Ministry of AYUSH: The Indian Government's Biggest Blunder (Documentary)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 июл 2024
- The biggest and most controversial video on my channel. A criticism of the Ayush Ministry. Here I present my case for why it’s a waste of public tax money. And on top of that it’s laughable adherence to safety and regulation harms a lot of people. Indian laws are also to blame.
One-time support:
UPI: scienceisdope@icici
buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Website: www.scienceisdope.com
Patreon: / scienceisdope_
Discord: / discord
Merch: kadakmerch.com/collections/sc...
#AYUSH
#Ayurveda
#Pseudoscience
Sources:
Dr. Abby Phillips:
/ theliverdr
/ @theliverdoc
Arif Hussain
www.youtube.com/@ArifHussainT...
Dr. Rohin Francis
/ @medlifecrisis
Dr. Abby’s toxicology & analysis results:
theliverdr/status...
theliverdr/status...
theliverdr/status...
theliverdr/status...
theliverdr/status...
Drugs and Cosmetics Rules 1945
cdsco.gov.in/opencms/export/s...
Toxic Metals in Ayurvedic Medicines
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
Patanjali’s Coronil study
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
Chapters:
00:00 - Intro
02:33 - The problem
06:47 - How alternative medicine makes you think it works
11:27 - Medical trials & their need
19:25 - The Ayush Ministry
24:20 - Is there value in traditional medicines
31:08 - Legal regulation
36:00 - Alternative Medicine Outside India
43:30 - What happens to alternative medicine practitioners now?
47:52 - Doctors and public health
52:10 - How the Indian Government misleads you
Patrons/members that support me at the highest tiers:
Rahul Raman
Don K.
Eranki Srikanth
MD Mudassir Hussain
Loveen Vuppala
Animesh Chaudhary
Wesley Potts
AV
Abhilash
Nate Hand
NEIL MHATRE
Eryk Thompson
Vivek Balasubramanian
Rags H
Jeevan
Sumana Gopinath
Nithin V Nath
Pradeep Chandran
Harsha
jeethendra d
khujema katleri
Muffin Man
Vedamoorthy Namasivayam
SV
sihoinvi
Sparsh Kumar
Divyaa Srinivasan
DarkSkies
Vinod Gopalakrishnan
Jamila Koshy
Dee Boudreau
Jatin Sharma
Shyam Katnagallu
Alden D'Souza
Yudhister Satija
Sri S
Selvakumar Jawahar
Kiran CJ
Prachet Verma
Suds Mekathotti
tariq sharif
Dev Agrawal
Thinking Humanist
Viswanathan Gopalan
Wrichik Basu
Dr. Kirat Tulaskar
Music Credits:
True Messiah - DJ Freedem
Follow me on social media:
Instagram: / scienceisdope_
Twitter: / scienceisdope_
RUclips: / scienceisdope
Reddit: / scienceisdope 
Развлечения
Support me at:
Buymeacoffee: buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Patreon: www.patreon.com/scienceisdope_
YT Membership: ruclips.net/channel/UCg--ENXdDpXh5LyLigolg2gjoin
UPI: scienceisdope@icici (QR Code available on www.scienceisdope.com/support )
I am no blind believer. But I don't see my msg. Is it deleted?
Something is fishy. When I tried giving journal links my msg gets deleted
@@bikram23bhuyan send it to me
docs.google.com/document/d/1nPdUA4nPQeDoIxRfyTZBSqFYNp6671ohzREo7vBvMvM/edit?usp=drivesdk
I would be happy if you make video on it,
I am so much thankfull to you as by your videos I was able to know the real truth. I was also one of the blind believers.
Thank you for your help Bro 🙇
What this country needs is some serious level of scientific temperament.
Scientific temperament is completely non-existent. Even when students study science, they do so without curiosity or interest. Only to score marks.
We won't have it anytime soon , until the sense of cultural superiority , dogmas , and insecurity about colonialism goes this will continues
Impossible when we have jholachap politicians like modi
The term 'alternative' medicine and homeopathy ( discipline)was actually created in the US. Also half of America does not 'believe' in climate change . 'Supplements' are not regulated by the FDA and not to mention fads like 'natural' and 'organic'.
In short, most of the problematic attitudes we have in India today regarding medicine are also prevalent in the united states and these ideas ( good or otherwise) are being exchanged.
💯
Thank you for inviting me to contribute a small part to this huge, impressive piece of work. I learnt quite a lot I hadn’t heard before, about the scale of the problem. Attaching quackery to legitimate medical establishments is right out of the famous Cleveland Clinic playbook, but it does untold damage. The jingoistic nonsense and profligate wasting of money on this nonsense is particularly sad when you consider how much Indian medical science has contributed. It could’ve continued on its previous path to being a real powerhouse, and developed more original research. People like Asima Chatterjee who discovered vinca alkyloids (vincristine - chemotherapy) using Ayurvedic therapies. Or Upendranath Brahmachari who prevented millions of deaths from kala-azar. Subash Mukhopadhyay who created the world’s second test tube baby, just weeks after the first (in the UK). There are so many brilliant scientists that currently decide to leave for the US or Europe.
Thanks for those indian names you mentioned, inspiring...
Thank you Dr. Rohin! And thank you for those names you mentioned. I'm curious now, will read up about them:)
🤡🤡🤡 glorified drug sellers.
Let me show you something:
". Ayurveda associated Pharmacology:
Sections:
i. Ayurveda in drugs
ii. Ayurveda inspired drugs
i. Ayurveda in drugs:
Some drugs that are isolated or created using Ayurvedic plants:
1. Bosentan: Bosentan, used in the treatment of pulmonary arterial hypertension, is derived from the plant Trachyspermum ammi (Ajwain). Ajwain has been traditionally used in Ayurveda for its medicinal properties, including respiratory support.
2. Rosiglitazone: Rosiglitazone, an oral antidiabetic medication used for the management of type 2 diabetes, is synthesized based on the chemical structure of compounds found in the herb Pterocarpus marsupium (Vijayasar). Vijayasar has been used in Ayurveda for its potential hypoglycemic effects.
3. Etoricoxib: Etoricoxib, a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) used for the management of pain and inflammation in conditions such as arthritis, is structurally derived from compounds found in the herb Withania somnifera (Ashwagandha). Ashwagandha has been traditionally used in Ayurveda for its anti-inflammatory properties.
4. Saxagliptin: Saxagliptin, an oral antidiabetic medication used for the management of type 2 diabetes, is developed based on the structural features of compounds found in the herb Gymnema sylvestre (Gurmar). Gurmar has been traditionally used in Ayurveda for its potential in managing diabetes.
5. Solifenacin: Solifenacin, used in the treatment of overactive bladder, is developed based on compounds found in the herb Dryopteris filix-mas (Male Fern). Male Fern has been used in Ayurveda for its potential diuretic and antispasmodic properties.
6. Rivastigmine: Rivastigmine, used in the treatment of Alzheimer's disease and Parkinson's disease, is a derivative of compounds found in the herb Acorus calamus (Sweet Flag). Sweet Flag has been traditionally used in Ayurveda for cognitive support.
7. Artesunate: Artesunate is a derivative of artemisinin, which is derived from the plant Artemisia annua. It is a key component in the treatment of malaria and has been effective in combating drug-resistant strains of the disease.
