Kieran's internal monologue: "Don't get shot Kieran, don't get shot, Arthur threw the fish back, that's okay, we're fine, don't get shot, don't get shot, ....".
Me too, second run I did, and almost screamed because Arthur was bullying him. I was like, "Arthur, stop or I'll drown you." Kieran is my favorite character, not even Arthur is allowed to be mean
I love that there’s just a loooong pause- “There ain’t a point in me saying anything is there….” Then the “welp. Guess I’m gonna go do something else now” 😂
That “good job Arthur” said enough lmfao. Kieran was a good character, I wish we had better interactions besides “where’s my money” every time we talk to him.
I was also kind of annoyed because every time you see another gang member bullying him, like Bill or Sean, it’s impossible to antagonize that person afterwards. It’s also impossible when greeting Kieran right after you witnessed it to get a line of dialogue related to the bullying. I wanted to shame the bullies and/or at least say a kind word to Kieran, but there’s no way. That’s pretty fucked
@@singingcat02 that's kind of weird that you can't do that. In Bully, if you antagonize someone bullying someone else, you'll say something like "leave them alone", and if you greet someone getting bullied, you'll say something like "want me to kick their ass for you?". It's unfortunate rdr2 took a step back in that regard
@@plus_sign no shit it's not Bully, but it's a game by the same studio with the same basic conversation mechanics, on top of being a game with a gargantuan budget and a shit ton of attention to detail.
@@plus_sign hahaha that's so ironic considering the news that just got released a few days after you commented that. Bully 2 got scrapped and they implemented many of its features and assets to red dead engine. They didn't specify but considering bully had the same system? This feature was actually mad for Bully 2 and got added to Red Dead after they cancelled it and scrapped it's assets. So ironic. How dumb do you feel?
Kieran SHOULD join Arthur, Dutch, and Hosea on fishing trips together. The young man could teach them a thing or two on getting more fishes on the dinner table for the rest. Kieran deserves to have that opportunity, indeed.
Arthur: Aw, Bluegill Fish... I wanted muneh! Arthur's brain: Bluegill Fish can buy many muneh. Arthur: Explain how! Arthur's brain: Bluegill Fish can be exchanged for currencies Arthur: Woo-hoo!
After a while I mostly quit interacting with Kieran. He seemed like a nice little dude and even Arthur's "friendly" greetings to Kieran were usually meaner than I wanted to be, so I just left him alone.
Whenever I came to camp, the first person I went looking for was Kieran. I loved him so much. Then, right after rescuing tilly, I noticed I couldn't find him ANYWHERE at camp... and I knew that the gang didn't let him on guard duty. I was worried but I couldn't do anything... Then he rolled up dead. And I said I fuckin knew it.
After this mission, Kieran left, and I saw a big bluegill in the water, shot it with the revolver. Went over and picked it up and it just happened to be the legendary bluegill lmao Edit: uploaded proof on my channel because some of you don't believe this for some reason
It kinda sucks that despite everything Kieren has been through, Arthur is still antagonistic toward him. Like, he had a rough time toward the end of his life, and it was unbelievable how he went out.
Bro had one of the most brutal Deaths riding like that in to camp didn't have to do him like that, an yea I do wish at sum point I wish they would put a normal dialogue not "I got my eye on you O'Driscoll"
For those wondering, after he leaves, an enormous Largemouth Bass will spawn in that spot, you can see it with eagle eye. I couldn't get him to bite the lure though
Yeah if you catch the legendary bluegill before you do Kierans fishing mission I believe it's also replaced by that large-mouth bass. It will be the fish that jumps out of the water when you see it in the cut-scene. All I caught with Kieran there was bass because I already got the massive bluegill but could never land the massive bass.
I read ur comment 2 days ago, and now I just did this mission, and waited for t largemouth bass. It didn't bite t lure after many attempts, so I unhooked 2 revolver drums in it. That damn fish was bullets proof though. I tried to fish it for a while again, but it was unless. I got mad and threw a dynamite at the bass. Despite it's size, t game considered it as a normal largemouth bass. T game said I could sell it for t fisherman from t legendary fish quest (only 80 cents), but nothing happened when I clicked to sell.
