The Cyrrilic alphabet was created in the Preslav literary school by Kliment of Ohrid, not in Thessaloniki. I think you confused it with the Glagolic alphabet that was made by Cyrril and Methodius in Thessaloniki.
@@rewriting-history you didn't explain it in the video, but if Yugoslavia captured Constantinople and renamed it to Trasigrad then how and why would they return in to the Ottomans after the war? You didn't explain that in the video.
Ehh personally I do not think that Bulgaria really wanted to form a South Slavic Empire, Bulgaria instead wanted territories like north Macedonia, Tsargrad and some other, But the possibility exists if we instead had a Bulgarian man kill the Austro Hungarian leader it might work out, personally I believe it will still be impossible for Bulgaria to just try and form pan slavic empire, for example maybe we could had had an too ambitious Serbia declaring war on Bulgaria and Greece where eventually Serbia looses after Romania too joins on the Bulgarian side, it will eventually set foot for Bulgaria to gain some more territories which could most likely cause the idea for a pan slavic state to rise up even more
@@pro_master2486 maybe but that depends if the leader wants to do it ,- the history It is not a simple science with formulas and the like - it depends on many things (not that mathematics is simple but I have exact formulas)
@@Chefo_311 Well there are a few cases in who might take rule, first on is the German Prince Ferdinand I of Bulgaria, another possibility is of course the Romanian king but of course the interests of Romania and Bulgaria were different so that did not succeed, the only way this could actually happen is really just Serbian King taking rule in Bulgaria which like again not the same interests. The only one who would make sense to rule is the German Prince or Ferdinand I of Bulgaria which would make Yugoslavia formed by Bulgaria again impossible due to interests
Well, from the Slavic accent, the text on Discord, and the goofy anger from Treaty of Berlin, I think it might be safe to say this guy is Bulgarian, which is quite a W in my opinion
I can say that this video is an improvement because you can go into as much detail as your past videos and still have a lot of time to continue the scenario. Keep it up 👍
@@rewriting-history it's a really nice change of pace from various other scenarios i've seen, most of those end with the country they focus on either dominating the world or disappearing in the first few minutes of the video. This is a nice midpoint!
Great video, my friend! Idk if this was a question, but I bet the Kaiser would stay in charge, maybe Wilhelm II might be replace with his oldest son. Once again, great video!
This is great, and yeah a part two would be cool, like we have to see what happens to turkey? Who gets Constantinople? And arabia? Like if Russia gets western Armenia then that just changes the borders of everything there as the uk would still not want a border, so much to discuss, this is why I love alt history channels like yours sir, have a good one haha
firstly bulgaria and serbia hated each other because of the second balkan wars and the first world war, secondly because the soviet union had worsened its relationships with yougoslavia after the late 1940s and bulgaria played along the soviet union
@@pizza8725 Nah, the UK only used Belgium as an excuse. It would have delayed their intervention, but not prevented it. Beside, the French-German border was heavily fortified, as soon as France would have been forced on the defensive, they would have stalled the German long enough for the UK to intervene.
What if Charlemagne only had 2 sons not 3 so the empire would be split evenly Also what if Napoleon also sold Haiti to the USA with Louisiana like what if he knew of the revolt in advance and did something similar to what happened with Corsica right before he was born
Maybe it's just me but I think Romania would still put more priority on claiming Transylvania than in pursuing a vengeance war on Yugoslavia. Transylvania was and still is today the jewel in the crown of any Romanian nationalist and I can't see them pass it up here. landlocked or not.
probably germany wouldnt be punished so hard, they would be the country whith the firts proposal of peace, seeing that their allies were terrible, and a stagnation in the french front. So i think that to not upset the balance of power another time, and with the acquisition of galicia by russia, Germany should have the sudetenland, so they wont be mad for lossing alssas lorraine. And i think the area should be partitioned with austria, so that they dont get so weak. I would suggest to give the yugoslavian lands of slovenia to austria, because there were some germans there, but thats a suggestion. And if you do a part 2, make the funny moustache man communist. Thats all, i liked the scenario, really good
You’d be surprised how there was a possibility for Bulgaria durning the Cold War joining Yugoslavia, personally I kinda wonder how would Yugoslavia survive in modern day if it does, I wonder what if that happened and the South Slavs were completely United. In the modern day the idea of Yugoslavia would never exist due to the so diverse ethnics in that the South Slavs possess,
I think it would be better for all Serbia woud give 2 communities whit Bulgarian majority to Bulgaria, Macedonia woud be like Montenegro and Serbia 2 countries/republics with same people a bit different dialect but same language (another example Austriaand Germany). I think also Macedonia would take and extend Serbian Cyrillic (they have done it but for soft c and d they created a distinct letters). Bulgaria would take the same letters (same language same alphabet) so it would not have ja jo ju like in Russian so more phonetic and easier to write. Macedonians would feel safe from both Serbian and Bulgarian pressure, since we know that they were not pressured in 2nd Yugoslavia
