M1 Mac mini , an absolute beast for audio and video production

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 авг 2024

Комментарии • 107

  • @MichelBarbaro
    @MichelBarbaro 2 года назад +13

    I`ve got a Mac Mini M1 16Gb RAM 512Gb, no regrets. It is faster than my i7 32Gb RAM. And I have no bluetooth issues. It is really a beast!

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +3

      Interesting you have no Bluetooth issues, that’s really the only problem I’ve had. But yeah, it gets the job done and then some!

    • @eprpop
      @eprpop 2 года назад +1

      You mean an i7 3rd gen, lol.

    • @MichelBarbaro
      @MichelBarbaro 2 года назад

      @@eprpop Yes, with 32Gb of RAM :)

    • @24thclassiccinema
      @24thclassiccinema 2 года назад +2

      I m going to buy the same . M1 Mac Mini 16GB Ram and 512 GB...... Is it comfortable for 4k and 6k footage ? plz conform. can I edit comfortably ?

    • @marcello4258
      @marcello4258 9 месяцев назад

      I7 from 2007? Downgrading from 32 to 16 seems kinda dumb

  • @bamber119
    @bamber119 2 года назад +8

    I've just done the exact same thing. My attitude is that if RUclipsrs can do video editing on a Mac mini for over a year then its not going to suddenly stop doing the job. The max bitrate I use is 100mb for film and I'm not making 500 track music neither. A Mac mini will do me nicely. 👍

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +3

      absolutely, you can't go wrong. One day I'll get a bigger machine like the mac studio, but I'm pretty happy right now.

    • @robtarius
      @robtarius 2 года назад +2

      just got a refurbished 16Gb RAM, 2TB SSD Mac Mini M1 from Hoxton Macs £1,000 + a dock for an nvme and sata ssd £80 and I already had keyboard, mouse and monitor. running Ableton Live 11 and loads of plugins and it’s running smooth and silently! Top stuff! (no issue with Bluetooth or wifi and I have two, neat, 4 USB extensions that are neatly tucked at the back of the machine, cool as)

  • @smoideen
    @smoideen 2 года назад +3

    one of the best down to earth Mac mini m1 impression videos. kudos 👍

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад

      Thank you! Several months later I’m still very happy with my purchase! Cheers!

  • @dean-marr
    @dean-marr Год назад +3

    I got a Mac m1 mini with ableton, 8gb 256, base, I only run 24 tracks like a tape machine, it's phenomenal 👌. Great video

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  Год назад +2

      It really is. I've had the odd issue, but only because I'm running nearly 40 tracks live looping now on Ableton which is a bit ridiculous, LOL. Cheers!

    • @martinmeije
      @martinmeije Год назад

      i got one too..the basic version. what audio interface is a good choice for this? i do everything inside of the box (all vsti's)

    • @directed6924
      @directed6924 3 месяца назад

      Nice mindset about 24 tracks. Don't forget some top studios used 2 tape machines, that will be 48 tracks.

    • @directed6924
      @directed6924 3 месяца назад

      @@martinmeije If you can afford RME Babyface Pro FS - go for it. If your budget is lower than that get SSL2.

  • @dannycampbell6223
    @dannycampbell6223 Год назад +3

    I record & produce music , I have just gone from an iMac to the M1 Mac mini 16g/1TB, I've paired it with an LG 34" curved monitor. I'm running Logic, I've had a couple of issues with 'some' plug-ins but I am over joyed with the upgrade. I have found the smoothness and stability great. TBH, I started with an 8 track Alesis ADAT and an Atari STE back in the day so can't complain.

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  Год назад +1

      Curved monitors are SWEET! Yeah, I think I had a couple of plug in issues when I first upgraded, but all is running smooth now. I started back in the day with a 4 track recording to cassette, so we've come a long way since then! LOL Cheers!

