I heard this on the radio for the first time the other evening whilst driving home from work. I had to stop the car because it made me cry. So beautiful.
So awesome that you finally discovered it. I also first heard it on the radio way back in 2004 as a kid. Was listening to Classical WNED out of Buffalo NY. That station is still around to this day. :) It was through that station that I was introduced to this piece, among many others, that to this day remain favorites of mine. So timeless and breathtaking.
Overwhelmed with love and light. I sobbed the first time I heard it . . . all I wanted was my son. I later learned that she is singing about the love between mother and son. Wow!
Listening to this brilliant composition evokes feelings of desperation and despair so unjustly imposed on human beings. What one man can do to another is beyond imagination. Let us strive to become better human beings each day we live.
There are 3 differing scenarios that Gorecki attempted to address in his Symphony No.3. A child, a little girl tells her Mother both of endearing love and of mournful separation, the second is of a lost child, the mother's boy who is she believes is dead and the Mother cries to the earth to Love her son and then there is one in which there is simply a separation which is represented by significant mournful suffering.
Rarely does a piece of music resonate through your whole body like this one. It felt like all the cells in my body were swaying as one with this piece. So moving and emotional.
Been listening to this piece for decades. Nothing comes close in its sublime but hauntingly beautiful human experience. Thank you thank god thank the universe
in the second part of the Symphony, the composer used the text of the inscription carved by 18-year-old Helena Błażusiakówna on the wall of the Gestapo torture chamber "Palace" in Zakopane, where the young highlander was held in 1944. This text: "O Mother, do not cry, no - Heavenly Chaste Queen, you always support me", ends with the prayer call "Hail Mary".
I wept the first time I heard this not knowing the lyrics. So amazing how important the arts are for telling stories and connecting people. It isn't possible for me to know what it was like seeing the etchings on that cell wall or being a victim of the Nazis. However, when I hear this, I get the tiniest glimpse of the pain and suffering that so many endured. Thanks, Gorecki for composing such a beautiful and gut wrenching piece of music. And thank you to art and music for connecting us all.
My mother survived the death camp that was Dachau but her father died there. She never spoke of her experiences there but I am so lucky she lived because she was the best mother anyone could have.
This first time I heard Gorecki's Symphony 3, 2nd Movement, I was living in the South fo France and it was fall time. It was gray outside., raining and the air was cold. I remember having incense burning, perhaps a fire in the fireplace. It left such an impression on me. Several years later, I was listening to it on my walkman living in Kyoto, Japan walking in the snow. Triple wow! That movement just grabs me.
Such a longing, an ineffable ache that resonates with the soul. Gardens of pain watered with the tears of generations lost. Gentle beauty flows from pain that echos across the decades. We must never forget.
I heard this first 30 odd years ago, by headphones from a small DAB radio from what I found out to be Classic FM. I was cutting back a laurel tree, had to stop sit and listen. I subsequently got the CD from W H Smiths, I still have it and still play it. There are many superlatives easily to describe this. You all know what it's like, possibly one of the greatest pieces of music ever written.
I cannot watch this post of such a beautiful, emotive piece of music now that it is immediately interrupted by an intrusive and wholly inappropriate advert!
Cette voix d'une grande pureté me transperce le coeur comme la pointe d'une épée et je comprends l'immense douleur de toutes ces mères désespérées à la recherche de leurs fils partis à la guerre. C'est extrêmement poignant ! This voice of great purity pierces my heart like the tip of a sword and I understand the immense pain of all these desperate mothers looking for their sons gone to war.
Close your eyes and let it go! Yes,- let all the concerns go and just open up your heart and soul to the majesty of music in the human voice. No, life is not just chaos, there is great beauty and joy in the human experience. And don't look for a two-second "I LOVE IT"" when you click on this button. Not everything in life revolves around instant gratification. This music like a great love story takes time, not a lot of time-but when your heart opens and you go to the other dimension beyond just hearing with your ears and capture the true bliss of this magical video. If you listen to this music by yourself in the dark of the night and quietly by yourself, don't be surprised if you are visited by a loved one from your past .. and you will feel a powerful, yet gentle spiritual presence of love embrace you and you will weep tears of sad joy. I don't understand it either..... just accept the mystery and "Let it be." May there be fair winds guiding you in life and may you go to beautiful places ~~~Mike Jacobs
where so much pain and sufferin has happend, a deep bow those how surived the holocaust, and brought the nazis to hold, in the jusitice court, looking them straight in the eye, those mosters, a deep bow for this super humans
this song is based on scribbles left on the wall by young polish girl murdered by Gestapo (hitler's police) in Zakopane, Poland during WW2. Incredibly simple and incredibly powerfull music.