@@aurelije well I'm not entirely sure about that because before 1878 the Southern part of the Morava river was also called Bulgarian morava because it was with a predominantly Bulgarian population. I'd say that would be included in this Yugoslavia in order to keep the Bulgarians happy (I'd say I'd be a dual monarchy like Austria-Hungary with the same monarch but different governments but a united foreign policy). This would assure Bulgarian loyalty to the Serbs. Then in the Balkan wars the whole of Macedonia and Thrace till the Midiya-Enos line would be annexed into Bulgaria because of their predominant Bulgarian population. Everything else without Albania would join Serbia and I'd even say as in the video Montenegro would join this Yugoslav state as a part of Serbia (they were Serbian after all). Then with WW1 Croatia would probably join the Serbian part as well, but Slovenia would be a third state due to their different language. As you said this transformation from "ю" "я" to "jу" "jа" could occur, however, somewhere I remember reading that the Serbian language was intentionally changed to be closer to Croatian and Slovenian languages, which because of Austria-Hungary were changed to have the Latin alphabet, to be closer for a potential Yugoslav unification. Before the Serbian changes it included slavic letters like я, ю, ъ, ѫ, ѧ, ѣ and didn't use the Latin alphabet at all. These letters also existed in the Bulgarian language prior to their independence. If the leaders play their cards right and give autonomy to Serbs from Vojvodina, Bosnia and Croatia, Croats from Bosnia and Croatia and Slovenes they might be able to keep this larger Yugoslavia without ot collapsing. My point is they could federalise and have the borders follow ethnic lines between the slavs which can keep their languages and alphabets intact.
What if kilkenny stayed the capital of Ireland and the English didn’t annex all of Ireland after the Viking invasions plz make a sceanario on this as I’m Irish and your one of my top three favourite RUclipsrs
Very interesting and part 2 would be nice. Just a personal preference, but konigsberg owned by russia doesn’t make a lot of sense. Other than that, great vid!
Haha I'm working towards getting to 10K, come back in a couple of months and I'll probably get there! For maps I use paint. net, it's free and quite good, does the job very well!
I don't think the Russian Revolution could not happen because it was inevitable since the russo-japanese war. Apart from this I liked this scenario. I would see a part 2.
I agree with you. What I meant is that it wouldn't maybe happen during the war, since Russia wasn't performing that bad. In part 2 they would maybe collapse.
I highly dought that germany in the peace treaty would be divided like that. Either they get completely carved up and spit into different states(the US wanted to keep germany whole while the other powers wanted to carve them up) or the polish majority/minority areas in the empire whould be given to russia.
4 Suggestions have the Community vote on them 1 What if Maximillian Remained Emperor of Mexico 2 What if Franz Ferdinand and Franz Joseph died on an earthquake in 1908 3 What if Bulgaria won the 2nd Balkan war and serbia became an austrian protectorate 4 What of the weird fiasco peace thing went through and germany invades austria-hungary
This is a stretch. Historically speaking the region of Yugoslavia has no major resources to support a full scale war, nor does this region have the population to withstand a full scale invasion on 3 fronts all from countries with greater resources, population, and military capacity. To add to this the Slavic people of this region historically could not come together and is y they’ve been in nearly constant war with each other. Not the best or most realistic outcome. They’d likely be steam rolled, occupied and broken up into separate nations. Then you just have normal WW1 situations after.
Perhaps you're right, but if I was 100% historically accurate, they would get destroyed and divided after. So nothing would change, they would exist for a bit, but in the end, the borders would be the same. This would make for a really boring video!
In 1916 you would get kaiser Karl who tried to ge tpewce OTL in 1916.with the war going even worse in this timeline it's likely he successfully gets out the war in 1916 in this timeline (historically it failed because he refused to give up South tirol, but with the war going even worse he would be more willibg to compromise)
If Yugoslavia is formed before WW1, probably it won't be there WW1 because there was Sarajevo assissination of Austro-hungarian archduke Franz Ferdinand that started war because, Sarajevo is not in Austria-Hungary then.
@@rewriting-history да Българин съм. Продължавай все така- много добро видео- гледах само това сега не мога още че ще спя че искам поне 7 часа сън.❤️❤️❤️
this is one of my favorite channels but I think the peace treaty is just a bit harsh on Germany I don't think that is very realistic because Germany even though they did surrender they didn't lose any land in fact they obliterated Russia and Belgium I think it makes sense for Germany to lose maybe half of Alsace Lorraine but that is really harsh but especially losing Koenigsberg would be an absolute no because the royal family of Germany is mainly Prussian.
Yeah I'm very well aware of your claims. In the end of the day, I wanted to make the video a bit more interesting, so a possible war could start in part 2! I was just setting up something
What if Bismark after Austro-prussian war annexed Austria and to Hungary gave independence and to South Slavs possibility of unification with Serbia and Montenegro and probably Bulgaria
Question : What happened to the german colonies? would they all be divided just like in our timeline, or since the war is shorter germany was allowed to keep most of it?
