Difficulty levels for Germans: 1. Same language family (Norwegian, Swedish, Dutch) 2. Same language family but strongly influenced by other languages/difficult pronunciation (English, Danish, Islandic) 3. Different language family but same writing system (Spanish, French, Italian, Turkish, Polish) 4. Different language family and different writing system (Russian, Greek) 5. Different language family, different writing system and unknown concepts (Chinese, Japanese, Arabic, Xhosa, Hausa) Arguably there should be a level for the roman languages, because of the history both language families share. Then there are Ergative languages which also deserve a level on their own. But you can apply this template for your own language and determine, which language would be the easiest for you. Or maybe you're looking for a challenge. Also some learners tend to have problems with writing, some with grammar and others with pronunciation. Chinese grammar is _very_ easy, but pronunciation and writing are difficult. Korean has an amazingly easy writing system, but pronunciation and grammar are a challenge. Japanese is easy to pronounce (with 1-2 exceptions), but writing and grammar are difficult. German is not even close to the more difficult languages. From an English native speaker's perspective it's level 2.
Actually all the languages included in the levels 1-4 technically belong to the same language family, the indo-european family. But I get the point, 1 and 2 are from the germanic branch so much more similar to one another than to the rest of the family memebers.
@@lanzsibelius yes you are right, when using the already technical term language family then use it right, indo-germanic languages. The chart is very rough and I wouldn’t subscribe to it as a German. Applying the system above French definitely needs its own category as 2.5 bc of the strong cultural exchange since forever and especially in modern times (also Dutch as 0.5 or put everything else above). Also Basque, Hungarian and Finnish would have been better examples in 4. But I don’t see how Korean would be harder than Turkish just because of Hangul because Turkish has a much harder pronunciation than Korean. Pronunciation for Korean as a German is not that hard, some of the missing sounds you can transfer from English, I would even claim Korean pronunciation has more similarity with German than English, actually the finer details of Korean pronunciation like the different rules how to use shiftings sounds of ㄹ, ㅂ, ㄷ Germans be like “pick a lane” because we clearly hear differentiated sounds we definitely have in German when the Hangul character is applied in different word context. But then try to explain to a german English learner when and/or why a word is pronounced with the English soft G or TH, priceless. I would say that for a German in general learning an agglutinative language is an “unknown concept”, most European languages (population wise) are inflected languages and we think to know how to learn them bc the drill is the same like how our school system perfected our Genera (der, die das) and cases bc German is hard and German children misgender everything and even whole regions and socioeconomic classes of people misuse the case system.
As a German I had absolutely no problem with Mandarin, piece of cake to reach high level fluency for me, while I perceived Russian as much harder and Arabic as basically impossible.
Absolutely agree with what Joshua said towards the end- accents are very charming and add to your character. I don't think anyone should try and be perfect with it if they don't want to and shouldn't feel bad about not getting rid of the accent.
I'm Brazilian, but I have been living in Germany since 2021, and I'm currently in high school. I like to learn German, and I was really happy when Joshua said that he likes accents and when people learn German.
Heyy, German here🥰 How are you doing? It's so cool that you are learning German! I also love different languages, cultures and ofc accents so much. I've always been a girlie who loved English and French in school and in a few months I'll start taking Spanish lessons. I'm so excited❤☀️
@@LenaGwscolombian here,i like so much germany,i like your culture and i'd like to visit your country i'd like to learn german and other languajes ,you have a beautifull country
@@jagutichsachma no, not in Germany. We highly respect the Brazilians and we dont make jokes on them 🇧🇷 they just caught a bad day, so kinda worst case happened, so thats sports.. Everything can happen.
I studied german , i liked the language , indeed it wasn't easy for me , i know the basics , but still having problem with thoso long words connected to each other 😂
Ich habe am 18te Dezember mit Deutsch angefangen, am 13te Februar bin ich mich nach Berlin umgezogen, und jetzt bin ich B2 Niveau. Es ist eine schwierige Sprache zu beherrschen.
"Ich habe am 18ten Dezember mit Deutsch angefangen, am 13ten Februar bin ich nach Berlin umgezogen, und jetzt bin ich B2 Niveau. Die Sprache zu beherrschen ist schwierig." Good luck with your studies.
@@tangente00to get the red marker out is the most German thing ever. And I‘m sure you were about to argue that they won’t learn it correctly if you don’t correct them 😂
But I was about to do the same thing so we good 😂! (Ich finde du bist wirklich gut dafür, dass du erst seit einigen Monaten deutsch lernst. Es ist eine schwere Sprache viel Glück weiterhin!)
1:45 The turkish guy speaks ghetto German. This means that he speaks with a strong Turkish accent and slurs the words. He uses sh instead of s. This is typical for foreign districts, where Turkish and Arabic are often spoken.
Good video. If you think about how someone can tell a native speaker vs. learning it later in life, the participants are a good place to look as far as English is concerned. You can tell Seong-ji is a native speaker, I remember she was from Canada, I don't remember if she was born there, but she started learning English very early in life. Her accent is similar to a girl that was on the videos a year or two ago, Callie, from Michigan. Everyone is easily to understand, and like Joshua said, accents are cute anyways.
Mr. Ribery doesn't even know what the word "jubeln" means. He just repeats the word and doesn't get the gist at all. That video was hilarious. His German is absolutely terrible considering he spent 12(!) years here. He just doesn't seem to be a very smart fella in general.
I wish i had the voice like the guy from Germany... and the video lacks celebs from US like Sandra Bullock or Kirsten Dunst but I do get that the "celebs" were chosen to match the nationality of the people represented here
@@luise4113 well I kinda agree you because I've heard the pure German English accent but I think his accent was a british-german accent like he kinda improved his German accent in a British way? Idk it was so passionate
@@taylorp.-zm7hu haha maybe, but it's not the german accent alot of germans have here, because I think the one he is speaking sounds nice and I (as a german) don't hear so much of those typical german sounds in his pronounciation yk
Son did a great job speaking German. One of my favorite footballers. I wonder what Shaqiri would sound like .I think he's Albanian that emigrated to Switzerland during the 90s
Learnin German is a process based on many years of communication it is not very hard language to learn it only needs having the standards and just start to commincate everyday non stop i think after 6 or 7 years you can speak it really good with a light accent
It kinda is, is has literally 6 tenses, 3 articles plus another 3 indefinite ones, nouns have a grammatical gender are bend by 4 grammatical cases and a ton of other flexions. There are adjectives and verbs and it’s gets just more complicating as you look deeper into it. The syntax can be also confusing for non Europeans. Don’t forget umlaut, the great letter ß and things like „sch“ and „ch“ that an embarrassingly amount of native speaks also get wrong. Tbh with you learning any European language without the knowledge of another one is straight up a pain in the ass. Most European languages kinda function the same no matter Germanic or Latin in the sense that they are Indo-European languages and follow quite similar rules. It’s only easy to us here, but not for the rest of the world so to make it short. *Stop gaslighting folks.* So Joshua is kinda right about it, it’s not more difficult than other European languages, but it’s also not the easiest one in the world.
