city want changing and the pl decision to block it was set aside

  • @topoftheleague8814
    @topoftheleague8814 11 дней назад +13

    As Pep said... their are no friends, only interests! Man U Arsenal Liverpool West Ham Bournemouth Brentford Fulham Wolves come to mind at this point!

    • @renderlifestyle
      @renderlifestyle 11 дней назад +1

      Wolves belong in the Championship

    • @jonathangasana
      @jonathangasana 11 дней назад +1

      @@renderlifestyle Definitely pulling for them to be in the championship now

    • @michellemaggs75
      @michellemaggs75 11 дней назад

      ​@renderlifestyle We play them next.

  • @normanseaman6397
    @normanseaman6397 11 дней назад +11

    As the pl cannot be taken to court by member clubs and only tribunals,is it time for fans to get involved as they can take the pl through the English courts.

  • @alexthornby4539
    @alexthornby4539 11 дней назад +19

    0:58 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @sammakwela
    @sammakwela 11 дней назад +4

    I'm not a City fan, but I enjoy hearing your banter 😂 all the way from 🇿🇦

  • @jasondent8303
    @jasondent8303 11 дней назад +8

    When City win... let's all post it on Liverpools & Arsenals page 😂😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤❤❤

    • @shanty4590
      @shanty4590 11 дней назад +2

      Don’t forget Scum Utd as well

  • @MichaelWardle-rz6qc
    @MichaelWardle-rz6qc 11 дней назад +13

    The club's who went against us have free interest loan's it's unfair

  • @BIGNOIDS
    @BIGNOIDS 11 дней назад +7

    The copium I'm seeing from rivals on social media is hilarious.

  • @jasondent8303
    @jasondent8303 11 дней назад +7

    Then WIN OUR 5TH TITLE RUB IT IN EVEN MORE

  • @williamking1554
    @williamking1554 11 дней назад +8

    beautiful jonny

  • @douglaswright2143
    @douglaswright2143 11 дней назад +3

    Nobbins was excellent on this matter. City were claiming that the APTs as implemented by the PL were illegal and City won on three counts. Even if City had won on one point, that would have been sufficient to demonstrate that the APTs as implemented were illegal.
    APTs are still in place, but they need to be adapted to bring them within English law. The PL are now trying to rush the new rules through. City are already threatening the PL with further legal action, should these be considered unfair.
    It would be fascinating to see what criteria is used to demonstrate "fair market value" as this is potentially subjective. The back and forth for three specific deals is ridiculous and casts doubt on the process. I would like to see a comparison with other clubs' applications.

  • @IHamilton9320
    @IHamilton9320 11 дней назад +3

    L. Pannick 1’
    I think it’s got us all laughing, their credibility was already damaged by coming after us but the consequences will take it to a new level. Very thankful we have a spokesperson as sane (1:00 debatable) and invested in this as you.
    How could we ever be anything less than confident in our club? They’ve got this in the bag

  • @normanseaman6397
    @normanseaman6397 11 дней назад +6

    If Joe blogs wants to pay for sponsorship Joe blogs decides what he wants to pay and that is the fair market value. It’s up to him

  • @KobElia824
    @KobElia824 10 дней назад +2

    Big up Johnny 💙... Let's fight until the end... to declare our innocence... to tear down not only the Premier League... but also the Red Cartel... Never Give Up lads... Come on CITEH 💙💙💙💙💪🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @gssf.gr29
    @gssf.gr29 10 дней назад