Tanzania they would lose for sure, most likely they also lose Namibia. I think they will keep Cameron and Togo. As in the Pacific, maybe they will lose everything to Japan
People always forget (or do not know) that the masterminds behind the ideology of pan-slavism and yugoslavism were in fact the Croats. The Yugoslavian ideology and idea was something that has been circulating and developing among Croatian intellectual elites and church officials since the early 16th century. The father of pan-slavism is a Croatian priest - Juraj Krizanic, while a series of his successors developed the Yugoslav idea. Even the idea of Yugoslavia among the Croatian elites changed a few times. Pavao Vitezovic for instance developed a pan-Croatian idea in which all southern slavs would unite under Croatian cultural and political leadership and strive for independence and unity. But, the point is, the creation of Yugoslavia came far too late. The strong national conciousness has already been developed in all south-slavic people by 1918, and the geopolitical, cultural, social and other interests of for example Croats and Serbs were absolutely, diametrically opposed. Yugoslavia MAYBE would have had a chance of survival if it was formed in 1818, and not 1918.
@@rewriting-historyAs a Serbian, I personally believe the Serbian Alphabet would be adopted across Serbo-Bulgaria because the modern Serbian Alphabet was perfected by Vuk Karadžić Zmaj as a way to simplify the Serbian Alphabet and remove a lot of unnecessary letters, symbols and expunge Russian influence from Serbian Academia brought by Russian Scholars, which only made it even harder to study an understand. The Alphabet was designed to be easy to learn, write and for everyone, it was meant to resemble the way common people talked, rather than the elite. So, an alphabet that is easy to learn and understand for an average person would be incredibly useful to culturally and linguistically similar, but still widely diverse inhabitants of Serbo-Bulgaria as the nation develops and Education becomes available to a larger number of people. Though, perhaps Vuk would work with Bulgarian Linguists and Scholars to make the new Alphabet truly Pan-South Slavic, rather than focusing just on Serbo-Croatian Language.
What if indians won the first war of Indian independence and led to a United India?? A unified India in 1857 is a topic that is barely discussed. Maybe include Burma and ceylone too.
It's an interesting idea, but I don't see anything happening with this scenario. No massive war would be altered, which would arguably create for a boring video. I will think about it
How does Bulgaria not reach Solun (Thessaloniki) in time when its literally a couple of kilometers away and also isn't Skopje already in the new nation during the first Balkan war
As a Serb i would like to Defend our Actions in 1 Balkan War . You didn't mention that Serbia would have given large portion of Macedonia to Bulgaria if Austria and Italy didn't pressure Serbia into giving up whole Albania + Austria Annexed Bosnia which was de facto under Ottoman Control which Serbia would give up Whole Macedonia for Bosnia . But Austrian and Italian imperialism and manipulation broke Relations between 2 brotherly nations . Conference of Yougoslavs (hidden in Austria-Hungary) was made up from Slovens Croats Muslim Bosnians and Serbs ) Serbs from There before 2nd Balkan War wanted to include Bulgaria in Yougoslavia and supported for bulgaria to go all the way to Constantinople . When Austria was demanding for Serbia to reatreat from Albania they first asked Bulgaria for help which they said (were to busy) so they gave up on Albania so they could Spare Whole Balkan from fighting another War against Big Power .
Russia most likely would annex possen(to form a polish kingdom in empire), armenian land in ottomans empire. I dont belive thay would annex Kaliningrad in this timeline.
I was debating if I should include it or not. It's very important as you said, so I think that Russia or the UK will want it more, taking it away from Yugoslavia!
That is true, but it was offered to Russia in our timeline to keep them in the war, without anyone takeing it from the ottomans, so my thought was simply: Would Yugoslavia give it up freely and would the other great powers go to war over it, as you said UK and France was more conserned about Russia not getting too powerfull and therefore kept the Ottomans alive, with the Ottomans gone they needed another counter balance against Russia Yugoslavia could fill that role, and Russia might accept since it was another slavic mostly Orthodox power, I don't think it's unrealistic. Great video btw thx for making it@@rewriting-history
*"Yo RH* 👋👋 Can we see a video on what happens if italy colonized ethiopia And post italian Colonialism I left a detailed Description in the previous video 👍👍
@@rewriting-history Left it in the previous Manchu China Video But I left a copy down here 👇 @rewriting-history yh I wanna see how The horn of Africa looks post italian Colonialism Pretty sure each Major Ethnic group gets their own Country Would definitely like to see a balkanize video on a Horn of Africa Country/YugoSlavia style government We could see Horn of Africa stay unified post Italian Colonialism but end up becoming Socialist Basically becoming the richest African state post - colonialism And joining Tito in the non-Aligned They probably have a Amhara or somali dictator who comes from half muslim half Christian mixed background then eventually past the 1990s the state collapses into ethnic And religious violence And eventually 5 main states secede from the state and officially dissolve the Horn of African union -Afaria -Oromia -Somalia -Amharia -tigrania Each state goes their separate ways
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
The Cyrrilic alphabet was created in the Preslav literary school by Kliment of Ohrid, not in Thessaloniki. I think you confused it with the Glagolic alphabet that was made by Cyrril and Methodius in Thessaloniki.
