Eine wundervolle Interpretation brillanter Musik! Ich komme aus Russland und mein Lieblingskomponist ist Deutscher. Ich habe dieses Werk im Film „Solaris“ gehört, mein Lieblingsregisseur ist Andrei Tarkovsky. Viel Glück und Inspiration!
Mit diesem Choralvorspiel hab ich auf der Orgel meine Aunahmeprüfung am Kons geschafft...die Prof.waten begeistert...ich spüre diesrn Moment immer noch😊
...Schuch is inside the music and in service to it, touching on the profound sense of humility so clearly intended by Bach...extra-ordinary, deepest thanks and bravo...)
The finest performance of this that I have heard. The lower dynamic near the end and the very deliberate conclusion are superb. The ending thus sounds natural instead of rather sudden as in so many other recordings. He really plays this as a prayer.
I call to thee, Lord Jesus Christ, I pray thee, hear my crying; Both lend me grace within this life And let me not lose courage; The proper path, O Lord, I seek, Which thou dost wish to give me: For thee living, My neighbor serving well, Thy word upholding justly.
Your performance ( for me ) is the best of all recordings I heard. The sound, the touch , legato, voicing - every note speaks deeply and with so much sensitivity. Thank you so much.
Herbert, you manage to take what I believe is the most sublime gem of Bach's small forms and bring grandeur to its perfection. I wept without control at the end. Thank you . . . thank you. I hope someday I can attend a performance of your true piano art.
Uno de los pianistas más interesantes actuales, sin duda. Es magnífico y con una sensibilidad y musicalidad fascinantes. Desde que ganó el premio Paloma O’Sea de Santander no ha dejado de deslumbrarme.
Zufällig entdeckte ich Ihre wunderbare und sehr ergreifende Aufführung heute, den 13.09.2021. Recht herzlichen Dank dafür, und herzlichen Glückwunsch zum Geburtstag!
Absolutely gorgeous. Thank you so much for sharing your artistry and dedication to the piano. And, many thanks for the piano technician’s brilliant preparation of this fine instrument.
I agree with John: Beautiful performance. At first I thought it was a little fast but the musicality of Herbert is great. Now I understand the connection to the 2end part. The fifth in the final major chord could be a little softer. Thank you Herbert Schuch!
From the first bar to the last chord: a swaying spirit of universal praying addressed to all people who believe in the power of pure art and its potential impact against everything that is evil and destructive on this planet. Thanks you, maestro Schuch, reminding me Haskil and Lipati; thank you, Johan Sebadtian Bach.
Nice. He takes a good tempo. Yes, the mood is prayerful and tends toward sad, perhaps regretful. Which mood it provokes is depends on you and what you bring to the listening experience. But one thing it is not (IMO of course) is a funeral dirge. Playing it too slowly makes it drag to the point where I get annoyed.
Es ist wunderschön gespielt. Bach ist Musik in absoluter Vollendung ❤❤❤
Ja, es ist Balsam für die Seele
Schöne Musik über die eigene Machtlosigkeit und Hingabe einer selbst an die übermenschlichen Gewalten.
Eine wundervolle Interpretation brillanter Musik! Ich komme aus Russland und mein Lieblingskomponist ist Deutscher. Ich habe dieses Werk im Film „Solaris“ gehört, mein Lieblingsregisseur ist Andrei Tarkovsky. Viel Glück und Inspiration!
Mit diesem Choralvorspiel hab ich auf der Orgel meine Aunahmeprüfung am Kons geschafft...die Prof.waten begeistert...ich spüre diesrn Moment immer noch😊
So tief ist es. So ist es...nicht so langsam...es muss sein vielleicht.
...Schuch is inside the music and in service to it, touching on the profound sense of humility so clearly intended by Bach...extra-ordinary, deepest thanks and bravo...)
The finest performance of this that I have heard. The lower dynamic near the end and the very deliberate conclusion are superb. The ending thus sounds natural instead of rather sudden as in so many other recordings. He really plays this as a prayer.
Thanks a lot for this!
Listen also to Tatiana Nikolayeva. All the best
I call to thee, Lord Jesus Christ,
I pray thee, hear my crying;
Both lend me grace within this life
And let me not lose courage;
The proper path, O Lord, I seek,
Which thou dost wish to give me:
For thee living,
My neighbor serving well,
Thy word upholding justly.
