No, they keep neighborhoods clean and safe. Just because he was a problem, that’s his problem. And what a laugh, criminalized? Lol HOA’s can’t and never will. If a board member does wrong, embezzles money, that’s the only person who would be a criminal. I live in a HOA community for over twenty years and never had one issue with any neighbors and I would never get into any neighbors face or property. If a neighbor isn’t happy with the people next door or across the street, it’s their business to report it to the people working at our community’s HOA’s main office. It cracks me up when people see one person or a couple being all crazy in one video, I see comments like yours like it’s going to solve world problems. Lol 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
@@JMarieCAlove HOA's don't keep neighborhoods clean and safe. What a crock of ____. All they do is pester people with tons of stupid rules and turn neighborhoods into fascist hellholes. Not only should they be criminalized, but the people who start them should be prosecuted under the 14th amendment and thrown in prison.
@@JMarieCAlove HOAs do not keep neighborhoods clean and safe. That's a crock. What they actually do is pester the neighborhood with tons of stupid rules. Not only should they be criminalized, but the people who start them should be prosecuted under the 14th amendment and thrown in prison.
She looks like the type of karen that goes thru your trash when you are at work..."Hey neighbor, I was going thru your trash the other day and noticed you put a piece of paper in your glass container..." fxxx off hoa Karen. I hrew up in am hoa and all the old ladies hated when kids would go outside and play or go into the pool area. Karen's tried to ruin our childhood and ive always hated them since then. Down with hoas.
Oh no, Florida is the land of free… funny how people believe so much bs about a state where old fuckers with too much time on their hands, do all they can to harass people minding their own business!
It is a blessing to live in a country where everything is not owned by the state. You have no freedom there. You cannot own private land that gives you the ability to restrict access to your property by people who insult you and abuse the privilege to come onto your property.
@@jackfanning7952 True. And it's a blessing to live in a country where everything is not owned privately, especially by an HOA. So glad my local parks and open space protects stuff like this.
I saw that and experienced it during the China flu scamdemic. Everyone was either a doctor or a security guard telling you to wear a mask and where to stand. Cops in my state were actually going through restaurants to make sure they were in compliance!
That may not be totally correct. In Colorado, the landowner owns the bottom of the river. You can float through someone's property but not get out and wade. I have no idea where this guy is fishing.
High water mark is public easement in Idaho if its "naviable" You cant tresspass over private land to get to it but if you enter at a public road you are good@@ML-ks2lj
the one river in Virginia comes under the old king George grant.the folks their owns the water and the land under the water.wrong but that's the way it is for those "ELITE" folks.
The fact that he saw you there with your child, minding your business, being a good dad and he STILL felt the need to ruin your days is pathetic. That old man is just straight up not a good person.
As a retired Forest Service officer you are correct, any navigable waterway can be used by the public below the high water mark and can not be posted below that, even if your land surrounds a river or stream. That is a federal law in every single state , weather someone likes it or not. I've run into the same thing before while looking for arrowheads along stream and lake banks. I do understand in a way why people don't like it ,, but let's face it some people are just pigs and leave mess's everywhere , but that issue can be resolved easily by law enforcement and the fines covering that infraction are much more serious than any trespassing charge, which in this case wouldn't apply anyhow. Now if someone was leaving trash and fire pits all along the bank , that's an entirely different story , then they can or could be charged with polluting a waterway or fishery , which can be a pretty hefty fine . I've written up more than one person myself for doing that in my 16+ years of service , and it's for a very good reason . If your the kinda person that does that , you just don't realize the impact those things can make on the health of a fishery or on the environment itself . Sadly there's dummy's and Kens and Karen's everywhere that don't know any better.
@@user-oq8zy3zg5u Generally speaking , if you can go down a river or stream , even on a inner tube or kayak , it's considered to be a navigable waterway by law. Hope that helps answer your question .
That is not the law in Ohio. The landowner owned the land below the water. It is legal to float, but the second you get out of your boat you are trespassing if you do not have permission
@@wildsau1965 What would happen would be that someone like myself or any other LEO would respond. below is only a small part of your states regulations and if you wish to jump down the rabbit hole further. There are many other statutes pertaining to this issue , but I'll waste no more time with you as you seem to know it all already ,,,I have better things to do and bigger fish to fry, pun intended. Chapter 14 Article 22A ss14-159.9 And that's not even counting all the Federal laws & CFR's pertaining to this .
Ive seen worse Karen"s. But he still needs to make sure he knows the law before confronting someone like this. How I deal with these types is I simply say, "call the game warden, if he tells me to leave then I will leave.. Until then, I do not want to discuss it any further. We can talk about the weather, but not about if I can fish here or not".
As someone that has lived in the boonies my whole life, the concept of a homeowners association dictating how your home can look and what you can have in your yard and harrassing people fishing on a public river just boggles my mind. Hope you and your daughter had fun anyways. Take care.
bingo. sounds like a white person in idaho. some of the most racist people and retarded people ive ever met. Its the illegals thats our nations problem. proceed to hire a gardner housekeeper etc that are all illegal. think their kids are too good to work dairies.... all illegals. americans need to stop being pussies and we will be alright
Are you stupid enough to assume you are not trepassing when someone tells you you are on private property? Take your chances. Roll the dice and see how that works out for you.
You read my mind! But I’ve noticed that some people have boundary issues. Like serious boundary issues. It’s an instinct that’s probably been reinforced too often.
If someone breaks their ankle while burglarizing your house they can sue you. Same principle applies here- plus the trash people leave behind is dangerous to wildlife and hurts the looks and environment. Boatless bank trash need to police themselves better.
@@cuivre2004get happier buddy. I'm sure you leave a paper trail without fishing. Why do you do about what you complain about? You just whine about "boat less bank trash" littering but you know you can't stop it so if it bothers you that much, do you go do park clean ups or pick up trash you see? If not then stfu unless you're willing to be the difference. My fishing pack has 2 30 gallon trash bags in it. I don't complain about the trash I just pick it up. Once you realize you cant control other people your life will be much better. And you'd be surprised on just being the guy to show up with his gear and before he leaves he takes a half hour to clean up the area, the domino effect that has. So nut up or shut up cake boy
Years ago, Californians started buying up riverside properties all up the Elk River, here in Oregon. In places where local people had for 100 years walked a short ways off the public road and down a bank to go fishing, even if they were hundreds of yards from the landowner's houses, they put up high chain link fences to block the access and put up no trespassing signs. Guess they didn't realize that rural Oregon isn't downtown LA or Oakland, and you don't need to lock everything up like Fort Knox with barbwire and machinegun nests. Not very neighborly.
I'd tell him to contact the DNR and send them out if I need to move. He has no jurisdiction nor ability to make you move. He does have the ability to be charged with harassing someone fishing.