Zofia is magnificent. Such emotion and sorrow in her performance. One of the most moving pieces of music I have experienced. Sir Gilbert Levine is so pationate in his conducting. Bravo.
"Mamo, nie płacz, nie... Niebios Przeczysta Królowo, Ty zawsze wspieraj mnie. Zdrowaś Mario, Łaskiś Pełna". (modlitwa wyryta przez młodą łączniczkę ZWZ-AK w celi katowni gestapo. Poniżej modlitwy znajdowała się inskrypcja: Zakopane Palace, cela nr 3, ściana nr 3. Błażusiakówna Helena Wanda, lat 18, siedzi od 25 września 44"). [Helena Błażusiak nikogo nie zdradziwszy przeżyła tortury, a także udało się jej zbiec z transportu do obozu. Zmarła w 1999 r.].
Te powalające pięknem słowa, które Pani/Pan przytacza mają swój wyraz/miejsce w muzyce Pana Góreckiego. Dziękuję za chwytającą za serce historię młodej bohaterki. (Nawiasem mówiąc; niesamowite skojarzenie.
I heard this the first time performed by Ms. Upshaw during Czech Republic's presidential funeral. I immediately started crying and still do. Absolutely mind blowing.
The first time I heard this piece of music , after three or four minutes I started to cry , so beautiful is it ! :'( I have never heard such a beautiful piece of music ! I came to this beacause Sarah Brightman has a version of this on her new album ! :)
A deeply moving performance of one of the most profoundly moving pieces of all time. I find the harmonic change at 7:10 (start at at least 7:00) to be one of the most beautiful and moving changes in music - a sort of "letting go, and letting God" moment.
I came here from the soundtrack of a movie: Beautiful Boy. Never heard about Gorecki before watching the movie. His Symphony 3, Op.36 is outlandish. This particular performance is as magnificent as entire universe!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This is on the John Hopkins playlist for psylocibin therapy. I found dignity love respect union with nature that day. Such a powerful trip. Anyways every time I listen to this piece again it just makes me cry automatically. One of the most powerful pieces of music I’ve ever heard.
I agree that this version is superior! This song is so beautifully heartbreaking and Kilanowicz conveys every ounce of the song's emotion. Moves me every time.
It's almost like Henryk Gorecki was somewhat channeling "HE WHO IS" when writing this piece. It's justy ridiculously celestial! Hard to top the beauty of this symphony.
Lyrics translation I found: No, Mother, do not weep, Most chaste Queen of Heaven Support me always. "Zdrowas Mario." (*) Prayer inscribed on wall 3 of cell no. 3 in the basement of "Palace," the Gestapo's headquarters in Zadopane; beneath is the signature of Helena Wanda Blazusiakówna, and the words "18 years old, imprisoned since 26 September 1944.") (*) "Zdrowas Mario" (Ave Maria)-the opening of the Polish prayer to the Holy Mother
One of the most heart touching pieces of music I’ve had the pleasure of hearing. Thank you. Thank you to the composer, the performers and the majestic singer who can make an old man cry every time I listen.
Donald Lord let’s appreciate this fine piece together man, I assure you that every time I hear this I get very sentimental and I understand how you feel, it’s amazing how this song can touch people from all ages... amazing
and a deep respect for the holocaust surivors how would bring the people to justice and facing them in the eye like in the nuremberg trail deep respect wich people have sufferd
Pani Zofio, doskonała interpretacja. Brzmienie Pani głosu, szczerość emocji i wrażliwość serca jaką Pani posiada powodują że za każdym razem jak słucham tego utworu w Pani wykonaniu ...mam łzy w oczach.