Me during my first playthrough of RDR2: "Man I don't want to go fishing with Kieran." Me after my first playthrough of RDR2: "Man... I wish I'd gone fishing with Kieran that one time"
in my case every time i was near him, he just hesitated and thought of what he's doing and arthur insulted him. i never got a quest to bring him some type of item or even request of fishing, so its like i thought he's one of those characters who never gets companion quests before they're written off the story
Yeah, before you get to this part of the story, go and find the legendary fish side mission. It unlocks the special lures from the fishing store in Lakay where you can buy the lure to catch this fish.
I never understood everyone’s relationship w Kieran. They all give him shit the entire game, then when he dies, everyone is sad and remarks how cool he was.
Mostly cause everyone in the gang picked on him so people kinda picked on him too, kinda like teasing but still liked him. Unless you mean people who go “Kieran is such an awful character I hate him raaww” then idk. My first play though I would constantly harass him cause it was funny but I generally really like him, but his death BROKE me…so every other playthough I appreciate Kieran more. Him and Sean are my favorite gang members
Kieran had good instincts and skill in the wilderness. It’s too bad he never found somewhere be belonged. O’Driscoll or Vanderlinde, he was never welcome anywhere. I wish Kieran didn’t die so early he really had potential as a far more important character.
Kieran: There's no point in me saying anything, is there? Arthur: He wasn't the first Legend I ever spared *Looks at Kieran with respect and admiration* The End
I was doing this mission, when suddenly like 10 bounty hunters arrived and forced me to shoot them in self defense while he just stood there and watched water
I mean to be fair they all already had major trust issues with anybody affiliated with the O'Driscolls. He was shown quite a bit of mercy being allowed to live in the camp.
@@barple367 True, it was a bit of both, they were kind for sparing him and letting him live with them but at the same time, Kieran deserved a bit better considering the way he respected the gang
@@se7enei8htnin97 I feel like he respected the gang out of fear because he knew that he slipped once he was done for. I feel like the gang had justifiable reasons to always be suspicious of Kieran. Didn't really deserve to die the way he did though, that was cruel for anybody.
this was early on, before his death he was basically part of the gang and even had a thing going with karen, early on they all still see him as an Odrsicoll
My only gripe with Arthur was how he treated Kieran. I wish Kieran would’ve survived and stood beside Arthur in the end. That would’ve been cool. Or imagine him and Mary-Beth escaping together. And then having John run into the 2 of them at the train station in Valentine 8 years later. I can see it now; John’s talking to Mary-Beth when the door to the station opens. Kieran walks out saying “I’ve got the tickets, trains about ready to…”. He stops mid-sentence as he makes eye contact with John. John says “…O’Driscoll!” And for the last time Kieran, in his timid way, says “I ain’t no O’Driscoll, mister!” John laughs and holds his hand out to Kieran and says “I know you’re not. You never were.” They shake hands and they all go their separate ways. That would’ve been cool. If Kieran hadn’t saved Arthur’s life, Arthur wouldn’t have been able to save John the way he did. Would’ve been great for John to also point that out to Kieran. Kieran deserved a happy ending.
Poor Kieran. Genuinely good guy but was in the wrong place at the wrong time. The way he died is disturbing and straight up depressing at the same time
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
I love how Kieran is just in utter disbelief LMAO
@Andy B you literally stole another top voted comment, cringe
his head was blown away
@Andy B O my god kk
I want some pizza 🍕
@@greatcoldemptiness i dont see it anywhere else. Cribge.
Yes cribge
Kieran's internal monologue: "Don't get shot Kieran, don't get shot, Arthur threw the fish back, that's okay, we're fine, don't get shot, don't get shot, ....".
Should have been "don't lose your head over this".
@@TheAgentAssassin BRUUUH! 🤣
@@TheAgentAssassin 💀
haha yes
awwww, he knows the player so well!
“What’s your biggest life regret”
Not going fishing with Kieran
#metoo ....well... til second run
Make sure you talk to the fish collector first and buy the advanced lure set. Then you'll catch the massive legendary bluegill on Kierans mission.
