So beautiful to hear you playing Bach, which I really love. You bring so much softness in his music. I never bevor heard him played in such a gentle way and I really hope to hear more Bach played by you. Thank you for sharing and greetings from Germany.
@OfficialBIG_CHEWSE_VRAll good chief, having the mental capacity to watch just 19 minutes of Tarkovsky's work is a decent achievement already and I'm saying this as a fan of his😂
@@laurarhymer9533 Don't take all the hard work, and thousands of hours of practicing that Paul has done, and make it like something "God" gave him. It's disrespectful towards Paul, imo.
@@swety2962 yes - whose nature (if you believe in this possibility, which e.g. Spinoza makes seem really almost indeed 'natural'!) it is - so (indeed inescapably, according to that logic) perhaps 'He' didn't strictly CHOOSE to do anything at all - to play out all the possibilities of everything through eternity; we are just lucky to have coincided, roughly..., with JSB, whose music is in the estimation of those competent to judge, the very nearest imaginable to what 'God' would play for us. Well...
Beautiful performance, thanks. I am obsessed by this chorale (both the original organ version and Busoni's piano version). It's way above my current ability, but I will get there one day. Seeing the score and the hands on the keyboard together is very very helpful. Thanks!
me too, I'm obsessed with this choral! I prepared a long playlist with all the versions I could find here on YT, not excluded those for strings, for choir or for saxophones :)
Thank you so much! It's really a pleasure to hear this marvellous piece and simultaneously be granted the chance to see both score and perfect fingering!
At 2:50 - 2:51 (right hand, second bar) the second E should be flat, but you played E natural like the first one. Apart this, thank you very much for this wonderful rendition, it's very helpful to watch :)
Thanks again, Paul, you always seem to have a video of the most beautiful pieces I'm looking to learn. On this occasion, I wonder if transposing it would work well on the piano. It has such subtle, but increasingly dark, harmonies, which don't seem to ring as I imagine they would on certain stops of the organ, or as they do on guitar. BTW, the link is broken to the imslp.
Good Evening , Paul Barton 🎶 Thank you so very much for sharing this beautiful music with everyone ! Have a great weekend , May God Sorround you with his grace and peace , Take care ! ✝️ 11/6/2020 ✝️
@@mink1097 2 years on - did you finish learning this amazing piece? I started on it two months ago, devoting about an hour a day to it on top of my other practice. Memorised all but two lines of it (the part with the huge LH chords (from 2:30 in this vid) but so far still very slowly and carefully at MM semiquaver = 66. I am giving myself a year to make it absolutely performance ready.
2:50 E-F-E flat here. But, as Beethoven said, "to play a wrong note is insignificant; to play without passion is inexcusable." And you play with passion.
Nah it is "Limbo... Lust... All gone... With gluttony soon to follow... Your kind know nothing but hunger, purged all life on the upper layers, and yet they remain unsatiatedy, As do you... You've taken everything from me machine.. And now all that remains is perfect hatred.
Thanks so much. If you love piano music and feel you need to play it, you absolutely can. When you are passionate about music you can learn any instrument that will enable you to play it.
Nice performance though - At about 2.51 in bar 2'of this page there is a misreading at the end of beat 1,the 4th 16th. note is an e flat ,not e natural 👍
einen kleinen Patzer haste reingehauen, irgendwo hättest Du n Es spielen müssen wo Du aus Versehen ein E gespielt hast, sonst sehr geil, vor allem mit den Klaviernoten zum Mitlesen, kuhle Sache
@@TheRedstonedeluxe yes, that is actually what I am saying. I know there are different opinion's on tempo and how to interpret these pieces, when the are rewritten for piano. But most of details and expressions in the piece should be kept. I remember many years ago when I played through this piece, I choose to play it in a faster tempo to suit the modern piano. It's not the, one or the other tempo choice thing, but he clearly makes a big tempo change at 1.29. There are also parts where the score writes "zehr weich"/very soft, where he flickers his hand making the notes hard. There are many places where I would personally play the notes softer and he plays it harder. He pauses his fermata as if they should be short fermata, but they are also uneven in a weird way. Maybe it is just me. Haven't played the piece for over 20 years.
This is interesting. Why did Busoni transcribed this from original organ to piano? Couldn't he at least transcribe it for pedal piano? Yes, there is such an instrument. Schumann liked it a lot. Now this is like "let's make ourselves a hard,, unnaturally sounding piece from easy, well suited for organ style piece". I can only assume there was a fashion like this in the sixties. Funny that people can still fall for it. I have mixed feelings about this. Sorry.
I agree with Luca's answer here - and I also agree with you, The piano version misses the depth of the eternal organ tones, to the point that it's not at all the same piece anymore. On the other hand, it gives a little insight in the structure of the real thing.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
This is my first time listening to this piece. What an experience. Thank you for sharing your talent.
