Cormac Smith - Negotiations for Putin only Provide a Pause for him to Rearm and Attack Ukraine Again
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 июл 2024
- Cormac Smith has worked in Public Relations and Corporate Communications for over three decades. Before moving into the government sector in 2000 I spent most of the 1990’s managing media relations in the pharmaceutical industry. He has held several senior communication management positions in local government, and Whitehall departments, but in 2016 travelled to Ukraine to take up a special appointment as the ‘Strategic Communication Advisor’ to Pavlo Klimkin, then the Foreign Minister of Ukraine. He was attached to the British Embassy in Kyiv but was embedded in Ukraine’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the first foreigner to hold such a position. While in Kyiv, he also advised and provided training for five other government ministries and worked directly with three other cabinet ministers: Health, Education and the Deputy Prime Minister. In addition, he worked with The National Security and Defence Council of Ukraine and the NATO mission to the country.
----------
LINKS:
x.com/CormacS63
/ cormac-smith-848360162
defencebrink.uk/
DEBATE:
• Peter Hitchens and Cor...
----------
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL:
www.buymeacoffee.com/siliconc...
/ siliconcurtain
----------
TRUSTED CHARITIES ON THE GROUND:
kharpp - Reconstruction project supporting communities in Kharkiv and Przemyśl
kharpp.com/
Save Ukraine
www.saveukraineua.org/
Superhumans - Hospital for war traumas
superhumans.com/en/
UNBROKEN - Treatment. Prosthesis. Rehabilitation for Ukrainians in Ukraine
unbroken.org.ua/
Come Back Alive
savelife.in.ua/en/
Chefs For Ukraine - World Central Kitchen
wck.org/relief/activation-che...
Ukrainian Freedom News
www.ukrainianfreedomnews.com/...
UNITED24 - An initiative of President Zelenskyy
u24.gov.ua/
Serhiy Prytula Charity Foundation
prytulafoundation.org
NGO “Herojam Slava”
heroiamslava.org/
NOR DOG Animal Rescue
www.nor-dog.org/home/
----------
PLATFORMS:
Twitter: / curtainsilicon
Instagram: / siliconcurtain
Podcast: open.spotify.com/show/4thRZj6...
Linkedin: / finkjonathan
Patreon: / siliconcurtain
----------
Welcome to the Silicon Curtain podcast. Please like and subscribe if you like the content we produce. It will really help to increase the popularity of our content in RUclips’s algorithm. Our material is now being made available on popular podcasting platforms as well, such as Spotify and Apple Podcasts.
This is one of the best conversations about the war on Ukraine that I have listened to. I wish that I could listen for 10 more hours. This should be broadcasted on prime time TV all over the world. I struggle to grasp why this is so difficult to understand for many people, as well as media and politicians.
I feel the same should be posted everywhere 🙏🇦🇺👍🏼
yes. the reason it's not is a combo of several factors including some older folks, ironicaly especially conservative ones, who still see Ru as a superpower, even tho it's not even a third tier country overall now, and it's military is not particularly capable, per the mil experts in the West and many others. Ru is regarded as a paper tiger, and thus how we military face it and finally vanquish it, will determine how long the Ukr's infra and ppl get killed, tortured, (incl a LOT of torture , e.g. half of the big city of Kherson was tortured, bcuz those strong ppl....would...not...succumb! These are the strongest humans on earth, i attest! Let's demand our leaders support Ukr fully and prepare for whatever hyperaggressive behavior is done by Ru against us, ongoinginly!
Good points regarding the biden’s administration outright perfidy . Beyond disgusting when looked at sanely .
Absolutely!
I totally agree, more people need to hear this.
Cormac Smith here is the most powerful example of heroically contained righteous anger combined with ice-cold lucidity that I have ever seen. Applause , and respect.
I sensed that, too, but didn't know how to describe that aspect of his persona as eloquently as you did.
All people in the West need to listen to what this man said: "We need to see Russia through Ukrainian eyes". This is the only truth that matters today. Everything else is secondary. Thanks so much for this quality content. This channel should have millions of followers.
