Yuval Noah Harari on CNN Amanpour | Hamas' aim was 'to assassinate any chance for peace'
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 окт 2023
- Watch Christiane Amanpour's interview with Yuval Noah Harari, exploring the long-term implications of Hamas' attack on Israel and the subsequent retaliation in Gaza.
Broadcast live on CNN International on October 12, 2023.
I'm a 50 year old Israeli woman who has been crying on and off since last Saturday and in rage towards my own government at the same time. These 10 minutes lifted my spirits out of the Apocalypse we're in. Hoping for better days and better leaders on both sides. We deserve better leadership.
I hope that at some point in the future Israelis and Palestinians will be able to let history be history (like the Poles/Ukrainians/Lithuanians did). I hope they realize also that it is an imperative for the future of their children. The path which both sides are on only leads to one end: the holy land being a nuclear wasteland (that technology proliferates more and more). That is an end in which no one wins. I hope you all can reconcile someday in the future. Most of the world has the same hope. There is no joy in you all killing each other, endlessly.
Israel stole their land and systematically try to erase them. Like in Gaza they are in the biggest air prison in the world. It is not really surprising that these people that got their land stolen and ethnically cleansed and imprisoned, now desperately look for radical leaders to stop this. Now they bomb Gaza even more. I know it's a complex situation. But if you just look at the land distribution and how their land shrunk and shrunk. Every rational mind knew this will backfire. And the victims are ok both sides. But 10x more on the side of Palestina. It's fucked up. But Israels actions over the last 100 years were creating this madness.
@@galacticrepublic3732except a few thousand lives, please sit down
@@SV-nv7jq I lost my home and cried on and on but I had to make a new life in order for my children to forge a new life and future. I didnt want them to spend their lives crying on and on over a home that was taken from me. Terrible for me and I was wronged, but my children needed to forge a new life without my rage and hatred. Its hard for God to place blessings in your hands if your hands are clutching rage and hatred over what someone took from you. If its meant to be restored, it shall be restored in Gods time and in His way.
Instead of a spirit-lifter I would like to hear a neutral analysis. Mr. Harari is again Israeli, so he belongs to one of the side of the conflict, and obviously as he speaks he is not neutral. He is biased. This is of no help. Get nonbiased, neutral experts to be Interviewed, and not those lobbyists.
"Start by saying sorry!" If only more of us humans could look inside and see how dire is the need to take responsibility and seek atonement.
Be sorry....feel remorse before "saying sorry." If the sentiment is lacking, the words are deceitful or worse, a false placation.
Jesus = forgiveness
It's hard to imagine as long as man has existed, we still haven't figured out how to live in peace with our neighbors. Power, religion, racism among many other things as well. My hope is fading and we are forgetting the things that should be self evident. The saddest thing is the peaceful innocent people are always the ones who suffer the most. It's a sad day for many.
There will never be peace in that region brother. Thessalonians 5:3:
For when they shall say, Peace and safety; then sudden destruction cometh upon them, as travail upon a woman with child; and they shall not escape.
The singularity may save us. Or we evolve. Or we die.
"Start by saying we are sorry, it's a simple as that."
Wise words.
I hope the people in the US are listening. Division in the society is dangerous for any democracy.
But diversity is strength … isn’t it?
Not just US, entire world, Polarization is virus spreading thick and fast.
Diversity is different from division Division is US vs THEM
It’s the Jews vs them
It’s not USA vs them !
This is not the fight of the American people
@@osamasarhan6151moron, he’s comparing Dems vs Republicans
I am from Turkey and have no religious affiliation with any religion. It is really insane what people are suffering in the name of religion. We need to get rid of leaders who indeed divide nations to rule. Erdogan, Netanyahu, Putin.. Let us stop this insanity.
Я вас поддерживаю из России.
Are you fucking joking!! THANK GOD for Netanyahu. IF not for Bibi, shit would be worst for Jews. You're doing the same shit. You're putting a mini start on the victim here. Don't fucking compare Bibi to Erdogan. Erdogan is a thug. The conditions in Israel are enormously different from Turkey. How are gays treated in Turkey vs. Israel. Hell, how are Israeli Palestinians accepted in Israel versus even in their own Muslim countries?
This is Harari's RUclips channel. Nobody from the WEF has a moral leg to stand on when it comes to divisiveness and oppression.
Israel, USA, UK, France, India, China and Russia all kill Muslims for the religious motivation
its good to see turkish not following any religion,, always stay away from religious persons ,they can do anything and they say allah told us to do ,
United we stand. Divided we fall. That has always been the case. As humans we must stand together for our humanity!
why would you support Bibi the most failed premier in Israel history and now you want to stand by this failure who has brought nothing but pain and sorrow to the Israelites
did anyone hear Bibi condemn the Russian invasion ?NO you,useful fools
No disagreement with your truism. However, what do we do when someone or some group decides they will not stand with others?
We are all struggling and suffering with this horrific war, but we must not loose hope on humanity🙏
You think Palestinian are human ??
@@Handle.326 ah yes thank you mother teresa
What a great man is Juval. I am from Iran and I love both Israelis and Palestinians. I am deeply sad for our traumatised and divided region. 😔
Being an Iranian and not taking any sides, you must be exceptional person!!
I appreciate you for being unbiased!!
You can only hope that Iranian leadership will eventually reduce its hostilities towards Israel, which is probably a major obstacle for peace between Israelis and Palestinians.
Hopefully Iran, Israel and Palestine can someday in the future live like Poland, Lithuania and Ukraine today.
