"Yes, this is actually the rarest encounter to trigger.." -RDR2
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- This took me hours to trigger, the dialogue between the strangers and hosea is bugged midways, so i had to redo it over and over again till i get the whole conversation. Hope you enjoyed!
thank you for watching!
/ @tricksterious
#gaming #rdr2 #reddeadredemtion2 #reddeaddredemption #arthurmorgan
#rdr
6 years… 6 years and we’re still finding shit
Just Gavin and the third meteorite left to find
Shouldn’t be surprising considering how skyrim is
Its not the 90's games get regular updates. Quality of life updates add more content often than not. I get ya though but it honestly should be industry norm
@@donlavita3453RDR2 hasn't had updates in forever and I doubt they ever added content to story mode, just online
@@devinvenne they did. It was released in 2018 and last update was 2020. Alot can change in 2 years. Cyberpunk and no mans sky proof but i gets ya has been 4 years but i meant when they did do story updates
Wow, never got this before. This alone shows how much of a good talker Hosea is. He’s slick.
He literally said "Either you get the F outta here or I'll blow your brains out" but in fancy words lol
Last time I played I got arrested in Saint Denis after massacring waves after waves of the law, and I got a cutscene where Hosea comes into the Saint Denis police station with a crate of booze, then it just cuts to you and Hosea leaving the station while you thank him for springing you
Like I literally got arrested for mass murder, Arthur should really of been hung, and Hosea just gets me out like it’s nothing (I get that the game can’t differentiate from crimes like that but still, it’s funny the explanation for me getting away with it was that Hosea turned conning into a super power)
Hosea was a true huckster through and through
Hosea could talk a cat off a fish cart
"Should have"
Hosea’s speech was smoother than Jon’s brain in this game. A true legend man. He’s probably up there playing chess. Or games of wit with philosophers and other fellow deep thinkers. Bro was way too good a guy for he got. They always take the good ones from us man. RIP
Hosea really knows how to intimidate without doing any harm.
You can actually tell when the local realizes that he's in way over his head coming up to a camp with armed guards and large men with guns telling him, as kindly as possible, "get the fuck out"
Old man in a young man's world
He doesn’t choose the intimidate dialogue option. He chooses the persuade dialogue option. Always the best choice
@@suspiciouschickenYoung Men amongst Elder Gods in over their heads.
Hosea just dropped the most subtle but foreshadowing threat ever heard, and that other man immediately picked up on it
That was the subtle
Are you sure? The way i see it he was just avoiding conflict
@@Nothingeverything192definitely a threat, “many of life’s most avoidable tragedies often stem from a lack of basic comprehension” refers to their deaths had they continued to question the camp because they were not understanding the people they were messing with
@@i3642 that ain't a threat. He was telling them they have no reason to fight each other and clear misunderstanding.
@@Nothingeverything192 what do you think the avoidable tragedy he refers to would be? They are killers are robbers on the run, they aren’t gonna beat up 2 guys and let them go tell the police where they are, they would have killed them
1:31 that little "Ah.." was his last 3 brain cells trying to comprehend a small fraction of Hosea's communication skills
I've always thought hosea would've been a perfect saint denis gentleman
Here's the thing. You can eye the conversation all you want, but around that time, his gun hand hovers near his hips and stays there, unflinching for the most part. When he says that line, it goes still as a stone. That man was one wrong move/answer away from being given a new nostril. Even walking away, it stays like that for a second or two until Author gets behind him and only THEN does it go with his natural sway. Hosea is not a man to be trifled with. Shame what happened to him.
Hosea fried the dude's damn brains!
he's half braincell couldn't take the quote so he ended the conversation on "AH.. goodbye"
That’s why I love this game because they added realism I mean how do you not notice a camp of 20 or so people sitting outside of town
It’s stuff like this how I talked MY way into a 50 minute video about details on the game.
Keep in mind that the real life map of rdr2 is not the same one thats in the game
You have to imagine that actually the map is bigger in real life than in game. You go from Valentine to Saint Denis and that equates to in game a couple of miles when in actuality you would’ve traveled from like Colorado to Florida (not sure about the actual respective locations but you get the point). When the forest surrounding Clemens Point (or whatever the cliffside camp in this video was called) is in game 1/3 mile across, in real life it would be something like 5 miles, I would guess.
@@ruohonleikkaaja ya New Hanover is like the edge of Colorado, Nebraska, Kansas, Missouri type area. Lemoyne is Louisiana (Saint Denis is like a near carbon copy of NOLA). New Austin of course is Texas, Ambarino is like the Montana/Dakotas I think, and West Elizabeth is most of Colorado plus some of New Mexico and Oklahoma I think.