  • @jimrogers7425
    @jimrogers7425 2 года назад +2

    I recently got a 2013 'trash can' Mac Pro and am happy that I made the purchase... 8 core processor, 64 GB of RAM, 1 TB internal storage. I got an OWN Thunderbolt 2 drive bay for 2.5" drives and all is well. I wondered if I should have gone with the new M1 Mac Mini and decided against it, in spite of everything I've read because it's a known quantity! Great video!! Thanks, Dan!!

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      The Mac pros will always be beasts for sure! And you can never go wrong maxing out with RAM. I'm just kind of blown away by the fact that I can run audio and video projects with half the RAM that I had on the last system but with much better efficiency. Apple is almost shooting themselves in the foot by making their lower range products so good! Cheers!

  • @accentontheoff
    @accentontheoff 5 месяцев назад

    Greetings and thanks. Just checking if you feel the same way one year later about the 16 GB Mac Mini. Esp for music production.

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  5 месяцев назад

      Absolutely. I’m still rocking the same computer and have used it in several productions for client work. I have also tested the m1 air with the same configuration and it can run large Ableton live looping templates with ease. If you’re running very large projects with tonnes of vsts, you may want to consider something more powerful. But I haven’t run into any issues yet. I would still recommend it even though the m2 and m3 are out. Hope that helps!

    • @accentontheoff
      @accentontheoff 5 месяцев назад

      Fantastic, good to know, thanks!@@DanTremblayMusic

  • @victorschweitzer7778
    @victorschweitzer7778 2 года назад +2

    I bought the Mini with 16 gig and 500 SSD.
    I ended up returning it because the Studio came out and it was only a bit more.
    The Mac Studio without upgrades really was the best bang for the buck.

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      Yeah, I hear ya. If my last IMac wasn’t so old I would have waited too. You will not outgrow the studio any time soon!

    • @KyleMechlinski
      @KyleMechlinski 2 года назад

      except you can hear the fans

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      @@KyleMechlinski in comparison to my intel iMac and mbp I would say no, it is nearly completely silent, and certainly inaudible when recording and live-streaming.

    • @KyleMechlinski
      @KyleMechlinski 2 года назад

      @@DanTremblayMusic the new Mac studio

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      @@KyleMechlinski oooooo!! Really!! That’s too bad. Seems like a design flaw on apples part. Crazy! I guess to accommodate for the larger unit.

  • @michaelmanus7765
    @michaelmanus7765 2 года назад +1

    M1 Mini 512/16. Great to use but does have drawbacks. When I have a couple of tabs open in Safari, mail open, and items like this, my photo app suffers doing some typical tool work (Affinity Photo). I believe the hardware of the Mac is fine but the software remains suspect when it cannot set a ceiling for various apps or at least allow the end user to decide. I don't need gigs of memory used for 3-4 tabs in Safari as an example. When I have most apps closed, my photo app works smoothly and is quite amazing where processing power is concerned. As for Bluetooth, I have rare hiccups but am not overly concerned. I use a nice AX router and get speed as the M1 is down a hall in a different room than the router. Overall, save for RAM issue, a brilliant little machine.

  • @wil2k747
    @wil2k747 2 года назад +3

    i have the base model mac mini and I had to learn all the rest are for those needed the most it would be a waist to have what I don't need...

    • @dean-marr
      @dean-marr 2 года назад

      I have the same and using ableton and it is awesome

  • @amiller1758
    @amiller1758 2 года назад

    Hi Dan ! I'm soo glad I stumbled on your channel . I've been on the fence for a while , and I greatly wanted the " Sports Car " coming from my wind tunnel 2011 imac ( can't be upgraded any more ) Lot's of crashes ,slow downs, and performance issues. I won't even use certain programs, (Macshine) Native instruments , and various plug-ins because I know it's gonna cause a problem.... So you saying that it's a Honda Civic or Corolla hit home for me (Not to mention the "Sports Car is not in my budget ) But I'm getting the idea that this 16 gig Mac Mini will be so far ahead of what I've been using that it's Gonna be Great for years to come . And If things should change ,they'll be even better choices a year an a half from now. So Sorry to be so long winded , I rarely even comment on peoples post. But I'm about to proudly show off my New Civic / Corolla Thanks Be Well Cya Aaron

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      Thanks for your kind words! I appreciate it! The mac mini really is a sweet machine. If you want to be absolutely certain of buying a machine that is future proof, take a look at the new mbp. There is no going wrong with that machine, but it comes with the price tag to boot! If you keep your project sizes small, route your effects to auxiliary channels and stay efficient, the mini will get the job done. Cheers!