@@log4john No honey, I am not exceptional. There are many Iranians who are unbiased in this conflict.
@@sebastiantorker4930 the I.R. in Iran will never do that unless it is forced to. They are a big problem for both Iran and our region.
Thanks for giving Poland as positive example. It really is good to be someone's positive example.
Thanks for educating the world about this. We Americans don’t hear a lot about the historical context and positive outcomes between Poland, Lithuania and Ukraine. Provides some hope in these pessimistic times.
I didn’t know that either. Brilliant that Poland saw that and decided to be future-looking.
In 1812 the British fully burned down the White House. Somehow in the 100 years between then and WWI the US and the UK became so close the Brits literally call it "The Special Relationship."
Admirable decision by Poland.
On the other hand, Poland got Gdansk and Silesia in the west. Poland is the country knows very well how the borders can be drawn and redrawn every a few hundreds of years
Amanpour is one of the greats ! "Is it possible to hold two ideas at the same time..." This is the question everyone needs to be asking and finding answers to. She says it's so calmly, concisely, and correctly.
No, I don't like her question, because she is looking for appeasement and NOT TRUTH. That cannot work here. Bottom line is that such an approach is at best naive and at worst deeply disingenuous. She clearly will not accept realities such as Palestians blaming the Jews for their problems, rather than their own leadership.
@@truthseeker9975you’re making the worst mistake here. You are equating the crimes of Hamas with all Palestinians, and Israel as a state (which is perpetrating an illegal occupation) with innocent Jews.
@truthseeker seeking truth demands going beyond the convenience of blaming the victims.
As a Muslim, I've disgusted what hamas did.. if they restricted their attacks only to military targets, it could be understandable, but massacre of civillians, and broadcasting those things, can not be accepted.
Thankyou.You are the first Moslem I've heard say this publicly.Respect to you.We need more more moral voices like this and louder from your community
❤
“If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed, and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”
― Malcolm X
A criminal, hateful racist, killed by his fellow Muslims- well at least a perverse form of the religion. Nice.
Quoting another islamic extremist doesn't make him right or a good man.
From Palestine i hope this lesson will be taken from both the people and make peace. It's enough enough enough. We need to live like all the people in this world.
Agreed. All that happens in the end is innocent people suffer.
Between organizations like Hamas and the Israeli right there will be no peace
Humanity is the loser in all conflicts.
Amen for that brother.
Peace from Tel aviv to The Gaza strip and Ramallha.
I hope the people will see that the past is not going to make there future better.
And Idiology is just an idea in the people mind...
Tell your friends to stop electing terrorist organizations.
You can't make peace with a rabid dog, or a big nosed rat.
This man got it. That is exactly how and why this happened.
Most important piece from 7.30.
Having a strong leader who builds power by dividing the nation for own political gains may appear tough initially but is the biggest curse for a country.Hope many countries including mine (India) learn from it.
Very true. Mine too (Philippines)
How our leader is dividing the nation? Some would say this exactly is how the leader has divided the nation for power when one subjective opinion like yours is countered, but we know this not division but democracy. Even though he had full majority to build the Ram Mandir he went the Constitutional route not like Netanyahu who wanted to strip supreme court of Israel to save his corruption!
Most of the Arabs have built the power by dividing the nation into Sunni and Shia and then driving the Shia out, but they have been successful.
Dividing the country also has been done by Erdogan he is successful term after term.
Harari is speaking about his own country. Do not extrapolate just because you can.
Tough few years to be a paper tiger
@@user-yn5od8vg1i I'll just say one thing, you know right that lawyers and judges can be bribed right to a certain extent, and also which judges take your case also becomes important for any case.
We have the same thing going on with Nationalists and Anti-Nationalists as the ruling party calls it, doesn't matter if they are Hindu, Muslim, or if they love their country. Its subtle narrative building doesn't have to be in your face like Israel or Arabs, we can be like China slowly but surely brainwashing the entire country.
Hopefully, the government will come to its senses and focus on economic development more during elections than division.
Edit: I'll say any criticism of the government is not criticism of the nation, but a system that needs to be changed by any political government, even the ruling party can change its narrative too.
Free Israel from Bibi and free Palestinians from Hamas
An interview that challenges my thinking and understanding is exactly what I'm looking for. What a relief. I'm so worn out listening to propaganda from one corner of the globe to another.
True
Hamas has established less than 20 years as a resistance , what avout 75 years before Hamas ? What about weapons that israel owns and what Hamas owns ?
Israel is killing all shapes of life in Palestine to pull out the rest of palestinian people ouside their country
It is propaganda
This is the propaganda you should be sick of 😂.
This is a kind of propaganda in itself to be honest, because there is in fact a case to be made for the Palestinians as well who have essentially been in a prison for like 70 years now.
How do you explain the deliberate killings and torture, filmed, and the religious motives?
'Can we hold 2 ideas at the same time?' THIS WAS BRILLIANT. Thank you both. Excellent interview.
You must unplug from the brainwashing some time.
It's bullshit...
They were offered peace many times and rejected it over and over.
And they keep saying that they don't want peace but the world is pretending like they do want peace in some fake empathetic way because they want this conflict to go on.
@@talsapps I agree. The west is being gaslit by western terms of "autonomy, self-determination, rights." Nobody in that region (other than the only democracy there: Israel) craves such ideals. They just use those terms because western media, et. al. understand them the way the ones using them don't. Almost every arab in the region lives under a dictatorship nobody voted for (can't criticize). They seem ok with that Gazans placed themselves under even more brutal & intolerant leadership. Their first order of business 18 years ago was to throw rival Fatah members from rooftops to their deaths. That doesn't sound like people who value freedom, rights.
