M3 Pro vs AMD Ryzen - Blender Tests

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 янв 2025

Комментарии • 20

  • @SquareOFortune
    @SquareOFortune Год назад +3

    What was the status of Low Power Mode on the M3? "Always," "Never," or "Only on Battery?" If it was on, I'd be interested in if the results are any different with it set to "Never" (although I know Blender's ray tracing hasn't yet had time to fully optimize around the new M3 RT architecture).

    • @BlendlogicTech
      @BlendlogicTech  Год назад +1

      I dont know to be honest - never checked setting - whatever default is - I would assume it was Never?

    • @buns_o_steel
      @buns_o_steel Год назад

      There's also a Performance mode that you can turn on for the Macbook. I wonder what the performance difference is like with that turned on.

  • @mongkolchaik5865
    @mongkolchaik5865 11 месяцев назад +1

    Good comparison! Thank you!

  • @az9az9az9
    @az9az9az9 Год назад +3

    The HIP and OpenCL renders don't work because AMD has not released ROCm for ZEN4 RDNA3 APU'S that were released 11 months ago.

    • @BlendlogicTech
      @BlendlogicTech  Год назад

      oh didnt know that - thought it was just the memory limit

    • @az9az9az9
      @az9az9az9 Год назад

      @@BlendlogicTech My Legion slim 5 is limited to 4GB from Bios, but i read it's adjusted automatically beyond that from system RAM, i expect all 96GB to be usable for iGPU that i have installed.

  • @klkhenma22
    @klkhenma22 Год назад +6

    I think that is not correct using both Render devices on any one of these machines.. my m3 pro runs way better when i only choose the first option...

    • @BlendlogicTech
      @BlendlogicTech  Год назад +2

      That’s correct the GPU option is faster - but AMD can’t run it so I do a CPU vs CPU test

    • @Shura859
      @Shura859 Год назад +5

      This is a Cpu comparison. My rtx 3090 "runs way better when I choose the first option..." too.

    • @BlendlogicTech
      @BlendlogicTech  Год назад +1

      @@Shura859Correct - someone posted APU GPU mode doesnt work with blender cuz AMD hasn't relased drivers - I had not done prior research and just noticed when I choose 780m it says canont run - thus the CPU to CPU comparison -- but I did show/talk about M3 Pro GPU and RT performance

  • @gregvisualfx
    @gregvisualfx Год назад +4

    yeah man for real, My rtx2070 does this scene in 25sec so non of these are of any utility. Even M3 Max with 40cores, seems it's about (maybe) as fast as rtx3070/3080 (desktop) and that's a laptop for 4K$+ wthout taxes. Truth is still - If you're a 3d artist that does some amount of 3d rendering, get an Nvidia, preferebly desktop. no alternative at the moment if you want performance.

    • @BlendlogicTech
      @BlendlogicTech  Год назад +2

      I've came to that idea/conclusion - but on reddit ppl downvote me - I dont do this work I just somehow got youtube algo to get people to watch video adn its not hard to make these video so I do them.
      But Like - I just play dota /league - and Dota 2 does not run 100% as windows - so yea even gaming aint good. Its honestly just really good for video editing in the encoders and browsing/etams etc - Teams/Zoom runs 0 0lag so yea

  • @deepwavez
    @deepwavez Год назад +4

    Its probably minutes and not hours for this cpu render, my very old laptop renders in about 1h35 on cpu.
    (Close to 100 times slower than the new metal RT render ! ha ha )
    Maybe blender uses only the performance cores on the Mac, or maybe this is one of the cases where hyper threading is effective. For other tasks, you may get different results.
    Also don't under estimate single core speed. There are many tasks that aren't multi threaded.
    Anyways, there will always be a faster computer, buying just to have bigger numbers will make you regret in a few month when the new ones come out.
    That Mac that you have looks like a good compromise between power and efficiency.. and has a nice screen too.

    • @BlendlogicTech
      @BlendlogicTech  Год назад

      Oh wow lol your right haha I've tested this before but always with GPU - went back to the tape and my previous videos and it is indeed MM:SS:millisecond (how do you show ms in short hand besides ms? is it :ms,ms lol)

  • @NexusGuru
    @NexusGuru 9 месяцев назад +1

    You said you got the m3 for 899?

    • @BlendlogicTech
      @BlendlogicTech  9 месяцев назад +1

      1899 sorry if I misspoke

    • @hsssbjejew764
      @hsssbjejew764 5 месяцев назад

      that makes more sense XD ​@@BlendlogicTech