Get 20% off Car Vertical using code Autoalex! GB: www.carvertical.com/gb/landing/v3?a=AutoAlex&b=38b26e3a&voucher=autoalex US: www.carvertical.com/landing/v3?a=AutoAlex&b=2c9b600c&voucher=autoalex
@@adamcox374it’s actually not against the law to use two way radio equipment while driving as long as it’s not being used in a way that is proven to be a distraction that could lead to careless or dangerous driving. That’s why use Amateur and CB radio equipment is allowed while driving.
@@ratgreen They saw it done on Top Gear (the real stuff, with Clarkson, Hammond and May) and it's heavily.. "inspired" (without caravans and SUV) from the Last episode which the golden trio were in called SUV Caravan Challenge.
Could do with bringing in Jack and Eaton from all the gear to sort out the camera work. For 2 guys on their own making full videos their footage is always amazing, could really have done with those guys on this shoot
@@Budisgud69 They have drone shots in other parts of the video. They also have GoPros. Instead of putting multiple ones on the outside, they could have just used one to film the speedometer. We don't need Top Gear/Grand Tour levels of production, we just want them to do a bit better.
@@MrDedatYToh bore off you melt, the content wasn’t worth watching because of the shit footage they had and what felt like cringy scripting of top gear like moments.
Also felt so scripted to be like a top gear moment especially when Rory shouted in Alex’s face after his handbrake turn and moving the cone on Taylor 🤦🏻♂️
@@eirebhoy132 yea that was really annoying and Rory acting like James on the way round whilst Alex and Taylor do the Clarkson and Hammond thing on the sidelines. Like ffs we all loved top gear of course and we appreciate similarities sometimes but that doesn’t mean we want the wish version on every video
Not often I say this, but the camerawork was pants on this video! Why wasn’t the drone used on the first two challenges? All reaction shots, no action shots.
Guys you've built a cracking channel without all the obvious scripted crap up until now. Please don't go down that rabbit hole just to force content and views. The "crash" into the tree just screams faked laziness. We know you are better than this!
hopping down to check the comments and i’m not disappointed by the community. shot choices all over the shop. it also feels like you’re moving away from “lads having fun with motahs” to being a littttleeeee bit too try hard. felt forced in a lot of spots chaps.
Agreed. The another channel trying to be top gear choice is starting to become quite obvious. I've never laughed as hard as when Alex & Taylor first starting mucking about with cars in the yard. Now it's all feeling quite forced
@@Traxxmaciek I would argue it’s possibly budget. You can hire a cameraman for 25k a year, but they’ll be straight out of uni with little experience of how to plan their filming schedule, not just physically shoot it. Could be wrong of course but this is how it feels.
I’ve mentioned this before but hopefully persistence pays off, please hire a producer. You need someone who isn’t presenting or filming to be planning these videos more thoroughly; someone who is there with a shot list, a rough plan and an idea of what’s coming up next. There are so many missed opportunities in this, including drone shots of some of the challenges, better timed exterior shots of the handbrake turns, voiceovers that could have replaced minutes of waffle, a physical scoreboard, etc. In fact, this whole off road segment could have been exactly that, a 10 minute segment in a 30 minute video. The other segments could be their enjoyment on a b-road in Wales, how much shit you can cram in them, or how many underaged girls the corsa can attract in a maccies car park (don’t do that). I don’t think any of us would mind waiting a little longer for something that had some more variety, a stricter editing process and a little more production value.
Remember that he left car throttle and started this channel with the purpose of being able to own and do whatever he wants without having a producer and a bunch of suits breathing down his neck. But with that being said, the editing and camera work in general was off on this one.
@@AlmightyDilan That isn't the job of a producer though-they're simply there to make sure things go according to plan . Alex can still come up with all the ideas and have total control, of course, but trying to present and direct at the same time is a difficult task.
@@AlmightyDilan producers weren’t the problem there, all they do is make sure everything is polished and I don’t mean fake or set up. Basically they help him implement his ideas.
@@KeyBrosUK you guys are absolutely right, production value is essential to growth and i wouldnt mind seeing it, but im just not sure thats the direction hes going for I could be wrong tho
@@DueVolvi Thats the reason I stopped watching TV and started looking on YT for people who show (at least mostly) their real personality + stuff was real and not written.
@@Twistandgouk Ah yes the typical brain dead comment of "If you criticize you have to go there and do better". I'm sure you never criticized politicians, footballers, cooks, race drivers etc etc. Dumb cunt
I feel like you guys forgot to actually record the cars instead of just jump cutting between angles of yourself lol. For reference go watch a gears and gasoline video
@@YusufJoeKarolia werent Jack and Ethan a camera man and an editor originally at CT though? Maybe I'm misremembering! No matter though, I agree, All the Gear vids are great!
so to decide what's the best car you drove them around a mud pit for 40 seconds while filming your faces? Nah, great concept(not a new one..), extremely poor execution between the 3 of you bouncing ideas, that's the best you could come up with,do handbrake turns in cars without a functioning handbrake, and doing a nascar lap around a square soggy field in hot hatches??
@@rg6982 You think the comment section is only for you to go on your knees and giving that hawk tuah to RUclipsrs? No. It's to criticize them as well... dipstick.
Judging by the comments you’ve liked, I’d say it’s safe to assume you purposely went for the “top gear vibe” which is fair enough. You need to listen to your community and take on the feedback though. Being sat there liking all the comments glazing the video makes it look more like you’re sticking your head in the dirt than anything. I’m sure you’re aware of Cleetus’ channel. They did a few “Challenge” video series and none of those videos came across as cheap and knockoff-y as this. I get the budgets are very different, but there is more you could’ve done here. RUclips is RUclips and people want to see authentic and genuine content. This is everything but. Stop with the fakery before it’s too late. And if you’re gonna do a Top Gear “inspired” video, be honest about your intentions. It’s one thing to pay homage to something so beloved (and consequently ruined) and it’s another thing to attempt to copy it. If you really were going for a top gear inspired video, it was truly, horrendously executed. I’m really not wanting this to come across like I’m hating. I’ve been watching since the early Car Throttle days, I just don’t want this channel to be in the “Top 10 hardest automotive RUclipsr falloff’s of all time” Please listen to the constructive feedback you get.
