Чому не вийшло? - Why Didn't it Work? (Ukrainian Anarchist Song)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 фев 2025
- A Ukrainian anarchist song asking the question of why the Black Army was unsuccessful during the Russian Civil War.
Performer: Anatoly Serdyuk (Сердюк Анатолій)
Year Recorded: 1994
Composer: Anatoly Serdyuk (Сердюк Анатолій)
Lyricist: Hryhorii Liutyi (Григорій Лютий)
Image: Commanders of the Black Army, including Semen Karetnyk, Nestor Makhno, and Fedir Shchus, 1919.
Nestor's home town of Huliaipole is now a frontline town in the Russo-Ukrainian War.
@Occasional Troller what is tachanka
A horse-drawn machine gun.
@@JaiAcuneIdeeQuoiMettreIci ?
Evacuate civilians and bomb it asap
Now it's seized by the invaders……
Anyone notice how excellent the drum mix is? Crystal clear yet punchy!
Nice!
I think it may be done on a computer
New account, but yeah these are e-drum beats. Pretty good for the time, though. A lot of songs from the 80s and 90s had not very great e-drum beats
It is written by the most broken soul in the world, it is so sad.
Kim tarafından yazıldı ki?
Though a fan of Makhno, I find it hard to not sympathize with the feeling of betrayal on the singer's voice.
Anarchism in a nutshell
@Grugg you don't get it. There is no betrayal by them. They warned them all DO NOT TRUST THE BOLSHEVIKS. THEY warned them they'd come back and take the food again. Saying "you fools, youll be working all day for a cup of milk from your own cows!" Not even they could have forseen the Holodomor! Not even they could predict such cruelty. It's one thing to fight on a battlefield. It's quite another to work someone to death denying them any sustanenance!
Condemnation from the singer isn't for Makhno if there is any at all. It's grief and longing. Knowing how much better...REMEMBERING HOW MUCH BETTER IT WAS. Nay, the singer believed in them.
@@DialecticalMaterialismRocks indeed comrade
Makhno wasn't carefree. They wept often over casualties, and losses of areas they had sworn to protect. This was a kid who was CONDEMNED TO DIE before they were even 18. They struggled.
He*
@@carbon4454 grammar nazi
They or
He works but I’m
Pretty sure Nestor was a he
@@6idangle I think "they" in this instance refers to Makhno and the black army/those who he worked with. Also I sometimes use they reflexively myself.
Look how quick to "correct" me when I didn't even use "they" in a derogatory way, whatsoever. The bottom line is? You can't claim any more than I can what Nestor Ivanovich Makhno's gender is, as they're dead, and not here to say one way or the other. As far as evidence one way or the other goes? Can't make that argument since survival often necessitates the hiding of gender and sexual minorities, so there's no way to be certain they couldn't be trans. So, back off, because anyone who could pass as female well enough to recon their enemies in battle without being spotted has at least a chance of actually being a woman.
Перекоп - is city name, this city is a "gate" of Crimea. Makhnovians fight with White Army soldiers near it. "Під Перекопом" means near this city.
R.I.P Makhnovia
R.I.P
@Peyton Walters same!
Truly one of the greatest free territories in history
rest in piss you won’t be missed smoking this makhnovia pack 💀💀👎🏼🤣🤣
@@stalinikos you forgot trollface.jpg
I can feel the pain of this seeping deep into the blood and sinews of the singer, a longing of the soul.
Eternal story of Ukrainian life: "Why didn't it work?"
Ahaha actually very accurate)))
As a Ukrainian, can confirm
That's why their history is so interesting
Spent 3 years living with Ukrainians. They probably agree.
The Soviets
I rather enjoy this. Thank you
You are truly inspirational, Comrade Hat. Keep Makhnos Head warm!
All this anarchist music sounds way more like something you would play at a party
@Thought for Food fuck yeah we do
@eXGn0cKS lmao, how is this propaganda music? It literally is just a song about the bolshevik invasion of anarchist ukraine
More like a 4 AM Karaoke in the middle of the countryside, this one at least..
Who wouldn't party in an anarchist country.
that's why those anarchists dont know how a revolution works, they think it is some saturday night party lol
Why didn't it work
Friendly fire was on
Anarchists, no matter how many times authcoms fuck them hard, never learn their lesson.