A little bit cliché that in the end there were a lot of football players, as for “Koreans” there is the actor Teo Yoo from the 2023 American-Korean movie “Past Lives”, was blown away when I found out that he grew up in Germany.
Joshuas voice sounds so smooth and deep. Regarding the japanese Guy, he got pretty far with the pronucation only the 'sch' and 'ch' sound he confuses a little. I got the feeling he makes a hard stop at each sentence. That reminds me that the first classes in japanese all sentence endet with a 'desu' hard stop.
@@HopeeInk Hängt das nicht davon ab, woher man kommt? Bei mir in Süddeutschland bin ich noch nie jemandem begegnet, der Kirsche statt Kirche sagt. Hat eher was mit dem jeweiligen Dialekt zu tun
She sounded almost completely native to me, apart from a small grammar mistake. I think she’s just using somewhat of a Korean rhythm when speaking, so it sounds different, but her pronunciation is right. She even fluently pronounced “helfen” as “helf’n”, which most non-natives can’t do without still having an accent.
I looove when French folks speak German, the French tongue makes it sound almost sensual xD like one time this French girl was speaking German to me complaining about expensive prices in public transport and I was like: yeah could you repeat the last part again for me, sorry I was a bit distracted xD her tone was so flirty
The origin of bad behavior lies not in nationality, but in the individuals themselves and the education they have received. It's pretty obvious that a lack of civic-mindedness doesn't stop at the border, especially in a globalized society.
@@skrang6472 You are right, but there is a prejudice about the French being egoistic. Also, since we hear that they do not like Turks, you automatically have prejudices as a Turk.But unless I'm doing the wrong analysis, there is no egoism on Robin's face. For this reason, he broke my prejudice. Of course, I don't know what his thoughts are about the Turks.
Great video. But I missed Sandra Bullock and Leonardo DiCaprio. Sandra Bullock`s mother was a German opera singer and Leonardo DiCaprio´s grandma lives in Germany.
Das längste wort in Deutschland das ich kenne heißt ,,Donaudampfschifffahrtselektrizitätenhauptbetriebswerkbauunterbeamtengesellschaft,,. Viel Spaß das auszusprechen😂
@@kellymcbright5456 stimmt doch gar nicht, man versteht, dass es Beamtendeutsch ist und dass es um Bauunternehmer von Dampfschiffen auf der Donau geht.
@@HopeeInk i tell you a longer one "Donaudampfschifffahrtselektrizitätenhauptbetriebswerkbauunterbeamtengesellschaftsmitarbeiter" ....in the german langues you can just connect words. the word that i created is proper german and describes someone that woks at the "....beamtengesellschaft". i just added the word "mitarbeiter" which you can do with no issue. you can even add more if you like to. you could also add the german word for desk so that you revering to the desk of the guy that works there -> "Donaudampfschifffahrtselektrizitätenhauptbetriebswerkbauunterbeamtengesellschaftsmitarbeiterschreibtisch"
She is pretty fluent in German, but she has definately some touch of Asian accent and sometimes intonation of words is a little off. Maybe it was influenced, because she switched between both languages to translate every sentence.
Heung Min Son’s incredibly fluent in Germany and considering he lives there since he was 16,agree with Joshua that it is amongst the best of non German speaking the language
Still quite impressive for him to learn the language to that degree only having been in Germany for 6 or so years and having moved in his late teens. Personally know many people who've been in countries for 10-20 years without developing conversational fluency
@@arbabasukalsar4361 Tbf think it came out later that his English was decent... he just pulled a Gareth Bale. It's not that they can't, it's that they won't 😂
@@OMEGALULEatingAnEggplant Makes sense though since he spoke German before he learned English. And since German and English are more than 50% alike, he probably learned English through German words and pronunciations
Uhm, good video idea, but I would hella appreciate another version of something similar, there are way bigger artists which can speak german. It's actually really interesting to look into Hollywood and these guys, because you will see many hollywoodactors speak it
Well there are already dozens of videos with Sandra Bullock or Leonardo DiCaprio. I found it much more refreshing to have other stars speaking German. Most of them were football players that have played for many years for German clubs.
Ich lerne Deutsch seit seiben Monat und ich denke, dass Deutsch sehr schwer ist. Weil es zu viele Regeln gibt. Ohne Polisch Sprechen ich glaube, dass Deutsch das Schwierigste Sprechen in Europa ist.
Well it always depends on your starting point (meaning: your mother tongue). For a Norwegian or Dutch-speaker German is not that hard to learn. For an Italian or Greek it's probably much tougher. So I think the German guy is right by putting it in the middle. Harder than English, but easier than Polish, Finish or Hungarian.
Ich glaube das nicht, die deutsche Sprache ist nicht so schwer , es braucht mehr kommunikation den ganzen Tag non stop , nach 5 Jahre kann Mann richtig gut Deutsch sprechen , ich spreche Deutsch jetzt seit 3 Jahre und ich lerne immer aber kannst du merken dass du hast sehr gut selbst entwickelt !
@@sanipine "For a Norwegian or Dutch-speaker German is not that hard to learn." Ye you have a much easier time than people coming from other backgrounds so you will make progress way quicker. But learning German properly, with little to no grammatical mistakes is still super hard for them as well and they will probably never reach that point.
I think it's nice to hear him say how an accent adds to your character. I hate to have an accent and I really want to get rid of it but he's kind of right. It's ok to have an accent.
Koreli ve fransızın genel kültür hakkında hiç bir fikri yok arap aksanı türklerden çok fransızlarda var koreli kızın Türkiye ve Iran için doğu demesi daha komik kendinin koreli olduğunu unuttu galiba coğrafya bilgisi yok😂
Gerçekten inanılmaz Türkçe ve arapçanın aksan olarak hiçbir benzerliği yok. insanların böyle konuşması Türk insanları daha da kültür açısından ofansif yapıyor. Hayır benzeyip benzememesi bir şey ifade etmez de, benzemeyen bir şeyi saçma sapan her ortamda duyunca halkımız haklı olarak tepki koyuyor. Bu kez Türkler ırkçı oluyor 😂😂
Maalesef bu genel kültür ile alakalı bir durum değil, 2 yıldır İrlanda'da yaşıyorum ve "Arapça mi konusuyorsunuz" "Arap aksanın var" gibi durumlarla çokça karşılaştım. Bence nedeni Türkiye'de baskın dinin müslümanlık olması ve benim adım dahil, 'merhaba' 'teşekkür' gibi basit sözcüklerin ödünç alınması başka bir dile geçerken etkiliyor. Başlarda ben de çok kızıyordum ama zamanla alıştım, tavsiyem boş verin ve izleyip eğlenmenize bakın 😊
@@KmlYldz Dilimize arapça kadar Fransızca sözcükte girmiş ama kimse bize fransızca mı konuşuyorsunuz demiyor (öyle desinler diye demiyorum) dinle alakalı bir durum olsaydı arnavut ya da boşnaklara da Arap demeleri gerekiyor çoğunlukla müslüman ama hiç diyeni duymadım bu bence tamamen genel kültürle alakalı bir durum Brezilyalılara İspanyolca mı konuşuyorsunuz demek gibi bir şey
I like it when he says that they are not "foreigners," but rather Germans who have grown up or were born in Germany. I feel the same way! Ich mag es, wenn er sagt, dass das keine "Ausländer" sind, sondern dass es Deutsche sind, die in Deutschland aufgewachsen oder geboren worden sind. Sehe ich genauso!