Me too, second run I did, and almost screamed because Arthur was bullying him. I was like, "Arthur, stop or I'll drown you." Kieran is my favorite character, not even Arthur is allowed to be mean
me:......
So true.... hehe
(dammit I just wanted to rob trains and carriages)
@@lemonshobbies thanks
I love that there’s just a loooong pause-
“There ain’t a point in me saying anything is there….”
Then the “welp. Guess I’m gonna go do something else now” 😂
that's because the dialogue in this game is shit. it wasnt intentional.
@@pavle480 You're really claiming the dialogue in RDR2 is shit? The dialogue in this game is perhaps the best dialogue ever put in a video game.
@@pavle480 Wasn't intentional? What?
@@pavle480 you got ratio'd into the ether
@@pavle480 you must’ve not played the same game the rest of us did
That “good job Arthur” said enough lmfao. Kieran was a good character, I wish we had better interactions besides “where’s my money” every time we talk to him.
I was also kind of annoyed because every time you see another gang member bullying him, like Bill or Sean, it’s impossible to antagonize that person afterwards. It’s also impossible when greeting Kieran right after you witnessed it to get a line of dialogue related to the bullying. I wanted to shame the bullies and/or at least say a kind word to Kieran, but there’s no way. That’s pretty fucked
@@singingcat02 that's kind of weird that you can't do that. In Bully, if you antagonize someone bullying someone else, you'll say something like "leave them alone", and if you greet someone getting bullied, you'll say something like "want me to kick their ass for you?". It's unfortunate rdr2 took a step back in that regard
@@n6h6 this isn't Bully lol it's RDR2 that's the core mechanic of that game
@@plus_sign no shit it's not Bully, but it's a game by the same studio with the same basic conversation mechanics, on top of being a game with a gargantuan budget and a shit ton of attention to detail.
@@plus_sign hahaha that's so ironic considering the news that just got released a few days after you commented that. Bully 2 got scrapped and they implemented many of its features and assets to red dead engine. They didn't specify but considering bully had the same system?
This feature was actually mad for Bully 2 and got added to Red Dead after they cancelled it and scrapped it's assets.
So ironic. How dumb do you feel?
Kieran SHOULD join Arthur, Dutch, and Hosea on fishing trips together.
The young man could teach them a thing or two on getting more fishes on the dinner table for the rest.
Kieran deserves to have that opportunity, indeed.
No he an o Driscoll can’t ever trust him
Both of you are wrong, he doesn’t have a head so that means he can’t go on fishing trips or prove his worth
@@TheStrangr2112 well, Hosea doesn't have a functioning heart either, and Arthur may or may not have a bullet in his head
Nice name lmao
bro fucking died
Lmao Kieran is amazed
I think he’s more pissed off then amazed
@@jameskincaid1770 Thomas Kincaid
You’re a wanted man mr morgan
@BananVR well then could i turn myself in?
Kieran didn't deserve a single thing that happened to him.
Arthur was so mean to him during the entire fishing trip too....
I swear
Fr. He never did anything wrong and just stayed at camp taking care of the horses. Then he gets his fucking head cut off by the bastard odriscols
Sure he did. He was a thief and an outlaw.
@@doulos9828 He only lived that life because it was the only solution he could think of after his parents died.
"You think I give a damn about fish? I only give a damn about Muneh."
Arthur: Aw, Bluegill Fish... I wanted muneh!
Arthur's brain: Bluegill Fish can buy many muneh.
Arthur: Explain how!
Arthur's brain: Bluegill Fish can be exchanged for currencies
Arthur: Woo-hoo!
Nah he wanted the honor
@@tarnishedpose i laughed so hard at this LMAOOO
I'm glad Kieran didn't lose his head over that
Haur haur haur...
:((
Jail. Now.
ha.
:(
Was only able to catch that fish after... certain events, and I just shouted from the bottom of my lungs "THIS IS FOR YOU, KIERAN!".
cringe
@@j-dot_cv5010 if you say so🤷🏼♂️
@@j-dot_cv5010and who tf are you?
@@j-dot_cv5010 Why aren't people allowed to have fun anymore?