I went on a tour to Poland. En trip of 7 day's to the shoah history. 7 days 7 concentration camps. Then thinking of those innocent people who lost their lives 😢😢😢. And listening to this wonderful music. Makes me cry al the time 😢😢😢 Wonderful 😢😢😢
WOW... Chills up and down my spine, tears in my eyes and in awe of such wonderful singing... Well played chaps and Beautifully sung too... *sighs* :0)X
This is hauntingly beautiful. It speaks of such tragedy and loss, that people can't fail to be moved by it. It could have been written for Dawn Upshaw's voice. She is able to communicate the melancholic beauty, like no one else I have heard.
This is not Dawn, this is a Polish soprano and it's performed in St. Mary's Church in Krakow. It has little to do with melancholy, it is poem written by a young girl on the wall of a Nazi prison to her mother before she was murdered there
@@BytomGirl It was a Gestapo cell in Zakopane and she was not murdered. Helena Wanda Błażusiakówna (born 4 February 1926, died 25 July 1999). The prayer is not to her mother, but to Mary Mother of Jesus: Mother, no, do not cry, Queen of Heaven most chaste Help me always. Hail Mary.
Watched and listened again to this moving peace of music. Not heard Zofia doing this before and I just wonder how she holds it together. It has made lockdown well worth it. I shall go and pull myself together.
This beautiful piece is a vocal rendition of soul searing grief. I rarely listen to it as it reduces me from the word to hopeless tears. It is without hope.
I know how you feel. My mother in fact survived the death camp that was Dachau but her father died there. I feel so lucky to have had the best mum in the world who was also my best friend.
I listen to this while I am typing my dissertation. Moving and yet unyieldingly sorrowful. Amazing how the mind can correlate music with inspiration- even a song so sorrowful as this.
I was driving in my car today when this piece came on my Symphony channel...Luckily, it was labeled, and I had to find it online to hear it again. So heartfelt and beautiful a piece! Bravo Zofia!!!😍
Simply breathtaking...I am writing a a book of poetry on a tragic recent war and though the poetry is very humorous they are also really tragic like any war ...this part of the symphony touches me so deeply that I hear the mothers cry and the fathers sigh...! Thank you Górecki . Wow
Fresh on my memory, can not recall other occasions that may have had this kind of joyful, beloved impression left on my emotions, ater exposure to an experience as such. Absolutely Marvelous.
I was lucky, as a Friend' of The LPO, to attend a rehearsal of Gorecki's music at the London Festival Hall. Was totally entranced, then and every time I hear this. Absolutely beautiful singing!
Esta obra do Henrik Goreck é fantástica e a interpretação da Zofia Kilanowicz é maravilhosa! A voz dela deixa minha alma inebriada e me leva a superiores esferas espirituais. SInto que estou sendo transportado para o mundo espiritual! É maravilhoso e fico bastante feliz e emocionado!
¡ recuerdo la presencia de Gorecki hace muchos años y el estreno con la 3a. sinfonía durante uno de los Festivales Cervantinos efectuado de Guanajuato, México !
I first heard this on BBC radio 6 music , Marc Radcliffe and Stuart MacConie show. Many years ago, lit the torch for me to explore other music. Thanks lads. ❤❤
The story behind this music is so heartbreaking that I can barely listen to it. Yet it is truly beautiful. This is indeed the sadist music I've ever heard.
I heard this masterpiece in 2004 on the Spanish National Broadcasting News after the 11th March Madrid trains bombings (193 killed and more than 2500 injured). This shympony with the images of 2'3 millions of people under the rain in Madrid and other 11 million people in the the rest of Spain the day after (12th of March) was very impressive. I was seven y.o. but I remember that like it was yesterday.
Paul R I love many styles and felt that this piece was like a slow rock song with big chunky power chords layered over bass. Not a classical nerd but love this And I have tickets to experience it live in November 😀
Thank you! I listened to as much of Upshaw's performance as possible, long after hearing Kilanowicz about 20 years earlier. The 3rd movement (sung by Kilanowicz!)is perhaps my favorite in all vocal music.