    Well done, Johnny. As ever, you're the ONLY one who takes the time to go through the details and fully explain them. Everybody else can come and put forward their own agenda but as soon as the facts are pointed out to them they disappear back into the cracks in the woodwork.
    In this case the PL and the clubs involved can say what they like but the panel summed it up in one word: UNLAWFUL. That's all we need to know. What that means is they can't claim the moral high ground any more, because it has now been declared by an independent panel comprised of people who are as esteemed in the legal system as it is possible to be.
    So they can say and do what they like, keep whinging, keep crying, keep accusing but it's now proven that it's the PL who have acted UNLAWFULLY. To think that anybody has the audacity to call City cheats is disgraceful, and it's admirable that the club have proven to everybody that they're not going to roll over and have the balls to carry through with it and ultimately report it for exactly what it is.
    The very fact that the PL are still trying to save face and blame City proves what an absolute joke this outfit really is. Not fit for purpose, and I can't wait for the day that Masters is shown the door; in fact he should resign now. What most people don't realise is he was actually FOURTH choice for the position, the three candidates selected ahead of him all declined the offer of the job, proving that even internally the whole place is such a shit show that nobody wants the job. Not much more to say really is there?

  • @ryancitygo
    @ryancitygo 11 дней назад +6

    Man City still won because the ATP Case is unlawful so the Premier League lost so this is confusing how can both win 😂😂😂

  • @MAN_CITY-p7d
    @MAN_CITY-p7d 11 дней назад +18

    City won.

  • @professorb3843
    @professorb3843 11 дней назад +6

    0:58 😂😂😂!

  • @bigm9465
    @bigm9465 11 дней назад

    Was what Jonny said from the beginning. Breach of competition law. Great job as always.

  • @MickkimUK79
    @MickkimUK79 11 дней назад +2

    There’s only way to describe the premier leagues rules to prevent us, Newcastle, Everton etc… Draconian

  • @andykilgour5269
    @andykilgour5269 10 дней назад

    Bang on thank's for the info & the time you've given to explaining this, much appriecated pal. 😊 CTID

  • @robfielding100
    @robfielding100 11 дней назад +4

    The Premiership and other teams and fans do like CITY to be the evil pantomime villains… Oh yes they do! Let’s hope this bodes well for the next ‘witch hunt’ trial😡

  • @robfielding100
    @robfielding100 11 дней назад +8

    Liverpool, Arsenal and United will have to change in the car park when they visit The Etihad! 🙄😊

  • @joe8120
    @joe8120 10 дней назад

    Brilliant mate thanks for taking the time to explain

  • @GaryWalker-lq4fd
    @GaryWalker-lq4fd 10 дней назад

    Thanks Johnny for explaining all that, I'm starting to get my head around it 👍

  • @panayiotis81
    @panayiotis81 10 дней назад

    Amazing video. Always easy to understand content. Thanks.

  • @leeprice8949
    @leeprice8949 11 дней назад +2

    PL needs fining for breaking UK competition laws , me or you would be in jail for 5 years

  • @raymondbeddow2064
    @raymondbeddow2064 11 дней назад +6

    Will that win yesterday ? Will that open some roads open towards the 115 I believe it will

    • @freddiehardicre8752
      @freddiehardicre8752 11 дней назад

      It is not 115 charges its 15 over ten years that's a media driven 115 looks a good headline and clicks can't wait for the melt down when city are cleared.

    • @ghmacnay
      @ghmacnay 11 дней назад +1

      ​@@freddiehardicre8752actually it's 5 × several subsections over 9 years

  • @simonnewcastle
    @simonnewcastle 11 дней назад +2

    Great vid mate fk the red cartel

  • @philipmountfield3139
    @philipmountfield3139 11 дней назад +1

    all the other clubs should be supporting city for this action..

    • @freddiehardicre8752
      @freddiehardicre8752 11 дней назад

      Your joking ain't you do you mean the red cartel? They run the premier league thought they have found a loop hole with there 200 million interest free loans oh dear the three of them will fail ffp let's see what happens to them?

  • @bobofett3966
    @bobofett3966 11 дней назад +7

    City won, when the judgment says the FA acted unlawfully that tells you everything, all this spin that the FA won is a joke, if they won why the emergency meeting with all the clubs this week

  • @cschristan1
    @cschristan1 7 дней назад

    the Shareholders Loan scheme needs to be investigated in depth.

