@@Wk18thalait's chori and dakaiti of rationalism and scientific method... it will only make people fools and lead deepen the demographic disaster even more.
Getsetfly science used to be an amazing science channel. I wouldn't hesitate to say that my introduction to rationality and scientific thinking was from that channel. That being said it is really sad how downhill gsf science has gone with time. Seems like the guy sacrificed his principles to gain a bigger audience.
yes I also think somewhat like this.. but other than very few recent videos, he is still doing good job in making us think rationally.. pls correct me if wrong😄
Man if you observe the behavioral pattern that emerges out a collective behavior of primates are all religious patterns . Which can be shown statistically. So this athiest guy himself is being unscientific when he trying to destroy religion... which is scientifically impossible...as religious pattern is evolutionary hardwired for survival For example if you obseve the collective patterns of woke culture... individually most of them are athiest with no religion .. But if you observe there behaviorial patterns in a collective .. it has all properties of religion .. with set of narratives that defines boundaries of acceptability, with moral policing and blasphemy whoever challenges there central narrative. I would like to state that at the present stage woke culture has stronger religious baring with more intense moral policing and blasphemy laws than Christianity in present day ... because you can joke about jesus left right and center but you can't dare to challenge there narrative or else you will be punished or cancelled from all the platforms.
Hi Pranav, I see your channel as 'News Laundry' of Indian Sci-com. With the democratization of media and rise of independent content, it's also necessary to put checks and balances in place. SiD is one of the few channels which keeps a check on Indian SciCom. I have not watched all of your videos. But I have watched a few and they are amazing. We might disagree on certain aspects(Which is fine). But, your content is really helpful for me as a Science Communicator. This is helping me develop a critical perspective for my own content as well. I assume that this niche might not attract masses as others do. But it's a noble deed. We need more people like you. And more support from community for channels like this one. 😇 Ayush
@@scienceisdope I think you should see News Laundry's comments on Chandrayaan 3. He spread his mahan Gyan that none of the countries sending mission to moon & it's a waste of money. So, if you proudly accept that you are equivalent to News Laundry, then you're lowering ur own standards.
@@Agnosticcc-x3m don't act up, I understand your pain, I know it hurts when some independent media anchor criticizes your favourite supreme leader MODI, I mean how can someone question your supreme autocratic leader, though he has bought the whole national media for praising him for killing people of different religion and ignoring all the national issues, I'm sure you take interest in watching these sold out anchors asking nonsensical questions to your fav supreme leader, as for me i am fine with news laundry pointing out issues like unemployment, inflation, manipur
Science is not about results, science is about process. Aryabhatta didn't know what formula he will get, Einstein didn't knew about final result of General theory of relativity and Newton also didn't knew about final answer. They all just followed process and evidences.
Gaurav has justified all the points from scriptures but this guy is also similar like others who is just believing that no that can't be right and reacting to only some points of gaurav video without any proper counter argument. He is just a type of person I used to be when anyone even tries to say something scientific about scripture I used to decline by just calling myself a rationalist for whom science is everything but as a rational person your duty is to look at others claims also scientifically with proper evidence and that's what gaurav BHAIYA did and given all the evidence.. What this guy will say about RAMANUJAM who says that EQUATION used to come in my mind automatically which were absolutely correct.Did this guy think Ramanujam must have invented "equationometer"😂 to discover those equations😂
@@Atheisttandpatrioticdid you even watch video? Literally he debunked every shlokas. Gaurav said 1 yojan =9.9 miles but in Hanuman chalisa everyone took 1 yojan as 8 miles like every one wants to take Their own number to suit their own agenda. Looks like you are andhbhakt.
@@logohub1234what else do you expect from him?? The moment he said that typical "I "used" to be a rationalist and believe that science is everything" I knew he isn't a person who would watch the whole video and understand what pranav actually said rather he's a person would would either watch the whole video but still won't believe it coz of his biasness or just watch a small portion of the video and decides that "nahh man, this dude is lying, i wouldn't watch the whole video still I know that this dude is wrong and gaurav is right coz he "tries" to connect hinduism with science "
Yep, His Videos on any Science topic are very good.... But, When it comes to Religion.... He makes totally Biased Video without any research and evidence.... He should stop getting biased towards religion.....
@@fnsjit733 he thinks his entire audiences are fool or blind. Catched his propaganda long ago. Now his sister is doing that as well. Turant unsuscribed the day I noticed 😂😂
You know, I was once one of these people who posted hate comments below your videos, ig atleast a year back. But recently, as I have learnt to 'listen' more and talk less, I have come to respect so many of your opinions. It was as if I was filled with these, these non sensical pseudo positive narratives which whenever I heard, I used to feel really good without even rechecking the facts. Thank you so much to help me understand this!
India's Vedic texts are a treasure trove of ancient knowledge, encompassing a wide range of subjects such as mathematics, astronomy, medicine, and philosophy. These texts reflect the sophisticated understanding and advanced intellectual achievements of ancient Indian scholars. Below is a detailed analysis of some of the most notable contributions from Vedic literature. ### Mathematics **1. Concept of Zero:** The concept of zero as a number was developed by Indian mathematicians. This revolutionary idea is attributed to Brahmagupta, who in the 7th century provided a formal definition of zero and its mathematical operations in his seminal work, the *Brahmasphutasiddhanta*. **2. Decimal System:** The decimal system, which is the foundation of modern arithmetic, was first documented in India. The place-value notation and the use of ten as a base for counting were critical developments in mathematical history. **3. Algebra and Trigonometry:** - **Aryabhata (476-550 CE):** Aryabhata's *Aryabhatiya* is a landmark text that covers arithmetic, algebra, plane trigonometry, and spherical trigonometry. Aryabhata introduced the concept of sine and cosine, which are fundamental in trigonometry. - **Bhaskara II (1114-1185 CE):** In his work *Lilavati*, Bhaskara II provided solutions to various algebraic equations and developed methods that are remarkably advanced for their time. ### Astronomy **1. Aryabhata's Contributions:** Aryabhata's *Aryabhatiya* also made significant contributions to astronomy. He proposed a heliocentric model where the Earth rotates on its axis, a concept that predated Copernicus by over a thousand years. Aryabhata accurately calculated the length of the solar year and provided detailed explanations of solar and lunar eclipses. **2. Surya Siddhanta:** The *Surya Siddhanta* is an ancient astronomical treatise that outlines various astronomical calculations and models. It includes methods for calculating the positions of planets, eclipses, and other celestial phenomena with remarkable precision. ### Medicine **1. Ayurveda:** Ayurveda, the traditional system of medicine in India, is documented in ancient texts such as the *Charaka Samhita* and the *Sushruta Samhita*. - **Charaka Samhita:** Attributed to Charaka, this text is a comprehensive guide on internal medicine, discussing various diseases, their diagnosis, and treatment methods. It emphasizes the balance of bodily humors (doshas) and includes detailed descriptions of numerous medicinal plants. - **Sushruta Samhita:** Attributed to Sushruta, this text is one of the earliest works on surgery. It describes various surgical techniques, including rhinoplasty (reconstructive surgery of the nose), cataract surgery, and procedures for treating fractures and wounds. ### Philosophy and Metaphysics **1. The Upanishads:** The Upanishads are philosophical texts that explore the nature of reality and the self. They form the basis of Vedanta, one of the six orthodox schools of Hindu philosophy. - **Concept of Brahman and Atman:** The Upanishads discuss the ultimate reality (Brahman) and the individual soul (Atman), emphasizing their unity. The famous Mahavakya (great sayings) like "Tat Tvam Asi" (Thou art That) from the *Chandogya Upanishad* encapsulate this profound philosophical idea. **2. Bhagavad Gita:** Part of the Mahabharata, the Bhagavad Gita is a 700-verse text that addresses the moral and philosophical dilemmas faced by Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukshetra. It covers a wide range of topics including duty (dharma), righteousness, and the paths of devotion (bhakti), knowledge (jnana), and action (karma). ### Linguistics and Grammar **1. Panini's Ashtadhyayi:** Panini's *Ashtadhyayi* is an ancient Sanskrit grammar that lays down rules for the morphology and syntax of Sanskrit. Composed around the 4th century BCE, it is one of the earliest and most comprehensive linguistic analyses, setting the standard for linguistic theory and descriptive grammar. ### Conclusion The Vedic texts reflect an advanced level of knowledge in various fields that was unparalleled in the ancient world. They illustrate the sophisticated intellectual pursuits of ancient Indian scholars and their contributions to global knowledge. Despite the disruptions caused by later historical events, the legacy of Vedic scholarship continues to be a source of inspiration and pride.
Let’s take a look at what i found in Vedas : 1. EARTH IS STATIONARY - RIG VEDA 3.30.4 2. EARTH IS FLAT - ATHARVA VEDA 15.7.1 3. BULL IS HOLDING UP THE EARTH - ATHARVA VEDA 4.11.1 4. SUN MOVES AROUND EARTH WITH A CHARIOT PULLED BY HORSES - ATHARVA VEDA 6.8.3 5. URINE IS A POTENT REMEDY AND DRINK OF THE GODS - ATHARVA VEDA 6.44.3 It would take me hours to write down everything. I do agree with the 5th Point .
Any Sanskrit word related to “flat” has not been mentioned in any of the vedas so your comment is refutable also a hymn in vedas are composed of more than 9 words but rigveda 3/30/4,atharveda 6.8.3 have contained only three and 9 words which is again refutable. So one doesn't even need to cross check your claims.
@@itsoblivion8124 Hah don’t you understand what literal reading is ? Science doesn’t depend on metaphors… if it does then that is not science. Go play with your poetic metaphysical lines . They have nothing to do with science
Videos like these have an audience, creators are aware of it hence they make these stupid videos kudos to you Pranav for debunking these pseudoscientific claims and bearing all the hate.
Man if you observe the behavioral pattern that emerges out a collective behavior of primates are all religious patterns . Which can be shown statistically. So this athiest guy himself is being unscientific when he trying to destroy religion... which is scientifically impossible...as religious pattern is evolutionary hardwired for survival For example if you obseve the collective patterns of woke culture... individually most of them are athiest with no religion .. But if you observe there behaviorial patterns in a collective .. it has all properties of religion .. with set of narratives that defines boundaries of acceptability, with moral policing and blasphemy whoever challenges there central narrative. I would like to state that at the present stage woke culture has stronger religious baring with more intense moral policing and blasphemy laws than Christianity in present day ... because you can joke about jesus left right and center but you can't dare to challenge there narrative or else you will be punished or cancelled from all the platforms.
Exactly. They started their YT career at the same time and they're friends. They know the YT business. No wonder, to attract mass audience they compromised with their principles.
You're absolutely nailing it my big brother! It's such a pleasure to be able to see such a high quality video talking about rationality and as well as demystifying the distorted pseudo scientific wave ! Keep up the good work ill always support you
Finally someone made a video against Gaurav's Double standard.. As a science lover i used to watch his videos but dunno why he has turned towards rightist biasedness...
