Superhero Rewind: Superman 3 Review

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 фев 2025

Комментарии • 174

  • @TheReviewSpot
    @TheReviewSpot 14 лет назад +5

    The only thing that saves this movie for me is the Battle between Superman and Clark Kent, personally one of the greatest comic book movie moments of all time especially when Clark says to Superman "you know I can give it just as good as I can take it" and Superman responds with "well bring it on" that to me still gives me chills to watch, Richard Pryor works well in the movie but everything else just falls apart, I liked the Smallville story but it was badly executed.

    • @clarenceandgennymcneil251
      @clarenceandgennymcneil251 Год назад

      12 years too late but I agree. Just saw the movie and the only scenes I enjoyed are the smallville scenes and the clark battle

  • @TaliaIGhul
    @TaliaIGhul 13 лет назад +1

    Much like Highlander: The Source is considered a bad fevered daydream of Duncan MacLoed, this and Superman IV is a bad fevered daydream of Kal-El.

  • @zoomerjack5435
    @zoomerjack5435 9 лет назад +9

    Ah, Superman III, the precursor to Batman Forever and Spider-Man 3, the third installments to the Batman and Spider-Man franchises that instead of going really dark, they went for comedy. Superman III was the first one of these superhero threequels to do this.

  • @TheAuthorDanLee
    @TheAuthorDanLee 13 лет назад +1

    If I had to choose between Superman III and Batman Forever, I'd choose Batman Forever because they focused more on themes of revenge and power. Superman III doesn't concentrate on themes. Does it have a message? No. Batman Forever may have been silly at some points but at least it focused on themes and I'm not sure whether there was a message but if there was one I'd say it was "Revenge isn't the answer". Superman III's message? There wasn't one.

  • @patrickbarnes9462
    @patrickbarnes9462 11 лет назад +5

    "Terrible--not especially interesting, but terrible." Classic.
    Thank you for a great review!

  • @wherewhenwhat
    @wherewhenwhat 13 лет назад

    @Geekvolution I forget, what was Lois's role or purpose in this film? was she just in the background ?

  • @Geekvolution
    @Geekvolution  13 лет назад +1

    @CubbieBear1980 It is Lana Lang. She's suposed to be Clark's high school sweetheart, a relationship that never quite worked out but they still have enormous affection for each other, and the dynamic that sometimes makes it interesting is that she's one of the only people who knows Clark is Superman. Even knowing that, it's still a relationship that didn't pan out. Unlike Lois, Clark and Superman being the same person doesn't seem to factor so much into the equation.
    -CL

  • @LordMalice6d9
    @LordMalice6d9 11 лет назад +3

    I do not understand why the studio simply didn't go with the original idea of having Brainiac as the villain of Superman 3 instead a super computer and an evil Superman.

  • @jeremykrause4665
    @jeremykrause4665 5 лет назад

    My grandpa isn’t doing well right now but listening to your awesome analysis always makes me happy. :)

  • @tonystark106422
    @tonystark106422 14 лет назад

    @Geekvolution Apparently, the orignal script (at some point) the film was supposed to include Brainiac (the Real Brainiac, not Gus' computer), Supergirl, and Mr. Mxyzptlk. Thoughts?

  • @JoeChillton
    @JoeChillton 13 лет назад

    @Geekvolution Any chance of a Ghost Rider or Incredible Hulk one soon??

  • @Angyali
    @Angyali 13 лет назад

    @Geekvolution
    Which one is your 100. review?

  • @OperatorOscillation
    @OperatorOscillation 12 лет назад +1

    technically the computer could make kryptonite through nuclear reaction, assuming that kryptonight is made out of atoms and assuming that the computer has the resources to make a reaction (which it would have to if it can make any other element on demand in the first place.

  • @Mrcool210
    @Mrcool210 11 лет назад

    the kyrptonite ingridient is not found on earth, plus how would they know what the element is? superman never says what it is

  • @opa-age
    @opa-age 11 лет назад +1

    Lana Lang was frickin hot in this movie.