The camera work was dreadful, on the handbrake turns we got an inside shot it you driving in then an outside shot of a parked car. And Alex’s crash was also missed looked too staged.
Alex, listen to your viewers. Cut the Billy bullshit btec acting, staged stunts and budget challenges where 2 out of 3 go over budget. We all subscribe to support you and our mutual passion for cars. Don't forget your roots.
The gang produce brilliant content but this felt a little rushed, more cameramen/women would help. Luke being the independent adjudicator would have added something…
No doubt a lot of work went into doing this. It just seems like not a lot of brains or consideration did. First of all, why are you on mud in hot hatches? Why do we not get full exterior shots of the challenges being performed? The entire video flow is boring, the cuts are the same for the entire duration and the laugh seems really forced. You can do better than this. You would have had more genuine and funny content, if you had planned this challenge better. It could have been an autocross challenge, reverse J turns, B road testing, blasting offensive music and seeing which car gets the most attention, rev limit sound-off, wheelspin attempts, getting young girls opinions, dressing up as hot hatch teenagers and so on.. Hope to see you returning to better form soon! All the best
@@John.Winchester yeah Rory comes over as an overdramtic 2 year old that always sounds like his crying ... and the way he comes up with b.s so quick is pretty alarming ... wouldn't trust him as far as I could throw him
Sorry to say this felt well under par guys, poor camerawork, far too scripted, over excitement, fake laughter, very cheesy and 1st ever time I've turned off early. I appreciate change/evolving is good, but this seemed completely forced and unnatural. Generally love what you do and I'll be back for the next video 👍
I feel like this video is an example of where they crossed the line of invoking the 'spirit' of old Top Gear and actually trying to replicate it. The latter is doomed to fail. Top Gear couldn't even replicate Top Gear anymore.
Apologies, I really don't like "hating" but I think you need to invest in more/better camera men and better editing. How you don't actually show the shot of the cars doing the handbrake turns or Alex accidentally reversing to name a few examples just seems so amateur.
Agreed, although what they need is a producer/director IMO. Someone who isn’t presenting or filming and can focus on the upcoming shots, general plan, the edit, etc. There’s so much potential to be had but this one thing is holding them back hugely I think
But this is RUclips, things happen rather than pretend to happen? You need to demand an immediate refund of the feck all this cost you and get back to the Grand Tour
@@stuartkennedy2082 That’s a rather needlessly aggressive way to respond. People are simply giving feedback, which is what these comments are for. I agree, things need to happen and not pretend to happen, but the production value needs to improve.
wouldnt be able to do a drone shot of the puegeot as it was clearly scripted, hope these lot down go down the route of making up stuff for entertainment its just lazy
The older I have gotten, the more opportunity I have had to afford nicer vehicles. However, as of late I have started to miss cheap shit boxes from my younger years. Like these that really have a lot of character and where you just do basic mods and repairs yet drive them like you absolutely have stole them. Keep it up gents, your showing really how
Wasn’t just me that thought the camera work was sub par judging by the comments. This must’ve been failed cameras. There’s no way the camera work was planned like this. Other people have said there’s some scripting. I’m not sure on that but some of it did feel a bit forced. You’ve got a fantastic channel, hope it carries on that way. Still enjoyed it anyway. Kinda wanted the VXR to win!
come on lads, this was shot poorly, the handbrake test was terrible, as a viewer I had no clue what was actually happening because all we saw was Rorys reactions.
I was really hoping for a lot more from the end of this series, as hot hatchs are where most enthusiasts begin. Ending it in a flat field felt like we can't be arsed.
okay, this feels like a cheap fake, because you dont really know how to fake a video like this. this was very different from the usual autoalex video vibes, youre just going full top-gear, please stop.
Love the videos but this one just seemed too scripted, it was just trying too much to be like top gear aswell and the camera work wasn’t the best but love the work keep it up fellas and look forward to seeing you at ShedFest 3.0
I would say, the old Car Throttle videos did feel a whole lot better in terms of planning and filming. There was fun challenges, structure and great producing. For example the 500£ daily driver challenge. A bit like comparing Top Gear with The Grand Tour. Top Gear felt well planned, funny but structured while The Grand Tour feels a bit slow and half-planned to me personally.
I feel like you guys didn't have enough camera people. I can't imagine how expensive it would be especially if you're on a budget, but I felt like we missed most of the action of all the great and funny things that happened in this vid. Not trying to be mean, Love you guys, I will always watch the vids haha
This episode felt a little weird, rushed, even staged (for the 1st time)... - No camera angle for the handbrake turns - Incorrect outcome for the handbrake turns to build suspense, I guess? - That crash didn't seem possible (and yet you were filming but chose not to show it all) - Rory's in car comms were forced (just be in the zone, don't shout and scream) - I didn't mind the camera work overall, but the editing was rough You boys are natural talents, theres no need to rush things
Had to turn it off halfway through. Camera work, editing and the fake crash left a sour taste in my mouth. I liked this channel as well, please don’t go down this route.
Not disappointed by the community in the comments on this one, bit disappointing lads. Hopefully the next one is a bit more well put together because this felt chaotic and majority of it was babble and reaction shots. No hate just constructive critisism.
Maybe now is just the right time for Taylor, Luke & Chris to launch a Taylor Made Cars channel. This scripted nonsense and bad acting/fake/over exaggerated "reactions" have worn a bit thin now. This is RUclips, not Amazon/Netflix!
The camera work wasn’t up to the standard we expect from the channel. But one of the best little series you have done in a while, nice to see some video’s without a mini or a BMW! And not Including the usually E73 i M sports grand touring Alpina coupe cobblers.
As an owner of a 208gti I can safely say that it deserves more than a 4/10!! Not bland at all!! Very nippy and fun to drive day to day. 0-60 in 6.5secs. 200bhp. What's not to like!!
Might be unpopular for saying this but I really think Rory should go back to editing, I don’t think being a presenter suits him, just doesn’t come naturally and it’s very obvious. Agree with the rest about the camerawork which was poor. Also Alex accidentally starting in reverse and crashing into the tree was pathetic.