🙂👍 Wrong guy wrong section wrong time I know ...but it feels really good to meet people who really feel like me.... everywhere I go I see idiots blindly believing in everything related to religion....God really created some good people like u ...The other believers goes to hell
Bruh you think he doesn't know what he's doing??? 😂😂😂😂... He is one of the most old RUclipsrs and he knows what the audience wants . He doesn't care about the facts
**Title:** "Analyzing Bias and Misrepresentation in a Science Video" **Summary:** This video response critically examines another video that attempts to draw connections between ancient Indian scriptures and modern scientific concepts. The response video, created by Pranav, highlights various flaws, biases, and inaccuracies in the original video's arguments. It questions the interpretation of certain scriptures, mathematical calculations, and the overall scientific rigor of the claims made in the video. Pranav argues that such attempts to link religion and science can mislead and give a false impression of how science works. **Key Points and Takeaways:** 1. **Introduction and Context:** Pranav begins by introducing the video he is responding to and highlights his respect for the original content creator as a science communicator. He acknowledges that the creator's channel usually covers scientific topics effectively but questions their approach when discussing religion. 2. **Cherry-Picking Topics:** Pranav criticizes the original video for selectively choosing topics to investigate and not covering all the aspects mentioned in the source material. He argues that cherry-picking can cater to the biases of the audience and does not promote a rational or unbiased examination. 3. **Questionable Interpretations:** Pranav raises concerns about the interpretations of ancient scriptures in the original video, particularly when it comes to linking them to modern scientific concepts. He highlights that these interpretations may lack evidence and can lead to misconceptions about how science operates. 4. **Errors in Calculations:** Pranav points out errors in calculations made in the original video to determine the speed of light based on ancient measurements. He emphasizes that such inaccuracies can mislead viewers and undermine the credibility of the claims. 5. **Appeal to Authority:** The response video criticizes the original video for using appeals to authority, such as quoting scientists like Schrödinger and Heisenberg, to bolster its arguments. Pranav argues that this doesn't necessarily validate the claims made. 6. **Middle Ground Fallacy:** Pranav challenges the original video's assertion that taking a middle ground between science and religion is a reasonable approach. He contends that seeking a middle ground between two extremes doesn't necessarily lead to a rational conclusion and emphasizes the importance of evidence-based reasoning. 7. **Philosophy Comparison:** The response video points out an error in the original video's classification of Indian philosophies, stating that the categorization of astika and nastika schools doesn't align with the definitions of these terms. 8. **Promotion of Skepticism:** Pranav underscores the importance of skepticism and critical thinking in evaluating claims, especially when it comes to topics like the intersection of science and religion. He encourages viewers to consider evidence and question assertions. 9. **Support for the Creator:** Pranav promotes support for his own content via various platforms, including Patreon, RUclips memberships, and Nas IOU, emphasizing the significance of fan support for creators like himself. In summary, the response video highlights several shortcomings and biases in the original content's attempt to link ancient Indian scriptures with modern science. It underscores the need for critical thinking and evidence-based reasoning in such discussions.
Thanks man this is really good. Please upvote and help it reach the top, I can't rewove my pinned comment as it has sponsor. Btw did you write this yourself or use a tool?
Well I personally really respect Gaurav as he also promotes rational thinking. I think he might be willing to have a discussion with Pranav. Let's hope he does agree for the discussion
@@spuriusscapula4829well I don't really understand why people want validation of their religion from science. Shouldn't you be confident enough in your faith ?Honestly I believe that religion is not a science. So if you analyse religion using scientific explanations or theories that would be a wrong approach. I believe if we want to really analyse religion we need to go into philosophy, theology etc.
@@MrdacrazecatI only find these hindoo sanghis doing all the time.Sanghis made their religion their whole personality.Nowadays youtubers like gaurav fools makes bullshit video like this to get views.These people would go to any level to prove how great their religion is.They will claim hindoo sunak.4-5 Africans converted to Hinduism they made an entire video how Hinduism is rising in Africa 🤣.It is based on Inferiority complex.
I Appreciate pranav for shedding light on the distinction between science and pattern-seeking in Hindu mythology. It's important to separate fact from fiction in these discussions. Keep up the great work in promoting scientific understanding!
To compare Hindu religion with science, Hanuman had eaten the sun, say this, Varaha had lifted the earth, say this, 5000 years ago men of 10 head how, say this.
Grow up child.You need to be mature. have you ever read Vedas?If we had kept our Vedas and Sanskrit.Answer me how India was the golden bird.You are like a illetrate here talking about world.
Most atheists were born into some religion and what caused them to move away was curiousity and asking questions. The reason why people think that athesits are hell bent on proving religious scriptures wrong is basically them not wanting to ask or entertain questions. As a former religious nut this is very familiar to me cz religion gives you instructions and does the ground work for you on what to do and gives simplistic reasons for it, you dont have to use your brains and a lot of people, especially from difficult realities, want this. Religion targets the vulnerable, gives you escapist narratives which gives people an addictive dopamine hit constantly.
hinduism gives you freedom. In hinduism, one does not have to be a devotee or even pray. All one has to do is one's duty towards society. One must show kindness, compassion and empathy towards others. One must simply pursue knowledge.
@@Vededits6542 feelingggg prouuddd hindu armyyyyy good job that's very hindu of you first you discriminate your fellow religion mates then blame them for converting to other religions
@@shreshtharya9967Then for all these things you don’t really need to be a part of any religion or believe in god, you just have to a rational human. Its basic humanity that all religions preach in the name of spirituality
Haters are the only people who came here to spit poisons without watching the video .......... Hope they'll watch the whole video not try to cherrypick.....
@@mr.gamerkabir8142 No need to read scriptures, the so called hindu nationalists who claim to have read the scriptures have made fool of themseleves with their non sense, unscientific and weak claims which they say have come from "science of vedas"! This is enough to conclude vedas don't have science!
Glad you noticed his agenda. Tho I used to like Gaurav because of space science videos, but unsuscribed his another channel. You're doing an amazing job Pranav👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I love our history (mythology?) But we definitely need evidence , proof, theorems which are directly indicating to the topic and not just writings which can be interpreted in many different ways
The thing is these so called Rationalists ( Getsetpseudoscience )confuse Scriptural Philosophy & Metaphysics with Science. And that’s all you need to make a fool out of people who merely understand what science is and that gives their cognitive biases a boost. Keep the good work going Pranav 👏
Which no one gives fuck😂😂 for real. My parents told this article since childhood but even in school I never observed any teachers celebrating or explaining about this one particular highly important thing in constitution.
Hi pranav , glad to see your video on him..please make shorts of your videos...so it will be helpful for us to share your shorts and get subscribers to spread awareness..❤👍
Science is dope is that guy who would call samudragupta indian napolean even though samudragupta came before him. Reason ...well the european writers said it .😅
Egos are everywhere dude, you can't deny that lot of 'rational people' self-professed or otherwise usually revel in the notion that they are 'smarter' or 'superior' because they are more 'educated' or 'knowledgeable'. True or not, ego is still very much in play.
very well put together . Most of the people in pranav's comments arent even rational , they are just elitist , who feel they are superior than rest of the Indian population , just because they dont feed into the pseudoscience narrative of select few youtubers . The first and the most Important step to learn , is to give up your damn ego and accept you know nothing, lets all accept that dunning kruger effect is real
How is this relevant to anything being said here? We don't make blanket statement here bud. If you have a query put forth a solid argument. He weekly reacts to them in his live streams.
@@berserk322 in this video he seems to imply only nationalists have egos that can get 'popped' . My comment was merely pointing out that everyone here: "rationalist" Or otherwise are operating on their egos and not their intellects
Thanks for this video man, I think the sooner ppl in our country gain media literacy the better off we will be. The combination of cognitive bias and social media algorithms are destroying the current generation.
this is not a hate comment first of all but just noticed that this person (Science is Dope) is going into a more mental oriented debate instead of cross checking the facts and information presented by Getsetflyscience. Hence he himself is making a Logical Fallacy by countering the words, topics chosen and connection to books and authors in a humorous way that is making people think the claims made initially as just fallacies rather than going into the actual information which u were meant to cross check for making a conclusion that Science came from hinduism or not...... think it wisely everybody, everybody iis content creator and have their own fields of growth, they are doing what they are meant to ( wo alag baat h ki inka goal kuch bhi krke samne wale ko galat dikhana h) hence it is what it is, really cant do anything about them :)
Thanks god someone got it,I watched whole video but this guy haven't proved any point of gaurav's wrong.He is just saying it as wrong without a single counter argument and fact
I think that while you wanted a rational debate, looking at the comments section, you ended up villainising Gaurav a bit. Overall, I found your video to be a little nitpicky, I will clarify a couple of things related to your questions on the speed of the light claim: 1. You quote him talking about uncertainties of these units like Yojana and Nimesha and then make a contradictory claim stating he does not mention any uncertainties! Did you expect him to put a disclaimer once every five second talking about the uncertainties?! The way I see it, He very clearly put a disclaimer talking about these units not being standardized and the possibility of them getting conveniently interpreted. 2. 1 Dhanu = 6 feet on an average claim: You say, "where did he get this value from? I don't know". He has taken it from the paper by Subhash Kak(Go to his video and pause on 20.04th minute), in that paper he quotes Kautilya's Arthashastra as the source for that. Even Kak clearly mentions that Yojana can be interpreted as multiple things and states his reasoning for choosing 1 Yojana = 9 miles. 3. I looked at 3 Sanskrit dictionaries that are reputed and here is what they say about Yojana: VS Apte: A measure of distance equal to four Krośas or eight or nine miles Monier-Williams: a distance traversed in one harnessing or without unyoking; especially a particular measure of distance, sometimes regarded as equal to 4 or 5 English miles, but more correctly = 4 krośa-s or about 9 miles;according to other calculations = 2 1/2 English miles, and according to some = 8 krośa-s) etc Arthur Anthony Macdonell: a measure of distance equal to four krosas or about nine English miles 4. You bring the Hanuman Chalisa bit. If somebody making a claim about Hanuman Chalisa says that 1 Yojana = 8 miles, why should Gaurav be held accountable for that? 5. 1 nimesha = 0.2 seconds, you talk about no reasons being mentioned for that. He actually shows the screenshot for the source at around 20.21 minute. He is taking it from the 4th page of the following book: Units of Measurement: Past, Present and Future. International System of Units By S. V. Gupta The paper by Subhash Kak also takes the same stance. 6. All said, the calculation error that you point out is valid. For the details of the actual calculation we have to look at the paper by Subhash Kak and the sources that he cites and examine the claims there. Anyway, read Subhash Kak's paper, that will answer many of your quetions: browse.arxiv.org/pdf/physics/9804020.pdf
So are you saying all the concepts I learned from Irodov , HC Verma , Resnick Halliday , Loney etc. 10 years ago for my Engineering exam were a waste of time . Goddam Pranav , I’m furious at my Physics teacher for not telling me about the Vedas back then .
The sad truth is that this is not just a weird RUclipsr spreading pseudoscience.It's in the movies,media,print, advertisement,naming cities, building monuments,etc etc.We are busy trying to portray India as some kind of glory land with Wifi,Planes, astronomical knowledge and time travel until some foreign rulers came and conquered them.And the worst thing is people are going to get influenced by all of this and will slowly start to form an opinion that some of the people in our country are truly "outsiders".And just give it time to reflect in elections and then we'll have a fully religious state.🎉
As if USA is perfect. Dude, stop thinking only India has this, look at Islam and Christianity. When do u people LEARN to be FAIR... Open ur eyes and look at the world.