  • @faulknerclan4
    @faulknerclan4 12 лет назад

    waht is the opaning song

  • @LizzyVonBloom
    @LizzyVonBloom 11 лет назад +10

    Wow, Annet O'Toole went from being Clark's high school crush to being Clark's mom!!!

    • @7833ana
      @7833ana 10 лет назад +3

      I know right? I actually kinda found her very attractive in Smallville.

  • @Batman8657
    @Batman8657 14 лет назад +1

    Robert Vaughn was the Samuel L. Jackson of the 60s, 70s and early 80s. He was in EVERYTHING.

  • @noway2009
    @noway2009 11 лет назад +3

    I enjoyed Superman III more than Superman Returns to be quite honest with you.

    • @mws755
      @mws755 4 года назад +1

      I enjoyed Superman 3 more than any Superman movie

    • @noway2009
      @noway2009 4 года назад

      @@mws755 it's pretty much a fun film to watch

  • @dvid22
    @dvid22 14 лет назад

    so the real smallville that you know does not have a train station and or airport? just asking.

  • @LeeHutchingsdrumsUK
    @LeeHutchingsdrumsUK 14 лет назад +1

    I've always thought it interesting that (I think at least) Superman's build in this film is probably closet to the comics or is that just me? Of course Christopher Reeve had put on weight since Superman 1 but I do think when he bulked up for 3 it made his build appear closer to the comics than previously seen.

  • @Angyali
    @Angyali 14 лет назад

    Is there a Superman 4 review?

  • @tthomaselli2
    @tthomaselli2 11 лет назад +1

    I thought the same thing, myself, many years ago... I was talking about it with a few of my friends during my 6th grade year of middle-school & "If only..." was the only thing I could say about it, at the time & I still say that, to this day about it.

  • @Swartlandboys99
    @Swartlandboys99 11 лет назад +2

    Think how good that would have been for a followup to S2. It would have saved the franchise and we may have seen some more films in the 80's and early 90's.

  • @KnightofDuroch
    @KnightofDuroch 14 лет назад

    IIRC, Lois never printed anything about kryptonite. She printed his inability to see through lead allright, but Superman's weakness to the green was something that Lex figured out through plot convenience.

  • @harrisonward6574
    @harrisonward6574 12 лет назад

    first Annette O'Toole is Lana Lang and then she played Miss Kent in Smallville and then you even have Christopher Reeve make a cameo as a sort of mentor to clark again in Smallville

  • @Bobsheaux
    @Bobsheaux 11 лет назад +1

    Superman going nuts... THAT is a good excuse to pit Batman against him. All Bats has to do is distract him long enough for whatever's playing with his brain to wear off. Nowadays, writers seem convinced that just because they disagree with each other on some points, that means they ALWAYS have to be at each others' throats. Ugh...

  • @osufan3id
    @osufan3id 13 лет назад +1

    This movie always felt like a Richard Pryor movie with some Superman thrown in.

  • @LATVERIAN1
    @LATVERIAN1 5 лет назад

    Evil Superman should have gone the same route as General Zod, and go
    about taking over the world. That would have been interesting. Furthermore,
    classic Superman villains such as Metallo, Parasite, Toyman, and (*yes*) Lex
    Luthor should have been brought forth, teaming up to thwart evil Superman's
    plans of world domination. After all, it's the villains'' world too. Oh, but those
    glorious Reeve/ Donner/ Williams days are sadly long past. Perhaps on a parallel
    earth? Oh, but that's yet another Superman tale to be told.. ;)
    p.s. Excellent & intelligent review, Captain Logan. I truly enjoyed it. Thank you.

  • @sproy1
    @sproy1 12 лет назад +1

    A MUCH more entertaining instance of "Evil Superman" comes in Superman: The Animated Series. The episode is "Brave New Metropolis" and centers around Superman going psycho after botching a Lois rescue.

