I love it when the camera zooms in on the viola bridge so you can see how Zukerman changes tonal colors as the bow moves nearer and farther away from the bridge.
Нет слов ,прекраснейшее прочтение ,альт звучит превосходно..и очень необычные штрихи как в оригинале в 3 части ,обычно играют все не так,но это прекрасно ,так больше походит на Шуберта .Я в восторге !!!Супер
@@orchepiaviolinviola The ol' American "must-put-on-a-good-show" / cheerleader style playing of violin. Hilary Hahn used to bop around quite a bit too when she was younger (and still does the occasional strange torso movement). It is annoying to me. More so with Bell. So much more.... The one thing that bugs me is the unnecessary bending/crouching at the knees to exaggerate notes. Are the violinists not aware that you can achieve the desired sound without doing that ridiculous move? Hahah.
@@liamnevilleviolist1809 i don’t think they do that purposefully. When you’re completely immersed in your music, you do not take the time to think about how to move your body- the music pulls your body with you. Yes, some people can play completely fine without moving their bodies, but others find musical expression in swaying to the music, or bending their knees. Excessive moving that interferes with the music IS bad, but other types of moving only helps bring out the music. Music is a PERFORMING art, which means that there is also a visual element to it.
hey, i dont know about the viola, other than of course what i hear in quartets. i also very much like his playing...what is it that you like it...as a violinist i love his warmth and expression, and spirit, but i could not say anything technically.....(i am a pianist). thanks!
When I was younger (and this video was available to watch, uploaded by someone else) I was annoyed that Zukerman played many passages down the octave...because my teacher at the time [and I was about 14 years old] said I had to play up the octave wherever possible. I said "Zukerman choose the lower octave" and my teacher said "well... you're not Zukerman, you don't get to call the shots". Fair point. After all these years though, I have this to say: instrumentluckyrenditions available to watch on RUclips. Long story short, I like Zukerman's choices! His tone blends well with Neikrug!
Amazing. Like a private lesson. Of course it is a slavish copying job I am doing and minus the personal “how to do it” but what a place to start in building an interpretation! So far beyond the International/Katims edition.
Great video really! Thanks to those that put this amazing performance here: The title could include the key, which is A minor (The "D.821" is about the catalogue that Deutsch did about Shubert work)...Interesting approach to the third movement that everyone play it a bit more roughly: Love it!
Lovely. With the benefit of the record engineer that Bruno Giuranna had for this piece, i twould have been sensational. He has a similar bowing technique in some ways to Perlman. Perhaps this is Ivan Galamian's influence.
This is my favorite performance of Schubert's Arpeggione Sonata. I also like the sonata on the cello and bass. My least favorite instrument is the arpeggione as there is an edge to the sound.
I love them! Neikrug is a wonderful musician quite underrated, in my opinion. There used to be a video of theirs playing Schumann's Märchenbilder, and it was fantastic. I wonder how can I find it.
As beautiful as this performance is, try listening to the same piece played on oboe and piano, with the wonderful Alex Klein on oboe. I'm partial, as an oboist, but I think hearing this same piece on oboe and piano may even be more beautiful. It's on a CD titled "The Greatest Works Shubert (N)ever Wrote for the Oboe". Klein, former principal of the Chicago Symphony, uses a special extended range oboe to cover all the notes. Incidentally, this piece was originally written for what Schubert called an "arpeggione", which was invented around 1823 and whose maker called it a "guitarre d'amour". It looked like a guitar and had the same tuning of its six strings, but the strings ran over an arched bridge, like that of a cello. This piece is apparently the only significant one ever written for the arpeggione.
I am an oboist too, but still think the version for cello and piano is most likely to be closest to the original. There is a great version in RUclips with M. Rostropovich and B. Britten that is hard to beat! Cf. ruclips.net/video/aPLOfZW5VwE/видео.html
Wow, I cannot imagine this on oboe, nor would I want to. This is very much a string piece. I guess since I'm a violist, I am partial to it on the viola. I can tolerate it on the 'cello. But a woodwind instrument? For me, no way. P.S. Nothing against the oboe. It's nice for woodwind repertoire.
@@Old1bear Hi Philippe. The cello/piano version is indeed beautiful (how could it not be with Rostropovich and Benjamin Britten himself at the piano?), but it's also very different. For pure sound, I still like the oboe version better (that's why I took up the instrument in the first place). I think it goes to prove how wonderful a piece Schubert wrote, that on any instrument that plays it, it sounds beautiful. That's the real magic here.