I've been hosteling in Scandinavia Performed a couple of Scandy flicks myself. 😂😂😂 My Dad also works at Nintendo though, so take that as you will... 😂😂😂😂
So we had lots of videos on the buying and build up to this end? Hot hatches in the mud? How bizarre. I feel like you've done these cars an injustice with this. I'm glad the Clio won, because it's obviously the best car, but perhaps a track would have been a better use of our time?
Back in the day Performance Car magazine had two rules for the jurnos. 1 keep control of the car at all times. 2 keep control of your face at all times. One for Rory there 😀
What's going on lad's. This was poor! Scripted crashes and really bad camera work. Please go back to your high-quality videos 👏 I look forward to them, but they have been consistently decreasing in quality!! Even the podcasts are going downhill 😢
No that’s any group of mates in this situation…. It’s just happened to be that Jeremy, James and Richard were mates. The same as Alex, Taylor and Rory are.
@@EazyDuz18 Except groups of friends were doing that for god knows how many years before Top Gear did it, and have for the 20 years since. The Top Gear three didn’t invent stitching a mate up.
This is just a blatant copy of the old Top Gear challenge style videos, moving the cones, in reverse by accident, fake crash, silly camera cuts. I love the channel and you guys but please please keep it original, this was just trying too hard.
Please stop trying to be Top Gear. It's just cringy. Love you guys but it's just not working. And don't be an A-hole to Taylor. 0 points for the handbrake? He did better than Alex and Rory
Was there a new editor for this one? Or were there missing cameras or lost footage (it's like one of them is shooting in manual focus too). It's really strange, Alex's 40mph run is literally 2 seconds of the start and then a flash of a speedo (miles away from the tree) and then a crash. The rest of the video is just so strangely cut.
Also on the final challenge - no rundown of the course or expanation, more footage of the two guys watching the car (and commentating) than the actual footage itself. So strange lads and I'm normally such a huge fan of the channel but things have been off recently!
well, maybe the challenge was great, but actually never saw the cars ... today's filming was poor af TBH I enjoyed watching Ethan and Jack walking for 24h more
Don't use Car Vertical. They don't do their checks properly. Mine came back as the wrong make, model and engine, despite having the original documents from the manufacture from new. Plus, their stolen car checks were only done in three countries. All info available can be found for free.
I've watched pretty much every video as far back as the CT days, but this is one I couldn't watch to the end. The idea was good, production good, TopGear-esq, even with the set-up crash in the hedge,, but so much screaming and shouting, it's ear piercing 😩 Also, why wasn't the camera man actually filming the handbrake turns? 🤷🏻
@@AutoalexCarsWhy didn't we get a good view of the crash then? Was the footage lost? What happened? If that genuinely wasn't a scripted crash, the way it was edited made it look scripted.
So I need to give some props, respect, whatever you want to call it to Mr. Taylor Hetherington. Not only is he a great mechanic, great presenter and he loves his mum... it also turns out he's something of a helmsman! Fantastic work sir, you are the clear winner of all of the challenges, no matter what Rory and Alex says.
I have owned a few hot hatches in my time, I have never once raced them around a muddy field. Wouldn't it have been a much better test if you had taken them around the small race track you used to use?
I’m a huge fan of this channel. 100% the best car channel out there and I will watch every single video and podcast start to finish. This video was great. It’s funny but it was a bit wierd not seeing actual footage of driving and the challenges. I’ve said it before, Autoalex usually has fantastic editing and little Easter eggs however this video wasn’t quite there. Still a lot of fun but wierd watching Taylor and Rory looking into a car doing a challenge and not actually seeing said car. Still great effort and top content as ever!
@@toastrytoasterthe blokes just had a kid he’ll be getting about 20 minutes of sleep a week it was solid before it’s just more sporadic for a bit he’s obviously not going to be doing 1000 mile shitbox trips with a what one and a bit month old baby at home is he
I really hope this isn't the start of the decline of this channel. It all seems too formulaic and repeated over and over again, regardless of the vehicles you get (which we see briefly and never again.) There's no way the Peugeot was £1500, Taylor was over budget and the camera work was terrible. I hate to be negative, but the quality has taken a nosedive and it seems to be more about churning out more videos to get that sponsorship money through the door.
Of the many sections that weren't entirely believable, the £1500 Peugeot kind of was... it was pretty knackered, and "newer" cars at silly low prices because they're accident damaged/knackered/engine lights on are pretty common.
Another comment for you which I hope is constructive and not just another negative and as you guys are great. Agreed with many comments here the camera/edit was a little all over the place, hard to pin it down. On your tasks it was genuinely hard to unpick what was going on so we as an audience we aren't following the plot points your laying out and end up not invested in the competition. I'd say the race was the best section but you needed a fixed drone shot or higher angle shot of each lap so you could really see the route and compare laps, also probably worth explaining the route and showing a diagram before the race. Second point, and I think more importantly, whilst I get that you can't fall in love with every car in the world I think more needs to be done to build the relationship with each of your cars, whether that means a slower series or splitting to each of you doing your process. There's been quite a few moments where a car or some modifications come out of nowhere and the process of you getting it or doing that is half of what gets the audience invested in the builds and the story and therefore actually caring who wins the competition. Almost like Donuts high car low car where we see real work being done and a story behind the car other than it is a "shit hatchback that I bought" and now we're racing. Odd suggestions but take a look at the "scrapyward wars" series setup by linus tech tips (this is PC building but a great format you guys could adapt I'm sure). I think all three of you are now solid presenters on the channel so you should each be managing your story and coming together for a joint episode at the end as the build up to this episode has also been a little underwhelming. You guys will figure it out but just wanted to give some thoughts that might be beneficial..
Im pretty new to the channel, and I only know Alex a bit from his previous channel. But Ive been binging the last couple of days and I just wanna say bringing Rory in front of the camera, and having Taylor in more videos was a great decision. The three of you together are great. I can, and do, watch idiots buy and play with shitboxes all day.