  • @baronvg
    @baronvg 2 года назад

    It’s funny, as a kid, I knew it wasn’t as good as the first two but couldn’t think of why. Then as I’ve gotten older, whatever questions I had about this movie have been brushed to the side and now I only have nostalgia for it. But this review has brought up those questions and explained them. I still don’t think I could ever hate this movie (like I’ll always hate IV) but now I wonder if this ovoid could ever be remade and have those issues fixed.

  • @JinChohan
    @JinChohan 11 лет назад

    when he makes the kryptonite that missing ingredient is what makes superman bad and not weak. That's how iv always understood it

  • @Geekvolution
    @Geekvolution  13 лет назад

    @juken16 Will do! Supergirl will probably happen this year or early next year.
    -CL

  • @armortron
    @armortron 13 лет назад

    Did Superman destroy the Fortress of Solitude at the end of this movie?

  • @Robizoid
    @Robizoid 11 лет назад +1

    Not a fan of love triagles, huh? Well, I wrote a whole poem about how this could work. I like Lana Lang, she's a far more interesting character than Lois. I wish they could have done more with her, maybe even have her in Superman IV.

  • @arp17011
    @arp17011 11 лет назад

    Actually, there's a line that Robert Vaughn says that they found the right kryptonite ingredient and programmed it into the computer.

  • @Asmah2012
    @Asmah2012 11 лет назад +1

    I know a LOT of people will disagree with men, and I can see why people HATE this, but I LIKED Superman 3.

  • @juken16
    @juken16 13 лет назад

    please do a steel and supergirl review

  • @1424nathan
    @1424nathan 14 лет назад

    I find it kind of neat that Lana Lang is the same person that plays Martha Kent in the tv series Smallville. Too bad the two never had a scene together in Smallville while Reeve was still alive. :(

  • @Vader47000
    @Vader47000 13 лет назад

    I don't think it's making Kryptonite, but scanning Superman to find a type of radiation that can harm him and then emitting just the energy that Kryptonite would normally put out. So somehow it can do at least that

  • @CubanPete1990
    @CubanPete1990 5 лет назад

    You know what they should add The Super Villain name Brainiac played by Sam Neill in Superman 3 (1983) not just Richard Pryor!

  • @thegodmachine
    @thegodmachine 13 лет назад

    Personally, my biggest complaint was the lack of continuity as far as romance was allowed in Superman's life. In Superman II, didn't Clark have to give up his powers to be with Lois? But that's not an issue where Lana's concerned?

  • @Mrcool210
    @Mrcool210 13 лет назад

    i would call the fight between superman and clark an inner struggle but i dont think the filmmakers were smart enough to think of that

  • @navylaks2
    @navylaks2 12 лет назад

    I remember that the woman being turned into a robot just freaked me out, that's were the film turned from kid friendly to HR Gieger horror

  • @TheRealNahre
    @TheRealNahre 12 лет назад

    The best thing about this movie is that a plot point from it was used as a plot point in Office Space :D

  • @rxtsec1
    @rxtsec1 4 года назад

    Everything you said makes sense but the battle in the junkyard scene is worth the price alone

  • @jorgezarco9269
    @jorgezarco9269 2 года назад

    Clark Kent vs. Superman is one of the best scenes in the movie. Sam Raimi tried something similar in Spider-Man 3(2007).

  • @3dartistguy
    @3dartistguy 9 лет назад

    The reason why Gus's computer was able to create a kryptonite radiation because Gus had used Ross's computers to determine the correct elements of kryptonite. Even Ross's ugly sister proclaimed that 'this time they got it right". when the computer created a kryptonite beam. No doubt they anticipated Superman opposing them at some future point.

  • @JoeChillton
    @JoeChillton 12 лет назад

    There's some Black K, that splits the person into one good, one bad (from the show Smallville), and another version of Black K in All Star Superman makes him talk like Bizarro andact like one too.