Ah yes, my bad!
@@rewriting-history и аз поняка забравям тази част...
@@42carlosизобщо ми изкопи от ума този факт. Просто си пиша скрипта и хич не се замислих 😂
If your a christian. you need to repent of your sins PLZ
@@rewriting-history you didn't explain it in the video, but if Yugoslavia captured Constantinople and renamed it to Trasigrad then how and why would they return in to the Ottomans after the war? You didn't explain that in the video.
What if bulgaria is the one that formed yugoslavia and not serbia
Great idea! I love it!
From the beginning if the video i wanted that 😢😮😅😊❤😂🎉
Ehh personally I do not think that Bulgaria really wanted to form a South Slavic Empire, Bulgaria instead wanted territories like north Macedonia, Tsargrad and some other, But the possibility exists if we instead had a Bulgarian man kill the Austro Hungarian leader it might work out, personally I believe it will still be impossible for Bulgaria to just try and form pan slavic empire, for example maybe we could had had an too ambitious Serbia declaring war on Bulgaria and Greece where eventually Serbia looses after Romania too joins on the Bulgarian side, it will eventually set foot for Bulgaria to gain some more territories which could most likely cause the idea for a pan slavic state to rise up even more
@@pro_master2486 maybe but that depends if the leader wants to do it ,- the history It is not a simple science with formulas and the like - it depends on many things (not that mathematics is simple but I have exact formulas)
@@Chefo_311 Well there are a few cases in who might take rule, first on is the German Prince Ferdinand I of Bulgaria, another possibility is of course the Romanian king but of course the interests of Romania and Bulgaria were different so that did not succeed, the only way this could actually happen is really just Serbian King taking rule in Bulgaria which like again not the same interests. The only one who would make sense to rule is the German Prince or Ferdinand I of Bulgaria which would make Yugoslavia formed by Bulgaria again impossible due to interests
Well, from the Slavic accent, the text on Discord, and the goofy anger from Treaty of Berlin, I think it might be safe to say this guy is Bulgarian, which is quite a W in my opinion
I'm 1000% bulgarian, you're right!
@@rewriting-history Nice! You must be pretty happy about Possible History’s Perfect Bulgaria then huh?
@@Sr.Originality100 oh damn this video was ages ago! Yeah I liked it, it was fairly fun, although I would add a lot more to it!
@@rewriting-history If I had the ability to properly make art and edit videos, I also would have multiple ideas, too!
@@rewriting-history cool love bulgaria but its kinda they both backstabed serbia not giving land bulgaria attacking while in alance whit them
2:14 literally every Bulgarian
Absolutely lol!
What is the translation in english, if you know?
me being bulgarian and laughing my a** off
The amount of detail you put into a realistic way for this to happen is astounding!!
Thank you! I hope you liked the video!
I can say that this video is an improvement because you can go into as much detail as your past videos and still have a lot of time to continue the scenario. Keep it up 👍
I appreciate that! Thank you very much and I'm glad you liked the video!
YOOOO ITER
0:46 nice that you talked to them in their native language, I also do that for people who don't speak English. (Thanks Google Translate)
It's not their native language, it's also mine too!
@@rewriting-history oh wow that's cool!
@@MakriaMicronationhe is Bulgarian
Радвам се че все още има хора в България, които се интерсуват от световната модерна история! Много добра работа.
An interesting idea for a future video is if the Chinese colonized California during the Ming Dynasty.
Nice! I will look into it and consider it!
We definitely want a part 2!
Damn I'm very surprised to find that people really love this scenario!
@@rewriting-history it's a really nice change of pace from various other scenarios i've seen, most of those end with the country they focus on either dominating the world or disappearing in the first few minutes of the video. This is a nice midpoint!
@@rewriting-history as a half serb half bulgarian,i would see part 2 as an absolute win
I keep asking
Suggestion: What if Franz Jospeh I died in an accident and his son Rudolf succeeded him at 20?
I believe that somebody else already made a video about this, but I'm not sure!
Great video, my friend! Idk if this was a question, but I bet the Kaiser would stay in charge, maybe Wilhelm II might be replace with his oldest son. Once again, great video!
Thank you very much! I do agree with you!
Yugoslavia now dominates every single international competition
Bulgaria wouldn't contribute much to that nowadays, but the football world cup in 1994 could be won by this Yugoslavia
This is great, and yeah a part two would be cool, like we have to see what happens to turkey? Who gets Constantinople? And arabia? Like if Russia gets western Armenia then that just changes the borders of everything there as the uk would still not want a border, so much to discuss, this is why I love alt history channels like yours sir, have a good one haha
Thank you very much and I'm glad you liked it! Part 2 will be very interesting for sure!
glad to have come early enough to join the stream it was fun
Glad to have you there! Hope you had fun there!
love how basically everything in your video fits the narative
Well that's what I'm trying to achieve! Thanks!
Yes make part two!
It's right around the corner!
Nice video! I like the idea of a Bulgarian Yugoslavia !