@@Agnosticcc-x3m hehe I didn't get to choose my name.But you decided to judge people based on their names 😵.And I am not religious one bit.And just because USA is doing it or Pakistan is doing it doesn't mean it's okay! And Israel,USA are poor examples because they don't have this kind of diversity and each group having a significant population load.Israel literally has a single group of people in that country.(kinda same with USA).In India,super religiosity in polity will NOT lead to progress and develop.Things are going to get out of control at one point. All it takes is a slight provocation from any of the sides and we'll have a full fledged communal riot/mob lynching in almost anywhere in India now. Thanks to all the propaganda and emotional build up done by so called nationalist youtubers,media,influencers etc etc.
the first thing I dont understand and have a problem with , is people saying "western science " . Wtf is even western science , science emerged due to the collective efforts of humanity and no special group or part of world has the right to call it solely their creation
Hi Pranav, appreciate your hardwork in this video,but what I've found after some research is that the statement about the Speed of light in vedas is quite right. Consider the below verse from (Rig-veda book I, chapter 50, hymn 4) “Yojananam Dwe Dwe Shate Dwe Cha Yojane Aken Nimishardena Kramana Namostute” In the above verse, Nimishardhena means Half Nimisha, Dwe means “two” & shate means “Hundred”, So the above means “Sun light travels 2202 Yojanas in half Nimisha.” Yojana and Nimisha are the vedic units of distance and time respectively which can be expressed in many ways like Nimishardhena means half of nimesa. Nimisa means winking the eye. According to science, our eyes wink five times in one second. So, Nimishardhena is 0.1 seconds. (1/5 * 1/2) 1 Yojana =8000 Purushu(man’s height)= 8000* 6 feet=14.63 km~9 miles Monier Williams further derived the value of yojana based on his research as 9 miles i.e. 14.48 km. Considering the above units, speed of light in modern SI unit can be calculated as distance/time = 2202 x 9 / 0.1056 = 19818/0.1056 = 187670.45 miles per second Which is very close to the value which modern science derives. That is 186000 miles per second
@@lightningrodMC This is my own research across the web and i don't remember much links. My best suggestion for you is to again search these up. You can type in the question "Is the value of the speed of light mentioned in Hindu Vedas?" and you will get many results
As a sanatani and science lover i just want to say one thing that don't mix science with any religion or dharma cause there is no similarity between these, Science is science and religion is religion 😂😂😂 but some andbhakt would deny that and will tell that science came from sanatan, many will tell that it came from islam but reality is that science is science which is universal truth and it didn't come from any religion so don't mix these two things.
you are right and wrong logic is a limitation for our minds anything that we've haven't seen from our eyes or haven't seen a very big number of people's accepting it we don't believe it........... Science doesn't make anything=Anything make science... if there's nothing there's no science... Science is way to know how Things work what are They Why are They science doesn't came from any religion neither HINDUISM OR Islam............... But it came from human mind . And for celerity sake i'am a Muslim and a Science Nerd❤ And I don't know if you believe in God or not..... but there is something that created this which we are living in... if i bring you a camera and say in billions of years space dust geatherd and this thing while can capture and record came in existence would you gonna believe it What am expecting your answer is no...... and we humans and this universe is way much complicated that that camera . science doesn't came from religion neither religion came from science as a Muslim what i believe is this life is a test for us how we do what we do..... and science is pretty much a way to live life now.and religion is also a way to live life is a particular way that harm no one is this time no one literally no one neither I follow my religion 100%. and in Quran there are many references of events which science have told us about like big bang and all if you want i can tell you about those .
@@K-SHABABScience in Qur'an 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. The same Qur'an which says Sperms come from between the loins and the ribs ? 😂😂😂 The same Qur'an which says Earth is flat ? The same Qur'an which says the first human beings were made by mud ? 😂😂😂😂 The same Qur'an which says no human can go above the ground? 😂😂😂😂The same Quran which says Donkeys can fly ? The same Qur'an which promotes drinking camel urine as medicine? 😂😂😂😂 The same Qur'an which says Mohammed splited the moon in two half by his finger ? 😂😂😂😂. You are funny af
I got a job opportunity in Getsetfly science a year ago I guess. I told them I would look at their content and will let them know. Fortunately I was smart enough to realise what are they trying to do. (Yes I denied the opportunity) Most of the information they provided was quite good but it does feel irrational a number of times when you scrutinize it. It may appear good for some people who aren't from a science background but ultimately its creating a bias inside young minds that "WE know it before THEY do! ".
Thank you pranav for this video. When I watched video of GSFS there were some red flags but I didn't pointed out thinking it just my lack of knowledge but after this all my questions are clear! Thank you.
Hi Pranav , I Love Watching your videos..i wanted to ask you this here because of this -16:33.. At least based on the clip of GSFS in this video at 15:18, Gaurav doesn't say that it resembles or explains time dilation(even tho that was what he said he would talk about), he says that it shows that there was an understanding of time being relative.. but you only explained how what Gaurav said does not have anything to do with Time dilation and not much about how it is unrelated to the idea of time being relative.. altho u did speak about how we understood that it is quantities that change ..but that was before playing the clip..either it's a misunderstanding on my part or the time at which the clip of GSFS was played was wrong or misplaced..can you please clarify..
I completely agree with you Pranav. I was very much dissappointed by Gaurav after I watched his this very video. I was a big fan of him when he used to make space related videos earlier, but since last few years I can see he is much more biased towards the current government and religion. Thanks for making a video, hope this reaches out to him, we will be happy to see the rational Gaurav back.
in neils bohr's book, he has written "quantum physics will not be confusing to those who have mastered the vedanta"....not just hindus, only those who studied vedanta
Thanks for your contribution to debunking the pseudo scientific claims with religious bias!!!! U r a man with big brain and steel heart to fight against the agenda of making Veda as a source of science.
@@amanjha890it’s neither connected to melecha Islam created Hinduism …another name of secular . SANATANA IS ONLY RELIGION. Everything else is of cults. To understand that you must be intelligent very, and an atheist cannot speak about reason and science in evidence, because because he can, he couldn’t figure out something he couldn’t understand so he came in atheist the easy way out that means another word for can’t understand or naturally something like that is Pondo
These questions must be asked because GetSetFly is one of those channels that promote Rational Thinking and cover many topics... So if he is doing something wrong (For Whatever reason), that needs to be called out...
When i saw that video of Gaurav. I was confused about how vedas got the speed of light right and really needed your video to cross verify it. Thanks for saving me from falling into this pit of misinterpretation of vedas
read your previous comment: Consider the below verse from (Rig-veda book I, chapter 50, hymn 4) “Yojananam Dwe Dwe Shate Dwe Cha Yojane Aken Nimishardena Kramana Namostute” In the above verse, Nimishardhena means Half Nimisha, Dwe means “two” & shate means “Hundred”, So the above means “Sun light travels 2202 Yojanas in half Nimisha.” Yojana and Nimisha are the vedic units of distance and time respectively which can be expressed in many ways like Nimishardhena means half of nimesa. Nimisa means winking the eye. According to science, our eyes wink five times in one second. So, Nimishardhena is 0.1 seconds. (1/5 * 1/2) 1 Yojana =8000 Purushu(man’s height)= 8000* 6 feet=14.63 km~9 miles Monier Williams further derived the value of yojana based on his research as 9 miles i.e. 14.48 km. Considering the above units, speed of light in modern SI unit can be calculated as distance/time = 2202 x 9 / 0.1056 = 19818/0.1056 = 187670.45 miles per second Which is very close to the value which modern science derives. That is 186000 miles per second
Purana stories are symbolic , there are many symbolism in Ramayana also like Hanuman ji is symbol of having devotion in god , surrender your kamra and ego , this the meaning of Hanuman ji
@@mr.gamerkabir8142 purano ka history se lene dena nhi hai but ho sakta hai Hanuman ji ho , par hame purano ke symbols ko samajna chahiye , usme philosophy hai , Hanuman ji kaliyug ma hai ki nhi pata nhi par Hanuman ji ke vyaktitva (character) se bohot kuch sikha ja sakta hai
I am totally agreeing with you in this video.But I think debunking the whole ancient indian society as a non scientific one is an absolute nonsense. There used to be great respect to scientific things those days.There were many great universities in india those days like Takshasila, Nalanda ,etc..where people from different parts of world used to get there to study about different aspects of sciences and humanitarians.Many of those things might not be very relavent today but the nature of indian society must be noted..Many things those were thought scientifically correct in the 19th century by those scientific societies were thought to be absolutely not true by the 20th century. As a medical student I totally object the practice of Ayurveda these days. But it is a very great thing in those days which has many aspects of scientific achievements. THE THING IS THOSE ARE NOT JUST RELAVENT TO THIS DAY ANYMORE. The thing which is relavent today won't be relavent anymore in about 50 to 100 years. THIS DOESN'T MEAN PEOPLE OF THIS LAND WERE NOT RATIONAL IN THE COVER OF RELEGION.They usually never priorotized the unproven facts written in some relegious books over the proven scientific ones(Which used to be in the the other parts of world)(you know what happened to Galelio and Copernicus ). And the main thing is the institutions of scientific methodologies in india were destroyed (Takshasila ,Nalanda,etc..)so from then so no advancements occured from then to be relavent to this day.(Read about why Md.Khaliji destroyed nalanda)
I wish they do the same with Sham Sharma show.That due criticizes secularism, liberalism wants India to be a Hindoo rastra but lives in New Zealand and married to white woman.Pretty sure he is also fooling his audience and making a living out of it.I wonder why that sanatani Sher deshbhakt don't live in India.Why he is living in a secular country.
@@KANGZZZ.I know for certain you'll be the the first one to flee the country if you get a chance, and india is a secular country because of the hindu majority not because of constitution or sume other bs. Iran, saudi even fck8n north korea and china have a constitution that doesnt make them secuarl, the people does and fortunately for this counry hindu are the majority .
His followers are as dumb as him , he haven't shown any proof and or explained any topic in depth he just passed his thoughts and philosophy and think is rational and logical
Comparing the date of the Baudhayana text to Pythagoras is silly. The theorem was widely known throughout the ancient world, likely also India, centuries before either came around.
Just a thought.... Why does it always happens that we try to show the "we first" evidence for a already proven technology. And why not technology which will be used 15 - 20 Yrs in future... 🤔 For example quantum computing, vaccum travel etc...
He also went too far by promoting apps like binamo and such things. I mean yeah he can do whatever he want. But as someone with that much following with teenagers watching his videos he could have been more responsible for the things he promote and the type of content he makes
I was a huge fan of this channel around 2 years ago when this channel was neutral and didn't promoted any propaganda. It was one of the best fact channel back then when it was not a hindutva fact channel. Now this channel is just plain bs. Glad you exposed this channel. BTW I know where his turning point came from, it was from that one Mughal video where he unbiasedly described both positive and negative aspects of the Mughals but the "certain" section got trigerred and trolled him, then he make another video on the same mughals but this time from their perspective and rest is what it is now. 😂😂😂😂
He is possibly paid by Atheist organizations, and doing propaganda. Even a religion like Hinduism which is based on spiritual practices, has to be tried. You can not make judgement about others, without reaching that level of spiritual acoomplishments.