  • @jokertdk
    @jokertdk 14 лет назад

    I agree with the Captain for the most part. The film isn't anything to write home about, and outside of the Clark vs. Bad Supes fight, and some other key scenes, the film as a whole is anything but memorable. Though I will saw the Smallville scenes do have a certain charm about them.

  • @CubanPete1990
    @CubanPete1990 8 лет назад

    Man they should add Brainiac in this movie but the Brainiac character will be played by Michael Keaton who did Batman (1989) but he Sholud played Brainiac in Superman 3 (1983) with Christopher reeve!

  • @Darknightdetective52
    @Darknightdetective52 12 лет назад

    I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure solomon grundy is a batman villian

  • @Geekvolution
    @Geekvolution  13 лет назад +1

    @thesyfychannel15 Great idea to use Morgan Edge, really any incarnation of him could be effective. I actually like the mob boss version from Smallville, but part of that was an excellent actor (at least, before he got a face-change).
    -CL

  • @ps3man1998
    @ps3man1998 12 лет назад

    I actually want to see condiment king in the next batman, only to see how hilarious it will be. So batman is like "HOCKEY PADDDS" and the the condiment king then says "Lets cut the mustard" and shoots alfred in the face with some dejon mustard, and he dies from being allergic to the substance. Batman then finally breaks his one rule, but not on the joker (his arch-nemesis and one of the few villains that fans want batman to kill, simply for an interesting outlook on the universe. In fact, an els

  • @Maximara
    @Maximara 11 лет назад

    Minor point. In the Animated Series Brainiac leaves Krypton to its fate because there is not enough time to save it. Even the Superman: Unbound (2013) Brainiac didn't actively destroy Krypton but let nature take is course.

  • @tommyrichman7220
    @tommyrichman7220 12 лет назад

    Lex Luthor, Doomsday, Brainiac, Parasite, Prankster, Toyman, Ultraman, Bizzaro, Metallo, Atlas, Atomic Skull, Morgan Edge, Mister Mxyzptlk, Solomon Grundy annndddd you were saying?

  • @ANTSEMUT1
    @ANTSEMUT1 12 лет назад

    Darkseid Imperiex ,granny goodness mongul, lobo when he feels like been bad livewire etc etc

  • @Geekvolution
    @Geekvolution  13 лет назад

    @Geekvolution And yes, the LL thing seems goofy, but remember, most of this stuff was dreamed up in the 40s and 50s, when those kinds of conveniences were pretty commonplace. You want contrived? Throw Lex Luthor in there too! And how about all those stories where Lois and Lex nearly get married!
    -CL

  • @joetwist
    @joetwist 13 лет назад +1

    I agree with you for the most part, but I can't help thinking you're taking a SUPERHERO movie a little too seriously. What I like about the Superman movies is that they don't take themselves seriously, which makes them so lovable. But with that said, I agree that Lester was TERRIBLE, and clearly didn't take Superman seriously enough.
    Also I'm biased - This was the first movie I ever watched, as in, I was 2 years old and it's the first movie I ever remember watching and I loved it but now know

  • @nightowl685
    @nightowl685 14 лет назад

    i look forward to reading your inevitable review of Superman 4:)

  • @DwRockett
    @DwRockett 12 лет назад +1

    You review is perfect at describing how awful this movie is. Great Review Cap

  • @Ruvik2025
    @Ruvik2025 3 года назад

    the Gus computer should of been in the middle or close to beginning of the movie and would of been a great opportunity to create Cyborg Superman instead of the woman and red kryptonite would of made more sense in the computer and he is transformed and stripped of his good side but through the movie, he fights himself but more in mind battle where he returns and destroys computer freeing Superman from the Cyborg enhancements and turned back to good.

  • @SuperLaney81
    @SuperLaney81 11 лет назад

    I agree! Read my comment --- I always assumed Guss went back and took the job...