I am Polish and it pissies me off everytime I go abroad for vacation and waiter in a restaurant greets me with his basic russian language skills. Western Europeans never stopped looking at Eastern Europeans though Russia's eyes. They hardly cared about our agenda, safety and rights in all of this. It was always about Russia' agenda and "not poking russian bear". It was always about keeping your western comfort zone. It was always about whataboutism. What would USA did if....bla bla bla...Well, USA is a super power. Russia is not. Not anymore. And we are free people, we are not soviet backyard. We do not have to care about Putin's excues.
@@Blanka1100 I have similar experience, you speak the truth!
Any kind of ceasefire on putin’s terms will show him that he can continue doing whatever he wants unpunished. The international community should not back down now!
Sadly so many otherwise intelligent people are falling for orc BS.
MORE THAN ANYONE ELSE, MR. SMITH UNDERSTANDS!!!!👍
Very good interview. Pity these sort of discussions are absent on national tv.
Why would they be? It’s important to feed us all rubbish and keep us dumbed down so we don’t ask questions and rise up! We get “not” news like Brittany’s concerts etc or Glastonbury headliners. Makes me crazy. I go to Euro news , Al Jazeera or CNN to try and find out what is going on!
@@susiea1419 very good susie
It made me sick when the headline news in NZ a couple of weeks ago was Justin Timberlake was arrested for DUI. Meanwhile people are dying in this pointless war
Amazing guest and episode. Thank you Jonathan and Cormac.
Have you read Lev Parnas' book?
@@jannichi6431 I haven't
I've listened to many talks regarding Ukraine in the past two years, but this was by far the most eloquent, passionate and well delivered. Thank you and very well done.
👏👏
This mans words are like a breath of fresh air !! Bravo Cormac Smith 💝 You speak truths that those decision makers who should have expressed them a long time ago, should speak them now, loud and clear, for all to hear !! Ukraine should be given the respect and the weaponry it so rightly deserves. Slava Ukraine 💙💛
excellent!
Has Britain investigated all the Russian investments in London and the like?
I could listen to Cormac all day long. He hits every nail firmly on the head when it comes to Kremlin propaganda and the insatiable appetites of Putin and others despots around the world. Thank you for setting up this enthralling conversation, Jonathan.
And neither was Adolf … Learn your history America !
It shouldn’t require so much effort to not hate such a ridiculous ‘people’ …. This is at least the third time in a century that america was equanimous about the mass slaughter of east Europeans , especially Ukrainians ,
Chamberlain waving a piece of paper seems to come to my memory from history class…. Learn your history
Amazing work gentlemen. I wish the main stream media in Canada and usa would hear these reasons why we need to support Ukraine. People over here have NO idea !!
Cormac Smith, GREAT interview! He's right on all counts! As a student of Prof.Snyder's Yale class on Ukraine, I remember chillingly his Oct 29, 2022 lecture at Boston U - "The War in Ukraine and the Question of Genocide: Genocide is underway. If we don't see it, the failure is ours." I love all his work, but that one is etched in my memory. We can't turn away from Ukraine, and I'm angry about NATO and how slowly Ukraine receives weapons and every nonsense red line (that allows Putin to have sanctuary and dictate the rules of engagement.) From the very start of the invasion it angered me the way we in the West treated Ukraine, like they were beggars for aid, when in fact, WE OWE THEM (Budapest Mem) and we owe them so much more, for their intelligence and courage and amazing inventiveness. Ukraine has so much to teach us. They are a force for GOOD in a world that now lives in the shadow of Mordor. 💙💛
Parole sante !👏♥️
True that😖
Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦 🇩🇪
I really appreciate Cormac Smith’s insight and contribution to this podcast.
He us a mo day morning quarterback trying to pretend he is a prophet! What an ego to say things like this. He us not perfect and has no power to make anything happen. Just an old has been or wannabe
Dear Jonathan and Cormac, thank you both so much... 🙏💙💛
One of your best guests ever. Thank you, Jonathan. Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦
👍👍👍🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
It's never been about peace. It's always, about control, the fleeting hope of stability for a small man.
He is a paranoid little coward.
Right. We had peace! Germany connected 4 pipes of Russian natural gas - who would connect to an enemy, right before you plan to attack them?
It's also not about Nato. Nato have been in the Baltics for 2 decades - 150 km from Sct. Petersburg - with hardly any military hardware....
Thank you, Jonathan.
Keep up with your efforts battling corruption, Ukraine.