@@j-dot_cv5010lol, you're the only fool looking cringe 😂
After a while I mostly quit interacting with Kieran. He seemed like a nice little dude and even Arthur's "friendly" greetings to Kieran were usually meaner than I wanted to be, so I just left him alone.
Whenever I came to camp, the first person I went looking for was Kieran. I loved him so much. Then, right after rescuing tilly, I noticed I couldn't find him ANYWHERE at camp... and I knew that the gang didn't let him on guard duty. I was worried but I couldn't do anything...
Then he rolled up dead. And I said I fuckin knew it.
left him alone for the same reason, feel real guilty for it now that he's dead in my playthrough. rip homie
I always antagonized him. It felt like something Arthur would do everytime encountering him.
@@FunnyRedemptionnaw it's prolly something you do in real life
@@jiien6662 You misspelled "nah".
After this mission, Kieran left, and I saw a big bluegill in the water, shot it with the revolver. Went over and picked it up and it just happened to be the legendary bluegill lmao
Edit: uploaded proof on my channel because some of you don't believe this for some reason
American fishing
Yes I used the hunting track and spotted it close to shore
@@stanleybochenek1862 we only use it in the black sea...
@@Fugitive685 bruh
Its easier to do it that way
It kinda sucks that despite everything Kieren has been through, Arthur is still antagonistic toward him. Like, he had a rough time toward the end of his life, and it was unbelievable how he went out.
I never thought of this before but they probably tortured him before they chopped his head off, really rough way to go.
True...i mean Arthur still regrets it in the end tho...mf saved his ass 2 times
@@kiro2532nd time where ? I am sorry I don't remember ?
People forget that Arthur is actually a dick.
Bro had one of the most brutal Deaths riding like that in to camp didn't have to do him like that, an yea I do wish at sum point I wish they would put a normal dialogue not "I got my eye on you O'Driscoll"
For those wondering, after he leaves, an enormous Largemouth Bass will spawn in that spot, you can see it with eagle eye. I couldn't get him to bite the lure though
Yeah if you catch the legendary bluegill before you do Kierans fishing mission I believe it's also replaced by that large-mouth bass. It will be the fish that jumps out of the water when you see it in the cut-scene. All I caught with Kieran there was bass because I already got the massive bluegill but could never land the massive bass.
I read ur comment 2 days ago, and now I just did this mission, and waited for t largemouth bass. It didn't bite t lure after many attempts, so I unhooked 2 revolver drums in it. That damn fish was bullets proof though. I tried to fish it for a while again, but it was unless. I got mad and threw a dynamite at the bass.
Despite it's size, t game considered it as a normal largemouth bass. T game said I could sell it for t fisherman from t legendary fish quest (only 80 cents), but nothing happened when I clicked to sell.
@@fapbird7733where he at
Me during my first playthrough of RDR2: "Man I don't want to go fishing with Kieran."
Me after my first playthrough of RDR2: "Man... I wish I'd gone fishing with Kieran that one time"
in my case every time i was near him, he just hesitated and thought of what he's doing and arthur insulted him. i never got a quest to bring him some type of item or even request of fishing, so its like i thought he's one of those characters who never gets companion quests before they're written off the story
"I'm not even mad, just disappointed."
Kieran's response is great. Guy has a good head on his shoulders.
Well….
Nah bro you didn’t….
He has a real eye for these things.
Had
Nahhhhhh💀
The pause after Arthur threw the fish back was priceless
He is *STUNNED*
I can't believe it, hes so done. 😂 he literally said "welp, imma head out"
god i forgot how mean arthur was to kieran 😭😭😭
Literally I was like damnnn😭
He's literally in disbelief 😂
RIP Kieran Duffy. Thank you for saving Arthur's life. Rest easy boah.
Oh Kieran ❤️ I love him so much. Always my favorite
He always did get ahead of himself ❤
@@donseavey3704 😭😭😭
Bill Williamson be like:
@@donseavey3704 Nah
@@Paaarrrrkerrr Bill Willamson be like:
I shot the fish on my first play through, it literally beached itself and Kieran didn’t say shit 😂
He was thinking "oh shit what if I'm next"
Yeah that's one of the few instances where the game just literally has no dialogue for such an occurrence.