The W. bank hasn't had an election for almost 20 years for fear they'll choose the same thing. Nobody's up in arms about that suppression of self-determination. Jordan's dictatorship took 78% of the planned state of palestine (as a political bribe no less). They occupy that land today, denying inhabitants (2/3 of whom are palestinian) the right to even vote on this matter. (In 71, Jordan's dictatorship killed 10s of thousands of palestinians who rightfully believed it was their land.). That's all been accepted as a nothingburger.
The only time western standards of liberty seem important is when it's "the infidel in our midst." It's pan-arabism, not anything to do with the standards being used to influence westeners.
@@markfuller exactly...
It's all fake theatrics to keep this war going.
F Scott Fitzgerald - “the measure of a first rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposing ideas in the mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function”
Thank you both, Amanpour from British-Iran and Harari from Israel. What a level of insight and synthesis communication. Very important interview of 10:25. But closer attention to Minute 7:30 a strong leader in power whos devides the nation for own political gains. I think it had happened in many countries. And all continents .repeating this over and over.We must live in peace. But big companies and nations who get lucrative by selling weapons seems wont allow it, thirsty of power and money. Both nations deserve to exist and live in peace.
@peacelove7787and conditions are much, much worse over the past 20 years. More illegal Zionist settlements, and more disregard, dehumanization and demonization of Palestinians. It can only end one way: Freedom and equality for all Palestinians.
The man that we all wanted to hear talking about this situacion
The tragedy is that Hamas knew full well that more Palestinians than Israelis would die as a consequence of this attack. This was fine for them as is would prolong the cycle of hate. The purpose of terrorism is not to further a cause, but to prolong the conflict.
Why would/should more Palestinians die than Israelis? Why? Oh yes one Isaraeli life is more valuable than 100 Palestinians. The rule of 10 to one. Nazis did the same in the ghettos
@@JP-tq7nihe means because of military power. Stop being blinded by emotion.
@@JaniceDoe210u mean the military power is not powerful enough to target Hamas accurately and precisely but powerful enough to create enough so-called collateral damage? Let’s be honest, If they really care about Palestinian civilian lives, there wouldn’t be so many Palestinians died over the past several decades.
@@waynew2835that they don't care abt the lives of civilians is a given
@@JP-tq7ni Hamas can end this at any time by releasing the hostages alive. The Palestinian people can end this at any time, by ending Hamas, and releasing the hostages alive. But they choose not too. The Jews are in Judaea and the Levant. As they have been since the era of ancient Egypt. The Jewish people, the tribes of Jacob, these are the indigenous people of the lands of Israel.
Also, go on Google Maps to look at the hotels, sports facilities, businesses etc. in Gaza BEFORE Hamas decided to murder babies and rape women? Gaza has been in Palestinian control since 2004 btw. Return to Palestinian land? They are already there in Gaza.
my favorite author, have read three of your series books, respect from a Muslim. wish peace prevails over these dark days. I think we should all condemn any side spreading war crimes in the region.
soo true. Be humble.he is a great human being
A Muslim who supports an athiest Israeli who is a leading figure of the World Economic Forum? You need a massive reset in your thought process! Lol
He is pure evil.
Your reading the wrong books😂😂
I’m a muslim and I hate him.
Harari has a way of explaining a complex situation in reasoned, empathetic language with the intention of creating understanding without division. I find him and Amanpour credible and reassuring even in this time of great sadness and turmoil in our world.
Harari is a psychopath he supprts CLAWN Schwab thinks we should have chop in our body under our skin
"As long as People Believe in Absurdities, people will always Commit Atrocities". Voltaire.
Thank you very much for your perspective, for mentioning the warning for those leaders ( in Poland as well) who have divided their own nations as there's high time to say sorry and start uniting people again or withdrawing from the political scene
Poland has an election tomorrow where this question will actually be on the ballot...
Are u kidding???? Do you NOT see the murdered babies??? You you Not see the beheaded infants??
Your view is both disgusting and unbelievable!! Shame!!!
happy first anniversary of your joining youtube, barbara 🥳
Peace! My paternal grandfather was born in Warsaw!
In the name of superiority not religion
“Is there a moral maze - an ability to hold 2 thoughts at the same time.” Such an important question…
For sure, it’s called schizophrenia. They want us insane. Check out those dog experiments with the circles. The dogs went mad. Confused is what they want us. Keep lapping it up.
Yes, and he didn’t answer it
@@paddyf2533The question was at 4:12 and answered at 5:02…..He said that you can see the question if you are not directly involved in the conflict, you are far away from it. It is impossible to see it if you are in the conflict.
@@lesliepropheter5040 indeed, we dont care about morals when the danger in front of us, our mind is just thinking how to survive and protect our loved one
Yes , that means hypocracy of him , means no moral and no principles . Either u r honest or not honest . Either u r good man or bad man . Israel always a hypocrite country
A high intellect person like him, should not fuel the fire. But should give wise advise on how to resolve such conflict. If such person himself not looking how to resolve, instead of any other person doing blood for blood. Then human is in danger.
Than’ you, sir.” Love your books, and deeply appreciate your work.
The world need people with a clear mind like you in time of crisis .
Israel is lucky to have a strong leader. This guy's a clown
He's a wolf 🐺 in sheep's 🐑 clothing. Don't trust him 😢
I like Yuval but he has biases just like anyone else
@@mountainairbiases😂. He’s a eugenicist.