Ever notice how fish seem to congregate in waterways that run through land owned by entitled assholes? Been thru this same scenario too many times to count. Glad you stood your ground man.
Yeah I know. I live in a rural area and when someone comes along and buys 5 acres they act like they own the whole county. Walking, hunting, riding ATVs and putting up hunting stands on everyone else's land.
If you are below the regular high-water line and you did not trespass to get there, you are 100% allowed to fish. The road's a stones throw away. Is their front porch the reeds or the bank? No. I guarantee the water line goes up at least a couple feet at least once a year, if not more. No one would ever build their house there. no matter who owns the property, that area is 100% legal to fish.
So many rich land grabbers feel that they are entitled to control everything in the surrounding areas of their property. We had an entitled a** by the farm next to my childhood home. One day I was out hunting our property when I was approached by a man saying that I was on private property and if I didn't leave I would be charged with trespassing. I responded by saying "That works for me"! I then introduced myself and laughed when he started sputtering, him and hahing realizing I was the kid of the owners. The entitled ass didn't feel so entitled all of a sudden!😂😂
You, sir have a lot more patience than I do. A wise old man once told me “Do you know what gets people killed? Other people’s business. So you best just mind yours.”
Problem is... the infestation of Social Media and being in everyone's business has created people like these who feel they're entitled to stick their nose in yours at every turn. It's absolutely sickening.
Former friend bought some land here in Montana next to a river. The MT Supreme Court ruled that people could walk along a river to the high-water mark and they can operate boats up and down rivers too. He threw a fit. "Nobody should be able to step one inch on his land, water mark or no. And no one should be allowed to run a boat over his part of the river." I didn't argue, I knew it would be pointless. I just wondered how anyone could get that selfish.
Here in Texas it's actually a jailable offense to interfere with or harass a hunter/angler. We also have water rights. Unless your property is completely surrounding the body of water there is like a 5 foot public easement to the navigable water. I ran into someone like this recently at a community lake. Now that I know the law, I'm just going to tell him to leave me alone or I'm calling TPWD out to cite him. I suggest looking into your states laws regarding this. If it's illegal where you are, then just call the wardens out to deal with this guy next time.
The old man hasn't lived there his whole life. If he did, and that's a big if. He would know millions of people fish all parts of the snake. And he can only stock a lake that is private if he pays for the fish himself. I never heard in Idaho where the fish and game just up and stocked private property ponds. Unless you payed for them to do it. He's from California no doubt.
@@penguin12902 I totally agree with you, I was just saying to call the police to so everyone gets an education from the gamewarden and the guy harassing the fishermen gets to feel like a dip shit in front of the cop and gamewarden and the fishermen.
Properly placed posted signs along the road side of his property could stop you by trespassing you if you cross his property to get to the highwater line. Unless there is a right-of-way road/path for access to the water. But you could still enter the legal area from up or downstream. It's a shame people have to make such wholesome activities a pain in the neck.
Did you get that guys name and contact information? Fish and Game will have plenty to say about this. Would you please keep us updated on this situation? Thx.
Boise Idaho resident here. Just an FYI from fisherman to fisherman, if there is a river that flows through someone's property, they cannot deny you access to said body of water. They are required by law to have public access through their property to the river in question and the banks on either side of the river are still considered public property even if they "bought" the land directly adjacent. It's not even a waterline thing. Even when the water is at its highest, you are still allowed to access the bank and nobody can tell you otherwise as nobody can own any flowing body of water in Idaho. But it seems like you know this already lol this is more for anyone else in the chat who may or may not know the law. ❤
Ignorance is bliss. A freakin' HOA coming to a waterway and declaring HOA rules. Laughable ...just simply stupid and laughable. I bet he likes telling his neighbors their flowers are the wrong color for the HOA rules .....
If you are 100% confident you are in a legal spot, the answer is always "Let's get the game warden out here, and if I am correct, I will be asking to press charges under the state's harassment clause." Let them put their money where their mouth is.
If it’s “waters of the US”, which this is, the public can use the water and the property owner can’t regulate that. However, the property owner can regulate “access” to it if the public trespasses on private property to gain access to the water. This is why it is legal for boats and kayaks to gain access to this specific spot via upstream but not legal for people to bank fish after trespassing across private property.
Unless there is an existing public access. Even if the property Owner doesn’t want it,if it is established not Much the “new” Property owner Can do about it.
if that clown had any authority he would not be there flapping his gums, he would have called the law, you just look at some fool like that and say " if you can trespass me do it, otherwise shut up and go away " .. there are so many people who think they own things they simply live near
How you access the river is definitely important. If you crossed his property to get to the high water mark then you are in the wrong. If you waded the bank to get there then I’d say you’re good.
Reminds me of the time I was at my local sheriffs office on a Saturday morning, and the people in front of me were trying to file a report on a father and son were fishing from a public area into a public access lake behind their house.
These days My response to Karens that keep going after they can't bully me is " well if you honestly believe that your right, call the police. In fact let me call them for you!" They generally run when I actually do call them, and I do!
When you come across people like this no matter what you say they think they right. You can pull up the law on Google but even then most won't admit they're wrong or they simply can't comprehend it. All you ever need to tell them is I'm not leaving until the game warden says I'm breaking the law.
F him .I can't speak to Idaho laws but I know in many other places if you access the water from a public easement and are standing below the high water mark they can't say shi$t. If you are on navigatabl water they are also s o l . Good on you for being calm and cool.
Quit blaming “Californians”…if they can afford to buy that land,then they deserve to own it.Money talks,and bullshit walks.Save your money,buy your own land,and quit crying.
@@redman840oh, so you haven’t lived in an area where the locusts came up and bought everything, pricing all the locals out of their own towns. Or you’re just one of the locusts. There’s a reason why everyone in the entire country hate to see California or New York plates. Every single person hates them for a very good reason. So nah, you can go screw yourself cock sucker.
its a strange world indeed. Because Private land may be owned but in many cases, the water is owned by U.S. government according to LAW. So the only way a person can stop you is by taking the land right away from you. This is always true of course but it's mostly what America's law is.
I don't argue with people on this. I have had many interactions with these types of nosey Karens and Darens and I just keep it simple. "If you think I am doing something illegal, feel free to call the authorities. Otherwise, please leave me alone or I will call them and file harassment charges against you." I also carry a cheap body camera that I carry with me just in case I have those interactions, because as we all know, Karens and Darens will straight up lie to the authorities in an attempt to get their way. Then you can get them for filing a false report and likely other charges as well. Eventually, they can lose their waterway access rights if they have any.