8. Forskolin: Forskolin is isolated from the roots of the plant Coleus forskohlii. It has been used in the treatment of various conditions, including asthma, cardiovascular disorders, and obesity.
9. Galantamine: Galantamine is derived from the Galanthus spp., particularly Galanthus nivalis and Galanthus woronowii. It is used for the treatment of Alzheimer's disease and other cognitive disorders.
10. Vinblastine and Vincristine: These anticancer drugs are derived from the plant Catharanthus roseus, also known as Madagascar periwinkle. They have been used in the treatment of various types of cancer, including Hodgkin's lymphoma, leukemia, and breast cancer.
11. Quinine: Quinine is derived from the bark of the Cinchona tree, particularly Cinchona officinalis. It has been traditionally used for treating malaria and is still used today in some cases of drug-resistant malaria.
12. Reserpine: Reserpine is derived from the roots of Rauwolfia serpentina, a plant traditionally used in Ayurveda for its antihypertensive properties. Reserpine has been used as an antihypertensive medication.
13. Podophyllotoxin and Etoposide: These drugs are derived from the roots and rhizomes of Podophyllum plants, such as Podophyllum peltatum. They have been used in the treatment of various cancers, including testicular, lung, and ovarian cancers.
14. Paclitaxel (Taxol): Paclitaxel is derived from the bark of the Pacific yew tree, Taxus brevifolia. It is an important chemotherapy drug used for various types of cancer, including breast, ovarian, and lung cancers.
15. Camptothecin and Irinotecan: These drugs are derived from the bark and stem of the tree Camptotheca acuminata. They have been used in the treatment of colorectal, ovarian, and lung cancers.
16. Guggulsterones: Guggulsterones are isolated from the resin of the Commiphora mukul tree, commonly known as Guggul. They have been used for their lipid-lowering and anti-inflammatory properties.
ii. Ayurveda inspired drugs:
While Ayurveda has influenced various aspects of modern medicine, including the development of certain drugs, direct translations or exact equivalents of Ayurvedic formulations into modern medicine may not always exist. Here are some examples of drugs that have been inspired by or have a connection to Ayurvedic principles and concepts.
1. Aspirin (Acetylsalicylic acid): While not directly derived from Ayurveda, aspirin is inspired by the use of willow bark in traditional medicine systems, including Ayurveda. Willow bark contains salicin, which has analgesic and anti-inflammatory properties. Aspirin, a synthetic derivative of salicin, is widely used as an analgesic, anti-inflammatory, and antiplatelet drug.
2. Digoxin: Derived from the foxglove plant (Digitalis purpurea), digoxin has cardiac glycoside properties. It has been used in modern medicine to treat heart failure and certain cardiac arrhythmias. The concept of using plants with cardiac effects has similarities to the Ayurvedic concept of strengthening the heart (Hridya Rasayana).
3. Artemisinin: Derived from the Artemisia annua plant, artemisinin is a key component in the treatment of malaria. The use of Artemisia species for treating fevers, including malaria-like symptoms, has roots in traditional medicine systems, including Ayurveda.
4. Paclitaxel: Derived from the Pacific yew tree (Taxus brevifolia), paclitaxel is a chemotherapy drug used in the treatment of various cancers. The concept of using plant-based medicines for their anticancer properties can be seen in Ayurveda, where various herbs and plant extracts are used in cancer management.
5. Metformin: While not directly related to Ayurveda, metformin has similarities to the Ayurvedic concept of "Guduchi" or Tinospora cordifolia, which has been traditionally used for managing diabetes. Metformin is a widely used first-line drug for the treatment of type 2 diabetes.
6. Rauwolfia alkaloids: Derived from the Rauwolfia serpentina plant, these alkaloids, including reserpine, have been used as antihypertensive agents. The plant has a history of use in Ayurveda, and its traditional applications for conditions like hypertension are reflected in modern medicine.
7. Colchicine: While not directly linked to Ayurveda, colchicine has similarities to the Ayurvedic concept of "Suranjan" or Colchicum autumnale, which has been traditionally used for managing gout. Colchicine is used in modern medicine for the treatment of acute gout attacks.”
Check this out too
iii. Ayurvedic Pharmacology:
Active compounds and mechanisms of action of some Ayurvedic medicines:
1. Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera):
- Active Compounds: Withanolides (e.g., Withaferin A, Withanolide A), alkaloids, saponins, flavonoids.
- Mechanisms of Action: Modulation of HPA axis, regulation of cortisol levels, enhancement of GABAergic neurotransmission, modulation of pro-inflammatory cytokines, antioxidant enzyme modulation, and neuroprotective effects.
2. Turmeric (Curcuma longa):
- Active Compound: Curcuminoids, including curcumin, demethoxycurcumin, and bisdemethoxycurcumin.
- Mechanisms of Action: Inhibition of pro-inflammatory pathways (NF-κB), antioxidant activity, modulation of cytokines and growth factors, and interaction with various cellular targets.
3. Triphala:
- Active Compounds: Tannins, gallic acid, ellagic acid, chebulic acid, chebulagic acid, chebulinic acid, emblicanin A and B, galloyl glucose.
- Mechanisms of Action: Free radical scavenging, anti-inflammatory activity, modulation of immune responses, enhancement of antioxidant enzymes, and hepatoprotective effects.
4. Brahmi (Bacopa monnieri):
- Active Compounds: Bacosides (e.g., bacoside A, bacoside B), alkaloids, flavonoids, saponins.
- Mechanisms of Action: Enhancement of cholinergic neurotransmission, modulation of neurotrophic factors, antioxidant activity, and neuroprotective effects.
5. Guggul (Commiphora mukul):
- Active Compounds: Guggulsterones (e.g., E- and Z-guggulsterone), guggulipids, resinous components.
- Mechanisms of Action: Regulation of lipid metabolism, modulation of inflammatory pathways, antioxidant activity, and enhancement of liver function.
6. Neem (Azadirachta indica):
- Active Compounds: Nimbidin, nimbin, gedunin, azadirachtin, quercetin, catechin, tannins.
- Mechanisms of Action: Disruption of microbial cell membranes, inhibition of microbial enzymes, modulation of inflammatory pathways, scavenging of free radicals, and promotion of wound healing processes.
7. Shatavari (Asparagus racemosus):
- Active Compounds: Saponins (e.g., shatavarins), steroidal glycosides, flavonoids, alkaloids.
- Mechanisms of Action: Modulation of hormonal levels, regulation of stress response, immunomodulation, antioxidant activity, and anti-inflammatory effects.
8. Licorice (Glycyrrhiza glabra):
- Active Compounds: Glycyrrhizin, glycyrrhetinic acid, liquiritin, isoliquiritin, flavonoids.
- Mechanisms of Action: Inhibition of inflammatory pathways, antiviral activity, antioxidant properties, enhancement of liver function, and protection of the gastrointestinal mucosa.
9. Amalaki (Emblica officinalis):
- Active Compounds: Vitamin C (ascorbic acid), ellagic acid, gallic acid, tannins, flavonoids.
- Mechanisms of Action: Scavenging of free radicals, modulation of immune responses, enhancement of liver function, regulation of inflammatory pathways, and anti-aging properties.
10. Haritaki (Terminalia chebula):
- Active Compounds: Tannins (e.g., chebulagic acid, chebulinic acid), gallic acid, ellagic acid, flavonoids.