"left unity bro how are we gonna kill the fascists if we're divided"
Remind me the difference between state violence from authcoms and authcaps?
State violence is state violence.
See Holodomor.
@@terezip2213 Yes, it does not matter if we are oppressed by the state or by capital, we are oppressed the same!
@@Suth1172 and btw, marxist-leninists never abolished capital, it was always basically socialdemocracy without democracy
semem steve holodomor wasn’t a genocide
I do agree with "Kommissar" that it was not intentional.
However I do concede that it was partially caused by man.
The person signing sounds very betrayed, I want to give them a hug
The world will keep evolving and we will only get closer into believing anarchy. Anarchy will not fail forever.
Belief. Sums up anarchism perfect.
Anarchism is a flower that has yet to bloom.
Once it blooms, Mother Anarchy will rise like the sun in the east.
The road may seem long, especially now. However, let's consider that since the birth of anarchism, we have taken large strides forward in human rights, and while capitalism keeps getting worse, there is a reason late stage capitalism has the world late stage in it
it’s not too late for Makhnovchina! Carry on the dream comrades! Mother Anarchy loves her sons ✊
Indeed comrade. The revolution only dies when we lose hope!
@@JohnDoe-ek9ng THE REVOLUTION WILL NEVER DIE!! WE'LL NEVER LOSE HOPE! If anything we will gain hope
Nope, in the 21th century, I think nothing come true… Not hovercars, not desired anarchy.
@@KapkutVoiceovers Nonsense. If one wishes to move mountains tomorrow, you must move pebbles today. Anything is possible, comrade, anything we put our mind to.
You cannot change the past, now there's no time , think for the future
Yes the neo liberals have destroyed our revolution, we need another one
@@Zen-rw2fz I'd like to see it even get 100k members. Never will happen haha
@@IronFox1337 Go look outside of the internet and the western world; China is controlled by such a revolution; do I support it? Nah, but it's from the same era.
India has a large MLM movement also, they skirmish with government forces constantly, same in Bangladesh.
Quit thinking a revolution would occur in a landscape where our lives are so easy we get to comment and shitpost on the internet, go look at the 3rd world and see for yourself of a coming tide of change that is only inevitable as the U.S and large super powers come closer and closer to collapsing in on themselves.
@@IronFox1337 Zapatistas
@@missk1697 rojava and greek anarachists
This feels like it has the potential to birth a new movement. Why didn't it work? It is a perfect refrain for all of our attempts and failures. We iterate and build our better world step by step, brick by brick, note by note and word by word. Freedom and liberation are within reach, but have been before... why didn't it work?
Це завжди було, українці завжди за це вмирали, але тільки зараз світ побачив це
for Ukrainians it is outdated
Shutup, doomer
The revolution will come and we'll all be dead before it, but rest happy knowing we pushed forward the mantle that our grandchildren will inherit
The odds against Bat'ko were too great, and we are in much the same situation; but we must not lose hope, for then the Bourgeois have truly won.
@John Doe You're talking about Makhno as if he's Putin just today
No matter how much the traitors squander us, the human urge to embrace true freedom shall never cease!
Huzzah!
Long live mother anarchy
@Blue Ceasar what are you talking about?
@Blue Ceasar soy moment
@@donovantownshend8783 Fallout: New Vegas, he's referencing one of the factions that go with the sorta 'Anarchy' vibe.
Дякую, товарише. Привіт з України і махновського краю
Slava Ukraine!
I have my doubts about anarchism as an ideology but I can respect Makhno for acting as humanely as possible in a horrible war while still fighting for what he believed in.
@@Modern_Diogenes yess! i recommendo Nestor Mahkno: Anarchy Cossack if u want ti know more about him btw, and some kropoktin and bakunin books if u want to know anarchist theory stuff!!
Some Saxophone would spice this up.
William Chapman Ah a fellow Australian
@@aidenmcdonald1285 Ah a fellow Australian
@@tonyjones8721 Ah a fellow Australian
@@louieford6063 Ah a fellow Australian
Ah a fellow Australian
when fascistball's channel gets destroyed by the algorithm
Lol it came right back at him. the irony
Fate of all fascists
@@sovietdawn8731 The only good fascist is a dead fascist.