@@dustyflairthat all depends on the state buddy in my state the state owns 5 feet from the high tide mark and all the water and land under it is state owned
Every state water way laws differ here in Alabama if you launch in a public place (boat ramp) and you go 10.miles down or up river and see an opening of a creek channel and can navigate your boat through it with out passing through a gate that closes the creek a gate now I remind you and it opens up to a lake you are permitted to fish it regardless if it's privately owned or not due to the fact you entered through it on public access so if you own that lake and you have people enter it through that channel you have to get permission to place a gate not a fence or cut a tree down but an actual gate that can be locked and put a no trespassing sign on it to legally keep people out of your private lake
As a fellow dedicated fisherman, I can tell you that most of us think we’re experts on riparian law, when in fact, it can be very tricky, if not complex. Riparian law is completely different than conventional law. Yes, certain laws apply to “navigable” waters, but what is the legal definition of navigable. It not only has to do with the obvious, that a boat can navigate it, but other criteria apply as well, such as width, depth, length, source, naturally occurring or man made, etc. What verification do you have that it is navigable other than assumption or word of mouth? Rather than all the tit for tat, simply contact fish and wildlife and request a meeting with the officer at the site. Beforehand , go down to the courthouse and spend a couple dollars and get a copy of the plat of the related subdivision and bring it to your meet. I don’t know if it is or not, but if that was a man made channel, maybe many, many years ago, it’s entirely possible ( not probable) the developer conveyed ownership of the lot to the middle of the stream bed. (An example of the complexities of riparian law.) You could be dead right, or, dead wrong. If you’re right, you should stand up for yourself. If you’re wrong, lesson learned, and move on. I’m on your side, I just think you need to get all the facts. It seems there are 2 types of people One that actually wants a resolution to an issue, And the other that is just to looking to express themselves. Decide which type you are and base your actions on that. Thanks for listening :)
Life long resident and avid fisherman/ hunter in Idaho, and I think you nailed it. Might not be as cut and dry as alot of people think. I'm sure this is going to be hashed out in court more often in the near future. I would be curious as to F&G's opinion in this instance, as I've been threatened with trespass to hunt or fish by F&G on Pend Oreille lake under the high water mark. I've also had a freind threatened with the same on some smaller natural creeks that probably weren't navigable. My experience has been F&G hasn't been on the side of the sportsman. I know for fact they won't lift a finger for hunter harassment.
Find out from the DNR if it’s navigable and if it isn’t then research to see how it was used. Commerce is the main criteria for declaration and not if it was floatable . If it hasn’t been declared then you may want to present your research to the State to consider a Declaration
HOAs believe that they create a sovereign state once it is established. They own the rivers, lakes, oceanfront, some believe they own the parks, can restrict accommodations for handicapped, as well as tell you what color your flowers have to be on your flower pot on your front porch if they allow a flower pot. IHOA’s should be rendered legally Impotent.
I’m from the communist east coast and hunted in Wyoming for the first time on state and blm land, what a shock. For a state that prides itself on freedom, HOAs essentially cut off thousands and thousands of public hunting land bc of access over a stupid gravel road. I took an antelope on blm land and had a landowner lose it on me bc apparently I drove down a small section of HOA gravel road. These land owners get free access to public land no one else can. One of the most screwed up places I’ve been too
That's only partially correct, if you can go up or down a waterway , even on a inner tube or by kayak , property can not be posted below the high water mark. It's a Federal law valid in all 50 states.
@@twa2471 not sure if what I read pertains to easements only but the Code was separate from the navigable waters code which I am aware of, the former code seems logical because if John Q taxpayer has a fishing license he by all rights should be able to legally fish that body of water if indeed it is stocked by the state where John Q and the body of water reside. Not sure if this is a California only code because that is where this John Q lives lol.
@@noel3422 Those were just a couple links that came to mind, there's defiantly lots of other links and CFR's that might be a bit more concise I'm sure . There is allot of them and ,,fairly,,easy to find with a bit of searching. A few years back in the Winter months I worked with Clam Outdoors as a Pro Staffer and traveled the ice belt from Maine to Western NY , doing ice fishing / kids fishing clinics with Fish& Wildlife often, tons of tournaments,and did presentations at all the major sporting goods retailers like Bass Pro Shops, Cabellas, Gander MT.,,,ect so I had to put up with landowners misconceptions then too. Not only while working with the Forest Service on the enforcement end . There are different regulations in different areas for sure though , but there are basic CFR's that apply nation wide still when it comes to waterway travel . Generally speaking land can not be posted below the high water mark along a passable water way is the rule of thumb by CFR's other than in a few rare exceptions ie; soft turtle nesting areas, Loon nesting areas ect . As I warned , it can become a rabbit hole to find all the info you may be looking for and takes a heck of a long time finding it in all those CFR's I know . But with some searching you'll get better answers than from those I cited, those are very basic and don't really cover everything. Just talking to the Fish & Game guys will allow you to know what applies in your area more than anything ,so that would be simplest route to go IMHO. I did allot with them both while with the Forest Service and at Clam both and there a great bunch of folks,,,,until you mess up of course ,,,LMAO !!!!
Problem is land owners try to block access points to the water, there are regulations stating that land owners cannot block access. Wealthy landowners make sure those regulations aren’t enforced. Just look at Martins Beach in San Mateo county.
The issue is not the fishing, but the land. If you’re on the land, then you’re on private property. In some places it even the bottom of the river is considered private property, you can float through it, but you can’t put your feet on the bottom.
You couldn't be more wrong ... I've done the research and every state in union has laws protecting the fisherman's rights with easements to access all navigable waters !!!
I don't know who the hell told you that but you are 100% wrong... and if someone's trying to enforce that BS it's against the law and you should be suing the piss out of them.
Not wrong... In Connecticut if you own the land on both sides of a river, you own the river bottom as well. Fishermen could float down the river but standing in it would be considered trespassing
I can't even imagine the horsepoop for a brain and soul you'd have to have going on to see someone fishing and decide to harass them like that. This guy was waaaay too nice to that mf'er...
Navigable vs riparian is one debate. High water mark is the navigable standard, center of the river is the riparian standard. This being a navigable discussion, the HOA guys point may have been one about egress. Egess matters even in navigable water. That said, everything I saw in the video was legal. The HOA's next step will be address the access if the trails to the stream go across private property. Trail cams are used for this regularly.
Not directly related to this video, but what I hate about encounters like this is when people say "I've been fishing (or hunting ) this area my whole life and blah blah blah". Like that gives them some special rights. This happens with duck hunting blinds on our local lake and hunters think they "own" the blind or the area where they have hunted forever.