I think german is hard to get when natives speak with unclear pronunciation, called nuscheln in german. We skip letters like e at end of words - habn instead of haben. Btw Google translation follow nuscheln too...
I am Turkish, born and raised in Germany. I am 32 years old and still have difficulties with grammar. I don't know how German can be classified as medium difficulty when there's even a saying: „Deutsche Sprache, schwere Sprache.“ - 'German language, difficult language.'😅
@@texmexexpresssaya menonton drama Ertugrul, dan saya melihat para pelakon mirip gadis Iran ini, berambut hitam, bola mata warna hitam, kulit putih, hidung mancung, dan iras orang timur Tengah
@@Kane_2001Penampilan yang kamu gambarkan bukanlah penampilan Timur Tengah. Penampilan yang kamu gambarkan adalah penampilan Iran. Aktris-aktris Turki dalam seri Ertuğrul bahkan tidak setengah cantik dibandingkan wanita-wanita Iran.
I actually can't believe how fast football players pick up the language. Imagine coming to a different country and learning the language from scratch... I could never
1:45 The turkish guy speaks ghetto German. This means that he speaks with a strong Turkish accent and slurs the words. He uses sh instead of s. This is typical for foreign districts, where Turkish and Arabic are often spoken.
We need a video of people pronouncing of famous people from Germany and Austria Diane Kruger(from Troy and National Treasure),Daniel Brühl(Rush),Til Schweiger(Inglorious basterds),Alexandra Maria Lars(Rush),Arnold Schwarzenegger and Christopher Waltz. Michael Schumacher,Sebastian Vettel and Nico Rosberg;Formula 1 race car world champions Football Toni Kroos,Bastian Schweinsteiger,Ilkay Gundogan,Mesut Özil(Love to see their name pronounciations in Turkish) and Joshua Kimmich Basketball’s Dirk Norwitzski
9:57 She is so ignorant. A person who was born and raised in Germany is German, both nationally and politically. Why was she so surprised to the contrary. That person has no connection with Korea what so over - he isn't Korean at all. Of course, he speaks German fluently. What else would he speak?
yo, Cha Du-Ri is OG German home boy. Also football is “the medium” how we integrate people into German society, Turkish Germans ended some nasty debates of the 1990s of Turkish people not being part of Germany by being the most German fans of the football World Cup 2006.
Cha do-ri ist in Deutschland aufgewachsen. Er ist der Sohn von Cha bum-kun, ein Koreanischer Fußballer, der in den 80gern ewig lange für Bayer Leverkusen gespielt hat.
Germans articles so hard to learn. As a Turkish person , in my opinion, learning articles the hardest think while you trying learn German language. All the language build up from them. But its really nice they have really richest gramer structure.
@@puccaland in bavaria they tend to speak with a very heavy accent and the rest of germany don't understand them most of the time, it is basically considered as another language (quite a common joke and yet so true). so if you ask him to speak german and he starts to go off on bavarian with a french accent germans would not understand him, since he learned another language 😁
It's called "Fußball" (Football) in German. They usually teach British English in German schools. Maybe he consumed too much American media, hence he has an inclination to use American English terms when he speaks in English.
The first "German" speaker in the videos obviously spoke German like foreigners from the Near East (like Turks, Arabs). No native German or native from other German speaking countries has that thick accent.
The appearance of an Iranian woman was completely different from all women, for example, a Korean and a Japanese woman were the same, their faces were the same, and a Turkish woman was different from everyone, like an Iranian, but Kimia, who is Iranian, was much more beautiful in my opinion because we are from the same country. Are
Heung Min Son shows that you do not have to be born in a place, in order to learn the language: Just talk to the natives, do you homework and use the language a lot. It helps to start out young though 😉
He came to Germany when he was pretty young and started to play in the football academy of Hamburg and lived there in a shared flat with mostly German kids. By that he learned it really well and I couldn't tell he is not German by his accent. Maybe only in very deep conversations with complex topics.
@@somersault4762als Hamburger, wenngleich Anhänger der (jetzt auch sportlich) Nummer Eins der Stadt, weiß ich das natürlich. Ich würde dennoch widersprechen, er spricht definitiv sehr gut, gerade die Aussprache und Betonung hat er drauf, aber strukturell merkt man ziemlich schnell, dass er kein Muttersprachler ist. Hier z.B.: m.ruclips.net/video/TFvQfSsNsfQ/видео.html Dennoch steht meine Aussage oben: Heu Ming Song zeigt dass und wie es geht 😉
# Kırık Dostlukların Sırları# Bölüm 1: Gizemli Mesaj Bang Chan, Hyunjin, Han, Felix, Seungmin, Jeongin ve Lee Know, kasabanın en iyi arkadaşlarıydı. Ancak, bir gün, hayatları beklenmedik bir mesajla altüst oldu. Hepsi aynı anda garip bir mesaj aldılar. Mesajda, "Gece yarısı, eski fabrikada buluşun. Geçmişin sırları sizi bekliyor," yazıyordu. Bang Chan, meraklı bir lider olarak, mesajın nereden geldiğini araştırmaya başladı. Ancak, numara iz bırakmamıştı, mesajın gizemi korunuyordu. Seungmin: "Bu bir şaka olabilir mi?" Hyunjin: "Belki de değil. Belki de gerçekten bir şeyler var." Gece yarısı fabrikada buluşmaya karar verdiler. Fabrika, karanlık ve terkedilmişti. Kapıları açtıklarında, içeride eski makineler ve toz bulutlarıyla karşılaştılar. Ortada eski bir masa ve üzerinde tozlu bir defter vardı. Felix, defteri açıp ilk sayfayı okudu: "Gerçekler acıdır ve bazen en yakınınızdakiler bile sırlara sahiptir." Lee Know: "Bu ne demek olabilir?" Işıklar birden söndü ve kapı kapanarak kilitlendi. İçeride mahsur kalmışlardı. Hyunjin, sessizce itiraf etti: "Bu mesajı ben gönderdim." Arkadaşları şaşkınlık içinde bakarken, Hyunjin devam etti: "Geçmişimde yaptığım bir hata yüzünden sizleri tehlikeye attım. Bu fabrika, o karanlık günlerden kalma." Tam o sırada, fabrikaya silahlı adamlar girdi ve kapıyı kilitledi. Han: "Ne yapacağız?" Bang Chan hızla bir plan yaparak: "Birlikte çalışmalıyız. Hyunjin'in sırlarını kabul etmeliyiz ama bu durumdan nasıl kurtulacağımızı bulmalıyız." Seungmin ve Jeongin, dikkat dağıtmak için ekipmanları kullanırken, diğerleri kaçış yolları aradı. Hyunjin ise pişmanlık ve korku içindeydi: "Özür dilerim. Ama birlikte bunun üstesinden gelebiliriz." Tam kaçacakken, patlama sesi duyuldu ve bir duvar yıkılarak yardım sinyalleri geldi. Bang Chan: "Gerçek tehlike daha yeni başlıyor." Grup, fabrikadan çıkıp kurtarılmayı beklerken, kimin yardım ettiğini anlamaya çalışıyordu. Gölgeler arasında beliren kişi, onlara yardım ediyordu, ancak niyetleri hala belirsizdi. Jeongin: "Sen kimsin?" Gizemli kişi, yüzünü gizleyen kapüşonunu indirdi ve kendini tanıttı: "Ben Yeji. Sizi takip ediyordum çünkü Hyunjin'in sırları benim için de önemli." Hyunjin şaşkınlıkla sordu: "Senin burada ne işin var? Seninle yollarımız ayrılmıştı." Yeji: "Size yardım etmeye geldim. Ama bunun karşılığında bazı cevaplara ihtiyacım var." Bang Chan, güvenli bir yer aramaya karar verdi: "Örgütten kurtulmamıza yardım edebileceğini söylüyorsan, peşimizdeki adamlar hakkında ne biliyorsun?" Yeji, örgütün peşinde olduklarını ve Hyunjin'in ellerindeki belgeler yüzünden tehlikede olduklarını açıkladı. Felix: "Hyunjin, ne tür belgeler?" Hyunjin, titreyen bir sesle: "Örgüt liderinin suçlarını kanıtlayanlar. Ama bunlar gizli bir yerde." Grup, belgeleri bulmak ve tehlikeden kurtulmak için harekete geçti. Ancak, aralarındaki güven giderek zayıflıyordu. Geçmişin gölgeleri, karanlık sırlarla birleşerek ortaya çıkıyordu. --- 2. BÖLÜM İÇİN ABONE OLUR MUSUN? KANALIMI BÜYÜTMEK ISTİYORUM YARDIMCI OLUR MUSUNUZ?❤❤❤
I love how he talks English with german accents..
That's so charismatic and charming!
sry but wheres the german accent there? I see almost no german accent in anything he spoke.
@@lazymate7421 Yeah, I too
No german Accent available there at all
@@stecher1995 Well I can hear it. But maybe thats a german thing. We are weird like that.
@@lazymate7421 I hear it. It's the the way he enunciates
The German guy was so chill. Loved his vibe.
I think he is rather strange with his choice of outfit.
He is a weirdo
@@othellox1064 Yep, he is trying to act cool which makes him seem cocky.
@@Gewaldro bruh he can wear whatever he wants, stop insulting him just because you lack his style and can’t dress properly
@@othellox1064why?
The french guy is so cute, he was kinda shy haha
My first time doing this sorry 🫣
@@Shijaaa hahaha don't worry, you did it and it was cute!
@@arturfellipe372True he's very cute
@@Shijaaa mignon
@@Shijaaawe need to see you more in videoos
i need a 1 hour podcast from that german
Ja or yes
Great job! Loved the approach of hearing people speaking in a natural context and not sounding like the canned harsh German stereotype. Way to go!
Difficulty levels for Germans:
1. Same language family (Norwegian, Swedish, Dutch)
2. Same language family but strongly influenced by other languages/difficult pronunciation (English, Danish, Islandic)
3. Different language family but same writing system (Spanish, French, Italian, Turkish, Polish)
4. Different language family and different writing system (Russian, Greek)
5. Different language family, different writing system and unknown concepts (Chinese, Japanese, Arabic, Xhosa, Hausa)
Arguably there should be a level for the roman languages, because of the history both language families share. Then there are Ergative languages which also deserve a level on their own. But you can apply this template for your own language and determine, which language would be the easiest for you. Or maybe you're looking for a challenge. Also some learners tend to have problems with writing, some with grammar and others with pronunciation. Chinese grammar is _very_ easy, but pronunciation and writing are difficult. Korean has an amazingly easy writing system, but pronunciation and grammar are a challenge. Japanese is easy to pronounce (with 1-2 exceptions), but writing and grammar are difficult. German is not even close to the more difficult languages. From an English native speaker's perspective it's level 2.
Sehr beeindruckend das Sie so viel wissen darüber! 😁
@@caisrr
Berufskrankheit :)
Actually all the languages included in the levels 1-4 technically belong to the same language family, the indo-european family. But I get the point, 1 and 2 are from the germanic branch so much more similar to one another than to the rest of the family memebers.
@@lanzsibelius yes you are right, when using the already technical term language family then use it right, indo-germanic languages. The chart is very rough and I wouldn’t subscribe to it as a German.
Applying the system above French definitely needs its own category as 2.5 bc of the strong cultural exchange since forever and especially in modern times (also Dutch as 0.5 or put everything else above).
Also Basque, Hungarian and Finnish would have been better examples in 4. But I don’t see how Korean would be harder than Turkish just because of Hangul because Turkish has a much harder pronunciation than Korean. Pronunciation for Korean as a German is not that hard, some of the missing sounds you can transfer from English, I would even claim Korean pronunciation has more similarity with German than English, actually the finer details of Korean pronunciation like the different rules how to use shiftings sounds of ㄹ, ㅂ, ㄷ Germans be like “pick a lane” because we clearly hear differentiated sounds we definitely have in German when the Hangul character is applied in different word context. But then try to explain to a german English learner when and/or why a word is pronounced with the English soft G or TH, priceless.
I would say that for a German in general learning an agglutinative language is an “unknown concept”, most European languages (population wise) are inflected languages and we think to know how to learn them bc the drill is the same like how our school system perfected our Genera (der, die das) and cases bc German is hard and German children misgender everything and even whole regions and socioeconomic classes of people misuse the case system.
As a German I had absolutely no problem with Mandarin, piece of cake to reach high level fluency for me, while I perceived Russian as much harder and Arabic as basically impossible.
Absolutely agree with what Joshua said towards the end- accents are very charming and add to your character. I don't think anyone should try and be perfect with it if they don't want to and shouldn't feel bad about not getting rid of the accent.
I'm Brazilian, but I have been living in Germany since 2021, and I'm currently in high school. I like to learn German, and I was really happy when Joshua said that he likes accents and when people learn German.