@@iCyclone Hi Cyclone. I completely understand your partiality to the viola since that's what you play. I also assume you've heard the oboe version. If not, check it out: ruclips.net/video/uAwpLp9voio/видео.html. You write you can "tolerate" it on the cello and the oboe, "no way". I think you're showing quite a bit of snobbishness. As I mentioned in a different reply, it's the piece by Schubert that is the magic here. Each instrument, played beautifully, displays that magic. I hope you can come to appreciate that .
I read another comment and apparently it’s because of the string length and how the string resonates and on some violas it would work better than using only pegs but Idk for me the C-string is harder to tune with pegs than other strings so it might just be because it’s easier to tune 🤷♀️
It sounds very nice on the viola! Finally, a performer who gets closer to the right tempo of the first movement. Did Zukerman go off-tune in the first movement? Feuermann is still unrivaled at playing this piece.
I don't mean any offense and disrespect to the legend Zuckermann but I prefer this piece in a dark tone and thick sound. Like Richard O' Neil played in NYCP. I feel that's how this ought to be played. (Just a thought) 🙂 But the rubato and slides of Mr. Pinky are beautiful. And thanks a lot for this video. 🙂
I'm not sure I understand this comment, since Zukerman has maybe the darkest, fullest, thickest tone of any violist-- that's actually his trademark-- what makes his playing unique. I like O'Neill's performance, but this totally blows O'Neill's out of the water-- and, again, the sound here is much darker.
No comparison, Pinky is just on a completely different level in terms of intimacy, tone, colours, sound quality and phrasing. No offence to Richard O’Neil, but ...
It’s amazing how effortless his phrasing is. And with that flawless sound-I’m in awe.
this recording is a treasure
Franz Schubert.............. 🥰♥🎵............ he was a genius.
The only thing better than Pinchas Zukerman playing the violin, is Pinchas Zukerman playing the viola!
I agree with you
You are so right!
Nick, Helen York I completely agree!
Exactly!!!
concordo, il maestro zuckerman suona da dio il violino,ma e ' celestiale il suo suono dalla viola!
I love it when the camera zooms in on the viola bridge so you can see how Zukerman changes tonal colors as the bow moves nearer and farther away from the bridge.
О какое здоровское построение формы! Я не слышала более целостной интерпретации! Компактно, все кульминации на месте, не "размазано". Спасибо! 👏
Pinchas Zukermann ist wunderbar, egal, ob er Violine oder Viola spielt. Dieses Video ist besonders schön. Ein sehr schöner inniger Ton. Danke !
ただ美しい音色に心をうばわれ心地よく。その後、座ったまま泣いておりました。ラストに希望が見えました♫すばらしい♡
Es ist unglaublich, daß der beste Violaspieler der Welt ein Violinspieler ist.
zukerman is a genius, he plays with such wonderful emotion and dynamics. and those trills! damn
So wunderbar einfach kann Musik sein. Die innige Tongebung ist einfach grossartig. Danke!
Pinchas Zukerman is
excellent and gorgeous playerist.
Amazing interpretation... And a unique viola sound!😍
Greatest violist who ever lived.
He is still living
he's not dead unlike you
Just joking
Aesthetic level : I burst out tears.
L' élégance et sérénité à Schubert. Remarcable.
Выдающиеся музыканты, замечательное исполнение, изумительное звучание скрипки!
это альт.
The greatest viola player!
Vivat and Cheers for both Maestro Zukerman and Neikrug !
MOLTO espressivo, BRAVO!!!
Inarrivabile. Il migliore
Нет слов ,прекраснейшее прочтение ,альт звучит превосходно..и очень необычные штрихи как в оригинале в 3 части ,обычно играют все не так,но это прекрасно ,так больше походит на Шуберта .Я в восторге !!!Супер
Es ist einfach fabelhaft..
Perfection!
And Pinky gives us an earful without lashing his body around the stage like Joshua Bell!
what are you talking about Elizabeth Monacelli, MR ZUKERMAN IS BETTER I MEAN BETTER THAN JOSHUA BELL bell is nothing compared to Mr pinky
nirmala ganesh Exactly! That’s what I wrote in my comment
nirmala ganesh I hate the way Joshua moves around so much and he still doesn’t say much.
@@orchepiaviolinviola The ol' American "must-put-on-a-good-show" / cheerleader style playing of violin.