- Mechanisms of Action: Enhancement of digestive functions, antioxidant activity, modulation of inflammatory pathways, hepatoprotective effects, and antimicrobial properties.
11. Yashtimadhu (Glycyrrhiza glabra):
- Active Compounds: Glycyrrhizin, glycyrrhetinic acid, liquiritin, isoliquiritin, flavonoids.
- Mechanisms of Action: Inhibition of inflammatory pathways, promotion of expectoration, antiviral activity, antioxidant properties, and protection of the gastrointestinal mucosa.
12. Punarnava (Boerhavia diffusa):
- Active Compounds: Flavonoids, alkaloids, saponins, rotenoids.
- Mechanisms of Action: Promotion of diuresis, modulation of inflammatory pathways, antioxidant activity, protection of liver cells, and modulation of immune responses.
13. Kutaja (Holarrhena antidysenterica):
- Active Compounds: Conessine, holarrhine, conimine, holacetin, alkaloids.
- Mechanisms of Action: Inhibition of diarrheal pathogens, modulation of inflammatory pathways, antioxidant activity, protection of liver cells, and antimicrobial properties.
14. Arjuna (Terminalia arjuna):
- Active Compounds: Triterpenoids (e.g., arjunic acid, arjunolic acid), flavonoids, tannins.
- Mechanisms of Action: Protection of the heart and blood vessels, modulation of inflammatory pathways, antioxidant activity, regulation of blood pressure, and inhibition of platelet aggregation.
15. Bhringraj (Eclipta alba):
- Active Compounds: Wedelolactone, eclipticin, apigenin, coumestans, triterpenoids.
- Mechanisms of Action: Promotion of hair growth, protection of liver cells, modulation of inflammatory pathways, antioxidant activity, and antimicrobial properties.
16. Shankhpushpi (Convolvulus pluricaulis):
- Active Compounds: Alkaloids (e.g., shankhapushpine, convolvine, convolamine), flavonoids, glycosides.
- Mechanisms of Action: Enhancement of cholinergic neurotransmission, modulation of neurotrophic factors, antioxidant activity, and neuroprotective effects.
17. Pippali (Piper longum):
- Active Compounds: Piperine, piperlongumine, piperlonguminine, piperlonguminine hydroxide, terpenes.
- Mechanisms of Action: Stimulation of respiratory functions, enhancement of digestive processes, antioxidant activity, modulation of inflammatory pathways, and immunomodulation.
18. Manjistha (Rubia cordifolia):
- Active Compounds: Anthraquinones (e.g., alizarin, purpurin), flavonoids, tannins, xanthones.
- Mechanisms of Action: Promotion of blood purification, antioxidant activity, modulation of inflammatory pathways, protection of liver cells, and antimicrobial properties.
19. Giloy (Tinospora cordifolia):
- Active Compounds: Tinosporaside, tinosporic acid, cordifolioside A, cordifolioside B, alkaloids.
- Mechanisms of Action: Modulation of immune responses, antioxidant activity, modulation of inflammatory pathways, protection of liver cells, and reduction of fever.
20. Trikatu:
- Active Compounds: Piperine (from black pepper), gingerols (from ginger), piperlonguminine (from long pepper).
- Mechanisms of Action: Enhancement of digestive functions, antioxidant activity, modulation of inflammatory pathways, and immunomodulation
People in the country dont know to ask questions. They think asking questions is disrespect.
Correct !
Seriously!!! I got shouted at so many times in college for asking questions!
Because We study because only to get jobs and competitive exams not for the love of subject. The teachers themselves become teachers because they can't get any work
One of my relative recently died of Thyrotoxicosis and Modern Medicine doctor was treating her ,he explained me 60% of diseases don't have treatment even today. Why he said so ??? I read in every Allopathic medicine leaflet medicine is Hepatotoxic (liver damaging)Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic etc if allopathic medicine are good and scientific then why so much caution about it's I'll affect ???
I have a question 7 lakh people die every year in US of IHD and Stroke there's no Ayurveda or Homeopathy then why can't modern medicine doctors fail to save them same in number die in India.
100% correct !
I know someone, whose story is quite harrowing. I'll not say her name to protect her privacy. She was born with a genetic illness, that was progressing with age. It got serious and she started losing hearing in one ear. Her parents took her to several doctors, to no avail. And then, they took her to an Ayurvedic retreat. She, like the people mentioned in the video, ended up with a poisoned liver. Her illness progressed even further after this and she was on the brink of dying. It was ultimately what ayurveda fanatics call "Western Medicine" that is keeping her alive.
She's lost hearing totally in both ears now, has been so for a few years. It got very bad during covid that she couldn't even expose herself to the air, and generally lives life with some level of quarantine protocols.
Much needed video, this.
Damn... Stories like this will never make the news
@@scienceisdopebut success story due to coincidence will be headlines and best marketing techniques ad later. Example :Kenya prime minister daughter story at sreedhareeyam.
I've many family members in the medical and health care industry, most of them working in government hospitals. I have been hearing such stories since my childhood. When the patient is too sick and close to losing their lives, the relatives bring to some hospital as a last resort. Then the doctors have very little window to do much. Many times limbs are on the verge of being amputated to save the life, or the liver or kidney has been damaged to the point of death or disability. It's scary that people still believe that ayurveda/homeo/naturopathy/ayush stuff are these harmless little practice with no side effects or issues. Our government should not be endorsing this stuff.
Bro it's also true 60% of diseases don't have treatment even today in modern medicine, Dr Gaurav Gandhi a cardiologist died of heart attack,7 lakh people in USA die every year of heart attack, and telling Modern Medicine don't effect Liver is foolishness most of them are Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic and Hepatotoxic,200 drugs like Acetaminophen , Tramadol Hydromorphone Carbamezapine Gabapentine alone can cause Suicidal thoughts in patients, I am a M Pharm Pharamcologist, it's completely tru that 70% modern medicine have deadly adverse effects .
@@lakshmitejas1685How about FDA data of USA atleast 7 lakh people die in US every year due Ischemic heart disease 😂 60% of diseases don't have treatment even in modern medicine,these fellow saying Ayurvedic medicine affect liver ,can he explain why modern medicine have caution leaflet with modern medicine as Hepatotoxic liver damaging Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic etc any medicine taken for longer duration will definitely damage liver , kidney etc
This is so well thought through and presented. Superb.
Also, I'm blown away by how carefully and meticulously the RCT for medicine has been devised. Brilliant.
(Equally blown away by the "regulations" for Ayurveda. Wow.)
Thank you so much!!
Half of the money goes to RUclips😢 such a waste
@@arhaanahmed1449😂😂
use UPI or other forms to give money to creator
if you do it using youtube, youtube will take 30% of money you decide to donate
so basically you gave rs600 to youtube
@@shubhamarutwar9396 Never understood why giving money to RUclips is a bad thing. I'm okay with it.
Budget of Adipurush 700 cr.
Budget of mandir 2000 cr.
Budget of chandrayaan 3 ,615 cr.
Engineers of chandrayaan 3 , not paid salary of 16 months .
No correlation to any of the above.
Maintain the context pls
Think my friends
Why india 🇮🇳 has no scientific tempre
Adipursh is not a govt scheme nor is Ram mandir stop stating non related stuff as per engineers being unpaid pls state your source as well.
The other side of the coin(opposite of andhbhakts)
The only thing bhakts are going to pick from this video is the name 'Arif Hussain'.