  • @PolluxChung
    @PolluxChung 2 года назад +2

    Mine has 16GB RAM as well. For the price, it's definitely the best-valued Mac.

  • @atashbeats8055
    @atashbeats8055 2 года назад

    Thanks for the tips, this really helps.

  • @jean-marclariviere7618
    @jean-marclariviere7618 11 месяцев назад

    Watched many on the Mac mini M2, just needed a final push...thanks...

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  11 месяцев назад

      M2 will be sweet guaranteed!

    • @jean-marclariviere7618
      @jean-marclariviere7618 11 месяцев назад

      @@DanTremblayMusic watched a lot of your Vids, left comments...or not but still, you are a great creator Sir...Bravo à toi...much talent...

  • @JamesBermingham
    @JamesBermingham Год назад +1

    Great honest review. I've been thinking Studio or Mini. Think il save my cash and go MINI :)

  • @koyaanisqatsi78
    @koyaanisqatsi78 2 года назад +1

    I bought a G4 in 1998 for audio production, swapped that out for a Mini I7 quad core in 2012, and well I'm still using that today, and for audio it's still fine.. for video it ain't though o now I'm thinking about upgrading to a new mini. I think that's pretty okay longevity wise.

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      The M1 is a beast. Take a hard look at the mac studio. The specs are crazy!

    • @koyaanisqatsi78
      @koyaanisqatsi78 2 года назад +1

      @@DanTremblayMusic hmm yes I know new thing! It'd be a 1,1k difference.. the Mini decked with 16 gig and 1TB, or the base model studio with 1TB it would be 2 cores more, triple the GPU cores and that has 32GB though. Certainly would be the more interesting one for handling video.
      But I love the form factor of the mini, as it's so convenient it slides under the monitor stand.. the studio wouldn't fit so I'd need to re-arrange & it's quite portable really, just throw it in the backpack and I have all my sessions with me. The studio does seem quite a more significant hunk of alu.
      Maybe see what fall brings? I'm in no hurry I can just still do what I want right now.. certainly audio wise.
      And I don't like the direction things have taken, in my mini I can still easily change the ram and hard drive, I've even recently popped in a new fan. All just a few minutes work. At this rate Apple wants us to buy a new machine every season, and I kinda want & used them for something that just works preferably 10+ years.

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      @@koyaanisqatsi78 no doubt. It’s hard to keep up with all of the new products. For now the mini serves my purposes well so I won’t be upgrading any time soon. The studio is more of a sports car, but maybe one day!

  • @jasonmeyermusic5639
    @jasonmeyermusic5639 8 месяцев назад

    Hi Dan, and thanx for your layed back video. Have you ever tried a M1 a Macbook AIr 16Go Ram.

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  8 месяцев назад +1

      I have an M1 MacBook Air 16gb for live use. I haven’t tried editing video on it, but it runs my Ableton live template smooth as silk. And also runs silently. Zero complaints.

    • @jasonmeyermusic5639
      @jasonmeyermusic5639 8 месяцев назад

      Thanx Dan@@DanTremblayMusic

  • @goobfilmcast4239
    @goobfilmcast4239 9 месяцев назад

    Nov 2023......I am not a content creator......I am however, on my 3rd year of use with my base M1 Mini and it still feels like my "new" computer. I am still not tempted to move to M3.....but let's see what's offered in the Mini form factor.