@@ruohonleikkaajayeah, blackwater to colter is 2 days of riding intensively, strawberry to mont hagen around 24 hours
1:24
Essentially saying yeah you heard right abt the problem. And your risking death by coming here
Essentially he’s saying “get out while you still can”
Hosea can be scary when he wants to.
Thank you for the explanations, it does make sense now and this just made me respect Hosea even more. Wonder how the gang will be if they led by him since the beginning. He has the wisdom, negotiation skill as well as intimidating personality, yet he's just behind Dutch about people skill.
Look at his right hand too in the five to ten seconds before he says that. He starts subtly moving it closer to his holster, showing the visitors that he is ready to draw down on them, should he need to. This and Hosea drawing on Bill in a split second are some of my favourite moments of his in the game and they’re not even apart of a mission or cutscene either
and for even dumber people, its meaning is "don't chew on more than you can swallow"
"We heard there was some problem-causing folk around here... in response we walked right into their camp ground alone to threaten them!"
Thats what you did back then if you werent going to sit passively and wait and hope. Grab whatever other males of able body to go with you, take weapons for just in case and go head on. Talk respectfully and get your point across.
@@eric7964 Exactly. And they did get their point across without any harm done. The gang is now wary that trouble is more likely going to find them soon.
@@eric7964nah only the idiots did that
Did you see the January 6th riot? Country folk haven't ever been the sharpest tools in the shed
@@outrider425oh yeah you know that for sure
Damn Hosea, Arthur didn't even say a word and you start in with that dropped-on-his-head-as-a-baby stuff! 😂
Arthur doesnt really like playing along with Hosea's acts so He mentions he was dropped on his head so Arthur can mostly just sit there looking menacing
Simmer down, Fenton... no need to do this feller like ya done Ma.
@@Ducky935exactly set your enforcer up to shine and allow him to focus on his job rather than acting
Reminds me of that one page from of mice and men.
These guys and Ms Downes are the only non gang members I ever seen at camp
MS DOWNES CAN COME TO CAMP??? I NEVER GOT THAT
@@bread_0113I’ve only seen a clip but she comes in to tell Strauss that Thomas is dead on account of his sickness and the beating Arthur gave him
@@SpookySpice6419 how did she even find the camp???
@@bread_0113 I’m assuming that the gang would never tell an outsider where they’re located so I think it just doesn’t make since but happens anyways just so you know Thomas is dead
@@bread_0113yep, she paid the remaining debt and telling Strauss that her husband is deceased, but this 2 guys, it’s the first time for me
0:57 the subtle block Hosea does to stop him…. Jeez.
I loved that sublte show of Hosea's fighting skills!
Assert dominance
Wow pretty interesting, I’ve never seen this interaction before, after years there is still more to discover, this is the proof that this is one of the best video games ever created.
100% agreed
@@TricksteriousI have sent close to 18 play throughs never saw this. Had in day one 2018
It's an amazing game that I never finished because the gameplay is so repetitive and boring. It would've been better as a TV show or movie
@@redblue5140 Interesting point. The line is blurring between games and broadcast entertainment. A lot of games I have no interest in playing but love watching someone else's gameplay, to enjoy the story.
@@redblue5140if this game is boring too you then 😂😂
Hosea deserves some kind of reward for communicating the most eloquent “ur not that guy pal” ever put to words
At this point one day is gonna come when someone finds Gavin
Someone found a corpse that is dressed similarly to the guy who is looking for Gavin
Gavin is the cameraman, that’s why we can’t find him
I saw a video from someone theorizing that’s Gavin is inside the man’s head and he’s actually got dissociative personality disorder
@@justinhunt8409 that theory was made by the strange man I also saw the vid aswell and it makes alot of sense lol.
@@William11987 yeah I actually found a letter from the dude’s family member in game that mentions hoping he’s well and something about medication if I remember correctly, so much lore behind such a bizarre random encounter lol
I don't think there's one player, after six years of this game being out, that has seen everything there is to see. No one.
True. We’ve had the game since it released and neither of us cousins have 100% completion either
@@ClubisteMWow, careful everyone, the unimpressive man is here.
@@AngelMogol1c0That sounds like a (non) supervillain name
Reminds me a lot of skyrim, heck been playing that for years too and still find new things every now and again.
