The Ultimate Star Wars Ranking

[@pabhk]

My taste kinda tracks yours. I can see why people don't like Solo, but I quite enjoyed it tbh. It was fun. As for Andor, I have been thinking of ways to introduce Jedis (and thus make detractors happy) without breaking its sense of realism. For example, what would stop a Jedi or Sith from breaking everyone's neck in a certain radius? (They can lift X-Wings after all) I imagine them being much more feared/respected, but only in close encounters. Their powers would be inconsequential in warfare and they would have to rely on their very human capabilities, like everyone else's.

[@kevinbahr5954]

There are arguably worse-quality films and shows than Last Jedi, but man, that was the first and only time I left a theater depressed and angry. F you, Rian Johnson.

[@MrIbbitson]

I can not disagree more on Asohka - it's OUTSTANDING! I also love SOLO and the music....

[@mikerohlfing]

We agree 50% then 😊

[@krish_4872]

There’s only one way out of this Disney nightmare, ONE WAY OUT!

[@cjk225]

Nice video, definitely deserves more attention 👌🏻

[@mikerohlfing]

Thanks for watching!

[@ThatFilmGuyyy]

Fantastic editing!

[@mikerohlfing]

Thanks!!

[@charliedupuis8461]

Mate keep going you deserve way more subs and views.

[@mikerohlfing]

Thanks! I have lots of ideas, just need the time.

[@andys.9526]

Agree with you except for Solo which I found reeeeally bad.

[@mikerohlfing]

Good enough! 😊

[@wafflestoyou]

What a good video amazingly well done

[@mikerohlfing]

Thank you!

[@KyubiBlossom]

Altough I respect your opinion on the LA Disney SW I would have found it just waaaaay too funny if u actually said what probably anyone, but those Disney fanbois (sorry but true lol), have thought alrdy starting the video with "Ranking all the SW LA Disney Shows from Worst to best... First off i gotta mention they are all in a grave already, anyways lets start with nr. 10" lol
Despite that I'd say decent ranking altough for me (not having watched anything after mando got bad and kenobi beeing a disappointment) Rogue one is arguably the best...Setting, Story that is actually in harony with OG Triology and Prequel, interesting and not woke characters...and many more things (Droid being the Goat of the Crew)
Maybe Andor has the same charm ? idk if so def. worth a watch
Keep it up dude!

[@mikerohlfing]

I love reading everyone’s takes! It’s hard to rank these, but it was fun to do. Thanks for watching.

[@Fragos_04]

1) The Mandalorian
2) Rogue One
3) Andor
4) Ashoka
5) The Book of Boba Fett
6) Solo
7) The Acolypte
8) The Force Awakens
9) Obi Wan Kenobi
10) The Rise of Skywalker
11) The Last Jedi

[@spacemanspiff3052]

While I don’t agree with your list, I get your thinking and it’s certainly valid. However, from worst to best . . . including the Acolyte because the last episode isn’t going to save the show or make it worse . . .
F- The Rise of Skywalker (trash)
F The Acolyte (Bad storytelling and production, total waste of a good cast)
D. The Last Jedi (Bad choices, but at least it was the creative contribution to the misfired Sequel Trilogy, still love seeing Mark Hamill though I didn’t see Luke Skywalker)
C- The Force Awakens (It’s ok but lacks creativity, too bad likable new cast love seeing OG cast)
C. Solo (I agree, not a bad movie, a lot I like, but very inconsequential overall)
C+ The Book of Boba Fett (an uneven mess, but a lot I liked and memorably so).
C+. Kenobi (also uneven and mildly disappointing, but when it was good it was great!!!)
B- Ahsoka (Thank goodness for a strong later half of season to save uninspired early episodes)
B. The Mandalorian (the 3rd season had some good episodes on par with earlier seasons, but it didn’t stick the landing because of some surprisingly weak episodes)
A+ Andor was magnificent storytelling and I’m so excited for season 2.
So, as someone who saw the original Star Wars in 1977 release as a 5 year old and was a fan ever since, I’m not as angry at Disney for its misfires because I remember many misfires under George Lucas’ helm.
F- The Star Wars Holiday Special (even though I LOVE Harvey Corman)
D- The made for TV Ewoks’ Caravan of Courage and Battle for Endor (don’t remember much about them other than they were goofy, a mess, and the latter was very dark)
D+ The Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones (Great world-building, but so much I didn’t like in overall execution, really rehabilitated by Clone Wars animation by first Tartakovsky and then Filoni. )
B+ Revenge of the Sith (The good one of the Prequel Trilogy)
A- Return of the Jedi
A. Star Wars
A+. The Empire Strikes Back
Like any franchise, SW has its ups and downs.

[@mikerohlfing]

What about Rouge One?

[@spacemanspiff3052]

@@mikerohlfing Thanks! I can’t believe I forgot Rogue One. I liked it a lot, wasn’t perfect, but near so. I’d give it an A-, just another reason why Disney Star Wars isn’t all bad.
Though I can never forgive them for setting their Star Wars theme parks in the Sequel era.

[@mikerohlfing]

@@spacemanspiff3052 I appreciate your opinions! I love your detailed list. I agree about the theme parks. I enjoy Galaxy's Edge, but it could've been so much better.

[@Dark_Voice]

For me, I dont like the Solo movie at all but its 3rd place. Rogue one is for me first place and Andor second. Everything else I throw in the trash can.
So my ranking?
1.Rogue one
2. Andor
3. Solo
...
25. Force awakens
...
66. Everything else
...
Absolutely off the charts is Acolyte so far. BUT its best feature is the drama around it :) That show is so bad its comical. I wouldnt survive more than those 20 min I wasted already and wanna refund on those but watching the plot summary and the comical ripping of it to shreds by Crittical drinker etc. is just so good :D

[@mikerohlfing]

Interesting list! I was hoping Acolyte would improve, but that hasn’t happened.

[@CurriedBat]

I would swap The Last Jedi with Ahsoka... and maybe even leave Solo where you left it... it's hard to measure my hatred.

[@user-dl1zx9sr4q]

I disagree with you in one point. You put VII episode above Mandalorian. VII episode was a huge disrespect to SW and I can not understand how anybody could like it.
Also, I respect Solo but IMHO Rogue One is better but it is not a big disagreement.

[@love_and_light_in_heart]

Your video is very professional and well done. I appreciate your respectful approach. I wish you good luck in the future and a lot of views!

[@mikerohlfing]

Thank you! I appreciate it.

[@Matkatamiba]

What was the behind the scenes drama with Rogue One?

[@mikerohlfing]

They brought in a new writer/director (Tony Gilroy) late in the project to rework and reshoot a considerable portion of the movie.

[@ryankinsey3903]

Wrong ranking for Mando! But otherwise I agree

[@TGx92]

Episode 9 is god awful. The worst one of all time

[@vesbudi7890]

Episode 8??? Come ooon , that’s the worst episode eveeeer

[@mikerohlfing]

I've seen worse. :) Thanks for watching!

[@TGx92]

9 is the absolute worst

[@vesbudi7890]

Your ranking sucks

[@love_and_light_in_heart]

It is important to respect each other and understand that everyone has the right to their own opinion. Although I also consider The Last Jedi to be a bad movie, I think The Rise of Skywalker is much worse.

[@mikerohlfing]

Bantha poodoo?

[@leevaughn9360]

Andor is by far the worst piece of crap to be part of all of Star Wars it ranks below the holiday special

[@carlosdanielpina2896]

I'm not trying to disrespect you, but... Did you watch The Acolyte?