They'll stop the video there, declare Arif as antinational ISIS supporter, you as his parnter and liverdoc as henchman
💀
😂
thts y he had to emphasize exMuslim in the start🤣
Arif hussain is well known in Kerela as a sanghi. He is ex muslim and his 99% videos are against fundemntal islamists. So dont worry.
@@pradeepanck8213Yes in Kerala, but outside Kerala, people just need a non hindu name🤷♀️🤷♂️
If this is shocking, wait until you know that, they just added Ayurveda as one of the clinical rotations which one as to go through while completing MBBS. Further they are planning to add Ayurveda as part of MBBS course in upcoming curriculum.( because opening AYUSH ministry was not enough to persuard majority people).
And Gov as also granted them permission in getting postgraduate degrees in surgical fields too, for AYUSH graduates.
This right wing political party will go to any extent to get some votes.
Don't worry after Internship u can choose only Allopathic. It's also true that 60% of diseases don't have treatment even in allopathic medicine, one of the endocrinologist explained me about this when one of my relative died of Thyrotoxicosis. Medicine field itself didn't progress like Engeneering technology field etc. These two guys don't know even allopathic medicine are Hepatotoxic Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic etc directly mentioned on leaflet in medicine box. So world is battling to find solutions nothing else.
@@MuskanSingh-ol6lqModem Medicine are no saint they loot patients like anything,60% of diseases don't have treatment even in 2023 ,they clearly mention on medicine leaflet medicine is Hepatotoxic Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic etc ,7 lakh people die in US every year of IHD and Stroke there's no Ayurveda or Homoeopathy,and same number die in India .
Reality and news Is different my friend..
@@ssryr6427Modern medicine has always put warnings of side effects and acknowledges its shortcomings. That is the path of scientific progress. The alternative medicines always claim to be 'natural' and 'side effect free' but actually that's not the case.
They operate from unupdated, unresearched knowledge and hide behind tradition and religion for covering them up.
Actually it's not like what you said. AYUSH is added as 1 week program in MBBS internship, but students are given a choice to opt anyone from Ayurveda, Yoga, Unani, Siddha and Homoeopathy.
In reality, nothing happens in those one week. The interns just visits any AYUSH unit nearby to the medical college and takes 1 week break from the hectic 1 year schedule.
However it's a good initiative of the government. Many MBBS student even thinks that AYUSH treatment are harmless , so now they will know atleast something about the AYUSH system.
Now Pranav will be targeted as Khangressi Kommunist by the IT Cell
Trust me he will not. Mudi has done many things wrong but has done some good things too. If anti india channel can run freely then this video is not gonna go anywhere so chill.
he may be a communist from kerala..
@@sharunps4356 Good for him. He is a rational dude.
Neither Congress or communist will target him because both the parties are against BJP.
@@tomorrow. I never said that. I said he would be targeted by BJP.
You know being in the pharmaceutical industry I was always frustrated at how much more strict the regulations are for drugs of modern medicine than for the alternative medicine.....
It's sad
Isn't that for good? Drugs should have strict regulation and testing before being released for medical use.
@@EvilSapphireRyeah but the regulations to that degree should be applied to alternative medicine as well.
@Prodigious147 He is talking about generational and cultural knowledge here.. he gave example how traditional medicines lead to discovering active ingredients of many modern medicines through scientific research.
It is not trusting something blindly or throwing away everything blindly. It is about scientific temperament.
@Prodigious147 Which herbs do you look for active ingredients and what active ingredients are you looking for?
Cultural knowledge can show some direction to verify whether something works or not
A must watch! Well balanced. On point in creating awareness, especially on regulation issues. "Anything" claimed to aid in "healing" and healthcare must pass a rigorous drug trial and the data should be published on well peer reviewed journals. No exceptions on public healthcare please! 🙏
Thank you so much!
@@scienceisdope 60% of diseases have no treatment available in Modern Medicine or any other system of medicine even today,many modern doctors manipulate patients for money instead of telling them truth.
Thanks! This is very brave of you!
Thank you so much♥️
Bro is tryna get himself get killed 💀💀
We have never had such a proudly anti-modernity party in power before.
reject modernity embrace ~monke~ Islam
@@zhinkunakur4751 Hindu Muslim bhai bhai gawar gawar gai gai
@@abhinandanbanerjee5471 are oye shanti ke murat ek bar quran padh le sari shanti nikal jaegi
"I have been commanded to fight the people until they say there is no God but Allah, so when they say there is no God but Allah then their lives and wealth are protected from me, except by right of justice, and their reckoning is with Allah."
@@kakun63 shanti toh meri tabh nikal gaayi jab mene padhaa ki brahma ne apni beti sarswati se sadi ker li. Shanti tab chali gaayi jab padha widow ki sati karte wakt woh bhagwan ka naam lete the, aur bhagwan ne un widows ko bhas jalte aur tadapte dekha. shanti tab nikali jab krishna womanizer ne gopiyo ke kapde chura liye aur unhe nange apne hath uper ker nadi ki puja karne bola but draupadi ko kapde pehna diya(what a partiality!), ager krishna aaj ye karta to jail me hota...... krishna ne jab 3000 raniyo se saadi ki tabh bhi shanti nikal gaayi. me bhi hindu(sanatani) tha per ab nahi hu, abh me rationalist, moral, and agnostic atheist hu.
Please release this in vernacular languages, few sections if not the whole video!! Thats how you make your message reach
I wish that were easier to do. I would
@@scienceisdope AI can do that easliy now
@@AashayAgrawal Automatic translation is not good for Indian languages.
No I think there are softwares like dubverse that can do it... It costs a decent amount of money though
@@scienceisdope yeah you definitely need to make this atleast in hindi if you want to reach a wider audience in northern india
I'm currently studying BHMS, I just finished my 3rd year. Recently I've decided to discontinue the course. Your video is spot on on the time. I feel I'm taking the right decision.
all the best!! power to you
strive more, harder, you are at right path👍👍
Bro just finish your course and go for MBA later
So much guts. Hats off
All the best bro! I've discussed options you can take!
Alternative medicine eventually took my grandfather's life. As a result of this treatment, his health gradually deteriorated. Since that day, I have wondered why no one talks about this issue. I greatly appreciate your response to this issue.
Alternative medicine was never meant for such critical situations. It's to fight normal diseases in day to day life without relying on strong medicines.
No medicine system is perfect, 7 lakh people die every year in US due to IHD and Stroke there's no alternative medicine in America. I saw many people dying in Delhi AIIMS . A neurologist once explained me 60% diseases don't have treatment even today. Now this You Tuber says Ayurveda Homeopathy medicine are harmful if so then why allopathic medicine leaflet on them show there medicine as Hepatotoxic ( liver damaging) Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic etc I think all these You Tubers just don't have logic,can they blame the number of people died in pandemic all around world because of Ayurveda and Homeopathy 😂
@BritishRajNationalist I am not telling who is famous here ,your Papa You Tuber exposing himself just by blaming others without knowing reality.
Yes if you have an incurable disease you will go to an allopath and patient dies, that time you will say oh he has taken all possible antibiotics and scientific treatment and it is his fate. You go to a good intentioned alternative medicine doctor who tries his best then you blame him, his credibility, his entire system. Why is it that the allopath gets away with any shit?