I can't stand people that get on their high horse and being over protective of land they own but this guy was as polite as he could be bringing up his concern. Even if he's wrong it's not hard for the person fishing to just say hey I don't know that you're right but I'll be sure and ask about it and if I'm not allowed to be here legally without permission you won't see me again. He kinda did that but he did it in a snarky manner. "Well I'll call fish and wildlife and see what they say about it." He didn't do anything overly aggressive to escalate the situation but he also didn't do anything to help come to terms or an agreement with the other gentleman. Disagreements can be figured out amicably.
If it’s navigable it doesn’t matter if both sides are owned . The nav rule has nothing to do with floating a boat or raft but has everything to do with how it was used with commerce and it goes back to the conception of our Government.
OR, from below the high water mark as well is perfectly fine . Property owners can not post below the high water mark, period whether there land encompasses both sides or not .
"I've live here my whole life. I've fishing this since I was 10 years old, I've live in this..." I am not from Idaho, but I like to fish, so I was curious if I would be in this situation, what I could find to verify what is allowed. I found a source, and what I think is relevant to video I found kind of confusing. ( Although, I was lazy and I did not read the whole source. 😅) NOTE: I did not search how HOA rules and state rules interact with one another. "The Snake River between Idaho, Oregon, or Washington: The holder of a valid Idaho fishing license and salmon or steelhead permit may fish for those species provided the season is open in the Snake River where it forms the boundary between the states of Idaho and Oregon or Washington, subject to the fish and game laws of Idaho, but may not fish from the shoreline, including wading, and may not fish in sloughs or tributaries on the Oregon or Washington side. " I might have misinterpreted this paragraph, but the reason that says "no shoreline, no sloughs, no tributaries" is because you can only fish from a boat ( or reasonable facsimile )? 🤔 That makes no sense, especially that it was clear in the video mentioning the 5 feet parking rule for fishing. (Unless that changed at some point). Source: www.eregulations.com/idaho/fishing/fishing-rules-2022-2024
I am so sick of people like this. When I was a kid I hunted ducks on a small river and people would always call the cops on me (they thought they "owned" a part of the river). Every time the cops would tell the homeowners that what I was doing was legal. Jerks
Instead of harassing this poor guy and his daughter why don’t he just grab a chair and a pole and hang out and fish with them and be a nice kind person why is that so hard to do these days smh the lord said to love thy neighbor and to treat others how you would wanna be treated I don’t think the lord said to harass others that are not apart of the home owners association and to be rude and stuck up and conceited. People really need to get their hearts in check this right here is why most people will be going to hell when they die instead of heaven I bet you anything that old man calls his self a Christian too out there harassing and bullying people that are just spending time with their daughter shame on him smh acting like he owns GODS WATER/RIVER SMH 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Here in North Carolina some of the best trout streams are legally protected and private waters. It’s tough but there are also over 4 thousand miles of public stocked streams and impoundments in NC too
I understand the frustrations of both sides of these situations. Being respectful of the property though doesn’t change to fact that you aren’t paying taxes on or maintaining the property.
Home Owner's Associations need to be criminalized.
No, they keep neighborhoods clean and safe. Just because he was a problem, that’s his problem. And what a laugh, criminalized? Lol HOA’s can’t and never will. If a board member does wrong, embezzles money, that’s the only person who would be a criminal. I live in a HOA community for over twenty years and never had one issue with any neighbors and I would never get into any neighbors face or property. If a neighbor isn’t happy with the people next door or across the street, it’s their business to report it to the people working at our community’s HOA’s main office. It cracks me up when people see one person or a couple being all crazy in one video, I see comments like yours like it’s going to solve world problems. Lol 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
@@JMarieCAlove HOA's don't keep neighborhoods clean and safe. What a crock of ____. All they do is pester people with tons of stupid rules and turn neighborhoods into fascist hellholes. Not only should they be criminalized, but the people who start them should be prosecuted under the 14th amendment and thrown in prison.
@@JMarieCAlove HOAs do not keep neighborhoods clean and safe. That's a crock. What they actually do is pester the neighborhood with tons of stupid rules. Not only should they be criminalized, but the people who start them should be prosecuted under the 14th amendment and thrown in prison.
Un elected power trip people 😜.
She looks like the type of karen that goes thru your trash when you are at work..."Hey neighbor, I was going thru your trash the other day and noticed you put a piece of paper in your glass container..." fxxx off hoa Karen. I hrew up in am hoa and all the old ladies hated when kids would go outside and play or go into the pool area. Karen's tried to ruin our childhood and ive always hated them since then. Down with hoas.
In Florida it's illegal to harass a fisherman.
Oh no, Florida is the land of free… funny how people believe so much bs about a state where old fuckers with too much time on their hands, do all they can to harass people minding their own business!
That’s why we now carry down here, no permit needed. You give me shit? Say hello to my little friend!
Same here in Idaho it's just easier to talk it out sometimes.
Same here. Illegal to harass a hunter and fisherman. Illegal to harass people period lol
@@bigjohn7057 OK Rambo
See what just a little power does to people. That’s why freedom is so important
It is a blessing to live in a country where everything is not owned by the state. You have no freedom there. You cannot own private land that gives you the ability to restrict access to your property by people who insult you and abuse the privilege to come onto your property.
@@jackfanning7952 then vote Democrat. Republicans want to eliminate all the national parks and recreational areas.
@@jackfanning7952 True. And it's a blessing to live in a country where everything is not owned privately, especially by an HOA. So glad my local parks and open space protects stuff like this.
@@maxsecrest I agree. And I will never, ever own any property governed by a HOA again.
I saw that and experienced it during the China flu scamdemic. Everyone was either a doctor or a security guard telling you to wear a mask and where to stand. Cops in my state were actually going through restaurants to make sure they were in compliance!
On behalf of all sportsmen, thank you for standing your ground.
It's navigable water. That's all you need to know, it's therefore NOT privately owned. Tell him to piss off.
I came here to say this
That may not be totally correct. In Colorado, the landowner owns the bottom of the river. You can float through someone's property but not get out and wade. I have no idea where this guy is fishing.
@@williambyington4864I'd look into that. I doubt it's illegal to wade the river bottom is always changing. Rivers edges erode. It's always changing.
High water mark is public easement in Idaho if its "naviable" You cant tresspass over private land to get to it but if you enter at a public road you are good@@ML-ks2lj
in most states the landowner owns the land UNDER the water to the MIDDLE of the channel/creek/etc. Called riparian rights.@@ML-ks2lj
It does not matter if the property is private or not. Idaho Law states, If it is a navigable water it has puplic access to the high water mark.
That's true!
the one river in Virginia comes under the old king George grant.the folks their owns the water and the land under the water.wrong but that's the way it is for those "ELITE" folks.
Florida also it's the same way👍👍👍
@@TB-lv2rh It is, it's a Federal law , not a state law.
And that's the truth!!!!!