So beautiful to hear you playing Bach, which I really love. You bring so much softness in his music. I never bevor heard him played in such a gentle way and I really hope to hear more Bach played by you. Thank you for sharing and greetings from Germany.
@FreiRaum01 -- Greetings too from Acapulco!
who remembers this from Tarkovsky's Solaris.....?
Everyone who watched and loved that movie. Which apparently Lem did not.
Well, Bach lived a bit earlier...
@@YugenOnLine It's a perfect fusion of two great artists.
@OfficialBIG_CHEWSE_VRAll good chief, having the mental capacity to watch just 19 minutes of Tarkovsky's work is a decent achievement already and I'm saying this as a fan of his😂
I've been trying to remember where I heard it, thanks
How do you play the piano with such affection it's just mesmerising to watch
GOD gave that GIFT! I don’t ask questions about what I KNOW the answer to.
@@laurarhymer9533 Don't take all the hard work, and thousands of hours of practicing that Paul has done, and make it like something "God" gave him. It's disrespectful towards Paul, imo.
@@adamrischel3810 I agree
@@adamrischel3810 and God
@@swety2962 yes - whose nature (if you believe in this possibility, which e.g. Spinoza makes seem really almost indeed 'natural'!) it is - so (indeed inescapably, according to that logic) perhaps 'He' didn't strictly CHOOSE to do anything at all - to play out all the possibilities of everything through eternity; we are just lucky to have coincided, roughly..., with JSB, whose music is in the estimation of those competent to judge, the very nearest imaginable to what 'God' would play for us. Well...
Beautiful performance, thanks. I am obsessed by this chorale (both the original organ version and Busoni's piano version). It's way above my current ability, but I will get there one day. Seeing the score and the hands on the keyboard together is very very helpful. Thanks!
me too, I'm obsessed with this choral! I prepared a long playlist with all the versions I could find here on YT, not excluded those for strings, for choir or for saxophones :)
Yes, I remember the film by Andrey Tarkowski very well. And the tune is an absolute part of it. Beautiful!
In this movie (at the end) is played version by Artemyev. I think it is better, is it not?
Thank you so much! It's really a pleasure to hear this marvellous piece and simultaneously be granted the chance to see both score and perfect fingering!
I am always astounded, humbled and entertained by your talent. Thank you. 😌
It's so beautiful!
Just beautiful.Such depth of emotion.
Oh so beautiful. Thank you.
These videos are an immense help with timing etc. many thanks Paul.
Blissfully twixt Pensive & Melancholic. Beautiful. مليار شكر.
Wunderbar, es passt so gut zu dem 77.sten Geburtstag heute von meinem Mann! Vielen herzlichen Dank, lieber Paul 💚🍀🌻
this is one of Bach,s organ chorale preludes,my favourite one
Благодарю 🙏🏻, Вас!
И музыка и Ваше исполнение завораживают!✨✨✨
RUclips の画面が動かないんですけど
Gracias ! un saludo desde muy lejos Valparaíso , Chile . Un gran abrazo y Feliz Navidad !
Paul Barton is a great artist in music and also in painting. He is like a dream on earth.
At 2:50 - 2:51 (right hand, second bar) the second E should be flat, but you played E natural like the first one. Apart this, thank you very much for this wonderful rendition, it's very helpful to watch :)
Love to hear this sung.
We sang Bach's Our Father in my Australian church .
Just sooooo soooothing.
I love you Paul...I'm really thankful for you passion on the art❤️ As a pianist, I have too say thanks for make me still be in love with all this!
Thanks a lot. Beautiful music I'm relax.
Bravo Monsieur , et MERCI à Jean Sébastien BACH .......
Thank you
Very beautiful
How could someone dislike this?!?
I'm so glad I'm subscribed to your channel, your selection of pieces is always exquisite.
You’ve got some good finger stretches in there 😎 Enjoyed watching and listening.
Oh very nice. I love this piece!
Wow 😯 Sounds Amazing Paul!!!
Merci du fond du cœur !
Tarcovsky Solaris sound track
Que maravilla Dios mío!!
Brilliant!
May we see you perform the Bach/Busoni Chaconne please? Thank you
Una maravilla!!! Gracias.
Thanks again, Paul, you always seem to have a video of the most beautiful pieces I'm looking to learn. On this occasion, I wonder if transposing it would work well on the piano. It has such subtle, but increasingly dark, harmonies, which don't seem to ring as I imagine they would on certain stops of the organ, or as they do on guitar. BTW, the link is broken to the imslp.
Beautiful!!!!!
Good Evening , Paul Barton 🎶
Thank you so very much for sharing this beautiful music with everyone ! Have a great weekend , May God Sorround you with his grace and peace , Take care !