I will also do a video about what if Bulgaria formed Yugoslavia
Can’t Wait To See It!
Добро видео! Доста убедително като за alternate history
Благодаря много, оценявам го!
If Yugoslavia,Albania,Bulgaria,Greece,Romania and Turkiye united into one single federation during Cold Wars
This video just by the thumbnail is already amazing
Thank you very much! It took me sometime to figure it out!
this is certainly an interesting scenario, I had always wondered why Bulgaria didn't join Yugoslavia
Now you know! Hope you learned something new and interesting!
firstly bulgaria and serbia hated each other because of the second balkan wars and the first world war, secondly because the soviet union had worsened its relationships with yougoslavia after the late 1940s and bulgaria played along the soviet union
thanks@@MPF5856
Yeah, there's just been too much bad blood and diplomatic separation between these two. Before and after WW1.
This needs a part 2
nice video, keep up the great work!
Thank you very much! I absolutely appreciate that! Very kind words
yay new video
Hope you liked it!
Nice video, always interesting to learn about Baltic history. Love from USA
Thank you! Love from Bulgaria!
BALTIC HISTORY🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰😰🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🙃💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
i like this, part 2 hopefully
I'm glad you liked it, appreciate the support! Part 2 inc.
@@rewriting-history wooo thank u :)
love ur vids!
Excellent video. Part 2 please. 😎👍
Coming soon! Thank you very much for the support!
@@rewriting-history No problem. Peace ✌🏻
rewriting history thank you for winning the game for me!
Any time! I appreciate the kind comment!
What if Germany never invaded Belgium in WW1?
Thank you for the suggestion! I saved it for later!
Than posible Germany could of won the war bc there would be no UK in the war
@@pizza8725 Nah, the UK only used Belgium as an excuse. It would have delayed their intervention, but not prevented it. Beside, the French-German border was heavily fortified, as soon as France would have been forced on the defensive, they would have stalled the German long enough for the UK to intervene.
What if Charlemagne only had 2 sons not 3 so the empire would be split evenly
Also what if Napoleon also sold Haiti to the USA with Louisiana like what if he knew of the revolt in advance and did something similar to what happened with Corsica right before he was born
Great ideas! I love them and save them for later!
It's been one year
Maybe it's just me but I think Romania would still put more priority on claiming Transylvania than in pursuing a vengeance war on Yugoslavia. Transylvania was and still is today the jewel in the crown of any Romanian nationalist and I can't see them pass it up here. landlocked or not.
I need a second part. Now I am curious about ww2!
Will do something interesting with that! Thank you for watching up until the end, I hope you enjoyed the video!
probably germany wouldnt be punished so hard, they would be the country whith the firts proposal of peace, seeing that their allies were terrible, and a stagnation in the french front. So i think that to not upset the balance of power another time, and with the acquisition of galicia by russia, Germany should have the sudetenland, so they wont be mad for lossing alssas lorraine. And i think the area should be partitioned with austria, so that they dont get so weak.
I would suggest to give the yugoslavian lands of slovenia to austria, because there were some germans there, but thats a suggestion.
And if you do a part 2, make the funny moustache man communist.
Thats all, i liked the scenario, really good
Good suggestions and I especially love the funny moustache man communist idea. Will for sure save it!
Comment for algorithm, because you asked us to make one
Yes! Thank you very much for that!
You should make a video in if Bulgaria and Romania United into one country 🇷🇴💪🇧🇬
Check out my first video, which is also mentioned in the end of this video! There I united Bulgaria and Romania!
hello begula
We need a part 2
I'm glad you guys like it! I will consider part 2 soon!
11:12 romania just casually annexed bukovina without anyone noticing
i would love a 2nd part
I would love to make it for you!
Дори и да съм от българите против Югославия, много ми хареса видеото и бих искал да видя втора част!
Благодаря и много го оценявам! Видеото изглежда се движи добре, ще направя втора част в бъдеще!
You’d be surprised how there was a possibility for Bulgaria durning the Cold War joining Yugoslavia, personally I kinda wonder how would Yugoslavia survive in modern day if it does, I wonder what if that happened and the South Slavs were completely United. In the modern day the idea of Yugoslavia would never exist due to the so diverse ethnics in that the South Slavs possess,
@@pro_master2486 and also after WW2 Bulgaria could have given Yugoslavia a small part of southwestern Bulgaria through the Bleed Agreement.