![Beth Gibbons / Penderecki / Górecki - Symphony No. 3 Final Movement [English Subtitles]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-YlGYxCSDJU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Beth Gibbons / Penderecki / Górecki - Symphony No. 3 Final Movement [English Subtitles]](/img/tr.png)
I heard this on the radio for the first time the other evening whilst driving home from work. I had to stop the car because it made me cry. So beautiful.
Music does that to me too.
Me too in my car and i stop too
It's truly a moving song.
Try listening to Boulez. He makes a lot of people cry too.
So awesome that you finally discovered it. I also first heard it on the radio way back in 2004 as a kid. Was listening to Classical WNED out of Buffalo NY. That station is still around to this day. :) It was through that station that I was introduced to this piece, among many others, that to this day remain favorites of mine. So timeless and breathtaking.
The most beautiful and heartbracking music I have ever heard . I’m an old punk rocker . . . I’m still crying
one of my favourite pieces of music I have ever heard in my entire life. I see galaxies when I hear it.
i totally agree this is from god
Overwhelmed with love and light. I sobbed the first time I heard it . . . all I wanted was my son. I later learned that she is singing about the love between mother and son. Wow!
Wonderful comment.
Perfect comment from you. Thanks, Indyana.
Agree, unbelievably moving and beautiful. Zofia is an angle.
If your tears fall to this beautiful voice and music…. It’s is your souls release xxx
Listening to this brilliant composition evokes feelings of desperation and despair so unjustly imposed on human beings. What one man can do to another is beyond imagination. Let us strive to become better human beings each day we live.
There are 3 differing scenarios that Gorecki attempted to address in his Symphony No.3. A child, a little girl tells her Mother both of endearing love and of mournful separation, the second is of a lost child, the mother's boy who is she believes is dead and the Mother cries to the earth to Love her son and then there is one in which there is simply a separation which is represented by significant mournful suffering.
Rarely does a piece of music resonate through your whole body like this one. It felt like all the cells in my body were swaying as one with this piece. So moving and emotional.
The first time I heard this it overwhelmed me. Tears running down even tho I didnt understand a single Word. Its so powerfull.
Been listening to this piece for decades. Nothing comes close in its sublime but hauntingly beautiful human experience. Thank you thank god thank the universe
I don't understand a single word, yet my soul is overwhelmed by her majestic voice.
in the second part of the Symphony, the composer used the text of the inscription carved by 18-year-old Helena Błażusiakówna on the wall of the Gestapo torture chamber "Palace" in Zakopane, where the young highlander was held in 1944. This text: "O Mother, do not cry, no - Heavenly Chaste Queen, you always support me", ends with the prayer call "Hail Mary".
It’s based on a little girl poem scratched in the wall of a concentration camp.
Basically it’s. Mother mother were are you I can’t find you im scared
Then you did understand every word.
It's very good that they chose a Polish soprano because version with soprano Dawn Upshaw was little cringe.
O Mamo nie placz nie
Oh, Mamma do not cry
Niebios Przeczysta Królowo
Immaculate Queen of Heaven
Ty zawsze wspieraj mnie
support me always
Has to be the most powerful combination of a beautiful voice and wonderful day orchestra, conductor and venue. Moved me to tears.
I wept the first time I heard this not knowing the lyrics. So amazing how important the arts are for telling stories and connecting people. It isn't possible for me to know what it was like seeing the etchings on that cell wall or being a victim of the Nazis. However, when I hear this, I get the tiniest glimpse of the pain and suffering that so many endured. Thanks, Gorecki for composing such a beautiful and gut wrenching piece of music. And thank you to art and music for connecting us all.
My mother survived the death camp that was Dachau but her father died there. She never spoke of her experiences there but I am so lucky she lived because she was the best mother anyone could have.
Nie NAZISTÓW TYLKO NIEMCÓW .
Please can u write the lyrics i couldn't understand it
True.
@@nickbateman484 you can google it in English
This first time I heard Gorecki's Symphony 3, 2nd Movement, I was living in the South fo France and it was fall time. It was gray outside., raining and the air was cold. I remember having incense burning, perhaps a fire in the fireplace. It left such an impression on me. Several years later, I was listening to it on my walkman living in Kyoto, Japan walking in the snow. Triple wow! That movement just grabs me.