  • @mr.sand7899
    @mr.sand7899 11 лет назад

    I can't think of more adjectives Mrs. Teacher Lady

  • @prphd555
    @prphd555 14 лет назад

    I still like the movie for bad reasons. I still think Smallville felt like Superman's home. The fight scenes were interesting and the rescue scene in the beginning of the movie is the best one ever.
    Wish Richard Pryor was funnier as I was a fan of him. Batman Forever style of him would've been satisfying.

  • @ntdonat
    @ntdonat 10 лет назад +1

    what? brainiac destroys krypton? i thought in the that animatedserries, brainiac, who realized that krypton was going to be destroyed, decided to hide that fact in order to save himself?
    you had no idea superman had no imagination? why did he never expose lex for his crimes? i know, lex runs metrapolis and a whole lot more, but its not like the world will stop if he gets punished for his actions for once.

  • @smallclone
    @smallclone 12 лет назад

    You do know this is a movie about a man that can fly and somehow fights an evil version on himself? Its kinda like ur trying to make sense out of something thats already insane.

  • @Geekvolution
    @Geekvolution  13 лет назад

    @Kennedy369 Thank you!
    -CL

  • @zombiefan011
    @zombiefan011 12 лет назад

    You ever notice how in these movies Superman never punches anybody?

  • @mandelharvey3429
    @mandelharvey3429 10 лет назад

    Richard Pryor was one of the greatest entertainers of all time missused horribly here. He would have made an interesting peter parker. Today DL Hugly's public persona wisecrack's like Richard Pryor writing for Peter Parker. May make sense to bring a comedian in to rewrite the lines to flow comedically within a real story.

  • @arp17011
    @arp17011 11 лет назад

    This isn't a movie where you can be logical. But look at it this way: Just because Krypton is an alien planet doesn't mean we don't share the same elements. The computer says 'unknown', maybe someone forgot to program all the elements into it. The real question is how do they know they got it right?

  • @jackthegreek6092
    @jackthegreek6092 7 лет назад

    How did Lois get that sunburn, Jesus.

  • @josiahcmiller
    @josiahcmiller 14 лет назад

    i never knew annette o' toole was in this! always saw her in smallville. lol

  • @Elementa2006
    @Elementa2006 13 лет назад

    To be honest I found Robert Vaugn's character Webster in the film to be a better Lex Luthor than the film series actual Lex Luthor(s) Gene Hackman and Kevin Spacey.

  • @Celerott
    @Celerott 11 лет назад

    Hey Captain Logan, imagine if Superman 3 had been done by Donner.

  • @sproy1
    @sproy1 13 лет назад

    Why is it your channel is called Geekvolution, but you always call yourself "Captain Logain?"

  • @MrAwesomebassplayer
    @MrAwesomebassplayer 12 лет назад

    Richard Pryor was the jar jar binks of superman movies

  • @santos8468
    @santos8468 11 лет назад

    He straightens the Leaning Tower of Pisa? So his idea of vandalism is to fix something. Yeah, that makes sense.

  • @TheHawkdaddy
    @TheHawkdaddy 13 лет назад

    The Condiment King is dastardly, don't underestimate him.

  • @horaciosi
    @horaciosi 12 лет назад

    Originaly Brainiac, Supergirl and Mxyzptlk were gonna appear in the movie, but the studio didn't like that idea......let me repeat that: It wasn't for budget problems, it wasn't for copyright issues, it was because the studio didn't like using charachers from the comic book and instead they used....this guys. I think i speak for everyone when i say this: /watch?v=FbYg7LNhqTw

  • @JoeChillton
    @JoeChillton 12 лет назад

    I really hope BrainIAC gets used in Man of Steel 2, yes he's that awesome and so much of a good villian.

    • @royprincevideos
      @royprincevideos 4 года назад

      Brainiac is now in Superman 3. My remake.
      ruclips.net/video/im1gYxUtlqA/видео.html

  • @popmonika
    @popmonika 12 лет назад

    err he punched Clark Kent, or a version of him in this one. As well as Nuclear Man in IV.
    Ok, not great films, but he does punch people sometimes.
    Unless of course you meant it as a praise. Cos Superman is so awesome he doesn´t need to punch anyone. One look will do. lol.