I think it would be better for all Serbia woud give 2 communities whit Bulgarian majority to Bulgaria, Macedonia woud be like Montenegro and Serbia 2 countries/republics with same people a bit different dialect but same language (another example Austriaand Germany). I think also Macedonia would take and extend Serbian Cyrillic (they have done it but for soft c and d they created a distinct letters). Bulgaria would take the same letters (same language same alphabet) so it would not have ja jo ju like in Russian so more phonetic and easier to write. Macedonians would feel safe from both Serbian and Bulgarian pressure, since we know that they were not pressured in 2nd Yugoslavia
@@aurelije well I'm not entirely sure about that because before 1878 the Southern part of the Morava river was also called Bulgarian morava because it was with a predominantly Bulgarian population. I'd say that would be included in this Yugoslavia in order to keep the Bulgarians happy (I'd say I'd be a dual monarchy like Austria-Hungary with the same monarch but different governments but a united foreign policy). This would assure Bulgarian loyalty to the Serbs. Then in the Balkan wars the whole of Macedonia and Thrace till the Midiya-Enos line would be annexed into Bulgaria because of their predominant Bulgarian population. Everything else without Albania would join Serbia and I'd even say as in the video Montenegro would join this Yugoslav state as a part of Serbia (they were Serbian after all). Then with WW1 Croatia would probably join the Serbian part as well, but Slovenia would be a third state due to their different language.
As you said this transformation from "ю" "я" to "jу" "jа" could occur, however, somewhere I remember reading that the Serbian language was intentionally changed to be closer to Croatian and Slovenian languages, which because of Austria-Hungary were changed to have the Latin alphabet, to be closer for a potential Yugoslav unification. Before the Serbian changes it included slavic letters like я, ю, ъ, ѫ, ѧ, ѣ and didn't use the Latin alphabet at all. These letters also existed in the Bulgarian language prior to their independence. If the leaders play their cards right and give autonomy to Serbs from Vojvodina, Bosnia and Croatia, Croats from Bosnia and Croatia and Slovenes they might be able to keep this larger Yugoslavia without ot collapsing. My point is they could federalise and have the borders follow ethnic lines between the slavs which can keep their languages and alphabets intact.
2:16 😱 no no no I’m scared of Bulgarian noises
Glad you don't know what I said 🤣
@@rewriting-historyI do💀💀💀
@@Tonkatabatkowhat was it?
What if kilkenny stayed the capital of Ireland and the English didn’t annex all of Ireland after the Viking invasions plz make a sceanario on this as I’m Irish and your one of my top three favourite RUclipsrs
Hey there, I like your suggestion and I will save it for later! Still haven't done a video about ireland! Also thank you for the support!
Very interesting and part 2 would be nice. Just a personal preference, but konigsberg owned by russia doesn’t make a lot of sense. Other than that, great vid!
Thank you very much! You're right about Russian East Prussia, should have given them something else instead
Nice vid
Really appreciate it man
I love it! I wish it happened like this
As a Bulgarian, I think it would be very cool!
@@rewriting-history As a Croat, it certainly beats what's happening in my country today
Ok, how does this guy not have 10K alreday? Also what do you use to map?
Haha I'm working towards getting to 10K, come back in a couple of months and I'll probably get there!
For maps I use paint. net, it's free and quite good, does the job very well!
Ohh ok thank you and good luck :D@@rewriting-history
The Maginot line was built in the 1930's in Alsace Lorraine !
Yeah my bad there
@@rewriting-history no problem
I love your videos man
Keep up the good work 💪
@@DK-ig8zi Appreciate that very much, thank you!
please make part two
Yessir!
I don't think the Russian Revolution could not happen because it was inevitable since the russo-japanese war.
Apart from this I liked this scenario. I would see a part 2.
I agree with you. What I meant is that it wouldn't maybe happen during the war, since Russia wasn't performing that bad. In part 2 they would maybe collapse.
it was not inevitable.
1:50 Great Bulgaria IS a thread!
уау страхотна работа продължавай в същия дух Велика Югославия!
Suggestion: What if russia was succesful in avoiding Russian revolution and was a victor in ww1?
Interesting idea, but this literally happened in this video! :D
Maka a part 2 please😢😢😢😢
I will, people really like it!
Hey, I see you & Khan were chatting on my birthday! What were you 2 doing on Discord, instead of being at my birthday party?😂🎉
Happy birthday! Also I don't know what you're talking about, who is Khan?
Part 2?!
Coming sooner than you might expect!
We need more
Part 2 should be my next video!
The only thing I dislike is Russia taking Königsburg and Memel but good video nonetheless
I'm glad you liked the video and watched up until the end. Yeah I agree with you, I don't know why I gave them that, but hey, I'm still learning
Me to
Готино видео, поздрав.
I highly dought that germany in the peace treaty would be divided like that. Either they get completely carved up and spit into different states(the US wanted to keep germany whole while the other powers wanted to carve them up) or the polish majority/minority areas in the empire whould be given to russia.
do you ever make part 2s?
I make sometimes, but often it's not worth it
Сега разбирам, че си българин :D
Преди това усетих от акцента, че си от Източна Европа, ама сега се изкефих още повече
Ееее че как, българите сме най-големите! :D
I just realized that the map you used for the default background was the HOI 4 map.
It is lol
конфедерация южных славскых народов!