This seems one of those pieces of music that should end not with applause but a holy hush.
Well said.
The setting for this recorded performance is magnificent.
"a Holy Hush" that is very good
everytime i think i'll keep it together and then she hits those high notes and my eyes just water all on their own
Trappa skunk it's not you crying it's your soul
Such a longing, an ineffable ache that resonates with the soul.
Gardens of pain watered with the tears of generations lost.
Gentle beauty flows from pain that echos across the decades. We must never forget.
thank you my mother survived the holocaust but was never a zionist; there is a place for us all to live together. Thank you!!!
bless her and her soul! may her memory be a blessing
The awful agony of those who witnessed the holocaust must never be erased. Bless your mother and wishing her every peace! Love from Eire ❤
I heard this first 30 odd years ago, by headphones from a small DAB radio from what I found out to be Classic FM. I was cutting back a laurel tree, had to stop sit and listen. I subsequently got the CD from W H Smiths, I still have it and still play it. There are many superlatives easily to describe this. You all know what it's like, possibly one of the greatest pieces of music ever written.
Do you know where this was recorded? I’d love to know which cathedral this is.
Ouch, 30 years ago was the 2000s...
My, how time passes 😢
That's in Krakow, Poland. @@carolinepollard5455
@@carolinepollard5455....this is Holly Mary cathedral (14/15 c.) in Kraków (Poland)....
A masterpiece one of the most beautiful pieces of music ever produced
100% agree.
@@johnkropczynski3358 me too from the horrors of the holocasut and the surivors of that time a deep respect
ruclips.net/video/0hxGf3qvivc/видео.html IN FULL
I cannot watch this post of such a beautiful, emotive piece of music now that it is immediately interrupted by an intrusive and wholly inappropriate advert!
One of my most favourite pieces of music of all time. 🎼🪔🎼🪔
This superb composer makes all who listen to his music cry..there is no one like him.
I see souls returning to heaven when I listen to this
One if the most moving pieces of music I've ever heard. I just heard this on the radio and it stopped me in my tracks 🥺🥺🥺
Beautiful, yes sorrowfull, but turns sorrow into joy from such a tragidy. Inspiring and motivating. Never forget ❤
Cette voix d'une grande pureté me transperce le coeur comme la pointe d'une épée et je comprends l'immense douleur de toutes ces mères désespérées à la recherche de leurs fils partis à la guerre. C'est extrêmement poignant !
This voice of great purity pierces my heart like the tip of a sword and I understand the immense pain of all these desperate mothers looking for their sons gone to war.
Close your eyes and let it go!
Yes,- let all the concerns go and just open up your heart and soul to the majesty of music in the human voice.
No, life is not just chaos, there is great beauty and joy in the human experience. And don't look for a two-second "I LOVE IT"" when you click on this button. Not everything in life revolves around instant gratification.
This music like a great love story takes time, not a lot of time-but when your heart opens and you go to the other dimension beyond just hearing with your ears and capture the true bliss of this magical video.
If you listen to this music by yourself in the dark of the night and quietly by yourself, don't be surprised if you are visited by a loved one from your past .. and you will feel a powerful, yet gentle spiritual presence of love embrace you and you will weep tears of sad joy.
I don't understand it either..... just accept the mystery and "Let it be."
May there be fair winds guiding you in life and may you go to beautiful places ~~~Mike Jacobs
this 'breathtaking cathedral' is actually a St. Mary's Basilica, one of the main landmarks in the Royal City of Krakow
where so much pain and sufferin has happend, a deep bow those how surived the holocaust, and brought the nazis to hold, in the jusitice court, looking them straight in the eye, those mosters, a deep bow for this super humans
hearing this wonderfull music, the horror of the holocaust, and the evil nazis, with no regard for life, al deep respect for the holocaust survivors
which is where my mother's family came from and she was in fact a holocaust survivor. Tx for mentioning this beautiful cathedral!!
A beautifully emotional piece to describe the most horrific event in recent human history
To what event are you referring? 3:16
@@paks2muchjewish holocaust
One of the most horrific
Big Big Love to Poland and thank You .