@@sovietdawn8731The RuZZians are next
LMAO
Fascistball should ask the Same to himself.
Little Ant Ich liebe MLP auch.
Tyva!
This is a fair point. I am probably closer to fascism than anarchism or communism but the Soviet block lasted for 70 to 50 years whereas the fascist "block" lasted for like 15 to 20 years at the most.
@@SvenskaKrig1709 And intrinsic fascist policy is what destroyed that fascist block, whereas the Soviet block's demise arose from a deviation from communist ideas.
@@SvenskaKrig1709 Also they lost all of the wars they fought in that original span of 15 years
Huliaipole is at war again. Long live the spirit of makhno
"Even they admit it". I mean, its talking about Makhno, so its not exactly talking about ALL communism. And besides, I don't see fascism working that well for all.
@Francesco Salvatore Yeah. Sadly it was because of one mans lust for control and power, despite having the goal of communism somewhat in mind. Meanwhile Fascists just fall face flat every fucking time.
I didn't talk about communism at all wtf, it talks about anarchism XD
@Francesco Salvatore
Free Ukraine and other smaller movements were seen as a threat to the fabric and solidarity of the USSR. And it had nothing to do with fascism, you can't just slip that in there as a non-existent boogeyman enemy and expect to get away with it.
@Jay Blake not communists, more mutalists/ syndicates
@@inkaf225 so communists
This song is insanely good!
Its wonderful , that no commercial attached. Pure.
Okay, the delivery of that last line jumpscared the hell outta me
makhno jumpscare
Don't ask Nestor why it didn't work, ask Lenin and Trotsky. They're why.
@Kingkee and then got trolled himself, what comes around.
@Kingkee stalin taked their revenge haha
:trollface:
@Karsar1917 Go larp in r/Genzedong
@@biyiklialperen1923 "taked" so u r an edgy anarkiddy cuz u can't use english and say took
Why didn't it work?
Because Trotsky didn't know the meaning of the words "United front".
Also this shit got me sad boogeying
Rest in peace. Truthful Anarchy.
1918-1921.
well I mean the catalonians had a bit of fun a few years later. their anarchy was pretty truthful
Glad it's gone and buried
Makhno ideology is not true anarchy
I know, but anarchy can’t truthful, Makhni just first anarchist in times of People war in Russia.
I changed look for ideologies.
If at first you don't succeed, try, try again!
@eXGn0cKS its anarchist song
@eXGn0cKS get out of here lib chud.
@eXGn0cKS its didnt succeed because the red army/bolshevik party/trotsky and stalin attacked them and killed their leader putting an end to the anarchist movement/black army. It have nothing to do with the political system itself
@@bigpp3189 lmao Sure keep lying to yourself
YES COMRADE!
СЛАВА НЕСТОРА МАХНА!!!!!!
що означає твоя аватарка і нік?
@@revgarr Українська Ноактська Імперська Республіка
я всё из-за проклятых большевиков(
и как ты можешь писать "СЛАВА НЕСТОРА МАХНА!!!!!!" если поддерживаешь империализм
Анатолий, почитал про вашу творчество и беру назад. Прошу прощения. Я служил там. Речка Молочная, надеюсь, такая же, тихая, красивая. В Тамбовке , полагаю, так же делают вино, как было, и очень много подсолнухи в огородах, как тогда. Бердянск, сильно надеюсь, такой же.
Well, it worked quite well at turning Fascistball's role-figures into something much more useful for society, fertilisers that is.
@althistoryknight Well, Karelia is no more Finnish, so... Don't think they would have a problem with all those marines dropping like flies in Lebanon and Iraq.
@@qasemsoleimani9443 Finnish Marines?
@@qasemsoleimani9443 Who is fascistball and what did they do
слава великим анархистам планеты.
Людоньки-напишить будь ласка-дуже прошу-хто автор і хто співає? Слухаю і плачу-я ж теж махновець,з Батькових онуків!
Музика і спів - Анатолій Сердюк із Запоріжжя (www.serduk.com.ua), слова Лариси Верьовки. Альбом 1998 р. "Гуляй-Поле"
capitalists may put additives in their food, we prefer to put sadditives
Seductive?