4 Suggestions have the Community vote on them
1 What if Maximillian Remained Emperor of Mexico
2 What if Franz Ferdinand and Franz Joseph died on an earthquake in 1908
3 What if Bulgaria won the 2nd Balkan war and serbia became an austrian protectorate
4 What of the weird fiasco peace thing went through and germany invades austria-hungary
Thank you for the suggestion, I'll get to it after I'm finished with the project I'm doing right now
2:13 I wasnt expecting that lmao
:D
This is a stretch. Historically speaking the region of Yugoslavia has no major resources to support a full scale war, nor does this region have the population to withstand a full scale invasion on 3 fronts all from countries with greater resources, population, and military capacity. To add to this the Slavic people of this region historically could not come together and is y they’ve been in nearly constant war with each other. Not the best or most realistic outcome. They’d likely be steam rolled, occupied and broken up into separate nations. Then you just have normal WW1 situations after.
Perhaps you're right, but if I was 100% historically accurate, they would get destroyed and divided after. So nothing would change, they would exist for a bit, but in the end, the borders would be the same. This would make for a really boring video!
In 1916 you would get kaiser Karl who tried to ge tpewce OTL in 1916.with the war going even worse in this timeline it's likely he successfully gets out the war in 1916 in this timeline (historically it failed because he refused to give up South tirol, but with the war going even worse he would be more willibg to compromise)
Could be very interesting if that happened for sure
part 2 !!!!! pls
Expect to see it very soon!
thx@@rewriting-history
How can I send you suggestions?
Just comment on the videos!
Whens part 2?
Most likely never
2:12 RAGING BULGARIAN SCREAMING INTENSIFIES
He wasn’t screaming tho
If Yugoslavia is formed before WW1, probably it won't be there WW1 because there was Sarajevo assissination of Austro-hungarian archduke Franz Ferdinand that started war because, Sarajevo is not in Austria-Hungary then.
Can you make similar to this video but Bulgaria make Yugoslavia ( i know other person write it but The more the more (колкото повече толкова повече)
Ааа и ти си от България? Да смятам да направя подобно видео, много ми харесва идеята!
@@rewriting-history да Българин съм. Продължавай все така- много добро видео- гледах само това сега не мога още че ще спя че искам поне 7 часа сън.❤️❤️❤️
How do you get your map?
It's a custom made map I made for my channel!
@@rewriting-history ohh ok
this is one of my favorite channels but I think the peace treaty is just a bit harsh on Germany I don't think that is very realistic because Germany even though they did surrender they didn't lose any land in fact they obliterated Russia and Belgium I think it makes sense for Germany to lose maybe half of Alsace Lorraine but that is really harsh but especially losing Koenigsberg would be an absolute no because the royal family of Germany is mainly Prussian.
Yeah I'm very well aware of your claims. In the end of the day, I wanted to make the video a bit more interesting, so a possible war could start in part 2! I was just setting up something
As a Hungarian this is truly a sight for sore eyes. Sure we still lose the Vajdaság (vojdovina) but most of my beautiful country is left in tact. 🇭🇺
Part 2 !!!
What if Bismark after Austro-prussian war annexed Austria and to Hungary gave independence and to South Slavs possibility of unification with Serbia and Montenegro and probably Bulgaria
PART 2!!!
Damn you guys love this scenario! I will do it!
Question : What happened to the german colonies? would they all be divided just like in our timeline, or since the war is shorter germany was allowed to keep most of it?
Tanzania they would lose for sure, most likely they also lose Namibia. I think they will keep Cameron and Togo. As in the Pacific, maybe they will lose everything to Japan
you can remake this video, is very good video
People always forget (or do not know) that the masterminds behind the ideology of pan-slavism and yugoslavism were in fact the Croats. The Yugoslavian ideology and idea was something that has been circulating and developing among Croatian intellectual elites and church officials since the early 16th century. The father of pan-slavism is a Croatian priest - Juraj Krizanic, while a series of his successors developed the Yugoslav idea. Even the idea of Yugoslavia among the Croatian elites changed a few times. Pavao Vitezovic for instance developed a pan-Croatian idea in which all southern slavs would unite under Croatian cultural and political leadership and strive for independence and unity. But, the point is, the creation of Yugoslavia came far too late. The strong national conciousness has already been developed in all south-slavic people by 1918, and the geopolitical, cultural, social and other interests of for example Croats and Serbs were absolutely, diametrically opposed. Yugoslavia MAYBE would have had a chance of survival if it was formed in 1818, and not 1918.
Not only
If Bulgaria and Serbia lasted Longer vs the Ottomans Yugoslavia might had a Chance
For example Romania
Интересен уот-иф, само ми е любопитно каква версия на кирилицата би се използвала? По-близка с българската със Ю, Я, Ѣ, Ъ и Ѫ или със сръбските Ј и Џ?
Интересен въпрос, може би сръбската, тъй като те ще доминират политиката първоначално
@@rewriting-historyAs a Serbian, I personally believe the Serbian Alphabet would be adopted across Serbo-Bulgaria because the modern Serbian Alphabet was perfected by Vuk Karadžić Zmaj as a way to simplify the Serbian Alphabet and remove a lot of unnecessary letters, symbols and expunge Russian influence from Serbian Academia brought by Russian Scholars, which only made it even harder to study an understand.
The Alphabet was designed to be easy to learn, write and for everyone, it was meant to resemble the way common people talked, rather than the elite.