@@sakumunalakamanqanqaxhow, your argument ?
Yuval Harari, this is an excellent interview. Yours is a voice of reason, decency, and compassion, and it is needed, now, more than ever.
are you blind or just not informed enough who he really is?
Find out who this cocorach is. He’s evil himself.
@@bele28Tell me what evils things he did
@@bele28bro it’s a bot
@@GoBrowns9821 forgot about those..
Mr. Noah, I will read all of your books. I'm half-way through Sapiens. You are critical contribution to general knowledge.
He is an intellectual juggernaut! Respect!
Where? I don't se Chomsky/Finkelstein there...
Chomksy is cool but the old dude can't clock 1.5 million views in 3 days let's be real 😅
I have never seen Yuval this sad… I can see the pain. 😢
Considering he thinks man will become useless and expendible…..
He has very little soul …
@@1134mijo what are you on about? When did he say that?
@@milesjolly6173 On his book "Homo Deus" he spoke about how AI and capitalism could lead to the majority of people becoming useless (i.e. invaluable) since they are replaceable by technologies/AI that are owned by the mega rich capitalists.
@@1134mijoyes. He said humans will become hackable animals.
Never seen him sad for the plight of everyday Palestinians. As an Australian I have a learning for the clear underdog.
If we could only have more intelligent, patient and thoughtful discussions like this - on TV and in all our circles of influence.
If these are the discussions being had, the Palestinians will be genocided that simple
This guy's a joke
if only western media would actually talk about the broader context of this struggle instead of only having israelis and zionists on to state their positions.. just because something sounds intelligent and thoughtful doesnt mean its true or fair the chance for peace was killed when israel started bulldozing thousands of homes, building settlements and kicking palestinians off their land, murdering 10,000 and more palestinian civilians, and keeping people in an open air prison.. israel never wanted peace, they want an excuse to keep killing palestinians and kicking them off their land gradually and take over everything youre a fool if you believe otherwise.. oh here is the israeli man to tell us that the violence always comes from hamas surprise surprise sitting in his big home in the west moralizing to people who have been under blockade and are constantly in fear of death and who have their food and water supplies dictated by their western, european settler colonial occupier
You should watch DDN double down news and get that prospective. Might change your view on the matter. This guy is a monster.
@@charlenefrench5404 You couldn't be more right about that. What was one of his quotes... "what are we going to do with all of these useless people"...words to that effect. He is pure evil.
This hatred is so horrid. I cannot find a path to think of it. Yet is importNt to try. This was very helpful. Thank you❤
If Hamas "went house to house for hours", where was the IDF all that time?
More wars,
More money, more power, more control…the more chaotic the better they can control people…Never and ever they let you have peace in your life…if not, they will not be in power…think outside of the box…
Fighting the terrorists who were blocking access & scrambling because they were not prepared. Truly horrific
Yeah, blame the victims. We know who's to blame. ISLAM in all it's manifestations.
The world is in a crisis of leadership. Too many world leaders have failed to serve and protect humanity and set examples for how to live ethically and responsibly.......
I think there are plenty of competent leaders around. But we keep electing Idiot Superheros who make decisions that affect us all with their egos. Partly it is our fault.
Your comment urged me to question WHY
no matter what a person's religious affiliation is, WHERE IS IT IN THOSE WHO TRULY BELIEVE THROUGH THE TEACHINGS
OF EACH OF THEIR SUPREME DEITIES, WHO EVER SAID OR COM-
10:25 10:25 MANDED
LEADERS TO, "GO FORTH AND 'KILL'
INNOCENT PEOPLE"?
I dare ANYONE to name one sacred deity that in the HEAVEN ABOVE, DID NOT COMMAND OF THEIR BELIEVERS TO:
"LOVE ONE ANOTHER!"
The stage has been set by those who choose to defy ALL those PEACE
KEEPING WORDS, FOR ALL MANKIND WHO INHABIT OUR WORLD TODAY!
Days of judgment shall await THEM ALL to answer for
the carnage and destruction of people, their towns/cities, that have faced the
UNPRECE-
DENTED, MODERN DAY, HORRORS OF WAR!!!
P.S.
I am am not an overly religious person, but do 10:25 maintain a faith instilled within me as a child,
that I hold dearly within me to this very day!
My prayers, I
offer to the
oppressed, whom I sincerely also
pray your LEADERS WILL DENOUNCE THEIR PENCHANCE FOR WAR, AN WILL SOON BE OBLITER-
ATED IN ORDER THAT "PEACE" BE RESTORED TO ALL NATIONS IN OUR WORLD,
FOREVER MORE.
NEVER LOSE YOUR FAITH!!!
@@gailcolthart2211 Maybe we could have peace if we sat down and talked instead of relying on God.
@Beerman204, I could not agree with you more.
World leaders busy with climate change virus and depopulation
I was needing to hear what he had to say. Thank you so much for this interview.
What a fantastic interview to pick the brain of such an esteemed intellectual as Yuval. He is extremely thoughtful and well read about the historical context for current wars and situations. It is complex and challenging for any normal person to reconcile two truths at the same time but he is highly skilled in unravelling such ideas and providing basis for them.
+100 shekels
Psychopats
He did not say anything substantial. He focused all the attention on the internal Israeli political scene putting the blame on the current PM as if the months long circus in Israel had no bearing on what happened. Ultimately , it is the fault of Hamas and their supporters like B'Tselem and others.