Lol that pause when you throw the fish away 😂
Arthur killed the vibe 💀
The first time I got this dialogue, I laughed out loud at the long pause followed by "there's no point in me saying anything, is there?"
The long pause and stare got me😂😂😂
In my almost 8 playthroughs i never got the fish
you need the special lure at the bait shop
Imagine playing this game 8 times and speeding through without even trying to do any side missions or hunt anything, couldn't be me 😂
I got it but my ps4 crashed 🦦
Yeah, before you get to this part of the story, go and find the legendary fish side mission. It unlocks the special lures from the fishing store in Lakay where you can buy the lure to catch this fish.
@FUM3TO K33M yeah, presuming that both you and the op were to lazy to go to the bait shop, you didn't do much at all apart from the main story.
Athur: Throws Legendary fish in the sea
Kieran: Aight, Imma head out
I like how theres just a brief moment of silence
the awkward silence is truly beautiful
The pause was the best part. He was completely dumbfounded😂
Huh! He's in shock. But he handled that situation like a gentleman.
They really do have dialogue for everything.. best goddamn game ever made
the way he just stands there is so fkn funny LMFOAOFDI
I find it funny thinking about how Kieran is most likely talking to the player as it is important for a side mission.
I never understood everyone’s relationship w Kieran. They all give him shit the entire game, then when he dies, everyone is sad and remarks how cool he was.
You'll see that a lot in real life
That’s how George Floyd’s life was.
@@ChadHellgado dawg
Mostly cause everyone in the gang picked on him so people kinda picked on him too, kinda like teasing but still liked him. Unless you mean people who go “Kieran is such an awful character I hate him raaww” then idk. My first play though I would constantly harass him cause it was funny but I generally really like him, but his death BROKE me…so every other playthough I appreciate Kieran more. Him and Sean are my favorite gang members
@@ChadHellgado A quick internet search revealed that he led a criminal life.
kieran is so sweet i love him
Bro this game is master piece FR
Don't you think Arthur was a little overreacting with that line?
Probably depend on his honor here
@@TamLe-vb5ig Yeah it has to be
I don't think anybody said he wasn't overreacting.
Nah
@@geofk6214 have you heard of the high elves?
that "i guess i'll head back to camp now. good job arthur" had so much pain behind it
I can feel his morale disappearing with the fish😂
Kieran had good instincts and skill in the wilderness. It’s too bad he never found somewhere be belonged. O’Driscoll or Vanderlinde, he was never welcome anywhere. I wish Kieran didn’t die so early he really had potential as a far more important character.
Now one of my new favorite dialogue scenes in the game lol
Oh man, I’m early in the game and Kieran is an cool character. I can’t wait to see him grow throughout the chapters.
💀
Kieran needed more screen time I forgot he was character until I saw his death
I'm surprised there even was a reaction. I've seen too many of these videos that don't actually show anything
Kieran really hit Arthur with the "Okay catch you later then"
Poor Kieran he deserved absolutely nothing, easily the most innocent member besides Jack
Damn to those O'Driscoll sympathizer, but for Kieran its tolerable
Arthur: *catches a fish
The fish:
Arthur: "I'll catch you later then."
I feel so bad for Kieran
I guess he almost lost his head in disbelief
“🎶i love my horsie and my horsie loves me🎶🗣️🗣️”
NPC has sudden horrifying moment of self-realization: _"There's no point in me saying anything, is there?"_
He was stunned, but he kept his head.
He was devastated
I find it funny that Kieran doesnt even look away or move, its like hes just in pure disbelief and shock
Kieran on the verge of crying
Damn. It just a Legendary fish. Kieran doesn’t have to lose his head over it.
i mean he is right, it's one of a kind after all
@@alexcritical9351 I don't think you get the joke
I am pretty sure he got blinded by his jelousness after arthur caught legandary fish
Bro💀
Bros soul left his body
Kieran: There's no point in me saying anything, is there?
Arthur: He wasn't the first Legend I ever spared
*Looks at Kieran with respect and admiration*
The End
"Watch out watch out watch out, RKO outta nowhere"
That 4 second pause was so funny 😂😂
Arthur: throws the legendary fish into the lake
Kieran: 🧍
I love Kieran so much. Just want to adopt the lil guy.