✝️ 11/6/2020 ✝️
Hey I just started learning this 3 days ago! How coincidental
How's it progressing?
@@peterjongsma5540 pretty good, I can comfortably play almost a third of the whole piece.
@@mink1097 2 years on - did you finish learning this amazing piece? I started on it two months ago, devoting about an hour a day to it on top of my other practice. Memorised all but two lines of it (the part with the huge LH chords (from 2:30 in this vid) but so far still very slowly and carefully at MM semiquaver = 66. I am giving myself a year to make it absolutely performance ready.
2:50 E-F-E flat here. But, as Beethoven said, "to play a wrong note is insignificant; to play without passion is inexcusable." And you play with passion.
Beautiful! When will will great you're sweet Daughter Emilee sing again!? I also Really miss you playing for the sweet elephants too!
Bravo!!!
Bach-Busoni - “Ich ruf zu dir Herr Jesu Christ” Chorale Prelude, BWV 639
(바흐-부조니 코랄 전주곡 "제가 주 예수 당신을 부르나이다", BWV 639)
Machine... Turn back.
Nah it is "Limbo... Lust... All gone... With gluttony soon to follow... Your kind know nothing but hunger, purged all life on the upper layers, and yet they remain unsatiatedy, As do you... You've taken everything from me machine.. And now all that remains is perfect hatred.
thank you for notes
I approve
Liszt! You are also here.
I tried to learned this and it was hard. Don't know why this particular piece
2:51 es
Well listened!
es arī
How to start with the piano and music? I would love to be able to interpret and play ♥️🎹
I love your videos! Congrats!
Thanks so much. If you love piano music and feel you need to play it, you absolutely can. When you are passionate about music you can learn any instrument that will enable you to play it.
@@PaulBartonPiano Thank you very much, I really appreciate it!!👏
Nice performance though -
At about 2.51 in bar 2'of this page there is a misreading at the end of beat 1,the 4th 16th. note is an e flat ,not e natural 👍
Kto zna to z film „Na zachodzie bez zmian”?
einen kleinen Patzer haste reingehauen, irgendwo hättest Du n Es spielen müssen wo Du aus Versehen ein E gespielt hast, sonst sehr geil, vor allem mit den Klaviernoten zum Mitlesen, kuhle Sache
The sheet music link is broken
Amen
There is something about the tempo. I just remember it differently when i played it when i was younger. It's not one place, it's all over the place.
Are you saying Paul's timing is not consistent? If so, that's not true as he is incredibly attentive to tempo in this piece.
@@TheRedstonedeluxe yes, that is actually what I am saying. I know there are different opinion's on tempo and how to interpret these pieces, when the are rewritten for piano. But most of details and expressions in the piece should be kept. I remember many years ago when I played through this piece, I choose to play it in a faster tempo to suit the modern piano. It's not the, one or the other tempo choice thing, but he clearly makes a big tempo change at 1.29. There are also parts where the score writes "zehr weich"/very soft, where he flickers his hand making the notes hard. There are many places where I would personally play the notes softer and he plays it harder. He pauses his fermata as if they should be short fermata, but they are also uneven in a weird way. Maybe it is just me. Haven't played the piece for over 20 years.
@@Ianthe22 Maybe without the different registration in the organ he needs to take liberties in differentiating the notes?
@@coa8109 tbh. It may be.
Well played. Good pick. Gg
Bach always gave the credit to God
Fourth semiquaver Eflat in the bar after calando 😊
Your performance is on the level! You're as good as the greatest pianists.
... 💚...
У маня одного ощущение, что он лажает на трелях и в других местах немного?
Machine, turn back now.
Shut up. You are not funny.
@@Monsoon-r5nNegative Nancy
@@Monsoon-r5nsomeone just came in from frown town
@@BurgerBoy9001 aglo go back to your vidya
Tarkovsky films 😢
This is interesting. Why did Busoni transcribed this from original organ to piano? Couldn't he at least transcribe it for pedal piano? Yes, there is such an instrument. Schumann liked it a lot. Now this is like "let's make ourselves a hard,, unnaturally sounding piece from easy, well suited for organ style piece". I can only assume there was a fashion like this in the sixties. Funny that people can still fall for it. I have mixed feelings about this. Sorry.
Because this is one of the most moving and expressive piece of music and not everyone has a pedal piano or a organ inside their houses, that's why
I agree with Luca's answer here - and I also agree with you, The piano version misses the depth of the eternal organ tones, to the point that it's not at all the same piece anymore.
On the other hand, it gives a little insight in the structure of the real thing.
SOLARIS.
Is it me, or is that piano out of tune?
Better on cello
Forgive me internet,
But there is now hope under the new black sun
terribly boring performance.