I can draw so many lessons for INDIA from this talk
What a fantastic interview. Mr Harari’s ability to universalize the things that are going on in the Middle East and provide learnings for all of us is profound
C'mon, you can do better than that. Sounds way too "AI."
or I say, what a psycho
"Today we have the technology to hack human beings on a massive scale." - Yuval Noah Harari
Islam and other religions hacked humans many centuries ago. Those who are free of such hacks are also nihilists--and fail to reproduce themselves. There is no "logical" purpose to life, after all. You either believe in something irrational or you believe in nothing--and go extinct. This is the tragic dilemma of humanity.
This man is the devil personified...
Meaningless quote, out of context, not even the same ball park..thanks for NOTHING🤮
"There is a speed bump ahead."
Exactly !!!!!!!!
This invariably happens everywhere : when you don’t want to negotiate a real solution with the moderates, then you encourage the extremists.
Negotiations with normal humans do work but not with a particular community that has been infected by a perverted cult leader and his book. They are sort of brain-dead zombies to such an extent that their sole motive is annihilation of non-believers through any excuse & opportunity.
The only way to deal with these perverted monsters is to never ever lift your boots from their neck.
If any thing that has ever worked on them then it is the exceptionally violent treatment as we keep often witness in the muslim societies around the globe.
Brilliant contribution from one of the best humankind analysts.❤
He wants to merge humans with technology did u hear that too?
@sharmafamily8250 It's our inevitable reality. We have merged already. Why are you against it while you are using the same technology to attack Yuval?
Peace to you all. I wish we could all live together in peace and stop all this hatred and intolerance. ❤
Since 1948, Israel's inception, they , the Arab surrounding nations, have had one goal; to eradicate the state of Israel and all Jews.
They have tried time after time, thankfully, unsuccessfully.
As Golda Meir Prime Minister of Israel stated " you can't negotiate peace with people who are trying to kill you"
How can Israel even begin to negotiate when Hamas, Iran, PLO, Lebanon, Syria etc.. refuse to acknowledge Israel's right to exist?
They NEVER have AND NEVER will!
Without this first step, everything else is futile!
americans dont know the history
thats why
It is not possible with religious people, especially not with radical Islam groups.
This is the cancer of humanity.
You cant make peace with people who don't value basic human life. Once the true evil is conquered then the foundation of peace can be laid down.
"When the power of love overcomes the love of power the world will know peace." -Jimi Hendrix.
Thank you for your perspective. I am deeply impressed, that you can see it like this, while in the midst of surviving these athroceties.
Both sides need to apologize for their sins. Forgive themselves and eachother! Just say “ I’m sorry for all the pain my actions created for you.
Yuval speaks with clarity of mind devoid of hatred and bigotry. We must have hope for real peace.
😢we are with humanity
😢
not if you are with Yuval here.
evil little goblin he is.
@@axeman2638 i don't know how you are examine the situation but this is a danger for me , innocent people are dying because of dictator people.
@@vikaspandey2155who is dictator
@@ShivamSoni-ol3rw dictator are from both side. It is so bad to attack on people in night,when they were sleeping . This is worst . We are in 21st century
That first step - taking responsibility - is the crucial step to peace and one dodged by many politicians, where they are apt to blame or claim only the victim position. Harari speaks about holding both things together victim and perpetrator. These are lessons for all humanity.
Even if as you say the Palestinians took responsibility, Israel would not dismantle one illegal settlement nor allow for an autonomous Palestinian state nor return to pre 67 borders. Neither would Palestinians be compensated for the loss of land in 48. Taking responsibility yields nothing...thus violence.
So you want to play the 'we were here first' game? Should all the middle eastern states dismantle their countries and give back land to the Jews deposed of it in antiquity? The only mistake Israel made was having Gaza exist at all as an independent entity. Hamas and their followers are barbarians. And anyone claiming 'zionist occupation' in the wake of this tragedy have condoned these actions. You should be ashamed.
@@Leo82870If you do wrong then you have to face consequences, Palestinian did wrong to support Arab invaders in 1948 and not accepting UN partition plan. Problem is that Muslims can’t see Jews ruling over them at Jerusalem. If Palestinian would have big heart, they would have given entire Jerusalem and Temple Mount to build third Jewish temple, I am sure Palestinian would have got much more. 75% population in Jordan is Palestinian, means Palestinians already have their own state, then why they want another. Go and get merge with them as were before 1967.
@@educationinnovation2454 Gaza is not a state in any sense of the word. It is not sovereign economically or militarily. It is occupied by Israel. Palestinians do not even have freedom of movement The wrong was done when the mandate for Palestine was imposed. Wrong is Israel continuing to violate international law as it continues to seize territory.
@@Leo82870 Wrong is also that Palestinian kept attacking Israel since 1948 and kept losing land. Somewhere they have to stop and accept the reality.
What a helpful perspective from a person I trust.
lol
Excellent analysis. Thank you very much
So brilliant, so nuanced, so human in the face of this horror. Thank you Yuval - for giving me hope.
@@youtubecensorship5544 sure you're not a deeply disturbed individual? touch grass.
Wtf does it mean?
@@andro.5678 What peace? 31 years after Oslo accord and the PLO recognition of Israel for two state solution: Israeli settlements in occupied Palestine increased from 70 to 320, and settlers grew from 120,000 to 950,000 that has dissected Palestinian West Bank into separate canteens; i.e. there is nothing left of the Palestinian West Bank to make any viable peace. Tens of thousands of Palestinians including hundreds of children are in prison. Lately, Israel Government formed extremist settlers militia that terrorize Palestinian civilians daily and started to conduct pogroms against defenseless civilians, the latest of which the burning of the town of Hewarah just six weeks ago; homes were burned while people inside were prevented from escaping the fire at gun point. Some were burned alive.