Warm support from Indonesia, the country with corroded corruption.
Amongst all the impressive speakers on this channel, Cormac has been the most impressive of them all. Spot on and impactful.
Finally someone who is intelligent and talks absolute sense. Shame you are not our PM!
Shame he isn't in Sullivan 's job.
Huge gratitude to Cormac Smith and Jonathan. Cannot agree more with Mr Smith . Appeasement management...💙💛👏👏👍✌️✌️♥️♥️♥️
Quote: "The APPEASER is the one who feeds crocodiles, hoping he'll be eaten last. (Winston Churchill)" That's going straight ino "my favourites"! Absolutely fantastic quote! :)
Great, moving touching interview. Thank you Jonnathan and Cormac. You make it very clear: the only way to end this war is Ukraini defeats Russia. Not US appeasement at all. Putin attacks the golden principle of a rule-based order: the international recognized border of a sovereign state must'nt be changed by the use of force. Slava Ukraini❤❤🇬🇧🇬🇧🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
👍👍👍
Very empathetic and in depth approach…
All so complicated and … so clear at the same time
Lack of leadership in the West;
Lack of …empathy and lack of political will…
How much more can those poor, innocent Ukrainian people take…,
Hey Jonathan thanks for the info you guys had a nice chat today with Jake bro your guest is one of the best you've ever had he is saying what so many of us have known from the start we should have honored The Budapest agreement an ejected Putin from Crimea so many would still be alive and not kidnapped and tortured total failure on the part of all our countries in the West Slava Ukraine
Absolutely. He’s definitely coming back on!
entirely agree! As Fiona Hill said in her interviews two years ago or later, this war signaled a catastrophic level failure in what we call international politics, including the efforts of the West. I've not since done deep reading, i.e. books, but hope to do so, to learn more about how military strategy and posturing works. I do sense that the U.S. withdrawing our mil ship from Black Sea, may have been a mistake, especially in conjunction w/ Biden's strangely worded (and overly elaborate/detailed) stmts in the months before the invasion (about what the U.S. would and wouldn't do--he specified it would depend on how big in invasion. But then the invasion WAS maximalist and yet no US mil involvement! So it's really strange the way Biden speaks etc-- he is a horrific speaker, tbph, and i'm a diehard suporter of him naturally, for obvious reasons (of US politics)
Fantastic conversation. Cormac is a superb communicator. 🇺🇦
Amazing stream !! Such an informed guy !!
Glad you think so!
Putin-Peace not to be used in 1 sentence
Probably the best discussion on the situation in Ukraine I have listened to up to this point 🇿🇦
The guests on your programme are always incredible people with a depth of knowledge that provides wisdom to all and I am certainly wiser for understanding Ukraine, Russia and US politics behaviours. As a Brit living in Australia now, today’s guest helped me to relate things to how the UK situation would be perceived that Ukraine are now in. This channel is without a doubt my best means with which to interpret the cowardly behaviour of the US and gives me some confidence in the EU leaders. But so much more immediacy in action is needed following sometimes the weak words of our leaders. I hope Ukraine is provided prompt appropriate behaviours and tools to restore this proud country to full democracy and a full member of NATO.
Words of the true gentleman!
Cormac was a great guest hope we see him again soon! Thanks Jonathan!
💛💙
👍👍👍
A truly enlightened man
THE SCOTUS AND THE COTUS DOES NOT COME WITH CLEAN HANDS EITHER. HOW DARE THE US EXPECT NON CORRUPTION IN OTHERS.
Exactly.
One of the best interviews I have seen
Please watch🙏❤
👍👍👍
Ukraine does not negotiate with terrorists.
Excellent Podcast! Thank you both. Slava Ukraine. 🦅
absolutely stunning guest ❤Thank you.
he said all the things I always thought but with his firsthand knowledge. Russia waged this war for two reasons: for money and for fear of democracy. If you are a tyrant and want to stay in power, you need money for your servants and no poor neighbor who gets rich in democracy by setting an example to your people.
Great interview. Infuriating. Thank you.
If Putin was serious about peace, he would never invade Ukraine in the first place
He is serious about bringing back the terror of the USSR
Thank you for the great informative interview ….., I hope we open our eyes soon to this selfish despot and his cronies
Cormac Smith speaks with experience and uncommonly good judgement. Thanks Johnathan for your excellent selections of outstanding guest speakers, expert questions and support for democracy over tyranny.