Huliaipole is still free. With this recent outbreak of the full invasion, Russian forces did try to assault the town but were halted around 10-ish km away back in 2022. It was never taken by Russian forces as of 30-06-2023. Russia forces didn't even get to touch the actual city with troops yet, just shells.
The mayor of the town uses Makhnovist imagery(patches saying "Greetings from the boys of Makhno's Town"), and some of the troops participating in the defense were at some point, anarchist units. The city still stands strong, endures shelling but fights on. Recently the town was the staging ground from some localized counter attacks as part of the greater Counter-Offensive. I seen some of the Kayfariki Group lads posting about it aswell a while back. "Serhiy Yarmak, the mayor of Huliaipole, reported that local Ukrainian forces had named their defensive positions after Nestor Makhno".
Makhno's Town still stands strong. Power to the Anarchists fighting for independence and anti-imperialism. Making Makhno proud, lads.
Sources: Eco-Platform, Blackheadquarter, REVDIA, Wikipedia page for Huliaipole, Popular Front and UACrisis.org.
Recently Russian forces destroyed the museum dedicated to Makhno in Huliaipole. I am not sure about the town itself though. It's very sad
To all my Anarchist comrades, I appreciate you and your dedication in the face of incredible opposition. While I do personally believe a transition state is necessary, I also acknowledge the danger of it and hope we can work together in the future to reduce government control as much as possible, and eliminate it as soon as possible. We cannot win without eachother. Long live the United Front! Long live the combined power of the revolutionary left. We can't do it alone.
🚩❤🏴
Needed now more than ever... The old world has died, and the new world is stillborn. Monsters reign supreme.
March on in the workers' united front, for you are a worker too
"Under the dungeon" is incorrect translation, Perekop are city
Together for Class Struggle!
"Why Didn't it Work?" Tankie says "Because Kronstadt !"
what happened in kronstadt?
I never know the history about that
@@DialecticalMaterialismRocks Kronstadt rebellion. March 7-17, 1921. Garrison of the Kronstadt fortress with sailors of the Baltic fleet revolted against the Bolsheviks.
Kronstadt rebellion was good actually
Kronstadt: we need equal rations plz
Soviets: *to the wall*
@Reschek asking for fair rations wasn't "above the roof" - especially when Bolshevik Officials were getting more than they needed, whilst others starved. You sound like all those fucknuggets who defend Boris Johnson and the Tories
Why does the singer sound like Gru from Despicable Me
Now I can’t help but imagine Ukrainian gru singing this, thanks
Here are the lyrics in the video for English
Black fortuneteller, Black Fortuneteller, telling the future
White and red, white and red, the tape was splitting up
And in Huliaipole, and in Huliaipole the cherries blossom
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Why did it Happen?
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, How Did you Believe in Happiness?
How were you measured, measured for the black suit?
And in Huliaipole, and in Huliaipole the cherries blossom
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Why did it Happen?
Over the Morning, Over the morning horses are galloping,
Bochanci boys, Vorpivci boys under the dungeon
And in Huliaipole, and in Huliaipole the cherries blossom
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Why did it Happen?
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, what is this fate?
Where you were hugged by Paris, - not Huliaipole?
And in Huliaipole, and in Huliaipole the cherries blossom
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Why did it Happen?
And in Huliaipole, and in Huliaipole the cherries cry
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Why did it Happen?
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Why didn’t it work?
🏴
🏴🚩🏴🚩
Btw,that's wrong translation of song name.
Actually,it translates like"Why wasn't it work?" or somehow like this. This song means that it failed there at Civil War time period. Not that it didn't work at all.
The translation "Why didn't it work" does fit that description, don't worry. "Didn't" can work as past-tense. An incorrect translation would be something more like "Why doesn't it work" or "Why can't it work".
Why? Generally because of Soviet terror...
Why? Cheka, GPU... Thousands killed... Blood...
It did work, actually. In Spain, Ukraine and currently in Chiapas, Mexico. Anarchism is the natural path that history eventually takes.The fact that there are some conservative forces such as fascism, neo-liberalism and stalinism (not communism) doesn't mean that the people won't fight their way through opression
What even is a Stalinism?
Gus STRG I think the song is about the destruction of anarchism in Ukraine, it does not deny that it ever existed. The problem with a working class revolution is that working class people have much less money.