Why don't you admit it is your lack of responsibility that lead to your grandfather's death? If you were so concerned you should have done your research before going to this practitioner and then bitching about his system here.
@@mohdsuhail9905 because alternative medicines keeps some people from approaching an actual doctor, and when the symptoms get worse, as a last resort, they seek modern medicine, but by then it's already too late. If the patient was diagnosed earlier by a doctor, he could have lived.
Hats off to you for shedding light on this myths and the underlying problems in India.
Truth 60% of diseases don't have treatment in modern medicine or homeopathy or Ayurveda 😂 7 lakh people die every year in US of IHD and Stroke same in India . Every modern medicine comes with caution leaflet with modern medicine is Hepatotoxic (liver damaging) Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic. So telling Modern Medicine don't damage liver is big lie.
I know a (doctor) colleague in Medanta Hospital. He was in Urology Department. As per him, many cases of urology could have been treated easily, if the patients coming to them wouldn't have taken Ayurveda medicine for years!!!
After deteriorating their conditions, patients wanted allopathic treatment.
*Modern medicine
Same...i also refuse the patients who deteriorate their condition from allopathic medicines...gosh...even your antibiotics arent going to work in upcoming yrs...and the drugs you use cause numerous health problems chronically🙏🏻
@@brahmiveda Jo marji kar lijiye. Allopathy is well researched, open to challenges and life saver.
Patanjali ke Balakrishnan beemar hue to apna treatment AIIMS mein karwaya... Kahin AIIMS ne unhe mana kar Diya hota to!
Ayurveda is the future
Being an ex-muslim who now understand science and spread scientific temper amonst my family and friends circle, a big fan of you and Dr Abby, this video is a must watch for everyone in this country, The people in power in this cursed country must watch and revise their AYUSH ministry.! If not for real modern scientific medicine, I wouldnt have been alive today. Modern science cured my congenital heart condition through a open-heart surgery. I request AYUSH to develop and use a single thing like the heart-lung machine, or say MRI. Those all are only outcomes of real science!!!
How about being ex schoolian and excollegian ?? Silly logic. Why don't you come up with your now identity?? Is it because you need to put muslim identity to spread agenda. Come from real id hindu .
Thank you so much!!
@@Dense197 Leave him be bro. Not a single ex muslim has won nobel prize yet while three muslims have won nobel prizes in physics and chemistry. Ahmed Zewali, Aziz Sancar and Abdus Salam. There have been eleven muslims in space not a single ex muslim in space. I really dont know why but that is the truth. The life of ex muslims starts with Islam and ends with Islam. Even nobel prize in literature went to two muslims. Our ex muslim (he didnt call himself that) Salman Rushdie is an exception. I just want to ask why did ex muslims not have accompolished anything yet. I challenge all ex muslims to atleast win a nobel prize in science.
@@ashamsaud4737 I don't know what fantasy they've to put ex muslim. If it is not what are you, then why come up with this identity. Come with what you are now ?? It's absurd logic actually
@@Dense197 I apologize. Three muslims have won nobel prize in literature not two. I stand corrected. 😅
How can you ask about Ayurveda to an Allopath who knows nothing other than the term Alternative medicine ? Ask authentic concerned people
U're doing God's work Pranav /s from a fellow atheist, Keep it up.
God's works. 😂
@@surferp89God's works in mysterious ways /s
So, since God does not exist, he is doing no work at all?😂
/s = Sarcastic 😅
top tier god level comment 😂😂
In Germany its similiar with Homeopathy. Lots of examptions from critical trials, lots of extra rules and politicians and health officials that refuse to do shit about it, because they get lobbied. The Insurances make a shitload of money because its cheap in production and can be sold very expensive.
People are denied wheelchairs because they are to expensive, but you get a doctor that prescribes u sugar pilles. Thats a frickin joke.
Every video like yours which call shit like this out is very appreciated. Good Work, keep it up.
Plzz
Tell
Some differences and indifferences
B/w India and Germany
Regarding this situation
Indians need to become more confident and secure in modern world with our modern achievements instead of clinging to the past.
These two don't have any knowledge about Ayurveda or allopathic,both Ayurveda and Allopathic medicine source is same Metal Minerals Plants Animals based. 40% of allopathic medicine are plant based 😂 emergency medicine like Sylmarine, Vincristine, Vinblastine sulphate,Quinidine Digoxin are plant extracts most of these are registered under CCIM Ayurveda. Modern medicine doctors themselves admit 60% of diseases don't have treatment. 22 lakh people die every year in US due to various diseases and 7 lakh people die only due to IHD and Stroke, similar is condition in India . Just blaming others don't work . Modern medicine has its own problems.
@BritishRajNationalist LOL hasn't it already happened ? India is literally one of the leading countries in software development, service sector and space exploration. You blind or what ?
@@DragonOfTheMortalKombat leading countries in software development? wtf
@@DragonOfTheMortalKombatfool leading. ...i don't think so yes but to make women naked and parading definitely became a vishwa guru
Both things can happen but we should stop acting like our culture invented everything science has to offer today
ayurveda graduate here (not currently practicing nor am I planning to ) the scientific temperament for ayurveda is really poor I remember pg.'s telling me research cases that was not accepted by the faculty cause it showed no result and though some treatments work, I believe it should be researched and implemented into modern medicine i wish the govt would close down these bams colleges who rip off students time and money and run proper trials on successful ayurveda treatments
Thank you for saying this. Voices like yours are not heard enough!
If it was implemented then it would no longer be ayurvedic medicine.
Exactly same feeling 😢... Ayush is simply a wastage of everything.
@@ArtbyUmaiza.2114 just practise allopathy bro. Why is it a big deal
@@VaidyatheDr yes definitely , a real Dr (mbbs _modern medicine/ evidence based medicine)
.after wasting my 3 years in ayush degree
As an endocrinologist i stopped councilling people from refraing alternative medicine... because they are not only stupid but also aggressive. most of them are happy even if they die .so i am focusing my energy and precious time on worthy patients
I also saw it done by my doctor. One of the patients had Hb1ac of 9.5 and the patient said she will see ayurvedic practitioner and try to get cured. My doctor said fine, no problem, anyway you have come back after a year or two to me and then I would start the treatment. When I asked the doctor why she said so and not convince the patient, the doctor told me that they won't be compliant and would drop off the treatment and so let the patient try everything, lose there and come back for the actual treatment which then she would follow properly. I really felt bad, uncontrolled sugar can create havoc to the various systems and that patient is taking a big risk for her own life, out of this belief that she will get cure for diabetes from ayurveda.
If you suggest them to take alternative medicine like homeopathy, your Thyroxine or neo mercazole patients will leave you forever so better say you don't want lose ₹1000-2000 consulting fees from each patients rather than calling them stupid or aggressive, they are not taking money from you to see a alternative medicine practitioner... Afterall our forefathers had alternative medicine not your western medicine
P.S: I am not against western medicine as I am also operated but I am against unnecessary medication and doctors monopoly and business, many are not guiding their patients in a right way which is lifestyle changes, dietotherapy and exercise, you guys definitely let your patients to try homeopathy ayurveda to see if body is responding well or not rather than denying whole alternative medicine pathy
@@alameludevanathan7399yurveda and other alternative medicine system has good management of diabetes, the one who are talking allopathy medicine will die sooner or someday while begging for death... I say best management for diabetis is lifestyle changes and keto, alternative medicine can add good thing too and allopathy for just emergency purpose, doctors just prescribe medicine and won't ask you that diet and lifestyle changes is a medicine of next century.... Check out videos of Dr Jason Fung, Eric berg to know about importance of diet and side effects of lifetime medication.....