@@veryangryduckpl2122 if dr. Doofinschmertz had a supervillain name, that would be it
I just had an encounter in chapter 2 where Javier tracked me down and said bill had been kidnapped. Then him and I rescued bill from bounty hunters. Never ever had this one before in 6 years of playing 😅
me either! always something interesting hugh? gotta love the game
Oh wow. Haven’t heard that one either.
Hosea for "Fuck around and find out"
Interesting encounter.
That's why Hosea's the huckster -- he's got the silver tongue. I daresay he's the same level with Trelawny or better yet above because he can be pompous (if he needs to) and he can fight.
Arthur just have to stand there and look mighty intimidating.
You are implying Josiah cannot fight 🤔
@@josiahgonzalez942 Well the "Magicians for Sport" mission shows Josiah can endure being tortured (he was brought to that small cabin over at the Braithwaites -- where Arthur & Charles tracked him down) but does implies he's not much of a brawler/able to protect himself with guns. Does he even carry guns?
P/S: You have an interesting name. :)
0:59 I like the detail of Hosea blocking the guy when he tried to circle around him
Those NPCs are using the weird and rare big Morgan horse that is also used for Jeremiah in the epilogue. You can steal theirs and keep just don't leave it in the stable or it will revert to the small size
This is explains how Milton and Ross just so happened to stumble across Arthur and Jack close to camp.
The fishing scene. Indeed, it does.
Yeah, because a group of 20 loud ass people right off the main road near town are so well hidden.
@@colejames423 lol
0:32 when your friends introduces you
You can actually see they're scared. They don't want any trouble in town.
Low rate of criminal activities, more peaceful town.
Not far from there happened of Cornwall burning the whole town because folks didn't want his products.
That's why they're being negative to scare off people who are in group with guns and camping near town.
You’re telling me Cornwall bruend down Limpany?
The “bad” thing about RDR2 is you cannot be everywhere to experience all the little things happening at any camp or elsewhere!
You’re out there investigating a creepy serial killer’s clue and this interaction could be happening at the same time!
Or you’re fighting the Night Folks in the spooky bayou because you were looking for orchids at 3am then the even spookier ghost train has sped away causing you to miss it until the next playthrough!
😜
Well, no, the game simulates around you
investigating the creepy serial killer from the moral high ground of the conventional serial killer is one of gameings finest moments
Yes it depends on how you play , not like other stupid games where whatever shit you do , all things happens in series
I wonder how the gang will be if they led by Hosea since the beginning. He has the wisdom, negotiation skill as well as intimidating personality, but he's just behind Dutch about people skill (he's not as manipulative as Dutch).
Being manipulative only gets one so far. The Wise know this.
I doubt Hosea could have kept the likes of Micah in line, at least not without relying on Arthur's muscle. Then again, Hosea probably wouldn't have let Micah join the gang in the first place 😉
@@SadDetonator Yeah especially Hosea was against Micah since the very beginning. In fact, only Dutch truly accepted Micah.
@@Rayquazamv
Agreed. Hosea's and Arthur's fault was that they didn't put an ultimatum to Dutch before it was too late. Towards the end, Dutch trusted Micah over both of them.
Those fools are lucky I was on my High Honor playthrough. 😂
I love finding new stuff in rdr2 after 5 years
It is incredible. Imagine GTA 6
@@JaguArchery all i can imagine is griefers lobby so far.
Greet/greet/antagonize must be an option here
"Who's this coward"? 😭 lol 😂
@@jaymac7203When the two strangers leave:
Arthur: "Find a skirt to hide under!"
@@DarkZeroHero "run back to momma"
@@PrashantKumar-vi6dp Oh man. I had so much fun antagonizing street urchins in Saint Denis.
"Even your momma doesn't love you!"
I got that one when I antagonized a guy running from Arthur😂@@PrashantKumar-vi6dp
It would have been amazing to see dutch interact with these fools
Some things are too good to occur.
I have , ah plan…
@@JaguArchery you always got a plan dutch
@@omhh1986 This is a good one
Hosea jumping at any opportunity to call arthur a dimwit 😂😂
man its these dialogue moments with Arthur and John where I wish I could let wolfbrains here tag along in my gallivanting adventures like R* originally planned....oh well.
maybe in Red Dead III eh?
Acording to Rob Nelson it was not good enough so they cut it but could have added more random events withh camp members.
Red Dead III you play as Dutch with Hosea tagging along yeehaw
I think this is not a great discovery such as the presented in video, but when riding for a long time with Arthur, he starts singing and humming, idk i just found it cool
Mee too
I didnt hear John do the same and I basically play a lot with him since i am doing trophies for platinum, so I think only Arthur does it
@@quentinn23 nah i'm 100% sure i've heard John sing while riding around.