I got stucked by this moment in my chair and my mouth astonishingly open wide while following her chanting those Polish words of agony😢😢
I love these pieces so much. Cant wait see this performed live next year in The Hague.
Very moving piece. I can't help from crying.
La musique la plus émouvante jamais écrite...merveilleuse Zofia Kilanowicz,et quelle magnifique cathédrale
A most beautiful rendition. Skin-tingling! This music is so highly charged.....I hold on tight, rising and falling, tears in my eyes!
this song is based on scribbles left on the wall by young polish girl murdered by Gestapo (hitler's police) in Zakopane, Poland during WW2. Incredibly simple and incredibly powerfull music.
it isnt.a myth
Zofia is magnificent. Such emotion and sorrow in her performance. One of the most moving pieces of music I have experienced. Sir Gilbert Levine is so pationate in his conducting. Bravo.
varshava ?
à TOULON .
BÂSE SOUS - MARINE ? EN BRETÂGNE .
Absolutely mesmerising! My heart ached, and my throat 'closed' with emotion.
"Mamo, nie płacz, nie...
Niebios Przeczysta Królowo,
Ty zawsze wspieraj mnie.
Zdrowaś Mario, Łaskiś Pełna".
(modlitwa wyryta przez młodą łączniczkę ZWZ-AK w celi katowni gestapo. Poniżej modlitwy znajdowała się inskrypcja:
Zakopane Palace, cela nr 3, ściana nr 3. Błażusiakówna Helena Wanda, lat 18, siedzi od 25 września 44").
[Helena Błażusiak nikogo nie zdradziwszy przeżyła tortury, a także udało się jej zbiec z transportu do obozu. Zmarła w 1999 r.].
Te powalające pięknem słowa, które Pani/Pan przytacza mają swój wyraz/miejsce w muzyce Pana Góreckiego. Dziękuję za chwytającą za serce historię młodej bohaterki. (Nawiasem mówiąc; niesamowite skojarzenie.
I heard this the first time performed by Ms. Upshaw during Czech Republic's presidential funeral. I immediately started crying and still do. Absolutely mind blowing.
The only song that always makes me cry.
One of the most beautiful and powerful pieces of emotion 🌹
i first heard this on the radio and it struck me- was able to find the name and its a true favorite
The first time I heard this piece of music , after three or four minutes I started to cry , so beautiful is it ! :'( I have never heard such a beautiful piece of music ! I came to this beacause Sarah Brightman has a version of this on her new album ! :)
I also discovered this beautiful piece thanks to Sarah...
A deeply moving performance of one of the most profoundly moving pieces of all time. I find the harmonic change at 7:10 (start at at least 7:00) to be one of the most beautiful and moving changes in music - a sort of "letting go, and letting God" moment.
Stunning words here ❤
Jeez. I haven't listened to this beautiful piece of music in a while. This performance is breathtaking.
I'm dying to sing this solo. It is so breathtakingly, beautifully sad.
I came here from the soundtrack of a movie: Beautiful Boy. Never heard about Gorecki before watching the movie. His Symphony 3, Op.36 is outlandish. This particular performance is as magnificent as entire universe!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Me too! I just watched Beautiful Boy and had to find this piece of music. So beautiful!!
Me as well, loved the soundtrack but this piece is the best!
Also used to great effect on the film, Fearless (1993),about a man who survived a plane crash
Came to descover this piece same circumstances. How did I search on my tv screen at the end of the list for the music of this film!!
Me to : I can't stop listening to every version I can find
This is on the John Hopkins playlist for psylocibin therapy. I found dignity love respect union with nature that day. Such a powerful trip. Anyways every time I listen to this piece again it just makes me cry automatically. One of the most powerful pieces of music I’ve ever heard.
I agree that this version is superior! This song is so beautifully heartbreaking and Kilanowicz conveys every ounce of the song's emotion. Moves me every time.
its devine and the surivors of the horror of the holocaust a deep respect for them mean the jews how have the most scars
It's almost like Henryk Gorecki was somewhat channeling "HE WHO IS" when writing this piece. It's justy ridiculously celestial! Hard to top the beauty of this symphony.