  • @CaminoAir
    @CaminoAir 13 лет назад

    Great review and analysis of why this film doesn't work. I'll add a couple of points. The scriptwriters (neither Puzo nor Mankeweitz(?) were involved. The film feels very calculated, the exact opposite in spirit to Donner. The missile attack effects at the end feel cheap and a cheat when they change to video game graphics. Pryor is taken out of his normal context and left without any way to be actually funny or relevent. There is no dramatic or emotional connection with I & II.

  • @mws755
    @mws755 4 года назад

    You can't have a Superman who is 100 % evil and killing people with an evil plot. Think about it

  • @handsomedevil98
    @handsomedevil98 13 лет назад

    @BRm2008 It was actually going to be Brainiac but that idea was thrown out the window!! they really spoilt it!! it would have been a brill trilogy!!

  • @BobTheHun64
    @BobTheHun64 12 лет назад

    This movie was weird, I remember the skiing down a building scene and the toy penguin scene.

  • @BrontoSmilodon1
    @BrontoSmilodon1 12 лет назад

    can't wait for steel then

  • @Dutch3k5
    @Dutch3k5 11 лет назад

    No mention of the the other lady henchman that turned into that creepy robot thing at the end. That was a horribly bad classic scene

  • @eddycoulson6133
    @eddycoulson6133 10 лет назад

    As a kid I loved this movie and so do my kids. Superman Movies is the best but this movie gets a hard rap

  • @Elsuperhombre42
    @Elsuperhombre42 13 лет назад

    eh, i still enjoy it more that supes 4 & it about ties with returns. but as a kid watching this movie i always thought it was a halfassed movie version of brainiac & bizzaro.

  • @ps3man1998
    @ps3man1998 12 лет назад

    Continued- Elseworld's story would be interesting if batman killed joker) It turns out he kills the Condiment King. The end.

  • @matthewhendron2725
    @matthewhendron2725 10 лет назад

    What were these guys thinking with the villain they went from General Zod to a lame tycoon that is not in the comics I mean come on superman has tones of other great villains such as metallo and brainiac and many others WHAT THE HELL WERE THEY THINKING!!!!

  • @samh09
    @samh09 13 лет назад

    Captain Logan, you should google Illya Salkinds 8 page treatment for Superman 3. The story idea he had was horrible on so many levels. That's what tonystark106422 is talking about. Thank God! Warner Bros had the smarts not say "NO!" to it.

  • @Swartlandboys99
    @Swartlandboys99 11 лет назад

    Villians should have obviously been Brainiac and Bizaro. Hahah Richard Pryor could have played a humorous Brainiac or clumsy henchmen

  • @tonystark106422
    @tonystark106422 14 лет назад +1

    Love this series.

  • @Dutch3k5
    @Dutch3k5 11 лет назад

    And I could give a rats ass about an explanation for Clark leaving supes body. That sequence was worth the price of admission.

  • @daftbottv
    @daftbottv 14 лет назад

    THERE'S THAT SPOILER WARNING! Nice guys... good job...

  • @theRealPlaidRabbit
    @theRealPlaidRabbit 14 лет назад

    Aah, Richard Pryor. An actor whose very presence is an announcement: "THIS IS THE 80's". Even when it's off by a year or two.
    I thought "what? An evil corporate tycoon other than Lex Luthor?". I suppose that's not so crazy, but it still seems wrong.
    Part of the trouble with Smallville is that Hollywood has *never* understood rural America. Never. Small towns, agricultural communities, extended families... these are always sloppily cardboard-ized in movies, sadly.

  • @ryanpopielarski569
    @ryanpopielarski569 11 лет назад

    You forgot to say General Zod.

  • @JoeChillton
    @JoeChillton 13 лет назад

    11:26, so true.