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  9 месяцев назад

      I’m still rocking my M1 and loving it. Ableton, Logic, Live-streaming, 4K editing in FCP. I’m sure it will eventually become outdated but so far so good.

  • @directed6924
    @directed6924 3 месяца назад

    Looking at Mac mini M2 Pro base model + Apple Cinema Display 30 inch or Thunderbolt Display 27 inch. Best price/performance setup right now.

  • @reggiedillard7731
    @reggiedillard7731 Год назад

    Very good video sir. Thank u👍🏾

  • @robertdufour2456
    @robertdufour2456 2 года назад

    This is a great help!

  • @rolandgerard6064
    @rolandgerard6064 2 года назад +4

    I agree, the mac mini 16GB / 1TB is great! More than enough for music production.

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад

      I think so too. Of course apple had to release the Mac studio right after I did this video! Lol! Thanks for watching, cheers!

    • @TrapBoiFuse561
      @TrapBoiFuse561 2 года назад

      M1 trash

  • @andreasfranzmann9634
    @andreasfranzmann9634 2 года назад

    Great video!
    May I ask about your experience with recording at low buffer sizes like 128? I am considering upgrading from my 2009 8-core Mac Pro and wondering how the M1 Mac mini is performing at low buffer sizes once you have a bunch of Plugins in the session.
    Thanks for your thoughts and the video! Best, Andy

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      Thanks for watching! I haven’t had any issues recording at 128. That being said, I keep my track counts relatively low. So I’m not running massive sessions on it. If you do run large sessions, you may want to look at the mac studio (though apparently fan noise is an issue) or the new mbp. Christian Henson had more than 400 separate instances of kontakt running on a new mbp pro without any issues. Craziness! I hope that helps! Cheers!

    • @andreasfranzmann9634
      @andreasfranzmann9634 2 года назад

      @@DanTremblayMusic Thanks for answering so quick! The MacMini should do it for me. I try to keep my track counts below 40-50 and mostly do audio or bounce/freeze vsts. Also using Reaper helps and with finally plugins taking advantage of the gpu on the way, the Macmini is the best for me. Thanks man!

    • @victoregea5311
      @victoregea5311 2 года назад

      watch this: ruclips.net/video/IoNk8NZzzQU/видео.html

  • @TheFandangovideoguy
    @TheFandangovideoguy Год назад

    hi there. I need help. I posted this elsewhere but this video is what i was looking for.I need an editing machine and my budget is limited. I could get a Mac Mini M1 with 16GB ram and 521SSD for a good price, but I wish I could afford a M2pro or a studio! for a lot more...
    I use Premiere pro. I intend to edit 4k30 and sometimes 4k60-one or two layers coming from a Sony FX30 in XAVC S at 200Mbps max or less...1080p 30/60 too. My projects range from 5min to 90 min max. No heavy grading at all..some lumetri colour. Am I delusional thinking that this Mac Mini M1 can edit this and export it in a reasonable time? I don't need it to be superfast for export but I care more about the editing experience. Has Premiere finally been optimized for the M1 chips? I just can't edit with FCPX...too old to re-learn! If someone could give me an honest and brutal opinion based on first hand experience I would appreciate it very much. Thanks

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  Год назад

      Boy, that’s a tough one. In my experience, apple’s native software always runs better than third party. So FCP runs very well as does logic. It’s possible this machine can do the job, but you may find it limited for your use. After reading tonnes of articles and watching countless reviews, I would maybe stay away from the Mac Studio. Too many users have reported fan noise which would drive me batty. Don’t get me wrong, the specs and performance are absolutely sick, but as an audio guy, I’m not willing to take the chance. I would look seriously at the mini m2 pro which looks very good. I think even if you upgrade to 32 gb ram it will still come in cheaper than the studio and do what you need it to do. I hope that helps!