Compare this to the last hot hatch challenge where Freddie and Ben Collins were involved. This is sadly, terrible. Sorry but the camera work is dire, the interactions seem like you are desperately trying to be the top gear trio and the whole thing just falls very flat. I turned it off before the end as it was just not worth my time. I've been watching since the Car Throttle days but recently there seems to be a desire to be Top Gear that is tainting all your stuff and this is kind of the nadir. You have 2 other channels which are doing what we all wanted you guys to be, natural and just enjoying what they are doing but keeping production value high despite low budgets. This just isn't it. The level of obvious scripting here kills it.
"How many tickets are there? This is a time-based competition rather than maximum ticket based." - Just to make people aware, no limit draw, meaning no implied odds (worst than gambling sites).
its the first video since auto alex and very old car throttle where i have not been excited to sit down and watch. i know the personal lives have haulted the big projects but since the majour investment this year its just getting tame. i hope this is a blip but less scripting, more cheap cars and focus on the projects you have not keep weekly adding new cars with no focus on returning.
Great idea and enthusiasm but as with a lot of comments camera / editing not up to usual standard. Be good to see more action not reaction. Everyone is allowed an off day, refocus and move on 💪🏻
Get 20% off Car Vertical using code Autoalex!
GB: www.carvertical.com/gb/landing/v3?a=AutoAlex&b=38b26e3a&voucher=autoalex
US: www.carvertical.com/landing/v3?a=AutoAlex&b=2c9b600c&voucher=autoalex
Be careful driving with these walkie-talkies, it's just as illegal as using your phone
Oh deer 4:42 another car vertical advert 😂🦌
Do an raly build wite the peugeot 208 i like that car
@@adamcox374it’s actually not against the law to use two way radio equipment while driving as long as it’s not being used in a way that is proven to be a distraction that could lead to careless or dangerous driving.
That’s why use Amateur and CB radio equipment is allowed while driving.
20% off what? How much is it normally? No one ever mentions this.
Taylor definitely won the handbrake test. Rory’s and Alex’s was bloody awful
#justicefortaylor
but that doesn't add suspense to the ending..
Would have been nice if they recorded them!
Not he didn't... he touched the cone... maybe if the guys didn't move the cones he would aced the second try, but we'll never know
@@p.informatico1320 they all touched the cones 😆
I liked the challenge, but...how did you manage to film everything except the cars themselves? 😅
@Ferrari_boi Because it was scripted and he drove into the tree on purpose and if you saw the full outside shot it would've been obvious.
@@ratgreen 100%
So they clear through the auction house without too much recognition
🚗 👀 🤫🤭
@@ratgreen They saw it done on Top Gear (the real stuff, with Clarkson, Hammond and May) and it's heavily.. "inspired" (without caravans and SUV) from the Last episode which the golden trio were in called SUV Caravan Challenge.
I 😂😂
Could do with bringing in Jack and Eaton from all the gear to sort out the camera work. For 2 guys on their own making full videos their footage is always amazing, could really have done with those guys on this shoot
Are you Jamaican?
Always liked an Ethan Twin Splitter
Ethan and Jack where videographers before presenters so it makes sense
Eaton
@@44shibby jamaican me crazy
Why are there no wide angle shots of the handbrake turns?
Or a drone shot above
Or an actual camera on the dials in the 0-40
@@Traxxmaciek This isn't TopGear mate, calm down.
@@Budisgud69
They have drone shots in other parts of the video.
They also have GoPros. Instead of putting multiple ones on the outside, they could have just used one to film the speedometer.
We don't need Top Gear/Grand Tour levels of production, we just want them to do a bit better.
@@GermanCptSloware you paying for these vids? yh didn’t think so, be grateful you’ve got some content to watch, sad git
@@MrDedatYToh bore off you melt, the content wasn’t worth watching because of the shit footage they had and what felt like cringy scripting of top gear like moments.
Did one of your cameras fail or your editor have funny turn because you didn't actually film any challenge
Top cat was a banger show
@@DavidWasTakni agree
Also felt so scripted to be like a top gear moment especially when Rory shouted in Alex’s face after his handbrake turn and moving the cone on Taylor 🤦🏻♂️
@@eirebhoy132 yea that was really annoying and Rory acting like James on the way round whilst Alex and Taylor do the Clarkson and Hammond thing on the sidelines. Like ffs we all loved top gear of course and we appreciate similarities sometimes but that doesn’t mean we want the wish version on every video
@@KeyBrosUK Indeed - There's no way Rory could REALLY have thought he was going quickly in the 3rd challengem so that felt REALLY fake IMHO.
Not often I say this, but the camerawork was pants on this video! Why wasn’t the drone used on the first two challenges? All reaction shots, no action shots.
illegal to fly a drone in that area
@@EazyDuz18 It's actually just outside the no fly zone
Made sure the camera work was good in the CV ad though didn’t they
Jesus moan about anything just shut up being negative
@@EazyDuz18except there’s lots of Drone shots of the course?
Guys you've built a cracking channel without all the obvious scripted crap up until now. Please don't go down that rabbit hole just to force content and views. The "crash" into the tree just screams faked laziness. We know you are better than this!
This channel is on the rocks a bit at the moment for some reason.
Been scripted since beginning
And Alex being in reverse "by mistake" for the handbrake bit...
The whole video was just a massive copy of all the stuff Top Gear did.
Couldn't agree more. People want authenticity, not fake crap. It's so unnecessary when they have good chemistry and are all funny guys.
hopping down to check the comments and i’m not disappointed by the community.
shot choices all over the shop.
it also feels like you’re moving away from “lads having fun with motahs” to being a littttleeeee bit too try hard. felt forced in a lot of spots chaps.
Glad it wasn’t just me..
Agreed. The another channel trying to be top gear choice is starting to become quite obvious. I've never laughed as hard as when Alex & Taylor first starting mucking about with cars in the yard. Now it's all feeling quite forced
You fuckers moaning about free content, literally free entertainment do my fucking head in. Don't like it, make something better.
Alex - "it looked really good didn't it"
Me - "I don't know there was no footage of the car"
Why the cameraman doesn't film the cars doing the challenge????
Yeah definitely need some improvement in that department. Video was really badly shot
I have the suspicion it's because they have gone down the fake it route and don't wanna show the full footage. Alex's "crash" reeks of a set up.