True words have been spoken.
❤❤❤❤❤
This conversation needs to be shown on all TV channels over and over again. It should also be shown to our royal family. Completely refund the BBC if they do not play ball.
The Ukrainians are like wolves, cunning, cautuious, and fiercely protective of their territory.
Cormac is a whirlwind! bring him back. “ALL IN Ukraine” 🇺🇦💙☀️🌾🌾🌾🌻
He's a west Brit
Ukraine should publish a monthly “Corruption Cleaned Up Scorecard” and a “Foreign Aid Transparency” matrix to make its accountability very visible and public.
The USA should, since we're withholding air support for opaque reasons.
As an American, I think we could use a little Ukrainian help dealing with corruption at the highest level of our judicial system.
🟥
Imagine a burglar still in your house saying, "let's negotiate about my noving into your basement". The very fact that the Putin regine cannot see the temerity of their offer just goes to show how dyed in the wool Russia is in criminality.
They believe in might is right. Morality is not important to them.
Trump to follow IF elected🌎🌍🌏
Can Cormac get himself sat down in front of anyone from our new government?
US would never for a second give sanctuary to any enemy behind their borders. And never has.
Because you don't realize that some enemies are from inside of USA.
Thanks Jonathan and his amazing guest cormac very interesting but very sad that our western governments don’t fully understand.
Cormac Smith is a fantastically knowledgeable guest. We need to hear more from him! Thank you for bringing him on to your show.
Thank you Jonathan, another great guest! Very informative.
Absolutely clear, precise no messing / hedging around the truth, when one hears it like it is, it makes so much sense. I wish politicians would learn from his school, the majority of them sit on the fence & when they finish we are never any wiser. Brilliant interview -- we need more of these simple truthful views, What a joy to listen to & so informative.
excellent guest and interview
Gr8 discussion guys ❤❤
Thank you Jonathon, nice to see the live today as well.
Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦
Thank you, Jonathan, for these smart, compassionate, kind, and humane guests.
Thank you, Jonathan and Cormac Smith, for this very insightful conversation. I hope, you will continue it in future.
🇺🇦 Перемоги та миру всім українцям! 🇺🇦
👍👍👍
This has been the most eloquent and informative commentary on the Ukraine war I have ever heard. Cormac’s words should be compulsory listening for every western politician, but especially those in America. We must support Ukraine to the hilt, or our children will have to deal with the consequences.
I was in Poland in 1991, Russia 1996 , Crimea 2000. And in Kiev last week....been there. Seen it.😊
Maybe Jake Sullivan should look around himself. A quick peek into the Supreme Court might give him some perspective.
He's a lawyer. He thinks in terms of mitigating risks. It doesn't work that well with dictators who are obsessed with ninth century history.
He would have feared the consequences of Nazi Germany collapsing, or the Soviet Union.
Thank you for your coverage and insights
🇪🇺🇺🇦🏴🇺🇦🏴🇺🇦🇬🇧
❤❤❤❤❤ 🇺🇦 🇺🇦 🇺🇦 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Excellent interview. Thank you 🙏
Great to hear somebody from my part of the UK doing such good work.
Jake Sullivan is ideologically obsolete.
Should speak at UN
Thanks guys 😁. It's great and interesting to hear youz talking about this. Keep IT Up 😊
Thanks for the update and views 🇺🇲🇺🇦
Oklahoma USA 🇺🇦🇺🇲
Thanks for the podcast
slava ukraini ! 🔱💙💛🌻😊✌
The best persuaders use examples that people can relate to. This is also what zielinski always does. This guest is expert at having you imagine what it would be like and pointing out how obvious the conclusion should be
Russia uses tanks. Russia loses tanks. Russia replaces those lost tanks with older, refurbished tanks and lesser-trained tank crews. Those older tanks aren't going to accomplish MORE than what the newer tanks managed.
If Ukraine simply plays a patient defense, then its battlefields turn it into Russia's Vietnam.
This war is far worse for Russia than Vietnam was for the United States. Russia is squandering everything they have trying to advance. By the time this is over, Russia will have no military and a destroyed economy.