We don't like people like you Shiny. Go pray east, the direction of your God-Emperor papa Stalin,
Gus STRG Not to mention, Rojava.
another great example of the triumph of anarchism
For roman alphabet users here are the lyrics :
Chorna vorozhka,
Chorna vorozhka
Krasno hadala.
Bilo-chervonu,
Bilo-chervonu
Strichku splitala.
Chorus:
A u Hulyaypoli,
A u Hulyaypoli,
Svityatʹsya vyshni.
Nestor Ivanovych,
Nestor Ivanovych,
Chomu tak vyyshlo?..
Nestor Ivanovych,
Yak Vy poviryly
V kazku pro shchastya,
Yak Vam namiryaly,
Yak Vam vidmiryaly
Z chornoyi masti.
Chorus
Ponad zirnytsi,
Ponad zirnytsi
Koni halopom.
Khloptsi bochantsi,
Khloptsi vorpivtsi
Pid perekopom.
Chorus
Nestor Ivanovych,
Nestor Ivanovych
Chom taka dolya,
Shcho obnyala Vas
Zemlya Paryzha -
Ne Hulyaypolya.
Chorus
Nestor Ivanovych,
Nestor Ivanovych,
Chomu ne vyyshlo?
Чорна ворожка,
Чорна ворожка
Красно гадала.
Біло-червону,
Біло-червону
Стрічку сплітала.
Приспів:
А у Гуляйполі,
А у Гуляйполі,
Світяться вишні.
Нестор Іванович,
Нестор Іванович,
Чому так вийшло?..
Нестор Іванович,
Як Ви повірили
В казку про щастя,
Як Вам наміряли,
Як Вам відміряли
З чорної масті.
Приспів
Понад зірниці,
Понад зірниці
Коні галопом.
Хлопці бочанці,
Хлопці ворпівці
Під перекопом.
Приспів
Нестор Іванович,
Нестор Іванович
Чом така доля,
Що обняла Вас
Земля Парижа -
Не Гуляйполя.
Приспів
Нестор Іванович,
Нестор Іванович,
Чому не вийшло?
This is so good...
Long live anarchy!
Слва Махно!
александр сергеев Героям Слава!
@@maxlin200 Героям НКВД слава
Всем кто противостоял царской власти слава!
@@tovarish1917 не всем Слава, не всем.
Yes, it didn't work in the face of overwhelming bolshevik pressure. It was still worth trying.
In the face of Bolshevik betrayal after winning the Civil War for them, but was still worth trying.
I love the piece but why is there a majestic Brian David Gilbert in the background
Bat'ko is happy :). Forgive me for being stupid, but I don't get the tweet at the beginning.
мяёCняоиїC918 Fascistball, a fascist youtuber who uploads far right songs, mocked one of GETchan's videos, because one song was called "Why didn't it work?" (Why did communism fail?)
Oh I see now. Thanks for clearing it up ;)
Parole en français
Diseuse de bonne aventure noire, diseuse de bonne aventure noire, racontant l'avenir
Blanc et rouge, blanc et rouge, la bande se séparait
Et à Huliaipole, et à Huliaipole les cerises fleurissent
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Pourquoi est-ce arrivé ?
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Comment avez-vous cru au bonheur ?
Comment avez-vous été mesuré, mesuré pour le costume noir?
Et à Huliaipole, et à Huliaipole les cerises fleurissent
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Pourquoi est-ce arrivé ?
Au cours du matin, Au cours du matin, les chevaux galopent,
Garçons Bochanci, garçons Vorpivci sous le donjon
Et à Huliaipole, et à Huliaipole les cerises fleurissent
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Pourquoi est-ce arrivé ?
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, quel est ce destin ?
Où t'as été embrassé par Paris, - pas Huliaipole ?
Et à Huliaipole, et à Huliaipole les cerises fleurissent
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Pourquoi est-ce arrivé ?
Et à Huliaipole, et à Huliaipole les cerises pleurent
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Pourquoi est-ce arrivé ?
Nestor Ivanovych, Nestor Ivanovych, Pourquoi ça n'a pas fonctionné ?
merci camarade
And in Huliaipole the cherries are weeping! 😢😭
glory to nestor makhno and glory to ukraine
This is where men cried
Truly one of the saddest songs
"Why didnt it work" might be the coolest and saddest name for a song ever.