Heyy, German here🥰 How are you doing? It's so cool that you are learning German! I also love different languages, cultures and ofc accents so much. I've always been a girlie who loved English and French in school and in a few months I'll start taking Spanish lessons. I'm so excited❤☀️
@@LenaGwscolombian here,i like so much germany,i like your culture and i'd like to visit your country i'd like to learn german and other languajes ,you have a beautifull country
you tired of the certain soccer result jokes yet?
@@jagutichsachma no, not in Germany. We highly respect the Brazilians and we dont make jokes on them 🇧🇷 they just caught a bad day, so kinda worst case happened, so thats sports.. Everything can happen.
@@jagutichsachma btw it's still football ⚽ not soccer 🇺🇸 Jack, check Laurenade or the song "football 's coming home" 😜
Why does that French guy have such a beautiful smile? It's unfair!
I don't 🫣
@@Shijaaa But you do! You need a licence for that smile 😁
He’s adorable
@@ZoeAlecxis Thanks 🥹
This german guy is as real as it gets.
Persian language is the best and most beautiful language in the world
Bur very hard to learn I think
I like that German guy. The way he talks is cool.
Like a movie villain 😂
I think Persian is a beautiful language ෆ
she is very pretty too (♡ω♡ )
I studied german , i liked the language , indeed it wasn't easy for me , i know the basics , but still having problem with thoso long words connected to each other 😂
Me either but i also still have problem with articles
Also hast du... Kompositionsverständnisprobleme? ^^
It's like Lego bricks, if you know the bricks it's easier than English.
Explain why it's easier than English?
@@alansmith4748 because you have to learn less vocabulary as words are put together.
Ich habe am 18te Dezember mit Deutsch angefangen, am 13te Februar bin ich mich nach Berlin umgezogen, und jetzt bin ich B2 Niveau. Es ist eine schwierige Sprache zu beherrschen.
"Ich habe am 18ten Dezember mit Deutsch angefangen, am 13ten Februar bin ich nach Berlin umgezogen, und jetzt bin ich B2 Niveau. Die Sprache zu beherrschen ist schwierig."
Good luck with your studies.
@@tangente00to get the red marker out is the most German thing ever. And I‘m sure you were about to argue that they won’t learn it correctly if you don’t correct them 😂
But I was about to do the same thing so we good 😂! (Ich finde du bist wirklich gut dafür, dass du erst seit einigen Monaten deutsch lernst. Es ist eine schwere Sprache viel Glück weiterhin!)
Mad respect! - May I ask what your mother tongue is?
@@tangente00 typical German comment. Shame on u 🤌🏼
As a football fan this makes me happy. It really brings cultures together
1:45 The turkish guy speaks ghetto German. This means that he speaks with a strong Turkish accent and slurs the words. He uses sh instead of s. This is typical for foreign districts, where Turkish and Arabic are often spoken.
@@inotoni6148bro you should have posted your own comment and not answering to this guy cause this has nothing to do with
Joshua participations are so cool!
9:55 "So zatz vai! Zats onfer!" When you're losing your cool and the accent comes out 🤣
😂😂😂oh i love it
Son’s German is amazing
I going to Turkey because Turkish is very interesting
Im from South Korea
Aynen knk korelisin nedense bion ve tanitim yazin oyle demiyor
Good video. If you think about how someone can tell a native speaker vs. learning it later in life, the participants are a good place to look as far as English is concerned. You can tell Seong-ji is a native speaker, I remember she was from Canada, I don't remember if she was born there, but she started learning English very early in life. Her accent is similar to a girl that was on the videos a year or two ago, Callie, from Michigan.
Everyone is easily to understand, and like Joshua said, accents are cute anyways.
Franck Ribéry struggles a lot in French. He's like a french version of Sinok from the goonies 🤣
Thanks! I knew I know the guy but I could not remember his name.
it was sad scene nobody said that his name in the video. He is legend... Franck Ribery
Mr. Ribery doesn't even know what the word "jubeln" means. He just repeats the word and doesn't get the gist at all. That video was hilarious.
His German is absolutely terrible considering he spent 12(!) years here. He just doesn't seem to be a very smart fella in general.
Ribéry struggles with a lot of things.
I wish i had the voice like the guy from Germany... and the video lacks celebs from US like Sandra Bullock or Kirsten Dunst but I do get that the "celebs" were chosen to match the nationality of the people represented here
and also, there is a different video where these celebs were chosen for this
To be honest i really liked this team .
This German guy made me in love with German English accent
Actually he doesn't speak in a german accent, he propably taught himself to use a british accent. :) The real german accent doesn't sound so nice xd
@@luise4113 Of course his accent is German, it's just not a strong accent
@@luise4113 well I kinda agree you because I've heard the pure German English accent but I think his accent was a british-german accent like he kinda improved his German accent in a British way? Idk it was so passionate
@@taylorp.-zm7hu haha maybe, but it's not the german accent alot of germans have here, because I think the one he is speaking sounds nice and I (as a german) don't hear so much of those typical german sounds in his pronounciation yk
@@luise4113 I'm German too and you can definitely tell his accent is German. But I know what you mean, his is less annoying
Son did a great job speaking German. One of my favorite footballers. I wonder what Shaqiri would sound like .I think he's Albanian that emigrated to Switzerland during the 90s
Love Germany and Germans from Persia ❤
Learnin German is a process based on many years of communication it is not very hard language to learn it only needs having the standards and just start to commincate everyday non stop i think after 6 or 7 years you can speak it really good with a light accent
It kinda is, is has literally 6 tenses, 3 articles plus another 3 indefinite ones, nouns have a grammatical gender are bend by 4 grammatical cases and a ton of other flexions. There are adjectives and verbs and it’s gets just more complicating as you look deeper into it. The syntax can be also confusing for non Europeans. Don’t forget umlaut, the great letter ß and things like „sch“ and „ch“ that an embarrassingly amount of native speaks also get wrong. Tbh with you learning any European language without the knowledge of another one is straight up a pain in the ass. Most European languages kinda function the same no matter Germanic or Latin in the sense that they are Indo-European languages and follow quite similar rules. It’s only easy to us here, but not for the rest of the world so to make it short. *Stop gaslighting folks.* So Joshua is kinda right about it, it’s not more difficult than other European languages, but it’s also not the easiest one in the world.
A little bit cliché that in the end there were a lot of football players, as for “Koreans” there is the actor Teo Yoo from the 2023 American-Korean movie “Past Lives”, was blown away when I found out that he grew up in Germany.
Joshuas voice sounds so smooth and deep. Regarding the japanese Guy, he got pretty far with the pronucation only the 'sch' and 'ch' sound he confuses a little. I got the feeling he makes a hard stop at each sentence. That reminds me that the first classes in japanese all sentence endet with a 'desu' hard stop.
To be fair to him most struggle with that one lowkey. Even the Germans themselves 😭. The good old Kirche and Kirsche dilemma 🤷🏾♀️. Hab ich recht?