Thank you very much for your program, your doing Verde just for you can and than for all europe and democratic world.
Mr Smith... I am impressed. Nothing more to say.
Thanks, for your job, for helping us, and especially for your point of view. Its very accurate.. unfortunately it's a real genocide, and we are facing with it again and again.. and i hope this time we will reach a justice, at least . Greetings from Ukraine 😢❤️
Russia is the last great European ethnic power trying to reassert its imperial ambitions and most Western leaders are for some reason slow to oppose this imperialism even when they reject it strongly within themselves, this foolishness is difficult to explain by logic.
This is such a brilliantly powerful discussion on what is happening and it should be shown on national TV and in educational establishments everywhere. Congratulations.
Really excellent discussion. That was some good straight talk about the dynamics between Ukraine, Russia, and the West. Top content! Great work, gentlemen!
Thanks!
Supporting Ukraine’s success is Western Europe’s best security!
Go Ukraine Go, May God be with them (all Ukrainians) in their fight for FREEDOM!
100% Agree
Great interviews
Peoples of the World, Should HEAR this Fellow !!!
Cormack is absolutely on the money about Western politicians not giving Ukraine agency. This has been the problem from the beginning.
Smith is simply excelent !!--henning olsen , Denmark
"Cowing" ducking and weaving, procrastinating, however we see the various countries, including 🇨🇦 my own, it's pathetic. Especially knowing the Ukranian people are trying everything they can to succeed.
Political cowardice.
A more apt analogy would be the USA invading and occupying 20% of Canada, with the US using nuclear weapons as a threat, Canada becoming the pawn.
Would that "world order" do anything, or treat us as pawns?
Russia could use a tactical weapon on us, and we're not a nuclear power just like Ukraine.
Are we pawns too? 🇨🇦😖
WOW, great broadcast
Great Podcast
One of the best yet sobering pieces on this conflict. Great work johnathan.
JAKE SULLIVAN HAS HIS DIRTY HANDS ON EVERYTHING!!
It's what happens when your office is closest to an ailing president.
Sullivan has been slight partisan for years.,🩸 Biden and NATO need Ukraine victory for many reasons. Democracy #1.
He's been a slight and coy partisan all his career🩸
Incredibly thoughtful and cogent discussion of the geopolitics regarding Russian criminal invasion. And the current status.
👍👍👍
Great insight by the guest, the Americans will most likely NEVER put their soldiers in the Bradleys , they could all go to Ukraine and save lives 🇬🇧🇺🇦🇺🇸
Great interview, but it is TOO PAINFUL to listen to it 😢 shame on us, the western world.
Often political game, to create themselves, at other peoples expense.
Weak support?
Considered to start a war?
Call xxxxx consultant...
...
Sad.
So, Ukraine was the California of the Soviet Union. I get it. The US depends on my state for much, the USSR depended on Ukraine. That fits if you consider just how inventive, creative, and productive Ukraine is during WAR TIME, imagine in peace time.... Go Ukraine! 🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦 As Timothy Snyder likes to say: Ukraine is exporting democracy. They are fighting so hard that they have excess democracy that they can export!
Mr. Smith is a very interesting guest, a great man and a great discussion, much appreciated. When you mentioned "escalation management" and he corrected you and said it was appeasement, I will mention to all readers in your defence Jonathon, that you also have called it this for a long time, ditto for myself too. Another thing that jumped out at me was Mr. Smith's mention of "s different form of communism under Tito", well in Yugoslavia at that time we could travel freely, own a small business and farms remained in private hands, there was no disastrous "Sovkhoz" or "Kolkhoz" collective farms. Keep in mind that Tito broke with Stalin and left he Soviet Bloc in 1948 successfully (unlike poor Czechoslovakia in 1968 and Hungary in 1956). And lastly, I don't think we are ever getting the F-16's. We were supposed to have them last new years, now mid year, this month. It's never gonna happen. Thank you Jake Sullivan and Samuel Charap (massive sarcasm). 😐
...if I may may!... U(k)raine! Pls! - correct the title - thank You. PS. As for the rest - 100% spot on.
Fixed! Thanks.
@@SiliconCurtain Oh!... Thank You! Have a nice day. :)
Slava Ukraine!
Great show.