    • @TheFandangovideoguy
      @TheFandangovideoguy Год назад

      @@DanTremblayMusic thanks man! I guess the only way to know is to hear from someone who uses premiere pro with the M1... I have watched a few videos...mostly from 1 year ago and Premiere was shaky...not there yet. I hope it's better now...The studio will cost me 2.5 times the price of the Mac mini...hmm..I'll keep researching. The M2pro looks promising...thanks

  • @24thclassiccinema
    @24thclassiccinema 2 года назад +1

    Hi Dan. M1 Mac Mini...... Is it comfortable for 4k and 6k footage ? plz conform. can I edit comfortably ?

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      I don’t usually edit my stuff in 4K. Generally shoot in 1080 and upscale to 4K. If you are editing with multiple camera angles, all in 4K or 6k, I would suggest the new mbp. If the projects are small and you are using only a couple of angles, no issues, export is a breeze. Because I a musician first, video is secondary for me, so the mini gets it done. If video production is your primary focus, I would def look at the M2 Mac Pro.

    • @24thclassiccinema
      @24thclassiccinema 2 года назад

      Thank you so much Mr.Dan to Help me.

  • @ankursahu5193
    @ankursahu5193 10 месяцев назад

    Nobody would believe but my lenovo slim 3 laptop ryzen 7 5700u ..8 gb ram ..is running 50 tracks on ableton including plugins 😅😅😅

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  10 месяцев назад

      Awesome! If it ain’t broke, don’t try to fix it. We all get caught up in the upgrade game sometimes, but no reason to if your setup does what you need.

  • @christopherhoare9509
    @christopherhoare9509 Год назад

    Never had a problem with Bluetooth on any of my Macs. And I’ve never known anyone who’s had a problem either.

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  Год назад

      Mostly just with lagging keyboard. But the lightning cable solved it. 🙂

  • @slav5417
    @slav5417 2 года назад

    Hi, do you use apple keyboard and mouse? or a different brand?

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад

      I used my old apple mouse which has been working fine. I sold my previous apple keyboard when I upgraded and picked up a new apple keyboard with a number pad. But there were constant Bluetooth issues with the keyboard so I use it with a lightning cable now.

  • @perrykeshahwalker5321
    @perrykeshahwalker5321 2 года назад

    I got the m1 mac mini and my transition hasn't been as smooth. Yes it is fast but I have had issues with Studio One V5. It loads my programs fast and web browsing is great. However I have had clicks and pops with small sessions (20 tracks or less ) running with medium amount of plugins and when I do basic video rendering in studio one it is slower than my Dell i7 4790 setup. As a matter of fact my Dell is faster than the m1 rendering my mix downs which is very confusing to me. I decided to go apple for the first time and so far it has been challenging. I believe Apple is on the right track but my experience with the Apple silicon has been rocky thus far. Still trying to figure out why.

    • @martymarl4602
      @martymarl4602 2 года назад

      is the Studio One V5 optimized for M1? if not, will it be in the future? It really is that simple...sounds like it's not

    • @rbmmb5009
      @rbmmb5009 2 года назад

      That's weird, I've been using Studio One V5 for almost 2 years now on the 2020 8 GB M1 Macbook Air, no video editing only music production, and it's working like a charm, mixdown rendering is super fast and it can handle 20/30-track projects with lots of plugins pretty well! (averages at 30/40% RAM usage at most, only seen it go up to 70% and above maybe 8 times)
      Although I did experience issues with 3rd party plugins, I think it's mostly due to the Rosetta thing/the plugins not being M1 native yet, so we're bound to see improvements soon! I remember Oct 2020, firing up Studio One on the macbook for the first time and 3/4 of my plugins taking their sweet time loading up or just crashing lol, but then over the months 90% of them got their M1 update and it's been a sweet ride.
      I switched over from a then 4-year old 16 GB Gaming Lenovo PC, and I'd say comparatively the 8 GB Macbook Air wins by a good margin. Only problems I still experience from time to time are USB/MIDI devices bugs (unplugging/plugging back in makes it work again) AND very frequently the piano roll just decides to glitch out of this galaxy (copy/pasting it, deleting the original and using the pasted one solves it).
      Try contacting PreSonus/Apple customer service, there might be some other issue!