@@HopeeInk Hängt das nicht davon ab, woher man kommt? Bei mir in Süddeutschland bin ich noch nie jemandem begegnet, der Kirsche statt Kirche sagt. Hat eher was mit dem jeweiligen Dialekt zu tun
@@LenaGws ja, eigentlich nur von der Pfalz ab, den Rhein entlang, bis nach Köln @hopeeink meint also das Rheinland
@@HopeeInk That's not struggling, that's dialect
Teo Yoo is also fluent in german he was born and raised over there
Afarin be namayande khobemon kimia khanom, movafagh bashi👍
09:20 his father Cha Bum-kun played for the same (best) team (in germany :-P ) and became german, so thats why he's so perfect ;-P
adorable Kimia❤
Persian language ❤
The Korean lady speaking in German has more of a korean accent 😊
She sounded almost completely native to me, apart from a small grammar mistake. I think she’s just using somewhat of a Korean rhythm when speaking, so it sounds different, but her pronunciation is right. She even fluently pronounced “helfen” as “helf’n”, which most non-natives can’t do without still having an accent.
I looove when French folks speak German, the French tongue makes it sound almost sensual xD like one time this French girl was speaking German to me complaining about expensive prices in public transport and I was like: yeah could you repeat the last part again for me, sorry I was a bit distracted xD her tone was so flirty
Yes on South Brasil some.people speaks Germany as first language
I think the area of Blumenau is pretty much influenced by Germans who emigrated there during the world wars.
This French boy broke my prejudice against French men a little. He seems like a good and pure person.
Of course I am 😢
The origin of bad behavior lies not in nationality, but in the individuals themselves and the education they have received. It's pretty obvious that a lack of civic-mindedness doesn't stop at the border, especially in a globalized society.
@@Shijaaa This is a good feature. Do not be sad 😊
@@skrang6472 You are right, but there is a prejudice about the French being egoistic. Also, since we hear that they do not like Turks, you automatically have prejudices as a Turk.But unless I'm doing the wrong analysis, there is no egoism on Robin's face. For this reason, he broke my prejudice. Of course, I don't know what his thoughts are about the Turks.
@g.n.k2996 I never judge someone by his ethnicity/origins, only the behavior matters to me ! 😊
Great video. But I missed Sandra Bullock and Leonardo DiCaprio. Sandra Bullock`s mother was a German opera singer and Leonardo DiCaprio´s grandma lives in Germany.
The German guy is majestic
Lol, so here we have a German who knows even less about Football/Soccer than me. 😂
Das längste wort in Deutschland das ich kenne heißt ,,Donaudampfschifffahrtselektrizitätenhauptbetriebswerkbauunterbeamtengesellschaft,,. Viel Spaß das auszusprechen😂
Das ist Nonsens.
@@kellymcbright5456 stimmt doch gar nicht, man versteht, dass es Beamtendeutsch ist und dass es um Bauunternehmer von Dampfschiffen auf der Donau geht.
@@kellymcbright5456it’s the longest German world. Es ist sogar ein Guiness Weltrekord.
@@HopeeInk i tell you a longer one "Donaudampfschifffahrtselektrizitätenhauptbetriebswerkbauunterbeamtengesellschaftsmitarbeiter" ....in the german langues you can just connect words. the word that i created is proper german and describes someone that woks at the "....beamtengesellschaft". i just added the word "mitarbeiter" which you can do with no issue. you can even add more if you like to. you could also add the german word for desk so that you revering to the desk of the guy that works there -> "Donaudampfschifffahrtselektrizitätenhauptbetriebswerkbauunterbeamtengesellschaftsmitarbeiterschreibtisch"
@@ShadowMcSneaky Zusammengesetzte Nomen sind an sich eigentlich unfair mit genug Kreativität kann man ja die Kette ewig weiterführen 😭😂
Should have added Sandra Bullock in the bonus round. She's great!
7:38 Not knowing German, I don't know if I necessarily picked up many accent mistakes, but her tonal phrasing definitely sounded like a South Korean.
She is pretty fluent in German, but she has definately some touch of Asian accent and sometimes intonation of words is a little off. Maybe it was influenced, because she switched between both languages to translate every sentence.
Heung Min Son’s incredibly fluent in Germany and considering he lives there since he was 16,agree with Joshua that it is amongst the best of non German speaking the language
Still quite impressive for him to learn the language to that degree only having been in Germany for 6 or so years and having moved in his late teens. Personally know many people who've been in countries for 10-20 years without developing conversational fluency
@@siiiiiuu7 Sergio Aguero lmao
Funny thing about son is that I feel like he has a german accent when speaking English, that's how fluent he is in german
@@arbabasukalsar4361 Tbf think it came out later that his English was decent... he just pulled a Gareth Bale. It's not that they can't, it's that they won't 😂
@@OMEGALULEatingAnEggplant Makes sense though since he spoke German before he learned English. And since German and English are more than 50% alike, he probably learned English through German words and pronunciations
Uhm, good video idea, but I would hella appreciate another version of something similar, there are way bigger artists which can speak german.
It's actually really interesting to look into Hollywood and these guys, because you will see many hollywoodactors speak it
Well there are already dozens of videos with Sandra Bullock or Leonardo DiCaprio. I found it much more refreshing to have other stars speaking German. Most of them were football players that have played for many years for German clubs.
Ich lerne Deutsch seit seiben Monat und ich denke, dass Deutsch sehr schwer ist. Weil es zu viele Regeln gibt. Ohne Polisch Sprechen ich glaube, dass Deutsch das Schwierigste Sprechen in Europa ist.
Well it always depends on your starting point (meaning: your mother tongue). For a Norwegian or Dutch-speaker German is not that hard to learn. For an Italian or Greek it's probably much tougher. So I think the German guy is right by putting it in the middle. Harder than English, but easier than Polish, Finish or Hungarian.
Ich glaube das nicht, die deutsche Sprache ist nicht so schwer , es braucht mehr kommunikation den ganzen Tag non stop , nach 5 Jahre kann Mann richtig gut Deutsch sprechen , ich spreche Deutsch jetzt seit 3 Jahre und ich lerne immer aber kannst du merken dass du hast sehr gut selbst entwickelt !
Тогда попробуй русский
@@sanipine "For a Norwegian or Dutch-speaker German is not that hard to learn."
Ye you have a much easier time than people coming from other backgrounds so you will make progress way quicker.
But learning German properly, with little to no grammatical mistakes is still super hard for them as well and they will probably never reach that point.
I think it's nice to hear him say how an accent adds to your character. I hate to have an accent and I really want to get rid of it but he's kind of right. It's ok to have an accent.