  • @russdavies2268
    @russdavies2268 11 дней назад +1

    City won and only needed to win 1 point to show ATP was unlawful. Bring on 115!!! MCFC OK

  • @tonyqwizzer8279
    @tonyqwizzer8279 10 дней назад +1

    I hope you & City fans have read and digested the THREE main articles in the Tues edition of the Times. The one especially by Martin Samuels...out only ally at times (sic)
    There's no backing the Prem there 😂☑️

  • @sirgio8312
    @sirgio8312 11 дней назад +3

    😂😂😂
    Brilliant !

  • @tropicalblue9432
    @tropicalblue9432 10 дней назад

    So the Premier League, despite being told by their legal advisers that they were not clearly lawful, knowingly proceeded with their unlawful rules, assuming that their dominant position allowed them to bully everyone. What a corrupt way of promoting Fair Play! Isn't the PL guilty of bringing the Game into disrepute?

  • @thelittlesignpost
    @thelittlesignpost 11 дней назад

    Yes Jonny, I am one of those who has been talking about and typing with 2 easy keys, about115, that is 115 Hat Tricks for Haaland, THAT is all I want to hear! Joking aside, yes there is a clear pattern, the one sided support of the PL for the reds! I am singing the Blues on behalf of the PL RED faces! Come on City!

  • @stephenkent129
    @stephenkent129 11 дней назад +1

    School teacher johny🫵yes brother well explained brother &always with ya funny bits love it tell ya what if I had someone explain thing like this when I was in school I might of ended up with a better job&life🫣for me I’d take this as a win&seriously hope the other cas goes as good then like ya said before we can celebrate out trophies all over again,so glad ya did a goldbridge dig what a prick he is,as always class bro👊

  • @RoomAtTheTopStudio
    @RoomAtTheTopStudio 11 дней назад

    Deardrie Dyson the wife of the Dyson who makes "vacuums," not "Hoovers," asked me to tell you that there is a differences between a vacuum and a Hoover so please don't call a Dyson a Hoover again lol

  • @magazijuto
    @magazijuto 11 дней назад

    Typical City u the best.! Keep it solid brother

  • @Renegade76892
    @Renegade76892 11 дней назад

    The premire league is beyond embarrassing

  • @paulbrickland9625
    @paulbrickland9625 11 дней назад +1

    City achieved what they set out to achieve and they will be consequences for the pl teams financial and points wise

  • @guvnormcfc66
    @guvnormcfc66 7 дней назад

    Any news on why the premier league stopped the documents being released for 12 days

  • @ThandoNkabi
    @ThandoNkabi 11 дней назад

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤ best channel

  • @Robson-te6cz
    @Robson-te6cz 10 дней назад

    won 2 out of 23 cases hardly a win. ATP affects the whole league

  • @obamagaming6332
    @obamagaming6332 11 дней назад

    Spurs stayed out of this one no?

  • @bigm9465
    @bigm9465 11 дней назад

    I mean the Premier league can't even get offsides right. What chance did they have in court? - the dust is settling 🤣🤣 city city city

  • @BlueChess-BenWilde
    @BlueChess-BenWilde 11 дней назад

    Down with the Red Cartel 👎🏻🩵CTID

  • @Birdiewizard1
    @Birdiewizard1 11 дней назад

    The premier league lost. They are trying to make a fist of it, but bottom line, they lost. See page 164 of the ruling. They are soooo gonna get hit for damages.

  • @johnwalters4792
    @johnwalters4792 11 дней назад

    City are Number 6 and the Prem are the Village.

  • @chorakdoon6658
    @chorakdoon6658 11 дней назад +3

    Correct me if I'm wrong but City won in a sense that unlawful decision to block 2 deals will be nullified for now. But APT law at its core will stay with some changes so it's not like City can do whatever to bring money to the club.
    And also City brought to light the no interest no repayment deadline shareholder loans for clubs like Arsenal. But the amount of interest for 260m loan money would be like 10m a year which isn't groundbreaking so Arsenal and the likes would choose to start paying for the interest if it meant APT law will keep clubs like City and Newcastle from getting a lot of cash than that.
    My question is what is stopping City from getting the same shareholder loans as the other clubs? I'm not very knowledgeable at economy or running business but I'm curious.