The fact that he saw you there with your child, minding your business, being a good dad and he STILL felt the need to ruin your days is pathetic. That old man is just straight up not a good person.
Love the fact you caught one right in front of him
As a retired Forest Service officer you are correct, any navigable waterway can be used by the public below the high water mark and can not be posted below that, even if your land surrounds a river or stream. That is a federal law in every single state , weather someone likes it or not.
I've run into the same thing before while looking for arrowheads along stream and lake banks. I do understand in a way why people don't like it ,, but let's face it some people are just pigs and leave mess's everywhere , but that issue can be resolved easily by law enforcement and the fines covering that infraction are much more serious than any trespassing charge, which in this case wouldn't apply anyhow.
Now if someone was leaving trash and fire pits all along the bank , that's an entirely different story , then they can or could be charged with polluting a waterway or fishery , which can be a pretty hefty fine . I've written up more than one person myself for doing that in my 16+ years of service , and it's for a very good reason . If your the kinda person that does that , you just don't realize the impact those things can make on the health of a fishery or on the environment itself .
Sadly there's dummy's and Kens and Karen's everywhere that don't know any better.
What defines navigable under law how would one know on shallow Creeks iam not sure but would like to know because I can run into this all the time
@@user-oq8zy3zg5u Generally speaking , if you can go down a river or stream , even on a inner tube or kayak , it's considered to be a navigable waterway by law. Hope that helps answer your question .
That is not the law in Ohio. The landowner owned the land below the water. It is legal to float, but the second you get out of your boat you are trespassing if you do not have permission
not in north carolina . go to villa crucis and see what happenes if your in the river where both sidesof the river banks are owned from one person
@@wildsau1965 What would happen would be that someone like myself or any other LEO would respond.
below is only a small part of your states regulations and if you wish to jump down the rabbit hole further. There are many other statutes pertaining to this issue , but I'll waste no more time with you as you seem to know it all already ,,,I have better things to do and bigger fish to fry, pun intended.
Chapter 14 Article 22A ss14-159.9
And that's not even counting all the Federal laws & CFR's pertaining to this .
Ive seen worse Karen"s. But he still needs to make sure he knows the law before confronting someone like this. How I deal with these types is I simply say, "call the game warden, if he tells me to leave then I will leave.. Until then, I do not want to discuss it any further. We can talk about the weather, but not about if I can fish here or not".
Knowing the law is secondary to just minding your own business, like this ole guy should have.
FACTS!!!
It's illegal to harass a fisherman or hunter.
@@madatu I could not agree with you more.
That’s my advice. Tell them to call the game warden then turn your back to them and don’t engage.
As someone that has lived in the boonies my whole life, the concept of a homeowners association dictating how your home can look and what you can have in your yard and harrassing people fishing on a public river just boggles my mind. Hope you and your daughter had fun anyways. Take care.
He’s probably the developer and he’s telling potential customers that they will have a private water access 😂
bingo. sounds like a white person in idaho. some of the most racist people and retarded people ive ever met. Its the illegals thats our nations problem. proceed to hire a gardner housekeeper etc that are all illegal. think their kids are too good to work dairies.... all illegals. americans need to stop being pussies and we will be alright
That's it!
Are you stupid enough to assume you are not trepassing when someone tells you you are on private property? Take your chances. Roll the dice and see how that works out for you.
Techncially they do have water access. The issue is, they think that includes the water.
That’s exactly who he is .
Always perplexed by people who try to stop other people from fishing
You read my mind! But I’ve noticed that some people have boundary issues. Like serious boundary issues. It’s an instinct that’s probably been reinforced too often.
If someone breaks their ankle while burglarizing your house they can sue you. Same principle applies here- plus the trash people leave behind is dangerous to wildlife and hurts the looks and environment. Boatless bank trash need to police themselves better.
@@cuivre2004get happier buddy. I'm sure you leave a paper trail without fishing. Why do you do about what you complain about? You just whine about "boat less bank trash" littering but you know you can't stop it so if it bothers you that much, do you go do park clean ups or pick up trash you see? If not then stfu unless you're willing to be the difference. My fishing pack has 2 30 gallon trash bags in it. I don't complain about the trash I just pick it up. Once you realize you cant control other people your life will be much better. And you'd be surprised on just being the guy to show up with his gear and before he leaves he takes a half hour to clean up the area, the domino effect that has. So nut up or shut up cake boy
@@cuivre2004nut up or shut up go pick up the trash instead of complaining. You can't stop it but you can clean it.
Years ago, Californians started buying up riverside properties all up the Elk River, here in Oregon. In places where local people had for 100 years walked a short ways off the public road and down a bank to go fishing, even if they were hundreds of yards from the landowner's houses, they put up high chain link fences to block the access and put up no trespassing signs. Guess they didn't realize that rural Oregon isn't downtown LA or Oakland, and you don't need to lock everything up like Fort Knox with barbwire and machinegun nests. Not very neighborly.
I'd tell him to contact the DNR and send them out if I need to move. He has no jurisdiction nor ability to make you move. He does have the ability to be charged with harassing someone fishing.
Ever notice how fish seem to congregate in waterways that run through land owned by entitled assholes? Been thru this same scenario too many times to count. Glad you stood your ground man.
I have been through this kinda shit through out my whole life,it's always people that move in from out of state, they bring their bullshit with them😢
Yeah I know. I live in a rural area and when someone comes along and buys 5 acres they act like they own the whole county. Walking, hunting, riding ATVs and putting up hunting stands on everyone else's land.
Fishing with nobody else insight. Not bothering anyone. Some people are unbelievable.
"I don't recognize your authority to stop me from fishing"
boom
Losers are everywhere that think they are smarter than you. How about just say call the game warden and don’t talk to me
If you are below the regular high-water line and you did not trespass to get there, you are 100% allowed to fish. The road's a stones throw away. Is their front porch the reeds or the bank? No. I guarantee the water line goes up at least a couple feet at least once a year, if not more. No one would ever build their house there. no matter who owns the property, that area is 100% legal to fish.
So many rich land grabbers feel that they are entitled to control everything in the surrounding areas of their property.
We had an entitled a** by the farm next to my childhood home.
One day I was out hunting our property when I was approached by a man saying that I was on private property and if I didn't leave I would be charged with trespassing.
I responded by saying "That works for me"!
I then introduced myself and laughed when he started sputtering, him and hahing realizing I was the kid of the owners.
The entitled ass didn't feel so entitled all of a sudden!😂😂
You, sir have a lot more patience than I do. A wise old man once told me “Do you know what gets people killed? Other people’s business. So you best just mind yours.”
Problem is... the infestation of Social Media and being in everyone's business has created people like these who feel they're entitled to stick their nose in yours at every turn. It's absolutely sickening.
he does not own the river no matter what he said!!