Hammas is an indigenous resistance grew from the suffering of its people and represent their last hope of getting rid of 75 years of brutal dehumanizing, dispossessing and enslaving occupation, that has setup an apartheid regime against the inhabitants of Palestine.
Why is this monster not telling the truth about his agenda of world depopulation . “ Come on man “
anything but human...
How the whole world seems to be ignoring these fact based views, is what I find most disturbing. For the love of God, the little children, and all innocent people of Gaza and Palestine must be protected. They have done nothing wrong, except for to exist. As a Jewish woman. I have always viewed Israeli government as victims who have become perpetrators of violence. The abused became the abusers. I sincerely appreciate this discussion and wish that some leaders will step up.
It's a nice thought that Palestinians are innocent. I'm sure some are
Do you not know that the Israeli lobby spends 40 million a year, in conjunction wit US Jewish owned media companies to threaten US politicians to follow their narrative or be called anti-Semitic? God is actually the problem. Every ignorant religious believer really thinks their specific god is the one true god when the reality is their idiotic faith is only because of their ignorant parents belief. Your god is fake, as is theirs, god is a fabrication of ignorant man who needed a way to explain things in a pre science world. Before your ignorant religion was popular, Romans gad gods you probably think were ignorant, Zeus and the like. Its no more stupid than your god or their god. Its all idiotic.
@joniberstein9047 since God divided the tribes of ISRAEL , you guys are still divided you never support your government, the messiah is returning home whether you believe I him or not , Israel history is not written by man but but God Isa 66 can a NATION be born in a day ? With its own people language and way of life ? no ! But ISRAEL Did !
Children of today murderers of tommorow because they are educated to do so!
Clean gaza from hamas then you can woery about innocent ppl
Should they leave the Palestinian land? That part confuses me.
Intellect comes with the realization of truth and by courage of honesty and not by being interviewed or interviewing on American media.
I love his perspective on society and this commentary. I read 2 of his books and am reading his 3rd. He's spot on the challenges that the world is facing.
The history of European Union shows that peace and shared prosperity are possible even after the most atrocious armed conflicts. Thank you Yuval Harari for reminding that to in that darkest moment. We need hope to go through the darkness, past grief and anger.
Just wait and watch…. European Union in going down a real bad path
The EU is ten minutes old and the cracks are large and growing. 🤷♂️
@@user-fk2yk8gg8jmostly. More not white diaspora and 2nd generation citizens than you'll find whites in other countries. But white isn't homogenous. There are dozens of clear ethnicities across Europe. Spaniards don't look like Slavs.
So all Gazans need to do is just to pull themselves up by their bootstrap and prosper? Who would have thought it would be that simple? Why didn’t anyone think of that?
LOL yeah right ....
Why did Jews leave Europe in the first place? Christianity is so peaceful isn't it !
Thank you for your words, sights and wisdom, in these moments of pain.
Brilliant man, very good interview with relevant questions
Never been fond of this man or what he speaks of, however, found this interview shining a different light on him. May there be peace throughout the world.
This is why i love listening to harai. Nuanced and open minded. Like he said, you can be a victim and preparator at the same time. Hamas' atrocities don't justify Israeli atrocities
Yet the west always justify Israeli atrocities for 70 years! HIs lies on decapitation was already disproved! I’m sorry if anyone thinks he is ok to listen to more apartheid state lies?
Sapiens is the best book I ever read. I have bought over 30 copies to give out to friends and family so they can also experience reading this incredible book.
I bet you rarely read thats why you found it so great
Most stupid book ever written ….. propaganda
I read it too. Yet he systematically glosses over the crimes against Palestinians.
I prefer the Bible. He is a globalist with an agenda to eradicate religion.
#Oh God, we entrust you to our brothers in Gaza, O Lord, O Generous, O Ever-Living, O Ever-Living, we call upon You in Your greatest name to protect its people, its land, its faces, and its sea 🤲🤲
He could just as easily been talking about Gaza. But because he’s Israeli he gets to do this on prime time.
Because he's a genius, not because he's Israeli...
Intelligent conversation,
certainly makes a person think about where your own mind sits on this war.
My favorite man, I can feel the controlled anger and the unhappiness in his eyes. Don’t give up and keep helping people make the necessary changes for the future. By reading your books and hearing your speeches, we are lifted up, hopeful and always strive for the best. You could raise an army yourself and we’d follow!
You have no idea who this man is
Or shall I say what he is
That's what he wants. He said humans are hackable animals. He's a disgusting POS
Prasing this evil man jesus have stupid can u be
He is an atheist and so don't care
I wish everyone in this world could listen to Yuval's points between 3:58 - 7:00 ! The world needs intellectual leaders like him!
very true. But our leaders never hear the intellectuals.
Its really bewildering that Yual Harini is discussing about Natanyahu's politics of diving people of Israel but not coming to the core point of the Freedom of Palestine. Amanpour referred to it and I thought there was going to be discussion on Palestinian self determination and dignity, but alas...they then drifted away. This is what I see in all Israel - Palestinian discussions. People talk about everything - Hamas. Hizbollah, Iran, US and everything else - but they do not talk about the core issue of Palestinian Freedom.
Occupying Palestine does not make a person Palestinian. The original Palestinians were Jews. These are common Arabs from the region, placed there to screw with Israel. There cannot be peace or they would have no reason to stay there. Israel should never again return captured ground to these animals. Send them back to their countries. In plastic bags if necessary.