Lyrics translation I found:
No, Mother, do not weep,
Most chaste Queen of Heaven
Support me always.
"Zdrowas Mario." (*)
Prayer inscribed on wall 3 of cell no. 3 in the basement of "Palace," the Gestapo's headquarters in Zadopane; beneath is the signature of Helena Wanda Blazusiakówna, and the words "18 years old, imprisoned since 26 September 1944.")
(*) "Zdrowas Mario" (Ave Maria)-the opening of the Polish prayer to the Holy Mother
Sean4Help... Thanks
in Zakopane
One of the most heart touching pieces of music I’ve had the pleasure of hearing. Thank you. Thank you to the composer, the performers and the majestic singer who can make an old man cry every time I listen.
Donald Lord let’s appreciate this fine piece together man, I assure you that every time I hear this I get very sentimental and I understand how you feel, it’s amazing how this song can touch people from all ages... amazing
Thank you so much!!!
Compulsive, hypnotic, inspiring, beautiful.
Unbelievable, out of this world
and the story behind this masterpiece is terrifyingly moving.
and a deep respect for the holocaust surivors how would bring the people to justice and facing them in the eye like in the nuremberg trail deep respect wich people have sufferd
Your mother is wonderful and blessed, as you are. Peace and love to you family. Xx
I heard this haunting and yet beautiful music 25 years ago and will never forget it. When I knew the story of the lamenting voice it made me cry.
Pani Zofio, doskonała interpretacja. Brzmienie Pani głosu, szczerość emocji i wrażliwość serca jaką Pani posiada powodują że za każdym razem jak słucham tego utworu w Pani wykonaniu ...mam łzy w oczach.
Moves me
Always will
Hope it will others
all my polish friends swallow their pride, one didn't, about the pronunciation. achingly brilliant.
I went on a tour to Poland. En trip of 7 day's to the shoah history. 7 days 7 concentration camps. Then thinking of those innocent people who lost their lives 😢😢😢. And listening to this wonderful music. Makes me cry al the time 😢😢😢
Wonderful 😢😢😢
Next time visit Ukraine and the rest of Eastern Europe to know the history of the Holodomors.
WOW... Chills up and down my spine, tears in my eyes and in awe of such wonderful singing... Well played chaps and Beautifully sung too... *sighs* :0)X
This is hauntingly beautiful. It speaks of such tragedy and loss, that people can't fail to be moved by it. It could have been written for Dawn Upshaw's voice. She is able to communicate the melancholic beauty, like no one else I have heard.
This is not Dawn Upshaw.
@@shinylittlegoldfish unfortunately
This is not Dawn, this is a Polish soprano and it's performed in St. Mary's Church in Krakow. It has little to do with melancholy, it is poem written by a young girl on the wall of a Nazi prison to her mother before she was murdered there
@@shinylittlegoldfish Fortunately
@@BytomGirl It was a Gestapo cell in Zakopane and she was not murdered. Helena Wanda Błażusiakówna (born 4 February 1926, died 25 July 1999). The prayer is not to her mother, but to Mary Mother of Jesus:
Mother, no, do not cry,
Queen of Heaven most chaste
Help me always.
Hail Mary.
Watched and listened again to this moving peace of music. Not heard Zofia doing this before and I just wonder how she holds it together. It has made lockdown well worth it. I shall go and pull myself together.
The most beautiful thing i have ever heard.
It is the symphony I have listened to the most times, by far, in my life, and it is part of my personal soundtrack.
This should have 363 million views.
ciarki przechodzą ....brawo Pani Zofio
Achingly beautiful. Thank you.
This beautiful piece is a vocal rendition of soul searing grief. I rarely listen to it as it reduces me from the word to hopeless tears. It is without hope.
I know how you feel. My mother in fact survived the death camp that was Dachau but her father died there. I feel so lucky to have had the best mum in the world who was also my best friend.
I listen to this while I am typing my dissertation. Moving and yet unyieldingly sorrowful. Amazing how the mind can correlate music with inspiration- even a song so sorrowful as this.
Ja Ich verstehe sie Yes I Understane you complete volich ganz, volledig. Lammert Doedens. I am also writting on my book witch this music.