"I appreciate your concern. Do you know who owns it?"
"Since you don't know who owns it, that means you trespassed to tell me I was trespassing."
As long as your within the high water mark nobody owns the rivers .
Only housewives go with that since they'll never really own anything since their sucker of a husband paid for it
The guy should just say he’s an illegal alien, no hablo ingles. Then, border patrol would come and bring him lunch and a gift card.
Congratulations that is the dumbest statement I’ve read all week. Keep sucking that orange cock cool aid.
I've always wished for a Star Trek phaser when I was a child and to this day,.. I'm still wishing for one just for these moments... lol🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
When a stranger comes to you and starts speaking, you're not obligated to speak.
Former friend bought some land here in Montana next to a river.
The MT Supreme Court ruled that people could walk along a river to the high-water mark and they can operate boats up and down rivers too.
He threw a fit. "Nobody should be able to step one inch on his land, water mark or no. And no one should be allowed to run a boat over his part of the river." I didn't argue, I knew it would be pointless.
I just wondered how anyone could get that selfish.
All river banks should be free access. No private ownership.
There were no homes in that video. To me, no homes no HOA. Only makes sense🤷♂️
Here in Texas it's actually a jailable offense to interfere with or harass a hunter/angler. We also have water rights. Unless your property is completely surrounding the body of water there is like a 5 foot public easement to the navigable water. I ran into someone like this recently at a community lake. Now that I know the law, I'm just going to tell him to leave me alone or I'm calling TPWD out to cite him. I suggest looking into your states laws regarding this. If it's illegal where you are, then just call the wardens out to deal with this guy next time.
The same in Florida! Two geat states!
The old man hasn't lived there his whole life. If he did, and that's a big if. He would know millions of people fish all parts of the snake. And he can only stock a lake that is private if he pays for the fish himself. I never heard in Idaho where the fish and game just up and stocked private property ponds. Unless you payed for them to do it. He's from California no doubt.
I tell people to call the game warden
And the local police to please 😂😂😂🤣
@@KevinPaulsen-jt4vzI wouldn't count on the police to know the law. The wardens will know.
@@penguin12902 I totally agree with you, I was just saying to call the police to so everyone gets an education from the gamewarden and the guy harassing the fishermen gets to feel like a dip shit in front of the cop and gamewarden and the fishermen.
Properly placed posted signs along the road side of his property could stop you by trespassing you if you cross his property to get to the highwater line. Unless there is a right-of-way road/path for access to the water. But you could still enter the legal area from up or downstream. It's a shame people have to make such wholesome activities a pain in the neck.
Catching the trout in his face was the ultimate power move lol, he didn't know whether to leave or burst at the seems.
Bring Karen deep in woods to meet up with Dog man. Lol
Say yello to my lidda fren. My bad! He nah so lidda.
Did you get that guys name and contact information?
Fish and Game will have plenty to say about this.
Would you please keep us updated on this situation? Thx.
Boise Idaho resident here. Just an FYI from fisherman to fisherman, if there is a river that flows through someone's property, they cannot deny you access to said body of water. They are required by law to have public access through their property to the river in question and the banks on either side of the river are still considered public property even if they "bought" the land directly adjacent. It's not even a waterline thing. Even when the water is at its highest, you are still allowed to access the bank and nobody can tell you otherwise as nobody can own any flowing body of water in Idaho. But it seems like you know this already lol this is more for anyone else in the chat who may or may not know the law. ❤
Ignorance is bliss. A freakin' HOA coming to a waterway and declaring HOA rules. Laughable ...just simply stupid and laughable. I bet he likes telling his neighbors their flowers are the wrong color for the HOA rules .....
Get a life Sir! Thanks for standing up to him.
If you are 100% confident you are in a legal spot, the answer is always "Let's get the game warden out here, and if I am correct, I will be asking to press charges under the state's harassment clause." Let them put their money where their mouth is.
I have never seen a lake so narrow with such strong current.
its tidal.
@EdWeibe You are remanded to two minutes of sarcasm re-education.
@@EdWeibe no tides in idaho
If it’s “waters of the US”, which this is, the public can use the water and the property owner can’t regulate that. However, the property owner can regulate “access” to it if the public trespasses on private property to gain access to the water. This is why it is legal for boats and kayaks to gain access to this specific spot via upstream but not legal for people to bank fish after trespassing across private property.
Unless there is an existing public access. Even if the property
Owner doesn’t want it,if it is established not
Much the “new”
Property owner
Can do about it.
if that clown had any authority he would not be there flapping his gums, he would have called the law, you just look at some fool like that and say " if you can trespass me do it, otherwise shut up and go away " .. there are so many people who think they own things they simply live near
The rule is don't be a Karen or a Kevin
Or a ken, their son
That's a good rule.
His wife probably put him up to it.
He was very nice and civil
he was only "nice" because he was being recorded.
@@jw-hy5nq
You don’t know that
@@user-hl1zo6co1o It is more than obvious. The man is a tyrant but also coward.
he was only nice because he is a coward
It's called," passive aggressive"
I would have told him to mind his own business! If it doesn’t have posted private property signs!!
How you access the river is definitely important. If you crossed his property to get to the high water mark then you are in the wrong. If you waded the bank to get there then I’d say you’re good.
Bush got nothing better to do from retirement. Just love how you don't waste time fishing rather than just talking to him.
That guy was not a Karen. He disagreed with you, and he was probably wrong, but he conducted himself politely.
Reminds me of the time I was at my local sheriffs office on a Saturday morning, and the people in front of me were trying to file a report on a father and son were fishing from a public area into a public access lake behind their house.
These days My response to Karens that keep going after they can't bully me is " well if you honestly believe that your right, call the police. In fact let me call them for you!"
They generally run when I actually do call them, and I do!
I tell them that they can use my phone and remind them that the number is 9-1-1.
When you argue with people like this, explain why you can legally be there. And they can call the cops if they dislike it. They hate it
Simple..."Have a nice day, goodbye".
When you come across people like this no matter what you say they think they right. You can pull up the law on Google but even then most won't admit they're wrong or they simply can't comprehend it.
All you ever need to tell them is I'm not leaving until the game warden says I'm breaking the law.
F him .I can't speak to Idaho laws but I know in many other places if you access the water from a public easement and are standing below the high water mark they can't say shi$t. If you are on navigatabl water they are also s o l . Good on you for being calm and cool.
Glad you stood your ground. What power does to people.
I would have told that man to stop talking to me the second he says "its private property"
The Californians who bought those lots are the ones pushing that old man to try and keep people out I’m sure. I used to live and fish that area too.