So, an alphabet that is easy to learn and understand for an average person would be incredibly useful to culturally and linguistically similar, but still widely diverse inhabitants of Serbo-Bulgaria as the nation develops and Education becomes available to a larger number of people.
Though, perhaps Vuk would work with Bulgarian Linguists and Scholars to make the new Alphabet truly Pan-South Slavic, rather than focusing just on Serbo-Croatian Language.
Great vid but Tsarigrad translates to The Emporers city not the kings city
What if indians won the first war of Indian independence and led to a United India??
A unified India in 1857 is a topic that is barely discussed. Maybe include Burma and ceylone too.
The revolution probably would have been successful if south India had also participated.
I like the idea! Will do a video about India soon!
Why would russia gain the german majority prussia instead if the polish majority poznan?
Yeah you have a good point. I should have mentioned that!
What if Greece and Albania united? Could be interesting, both languages apparently come from the same family
It's an interesting idea, but I don't see anything happening with this scenario. No massive war would be altered, which would arguably create for a boring video. I will think about it
@@rewriting-history maybe a short?
@@thetoastergod5935 Good idea! I wanted to make a short very soon! So I will do that!
What if the ottomans won the balkan war ?
Already have it! - ruclips.net/video/hnSbW7MV7dw/видео.htmlsi=UBvgzHS540_bNHXA
Make plz a part 2
How does Bulgaria not reach Solun (Thessaloniki) in time when its literally a couple of kilometers away and also isn't Skopje already in the new nation during the first Balkan war
As a Serb i would like to Defend our Actions in 1 Balkan War .
You didn't mention that Serbia would have given large portion of Macedonia to Bulgaria if Austria and Italy didn't pressure Serbia into giving up whole Albania + Austria Annexed Bosnia which was de facto under Ottoman Control which Serbia would give up Whole Macedonia for Bosnia . But Austrian and Italian imperialism and manipulation broke Relations between 2 brotherly nations .
Conference of Yougoslavs (hidden in Austria-Hungary) was made up from Slovens Croats Muslim Bosnians and Serbs ) Serbs from There before 2nd Balkan War wanted to include Bulgaria in Yougoslavia and supported for bulgaria to go all the way to Constantinople .
When Austria was demanding for Serbia to reatreat from Albania they first asked Bulgaria for help which they said (were to busy) so they gave up on Albania so they could Spare Whole Balkan from fighting another War against Big Power .
Russia most likely would annex possen(to form a polish kingdom in empire), armenian land in ottomans empire. I dont belive thay would annex Kaliningrad in this timeline.
I agree with you! It was a mistake doing this. It doesn't change this video and I'll fix it in the second part of the video.
Why not keep Constantinople? At the time it was just under 50 % Orthodox and it's a very important city even today
I was debating if I should include it or not. It's very important as you said, so I think that Russia or the UK will want it more, taking it away from Yugoslavia!
That is true, but it was offered to Russia in our timeline to keep them in the war, without anyone takeing it from the ottomans, so my thought was simply: Would Yugoslavia give it up freely and would the other great powers go to war over it, as you said UK and France was more conserned about Russia not getting too powerfull and therefore kept the Ottomans alive, with the Ottomans gone they needed another counter balance against Russia Yugoslavia could fill that role, and Russia might accept since it was another slavic mostly Orthodox power, I don't think it's unrealistic. Great video btw thx for making it@@rewriting-history
@@nicklars4099from what you're saying I think it's fair to say that Russia will gain it, so they avoid total collapse
Make part 2
*"Yo RH* 👋👋
Can we see a video on what happens if italy colonized ethiopia
And post italian Colonialism
I left a detailed Description in the previous video 👍👍
Hey I appreciate the proposal. Where did you leave a detailed description? I couldn't find it in my previous video.
@@rewriting-history
Left it in the previous Manchu China Video
But I left a copy down here 👇
@rewriting-history yh I wanna see how The horn of Africa looks post italian Colonialism
Pretty sure each Major Ethnic group gets their own Country
Would definitely like to see a balkanize video on a Horn of Africa Country/YugoSlavia style government
We could see Horn of Africa stay unified post Italian Colonialism but end up becoming Socialist
Basically becoming the richest African state post - colonialism And joining Tito in the non-Aligned
They probably have a Amhara or somali dictator who comes from half muslim half Christian mixed background then eventually past the 1990s the state collapses into ethnic And religious violence
And eventually 5 main states secede from the state and officially dissolve the Horn of African union
-Afaria
-Oromia
-Somalia
-Amharia
-tigrania
Each state goes their separate ways
this is so based and blessed
Красив Език🥰 2:16
Ama naistina deeba velikite sili deeba, haresvat si shibanata surbiq poveche ot nas deeba
Why would the Obrenovic Dynasty get replaced by the Karadjordjevic in this timeline
What if italy received its london pact'lands making it an ally into ww1 sequel?🤔
Great idea! I will do something very similar!
Why Ottoman got Thrace back after first Balkan war and why Corsica wasn’t painted into blue in this video?