Man if you observe the behavioral pattern that emerges out a collective behavior of primates are all religious patterns . Which can be shown statistically. So this athiest guy himself is being unscientific when he trying to destroy religion... which is scientifically impossible...as religious pattern is evolutionary hardwired for survival For example if you obseve the collective patterns of woke culture... individually most of them are athiest with no religion .. But if you observe there behaviorial patterns in a collective .. it has all properties of religion .. with set of narratives that defines boundaries of acceptability, with moral policing and blasphemy whoever challenges there central narrative. I would like to state that at the present stage woke culture has stronger religious baring with more intense moral policing and blasphemy laws than Christianity in present day ... because you can joke about jesus left right and center but you can't dare to challenge there narrative or else you will be punished or cancelled from all the platforms.
Even a scientist has to leave his/her scientific temper outside the temple, church or mosques' gate and enter them just by faith. And once he/she enters the lab they should leave religious faith outside the lab and only give way to reason, intuition, scientific assumptions and perspectives. This is how they can make good knowledge in the respective areas. Otherwise they are just confusing themselves and others and being experts in a field they should behave responsibly.
If you really want to know the corelation of science and religion, one should always take Einstien's "Science and Religion" essay. He just nailed the debate.
@@ajayagrawal4687 isn't it true, suppose I just tell some arbitrary facts and back it with science without giving the exact corelation, will it be considered as science. take another example: from ancient times people have noticed, observing lightning, that rubbing woollen cloth on any insulating material produces Static electricity, will you conclude that woolen and any insulating material are best conductors of electricity? *I had to edit the word PVC with insulator as you might hang to that simple error.
@@ranadityapandey4458that is not how science work and no body just back up anything with science. Science deals with objective reality- space and universe etc. Any thing subjective doesn't count and there are many people who try to pedel unscientific idea with science and maybe that is what you are reffering. You should talk once you have understanding of scientific methodology and experiments methodology. Logical and critical thinking courses and scientific thinking which is absent from school curriculum. Like me I got it from outside support
@@ranadityapandey4458yes it will consider as experimental science But not whole truth as far as reason are not known While when we get the reasons for it. We will modify it or change it accordingly Which is missing in religion that the problem
@@ranadityapandey4458which mean that anything said by scientists is not right and scientific unless it undergoes the peer reviewed and published in proper journal. Multiple trials are performed on the matter. If Einstein said that apples are rainbow 🌈 in colour people like me will not accept it unless there are observations, experiments, test results, multiple trial across the world and peer reviewed then published. Blind followers of Einstein may accept but not people like me who come from science background
I used to watch this GetsetflySCIENCE channel sometimes but recently after watching him i sense something selfish, something irrational like here in the video saying "as a science dharam(religion)4:32". I am not comfortable with terms like this where people mix the word science and religion. My point is everyone can change but the important think is your reason for changing self. I subscribed your channel just now because of the distance between sun and earth from hanuman chalisa video, You saved me a lot of time but that doesn't mean you will always be correct, i am not talking about technical incorrection but slowly turning into some kind of biased irrational person but i hope people like you stay the way you are right now, logical...
@my_father_sorry_i_am_lying_now Well you're absolutely wrong about everything you have written... But HEY.... I DON'T CARE.... If you really think it's true then good luck, really no offence ( the only thing you were right about is plastics surgery and which really does not have anything to do with veda)... But if you think it has something to do with vedas... Then again I DON'T CARE... You just keep believing what you believe... Now Peace❤❤❤
@my_father_sorry_i_am_lying_now ling of shiva never had been found in indus valley civilization There is multiple headed man which is assumed as pashupati nath by indologist but many didn't called it pashupati . and believe me ling never found And surgery all around the world had happening nothing special about it Almost 3000 yr back body had found in Africa where the amputation had been done 😅😅so think from brain not from emotions
@my_father_sorry_i_am_lying_now 😂lol I can debunk your whole life just not lies 😂 the first ‘surgeons’ practised in the Neolithic period, drilling a hole in skulls, probably to allow an evil spirit to escape but likely unknowingly treating epilepsy, headache or insanity, Friedenberg explains. Surprisingly, he adds, (more patients recovered than died from the procedure). Pub med Surgery is not begans by charak it's being modified by him lol Egypt, about 3000 BC, surgeons were immobilizing fractures, excising tumours and suturing wounds with linen thread. But what is most significant in the development of surgery, Friedenberg notes, was how the mummification of bodies taught surgeons about anatomy, improving their diagnosis and treatment of the living. 😁😁😁😁 Source - pub med a history of surgery
its so fun when we hear that vedas claim literally all modern science topics including quantum physics yet indians follow none of them and believe in gaumutra
Hey Pranav, the actual debunking starts at 8min 40sec. The first 8 minutes is more of introductions and fair usage of data etc. These introductions won't retain the attention of people who watch ur channel for the first time, and they will skip the video. Please start the videos directly with the actual topic and keep generic introductions towards the end of add in description. Particularly Young generation don't have patience unless the opening statements are captivating and presents the main topic asap. Love your content bro ❤
The most irrational thing about that man is not the deductions he made about Science in Vedas" but how he chose keep his t-shirt buttons open & reveal his bare chest.
The thing is gaurav Bhai used to tell in his videos that he doesn't believe in such things. Wind changes and religious videos getting more popularity. He switched side's suddenly and started to believe in such things, miraculously
Your is really touch my heart along with the other truth seekers,...... Thank you and I believe people like you still present who share the truth their audience
He just made videos to please his audience and not to prove any point. I Guess his videos should be considered as pure entertainment like TV drama and nothing else.
the thing is even Gaurav knows what he is doing . He knows Indian audience . he is purana khiladi of youtube
Tru af
He is just softly propogating hindutva under the shell of scientific temperament
What wrong in that he is not teaching To do Chori,Daikati Just Saying Positive Thing which anyone can take from their religion..😊
@@Wk18thalait's chori and dakaiti of rationalism and scientific method... it will only make people fools and lead deepen the demographic disaster even more.
@@Wk18thalakadwa sath is better than meetha jhooth.
Actually it harms the overall intelligence of people watching it.
Getsetfly science used to be an amazing science channel. I wouldn't hesitate to say that my introduction to rationality and scientific thinking was from that channel.
That being said it is really sad how downhill gsf science has gone with time. Seems like the guy sacrificed his principles to gain a bigger audience.
exactly bro exactly
Yes, he had been changing recently
@@engineering_studentgurung10 Since the nationalist bug bit him (Hindu nationalist to be specific)
Me too
yes I also think somewhat like this.. but other than very few recent videos, he is still doing good job in making us think rationally..
pls correct me if wrong😄
Yay! You got a sponsor! Happy for you Pranav!!
@@oz_peter Hi :)
Hii
Man if you observe the behavioral pattern that emerges out a collective behavior of primates are all religious patterns . Which can be shown statistically.
So this athiest guy himself is being unscientific when he trying to destroy religion... which is scientifically impossible...as religious pattern is evolutionary hardwired for survival
For example if you obseve the collective patterns of woke culture... individually most of them are athiest with no religion ..
But if you observe there behaviorial patterns in a collective .. it has all properties of religion .. with set of narratives that defines boundaries of acceptability, with moral policing and blasphemy whoever challenges there central narrative.
I would like to state that at the present stage woke culture has stronger religious baring with more intense moral policing and blasphemy laws than Christianity in present day ... because you can joke about jesus left right and center but you can't dare to challenge there narrative or else you will be punished or cancelled from all the platforms.
Hi
Pranav Bro
You are doing real scientific research oriented thinking pedagogy.
Only real scientific method should be promoted.
Hi Pranav,
I see your channel as 'News Laundry' of Indian Sci-com. With the democratization of media and rise of independent content, it's also necessary to put checks and balances in place. SiD is one of the few channels which keeps a check on Indian SciCom.
I have not watched all of your videos. But I have watched a few and they are amazing. We might disagree on certain aspects(Which is fine). But, your content is really helpful for me as a Science Communicator. This is helping me develop a critical perspective for my own content as well.
I assume that this niche might not attract masses as others do. But it's a noble deed. We need more people like you. And more support from community for channels like this one. 😇
Ayush
Thanks man!
Ohh, the infamous news laundry whose main anchor called Chandrayaan 3 is a waste of money.
@@scienceisdope I think you should see News Laundry's comments on Chandrayaan 3. He spread his mahan Gyan that none of the countries sending mission to moon & it's a waste of money. So, if you proudly accept that you are equivalent to News Laundry, then you're lowering ur own standards.
@@Agnosticcc-x3monce news laundry anchor called rajasthan,up and Bihar as gober pati ....... shameful
@@Agnosticcc-x3m don't act up, I understand your pain, I know it hurts when some independent media anchor criticizes your favourite supreme leader MODI, I mean how can someone question your supreme autocratic leader, though he has bought the whole national media for praising him for killing people of different religion and ignoring all the national issues, I'm sure you take interest in watching these sold out anchors asking nonsensical questions to your fav supreme leader, as for me i am fine with news laundry pointing out issues like unemployment, inflation, manipur
Science is not about results, science is about process. Aryabhatta didn't know what formula he will get, Einstein didn't knew about final result of General theory of relativity and Newton also didn't knew about final answer. They all just followed process and evidences.
Nah, science is about reason
@@gvsmani4810yes , using reason for the processes
That's what we need in Indian society...
Respect For Pranav👏👏
Gaurav has justified all the points from scriptures but this guy is also similar like others who is just believing that no that can't be right and reacting to only some points of gaurav video without any proper counter argument. He is just a type of person I used to be when anyone even tries to say something scientific about scripture I used to decline by just calling myself a rationalist for whom science is everything but as a rational person your duty is to look at others claims also scientifically with proper evidence and that's what gaurav BHAIYA did and given all the evidence..
What this guy will say about RAMANUJAM who says that EQUATION used to come in my mind automatically which were absolutely correct.Did this guy think Ramanujam must have invented "equationometer"😂 to discover those equations😂
@@Atheisttandpatrioticdid you even watch video? Literally he debunked every shlokas. Gaurav said 1 yojan =9.9 miles but in Hanuman chalisa everyone took 1 yojan as 8 miles like every one wants to take Their own number to suit their own agenda. Looks like you are andhbhakt.
Yojan value ranges from 8-9 miles.
It's approximate
@@logohub1234
@@logohub1234what else do you expect from him?? The moment he said that typical "I "used" to be a rationalist and believe that science is everything" I knew he isn't a person who would watch the whole video and understand what pranav actually said rather he's a person would would either watch the whole video but still won't believe it coz of his biasness or just watch a small portion of the video and decides that "nahh man, this dude is lying, i wouldn't watch the whole video still I know that this dude is wrong and gaurav is right coz he "tries" to connect hinduism with science "
That's the reason why i stopped watching gaurav's channel
Yep,
His Videos on any Science topic are very good....
But,
When it comes to Religion....
He makes totally Biased Video without any research and evidence....
He should stop getting biased towards religion.....
All his videos are based on science fictions . Moreover he is a bjp agent 😂😂
Disguises as "science man" 😂
@@yomaddy yeah in his second channel all he does is promoting bjp and in the main channel he picks only science fantasy topics
@@fnsjit733 he thinks his entire audiences are fool or blind. Catched his propaganda long ago. Now his sister is doing that as well. Turant unsuscribed the day I noticed 😂😂
@@yomaddyher sister is pro ☕
@@yomaddy Yeah.Double standard.