@@SelfMadeManiacthat’s the one mate he’s a right little sausage 😂
@@Traxxmaciek I would argue it’s possibly budget. You can hire a cameraman for 25k a year, but they’ll be straight out of uni with little experience of how to plan their filming schedule, not just physically shoot it. Could be wrong of course but this is how it feels.
I was about to say the SAME
I’ve mentioned this before but hopefully persistence pays off, please hire a producer. You need someone who isn’t presenting or filming to be planning these videos more thoroughly; someone who is there with a shot list, a rough plan and an idea of what’s coming up next. There are so many missed opportunities in this, including drone shots of some of the challenges, better timed exterior shots of the handbrake turns, voiceovers that could have replaced minutes of waffle, a physical scoreboard, etc. In fact, this whole off road segment could have been exactly that, a 10 minute segment in a 30 minute video. The other segments could be their enjoyment on a b-road in Wales, how much shit you can cram in them, or how many underaged girls the corsa can attract in a maccies car park (don’t do that). I don’t think any of us would mind waiting a little longer for something that had some more variety, a stricter editing process and a little more production value.
Remember that he left car throttle and started this channel with the purpose of being able to own and do whatever he wants without having a producer and a bunch of suits breathing down his neck.
But with that being said, the editing and camera work in general was off on this one.
@@AlmightyDilan That isn't the job of a producer though-they're simply there to make sure things go according to plan . Alex can still come up with all the ideas and have total control, of course, but trying to present and direct at the same time is a difficult task.
@@AlmightyDilan producers weren’t the problem there, all they do is make sure everything is polished and I don’t mean fake or set up. Basically they help him implement his ideas.
@@KeyBrosUK you guys are absolutely right, production value is essential to growth and i wouldnt mind seeing it, but im just not sure thats the direction hes going for
I could be wrong tho
@@KeyBrosUK Exactly that
can you show what is happening?
Alex crash looked fake because of it.
It was fake mate.
You mean like the Ferrari crash was staged as well? 👀
Almost all accidents in Top Gear were also fake/scripted/ staged! Only the real accidents were Hammonds....:-) And Captain Slow falling of a horse.
@@DueVolvi Thats the reason I stopped watching TV and started looking on YT for people who show (at least mostly) their real personality + stuff was real and not written.
@PointlessDrummer SAME!!! don't bring that lame tv crap over to youtube, PLEASE!!!!
Editing is all over the place
You volunteering? Thought not. 😂😂😂😂
@@curbyourshi1056you volunteering?
Hes also not complaining @ize100
@@Twistandgouk you complaining?
@@Twistandgouk Ah yes the typical brain dead comment of "If you criticize you have to go there and do better".
I'm sure you never criticized politicians, footballers, cooks, race drivers etc etc. Dumb cunt
I feel like you guys forgot to actually record the cars instead of just jump cutting between angles of yourself lol. For reference go watch a gears and gasoline video
They just need to watch jack and Ethan cause the 2 of them manage to capture everything even without cameramen
Nothing beats gears and gasoline
@@YusufJoeKarolia werent Jack and Ethan a camera man and an editor originally at CT though? Maybe I'm misremembering!
No matter though, I agree, All the Gear vids are great!
They think there clarksons crew and want all the attention on them it's been slowly getting worse
Or the latest Cleetus cheap truck challenge
so to decide what's the best car you drove them around a mud pit for 40 seconds while filming your faces?
Nah, great concept(not a new one..), extremely poor execution
between the 3 of you bouncing ideas, that's the best you could come up with,do handbrake turns in cars without a functioning handbrake, and doing a nascar lap around a square soggy field in hot hatches??
When you order Top Gear from Temu.
i liked the buying and dyno parts of this series.
They really think they are them 😂
Why are you watching then? 😂😂
Have you watched early top gear?
@@rg6982 You think the comment section is only for you to go on your knees and giving that hawk tuah to RUclipsrs? No. It's to criticize them as well... dipstick.
It's more like tepoo
Judging by the comments you’ve liked, I’d say it’s safe to assume you purposely went for the “top gear vibe” which is fair enough.
You need to listen to your community and take on the feedback though.
Being sat there liking all the comments glazing the video makes it look more like you’re sticking your head in the dirt than anything.
I’m sure you’re aware of Cleetus’ channel. They did a few “Challenge” video series and none of those videos came across as cheap and knockoff-y as this. I get the budgets are very different, but there is more you could’ve done here.
RUclips is RUclips and people want to see authentic and genuine content. This is everything but.
Stop with the fakery before it’s too late. And if you’re gonna do a Top Gear “inspired” video, be honest about your intentions. It’s one thing to pay homage to something so beloved (and consequently ruined) and it’s another thing to attempt to copy it. If you really were going for a top gear inspired video, it was truly, horrendously executed.
I’m really not wanting this to come across like I’m hating. I’ve been watching since the early Car Throttle days, I just don’t want this channel to be in the “Top 10 hardest automotive RUclipsr falloff’s of all time”
Please listen to the constructive feedback you get.
This was far more than just a Top Gear vibe, it felt like just an imitation.
Doing taylor dirty on the handbrake cos you knew he'd win 😢 nailed the second attempt
"YOU EVIL MAN, that's brilliant"
@@georgeg9959 the man child can’t ever lose🤣
The camera work was dreadful, on the handbrake turns we got an inside shot it you driving in then an outside shot of a parked car. And Alex’s crash was also missed looked too staged.
Alex, listen to your viewers. Cut the Billy bullshit btec acting, staged stunts and budget challenges where 2 out of 3 go over budget. We all subscribe to support you and our mutual passion for cars. Don't forget your roots.
17:10 a bit too scripted
Have you not noticed that this channel echos Top Gear quite a lot? And of course, a lot of other channels.
@@archechme 100%, being inspired is one thing but I think TGT ending has just made it even worse lol. And it's unfortunately a very poor imitation
The gang produce brilliant content but this felt a little rushed, more cameramen/women would help. Luke being the independent adjudicator would have added something…
No doubt a lot of work went into doing this. It just seems like not a lot of brains or consideration did. First of all, why are you on mud in hot hatches? Why do we not get full exterior shots of the challenges being performed? The entire video flow is boring, the cuts are the same for the entire duration and the laugh seems really forced. You can do better than this.