The word 'worthy' scares me. I would hope that it is understood that such people just don't know any better and deserve the treatment just as much.
@@deadalpeca8099 i write and explain about my treatment... but I don't care to educate them about alternative medicine.
many many patients said just give your prescription don't educate me on what to do or beleive ...
Bhakts incoming stay safe 😅
Anti indian spotted
This Ayush ministry gets 3000 crore Rupees every year, what a waste of tax money, it would be so much better to invest this money in research
Having education does not matter much, the ability to think sensibly and logically is more important than emotions these days!
Don't let your logic overpower you which will lead you to deny the reality, wake up to reality and don't bring science and rationality in everything
Where the logic ,modern medicine have its own problems,60% of diseases don't have treatment even today in 2023 in any system of medicine. 7 lakh people die every year in US of IHD and Stroke there's no Ayurveda or Homoeopathy whom to blame why such big failure. He says Homeopathy Ayurveda medicine are not safe then why allopathic medicine leaflet read take medicine with caution it's Hepatotoxic liver damaging, Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic etc
@@ZaidKhan-su3ey LOL reality follows logic, you should be the one waking up.
@@DragonOfTheMortalKombat read logic books of ancient Greece and medieval era, you will say they are nuts... Everything changes many theories was proven wrong this is why don't bring science in everything
@@confused_af to a bone head...
We bring religion because religion is the way of life, science and logic is not God... Don't shout science science science all the time because one day any scientist can go nuts...
From a Muslim
Such an awareness video is the requirement of the hour for our better understanding about '#MEDICINES' and it's not an hierarchy to get offended or upset about.
Thanks for the efforts behind it!
Thank u
It's worth noting that alternative medicine is also seen as a financially affordable option by many of its consumers, who more often than not, come from lower middle class and poor households. It is extremely troubling and inexcusable that they are dealt such toxic substances under the guise of medicine, while modern medicine is reserved for the wealthier class. 4000 crores every year can be utilised to make modern medicine affordable to the economically weaker sections of the society instead of subjecting them to such fraudulent, low-effort alternatives.
Not so...the affluent ppl spend much ok ayur bcos of the belief its safe and modern medicine has adverse events
@@sureshsamuel7936 That's why I said "also", it's an issue of underspending on the accessibility and testing the effectiveness of modern medicine within the country, due to so much splurging taxpayer money on alternative medicine and ineffectively going about testing the safety and efficacy of these products. I suspect that its lobbying is targeted at foreigners as well.
@Prodigious147 the products are targetted at all demographics, and it's completely neglected in research and testing, is released to the general public, and markets false information under the guise of ancient medicine and culture.
@@s_anandsurya
People don’t opt for alternative medicine not because they can’t afford allopathy , it’s because allopathy has its limitations and doesn’t work in all diseases whereas alternative medicine such as Ayurveda cures them completely.
@@kumarkk532 I honestly don't think alternative medicine cures those diseases, though it is marketed that way.
My personal recommendation is universal healthcare.
This is a comprehensive debunking video. Great job man. 👍👏👌
Very bold video, bhakts will not be able to bear this video. But more power to you bro 👊👍
Only namzi will able to destroy beautiful places like Sweden, France, Kashmir ...
Bhakts are needed to stop, BJP and thier fans are gonna destroy this country if they kept lose.
You are not bhakt of other party😂
@@saitamakun8266 he is andh namazi bro
@@lmaololfuhe might not be a Muslim. A huge number of viewers of this channel are Atheists or agnostics .
Lmao you both people cry else where
The problem in spreading this message is having to beat the amazing networking system of Indian unkills and antys 😂
The Gov. Of India has almost takes Ayurveda as part of cultural Heritage of India.....and promoting with stuff like yoga.
What's wrong with yoga?
Thats not a problem at all bt there is a limit to everything. Ayurveda is good up to a certain lvl and it should be promoted as it part of our culture. But going out of the way saying it can cure cancer,aids etc are just pathetic and are harmful. Like baba ramdev claiming his coronil medicine will cure COVID with a recovery rate of 100%. The health minister or medical council of India didn't say anything allowed the misinformation to spread. Becoz of very large media coverage and controversy did the medical council concluded it as a false claim. There is a clear line between being proud with what we have vs simple lying and promoting misinformation.
@@lavanya7721Good as an exercise. But there is nothing supernatural about it. You won't gain universal-knowledge or anything.
@@AERYS.Then why are your superior people westerners are using it. They were supposed to be modern and not care about a " uncivilised country "that they use to call us. Why are they using this yoga ,pattal(plate made out of leaves) thing of this uncivilised country ?
@@lavanya7721 nothing....it's fine but not arurveda
This is the first video I came across that actually talks about harms of alt med .
Have a lot of people even in my family who have resorted to alt med.
Please keep bringing more such research based deep dive topical videos often .
YOU'VE genuinely earned a subscribe !!
Great work 👏👏
Your best work yet in my opinion (I'm saying this as if this 17 yo boy has any right to be your judge lmao) but seriously tho you are awesome. Keep up the good work.
to answer your last question........ofcourse we are not a democracy anymore ( 'electoral autocracy' to say the least)😅
The only ayurvedic doc whom I respect is the old gentleman who treated my mom from post partum back injury. He would have loved to have a chat with you, but RIP old man.
He refuses to treat patients who need meds based on germ theory (HIV/AIDS, cholera, dengue). Asks cancer patients to strictly follow modern meds and might throw in an "immunity booster" for the placebo effect. He feels, his role is more about "mental health boost", "Operation prevention" and "post-op healthcare".
He knew the limits of Ayurveda and educated people about it. The man wanted to integrate Ayurvedic practices of patient care with modern meds and not use it as an alternative. Good man with good ethics.
Indian Medical Association should take interest in reaching out to public and creating awareness regarding public interest issues. They can conduct debates on you tube for instance
RUclips please introduce a double like option for atleast this vedio alone. Amount of effort he puts with very less income he receives. RUclips if hearing this and going to process of giving double like just consider thrible like.
Hahaha thank you!
This was a great informative video.
Make more of them…
I had to watch it in three parts but loved it. It’s really great that you make this kind of videos.
Amazing video, in-depth yet easy to understand, hope this reaches many more people.
Ps press the share button even if you don't send it to anyone
The worst part of Steve Jobs ailment is, although he had a pancreatic cancer, he had something called as Insulinoma, not the more aggressive adenocarcinoma of pancreas. Insulinoma is such cancer which can be diagnosed in very early state(i.e before it has metastasized) so he would have completely recovered had he been opted for surgery at the time of diagnosis. We would have still had the great visionary living.
Guys like Shri Rajiv Dixit will say "isme chemicals hai", and people will orgasm to the word "chemicals". He never said what those chemicals are, people never understood that chemicals are present everywhere.
Tell them what you eat for lunch and dinner is also chemicals
@@krox477recently I found I've been drinking dihydrogen monoxide! Can't believe no one warned me about it.
He is talking about reductionist chemicals .
@@guitarist_covers😂
yes this collab, lets gooo. edit: completed watching the whole thing and this is such a well made video, you covered all the aspects of this problem and explained it really well. great work, restored my hope in indian youtube.