Gaurav is andbhakt 😂😂😂😂
Aandbhakt
And athiest and pranav is libranchu😂
hes actually not an andhbhakt
he knows indian audience
how to get views
gobarbhakt
L. Andbhakt
You know, I was once one of these people who posted hate comments below your videos, ig atleast a year back. But recently, as I have learnt to 'listen' more and talk less, I have come to respect so many of your opinions. It was as if I was filled with these, these non sensical pseudo positive narratives which whenever I heard, I used to feel really good without even rechecking the facts. Thank you so much to help me understand this!
Much respect brother 🙏 hope more people think like you
@@factteller9640no we are not jihaadi
@@amanjha890 lol what does that thing has to do with my comment I didn't even said anything about that
@@amanjha890how is that related here?
@@sudhanvakashyap297 leave it bro usske sentiment hurt hoo gye hai ye jaan ke ki... nuclear reactors shiving se inspired nhi hai
India's Vedic texts are a treasure trove of ancient knowledge, encompassing a wide range of subjects such as mathematics, astronomy, medicine, and philosophy. These texts reflect the sophisticated understanding and advanced intellectual achievements of ancient Indian scholars. Below is a detailed analysis of some of the most notable contributions from Vedic literature.
### Mathematics
**1. Concept of Zero:**
The concept of zero as a number was developed by Indian mathematicians. This revolutionary idea is attributed to Brahmagupta, who in the 7th century provided a formal definition of zero and its mathematical operations in his seminal work, the *Brahmasphutasiddhanta*.
**2. Decimal System:**
The decimal system, which is the foundation of modern arithmetic, was first documented in India. The place-value notation and the use of ten as a base for counting were critical developments in mathematical history.
**3. Algebra and Trigonometry:**
- **Aryabhata (476-550 CE):** Aryabhata's *Aryabhatiya* is a landmark text that covers arithmetic, algebra, plane trigonometry, and spherical trigonometry. Aryabhata introduced the concept of sine and cosine, which are fundamental in trigonometry.
- **Bhaskara II (1114-1185 CE):** In his work *Lilavati*, Bhaskara II provided solutions to various algebraic equations and developed methods that are remarkably advanced for their time.
### Astronomy
**1. Aryabhata's Contributions:**
Aryabhata's *Aryabhatiya* also made significant contributions to astronomy. He proposed a heliocentric model where the Earth rotates on its axis, a concept that predated Copernicus by over a thousand years. Aryabhata accurately calculated the length of the solar year and provided detailed explanations of solar and lunar eclipses.
**2. Surya Siddhanta:**
The *Surya Siddhanta* is an ancient astronomical treatise that outlines various astronomical calculations and models. It includes methods for calculating the positions of planets, eclipses, and other celestial phenomena with remarkable precision.
### Medicine
**1. Ayurveda:**
Ayurveda, the traditional system of medicine in India, is documented in ancient texts such as the *Charaka Samhita* and the *Sushruta Samhita*.
- **Charaka Samhita:** Attributed to Charaka, this text is a comprehensive guide on internal medicine, discussing various diseases, their diagnosis, and treatment methods. It emphasizes the balance of bodily humors (doshas) and includes detailed descriptions of numerous medicinal plants.
- **Sushruta Samhita:** Attributed to Sushruta, this text is one of the earliest works on surgery. It describes various surgical techniques, including rhinoplasty (reconstructive surgery of the nose), cataract surgery, and procedures for treating fractures and wounds.
### Philosophy and Metaphysics
**1. The Upanishads:**
The Upanishads are philosophical texts that explore the nature of reality and the self. They form the basis of Vedanta, one of the six orthodox schools of Hindu philosophy.
- **Concept of Brahman and Atman:** The Upanishads discuss the ultimate reality (Brahman) and the individual soul (Atman), emphasizing their unity. The famous Mahavakya (great sayings) like "Tat Tvam Asi" (Thou art That) from the *Chandogya Upanishad* encapsulate this profound philosophical idea.
**2. Bhagavad Gita:**
Part of the Mahabharata, the Bhagavad Gita is a 700-verse text that addresses the moral and philosophical dilemmas faced by Arjuna on the battlefield of Kurukshetra. It covers a wide range of topics including duty (dharma), righteousness, and the paths of devotion (bhakti), knowledge (jnana), and action (karma).
### Linguistics and Grammar
**1. Panini's Ashtadhyayi:**
Panini's *Ashtadhyayi* is an ancient Sanskrit grammar that lays down rules for the morphology and syntax of Sanskrit. Composed around the 4th century BCE, it is one of the earliest and most comprehensive linguistic analyses, setting the standard for linguistic theory and descriptive grammar.
### Conclusion
The Vedic texts reflect an advanced level of knowledge in various fields that was unparalleled in the ancient world. They illustrate the sophisticated intellectual pursuits of ancient Indian scholars and their contributions to global knowledge. Despite the disruptions caused by later historical events, the legacy of Vedic scholarship continues to be a source of inspiration and pride.
Chatgpt 💀
Let’s take a look at what i found in Vedas :
1. EARTH IS STATIONARY - RIG VEDA
3.30.4
2. EARTH IS FLAT - ATHARVA VEDA
15.7.1
3. BULL IS HOLDING UP THE EARTH
- ATHARVA VEDA 4.11.1
4. SUN MOVES AROUND EARTH WITH A CHARIOT PULLED BY HORSES -
ATHARVA VEDA 6.8.3
5. URINE IS A POTENT REMEDY AND DRINK OF THE GODS - ATHARVA VEDA 6.44.3
It would take me hours to write down everything. I do agree with the 5th Point .
Any Sanskrit word related to “flat” has not been mentioned in any of the vedas so your comment is refutable also a hymn in vedas are composed of more than 9 words but rigveda 3/30/4,atharveda 6.8.3 have contained only three and 9 words which is again refutable.
So one doesn't even need to cross check your claims.
RigVeda AitreyaBrahmana 3/44 states:
एष न कदा चनास्तमेति नोदेति
eṣa na kadā canāstameti nodeti
Sun never rises àñd ñévér sets
@@itsoblivion8124 Hah don’t you understand what literal reading is ? Science doesn’t depend on metaphors… if it does then that is not science. Go play with your poetic metaphysical lines . They have nothing to do with science
@@mynnkkk isn't math metaphysical?
Mathamatics is purely abstract and it supports the existence for transdimensional abstract entities
@@itsoblivion8124 Wait wtf mathematics is metaphysics 😂😂 …. Go on dude i am not debating amateurs. No more replies from my side .
Videos like these have an audience, creators are aware of it hence they make these stupid videos kudos to you Pranav for debunking these pseudoscientific claims and bearing all the hate.
Man if you observe the behavioral pattern that emerges out a collective behavior of primates are all religious patterns . Which can be shown statistically.
So this athiest guy himself is being unscientific when he trying to destroy religion... which is scientifically impossible...as religious pattern is evolutionary hardwired for survival
For example if you obseve the collective patterns of woke culture... individually most of them are athiest with no religion ..
But if you observe there behaviorial patterns in a collective .. it has all properties of religion .. with set of narratives that defines boundaries of acceptability, with moral policing and blasphemy whoever challenges there central narrative.
I would like to state that at the present stage woke culture has stronger religious baring with more intense moral policing and blasphemy laws than Christianity in present day ... because you can joke about jesus left right and center but you can't dare to challenge there narrative or else you will be punished or cancelled from all the platforms.
Gaurav's channels and antriksh TV, both turned into the definition of irony
Really good channels when they started, don't know what happened
Yupp... Both of these channels really used be the source of our knowledge... But now... 💀💀💀💀
Exactly. They started their YT career at the same time and they're friends. They know the YT business. No wonder, to attract mass audience they compromised with their principles.
They are getting paid by the political party
Yeah correct I was also a heavy antriksh TV viewer but now stopped watching him
@@anamelessmonstereveryone is paid🙂🙃
Hindu ko tariff karo barbar millions mein views aa jayenge 😂😂😂
Ye mullo ka hota hai hmara ni beta
You're absolutely nailing it my big brother! It's such a pleasure to be able to see such a high quality video talking about rationality and as well as demystifying the distorted pseudo scientific wave !
Keep up the good work ill always support you
Lawda nailing it 🤣🤣🤣
That's why he couldn't even counter his points properly
Finally someone made a video against Gaurav's Double standard.. As a science lover i used to watch his videos but dunno why he has turned towards rightist biasedness...
To attract mass audience. More views, more engagement, more profit. He knows the business. Didn't hesitate to compromise his principles.
@@yomaddy Maybe he is getting some money from any political party cause TV media do this all the time.
You are absolutely right
🙂👍 Wrong guy wrong section wrong time I know ...but it feels really good to meet people who really feel like me.... everywhere I go I see idiots blindly believing in everything related to religion....God really created some good people like u ...The other believers goes to hell
@@castario_same here broo😂 but feel happy that there are people like me❤
Bruh you think he doesn't know what he's doing??? 😂😂😂😂... He is one of the most old RUclipsrs and he knows what the audience wants . He doesn't care about the facts
**Title:** "Analyzing Bias and Misrepresentation in a Science Video"
**Summary:**
This video response critically examines another video that attempts to draw connections between ancient Indian scriptures and modern scientific concepts. The response video, created by Pranav, highlights various flaws, biases, and inaccuracies in the original video's arguments. It questions the interpretation of certain scriptures, mathematical calculations, and the overall scientific rigor of the claims made in the video. Pranav argues that such attempts to link religion and science can mislead and give a false impression of how science works.
**Key Points and Takeaways:**
1. **Introduction and Context:** Pranav begins by introducing the video he is responding to and highlights his respect for the original content creator as a science communicator. He acknowledges that the creator's channel usually covers scientific topics effectively but questions their approach when discussing religion.
2. **Cherry-Picking Topics:** Pranav criticizes the original video for selectively choosing topics to investigate and not covering all the aspects mentioned in the source material. He argues that cherry-picking can cater to the biases of the audience and does not promote a rational or unbiased examination.
3. **Questionable Interpretations:** Pranav raises concerns about the interpretations of ancient scriptures in the original video, particularly when it comes to linking them to modern scientific concepts. He highlights that these interpretations may lack evidence and can lead to misconceptions about how science operates.
4. **Errors in Calculations:** Pranav points out errors in calculations made in the original video to determine the speed of light based on ancient measurements. He emphasizes that such inaccuracies can mislead viewers and undermine the credibility of the claims.
5. **Appeal to Authority:** The response video criticizes the original video for using appeals to authority, such as quoting scientists like Schrödinger and Heisenberg, to bolster its arguments. Pranav argues that this doesn't necessarily validate the claims made.
6. **Middle Ground Fallacy:** Pranav challenges the original video's assertion that taking a middle ground between science and religion is a reasonable approach. He contends that seeking a middle ground between two extremes doesn't necessarily lead to a rational conclusion and emphasizes the importance of evidence-based reasoning.
7. **Philosophy Comparison:** The response video points out an error in the original video's classification of Indian philosophies, stating that the categorization of astika and nastika schools doesn't align with the definitions of these terms.