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  11 месяцев назад

      Did you ever get this issue resolved?

    • @perrykeshahwalker5321
      @perrykeshahwalker5321 11 месяцев назад

      @@DanTremblayMusic yes to some point however I plan to go back to a Windows machine this September because I'm just used to Windows and I've never really had an issue with it I just wanted to try Mac and I did and it was great but I have to go back to Windows

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  11 месяцев назад

      @@perrykeshahwalker5321 glad you found a solution! Yeah, for sure there are always issues. Like for one, I always hold my breath every time there is an OS update that all my plugins are going to work. Lol. Anyway, happy mixing! Cheers!

  • @rajb3388
    @rajb3388 2 года назад

    I am thinking to go for a mini now.Should i go for the mini 16/500 or wait for the me version of same for music production.thanks

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад

      I think I’d probably wait at this point in time and see what’s going to be announced in the Fall. I still love my mini.

    • @rajb3388
      @rajb3388 2 года назад

      @@DanTremblayMusic I think it will go well for semi-professional music production,right?

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      @@rajb3388 absolutely. But you may want to hold off to see what apple announces in the next two months just in case.

    • @rajb3388
      @rajb3388 2 года назад

      @@DanTremblayMusic thanks man.Also, I think we should expect a price difference between the two chips rit

  • @CS-we8rv
    @CS-we8rv 2 года назад

    Has Bluetooth issue fixed now..?
    Thank you for this video..❤️

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +1

      Haven’t re-tested it to be honest. The mouse is fine, it’s the keyboard that I had all kinds of lagging issues with. I just have it connected with a lightning cable.

    • @CS-we8rv
      @CS-we8rv 2 года назад

      @@DanTremblayMusic Okay.. Thanks a lot Man..🙏

  • @bosssales9448
    @bosssales9448 2 года назад

    bro all vsts working ?? people are moving back to intel

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +3

      I’m running everything in Rosetta in logic, no issues whatsoever.

    • @bosssales9448
      @bosssales9448 2 года назад

      bro tell the truth ,,,,

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад +3

      @@bosssales9448 bro, all is working in Rosetta mode in logic. If you want more power, look at the mac studio or new mbp. Going back to intel would be redundant.

    • @perrykeshahwalker5321
      @perrykeshahwalker5321 2 года назад

      I got the m1 mac mini and my transition hasn't been as smooth. Yes it is fast but I have had issues with Studio One V5. It loads my programs fast and web browsing is great. However I have had clicks and pops with small sessions (20 tracks or less ) running with medium amount of plugins and when I do basic video rendering in studio one it is slower than my Dell i7 4790 setup. As a matter of fact my Dell is faster than the m1 rendering my mix downs which is very confusing to me. I decided to go apple for the first time and so far it has been challenging. I believe Apple is on the right track but my experience with the Apple silicon has been rocky thus far. Still trying to figure out why.

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  2 года назад

      @@perrykeshahwalker5321 that is a bummer for sure. I think the key thing with apple products is to dive deep into their ecosystem. Running native software is pretty much guaranteed to run better than non apple software. Pops and clicks are usually an indication of needing a higher buffer size, not sure if you tried that already. But you shouldn’t be hearing those with a count of only 20 tracks. Hope that helps!

  • @satyamchoudhary396
    @satyamchoudhary396 Год назад +1

    I need a mac for my music production in Logic, 🥲

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  Год назад +1

      This is the one to get, no need to buy more expensive models.

    • @NitroGamingPro17
      @NitroGamingPro17 Год назад

      Would you recommend the 8GB ? Best Buy only has that one

    • @DanTremblayMusic
      @DanTremblayMusic  Год назад

      @@NitroGamingPro17 def go 16 gb. 8 is going to be pretty limiting.