But logic missing, they say Ayurveda Homeopathy medicine are not safe then why allopathic medicine leaflet caution patients with medicine being Hepatotoxic liver damaging,Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic etc 7 lakh people die every year in US of IHD and Stroke there's no Ayurveda or Homoeopathy whom to blame for failure. I saw all big corporate hospital and also hospital like AIIMS in India , people die daily numbers there why if Allopathic is perfect,and i recently saw endocrinologist himself admitted 60% diseases don't have treatment even in 2023.
So true. So so true.this brings me tears that there are people who would go out of their way to bring truth to the surface. But if this video was done in Hindi thn people would have thrown a lot of fit. Trust me they make money off of the lies .
@bhavesh8385 yeah but trust me people would have had problem with this video if someone were to make
A video on the same topic in Hindi. The concept of Free speech is dying these days trust me. But it's amazing that he is able to say the truth.
Wait a minute I'm not a Tier Member but I'm able to find this video unlisted in Playlists section 😂😂
Thank you! Fixed it :)
@@scienceisdope Thank You for this awesome presentation and a much needed video!!!
Yes, research is needed 👍
Thanks!
Thank you so much!!
Science is just dope ❤
Brilliant work pranav.
Liverdoc should be invited in more and more podcasts to educate people.
You are 100% true Pranav, My ( non alcoholic) friend just passed away due to liver failure , he was diabetic and consuming Ayurvedic medicine as alternative medicine to support alophethi medicines.
😂😂 woow chemicals have no side effects herbals kills human 😂,
actually every medicine is medicine🙏even if it is both ayurvedic and allopathic so using everything on right path for the desease condition buy the prescription of a registered knowledged proffessional dr will never kill a woman
Overuse or misuse can kill anyone its applicable to both ayurvedic and allopathic too
Thousands of people are curing from Ayurvedic medicines everyday, pls don't say lie🙏
Respect everything, think before the times were modern science came here
Respect every science each and every science have its on benefits
On regular OPD we are seeing too many pateints due to side effects of allopathic medicines, they are curing buy ayurvedic medicines🙏
Pls atleast respect ,
BAMS students are also studying modern science too
But MBBS students didn't know anything, anything about Ayurveda
This is the truth 🙏
And that's how Pranav got the tag of Anti-national 😅.
This is a phenomenal video that’s very very necessary! You’re an inspiration Pranav! Keep up the amazing work. I’m sharing this everywhere! 😊
Deep-Down-the-rabbit-hole style video.
Salute to Pranav for such a marvelous piece on how the government is literally playing with human health.
That's intentional and criminal. AYUSH is a criminal enterprise. Period.
AYUSH was started by PM Neharu in 1954 with a separate ministry for it stop blaming Modi because Gujrat have very less Ayurveda or Homeopathy hospitals.
Second thing if Allopathic is perfect why 22 lakh people die every year in US due to various diseases,just due to IHD and Stroke 7 lakh people die every year in US there is no Ayurveda or Homoeopathy whom to blame ,same in all countries,in Mumbai 12000 people die every year due to Heart Attack, Modern Medicine doctors themselves admit 60% of diseases has no treatment even in 2023 . These two educated illiterate say Ayurveda Homeopathy medicine are not safe 😂if allopathic medicine is safe then why allopathic medicine leaflet caution patients about Medicine Hepatotoxic liver, damaging Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic etc just braging on You Tube and fooling people don't work there should be a logic .
@@ssryr6427 First learn who to learn. FYI, ctrl+c , ctrl+v from Wikipedia-> en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ministry_of_Ayush#:~:text=The%20Department%20of%20Indian%20Systems,the%20Modi%20government%20in%202014.
The Department of Indian Systems of Medicine and Homeopathy (ISM&H) was first established in 1995 under the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.[2] ISM&H was renamed as the Department of AYUSH. The department was made into an official ministry by the Modi government in 2014"
Pure idiocy 😂😂😂
So, I don't think u really understand the word "logic"... First understand it and then give pain to your fingers 😂😂😂.. poor chap
@@ssryr6427 who tf fck said modern medicines are perfect?
They are proven by scientific methods. They are tested.Produce same results in different tests and are peer reviewed.
Do the same things with your alternative medicines and you will be validated.
Is it so hard for you ?
@@ssryr6427exactly
I can't thank you enough for making this video. This is some serious education, which should be a part of critical thinking education.
Keep up the great work, and thanks again for the in-depth content.
Do More of these kinda videos. Really helpful and also include what could we do about this at an individual level .
Ayurvedic practitioner in rural,villages are really putting the life of innocents in danger
Exactly..I have heard and seen so many cases...they prescribe them allopathic medicine,(jinki in ayush practitioners ko koi knowledge hi nhi) for normal headache they prescribe medicines for migraine 😞
After watching this video my respect towards you has increased manifolds. I would definitely love to see more such in-depth content. May the force be always with you!
Hey pranav , big shout out to you , been with you since you had almost 10k followers,
You're doing something that i always wanted to do " spread awareness " .
Just a small request , post a video /content on educating people about idolizing anything/anyone .
Its succinct but I know you got it .
I can talk on this topic for hours .
Cheers
I was waiting for this, first Indian to address it and choice of alternative medicine is not because of lack of education it's because of choice.
Both fellows don't have logic ,a MBBS doctors will also not agree with them , because 60% of diseases don't have treatment in modern medicine or any other medicine even today, 7 lakh people die every year in US of IHD and Stroke there's no Ayurveda or Homoeopathy whom to blame for such failure. I saw many corporate hospital and big hospitals people die daily there ,why so if everything is perfect with modern medicine, he says Homeopathy Ayurveda medicine are not safe then wh Allopathic medicine leaflet caution patients about it with Hepatotoxic liver damaging, Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic. There's problem with logic in You Tubers 😂
Perfect video to spread awareness on dangers of anecdotal evidence. Kudos to you Pranav for another job well done👍👏
A very detailed and informative video👏👏👏
I think this content must be translated in every regional language to reach layman as well.
An engineering graduate making videos on medicine with such detailing is just fantastic. If you were a medicine student, you could've done many more such videos. Your concern for public health is really appreciable 👏🏻👏🏻.
Make a video series with the help of researchers/doctors about fake medicinal studies that are published on AYUSH or any other sites. Make a video playlist "PUBLIC HEALTH CONCERN". Continue making such videos.
One of my relative recently died of Thyrotoxicosis she was under treatment from a Endocrinologist modern medicine doctor . When we asked about it in explaining he said there are atleast 60% of diseases which doesn't have treatment even in 2023 . Here they're talking about liver damaging etc I want to ask if moder medicine are safe then why they mention in leaflet with Hepatotoxic liver damaging Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic etc 7 lakh people die in US every year of IHD and Stroke there's no Ayurveda or Homoeopathy same number die in various countries around the world,even today 2 lakh people die in India every year of TB government giving them free TB treatment but they die because of toxicity of high dosage . So blaming is easy there should be logical discussion with modern doctors, Ayurveda Homeopathy doctor instead of a engeener 😂
@@ssryr6427instead of commenting under every comment just stop going to the hospital bro. Don't ever buy any modern medicine and only take ayurveda. Even if you have cancer don't ever visit the hospital.