8. **Promotion of Skepticism:** Pranav underscores the importance of skepticism and critical thinking in evaluating claims, especially when it comes to topics like the intersection of science and religion. He encourages viewers to consider evidence and question assertions.
9. **Support for the Creator:** Pranav promotes support for his own content via various platforms, including Patreon, RUclips memberships, and Nas IOU, emphasizing the significance of fan support for creators like himself.
In summary, the response video highlights several shortcomings and biases in the original content's attempt to link ancient Indian scriptures with modern science. It underscores the need for critical thinking and evidence-based reasoning in such discussions.
Thanks man this is really good. Please upvote and help it reach the top, I can't rewove my pinned comment as it has sponsor. Btw did you write this yourself or use a tool?
@@scienceisdope I think he just scraped the autogenerated subs and fed it to ChatGPT.
I think so its generated by ai summarizing
@@scienceisdope youtube has a video transcript option, probably just copied it and pasted it into an LLM.
@@scienceisdope Yes I used ChatGPT to Summarize your transcript. Very effective with long videos.
Well I personally really respect Gaurav as he also promotes rational thinking. I think he might be willing to have a discussion with Pranav. Let's hope he does agree for the discussion
he's probably just pandering to the hyper-patriotic majority.
@@spuriusscapula4829well I don't really understand why people want validation of their religion from science. Shouldn't you be confident enough in your faith ?Honestly I believe that religion is not a science. So if you analyse religion using scientific explanations or theories that would be a wrong approach. I believe if we want to really analyse religion we need to go into philosophy, theology etc.
faith is dangerous
@@MrdacrazecatI only find these hindoo sanghis doing all the time.Sanghis made their religion their whole personality.Nowadays youtubers like gaurav fools makes bullshit video like this to get views.These people would go to any level to prove how great their religion is.They will claim hindoo sunak.4-5 Africans converted to Hinduism they made an entire video how Hinduism is rising in Africa 🤣.It is based on Inferiority complex.
@@MrdacrazecatI find religion more appropriate philosophically. It gives us different ways to think about society and stuff, whether bad or good.
I Appreciate pranav for shedding light on the distinction between science and pattern-seeking in Hindu mythology. It's important to separate fact from fiction in these discussions. Keep up the great work in promoting scientific understanding!
To compare Hindu religion with science, Hanuman had eaten the sun, say this, Varaha had lifted the earth, say this, 5000 years ago men of 10 head how, say this.
😂😂😂 you are just ignorant
Grow up child.You need to be mature. have you ever read Vedas?If we had kept our Vedas and Sanskrit.Answer me how India was the golden bird.You are like a illetrate here talking about world.
Most atheists were born into some religion and what caused them to move away was curiousity and asking questions. The reason why people think that athesits are hell bent on proving religious scriptures wrong is basically them not wanting to ask or entertain questions. As a former religious nut this is very familiar to me cz religion gives you instructions and does the ground work for you on what to do and gives simplistic reasons for it, you dont have to use your brains and a lot of people, especially from difficult realities, want this. Religion targets the vulnerable, gives you escapist narratives which gives people an addictive dopamine hit constantly.
Bhimta that's what i call you
hinduism gives you freedom. In hinduism, one does not have to be a devotee or even pray. All one has to do is one's duty towards society. One must show kindness, compassion and empathy towards others. One must simply pursue knowledge.
@@Vededits6542 feelingggg prouuddd hindu armyyyyy good job that's very hindu of you first you discriminate your fellow religion mates then blame them for converting to other religions
@@kishor.k8092 if he can discriminate against my religion than why not
@@shreshtharya9967Then for all these things you don’t really need to be a part of any religion or believe in god, you just have to a rational human.
Its basic humanity that all religions preach in the name of spirituality
Haters are the only people who came here to spit poisons without watching the video ..........
Hope they'll watch the whole video not try to cherrypick.....
Or is he the first forming hate by making an opinion on scriptures without reading them?
Don't be a hypocrite
@@mr.gamerkabir8142he is telling the truth not like you andhvakth
@@mr.gamerkabir8142lmao he's read them, translated them and then only debunks the forced correlation between them and science
@@mr.gamerkabir8142 No need to read scriptures, the so called hindu nationalists who claim to have read the scriptures have made fool of themseleves with their non sense, unscientific and weak claims which they say have come from "science of vedas"! This is enough to conclude vedas don't have science!
@@mr.gamerkabir8142he debunked the claim not book chutiye......
Ask your chacha(Gaurav) stop misrepresenting your religion
Glad you noticed his agenda. Tho I used to like Gaurav because of space science videos, but unsuscribed his another channel. You're doing an amazing job Pranav👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
why did u unsub? any false in that channel too?
@@joelprakashabraham4701only religion based videos of Gaurav are biased. The rest of them are good!
I love our history (mythology?) But we definitely need evidence , proof, theorems which are directly indicating to the topic and not just writings which can be interpreted in many different ways
Exactly!
Love this, u r arguing to convince, instead of arguing to argue
The thing is these so called Rationalists ( Getsetpseudoscience )confuse Scriptural Philosophy & Metaphysics with Science. And that’s all you need to make a fool out of people who merely understand what science is and that gives their cognitive biases a boost. Keep the good work going Pranav 👏
Finally someone said. I also unsubscribed him way earlier because of this.
Same here and her sister's channel as well.
@@yomaddy They both spread propaganda and agenda of BJP.
Same
Good work❤ article 51” s: It shall be the duty of every citizen of India To develop scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry and reform
51-ah
Yes
agreed
Which no one gives fuck😂😂 for real. My parents told this article since childhood but even in school I never observed any teachers celebrating or explaining about this one particular highly important thing in constitution.
@@user-dy1gb5sr4rI give a fuck so does people commenting it here don't act edgy it's only few people who bring the change.
Hi pranav , glad to see your video on him..please make shorts of your videos...so it will be helpful for us to share your shorts and get subscribers to spread awareness..❤👍
Science is dope is that guy who would call samudragupta indian napolean even though samudragupta came before him. Reason ...well the european writers said it .😅
The reason is because Napolean is more famous and more aware of public consciousness.
He's just another NRI with slavery mentality
He didn't say that
Egos are everywhere dude, you can't deny that lot of 'rational people' self-professed or otherwise usually revel in the notion that they are 'smarter' or 'superior' because they are more 'educated' or 'knowledgeable'. True or not, ego is still very much in play.
very well put together . Most of the people in pranav's comments arent even rational , they are just elitist , who feel they are superior than rest of the Indian population , just because they dont feed into the pseudoscience narrative of select few youtubers . The first and the most Important step to learn , is to give up your damn ego and accept you know nothing, lets all accept that dunning kruger effect is real
How is this relevant to anything being said here? We don't make blanket statement here bud. If you have a query put forth a solid argument. He weekly reacts to them in his live streams.
@@berserk322 in this video he seems to imply only nationalists have egos that can get 'popped' . My comment was merely pointing out that everyone here: "rationalist" Or otherwise are operating on their egos and not their intellects
@@ofAwxenGood observation
Thanks for this video man, I think the sooner ppl in our country gain media literacy the better off we will be. The combination of cognitive bias and social media algorithms are destroying the current generation.
this is not a hate comment first of all but just noticed that this person (Science is Dope) is going into a more mental oriented debate instead of cross checking the facts and information presented by Getsetflyscience. Hence he himself is making a Logical Fallacy by countering the words, topics chosen and connection to books and authors in a humorous way that is making people think the claims made initially as just fallacies rather than going into the actual information which u were meant to cross check for making a conclusion that Science came from hinduism or not......
think it wisely everybody, everybody iis content creator and have their own fields of growth, they are doing what they are meant to ( wo alag baat h ki inka goal kuch bhi krke samne wale ko galat dikhana h) hence it is what it is, really cant do anything about them :)
Thanks god someone got it,I watched whole video but this guy haven't proved any point of gaurav's wrong.He is just saying it as wrong without a single counter argument and fact
@@Atheisttandpatrioticexactly his whole channel is hinduphobic
@@Atheisttandpatrioticare you blind ?
@@AyushVerma-ks7tv ask yourself
@@AyushVerma-ks7tv ask yourself brother
I think that while you wanted a rational debate, looking at the comments section, you ended up villainising Gaurav a bit. Overall, I found your video to be a little nitpicky, I will clarify a couple of things related to your questions on the speed of the light claim:
1. You quote him talking about uncertainties of these units like Yojana and Nimesha and then make a contradictory claim stating he does not mention any uncertainties! Did you expect him to put a disclaimer once every five second talking about the uncertainties?! The way I see it, He very clearly put a disclaimer talking about these units not being standardized and the possibility of them getting conveniently interpreted.
2. 1 Dhanu = 6 feet on an average claim: You say, "where did he get this value from? I don't know". He has taken it from the paper by Subhash Kak(Go to his video and pause on 20.04th minute), in that paper he quotes Kautilya's Arthashastra as the source for that. Even Kak clearly mentions that Yojana can be interpreted as multiple things and states his reasoning for choosing 1 Yojana = 9 miles.
3. I looked at 3 Sanskrit dictionaries that are reputed and here is what they say about Yojana:
VS Apte: A measure of distance equal to four Krośas or eight or nine miles
Monier-Williams: a distance traversed in one harnessing or without unyoking; especially a particular measure of distance, sometimes regarded as equal to 4 or 5 English miles, but more correctly = 4 krośa-s or about 9 miles;according to other calculations = 2 1/2 English miles, and according to some = 8 krośa-s) etc
Arthur Anthony Macdonell: a measure of distance equal to four krosas or about nine English miles
4. You bring the Hanuman Chalisa bit. If somebody making a claim about Hanuman Chalisa says that 1 Yojana = 8 miles, why should Gaurav be held accountable for that?
5. 1 nimesha = 0.2 seconds, you talk about no reasons being mentioned for that. He actually shows the screenshot for the source at around 20.21 minute. He is taking it from the 4th page of the following book: Units of Measurement: Past, Present and Future. International System of Units By S. V. Gupta
The paper by Subhash Kak also takes the same stance.
6. All said, the calculation error that you point out is valid. For the details of the actual calculation we have to look at the paper by Subhash Kak and the sources that he cites and examine the claims there. Anyway, read Subhash Kak's paper, that will answer many of your quetions: browse.arxiv.org/pdf/physics/9804020.pdf
Thank you bhaiya, for crafting such content that has assisted me in cultivating a more rational and logical outlook for comprehending these things 💖
So are you saying all the concepts I learned from Irodov , HC Verma , Resnick Halliday , Loney etc. 10 years ago for my Engineering exam were a waste of time . Goddam Pranav , I’m furious at my Physics teacher for not telling me about the Vedas back then .
😂😂
😂😂😂
@@iiTzKaran_YTyo bro remember me i am from sarthaks video
@@Mihir_hun_vaii which one???
@@Mihir_hun_vaii Oh yeah, I see, lmao what a small world
Kon kon dhruv rathee ka video dekhkar aaya hai
Mr
This is what I wanted. I was confused about many topics after I had seen Gaurav sir's video. this clarified my confusions . thank you Pranav Sir
You are nakli Hindu that's the reason
The sad truth is that this is not just a weird RUclipsr spreading pseudoscience.It's in the movies,media,print, advertisement,naming cities, building monuments,etc etc.We are busy trying to portray India as some kind of glory land with Wifi,Planes, astronomical knowledge and time travel until some foreign rulers came and conquered them.And the worst thing is people are going to get influenced by all of this and will slowly start to form an opinion that some of the people in our country are truly "outsiders".And just give it time to reflect in elections and then we'll have a fully religious state.🎉
Well said bro well said ❤❤
Sums up Indian politics pretty well.