Hilary Hahn used to bop around quite a bit too when she was younger (and still does the occasional strange torso movement). It is annoying to me. More so with Bell. So much more....
The one thing that bugs me is the unnecessary bending/crouching at the knees to exaggerate notes.
Are the violinists not aware that you can achieve the desired sound without doing that ridiculous move? Hahah.
@@liamnevilleviolist1809 i don’t think they do that purposefully. When you’re completely immersed in your music, you do not take the time to think about how to move your body- the music pulls your body with you. Yes, some people can play completely fine without moving their bodies, but others find musical expression in swaying to the music, or bending their knees.
Excessive moving that interferes with the music IS bad, but other types of moving only helps bring out the music. Music is a PERFORMING art, which means that there is also a visual element to it.
Very beatiful.Amazing performance.
just amazing !!!
I'm a violist and Pinky is my gold standard-- who I'm always trying to sound like. There ain't nothin' like his viola playing.
hey, i dont know about the viola, other than of course what i hear in quartets. i also very much like his playing...what is it that you like it...as a violinist i love his warmth and expression, and spirit, but i could not say anything technically.....(i am a pianist). thanks!
De los últimos músicos con personalidad propia y reconocibles con los ojos cerrados. ¡Bravo!
When I was younger (and this video was available to watch, uploaded by someone else) I was annoyed that Zukerman played many passages down the octave...because my teacher at the time [and I was about 14 years old] said I had to play up the octave wherever possible.
I said "Zukerman choose the lower octave" and my teacher said "well... you're not Zukerman, you don't get to call the shots". Fair point.
After all these years though, I have this to say:
instrumentluckyrenditions available to watch on RUclips.
Long story short, I like Zukerman's choices! His tone blends well with Neikrug!
I love this so much.
The best Schubert Arpeggione recorded ever.....
🎉фантастично изпълнение!❤❤
BRAVO!!!
38 years ago... Wow
The second movement😍😍😍🤧😢
AMAZING!
Simply exquisite. My second-favourite version of the D821. Favourite is Perényi (cello) and Schiff (piano)!
Очень красивый
Meaning of perfection !!🤍
Amazing. Like a private lesson. Of course it is a slavish copying job I am doing and minus the personal “how to do it” but what a place to start in building an interpretation! So far beyond the International/Katims edition.
Лучший альт!
Interesting that he uses a fine tuner on the C string
I'm not really sure why he has it, but in my experience the C string is slightly harder to tune with just the pegs.
@@iambw_rblx7145 it has to do with the string length and the way the string resonates, on some violas it helps to put on a fine tuner.
The viola may have a wolf tone high on the C string. A fine tuner may lessen the problem. I did that with my first good viola.
Great video really! Thanks to those that put this amazing performance here: The title could include the key, which is A minor (The "D.821" is about the catalogue that Deutsch did about Shubert work)...Interesting approach to the third movement that everyone play it a bit more roughly: Love it!
Gracious!!! Epiphany
Not me wondering how I am possibly supposed to play this piece knowing I cannot hope to live up stunning example set forth by this performance.
0:55
Thanks
Lovely. With the benefit of the record engineer that Bruno Giuranna had for this piece, i twould have been sensational. He has a similar bowing technique in some ways to Perlman. Perhaps this is Ivan Galamian's influence.
My teacher teased me with this piece a while ago but I have yet to actually play it 😭 but oh well, I’m fine with playing Bach for now.
I’m playing it now 👀👀👀
@@mrswag535 nice :D
I am playing this piece as well as Bach. I love both. 🙂
BRAVI !!! Super !!!
bravo
The master.
Превосходно....
I wish my open strings sounded like that !!
I'm just learning about Franz schubert
Gorgeous! Everything the viola should be.
almeronfilms offenbach
Lillian Fuchs
Does anyone have sheet music for this version? Please 😩❤️
Это оригинальные штрихи ,как и напечатаны
It could be the Edition Peters version.
The Goat
Eccellente !!!!!❤
Do you know which chinrest Pinchas Zukermann uses?
Doesn’t look like he’s using one in this particular performance
This is my favorite performance of Schubert's Arpeggione Sonata. I also like the sonata on the cello and bass. My least favorite instrument is the arpeggione as there is an edge to the sound.
Agreed
❤❤❤
Where all the Zukerman/Neikrug performances were filmed? Thank you!