Nancy Ann
I’m listening to this while I am eating my dessert
What a beautiful voice...love this piece! Thank you all.
I was driving in my car today when this piece came on my Symphony channel...Luckily, it was labeled, and I had to find it online to hear it again. So heartfelt and beautiful a piece! Bravo Zofia!!!😍
Każdy jego utwór, jest wielki. Zarówno minimalistyczne "Święty, święty", jak i wielkie symfonie. Mistrz Górecki!
Merci pour l'écriture polonaise !!!
Perfeito ! Imortal ! Magnífico!
Simply breathtaking...I am writing a a book of poetry on a tragic recent war and though the poetry is very humorous they are also really tragic like any war ...this part of the symphony touches me so deeply that I hear the mothers cry and the fathers sigh...! Thank you Górecki . Wow
Marvelous piece of music
Fresh on my memory, can not recall other occasions that may have had this kind of joyful, beloved impression left on my emotions, ater exposure to an experience as such.
Absolutely Marvelous.
Beautiful beyond words
Bravo! 👏What a magnificent voice!
I was lucky, as a Friend' of The LPO, to attend a rehearsal of Gorecki's music at the London Festival Hall. Was totally entranced, then and every time I hear this. Absolutely beautiful singing!
Oh My!! Beautifully sung, and equally beautifully played. Absolutely flawless!
Esta obra do Henrik Goreck é fantástica e a interpretação da Zofia Kilanowicz é maravilhosa! A voz dela deixa minha alma inebriada e me leva a superiores esferas espirituais. SInto que estou sendo transportado para o mundo espiritual! É maravilhoso e fico bastante feliz e emocionado!
I will always love this piece and beautifull performance of Ms Zofia Kilanowicz
From time to time I hear this magic Symphony... it is Wonderful
WOW! Must have been amazing being there in person.
¡ recuerdo la presencia de Gorecki hace muchos años y el estreno con la 3a. sinfonía durante uno de los Festivales Cervantinos efectuado de Guanajuato, México !
I first heard this on BBC radio 6 music , Marc Radcliffe and Stuart MacConie show. Many years ago, lit the torch for me to explore other music. Thanks lads. ❤❤
The story behind this music is so heartbreaking that I can barely listen to it. Yet it is truly beautiful. This is indeed the sadist music I've ever heard.
Perfect....i was driving in my car when i first heard this..couldn't believe it ...so powerful and emotional.......
I'm speechless. It moved me to tears...
Oh my God,My soul can fly whit this piece,my ears felling soooo good!This piece talk with the most deep part of me!
So emotional with an inspiring message of hope ❤
absolutely beautiful deeply moving nothing like brought me to tears
I heard this masterpiece in 2004 on the Spanish National Broadcasting News after the 11th March Madrid trains bombings (193 killed and more than 2500 injured).
This shympony with the images of 2'3 millions of people under the rain in Madrid and other 11 million people in the the rest of Spain the day after (12th of March) was very impressive.
I was seven y.o. but I remember that like it was yesterday.
Such a beautiful, haunting piece of music.
i bought this album years ago. I love it, I am not a huge fan of classical music but this does it for me. So so good.
Paul R
I love many styles and felt that this piece was like a slow rock song with big chunky power chords layered over bass.
Not a classical nerd but love this
And I have tickets to experience it live in November 😀
Absolutely impressive Sorrow which is growing towards HOPE
今から３０年ぐらい前、話題になった曲ですね❤
当時は、デビット•ジンマンのCDがヒットしたと思います。
こうやって動画で聴くことが出来て感謝いたします。
どうもありがとうございます😊
An Absolute Masterpiece... My soul flies with this, this makes me a human...
Thank you! I listened to as much of Upshaw's performance as possible, long after hearing Kilanowicz about 20 years earlier. The 3rd movement (sung by Kilanowicz!)is perhaps my favorite in all vocal music.
This song encapsulates my Mum's last year's of life , then her freedom .....
Truly beautiful. And the backdrop. Hairs on ends, what an experience this must have been. Wonderful art .
Just so beautiful,makes you heart and soul soar