As if USA is perfect. Dude, stop thinking only India has this, look at Islam and Christianity. When do u people LEARN to be FAIR... Open ur eyes and look at the world.
Ohh sorry I didn't look at ur name. Israel is a religious state but achieved technological prowess.
@@Agnosticcc-x3m hehe I didn't get to choose my name.But you decided to judge people based on their names 😵.And I am not religious one bit.And just because USA is doing it or Pakistan is doing it doesn't mean it's okay! And Israel,USA are poor examples because they don't have this kind of diversity and each group having a significant population load.Israel literally has a single group of people in that country.(kinda same with USA).In India,super religiosity in polity will NOT lead to progress and develop.Things are going to get out of control at one point. All it takes is a slight provocation from any of the sides and we'll have a full fledged communal riot/mob lynching in almost anywhere in India now. Thanks to all the propaganda and emotional build up done by so called nationalist youtubers,media,influencers etc etc.
Thanks!
Thank you!
the first thing I dont understand and have a problem with , is people saying "western science " . Wtf is even western science , science emerged due to the collective efforts of humanity and no special group or part of world has the right to call it solely their creation
omg a particular region contributing to science better than we do, they must be spreading propaganda 😱😱😱🥺😯😰🥺😲🥺😲🥺😲🥺😲🥺😲😦
PEOPLE WILL FIGHT EACH OTHER UNTIL THE END OF THIS UNIVERSE WITHOUT UNDERSTANDING WHAT LIFE IS.
We need an alien species.. To unite us lol
@@TusharKumar-jb6vp
Hi Pranav, appreciate your hardwork in this video,but what I've found after some research is that the statement about the Speed of light in vedas is quite right.
Consider the below verse from (Rig-veda book I, chapter 50, hymn 4)
“Yojananam Dwe Dwe Shate Dwe Cha Yojane
Aken Nimishardena Kramana Namostute”
In the above verse,
Nimishardhena means Half Nimisha, Dwe means “two” & shate means “Hundred”, So the above means
“Sun light travels 2202 Yojanas in half Nimisha.”
Yojana and Nimisha are the vedic units of distance and time respectively which can be expressed in many ways like
Nimishardhena means half of nimesa. Nimisa means winking the eye. According to science, our eyes wink five times in one second. So, Nimishardhena is 0.1 seconds. (1/5 * 1/2)
1 Yojana =8000 Purushu(man’s height)= 8000* 6 feet=14.63 km~9 miles
Monier Williams further derived the value of yojana based on his research as 9 miles i.e. 14.48 km.
Considering the above units, speed of light in modern SI unit can be calculated as
distance/time
= 2202 x 9 / 0.1056
= 19818/0.1056
= 187670.45 miles per second
Which is very close to the value which modern science derives. That is 186000 miles per second
Hmmmmm
Could u tell me the sources from where u got the statement and values
@@lightningrodMC This is my own research across the web and i don't remember much links. My best suggestion for you is to again search these up.
You can type in the question
"Is the value of the speed of light mentioned in Hindu Vedas?" and you will get many results
broter the hymn you mentioned is from Vishnu Puraan not Rigved
@@ElonMusk-tb2yi No bro it's from rigved, I've searched it up multiple times
@@NobleDorito8698 Ok
Right Wing contents are in high demand nowadays, gaurav knows that and he went for it. simple
😂😂
As a sanatani and science lover i just want to say one thing that don't mix science with any religion or dharma cause there is no similarity between these, Science is science and religion is religion 😂😂😂 but some andbhakt would deny that and will tell that science came from sanatan, many will tell that it came from islam but reality is that science is science which is universal truth and it didn't come from any religion so don't mix these two things.
you are right and wrong logic is a limitation for our minds anything that we've haven't seen from our eyes or haven't seen a very big number of people's accepting it we don't believe it........... Science doesn't make anything=Anything make science... if there's nothing there's no science... Science is way to know how Things work what are They Why are They science doesn't came from any religion neither HINDUISM OR Islam............... But it came from human mind . And for celerity sake i'am a Muslim and a Science Nerd❤ And I don't know if you believe in God or not..... but there is something that created this which we are living in... if i bring you a camera and say in billions of years space dust geatherd and this thing while can capture and record came in existence would you gonna believe it What am expecting your answer is no...... and we humans and this universe is way much complicated that that camera . science doesn't came from religion neither religion came from science
as a Muslim what i believe is this life is a test for us how we do what we do..... and science is pretty much a way to live life now.and religion is also a way to live life is a particular way that harm no one is this time no one literally no one neither I follow my religion 100%. and in Quran there are many references of events which science have told us about like big bang and all if you want i can tell you about those .
❤
@@K-SHABABScience in Qur'an 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂. The same Qur'an which says Sperms come from between the loins and the ribs ? 😂😂😂 The same Qur'an which says Earth is flat ? The same Qur'an which says the first human beings were made by mud ? 😂😂😂😂 The same Qur'an which says no human can go above the ground? 😂😂😂😂The same Quran which says Donkeys can fly ? The same Qur'an which promotes drinking camel urine as medicine? 😂😂😂😂 The same Qur'an which says Mohammed splited the moon in two half by his finger ? 😂😂😂😂. You are funny af
@@K-SHABAB even Krishna has spoken about multiverse
@@K-SHABAB there was no smoke
This video is needed ❤
I got a job opportunity in Getsetfly science a year ago I guess. I told them I would look at their content and will let them know.
Fortunately I was smart enough to realise what are they trying to do. (Yes I denied the opportunity)
Most of the information they provided was quite good but it does feel irrational a number of times when you scrutinize it. It may appear good for some people who aren't from a science background but ultimately its creating a bias inside young minds that "WE know it before THEY do! ".
So they are doing this from about an year!!
What kinda job? Editing?
Stop lying. His thumbnail and video title are clickbaits but his video never promoted irrationality
@@itsoblivion8124 why would I lie lol.?
It is clearly evident that his content doesn't look scientific.
@@siddhuzplace3737 example
Great video! Thanks for making this one.
Thank you pranav for this video. When I watched video of GSFS there were some red flags but I didn't pointed out thinking it just my lack of knowledge but after this all my questions are clear! Thank you.
Hi Pranav , I Love Watching your videos..i wanted to ask you this here because of this -16:33.. At least based on the clip of GSFS in this video at 15:18, Gaurav doesn't say that it resembles or explains time dilation(even tho that was what he said he would talk about), he says that it shows that there was an understanding of time being relative.. but you only explained how what Gaurav said does not have anything to do with Time dilation and not much about how it is unrelated to the idea of time being relative.. altho u did speak about how we understood that it is quantities that change ..but that was before playing the clip..either it's a misunderstanding on my part or the time at which the clip of GSFS was played was wrong or misplaced..can you please clarify..
I completely agree with you Pranav. I was very much dissappointed by Gaurav after I watched his this very video. I was a big fan of him when he used to make space related videos earlier, but since last few years I can see he is much more biased towards the current government and religion. Thanks for making a video, hope this reaches out to him, we will be happy to see the rational Gaurav back.
in neils bohr's book, he has written "quantum physics will not be confusing to those who have mastered the vedanta"....not just hindus, only those who studied vedanta
book name?
India need more people with scientific temper. Thank You Pranav.
Indians ke DNA me hai scientific temper chal nikal lawde
@@amanjha890ooh astrology me believe karne Wale scientific temper sikha rahe hai
@@oneforall871kya bola bhai
Please don't worry about the haters.. keep up the good work.. All' the very best
Honestly pseudo-science is so confusing than science.
Thanks for your contribution to debunking the pseudo scientific claims with religious bias!!!! U r a man with big brain and steel heart to fight against the agenda of making Veda as a source of science.
Sanatan dharm is not religion understood??
@@amanjha890it’s neither connected to melecha Islam created Hinduism …another name of secular .
SANATANA IS ONLY RELIGION. Everything else is of cults. To understand that you must be intelligent very, and an atheist cannot speak about reason and science in evidence, because because he can, he couldn’t figure out something he couldn’t understand so he came in atheist the easy way out that means another word for can’t understand or naturally something like that is Pondo
These questions must be asked because GetSetFly is one of those channels that promote Rational Thinking and cover many topics... So if he is doing something wrong (For Whatever reason), that needs to be called out...
Views and subscribers, buddy...
They are Tunni not rational
When i saw the thumbnail
I was happy
Cause i thought it's a collaboration 😂😅
When i saw that video of Gaurav. I was confused about how vedas got the speed of light right and really needed your video to cross verify it. Thanks for saving me from falling into this pit of misinterpretation of vedas
read your previous comment:
Consider the below verse from (Rig-veda book I, chapter 50, hymn 4)
“Yojananam Dwe Dwe Shate Dwe Cha Yojane
Aken Nimishardena Kramana Namostute”
In the above verse,
Nimishardhena means Half Nimisha, Dwe means “two” & shate means “Hundred”, So the above means
“Sun light travels 2202 Yojanas in half Nimisha.”
Yojana and Nimisha are the vedic units of distance and time respectively which can be expressed in many ways like
Nimishardhena means half of nimesa. Nimisa means winking the eye. According to science, our eyes wink five times in one second. So, Nimishardhena is 0.1 seconds. (1/5 * 1/2)
1 Yojana =8000 Purushu(man’s height)= 8000* 6 feet=14.63 km~9 miles
Monier Williams further derived the value of yojana based on his research as 9 miles i.e. 14.48 km.
Considering the above units, speed of light in modern SI unit can be calculated as
distance/time
= 2202 x 9 / 0.1056
= 19818/0.1056
= 187670.45 miles per second
Which is very close to the value which modern science derives. That is 186000 miles per second
Amazing video bro ❤
Apki bhi videos mai dekhta hu, knowledgeable hai.
Purana stories are symbolic , there are many symbolism in Ramayana also like Hanuman ji is symbol of having devotion in god , surrender your kamra and ego , this the meaning of Hanuman ji
These stories are still treated as itihas and many people have got darshans of Hanuman in Kali yuga
@@mr.gamerkabir8142 purano ka history se lene dena nhi hai but ho sakta hai Hanuman ji ho , par hame purano ke symbols ko samajna chahiye , usme philosophy hai , Hanuman ji kaliyug ma hai ki nhi pata nhi par Hanuman ji ke vyaktitva (character) se bohot kuch sikha ja sakta hai
@@ShankarShankar-hb7bi firstly I know
But some are taken as literal itihas by any sampradaya
Some are just fictional 'stories'
Some are itihas
@@mr.gamerkabir8142 Sahi kaha
@@mr.gamerkabir8142 A Monkey Man Carrying a Mountain for Thousands of Kilometres is Itihaas?
I am totally agreeing with you in this video.But I think debunking the whole ancient indian society as a non scientific one is an absolute nonsense.