Koreli ve fransızın genel kültür hakkında hiç bir fikri yok arap aksanı türklerden çok fransızlarda var koreli kızın Türkiye ve Iran için doğu demesi daha komik kendinin koreli olduğunu unuttu galiba coğrafya bilgisi yok😂
Harbiden ya çok sinir bozucu
Gerçekten inanılmaz Türkçe ve arapçanın aksan olarak hiçbir benzerliği yok. insanların böyle konuşması Türk insanları daha da kültür açısından ofansif yapıyor. Hayır benzeyip benzememesi bir şey ifade etmez de, benzemeyen bir şeyi saçma sapan her ortamda duyunca halkımız haklı olarak tepki koyuyor. Bu kez Türkler ırkçı oluyor 😂😂
avrupa - hint dilleri arasında yer alıyorlar, biz dil olarak farklıyız fazlasıyla
Maalesef bu genel kültür ile alakalı bir durum değil, 2 yıldır İrlanda'da yaşıyorum ve "Arapça mi konusuyorsunuz" "Arap aksanın var" gibi durumlarla çokça karşılaştım. Bence nedeni Türkiye'de baskın dinin müslümanlık olması ve benim adım dahil, 'merhaba' 'teşekkür' gibi basit sözcüklerin ödünç alınması başka bir dile geçerken etkiliyor. Başlarda ben de çok kızıyordum ama zamanla alıştım, tavsiyem boş verin ve izleyip eğlenmenize bakın 😊
@@KmlYldz Dilimize arapça kadar Fransızca sözcükte girmiş ama kimse bize fransızca mı konuşuyorsunuz demiyor (öyle desinler diye demiyorum) dinle alakalı bir durum olsaydı arnavut ya da boşnaklara da Arap demeleri gerekiyor çoğunlukla müslüman ama hiç diyeni duymadım bu bence tamamen genel kültürle alakalı bir durum Brezilyalılara İspanyolca mı konuşuyorsunuz demek gibi bir şey
I like it when he says that they are not "foreigners," but rather Germans who have grown up or were born in Germany. I feel the same way!
Ich mag es, wenn er sagt, dass das keine "Ausländer" sind, sondern dass es Deutsche sind, die in Deutschland aufgewachsen oder geboren worden sind. Sehe ich genauso!
I think german is hard to get when natives speak with unclear pronunciation, called nuscheln in german. We skip letters like e at end of words - habn instead of haben. Btw Google translation follow nuscheln too...
Aleyna 😍😋
Good stuff your videos
Super gut gemacht
I am Turkish, born and raised in Germany. I am 32 years old and still have difficulties with grammar. I don't know how German can be classified as medium difficulty when there's even a saying: „Deutsche Sprache, schwere Sprache.“ - 'German language, difficult language.'😅
German guy has heavy voice
İran lı kızın yüzü kaşık gibi, çok sevimli, hep bir kız kardeşim olsun isterdim
Gadis Iran ini terlihat seperti orang turkiye timur
No @@Kane_2001
@@Kane_2001Tidak, gadis Iran itu sama sekali tidak mirip dengan orang-orang dari Turki Timur.
@@texmexexpresssaya menonton drama Ertugrul, dan saya melihat para pelakon mirip gadis Iran ini, berambut hitam, bola mata warna hitam, kulit putih, hidung mancung, dan iras orang timur Tengah
@@Kane_2001Penampilan yang kamu gambarkan bukanlah penampilan Timur Tengah. Penampilan yang kamu gambarkan adalah penampilan Iran. Aktris-aktris Turki dalam seri Ertuğrul bahkan tidak setengah cantik dibandingkan wanita-wanita Iran.
I love iran❤
I actually can't believe how fast football players pick up the language. Imagine coming to a different country and learning the language from scratch... I could never
neymar never learned a language
@@hede1574not even Brazilian Portuguese?
yeah, i like this video.
Aleynanın makyajı ve tavırları korelilere benziyor uzun süre orda yaşadı snrm
1:45 The turkish guy speaks ghetto German. This means that he speaks with a strong Turkish accent and slurs the words. He uses sh instead of s. This is typical for foreign districts, where Turkish and Arabic are often spoken.
This guy is so cool
Remind me Alex jolig 😁
German Language is difficult, When I started to learn about for furniture has a female and male options, I just fed up 😅
The japanese football player spoke very good German.
Arkadaki lise Almanca ders kitabı kapağı ya Allah kahretmesin
That German guy reminds me translater of Jürgen Klopp
I say that always when I wake up: Good morning, I love you sausage.
The Iranian girl looks alot like the Danish girl from past video's
We need a video of people pronouncing of famous people from Germany and Austria
Diane Kruger(from Troy and National Treasure),Daniel Brühl(Rush),Til Schweiger(Inglorious basterds),Alexandra Maria Lars(Rush),Arnold Schwarzenegger and Christopher Waltz.
Michael Schumacher,Sebastian Vettel and Nico Rosberg;Formula 1 race car world champions
Football Toni Kroos,Bastian Schweinsteiger,Ilkay Gundogan,Mesut Özil(Love to see their name pronounciations in Turkish) and Joshua Kimmich
Basketball’s Dirk Norwitzski
The German guy was very attractive
AS a men in agrred
9:57 She is so ignorant. A person who was born and raised in Germany is German, both nationally and politically. Why was she so surprised to the contrary. That person has no connection with Korea what so over - he isn't Korean at all. Of course, he speaks German fluently. What else would he speak?
yo, Cha Du-Ri is OG German home boy. Also football is “the medium” how we integrate people into German society, Turkish Germans ended some nasty debates of the 1990s of Turkish people not being part of Germany by being the most German fans of the football World Cup 2006.
Cha do-ri ist in Deutschland aufgewachsen. Er ist der Sohn von Cha bum-kun, ein Koreanischer Fußballer, der in den 80gern ewig lange für Bayer Leverkusen gespielt hat.
Germans articles so hard to learn. As a Turkish person , in my opinion, learning articles the hardest think while you trying learn German language. All the language build up from them. But its really nice they have really richest gramer structure.
Ribery speaks German better than he speaks French. 😂
😂😂😂🎉
Ribery spend 12+ years in bavaria, understandable that he didn't learn german 🤣
@@VanezBane you're not making any sense.
@@puccaland in bavaria they tend to speak with a very heavy accent and the rest of germany don't understand them most of the time, it is basically considered as another language (quite a common joke and yet so true). so if you ask him to speak german and he starts to go off on bavarian with a french accent germans would not understand him, since he learned another language 😁
@@VanezBane OK. Relevance to what I said?
Just wondering, how come the German guy is calling it soccer? In all of Europe we call it football
It's called "Fußball" (Football) in German. They usually teach British English in German schools. Maybe he consumed too much American media, hence he has an inclination to use American English terms when he speaks in English.
us tv shows probably
Maybe he did it, because hes on a RUclips channel, directed at foreigners an that's why he calls is soccer, so that everyone understands what he means
@@texmexexpress Exactly that, in Duch we call it voetbal.
I do say it in both ways. I think it's because I've had American-English teachers and British-English teachers, maybe he did too.
most players in foreign germany speaking after 1-2 years fluently german ,cuz of intensiv lessons by the club
what's the name of the german guy?