There is a bit I don't understand tho, is the singer blaming nestor or is it a retorical question?
Its a mourning song.
Could someone explain me the verse around 1:25 please ? What are those names ?
Edit : I think he means boys (men) from different ukrainian city (like Bochanci and Vorviptsi) are now fighting together in Perekop (city between Crimea and continental Ukraine) against the white army, which was an important makhnovist victory.
This is boys from Ukrainian village
Я люблю Україну.
Я теж
І я.
Ukraine Is the best
Ukraine smells of Anarchism :) LUV IT
Тоже, но не украинскую капиталистическую республику
Viva Néstor Maknho
Mahno*
Both of you are wrong, its Makhno.
@@somerandommen Махно = Machno or Makhno
Wolcottian: Néstor Ivanovytc yst un Revolutjonar Kumonist, hýmm er vårsk Zhjatsar das USSR.
English: Nestor Makhno was a communist.
Differences between Fascistball and Fascism
Fascistball: Darn good channel, Great music
Fascism: Terrible ideology.
Ever since I became an anarchist from a reactionary liberal, I just abstained from the ideology, the channel and the music altogether.
It dosent matter, is fascist so Baikal is all he deserves. Anne Frank and the rest of victims are asking for revenge. Its our obligation to finish with the work of our grandfathers.
@Devan 4237 >implying we are communists when this is an anarchist song
also: Communism Is Better But That's Besides The Point
@Devan 4237stand behind a tachanka
Literally the Ukrainian version of Napoleon’s “There’s nothing we can do”
Literally in ukrainian lang
@@Oniliker Oh I didn't see the latin 'i' in the lyrics. Fixed it.
Desde España ,Viva la Anarquía.
Share this with Ukrainian Socialists!..
listened to this while watching kiev be bombed and the Russians invade
Listening to this after the Russians didn't capture Huliaipole.
Full freedom will win one day!
Why did it turn out this way? Because Mahno was against both Communists and UPR, that's why. I'm Ukrainian BTW.
Nazar Derkach I wonder what a ukraine without the tyranny of the Soviet Union would have looked like today
@@levmarchuk998 Probably worst.
@OVOD.net Jesus you reek of being a Russian Bot lol. BTW guess what all these nations have in common. That is right, the Russians all oppressed them and tried to exterminate them.
I think Ukraine would have been better off if Makhnovists existed and won the Maidan not the fucking Right Sector or Azov cunts, now Ukraine is so hated because of those scums. Also Glory to Ukraine (Free Territory Ukraine)
@@levmarchuk998 Anarchist utopia until WW2 rolls around and Germany attacks, then I have no idea how it would have went from there
This is so sad :(
I'm crying...
Me too
Me too
because we got stabbed in the back
Nestor: "How about another anarchist revolt?"
Lenin: "No, I think we had enough of your anarchist revolts Nestor"
Tankie detected, deploying laser beams of mutual aid
@@namethathasntbeentakenyetm3682 Jokes on you I carry a mirror
@@diavasmamevroxi
You fool. The laser beam was simply a trick to make you bring a mirror. For we have flanked you, with rifles in our arms. What is a mirror to do against lead except to shatter?
@@brandon9172 we have tanks
@@literallyatank3918 We have tachankas and molotovs, you can't do anything against WE the anarchist
*laughs in Makhnovtchina*
Yea... I often ask myself this question too.
Of course I watch your channel.
I don't agree with your ideology, but I enjoy the music.
The more reason to start agreeing with it!
Fascistball IV I dont hate your music. I just hate your fans. :)
+420th Gommunist International read the biography of the maniac that wrote that book.
the more facist agree with communists the stronger the nazbols get
The fact that he went crazy later in the late 30's doesn't invalidate his points before.
6 months since i haven't listened to this masterpiece. Why do anarchists have such good songs
Where can you get a download of this song?
I’m a communist but I like this song
What can I say
ok guys check this out, much better song of anarchists ruclips.net/video/lxh_7LMGGrE/видео.html
This is a good, you can empathize with your enemies.
This is the difference between the far left and the far right
Nestor Makhno is a Communist too.
