Nice channel. Those who point to their large numbers and followers over the years and claim "Could all of them actually have been wrong!?", the Quran says the following: Quran 19:73-75: And when Our proofs are recited to them as clear signs, those who ignore warning say to those who heed warning: “Which of the two factions is better in standing and better in assembly?” But how many a generation We destroyed before them which was better in possessions and outward appearance! Say, "Whoever is in error - let the Most Merciful extend for him an extension until, when they see that which they were promised - either punishment or the Hour - they will come to know who is worst in position and weaker in soldiers." Peace.
Have you still not found where Josh says that most of these contradictions are not present within the sahih material? He's said this in more than 1 video
@@HadithCritic the document is a separate part. Have u at least backed away from Josh’s claim saying that there aren’t that many present in the sahih material?
@@murtazashafiq6807 he lists examples of contradictions within the sahih material. There are those like Ibn Hajr Asqalani who attempt to reconcile the contradictions, like in the example of whether the milk/wine test of the prophet during isra wal miraj was in Jerusalem or Heaven and he claims both to avoid contradictions. If one were to take accept these reconciliations by later individuals like Ibn Hajr, then the contradictions are explained away. When you allow the narrations to speak for themselves without the interpolation of later hadith reconcilers, then you get many contradictions. Hence, why claiming there aren’t many contradictions in the sahih material doesn’t make sense when there’s evidence for it. They’re only limited when you accept the reconciliations of later individuals like Ibn Hajr
the sound effect edits are great
Nice channel.
Those who point to their large numbers and followers over the years and claim "Could all of them actually have been wrong!?", the Quran says the following:
Quran 19:73-75:
And when Our proofs are recited to them as clear signs, those who ignore warning say to those who heed warning: “Which of the two factions is better in standing and better in assembly?”
But how many a generation We destroyed before them which was better in possessions and outward appearance!
Say, "Whoever is in error - let the Most Merciful extend for him an extension until, when they see that which they were promised - either punishment or the Hour - they will come to know who is worst in position and weaker in soldiers."
Peace.
The ammar guy is assuming that Muslims have not been led astray.....
Wtf. This guy is deranged
🔥
Have you still not found where Josh says that most of these contradictions are not present within the sahih material? He's said this in more than 1 video
asimiqbal2nd.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/contradictions.pdf
@@HadithCritic the document is a separate part. Have u at least backed away from Josh’s claim saying that there aren’t that many present in the sahih material?
@@murtazashafiq6807 he lists examples of contradictions within the sahih material. There are those like Ibn Hajr Asqalani who attempt to reconcile the contradictions, like in the example of whether the milk/wine test of the prophet during isra wal miraj was in Jerusalem or Heaven and he claims both to avoid contradictions. If one were to take accept these reconciliations by later individuals like Ibn Hajr, then the contradictions are explained away. When you allow the narrations to speak for themselves without the interpolation of later hadith reconcilers, then you get many contradictions. Hence, why claiming there aren’t many contradictions in the sahih material doesn’t make sense when there’s evidence for it. They’re only limited when you accept the reconciliations of later individuals like Ibn Hajr
@@HadithCritic ok that’s fine. The point I’m trying to establish is that u disagree with Josh on this?