@@quentinn23 John sings oh my darling while riding around sometimes it's just rare
I've never had this happen before 🤔 Hosiah, always with the insults to Arthur 😭😭 lol 😂
Well he has to come up with something I bet Arthur had a really scary stare
Now THAT'S an ice cold threat.
I love how Arthur is kinda quick to enter into Hosea's stories and characters lol
My cousin found this encounter once,he chased them down halfway up the road and they got killed by bobcat's.
Bobcats are in the game?
@@twistedhellhound666
Yes
@@Geo_TV I've never seen any. You mean cougars?
@twistedhellhound666
My cousin swears they were bobcats. He even killed them, and the game called them bobcats.
@@Geo_TV If you are talking about the first game, then yes. They were scrapped for RDR2
That's actually crazy. This happened during my first ever playthrough in 2019 and didn't think much of it. Now after my 3rd playthrough I never seen those guys again now that I think about it. Suppose I spent more time at camp during my maiden voyage of RDR2.
"Forget my friend, he's simple minded, dropped on his head as a baby..." The only way to make a guy like Arthur seem unthreatening is to make him an idiot with no discernment. Then that threat... (Chef's kiss)
I saw this encounter and didn’t think much of it, didn’t know it was rare until I found this video.
I had an interaction at Clemens point in the dead of night at camp, there was a question mark like when Arthur talks to one of the girls about murdering people, only this time he sat down at the campfire and told a story like we see other members of the gang do.
Dude, no joke, got that a few hours ago never knew about it till then
Well, what does he tell??
@@Charliosos he apologizes for being a grumpy asshole and explains he’s just worried about the gang, wants everyone to be OK, like Dutch and Hosea. Of course this is paraphrasing. But I have 300 hours on PC (300 on Xbox as well) and I have NEVER seen this once. This game is so deep.
I didn't know that was a rare interaction. I did that on my first play through. After researching for my second play through, apparently I've done a whole bunch or found "rare" stuff just by happen stance.
@@irregularrex4004 so many of the interactions are so rare. For example, after you get the letter from Mary in Chp 1, there's a chance two random townsfolk will visit camp, where Hosea threatens to them to leave
"great inability at basic comprehension" I agree, a lot of consternation happened due to my own brainfarts. And a lot of people seem utterly incapable of hearing what I'm trying to convey when I speak to them... They don't hear what I do say yet they hear a lot of things that I don't say and then it's impossible to convince them that what they heard isn't what I said.
i think just saying "people seem utterly incapable of comprehending what I am saying to them" is better. I also think that you should remove the "do" right before you say "say".
Er, okay, but what Hosea is actually saying:
_Fools get murked when they don't take a hint._
@@kristonthesecond751"do" is to put emphasis on "say", as it's followed with them focusing on what he's *not* saying. It makes sense.
@@3to4characters hmmm true that second part does make sense but the do isn’t entirely necessary
Or maybe they do hear it, but they refuse to acknowledge being wrong and either starts gaslighting you, or trying to strawman your arguments. Those types are annoying as hell.
Part of me wishing it was 2018 again, so I got to experience this game for the first time. Also things were a lot different before the 2020s rolled in.
Had this on my first playthrough. Didn't realize it was rare. They were so close to camp though I thought they were related to the main story somehow, like Milton was.
Crazy how this game came out 6 years ago and we still ain't seen everything.
Does this just happen randomly or some actions can trigger it?
it's after you receive the letter from mary that triggers it
So not rarer than any other encounters that happen in specific parts of the story then?
@@sambainbridge301 Basically, it's rarely encountered because there's a narrow window in the story mission timeline for it to trigger.
Those two guys…unarmed looking for trouble. Against a group of thieves and killers.
I saw Sean shooting snakes while he was on guard duty once. I have no idea of that was scripted or if the snakes were following me.
I don't think they were following me since the event happened right after I unintentionally fell through the map while gathering supplies from one of the camp's wagons. I teleported back to ground level and saw Sean shooting snakes lol.
I remember experiencing this in my first playthrough about 5 years ago. Didn't know it was rare
Hmm, they were asking a LOT of questions. I’m starting to think maybe… we shouldn’t have let them go 😳
"who's that creepy looking fella?" *points at arthur
"he's the village idiot, ignore him"
I can only imagine how big gta6 is gona be
everyone's saying hosea's threat was that the problems they heard of were true and they should leave if they want to avoid them, and while that definitely makes sense, the fact that hosea said arthur was slow twice made me think his threat was that, while hosea and the locals could understand each other, arthur most certainly could not, and so they should leave before they make the big guy mad
Either way the message is clear: Move along.