Grigory Sokolov also has a very very good version on RUclips
Lipatti-
Your performance ( for me ) is the best of all recordings I heard. The sound, the touch , legato, voicing - every note speaks deeply and with so much sensitivity. Thank you so much.
A worship song, played as a prayer. Beautiful
Simply not from this world...thanks a lot for the great present.
I can feel the passion on each phrase and note, Bach Will never die.
einer von wenigen Menschen, die die Dramatik von Bachs Musik empfinden und darstellen können
Very sensitive play, no ego just music as Bach likes in Heaven.
C'est sublime. Magnifique. Une merveilleuse source d'inspiration. Quelle pureté, quel velours !
bach jouer facon romantique cet tres beaux !! mai rien ne peut egaler la version d horowitz : pierre .
He has absolutely got this.
Ausgezeichnet 👍
Absolutely beautiful. What a perfect interpretation of this little masterpiece.
Very beautiful!
Wahrlich ruehrend und meisterhaft!
Прекрасное исполнение
Truly beautiful and pleasure to listen!
Красиво! С чувством! Спасибо!
Herbert, you manage to take what I believe is the most sublime gem of Bach's small forms and bring grandeur to its perfection. I wept without control at the end. Thank you . . . thank you. I hope someday I can attend a performance of your true piano art.
Große Kleinkunst.
@@johnrickert5572 Danke. Ich mag diese poetische Beschreibung; perfekt für viele Komponisten/Interpreten-Kombinationen.
@@prototropo Ich glaube, Vladimir Horowitz hat es über Scarlatti gesagt. Vielen Dank!
Brilliant ❤
Uno de los pianistas más interesantes actuales, sin duda. Es magnífico y con una sensibilidad y musicalidad fascinantes. Desde que ganó el premio Paloma O’Sea de Santander no ha dejado de deslumbrarme.
the great sound. It"s perfect
beautiful voicing! thank you!
La sua esecuzione è sempre pura, come la musica di Bach.
Herzlichen Dank!
The tear of 1.30m illustrates the emotion with which is played. Touching.
It's not a tear, actually, it's forehead sweating because of the heat of lights, falling on his eyes. Look more carefully
Zufällig entdeckte ich Ihre wunderbare und sehr ergreifende Aufführung heute, den 13.09.2021. Recht herzlichen Dank dafür, und herzlichen Glückwunsch zum Geburtstag!
Vielen Dank!!
Absolut berührend ! Wunderbare Interpretation!
Jan Sebastian Bach gdy pisał tą muzykę był przygnębiony i zasmucony
To się czuje.
Beautiful - a wonderful depiction of the incredible sensibility in you hands while playing this breath-taking masterpiece. Thank you for posting this!
Это превосходно, благодарю.
BRAVO!
Don't let the nervous beginning put you off or prompt you to stop listening, because this improves to the point of excellence.
Amazing Bach...!!!!!!
Wunderschön.........
Absolutely gorgeous. Thank you so much for sharing your artistry and dedication to the piano.
And, many thanks for the piano technician’s brilliant preparation of this fine instrument.
Як мені подобається цей чоловік!❤
А яке виконання чудове!
That moment when 18th century emotion was actually transport and brought forward through time by the power of music was here - 1:30
Unfortunately, it's sweat from his forehead because of heat (or stress), and not a tear :D look again !
Wonderful!!!
Wow!
Merci !!!!!!!!
Гениально...!❤
I remember.
❤
I agree with John: Beautiful performance. At first I thought it was a little fast but the musicality of Herbert is great.
Now I understand the connection to the 2end part. The fifth in the final major chord could be a little softer.
Thank you Herbert Schuch!
From the first bar to the last chord: a swaying spirit of universal praying addressed to all people who believe in the power of pure art and its potential impact against everything that is evil and destructive on this planet. Thanks you, maestro Schuch, reminding me Haskil and Lipati; thank you, Johan Sebadtian Bach.
👌🌹💫🌹🌹💫🌹🌹
Begeisterndes Spiel
la larmichette @ 1:30 !!!
Nice. He takes a good tempo. Yes, the mood is prayerful and tends toward sad, perhaps regretful. Which mood it provokes is depends on you and what you bring to the listening experience. But one thing it is not (IMO of course) is a funeral dirge. Playing it too slowly makes it drag to the point where I get annoyed.
Meine Meinung nach sollte diese wunderschoene Transcription Busonis etwas leiser und langsamer gespielt werden.