I love them! Neikrug is a wonderful musician quite underrated, in my opinion. There used to be a video of theirs playing Schumann's Märchenbilder, and it was fantastic. I wonder how can I find it.
As beautiful as this performance is, try listening to the same piece played on oboe and piano, with the wonderful Alex Klein on oboe. I'm partial, as an oboist, but I think hearing this same piece on oboe and piano may even be more beautiful. It's on a CD titled "The Greatest Works Shubert (N)ever Wrote for the Oboe". Klein, former principal of the Chicago Symphony, uses a special extended range oboe to cover all the notes. Incidentally, this piece was originally written for what Schubert called an "arpeggione", which was invented around 1823 and whose maker called it a "guitarre d'amour". It looked like a guitar and had the same tuning of its six strings, but the strings ran over an arched bridge, like that of a cello. This piece is apparently the only significant one ever written for the arpeggione.
I am an oboist too, but still think the version for cello and piano is most likely to be closest to the original. There is a great version in RUclips with M. Rostropovich and B. Britten that is hard to beat! Cf. ruclips.net/video/aPLOfZW5VwE/видео.html
How do you do pizzicato on an oboe? I:) started to learn oboe but my instrument was ruined by a "repairman".
Wow, I cannot imagine this on oboe, nor would I want to. This is very much a string piece. I guess since I'm a violist, I am partial to it on the viola. I can tolerate it on the 'cello. But a woodwind instrument? For me, no way. P.S. Nothing against the oboe. It's nice for woodwind repertoire.
@@Old1bear Hi Philippe. The cello/piano version is indeed beautiful (how could it not be with Rostropovich and Benjamin Britten himself at the piano?), but it's also very different. For pure sound, I still like the oboe version better (that's why I took up the instrument in the first place). I think it goes to prove how wonderful a piece Schubert wrote, that on any instrument that plays it, it sounds beautiful. That's the real magic here.
@@iCyclone Hi Cyclone. I completely understand your partiality to the viola since that's what you play. I also assume you've heard the oboe version. If not, check it out: ruclips.net/video/uAwpLp9voio/видео.html. You write you can "tolerate" it on the cello and the oboe, "no way". I think you're showing quite a bit of snobbishness. As I mentioned in a different reply, it's the piece by Schubert that is the magic here. Each instrument, played beautifully, displays that magic. I hope you can come to appreciate that .
Fine chocolate 🍫 and wine sound.
1:21~ 3:47
1:18
10:16
19:11
Marvelous. I wouldn't mind if the piano was louder.
whys his violin so big
Его инструмент называется альт. Альт больше скрипки, но намного меньше виолончели.
does anyone know why fine tuner on the C string?
Titanium string maybe.
I read another comment and apparently it’s because of the string length and how the string resonates and on some violas it would work better than using only pegs but Idk for me the C-string is harder to tune with pegs than other strings so it might just be because it’s easier to tune 🤷♀️
It sounds very nice on the viola! Finally, a performer who gets closer to the right tempo of the first movement. Did Zukerman go off-tune in the first movement? Feuermann is still unrivaled at playing this piece.
Such a tame performance
What a viola sound! Too bad this it not a viola piece...
I don't mean any offense and disrespect to the legend Zuckermann but I prefer this piece in a dark tone and thick sound. Like Richard O' Neil played in NYCP. I feel that's how this ought to be played. (Just a thought) 🙂 But the rubato and slides of Mr. Pinky are beautiful. And thanks a lot for this video. 🙂
I'm not sure I understand this comment, since Zukerman has maybe the darkest, fullest, thickest tone of any violist-- that's actually his trademark-- what makes his playing unique. I like O'Neill's performance, but this totally blows O'Neill's out of the water-- and, again, the sound here is much darker.
No comparison, Pinky is just on a completely different level in terms of intimacy, tone, colours, sound quality and phrasing. No offence to Richard O’Neil, but ...
Come on Pinchy. Please don't ever tune your viola like that. It destroyed the mood.
The piano sound is too agressive and heavy especially for this heavenly piece.
what happened to this man ? why did he end up as a teacher somewhere.
What are you talking about he's a super successful soloist and conductor
the racist
The piano can't be racist because it has black and white keys so must be a racist viola
TOO FAST FOR MY LOOK,TOO MUCH MOTION.
Gregory Gluck I don't agree, this is popular and fresh music in its forgotten origins.
0:55
❤❤
1:00