@@nunyabisness7055 no
@@bloodborne410 Yeah, about that.
Communism is a Stateless, Classless, Moneyless society, one that lacks unjust hierarchy.
Anarchism seeks to abolish unjust hierarchies.
You cannot be an Anarchist and not a Communist.
Me when I failed the exams:
instead of getting into a pointless and endless political debate, just enjoy the song
but the improvised debate ramblings are the most fun part of the comment section!
Free Territory? Don't mind if I do!
Could someone write the romanized lyrics in Ukrainian? I am really interested in the language, but can't read it :/
Chorna Barozhka, chorna barozhka, krasno gadala
Bila Cherabono Bila cherabono, spichka spitala
A u huaypoli, a u huaypoli, spitsespeni vishni
Nestor Ivanavich, Nestor Ivanavich, Shomu tak vishlo
Nestor Ivanavich, yak vi povirili vu kazka pro schastya
yak vam namirili, yam vam vidmiryali, z chornoi masti
A u huaypoli, a u huaypoli, spitsespeni vishni
Nestor Ivanavich, Nestor Ivanavich, Shomu tak vishlo
That's the first verse- Ukrainian Cyrillic is different than Russian Cyrillic, plus the accent is different, so excuse any mistakes, please. If you want to start learning Ukrainian, the alphabet is fairly easy to learn, despite its look. What's really time-consuming is reading well :) Good luck!
@@zorahunter3796 thank you very much! I myself am from another slavic country (Croatia) and I really like Ukraine and even understand some of the language. It is beyond me though, why Makhno doesn't get any recognition in Ukraine, I mean yes, he was an anarchist, but he was also a Ukrainian nationalist who fought for a free Ukraine, even if that meant an anarchist one. Besides that, the Black Army was really effective
@@ivanrenic4243 Agreed! Plus, the anti-semitism allegations were proven false, and there was an event where the Black Army took Red Army supplies from a train and distributed it to peasants living in the area- What's not to love about Makhno? While meanwhile, in America, we look up to slave owners. It's a shame.
I started to learn Russian a year or 2 ago, but I haven't really gotten anywhere- and I probably shouldn't have assumed you to be an American (the greatest insult XD).
I know that a few fascist groups in Ukraine look up to Makhno, but it's not the same as some of Ukraine's Antifa or left-anarchists looking up to him.
@@zorahunter3796 no harm done, are you from the US, because you said "we look up to"? If so, respect that you at least tried to learn Russian and know so much about European history
Нестор Іванович, чому так вийшло?
its not under the dungeon its at Perekop (perekop is a city (Ukrainan anarchist washington))
Эх Нестор Иванович не треба було с тими краснодирими якшатися...
Anyone know why the 1 hour video was taken down?
I don't know but in the meantime have a reupload ruclips.net/video/XEC_goU-H4s/видео.html
Анархия - мать порядка
Why didn’t it work? They made the same mistake every anarchist does: they believed the statists actually wanted left unity.
Do you have a source to back up this claim?
As far as I've read of The Road to Freedom, the newspaper mouthpiece for the Makhnovists, Makhno himself understood the pact with the USSR to be temporary and that Makhnovia was irreconcilable with the USSR.
But maybe you've read something different?
If not, you casting Makhno as a naive fool speaks more about your own naivete than it does his. Maybe put the internet down and read a book instead?
Who is this Nestor Ivanovych guy?
Nestor Makhno, anarchist ukranian revolutionary
Anubs lmao I thought that was a different person
@@falpsdsqglthnsac Ivanovych is kinda his middle name (we call it "ім'я по-батькові" which means "father's name").
@@anubs9528 He was a Libertarian Socialist.
@@erikchepkyy5912no Anarchy
I dont get the meaning of this song fully is it supposed to be like "we shouldve won why didnt we?"?
It's deeper than that. The song is about the tragedy of Makhno's life in general, both as a revolutionary and a human being. To appreciate the lyrics and the implied allusions, you need to understand the history and the political background of that period.
im sory my anarchist homies for trotsky
Anarchy - Future
Only if we live in post-appocalypse where the position of state is unecessary for survival of individualism commune
swag
Nestor wasnt in the mood i guess
Who translates these translated songs you post?
translators
19/17 very helpful