Joshua
The first "German" speaker in the videos obviously spoke German like foreigners from the Near East (like Turks, Arabs). No native German or native from other German speaking countries has that thick accent.
How to know german guy's insta acc?
I can speak german
My fevert gaiss
Nepal friend plss 🇳🇵🙏
The voice of the german boy 🔥
Türkiye ✅️
Turkey 🦃❌️
The appearance of an Iranian woman was completely different from all women, for example, a Korean and a Japanese woman were the same, their faces were the same, and a Turkish woman was different from everyone, like an Iranian, but Kimia, who is Iranian, was much more beautiful in my opinion because we are from the same country. Are
Zibtarine
من همون کامنت ایرانیم که دنبالشی
😂😂
4:42 QUE expressões são essas ai manos?? ;-; dkmdnasnkad
Calhanoglu different level
I dont think he was SHOCKED. Why use this stupid term.
in German he would have said "schockiert" and you can use it in this context...it means "puzzled, perplexed"
This korean girl was hands down the worst german speaker and he says she is fluent 😂
because she didnt sound ghetto German like all the other speakers, so yeah she is better
@@masaru340 lol, I am from germany and you are for sure wrong
Heung Min Son shows that you do not have to be born in a place, in order to learn the language: Just talk to the natives, do you homework and use the language a lot. It helps to start out young though 😉
He came to Germany when he was pretty young and started to play in the football academy of Hamburg and lived there in a shared flat with mostly German kids. By that he learned it really well and I couldn't tell he is not German by his accent. Maybe only in very deep conversations with complex topics.
@@somersault4762als Hamburger, wenngleich Anhänger der (jetzt auch sportlich) Nummer Eins der Stadt, weiß ich das natürlich. Ich würde dennoch widersprechen, er spricht definitiv sehr gut, gerade die Aussprache und Betonung hat er drauf, aber strukturell merkt man ziemlich schnell, dass er kein Muttersprachler ist. Hier z.B.: m.ruclips.net/video/TFvQfSsNsfQ/видео.html
Dennoch steht meine Aussage oben: Heu Ming Song zeigt dass und wie es geht 😉
this video is great we want to see more of this group 🫶🏼
# Kırık Dostlukların Sırları#
Bölüm 1: Gizemli Mesaj
Bang Chan, Hyunjin, Han, Felix, Seungmin, Jeongin ve Lee Know, kasabanın en iyi arkadaşlarıydı. Ancak, bir gün, hayatları beklenmedik bir mesajla altüst oldu. Hepsi aynı anda garip bir mesaj aldılar. Mesajda, "Gece yarısı, eski fabrikada buluşun. Geçmişin sırları sizi bekliyor," yazıyordu.
Bang Chan, meraklı bir lider olarak, mesajın nereden geldiğini araştırmaya başladı. Ancak, numara iz bırakmamıştı, mesajın gizemi korunuyordu.
Seungmin: "Bu bir şaka olabilir mi?"
Hyunjin: "Belki de değil. Belki de gerçekten bir şeyler var."
Gece yarısı fabrikada buluşmaya karar verdiler. Fabrika, karanlık ve terkedilmişti. Kapıları açtıklarında, içeride eski makineler ve toz bulutlarıyla karşılaştılar. Ortada eski bir masa ve üzerinde tozlu bir defter vardı.
Felix, defteri açıp ilk sayfayı okudu: "Gerçekler acıdır ve bazen en yakınınızdakiler bile sırlara sahiptir."
Lee Know: "Bu ne demek olabilir?"
Işıklar birden söndü ve kapı kapanarak kilitlendi. İçeride mahsur kalmışlardı.
Hyunjin, sessizce itiraf etti: "Bu mesajı ben gönderdim."
Arkadaşları şaşkınlık içinde bakarken, Hyunjin devam etti: "Geçmişimde yaptığım bir hata yüzünden sizleri tehlikeye attım. Bu fabrika, o karanlık günlerden kalma."
Tam o sırada, fabrikaya silahlı adamlar girdi ve kapıyı kilitledi.
Han: "Ne yapacağız?"
Bang Chan hızla bir plan yaparak: "Birlikte çalışmalıyız. Hyunjin'in sırlarını kabul etmeliyiz ama bu durumdan nasıl kurtulacağımızı bulmalıyız."
Seungmin ve Jeongin, dikkat dağıtmak için ekipmanları kullanırken, diğerleri kaçış yolları aradı. Hyunjin ise pişmanlık ve korku içindeydi: "Özür dilerim. Ama birlikte bunun üstesinden gelebiliriz."
Tam kaçacakken, patlama sesi duyuldu ve bir duvar yıkılarak yardım sinyalleri geldi.
Bang Chan: "Gerçek tehlike daha yeni başlıyor."
Grup, fabrikadan çıkıp kurtarılmayı beklerken, kimin yardım ettiğini anlamaya çalışıyordu. Gölgeler arasında beliren kişi, onlara yardım ediyordu, ancak niyetleri hala belirsizdi.
Jeongin: "Sen kimsin?"
Gizemli kişi, yüzünü gizleyen kapüşonunu indirdi ve kendini tanıttı: "Ben Yeji. Sizi takip ediyordum çünkü Hyunjin'in sırları benim için de önemli."
Hyunjin şaşkınlıkla sordu: "Senin burada ne işin var? Seninle yollarımız ayrılmıştı."
Yeji: "Size yardım etmeye geldim. Ama bunun karşılığında bazı cevaplara ihtiyacım var."
Bang Chan, güvenli bir yer aramaya karar verdi: "Örgütten kurtulmamıza yardım edebileceğini söylüyorsan, peşimizdeki adamlar hakkında ne biliyorsun?"
Yeji, örgütün peşinde olduklarını ve Hyunjin'in ellerindeki belgeler yüzünden tehlikede olduklarını açıkladı.
Felix: "Hyunjin, ne tür belgeler?"
Hyunjin, titreyen bir sesle: "Örgüt liderinin suçlarını kanıtlayanlar. Ama bunlar gizli bir yerde."
Grup, belgeleri bulmak ve tehlikeden kurtulmak için harekete geçti. Ancak, aralarındaki güven giderek zayıflıyordu. Geçmişin gölgeleri, karanlık sırlarla birleşerek ortaya çıkıyordu.
---
2. BÖLÜM İÇİN ABONE OLUR MUSUN?
KANALIMI BÜYÜTMEK ISTİYORUM YARDIMCI OLUR MUSUNUZ?❤❤❤
使われてる動画が全部ドイツ語だからよく分からんかった😢
Well, that was kind of the point here, right? 😅
The German guy was the "main character" on this video, so the videos showed were made to him to understand.
Ribéry barely speaks French as a native so cut him some slack 😂
🇹🇷
Hakan doesn’t count he was born and raised in Germany it makes no sense to put him in this video, probably speaks better German than Turkish
İki dili de iyi konuşuyor
@@user-jr4ue9xw9k I don’t understand mate 🇬🇧🇦🇺🦘🦘