Wacom Cintiq Pro vs iPad Pro | Which Is Best For ARTISTS And ANIMATORS?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
- In this video, I make an in-depth comparison regarding two very useful and powerful devices: Wacom Cintiq Pro vs iPad Pro. Which is best for artists and animators? Well, hopefully this video will help you decide on which drawing device is best for you and your needs. Enjoy!
Twitch: / techsummit
Instagram: / techsummit.tv
Twitter: / techsummittv
Reviews:
- iPad Pro Review: • The iPad Pro Review | ...
- Wacom Cintiq Review: • Wacom Cintiq Pro 13 Re...
- Huion KAMVAS 13 Review: • Huion KAMVAS 13 Review...
Affiliate Links:
- iPad Pro: amzn.to/34o42Jk
- Apple Pencil: amzn.to/2XpYQDs
- Wacom Cintiq Pro 13: amzn.to/2JPEwmO
- Buy Now, Pay Later with Abunda:
- iPad Pro: www.shopabunda...
- Apple Pencil: www.shopabunda...
- Wacom Cintiq Pro 13: www.shopabunda...
For other purchase alternatives, try LUSTRE:
- my.lustre.ai/8...
Subscribe for more content!
Were you left with any questions? Make sure to ask anything in the comments!
----------------------------------
*GEAR I USE*
_____________________
- Sony A6400: amzn.to/338Attk
- Panasonic G7: amzn.to/339qwMw
- Panasonic LX10: amzn.to/359T4qR
- Panasonic G 14mm Lens: amzn.to/2VmPRzF
- TASCAM DR-40: amzn.to/339qQuI
- Rode VideoMicro: amzn.to/2MkKdKi
- Rode SmartLav +: amzn.to/31NBSp0
- BONFOTO Tripod: amzn.to/30OgCOv
- JOBY Gorilla Pod: amzn.to/2oiDhW8
-------------------------------------------------
*MY EDITING PC SET UP*
______________________________
- Cooler Master MasterBox Pro 5: amzn.to/2APKNuq
- Gigabyte Z370 Aorus Gaming 5: amzn.to/31RfxXv
- Intel Core i7-9700K: amzn.to/2ANPeFT
- Gigabyte RTX2080 Windforce: amzn.to/2LTc316
- EVGA Supernova 850: amzn.to/2AMjG3p
- Patriot Extreme 32GB DDR4 Kit: amzn.to/2AQWhxq
- Gigabyte Aorus Air Cooler: amzn.to/2nlj6Gw
4TB HHD: amzn.to/2oYINNu
120GB SSD: amzn.to/337u2GX
Razer Blade 14 (2015): amzn.to/2MkS6iS
"When doing professional work-" cut to Dragonball fan art.
You may want to attend to the issue of the sounds playing in the background as your doing the review.
Thanks for the info! I’m buying the Cintiq pro 24” next week and I’ll use your link. Also, that Taylor Brusky guy blows. Ignore him, you did fantastic. My son has a slight stutter but he pushes himself to do public speaking. You rock and so does your confidence!
Digital artists:Wacom vs IPad
Traditional artists: 👁 👄 👁
Faber castle pencils vs regular ones 😂
@@houdhoudbrando9628 ohuhu markers vs copic markers
@@houdhoudbrando9628 staedtler anytime
Dude u gotta check for the background noise before u upload... Its very distracting.. But good explanation
Ive owned both, and cant even decide.
Same
Me too. But, I go with ipad more because of the portability!
I have tried both and the iPad Pro wins because it is tailored around it's size. The pen has much less latency, touch panning and zooming is smooth as butter, and the app-interfaces are minimalistic, giving you more screen space. The accessory stand called Sketchboard pro gives you borders around the tablet for your hands to rest on and is a must for artists. The aspect ratio is 4:3 so both portrait and landscape setups feel natural.
The Cintiq Pro has no business being only 16 inches. The aspect ratio of Cintiqs is 16:9 which makes them very wide, but it lacks top room. This is very inconvenient for artists that draw more vertically, like figure drawing, character design and such. Turning it into portrait position is a pain due to the cables and you don't get any space for your hand anymore. Then adding the pen latency and janky touch controls, it's not a very fun drawing experience.
In short: Ipad feels more artist-oriented, where as the Cintiq is more for digital work stuff. You certainly can do good art on it but it's not fun. If I had to choose between Cintiq Pro 24 and a 16 inch iPad Pro, I'd go with the iPad in a heartbeat. Sadly a 16 inch iPad doesn't exist yet.
What a ridiculous review. No professional artist worth their salt would pick an iPad pro over a Cintiq Pro. Cintiq and Photoshop are industry standard tools and this is not up for debate. You can use what you want but don't make up things that are simply not true.