You would have had more genuine and funny content, if you had planned this challenge better. It could have been an autocross challenge, reverse J turns, B road testing, blasting offensive music and seeing which car gets the most attention, rev limit sound-off, wheelspin attempts, getting young girls opinions, dressing up as hot hatch teenagers and so on.. Hope to see you returning to better form soon! All the best
@SevCars lots of work? Someone's yard and a few tyres and a random dinner lady as a camera man .... talk about budget video with fake everything
Feels sooo staged like the "worst" grand tour episode...
its getting harder to watch as the autoalex era continues, honestly if it wasnt for taylor, this channel would be dead.
@@John.Winchester yeah Rory comes over as an overdramtic 2 year old that always sounds like his crying ... and the way he comes up with b.s so quick is pretty alarming ... wouldn't trust him as far as I could throw him
Somehow Jack and Ethan on bicycles has become more entertaining than this nonsense.
Sorry to say this felt well under par guys, poor camerawork, far too scripted, over excitement, fake laughter, very cheesy and 1st ever time I've turned off early. I appreciate change/evolving is good, but this seemed completely forced and unnatural. Generally love what you do and I'll be back for the next video 👍
I feel like this video is an example of where they crossed the line of invoking the 'spirit' of old Top Gear and actually trying to replicate it.
The latter is doomed to fail. Top Gear couldn't even replicate Top Gear anymore.
Apologies, I really don't like "hating" but I think you need to invest in more/better camera men and better editing. How you don't actually show the shot of the cars doing the handbrake turns or Alex accidentally reversing to name a few examples just seems so amateur.
Weird huh?! Terrible camera work.
Agreed, although what they need is a producer/director IMO. Someone who isn’t presenting or filming and can focus on the upcoming shots, general plan, the edit, etc. There’s so much potential to be had but this one thing is holding them back hugely I think
But this is RUclips, things happen rather than pretend to happen? You need to demand an immediate refund of the feck all this cost you and get back to the Grand Tour
Get in the bin mate
@@stuartkennedy2082 That’s a rather needlessly aggressive way to respond. People are simply giving feedback, which is what these comments are for. I agree, things need to happen and not pretend to happen, but the production value needs to improve.
Surly the challenges should have been done in a supermarket car park for the true hot hatch experience
Get some Macdonald's trays for the handbrake turn challenge 😂
Brilliant idea
@@jordanhoughton2897 Yes! Maccas trays are classic
Why on earth have they done it in a field🤣🤣
@@thecodex0994 That's just oldschool MCM
You should use the drone more often, especially for this types of test. The 0-40 and brake whould have been great to see in that view
I agree, it was a really entertaining video, we got all the reactions but not enough of action shots.
Lots of shots of their faces but not the driving. Odd filming or editing choice.
Also came here to say this! Unusually piss-poor job from this channel
wouldnt be able to do a drone shot of the puegeot as it was clearly scripted, hope these lot down go down the route of making up stuff for entertainment its just lazy
@@wntr2980 The "accidental" crash was a bit naff to say the least.
My dogs ears pricked up when he heard Taylor laughing at the start 0:04 seconds 😂😂😂🐕🐕🐕
It's rare you get to see a car offered as a competition prize and then watch someone absolutely rag it off-road before you win it.
U won’t win it do ur homework into llf games total shambles
The older I have gotten, the more opportunity I have had to afford nicer vehicles. However, as of late I have started to miss cheap shit boxes from my younger years. Like these that really have a lot of character and where you just do basic mods and repairs yet drive them like you absolutely have stole them. Keep it up gents, your showing really how
Unpopular opinion, but Rory on camera just doesn't do it for me. Probably would do better behind the camera as this was terrible
From the comments here, I don't think your opinion is especially unpopular.
You’re spot on, the guy is unwatchable. He’s the equivalent of that Wombat on the Meerkat adverts.
Wasn’t just me that thought the camera work was sub par judging by the comments. This must’ve been failed cameras. There’s no way the camera work was planned like this.
Other people have said there’s some scripting. I’m not sure on that but some of it did feel a bit forced. You’ve got a fantastic channel, hope it carries on that way.
Still enjoyed it anyway. Kinda wanted the VXR to win!
come on lads, this was shot poorly, the handbrake test was terrible, as a viewer I had no clue what was actually happening because all we saw was Rorys reactions.
Taylor’s laugh sets me off everytime 😂😂😂😂
I was really hoping for a lot more from the end of this series, as hot hatchs are where most enthusiasts begin. Ending it in a flat field felt like we can't be arsed.
okay, this feels like a cheap fake, because you dont really know how to fake a video like this. this was very different from the usual autoalex video vibes, youre just going full top-gear, please stop.
Love the videos but this one just seemed too scripted, it was just trying too much to be like top gear aswell and the camera work wasn’t the best but love the work keep it up fellas and look forward to seeing you at ShedFest 3.0
I would say, the old Car Throttle videos did feel a whole lot better in terms of planning and filming. There was fun challenges, structure and great producing. For example the 500£ daily driver challenge. A bit like comparing Top Gear with The Grand Tour. Top Gear felt well planned, funny but structured while The Grand Tour feels a bit slow and half-planned to me personally.
I feel like you guys didn't have enough camera people. I can't imagine how expensive it would be especially if you're on a budget, but I felt like we missed most of the action of all the great and funny things that happened in this vid. Not trying to be mean, Love you guys, I will always watch the vids haha
Static cameras are always a good option. Couple of gopros on tripods would do the job for the handbrake turn test for example
This episode felt a little weird, rushed, even staged (for the 1st time)...
- No camera angle for the handbrake turns
- Incorrect outcome for the handbrake turns to build suspense, I guess?
- That crash didn't seem possible (and yet you were filming but chose not to show it all)
- Rory's in car comms were forced (just be in the zone, don't shout and scream)
- I didn't mind the camera work overall, but the editing was rough
You boys are natural talents, theres no need to rush things
Had to turn it off halfway through. Camera work, editing and the fake crash left a sour taste in my mouth. I liked this channel as well, please don’t go down this route.
We need a muscle car challenge 🙃
Yes!! Taylors mentioned Monaros and Maloos in the podcast a few times, totally think he needs to try one, I can confirm the Monaro is a total blast
Hell yes!