Quit blaming “Californians”…if they can afford to buy that land,then they deserve to own it.Money talks,and bullshit walks.Save your money,buy your own land,and quit crying.
Thanks for clearing that up for me! Where would I be without you!
@@redman840
@@redman840that’s why we don’t like Californias money dictates your principle and you walk your bullshit into our state.
@@redman840oh, so you haven’t lived in an area where the locusts came up and bought everything, pricing all the locals out of their own towns. Or you’re just one of the locusts. There’s a reason why everyone in the entire country hate to see California or New York plates. Every single person hates them for a very good reason. So nah, you can go screw yourself cock sucker.
@@redman840just remember that you said that when the Chinese start buying up all the land 👍🏻
You are a lot nicer than I would have been, good for you.
its a strange world indeed. Because Private land may be owned but in many cases, the water is owned by U.S. government according to LAW. So the only way a person can stop you is by taking the land right away from you. This is always true of course but it's mostly what America's law is.
What is more wholesome than fishing with your kid?
Every fisherman must know the state fishing rules and have at all times have a current state fishing rules book on them when they go fishing.
Okay--post the law that says every fisherman has to carry a fishing rules book with them.
Very nice !! 💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻🎣🐟🎣🐟👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Why does the government allow people to deny access to public waterways? Coastal waters and riverbanks ought never be privately owned!
I don't argue with people on this. I have had many interactions with these types of nosey Karens and Darens and I just keep it simple. "If you think I am doing something illegal, feel free to call the authorities. Otherwise, please leave me alone or I will call them and file harassment charges against you." I also carry a cheap body camera that I carry with me just in case I have those interactions, because as we all know, Karens and Darens will straight up lie to the authorities in an attempt to get their way. Then you can get them for filing a false report and likely other charges as well. Eventually, they can lose their waterway access rights if they have any.
You have wayyyyyy more patience than me...i would have told the old man to shut his yapper!
You spent more time with him than I would. When he said that it is coming to an end, I would say, "Not today, step off."
One foot in the grave but still trying to be pain to people.😂
The highest water line does not belong to the land owner.
the landowner USUALLY owns the land to the middle of the river NOT the water. People like you get confused.
@@dustyflairthat all depends on the state buddy in my state the state owns 5 feet from the high tide mark and all the water and land under it is state owned
HUH? So if I have a stream running thru my land I dont own the land? What state do you live in?@@yakamarezlife
@@dustyflair youtube Karen right here
@@SingularPeripheral Yep, I'm afraid ole dusty gets confused easily.
Every state water way laws differ here in Alabama if you launch in a public place (boat ramp) and you go 10.miles down or up river and see an opening of a creek channel and can navigate your boat through it with out passing through a gate that closes the creek a gate now I remind you and it opens up to a lake you are permitted to fish it regardless if it's privately owned or not due to the fact you entered through it on public access so if you own that lake and you have people enter it through that channel you have to get permission to place a gate not a fence or cut a tree down but an actual gate that can be locked and put a no trespassing sign on it to legally keep people out of your private lake
this is true in almost ALL STATES.
You were definitely a lot more polite than I would have been.
Don't argue with this person. Simply ask him to call the authorities and let them set him straight.
As a fellow dedicated fisherman, I can tell you that most of us think we’re experts on riparian law, when in fact, it can be very tricky, if not complex. Riparian law is completely different than conventional law.
Yes, certain laws apply to “navigable” waters, but what is the legal definition of navigable. It not only has to do with the obvious, that a boat can navigate it, but other criteria apply as well, such as width, depth, length, source, naturally occurring or man made, etc.
What verification do you have that it is navigable other than assumption or word of mouth?
Rather than all the tit for tat, simply contact fish and wildlife and request a meeting with the officer at the site.
Beforehand , go down to the courthouse and spend a couple dollars and get a copy of the plat of the related subdivision and bring it to your meet.
I don’t know if it is or not, but if that was a man made channel, maybe many, many years ago, it’s entirely possible ( not probable) the developer conveyed ownership of the lot to the middle of the stream bed. (An example of the complexities of riparian law.)
You could be dead right, or, dead wrong. If you’re right, you should stand up for yourself. If you’re wrong, lesson learned, and move on.
I’m on your side, I just think you need to get all the facts.
It seems there are 2 types of people
One that actually wants a resolution to an issue,
And the other that is just to looking to express themselves.
Decide which type you are and base your actions on that.
Thanks for listening :)
Life long resident and avid fisherman/ hunter in Idaho, and I think you nailed it. Might not be as cut and dry as alot of people think. I'm sure this is going to be hashed out in court more often in the near future.
I would be curious as to F&G's opinion in this instance, as I've been threatened with trespass to hunt or fish by F&G on Pend Oreille lake under the high water mark. I've also had a freind threatened with the same on some smaller natural creeks that probably weren't navigable. My experience has been F&G hasn't been on the side of the sportsman. I know for fact they won't lift a finger for hunter harassment.
Damn dude I fell asleep halfway through your post. But I fish anywhere I want to whenever I want to.
Find out from the DNR if it’s navigable and if it isn’t then research to see how it was used. Commerce is the main criteria for declaration and not if it was floatable . If it hasn’t been declared then you may want to present your research to the State to consider a Declaration
Tell Karen, “it’s mind over matter… I don’t mind because you don’t matter”
There needs to be more legislation to help hunters and anglers
Please provide a video update!
PREACH BROTHA
HOAs believe that they create a sovereign state once it is established. They own the rivers, lakes, oceanfront, some believe they own the parks, can restrict accommodations for handicapped, as well as tell you what color your flowers have to be on your flower pot on your front porch if they allow a flower pot. IHOA’s should be rendered legally Impotent.
I’m from the communist east coast and hunted in Wyoming for the first time on state and blm land, what a shock. For a state that prides itself on freedom, HOAs essentially cut off thousands and thousands of public hunting land bc of access over a stupid gravel road. I took an antelope on blm land and had a landowner lose it on me bc apparently I drove down a small section of HOA gravel road. These land owners get free access to public land no one else can. One of the most screwed up places I’ve been too
I have read that if the waters are stocked by the state then there must be an easement for fishermen who posses a valid fishing license.
That's only partially correct, if you can go up or down a waterway , even on a inner tube or by kayak , property can not be posted below the high water mark. It's a Federal law valid in all 50 states.
Fishing license is for slaves.
@@twa2471 not sure if what I read pertains to easements only but the
Code was separate from the navigable waters code which I am aware of, the former code seems logical because if John Q taxpayer has a fishing license he by all rights should be able to legally fish that body of water if indeed it is stocked by the state where John Q and the body of water reside. Not sure if this is a California only code because that is where this John Q lives lol.