Im a surgeon and during my general surgery time, Ive seen many patients who took ayurvedic treatment for their jaundice. Then when it didnt get better they come to modern medicine after which it would be found it was a tumour of the bile duct . But by that time often its too late and had already spread and we couldnt do surgery and had to refer to chemotherapy. . Truly there needs to be a better regulation
If a patient dies after taking modern medicine...then it's d fault of allopathic system???
@@seeker7090 I wasn't taking about treatment. Talking about the basic diagnosis for which the treatment should be based on . The person who went to Ayurveda first ideally should've got blood tests or CT scans to find out what was underlying cause of it before just being prescribed generic pills that supposedly cure all types of jaundice.. people will always die eventually no matter whatever drug they take . I'm talking about the preventable things that get missed because of mismanagement. And don't get me wrong. Even a modern medicine doctor can make the blunder and miss things but that's on that particular doctor. Whereas in alternative medicine that option to optimally diagnose and treat is not even there because it's not evidence based
@@georgetaliat1 thanks 👍 I just care for d innocent people
@@seeker7090 problem is people not taking modern medicine from the very beginning and making it worst by taking alternative medicine
Kudos for this brave effort. Thanks so much.
Wow, this one video nicely condensed all things "alternative" medicine. Well done!
Wonderful insights! Keep up the good work.. 🎉
This is such a well researched video honestly extremely eye opening on the other hand I also do wish that medical students are atleast taught nutrition as a subject they get zero knowledge about nutrition and most of the doctors are so dismissive about the fact that food and our diet does effect a certain condition and without going into the root cause are very quick to warrant a strong medicine for that for example let's take the case of acne most of the dermatologists they would straightaway shove a course of doxycycline ( antibiotics)which in turn further disrupts the entire gut microflora and it is such a vicious cycle and many such medicines without discussing what might be the root cause for eg hormonal imbalance, liver toxicity, gut health issues , heavy metal issue and on the other hand we don't have strict laws for the ayurveda and the herbs and the supplements although they do have a potential to help but it is always such a risk gauging the quality of such products.
Great work ,i think peoples love for party should not be more than the concern about its people.
I have been following Dr. Abby for a while and that's where I saw the link to your video. Kudos to your thorough research. Thank you for so much for breaking this and simplifying it for everyone else. The delusion of ayurveda healing people is so disturbingly deep rooted that my own family never takes me seriously whenever I ask them not to take these supplements!
Really loved the video. I know you said you were gonna make a video about problems in our current healthcare system like its expensiveness, corruption, lack of access etc but I wish you had elaborated on how these problems are the very reason that some people turn to alternative medicines.
I have seen such people in my own life where they couldn't access proper healthcare during covid and turned to alt medicines to treat their conditions and it ended up worsening them. But I guess the video would was long enough as it is and there is always the opportunity to talk about it some other time.
This was the very first video of yours that I watched and I can tell you that you have earned yourself a subscriber.
The content man the content , if even a 10min of video have rhat much of research i can't imagine how amazing the rest will gonna be ! .
Definitely digging out some time for this gem 🫡🫡🫡🫡🫡🫡
Greatly researched and thourough videos. Thanks Pranav.
Thank you!
The problem with Ayurveda is, it got the sanctity of religion & believers instead of improvising ancient techniques using modern techniques. Chinese have done this to their traditional medicines.
Thank you so much for this video, Pranav. This kind of content is very important.
Truly excellent video. Appreciate your guts, we need more people like you
Awesome work man 👏🏽👏🏽
Thank you so much 😀
Yes I'm so glad you brought the point of clinical trials. All the people that cry 'allopathy' 'western medicine' should learn what it takes for a drug or biological to get to the public. If they think ayurvedic/homeopathic medicines work then they should be checked for safety and efficacy just like any other drug.
Hi pranav can you guide for the below
1. is there any laboratory to do toxicology study that can be accessed for a private person (not for scientific institutions). I want to do the same from my side so that i can able to convince my family who are deeply into this dangerous alternative drugs.
2. What will be the approx cost associated with this.
Thanks in advance
This is much needed video in today's world, real research leading to real result, if any therapy is better than existing one it should stand in the trial rather then just on mouth of word publicity, false explanations and paid reviews.
indian society as a whole is in dire need of knowing the difference between scientific temperament and modernism/westernism . i dont have an opinion on wersternism but Politics in India intentionally leads people to think they are same and make them hate both as a whole.
Stunning. Thanks for this.
@Science is Dope: Pranav, this is by far the most detailed video you have made and while it had repetitions from other videos(I watch all your videos), I could imagine the time and pain it took you to throw light on not only pointing out the real issue, but also address those who took alternative medicine as a profession.
I would not have even given a rats ass about it and I believe most other content creators would not. This not only shows how well thought and researched your videos are but also how responsibly you are making content not only for your subscribers but also people who come to show hatred.
Keep up this great work. I was actually waiting for such a collab between you, the liverdoc and medlifecrisis. I've started following midlife crisis since the inception of covid and I follow Dr Abby and your content on Twitter.
I did not even feel a bit bored whole going through this entire video. I know you will receive a lot of hate for this. It just proves you are on the right track.
I am one of your early subscribers and I can see how far you've come in dealing with such issues. Keep on the good work. India needs more people like you
Every year 7 lakh people die in US of IHD and Stroke there's no Ayurveda or Homoeopathy ,same number die in many countries in Europe Asia . There are no availability of treatment for 60% in modern medicine or any other medicine. So blaming others is joke , maximum big hospitals u see are allopathic medicine where maximum people die daily like AIIMS . He says medicine damage liver,then why allopathic medicine give leaflet with there own medicine mentioned Hepatotoxic ( liver damaging)Nephrotoxic Neurotoxic etc
As a medical professionals it my advice to people to learn about efficiency rate of medicines and why and how they are effective. Ayurvedic medicines often don't have efficiency rates and therefore none recommends for diagnosis.
Hats off brother. We need more videos that help people improve their scientific temperament. Please also do a video on Yoga!
Mine is a minor problem on the scale of this stupidity of epic proportions, but the number of days I've had to miss school, the number of extra days where I've had to endure a fever just because my parents took me to a homeopathic dr just grinds my gears. One time I ate a whole bottle of homeopathic medicine and my father beat me up really badly, and i was really scared of something adverse happening to me, then he took me to the dr again to get a refill of that medicine.😢
Loved this one, I really admire the hard work put into this. You inspire me.🙌
Well put together Pranav. Thank You for this.
Hi Pranav, I hope my message finds you well. I am following you since your first video and I am writing this to sincerely thank you for all work you are doing in debunking pseudoscience, promoting critical thinking, increasing scientific literacy amongst youth. I got introduced to Dr Abby Sir and Vimoh (amazing people) through your videos and as someone who identifies as rationalist and science lover, I was delighted to find some creators who actually made thought provoking relatable content by addressing questions in respectful and intellectual manner.
Wishing you continued success and bigger milestones. Thank you
Same! I saw your comment too on vimoh's live yesterday. I am glad I am not alone in this journey:)
We need more videos like these!!
I've been so pissed at this shitty ministry, thansk for addressing it
Thank you for being a voice of empathy and sanity
Bhai, respect to u. U have a scientific mind and courage of a true revolutionary. To me the standout was the geunie humanitarian concerns u pointed out, even after an scientific investigation.
Keep enlightening!
How and why does a placebo work? I've always wondered about that. Is that still a mystery or are there any theories or studies on this?