Bro was absolutely bewildered
He was completely unable to express his disappointment
He didn't lose his head. Good lad.
Kieran is just done with Arthur. He looks so done.
I somehow managed to shoot the legendary bluegill with my revolver and Kieran just said the regular dialogue pretending it didn't happen.
Doesn't even look at the fish. Just stares at you like 8|
I was doing this mission, when suddenly like 10 bounty hunters arrived and forced me to shoot them in self defense while he just stood there and watched water
RIP Kieran
bro is flabbergasted
They never treated Kieran fairly tbh, that was one of Arthur’s flaws as a “good” guy
I mean to be fair they all already had major trust issues with anybody affiliated with the O'Driscolls. He was shown quite a bit of mercy being allowed to live in the camp.
@@barple367 True, it was a bit of both, they were kind for sparing him and letting him live with them but at the same time, Kieran deserved a bit better considering the way he respected the gang
@@se7enei8htnin97 I feel like he respected the gang out of fear because he knew that he slipped once he was done for. I feel like the gang had justifiable reasons to always be suspicious of Kieran. Didn't really deserve to die the way he did though, that was cruel for anybody.
this was early on, before his death he was basically part of the gang and even had a thing going with karen, early on they all still see him as an Odrsicoll
Kieran’s not mad, he just disappointed.
That’s the most passive aggressive “good job” I’ve ever heard
My only gripe with Arthur was how he treated Kieran. I wish Kieran would’ve survived and stood beside Arthur in the end. That would’ve been cool.
Or imagine him and Mary-Beth escaping together. And then having John run into the 2 of them at the train station in Valentine 8 years later. I can see it now; John’s talking to Mary-Beth when the door to the station opens. Kieran walks out saying “I’ve got the tickets, trains about ready to…”. He stops mid-sentence as he makes eye contact with John. John says “…O’Driscoll!” And for the last time Kieran, in his timid way, says “I ain’t no O’Driscoll, mister!” John laughs and holds his hand out to Kieran and says “I know you’re not. You never were.” They shake hands and they all go their separate ways. That would’ve been cool. If Kieran hadn’t saved Arthur’s life, Arthur wouldn’t have been able to save John the way he did. Would’ve been great for John to also point that out to Kieran. Kieran deserved a happy ending.
Nah Kieran’s a coward I always make sure to antagonize him.
So mad he had to just leave-
Good on him for not losing his head
I feel so bad for him, he dies one of the most horrific deaths
“You sir, are a fish.”
Kieran was baffled
He was stumped and his mind blown..
you should get a quarter of an honour bar, holding back the urge to keep it
I really like kieran. Hes a pure soul
I didn't know it was possible during this fishing trip I thought he just mentioned it
There’s a massive bass there too but it’s not the legendary one
Arthur even gains honor from doing that
Arthur is such a gigachad. Catches a legendary fish just to throw back into the water like he doesn't care xd
Bro insulted Kieran for no reason
Even the music when u throw the fish is hillarious
It’s like his eyes just popped out of his head
It’s good that he didn’t lose his head
Man, his reaction got me sad, especially after I just played the part where he's coming back to the Shady Belle camp.
where you get that black jacket
Its part of the ultimate edition one of the special things you get from buying it
You can only get it in chapter II, you have to give a rabbit to Pearson to make rabbit stew, and your health core has to be low to trigger it
@@bobbycaley that is a completely different jacket. That one is a variant on the scout jacket
@@thatoneguyowen1181 0:39
@@bobbycaley lmaoooo
I like ur videos so much
Poor Kieran. Genuinely good guy but was in the wrong place at the wrong time. The way he died is disturbing and straight up depressing at the same time
I caught half the legendary fish and nearly blew out my thumb/joystick before realizing I could change the settings to a button hold 🤣
wait what, i could. do that. seriously
Bro what
I literally stopped fishing after hanging out with Hamish because I feared for my joystick
You have shown me a wonderful thing.
In every single game you play, ALWAYS look at what you can change in your settings!