@@noel3422 Those were just a couple links that came to mind, there's defiantly lots of other links and CFR's that might be a bit more concise I'm sure . There is allot of them and ,,fairly,,easy to find with a bit of searching.
A few years back in the Winter months I worked with Clam Outdoors as a Pro Staffer and traveled the ice belt from Maine to Western NY , doing ice fishing / kids fishing clinics with Fish& Wildlife often, tons of tournaments,and did presentations at all the major sporting goods retailers like Bass Pro Shops, Cabellas, Gander MT.,,,ect so I had to put up with landowners misconceptions then too. Not only while working with the Forest Service on the enforcement end .
There are different regulations in different areas for sure though , but there are basic CFR's that apply nation wide still when it comes to waterway travel . Generally speaking land can not be posted below the high water mark along a passable water way is the rule of thumb by CFR's other than in a few rare exceptions ie; soft turtle nesting areas, Loon nesting areas ect .
As I warned , it can become a rabbit hole to find all the info you may be looking for and takes a heck of a long time finding it in all those CFR's I know . But with some searching you'll get better answers than from those I cited, those are very basic and don't really cover everything.
Just talking to the Fish & Game guys will allow you to know what applies in your area more than anything ,so that would be simplest route to go IMHO.
I did allot with them both while with the Forest Service and at Clam both and there a great bunch of folks,,,,until you mess up of course ,,,LMAO !!!!
Problem is land owners try to block access points to the water, there are regulations stating that land owners cannot block access. Wealthy landowners make sure those regulations aren’t enforced. Just look at Martins Beach in San Mateo county.
The issue is not the fishing, but the land. If you’re on the land, then you’re on private property. In some places it even the bottom of the river is considered private property, you can float through it, but you can’t put your feet on the bottom.
You couldn't be more wrong ... I've done the research and every state in union has laws protecting the fisherman's rights with easements to access all navigable waters !!!
You don’t know shit bro that’s not at all how it works, and definitely not in the state this guys in.
dude it is called riparian rights that belong to the land owner. Head back to law school chief.@@wilkeithsarratt1337
I don't know who the hell told you that but you are 100% wrong... and if someone's trying to enforce that BS it's against the law and you should be suing the piss out of them.
Not wrong... In Connecticut if you own the land on both sides of a river, you own the river bottom as well. Fishermen could float down the river but standing in it would be considered trespassing
I can't even imagine the horsepoop for a brain and soul you'd have to have going on to see someone fishing and decide to harass them like that. This guy was waaaay too nice to that mf'er...
Where I live it is illegal to harass anybody legally fishing. We're also allowed to fish all state waters
Navigable vs riparian is one debate. High water mark is the navigable standard, center of the river is the riparian standard. This being a navigable discussion, the HOA guys point may have been one about egress. Egess matters even in navigable water. That said, everything I saw in the video was legal.
The HOA's next step will be address the access if the trails to the stream go across private property. Trail cams are used for this regularly.
The word you're looking for is "access", not "egress/egess".
@@G31mR The legal right to access is defined as egress and ingress.
Riparian ! I learned a new word today. Thanks
real simple call the game warden
this guy knows whats up
This guy has nothing else to do with his time sad......
Hopefully you mean the ken Karen
Not directly related to this video, but what I hate about encounters like this is when people say "I've been fishing (or hunting ) this area my whole life and blah blah blah". Like that gives them some special rights. This happens with duck hunting blinds on our local lake and hunters think they "own" the blind or the area where they have hunted forever.
I can't stand people that get on their high horse and being over protective of land they own but this guy was as polite as he could be bringing up his concern. Even if he's wrong it's not hard for the person fishing to just say hey I don't know that you're right but I'll be sure and ask about it and if I'm not allowed to be here legally without permission you won't see me again. He kinda did that but he did it in a snarky manner. "Well I'll call fish and wildlife and see what they say about it." He didn't do anything overly aggressive to escalate the situation but he also didn't do anything to help come to terms or an agreement with the other gentleman. Disagreements can be figured out amicably.
If they own both sides of the river the high water rules don’t apply as far as I know. You can float through it
If it’s navigable it doesn’t matter if both sides are owned . The nav rule has nothing to do with floating a boat or raft but has everything to do with how it was used with commerce and it goes back to the conception of our Government.
Nope, not in Idaho...
You have every right to fish this water from boat
OR, from below the high water mark as well is perfectly fine . Property owners can not post below the high water mark, period whether there land encompasses both sides or not .
😂HOA folks are the worst kind of bored people
A man spending quality time with his child and he has to deal with this bs…
Catching the Lil rainbow in front of the male Karen = Bonus 😅
"I've live here my whole life. I've fishing this since I was 10 years old, I've live in this..."
I am not from Idaho, but I like to fish, so I was curious if I would be in this situation, what I could find to verify what is allowed.
I found a source, and what I think is relevant to video I found kind of confusing. ( Although, I was lazy and I did not read the whole source. 😅)
NOTE: I did not search how HOA rules and state rules interact with one another.
"The Snake River between Idaho, Oregon, or Washington: The holder of a valid Idaho fishing license and salmon or steelhead permit may fish for those species provided the season is open in the Snake River where it forms the boundary between the states of Idaho and Oregon or Washington, subject to the fish and game laws of Idaho, but may not fish from the shoreline, including wading, and may not fish in sloughs or tributaries on the Oregon or Washington side. "
I might have misinterpreted this paragraph, but the reason that says "no shoreline, no sloughs, no tributaries" is because you can only fish from a boat ( or reasonable facsimile )? 🤔
That makes no sense, especially that it was clear in the video mentioning the 5 feet parking rule for fishing. (Unless that changed at some point).
Source: www.eregulations.com/idaho/fishing/fishing-rules-2022-2024
I am so sick of people like this. When I was a kid I hunted ducks on a small river and people would always call the cops on me (they thought they "owned" a part of the river). Every time the cops would tell the homeowners that what I was doing was legal. Jerks
Instead of harassing this poor guy and his daughter why don’t he just grab a chair and a pole and hang out and fish with them and be a nice kind person why is that so hard to do these days smh the lord said to love thy neighbor and to treat others how you would wanna be treated I don’t think the lord said to harass others that are not apart of the home owners association and to be rude and stuck up and conceited. People really need to get their hearts in check this right here is why most people will be going to hell when they die instead of heaven I bet you anything that old man calls his self a Christian too out there harassing and bullying people that are just spending time with their daughter shame on him smh acting like he owns GODS WATER/RIVER SMH 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Here in North Carolina some of the best trout streams are legally protected and private waters. It’s tough but there are also over 4 thousand miles of public stocked streams and impoundments in NC too
I understand the frustrations of both sides of these situations. Being respectful of the property though doesn’t change to fact that you aren’t paying taxes on or maintaining the property.