After that scene, can't arthur just follow them down to wherever their walking to and just clean house?... he does that all the time anyway!😂 dead men tell no tales!...
ohhh yeah!
I got this on my first play through didn't realise it was rare
This isn't rare whatsoever. 😂🤡
What happens if you kill them after the interaction? Anyone know?
I've done 10+ playthroughs and I've only triggered this once and idk how I even did it
How in the world do you even trigger this encounter? I've played through the game about seven times now and I've never seen this in the game 😅
Need to show us that same scene with Arthur blowing them away.
Can you follow them and loot them? And can you shoot them and get another dialogue
I found this in my first playthrough, had no idea how rare it is.
I actually triggered this one. I thought it a new mission 😅
I just realised that Hosea is just Buster Scruggs.
But countless times better.
I’ve never known this encounter even existed
Even tho Bill always got a busted ear drum from Hosea, he was having his back & would destroy them both if they even tried to punch or attack Hosea. Bill was dumb but Loyal AF.
This was rare? I got this my first playthrough
Love how you can feel the air change after Hosea drops that last line.
Funny thing is I remember getting this in my very first playthrough years ago but I wondered if I dreamt it since it never happened in any of my next ones.
Over 1,000 hours and never seen this once.
Don't EVER test hoseas gangsta
I like how at 1:24 right as Hosea makes his subtle threat you can see ms grimshaw in the background move into position with her shotgun, the van der linde’s so close as a gang they almost thought and fought as one
Pretty sure that's just Karen on guard duty
@@skreeb Nah that was definitely Ms Grimshaw Karen has blonde hair
Can’t tell if the guy caught Hosea’s threat or was too confused at that sentence
Hosea is the best example of this, but it’s insane when you compare the intelligence of the van der linde gang to the others, like the O’driscal’s and Lemoyne Raiders. You interact with those bunch and there’s nothing in between the ears, can’t even shoot straight either.
That's just because both gangs are down to their 800th or so members after Arthur murdered the first 799 of 'em. They take whoever they can get at this point.
I got this cutscene on my first play through am I lucky?
Short answer: yes, long answer: hell yes 😉
How do you trigger this? Do you have to cause chaos?
It happened to me only once during my 2nd playthrough I believe, it's indeed the rarest encounter and feels so natural seeing that people are passing through there and they go to see who's there, unlike other games where your camp or house is basically a fortress where no one can enter except you or your allies
Nope I would not have let them walk away they gone snitch n tell ppl where the camp is 🤣🤣🤣🤦🏾♂️
Seen this if I'm correct spending lot pf time at camp ...sometime or the other u can see this event happened to me ... thought it was normal event
I've played the story around 4 times and never saw that 😂
To be honest, I'd be scared af seeing a Arthur standing nearby as Hosea is legit threatening. Like Arthur is a unite of a dude. And Hosea knows how to get a point across.
After, I'd guess 20 something playthroughs, I've never seen this. How do you trigger it?
Daaamnnnnnn it’s realllllyyyyyyy new to me!
i got this on my first playthrough earlier this year, i had no idea it was rare
My favorite is when Miss Grimshaw walks up to Arthur and asks him if he’s heard of someone running around shooting everyone they see. She claims she thought it was but but then changes her mind to think it’s you (which it is if you run and gun and kill everything that you pass on the roads)
fantastic❤. Never seen it before. I Really like John final comment.
Ok but did these 2 guys think they could start beef with these... "travellers"
Didn’t know this was rare, I’ve had this occur.
2,000+ hours of gameplay and never once seen this encounter
Who dafuq are they anyway? Just some Pawns getting cooky in front a gang?
Is this really rare or do people just never spend time at camp? I've gotten this in both of my playthroughs
I had this happen to me yesterday i thought it was a script added to one of my mods .... obvs not awesome 😅
Why is Hosea always faking Arthur's stupidness
He calls Arthur slow the whole time then says lack of comprehension causes tragedies, now that’s a good threat
Wow...i have never EVER seen that, I have done 5 play thru's, got 100%, plat trophy - you have ANY idea how long i spent in camp in valentine - but have Never EVER seen this. That was AWESOME...god i love this game and my favorite thing is Dialog hunting.
One of ems got slipperybastard and an elephant rifle. Be careful
I can confirm they were defiantly near camp 😂
Why does Hosea have to insult Arthur’s intelligence any chance he gets
If my camp they wouldn't have walked away.
1:20 Hosea says "fuck around and find out", but it's in Italic