There used to be great respect to scientific things those days.There were many great universities in india those days like Takshasila, Nalanda ,etc..where people from different parts of world used to get there to study about different aspects of sciences and humanitarians.Many of those things might not be very relavent today but the nature of indian society must be noted..Many things those were thought scientifically correct in the 19th century by those scientific societies were thought to be absolutely not true by the 20th century. As a medical student I totally object the practice of Ayurveda these days. But it is a very great thing in those days which has many aspects of scientific achievements.
THE THING IS THOSE ARE NOT JUST RELAVENT TO THIS DAY ANYMORE.
The thing which is relavent today won't be relavent anymore in about 50 to 100 years.
THIS DOESN'T MEAN PEOPLE OF THIS LAND WERE NOT RATIONAL IN THE COVER OF RELEGION.They usually never priorotized the unproven facts written in some relegious books over the proven scientific ones(Which used to be in the the other parts of world)(you know what happened to Galelio and Copernicus ).
And the main thing is the institutions of scientific methodologies in india were destroyed (Takshasila ,Nalanda,etc..)so from then so no advancements occured from then to be relavent to this day.(Read about why Md.Khaliji destroyed nalanda)
Strawman fallacy.....
WHAT@@electrondynamics9721
He doesn't say ancient India is completely unscientific.
(Meaning it's a strawman, that's probably what the person above me is talking about.)
@@Suryadev-qq6jjbro this guy hasn't proved a single evidence backed point of gaurav,he is just saying it wrong like trust me
Thank you for debunking this nonsense. Not rocket science, deducing why all these youtubers have pivoted towards RW talking points..
Hey babe wake up pranav droped the new debunk
Well done bro. Actually you are a truthseeker.. you gained a subscriber. Keep it up
It seems his writers are either using quick buck AI powered by blindfolded data collector.
Dunno...
Gaurav is draining the intelligence of the general audience and deceiving them.
yt deleted our beloved sting's channel 🤔i wonder why
Propagandaist good he is gone
good for humanity
GOOD FOR HUMANITY
I wish they do the same with Sham Sharma show.That due criticizes secularism, liberalism wants India to be a Hindoo rastra but lives in New Zealand and married to white woman.Pretty sure he is also fooling his audience and making a living out of it.I wonder why that sanatani Sher deshbhakt don't live in India.Why he is living in a secular country.
@@KANGZZZ.I know for certain you'll be the the first one to flee the country if you get a chance, and india is a secular country because of the hindu majority not because of constitution or sume other bs. Iran, saudi even fck8n north korea and china have a constitution that doesnt make them secuarl, the people does and fortunately for this counry hindu are the majority .
Thumbnail title changed , huh 😏
Only rational mind can digest this video ❤
Bro learnt basic psychology and science from RUclips and thinks he is the most genius person
Yeah just like gaurav's hindu bias and hypocrisy 😂🤣
His followers are as dumb as him , he haven't shown any proof and or explained any topic in depth he just passed his thoughts and philosophy and think is rational and logical
Comparing the date of the Baudhayana text to Pythagoras is silly. The theorem was widely known throughout the ancient world, likely also India, centuries before either came around.
Gaurav is agnostic himself, he has mentioned this in many videos
You deserve more reach .
Just a thought.... Why does it always happens that we try to show the "we first" evidence for a already proven technology. And why not technology which will be used 15 - 20 Yrs in future... 🤔
For example quantum computing, vaccum travel etc...
Nice point.
baap re ye to dhoti khol Raha hai 🙂🙂
amazing video loved it!
waiting for the vastu shastra video eagerly!
He also went too far by promoting apps like binamo and such things. I mean yeah he can do whatever he want. But as someone with that much following with teenagers watching his videos he could have been more responsible for the things he promote and the type of content he makes
I was a huge fan of this channel around 2 years ago when this channel was neutral and didn't promoted any propaganda. It was one of the best fact channel back then when it was not a hindutva fact channel. Now this channel is just plain bs. Glad you exposed this channel.
BTW I know where his turning point came from, it was from that one Mughal video where he unbiasedly described both positive and negative aspects of the Mughals but the "certain" section got trigerred and trolled him, then he make another video on the same mughals but this time from their perspective and rest is what it is now. 😂😂😂😂
So was I
He is possibly paid by Atheist organizations, and doing propaganda. Even a religion like Hinduism which is based on spiritual practices, has to be tried. You can not make judgement about others, without reaching that level of spiritual acoomplishments.
@@thegodlogic3844wdym by spiritual practices?? spiritual accomplishments??
@@YourParas word salad
Man if you observe the behavioral pattern that emerges out a collective behavior of primates are all religious patterns . Which can be shown statistically.
So this athiest guy himself is being unscientific when he trying to destroy religion... which is scientifically impossible...as religious pattern is evolutionary hardwired for survival
For example if you obseve the collective patterns of woke culture... individually most of them are athiest with no religion ..
But if you observe there behaviorial patterns in a collective .. it has all properties of religion .. with set of narratives that defines boundaries of acceptability, with moral policing and blasphemy whoever challenges there central narrative.
I would like to state that at the present stage woke culture has stronger religious baring with more intense moral policing and blasphemy laws than Christianity in present day ... because you can joke about jesus left right and center but you can't dare to challenge there narrative or else you will be punished or cancelled from all the platforms.
W Pranav!! ❤❤
Thanks
Hi Pranav. Please do not change like Gaurav did. 🙏 Thanks.
Even a scientist has to leave his/her scientific temper outside the temple, church or mosques' gate and enter them just by faith. And once he/she enters the lab they should leave religious faith outside the lab and only give way to reason, intuition, scientific assumptions and perspectives. This is how they can make good knowledge in the respective areas. Otherwise they are just confusing themselves and others and being experts in a field they should behave responsibly.
If you really want to know the corelation of science and religion, one should always take Einstien's "Science and Religion" essay. He just nailed the debate.
Dude he himself was an atheist
And if quoted many times that
All religions scripture are just like kids imaginary fiction stories from him
@@ajayagrawal4687 isn't it true, suppose I just tell some arbitrary facts and back it with science without giving the exact corelation, will it be considered as science.
take another example: from ancient times people have noticed, observing lightning, that rubbing woollen cloth on any insulating material produces Static electricity, will you conclude that woolen and any insulating material are best conductors of electricity?
*I had to edit the word PVC with insulator as you might hang to that simple error.
@@ranadityapandey4458that is not how science work and no body just back up anything with science. Science deals with objective reality- space and universe etc.
Any thing subjective doesn't count and there are many people who try to pedel unscientific idea with science and maybe that is what you are reffering.
You should talk once you have understanding of scientific methodology and experiments methodology. Logical and critical thinking courses and scientific thinking which is absent from school curriculum. Like me I got it from outside support
@@ranadityapandey4458yes it will consider as experimental science
But not whole truth as far as reason are not known
While when we get the reasons for it. We will modify it or change it accordingly
Which is missing in religion that the problem
@@ranadityapandey4458which mean that anything said by scientists is not right and scientific unless it undergoes the peer reviewed and published in proper journal. Multiple trials are performed on the matter.
If Einstein said that apples are rainbow 🌈 in colour people like me will not accept it unless there are observations, experiments, test results, multiple trial across the world and peer reviewed then published.
Blind followers of Einstein may accept but not people like me who come from science background
I used to watch this GetsetflySCIENCE channel sometimes but recently after watching him i sense something selfish, something irrational like here in the video saying "as a science dharam(religion)4:32". I am not comfortable with terms like this where people mix the word science and religion. My point is everyone can change but the important think is your reason for changing self. I subscribed your channel just now because of the distance between sun and earth from hanuman chalisa video, You saved me a lot of time but that doesn't mean you will always be correct, i am not talking about technical incorrection but slowly turning into some kind of biased irrational person but i hope people like you stay the way you are right now, logical...
Have been waiting from ages just to see someone from scientific community debunking gaurav 💀
❣️
@my_father_sorry_i_am_lying_now Well you're absolutely wrong about everything you have written... But HEY.... I DON'T CARE.... If you really think it's true then good luck, really no offence ( the only thing you were right about is plastics surgery and which really does not have anything to do with veda)... But if you think it has something to do with vedas... Then again I DON'T CARE... You just keep believing what you believe... Now Peace❤❤❤
@my_father_sorry_i_am_lying_now ling of shiva never had been found in indus valley civilization
There is multiple headed man which is assumed as pashupati nath by indologist but many didn't called it pashupati .
and believe me ling never found
And surgery all around the world had happening nothing special about it
Almost 3000 yr back body had found in Africa where the amputation had been done
😅😅so think from brain not from emotions
@my_father_sorry_i_am_lying_now 😂lol I can debunk your whole life just not lies 😂
the first ‘surgeons’ practised in the Neolithic period, drilling a hole in skulls, probably to allow an evil spirit to escape but likely unknowingly treating epilepsy, headache or insanity, Friedenberg explains. Surprisingly, he adds, (more patients recovered than died from the procedure).
Pub med
Surgery is not begans by charak it's being modified by him lol
Egypt, about 3000 BC, surgeons were immobilizing fractures, excising tumours and suturing wounds with linen thread. But what is most significant in the development of surgery, Friedenberg notes, was how the mummification of bodies taught surgeons about anatomy, improving their diagnosis and treatment of the living.
😁😁😁😁
Source - pub med a history of surgery
@my_father_sorry_i_am_lying_now and 😂never knew that J. L shashtri wrote shiv puran in madarsa 😂
its so fun when we hear that vedas claim literally all modern science topics including quantum physics yet indians follow none of them and believe in gaumutra
Dekuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu!
Shineeeeeeeeeee!
You're also indian
Hey Pranav, the actual debunking starts at 8min 40sec. The first 8 minutes is more of introductions and fair usage of data etc. These introductions won't retain the attention of people who watch ur channel for the first time, and they will skip the video. Please start the videos directly with the actual topic and keep generic introductions towards the end of add in description. Particularly Young generation don't have patience unless the opening statements are captivating and presents the main topic asap. Love your content bro ❤
The most irrational thing about that man is not the deductions he made about Science in Vedas" but how he chose keep his t-shirt buttons open & reveal his bare chest.
We support you brother, thanks for showing this type of biases made by this type of youtubers.
Abe gawaar kabhi Hindu grantho ko padha bhi hai?? Get setfly ne Sach bola to Dard ho gya 🤣🤣
The thing is gaurav Bhai used to tell in his videos that he doesn't believe in such things. Wind changes and religious videos getting more popularity. He switched side's suddenly and started to believe in such things, miraculously
Well Gaurav Thakur trying hard to white wash BJP Government and specially Yogi Adityanath's image... Nothing else😴🙏
You are a true investigator 👍😇
At 13:48 this statement comes to mind
If you are not completely confused by quantum mechanics, you do not understand it.
- John Wheeler
Your is really touch my heart along with the other truth seekers,...... Thank you and I believe people like you still present who share the truth their audience
He just made videos to please his audience and not to prove any point. I Guess his videos should be considered as pure entertainment like TV drama and nothing else.
kal me gaurav ko dekh raha tha aur soch raha tha ye religion me jyada ghus raha hai aur aaj tumhari video aagayi thanks man
Great work bro ❤
I really like Pranav's content and I'm taking interest in the evidence backed statements and the other videos
You keep asking for it. So here it is.
THIS IS A HATE COMMENT.