1. When was the country of Palestine founded and by whom?
2. What were its borders?
3. What was its capitol?
4. What were its major cities?
5. Name one Palestinian leader before Arafat.
6. What was the language of the country of Palestine?
7. What was the religion of the “ancient country of Palestine”?
8. What was the name of its currency?
9. Choose any date in history and tell what was the approximate exchange rate of the Palestinian monetary unit against the US Dollar, GB Pound, Japanese Yen or Chinese Yuan on that date.
10. Since there is no country of Palestine now, what caused its demise and when did it occur?
11.Why did the “Palestinians” never try to become independent until after the devastating defeat of invading Arab countries in the Six-Day War?
Note: Anyone able to answer any of the above questions should certainly be commended for their creative and imaginative writing.
Thoughtful substantive interview. 🙏🏽
Lol!
Will said. May peace and love be with us all.
This bloke is a mensch. The best speaker I've heard on the subject yet. Cheers, you have given me hope.
I'm finally in line with Mr. Harari
Very informative interview. Really important things he has to say.
What a genuine human being and intellectual you are, Mr. Harari! Humanity needs opinion leaders like you to avoid self destruction.
My understanding of the human nature and modern world got much more clear thanks to your book Sapiens, thank you and toda!
This man was called him self as a rational person and this is what he do “telling stupid words” , listen to Noam Chomsky when he describes all the situations In Middle East with a lot of rational and true words.. when you call yourself rational then you suppose to tell truth not just stand with your own ppl.
Great questions from Amanpour, nice interview
The crux of this conflict, as in all conflicts, is that we must get to a point where all peoples can live with dignity. Until that can happen there can be on peace - anywhere.
Get rid of religion
@@isay207 Wrong. Jesus gets rid of evil once and for all.
When Islamists and their terr0r modules supporters are around, don't expect any peace anywhere on this earth!
So no one wants to talk about how israle have been slaughtering Palestinians for decades stolen there homeland and cut them off from the world eith no water ?
@@isay207Yes! But this unfortunately is a very long and slow process, especially in the Middle East.
We could get along with Poles because we (Poles and Lithuanians) are both Catholics, and Ukrainians and Poles did the same because they both are Christians. I'm talking here not about the religiocity but about the culture, about the values inherited through generations. Russian Orthodox culture and mentality by the way is yet another universe, paradoxicaly similar to the Muslim one. I totally believe that it is possible to deal in a sencible way with politicians of the Muslim world, even with some religious scholars. But I have much less hope about the Muslim street folk. All over the World they are celebrating killings of inocent Israelis, they are blindly supporting Hamas murderers, they hate free World and democracy, even if some of them are living in Western countries and greatly benefiting from it.
excellent interview...very thoughtful, balanced and Human person...nice to be able to see such people...
Yuval is a bless for the world.
Which balance?😅
Thank you for this!
Unfortunately this cannot be solved with more violence. Prayers for healing.
One can feel Yuval's sorrow in his tone.
He is hurt. And it hurt watching him today...
Really.
"Some people just want to see the World Burn."
Yuval clearly knows that its not the time for taking sides. It's time for a reality check. From both sides.
I am soo sorry for your friends and family..I pray Jeshua will draw you with His love and comfort..The Lord knows your sorrow as He died for all our sins on the cross.Shalom
There needs to be more voices like this guy. Of course, certain networks will not give him a platform.
This is true. He has criticized Bibi in public .So he won't get air time on most networks in the US .
He is a layer , the Jewish state was founded by Jewish terrorist organizations that took control of Palestine and mass murder civilians including women children and elderly and even animals, with the objective of ethnic cleansing in-fact the Jewish leadership was joyful that there campaign of terror and mass massacres exceeded their expectations and since Ashkenazi Jewish took over Palestine the Palestinians continued to suffer each year and each day from tragedy after tragedy.
4:43 That it should be possible to understand that you can be victim and perpetrator at the same time. MADNESS
Poland have the largest state in Central Europe by contrast the UN at the time was under the control of Europeans and the west they gave the Ashkenazi Jewish settlers more then 50% of Palestine while the native Palestinians about 47% yet the Palestinians made the greatest compromise by accepting to recognize the Jewish state that was crated by Ashkenazi Jews from Europe who ethnically cleansed and committed the most horrific atrocities against them , but the Jewish side emboldened by western support and a seance they are the powerful tried to enforce an injustice humiliating solution that would violate the basic right of Palestinians to return to their native home and lands , ironically the Jews and Israel went after Germany demanding compensation and all their property’s and even payments for force labor, while the Jews want and demand their rights they don’t want the other side to do so .
He is a pop media figure,someone who doesn't get airtime at all is Norman Finkelstein.
Inspiring to hear this thoughtful and humane commentary at such a dark moment. May your voice carry to throughout Israel, Palestine, and beyond.
I miss the interviews with Palestinian scholars. We speak, as always, about them rather than with them, as those directly affected. The anger towards the Netanyahu group is indeed justified. Shedding light on Hariri's complicity as a citizen of an occupying power that has been bullying, dominating, killing, and tormenting the Palestinian people for 75 years interests me even more.
This man has always been a smart person. My expectations were fulfilled with this interview. A man thst does not blame civilians and also attacks lack of institutions in Israel and populism, but at the same time blames hammas for this current situation.
pragmatic, clear and compassionate speaker on this difficult conflict
An apology has to come with actions or it is worthless
Now I love him more !!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
im glad yuval says that israel can be the victim and the perpetrator at the same time..this needs to be admitted in order to find any peace
He ment both sides- why dont you say that.
