Are Images of Jesus a Violation of the Second Commandment?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024
  • On this episode, Keith welcomes his friend Michael McKendree, a presbyterian brother to discuss the subject of images of Christ. Michael holds that those images violate the second commandment, and Keith does not, so they have a brotherly discussion about their differences.
    Conversations with a Calvinist is the podcast ministry of Pastor Keith Foskey. If you want to learn more about Pastor Keith and his ministry at Sovereign Grace Family Church in Jacksonville, FL, visit www.SGFCjax.org. For older episodes of Conversations with a Calvinist, visit CalvinistPodcast.com To get the audio version of the podcast through Spotify, Apple, or other platforms, visit anchor.fm/medf... Follow Pastor Keith on Twitter @YourCalvinist Email questions about the program to CalvinistPodcast@gmail.com

Комментарии • 24

  • @SoldierofChrist9
    @SoldierofChrist9 Год назад +6

    Though I am of the position of images of Christ is forbidden, I believe the commandment is referring to the active worship of the image and/or utilizing it as a mean of connecting to God.

    • @danielritchie4400
      @danielritchie4400 8 месяцев назад

      Could I ask what would be your case for images? More of a Regulative principle thing where they're not provided?

  • @kimber52415
    @kimber52415 Месяц назад

    Just found this video. I have a family painting of mother Mary and baby Jesus hanging on one wall, and the painting from The Chosen after Jesus redeemed Mary Magdalen on the other. Neither of them do I pray to. They are both meaningful to me in different ways.
    Also, I wanted to address the comment made about Jonathan. He is always very careful to remind people when they meet him that he isn't Jesus. He has spoken about it both in interviews as well as his documentary.
    Really enjoyed the discussion!

  • @TheYoungCodger
    @TheYoungCodger 5 месяцев назад

    I went to PCC and went through the same process. Encouraged to hear someone else went down the same path!

  • @ChristieJo
    @ChristieJo 9 месяцев назад +1

    I got kicked out and blocked in a large reformed facebook group for kindly suggesting they go private when they took away the anonymous feature. They are brutal.

  • @clayman2216
    @clayman2216 11 месяцев назад +3

    Remember: the serpent on the pole issue and how Jesus refers to it AS an issue of understanding ETERNAL life.
    Also, there are artworks of the ram caught in the thicket by his horns which I believe is a direct prophecy of Jesus as God himself being the sacrifice for replacing Isaac and fulfilling Abraham for his obedience and faith.
    “God shall provide HIMSELF”!!!
    Just don’t WORSHIP the image.

  • @thelastoferrathen613
    @thelastoferrathen613 4 месяца назад

    What do you think about crosses.

  • @robschillinger3365
    @robschillinger3365 5 месяцев назад

    Hippolytus of Rome (176-236ad), Lactantius (250-325ad), Ephiphanius (315-403ad), & Eusebius (260-340ad) condenmned images of Christ.

    • @janejane6778
      @janejane6778 3 месяца назад

      That was a long time ago. This is ridiculous

    • @robschillinger3365
      @robschillinger3365 3 месяца назад

      @@janejane6778 what was a long time ago?

  • @nrse82
    @nrse82 Год назад +1

    To those who think images of Christ are permissible, even if you are correct, what is the point of doing so? Why do it?

    • @haronsmith8974
      @haronsmith8974 Год назад +3

      Every Iconoclast I've met would be angered by a statue or image of Jesus Christ, but would totally be fine with statues to Mickey Mouse or some other corporate idol. Fill your house with images that remind you of who you belong to and dont make room for the devil.
      This is exactly why the Jews built statues of angels for the temple and why you see images of Jesus, Mary and the Saints going back to the first century.

    • @doubtingthomas9117
      @doubtingthomas9117 11 месяцев назад +1

      To testify to the truth of the Incarnation.

    • @philagon
      @philagon 5 месяцев назад

      @@haronsmith8974Mute images cannot speak. They remind of nothing but themselves.

    • @ILNIL8U
      @ILNIL8U 4 месяца назад

      Galatians 3:1

    • @janejane6778
      @janejane6778 3 месяца назад

      To remember every day who you love- Jesus!! What a bunch of baloney. No one worships a statute. Get a grip !

  • @wesleydickens9283
    @wesleydickens9283 Год назад +2

    So you do wear your Methodist shirt irl.

    • @SGFCJax
      @SGFCJax Год назад

      HAHA! Yes! Nailed it.

  • @janejane6778
    @janejane6778 3 месяца назад

    I guess you all have no control over yourself if you had a picture or statute in front of you! Really this is absurd!!

  • @bobeddingfield6894
    @bobeddingfield6894 Год назад +3

    Calvinism is a great heresy.

  • @YodasTinyLightsaber
    @YodasTinyLightsaber 8 месяцев назад

    Here is something that could really bake your noodle if you think of it too long. Is theology a 1st/2nd commandment violation. I hear people all the time that quote John Calvin or John Wesley more than John the Apostle. I realize that this was a problem as early as the Pauline Epistles, but if we are going to get pedantic about things...

  • @janejane6778
    @janejane6778 3 месяца назад

    Did you all consider not defaming Catholics? Or you might think about the sin of gluttony too here!