    • @paulbrickland9625
      @paulbrickland9625 11 дней назад

      It's called financial doping it's what the pl have charged city with so as the mantra goes relegate arsenal Liverpool and utd as that's what they've been advocated for us the phrase the boot is on the other foot

    • @pauldowney4280
      @pauldowney4280 11 дней назад +1

      Because city makes a profit every year and is the best run club in Europe, it's why this is so disgusting. Please check it out, and we are one of the lowest spending clubs over the last ten years.

    • @shanty4590
      @shanty4590 11 дней назад

      PL re-writhing a new APT rule now

    • @chorakdoon6658
      @chorakdoon6658 11 дней назад

      @@pauldowney4280 Makes sense if we are financially sufficient and don't need any loans. While I do think the money UAE brought in played an undeniably huge factor in Man City's success, I think their decision to bring in ex-barca executives to run their club was the ultimate winning strategy for them. Nowadays, as you have mentioned we don't even spend that much on players because people like Txiki is so good at spotting talent and Guardiola is really good at developing players. If you look at clubs like Man Utd they can spend all the money in the world and still plays like dog poo. So I think we should feel proud of how City have operated with their money.

    • @paulbrickland9625
      @paulbrickland9625 11 дней назад +1

      @@chorakdoon6658 city won the part of psi they challenged that was scrutinising sponsorship contracts they also made sure that the shareholder loans that the other Premier league clubs were getting counted as part of psr in fact city's 115 charges the serious ones are for pumping in cash through their owner disguised as sponsorship which is what these no interest loans with no time limit to pay them back are therefore we know adsenal Brighton Liverpool have done whereas city have denied doing this and say they have the evidence to prove it so why are city being persecuted and the others not makes you wonder who's orchestrating this witch hunt doesn't it

  • @VOZA6
    @VOZA6 11 дней назад

    Just like the F.I.A

  • @dresantorini1770
    @dresantorini1770 9 дней назад

    City lost miserably, paying the media off hasn't done a thing😂😂😂

  • @garyellis2222
    @garyellis2222 11 дней назад

    The premier league is a laughing stock, var no good corrupt referees, now inconsistent about breaking rules

  • @markhaynes7895
    @markhaynes7895 11 дней назад

    Even more confident now regarding 115 prem league top brass are bent and I'm hearing city have more evidence of that to put to them ie Arab counties apaying massive sums of money for prem tv and a lot disappearing in back pockets?? games

  • @kontomylitis
    @kontomylitis 11 дней назад

    Spin doctors

  • @ovuakporoyeabegha9816
    @ovuakporoyeabegha9816 9 дней назад

    Man Cheaty................hahahahahaha...........................

  • @Adam-ui4ef
    @Adam-ui4ef 10 дней назад

    You didnt a video claiming victory, now your not so sure?
    Yes, City won a few procedural issue, however the PL won the biggest points. APT is valid and here to stay.
    City didnt win. You didnt win.

    • @ss-qu5yx
      @ss-qu5yx 10 дней назад +1

      City didn't say they were against all the rules. Just the unlawful ones 👍

  • @kevinmillar1122
    @kevinmillar1122 10 дней назад

    Yous won 2 of 15 🤣🤣🤣 what that 6 out of 48 points in matches Wow 🤣 City fans keep forgetting they started watching football 15 years ago , football is around much longer 🤣🤣

  • @mattpryokra2245
    @mattpryokra2245 11 дней назад +1

    I’m with Citeh 🖤🤍

  • @johnburgess2384
    @johnburgess2384 11 дней назад

    We have common enemies.