@@Gnybr based on points is it? Or is it your opinion that Phil barely beat Jay due to the physiques. Points have always been bs for several reasons, there's only so many ways the points can break down and they always favour the champ and their own bs it's quite evident some years they've made up their mind and then assign the points accordingly even on years when they make the right decision in the end.
This was closer than I thought, but it was still a stomp for Phil. This is definitely one of the best physiques ever brought to the stage in the 'post phil' era of bodybuilding we are in now though, from Hadi. Its insane how I still say 'wow' anytime I see a 2011 Phil comparison though, even though I've seen that versions hundreds of times already its just that damn impressive.
While I do think Phil in 11 was his best version, I'd give anything to see them on stage next to each other. I think the video or in person may be closer than the pictures show. But I do think Phil would still take ot
They were on the same stge in 2020 Olympia and Hadi dominate but the judges rewarded Phil cause he was 7 times M.Olympia. I've just see the video and hadi was very sharp in the evening, no way Phil could beat him.
@@ytsux9259 he looks good in the arms. They are lacking in size but the separation and condition look great. The only thing I see if the possibility of syntol but thats just speculation
Phil all the way for me. Impossible for me to overlook just how much bigger and thicker his arms are. I have Phil winning every shot except the back lat spread (draw) and abs and thigh (hadi wins this one pretty dominantly) Hadi is great, but for my money Phil's 2011 physique is among the 5 greatest physiques ever brought to the stage
Hadi’s feathering isn’t as prominent or isn’t prominent enough to mention. If it were to look like a flex wheeler or Andrew jacked quad then sure, however it’s barely noticeable in comparison to those two.
Phil all the way him in 2011 is nearly untouchable
I mean he barely beat an old-off Jay Cutler lol
@@Gnybr based on points is it? Or is it your opinion that Phil barely beat Jay due to the physiques. Points have always been bs for several reasons, there's only so many ways the points can break down and they always favour the champ and their own bs it's quite evident some years they've made up their mind and then assign the points accordingly even on years when they make the right decision in the end.
If Hadi had Phil Heaths or Kevin Levrones like triceps from the side, his side triceps would be litellary perfect
Also some good needed forearms
Except being 5'5" (no, he ain't 5'7"). 🙄
Wow! Here we are over a decade later and phil still smokes everyone. And I'm a Hadi fan too. Great video!!!!!
Hadi's arms really hold him back. Unfortunately there is nothing he can do about it cause of genetics
This was closer than I thought, but it was still a stomp for Phil. This is definitely one of the best physiques ever brought to the stage in the 'post phil' era of bodybuilding we are in now though, from Hadi.
Its insane how I still say 'wow' anytime I see a 2011 Phil comparison though, even though I've seen that versions hundreds of times already its just that damn impressive.
Great video!
FDB - Phil
FLS - Haadi
BDB - Phil
BLS - Haadi
SC - Phil
ST - Phil (side by side)
AT - Haadi
MM - Phil
I think this is dependent on which mm you use. The hands clasped is hadi all day, he's so striated. But crab is phils
Hadi's arms are so stringy and look half the size of Phil's. Look at the mm pose!
Yeah he could definitely use with some more tricep thickness and forearm/brachiallis development
i feel like hadi's triceps being so short really hold is most muscular back, really minimize the size of his arms from the outside
Lighting on Phil is wayyyy better why can't they showpiece these athletes today like this
Hadi really needs to bring up his forearms and calves, putting him next to Phil really shows how lacking he is in those areas
Hadi is an amazing bodybuilder, but Phil is simply unbeatable except for big Ron
I am a huge fan of Phil heath ❤
While I do think Phil in 11 was his best version, I'd give anything to see them on stage next to each other. I think the video or in person may be closer than the pictures show. But I do think Phil would still take ot
They were on the same stge in 2020 Olympia and Hadi dominate but the judges rewarded Phil cause he was 7 times M.Olympia. I've just see the video and hadi was very sharp in the evening, no way Phil could beat him.
@vivificateurveridique1420 I agree. I think hadi should be a 3 time Mr o winner.
This video just shows how close hadi is getting to be one of the best. People don't wanna acknowledge that but he's getting real close
His arms are some of the worst. Just look at the MM pose!
@@ytsux9259 he looks good in the arms. They are lacking in size but the separation and condition look great. The only thing I see if the possibility of syntol but thats just speculation
@@ytsux9259 Dexter won the olympia with no calves.
Phil all the way for me. Impossible for me to overlook just how much bigger and thicker his arms are. I have Phil winning every shot except the back lat spread (draw) and abs and thigh (hadi wins this one pretty dominantly)
Hadi is great, but for my money Phil's 2011 physique is among the 5 greatest physiques ever brought to the stage
Totally agree, for sure top 5 of all time. I’d say that 2013 was his best objectively (from judge perspective) however I like 2011’s lines and dryness
Look at Phil's mm crab pose. Incredible!!!
Nobody is touching Phil
JFC, Phil's quads don't have Hadi's feathering - how can you overlook that.
Hadi’s feathering isn’t as prominent or isn’t prominent enough to mention. If it were to look like a flex wheeler or Andrew jacked quad then sure, however it’s barely noticeable in comparison to those two.
Prime phil is only beatable by ronnie or dorian. Nobody else come close
Dorian isn't even close.
Only Coleman
@@jeffreyblakley3026 Yep, Phil would beat prime Dorian too.
I give phil 100% in all shots here as phil was on top form this year
Phil has better lines, shape, structure, and physique. I will give it to Phil all day, month, and year
How can Phill win the front lat spread.
Better everywhere but width. Undeniably in the muscularity
It's close. Hadi does have the structure tho, but Phil has superior muscle quality. Look at Hadi's arms in that pose (they look just wrong).
It’s a man vs a boy
sure Hadi is the man and Phil is the boy. You're right!
@@vivificateurveridique1420 hadi is a kindergartener compared to phil what drugs are you on?