True. I think he means humanity as a whole really. @@rachelpinto5733
That means both are terrorists
Why are you not pointing out that this man is involved with the WEF? He wants all of us to be in poverty and hopeless.
I am glad that there are others whom are aware of how dangerous this individual is.
Yes, in the early 20th century, Palestine was a diverse region with a majority Arab population, including both Muslims and Christians, as well as a significant Jewish minority. The Balfour Declaration, issued by the British government in 1917, expressed support for the establishment of a "national home for the Jewish people" in Palestine. This declaration had a profound impact on the course of history in the region, leading to the creation of the State of Israel in 1948 and the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians.
The Balfour Declaration was issued during World War I, when Britain was seeking the support of Jewish communities around the world in its war against Germany. The declaration was also influenced by the Zionist movement, which was advocating for the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.
The Balfour Declaration was controversial from the start. Many Arabs opposed the declaration, arguing that it would lead to the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine at the expense of the Arab population. The British government tried to balance the interests of the Arab and Jewish populations by promising that the establishment of a Jewish national home in Palestine would not prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities.
However, the Balfour Declaration ultimately led to the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians. In 1948, when the British withdrew from Palestine and the State of Israel was declared, many Palestinians fled their homes in fear of persecution. The Palestinian refugee crisis remains a major challenge today.
The Balfour Declaration is a complex and controversial issue with a long and lasting impact on the Middle East. It is important to understand the historical context of the declaration and the different perspectives on it in order to have a informed discussion about the issue.
Two State Solution is the only way now,
Two state solution is impossible. The settlers already took so much land that the Palestinians and Israelis would never accept the same proposal.
You might be interested to take a look at the history regarding the treatment of Jews in Europe (including Russia) before the Balfour declaration and the first world war. Interestingly in later years it was Russia that supported the vote at the UN to continue with the the Palestine Mandatory plan at a time when the US abstained. Also if you read UN correspondence (or League of Nations) from involved parties regarding the 'Mandatory Palestine' from the particularly in the 1930s, that is quite informative regarding the events and responses of the different groups on the ground.
This is such bullshit.
@@inrising6658tough, it shoukd at rhe very least be 2 equal sized states. They can stay and be under the rule of Palestine or go to Israel. if they were happy to kick out Palestinians, or rule them, they can have a taste of their own medicine.
If Israel takes a long hard look at themselves this shouldn't be hard and countries need to put pressure on them to the right thing.
Excellent interview! He speaks truth.
are you kidding me
The best solution to these crises is not further violence.
Seek democratic and peaceful means.
Otherwise the cycle of violence will continue for ever.😊
Wonderful interview and discussion. It's a very hopeful perspective. Around the world, we are fighting against these strongmen, populist or authoritarian leaders who are attempting to force their way into power. We have to continue to fight against these leaders who divide people instead of uniting us. I fear we are at a dangerous point in history and if we aren't vigilant we'll all lose any freedom we have left. Thoughts and prayers for the Israeli and Palestinian populations. 🕊
yuval is vomitus, as per usual.
but what u describe is precisely, what left wing leaders around the world have done, so stop demonizing right wing people! I woke up from the left wing propaganda years ago, they are at fault when it comes to the deterioration of Europe, Love, an Obama voter.
Israeli-Palestinian conflict is about land, it lasts for decades and has nothing to do with "populist politicians" or "strongman". One population is trying to exterminate the other, that's what humans do.
It's the SAVAGES against CIVILIZATION.
Attempting their way into power????! I have some news: they have been rulings this world from day 1.
If you want to have productive conversation, here are the key questions in front of you:
1) Support for the Oppressed: Are you with the oppressed or with the oppressor? The conversation can only continue if you are in support of the oppressed.
2) Right to Defense: Does a person have the right to defend themselves if they are attacked? (Regardless of which side you support)
3) Equality of Human Lives: Are all human lives equal in your eyes? Are innocent civilians on both sides seen as equal, or is one life valued more than another?
4) Proportionality of the War: Has this war been proportionate, or has it been disproportionate? This one aims to highlight the imbalance in power and suffering in the conflict.
5) Media Fairness: Has the media been fair in their coverage of the conflict? (I personally thinks it's not but curios to hear your thoughts)
All good but I differ on your “proportionality” query. In the law of war, proportionality refers to the force required to achieve the objective. Not a tit-for-tat ratio. So a tactical nuke to take out an operational center would be disproportionate. But the deaths involved in striking a legitimate target using the minimally required force are not. Hamas’ use of “lawfare,” embedding it’s operations underneath an entire region with the aim to maximize casualties creates a hellish new reality. They have potentially turned the entire territory into a legitimate military target. International law has not caught up with this horrific challenge.
An investigative study of the root causes, why and what leads to such situation was expected from you @yuval as a respected expert in history and the region. No proper human would be in favour of violence but sometimes it is a way to disrupt the ongoing unfairness and make people listen.
This man is extremely disappointing and biased on this topic.
My mom read your books and was telling us how she loved them Mr Harare but said they were frightening too much for me to read
I've read mr Harari's books-he was saying that a big war is impossible in our day and age. Little did he know!
This coming war will be small in scale. The Ukraine-Russia war is so big but still is dwarfed by ww2
Wait
@@asad-kc8zf even if free Gaza from Palestinians terrorists, it's about 2 million civilian casualties. Equivalent of Syrian civil war or war in Iraq.
Did you read the whole chapter?afraid not
@@santiagoTo wtf are you talking about 2 million civil casuaties?