Muscle cars are rare in britain, and when they are here, they aren't cheap, even for rust buckets.
In America
And no more BMW’s, ever.
15:22 Taylor summed up this video in Three Words.
I came down here to make the exact same comment
Not disappointed by the community in the comments on this one, bit disappointing lads. Hopefully the next one is a bit more well put together because this felt chaotic and majority of it was babble and reaction shots. No hate just constructive critisism.
Maybe now is just the right time for Taylor, Luke & Chris to launch a Taylor Made Cars channel. This scripted nonsense and bad acting/fake/over exaggerated "reactions" have worn a bit thin now. This is RUclips, not Amazon/Netflix!
The camera work wasn’t up to the standard we expect from the channel. But one of the best little series you have done in a while, nice to see some video’s without a mini or a BMW! And not Including the usually E73 i M sports grand touring Alpina coupe cobblers.
As an owner of a 208gti I can safely say that it deserves more than a 4/10!! Not bland at all!! Very nippy and fun to drive day to day. 0-60 in 6.5secs. 200bhp. What's not to like!!
Might be unpopular for saying this but I really think Rory should go back to editing, I don’t think being a presenter suits him, just doesn’t come naturally and it’s very obvious. Agree with the rest about the camerawork which was poor. Also Alex accidentally starting in reverse and crashing into the tree was pathetic.
Something makes me think that Rory doesn't know what a Scandy flick is.
I've been hosteling in Scandinavia Performed a couple of Scandy flicks myself. 😂😂😂 My Dad also works at Nintendo though, so take that as you will... 😂😂😂😂
So we had lots of videos on the buying and build up to this end? Hot hatches in the mud? How bizarre. I feel like you've done these cars an injustice with this. I'm glad the Clio won, because it's obviously the best car, but perhaps a track would have been a better use of our time?
Back in the day Performance Car magazine had two rules for the jurnos. 1 keep control of the car at all times. 2 keep control of your face at all times. One for Rory there 😀
What's going on lad's. This was poor! Scripted crashes and really bad camera work.
Please go back to your high-quality videos 👏
I look forward to them, but they have been consistently decreasing in quality!!
Even the podcasts are going downhill 😢
yes, definitely… If there's a contest between cars and the owner… We should all secretly vote against Alex
It's only the right thing to do
Moving the cone is a bit too TopGear tbh
No that’s any group of mates in this situation…. It’s just happened to be that Jeremy, James and Richard were mates. The same as Alex, Taylor and Rory are.
@@AshleyWilliams12345 Except that's literally what they did in a TopGear episode...
@@EazyDuz18 Except groups of friends were doing that for god knows how many years before Top Gear did it, and have for the 20 years since. The Top Gear three didn’t invent stitching a mate up.
@@markcraggs6471 Not on a car themed tv show they havn't
@EazyDuz18 it was all top gear but a wayyyyyyy wayyyy crapper version ... didn't sign up to this shite
Personally my choice would be the Clio, my first car was a Clio, so I got a soft spot for them. Only Alex could get a damp and soggy Peugeot 😂
This is just a blatant copy of the old Top Gear challenge style videos, moving the cones, in reverse by accident, fake crash, silly camera cuts. I love the channel and you guys but please please keep it original, this was just trying too hard.
Yup ... pretty tragic tbh
Please stop trying to be Top Gear. It's just cringy. Love you guys but it's just not working. And don't be an A-hole to Taylor. 0 points for the handbrake? He did better than Alex and Rory
Carlos.....you need to get a life
@@justanomadicguy Jog on, troll. And take your 1 subscriber with you 🤣
Was there a new editor for this one? Or were there missing cameras or lost footage (it's like one of them is shooting in manual focus too). It's really strange, Alex's 40mph run is literally 2 seconds of the start and then a flash of a speedo (miles away from the tree) and then a crash. The rest of the video is just so strangely cut.
Also on the final challenge - no rundown of the course or expanation, more footage of the two guys watching the car (and commentating) than the actual footage itself. So strange lads and I'm normally such a huge fan of the channel but things have been off recently!
Taylor won the handbrake, and lost the 0-40. That 0-40 jumped like wheel spin on Taylor's go, Rory was correct... There was no way to get to 40.
well, maybe the challenge was great, but actually never saw the cars ... today's filming was poor af
TBH I enjoyed watching Ethan and Jack walking for 24h more
Don't use Car Vertical. They don't do their checks properly. Mine came back as the wrong make, model and engine, despite having the original documents from the manufacture from new. Plus, their stolen car checks were only done in three countries. All info available can be found for free.
I've watched pretty much every video as far back as the CT days, but this is one I couldn't watch to the end. The idea was good, production good, TopGear-esq, even with the set-up crash in the hedge,, but so much screaming and shouting, it's ear piercing 😩 Also, why wasn't the camera man actually filming the handbrake turns? 🤷🏻
so funny story...I had no intention to end up in the trees!
@@AutoalexCarsWhy didn't we get a good view of the crash then? Was the footage lost? What happened? If that genuinely wasn't a scripted crash, the way it was edited made it look scripted.
@@AutoalexCars Come on man lol
So I need to give some props, respect, whatever you want to call it to Mr. Taylor Hetherington. Not only is he a great mechanic, great presenter and he loves his mum... it also turns out he's something of a helmsman! Fantastic work sir, you are the clear winner of all of the challenges, no matter what Rory and Alex says.
Was hoping for a drag race between these cars
I have owned a few hot hatches in my time, I have never once raced them around a muddy field. Wouldn't it have been a much better test if you had taken them around the small race track you used to use?
So we're swaping cars.... Have a word with your editor & enable that spell check :P
I’m a huge fan of this channel. 100% the best car channel out there and I will watch every single video and podcast start to finish. This video was great. It’s funny but it was a bit wierd not seeing actual footage of driving and the challenges. I’ve said it before, Autoalex usually has fantastic editing and little Easter eggs however this video wasn’t quite there. Still a lot of fun but wierd watching Taylor and Rory looking into a car doing a challenge and not actually seeing said car.
Still great effort and top content as ever!
@@AutoGASHcontentnot true. They are all great. Just this one video wasn’t the most enjoyable
@@toastrytoasterthe blokes just had a kid he’ll be getting about 20 minutes of sleep a week it was solid before it’s just more sporadic for a bit he’s obviously not going to be doing 1000 mile shitbox trips with a what one and a bit month old baby at home is he
@@AutoGASHcontent I don’t mind it so I’ll keep watching fellar have a gooden
I really hope this isn't the start of the decline of this channel. It all seems too formulaic and repeated over and over again, regardless of the vehicles you get (which we see briefly and never again.) There's no way the Peugeot was £1500, Taylor was over budget and the camera work was terrible. I hate to be negative, but the quality has taken a nosedive and it seems to be more about churning out more videos to get that sponsorship money through the door.
Of the many sections that weren't entirely believable, the £1500 Peugeot kind of was... it was pretty knackered, and "newer" cars at silly low prices because they're accident damaged/knackered/engine lights on are pretty common.
Another comment for you which I hope is constructive and not just another negative and as you guys are great.
Agreed with many comments here the camera/edit was a little all over the place, hard to pin it down. On your tasks it was genuinely hard to unpick what was going on so we as an audience we aren't following the plot points your laying out and end up not invested in the competition. I'd say the race was the best section but you needed a fixed drone shot or higher angle shot of each lap so you could really see the route and compare laps, also probably worth explaining the route and showing a diagram before the race.
Second point, and I think more importantly, whilst I get that you can't fall in love with every car in the world I think more needs to be done to build the relationship with each of your cars, whether that means a slower series or splitting to each of you doing your process. There's been quite a few moments where a car or some modifications come out of nowhere and the process of you getting it or doing that is half of what gets the audience invested in the builds and the story and therefore actually caring who wins the competition. Almost like Donuts high car low car where we see real work being done and a story behind the car other than it is a "shit hatchback that I bought" and now we're racing. Odd suggestions but take a look at the "scrapyward wars" series setup by linus tech tips (this is PC building but a great format you guys could adapt I'm sure). I think all three of you are now solid presenters on the channel so you should each be managing your story and coming together for a joint episode at the end as the build up to this episode has also been a little underwhelming. You guys will figure it out but just wanted to give some thoughts that might be beneficial..
Please keep Rory out of the videos. We are all pertrol heads but Rory has nithing to do with driving.
Had to turn it off this episode was so bad. Every cliche.
was the editor on drugs? Feel like i am having a stroke watching this
14:20 No no no! Taylor nailed that one!
Also, who would have thought the Renault is the least crap of those 😂
They nerfed the vauxhall 🤷🏻♂️
This video just shows.. you lot need to get rory a hell of alot more track time. Dude looks scared of anything over 30% throttle
@@shortmonk95 probably fake to imitate top gear James may (yet again)
Can't believe Rory is on this channel but not Jack/Ethan. He just isn't remotely funny or engaging.
Naaa, Talyor definitely won that first challenge, 100%
Not sure you can call that Peugeot bland compared to a Clio and a Corsa. It’s the most interesting one in my opinion…
It also has the best interior.
Not only should Rory not be in front of the camera, but there were more shots of him than the actual cars!
Agreed
Rory is class, give over.
Idk why but he is very unlikable
@@Shot_Kawla totally
@@Shot_Kawlayeah he needs to go back to being off camera
I haven't laughed so hard since OG Top Gear. Love your energy! Keep it up.
Is this gcse drama grand tour
Horrifically accurate
Im pretty new to the channel, and I only know Alex a bit from his previous channel. But Ive been binging the last couple of days and I just wanna say bringing Rory in front of the camera, and having Taylor in more videos was a great decision. The three of you together are great.
I can, and do, watch idiots buy and play with shitboxes all day.
Taylor is robbed during the handbrake challenge.
1:44 neons are now neOFF's
Whens the classic car challenge update?
Hearing Taylor and Rory cackling away is pure serotonin
Please I BEG YOU put Rory back behind the camera hes awful as a presenter
Nooooo! Just get a good cameraman
Agreed, he’s got all the charisma of wallpaper paste
Taylor is hilarious, definitely makes the channel worth watching. Xx
Im sure Rory is a nice guy, but goddamn does him in front of the camera not work.
Compare this to the last hot hatch challenge where Freddie and Ben Collins were involved. This is sadly, terrible. Sorry but the camera work is dire, the interactions seem like you are desperately trying to be the top gear trio and the whole thing just falls very flat. I turned it off before the end as it was just not worth my time. I've been watching since the Car Throttle days but recently there seems to be a desire to be Top Gear that is tainting all your stuff and this is kind of the nadir.
You have 2 other channels which are doing what we all wanted you guys to be, natural and just enjoying what they are doing but keeping production value high despite low budgets. This just isn't it. The level of obvious scripting here kills it.
"How many tickets are there?
This is a time-based competition rather than maximum ticket based." - Just to make people aware, no limit draw, meaning no implied odds (worst than gambling sites).
Have u heard the horror story’s behind llf games also alarming
Stop with the car vertical advertisement
its the first video since auto alex and very old car throttle where i have not been excited to sit down and watch. i know the personal lives have haulted the big projects but since the majour investment this year its just getting tame. i hope this is a blip but less scripting, more cheap cars and focus on the projects you have not keep weekly adding new cars with no focus on returning.
I saw this episode of Top Gear. It was James May in a Suzuki Vitara that couldn’t stop.
Wrong. It was Hammond.
@@H.K_R Said with all the authority of a keyboard warrior. 🤣🤣
These chaps and Car Trek really have carried the torch of TopGear/Grand Tour. Thank you and keep it up!
22:55 Danger to manifold 😂😂😂, careful or random floor bolts will pop and you will drop your floor pan
Great idea and enthusiasm but as with a lot of comments camera / editing not up to usual standard. Be good to see more action not reaction.
Everyone is allowed an off day, refocus and move on 💪🏻
Feel so sorry for Rory 😢 your girlfriend running off with your dad is just heartbreaking 💔
What
Gotta listen to the podcast it’s “what he doesn’t say”
Where did you hear this? Lol
Huh? Is that what happened?
Another one for the list of things that never happened
15:23 The Top gear reference was not lost on me :D