@@matthewphillips5483 plenty of professionals use an iPad for their work though. If we're comparing a 24 inch Wacom with an iPad then the Wacom wins by a landslide, but I maintain that a 16 inch pen monitor is a really awkward size for pro work. Menus clutter up the screen fast and there's not much room for your hand to rest, so it also takes up space. I have an iPad pro with the sketchboard pro accessory, that allows me to rest my hand outside of the screen, also the pen has less latency and touch navigation is smoother than on a Cintiq Pro. Speaking more charitably, it's a matter of preference, but yeah iPad pro does win in certain aspects
This latency is due to the streamline feature in procreate.I have seen a lot of these vids , there is noticeably greater lag in drawing tablets that are attached to pc then the Ipad. This is due to the drawing tablets being connected as a display and not being the computer themselves.
For a split second it said media offline.
You forgot to mention about budget, Cintig pro is double the price and if you want the same smooth experience like on iPad pro, you need to invest a VERY powerful computer/laptop (at least has 32gb Ram) which is more money than the Cintig itself...so, you'll need 4x to 6x budget than the iPad on its own...
This is such a critical point that should be highlighted, I never knew that part about integrating the Wacom with a PC requiring such high-end specs.
@@Waternar It's not wacom fault, software on PC required much more power to run smoothly, It's x86 architecture, and Ipad is run on ARM architecture. In some scenario, x86 can work with much complex data file, but now, with new 5nm arm architecture like M1 these gaps between x86 and arm are reduce to 0! Then if there are better apps for the job on iPadOS, you rather using ipad than a wacom, It's more power efficient and compact (but most powerful softwares are still have solution only on PC) so, it's depends, If you are graphic Designers, content creators, iPad is a better choice, but if you are 3D artist or architect or professional film editors, you are still stuck with PC
@@NhiepKen I see. Thanks for the detailed explanation. I would definitely have to go for iPad then. Now I'm not sure if the iPad Pro version would necessary. Do you know by any chance if a regular old iPad 4th generation can decently use the ProCreate app, hopefully as well as a modern iPad? I'm looking into ordering a stylus pen (same shown in this video) to test it on my old iPad.
It would be appreciated if you can let me know any experiences you may have.
@@NhiepKen These are some aspects that matter to me in this order: Latency, colors, compatibility with other apps like photoshop, etc.
@@Waternar you better not pick too old device like ipad 4th gen, because It'll not be supported by Apple any longer, and hot app like ProCreate they have their updates to match the power of new Apple silicon. You should pick at least iPad Air 3 or later, because it has laminated screen (and it's better for drawing, color accurate), more RAM (more layers to work with), and better Pen latency. IPad 4th gen has quite old CPU and GPU so if Apple stop supported u'll have to work with old app or no app at all. Another choice is iPad 7th gen (you can easily got 1 around $200 on ebay! Pencil is the best choice (got pressure sensor) or you can find Gojoodoq pen's around $10-15 with tilt sensor (no pressure) good for writing and sketching with no pen pressure requirement.
The cintiq pro comes with a express remote which can be used as buttons, just letting you know
It’s an interesting comparison especially if you keep in mind how can literally buy 2 current gen iPad Pros at the price of one Cintiq Pro
yeah,..maybe you can glue them together to try and match the size and working space of the Cintiq.
cintiq pro 16 is less money than a ipad pro 12.9 ;)
@@nunomota9838 no It’s not the 4K Cintiq 16 is like $1500 the iPad Pro is $1099
How does the iPad Pro compare to the Kamvas 13 ?
"full desktop apps"?
Sidecar: Am I joke to you?
What software do you use with the Wacom for sketching and animating as seen in your video? Love it by the way!
What about using the Wacom Cintiq Pro 24 with a MacBook Air M1? Will the new M1 be able to support it and run smoothly?
Thank you for your honesty. Many websites are designed to push their customers to buy an iPad pro without commenting on the intricate and technological differences. Just a note about the background music: the vocals distract from what you are saying.
At the time of this video they still had clip studio for iPad which is a complete port of the desktop software to the iPad and you can animate and draw with. Also my cintiq pro does have 4K and i only need to use the usb c cable. And tbh I think it might just be me but it feels more fluid drawing on the iPad Pro and feels more like an actual pencil compared to the Wacom pen, but the only problem I have for me personally is that the iPad pencil has a rounded tip instead of a fine tip so it kinda feels like I’m using a unsharpened pencil but other than that both are really great and I would suggest the iPad if you want something portable without the need of a laptop or pc and just something you can sketch on. And like I said if you need it for animation you can use clip studio however the downside is that it’s a monthly subscription for the iPad version. The pc version is just a one time payment and they usually have sales.
bruh you got linus tech tips in the background
What if we use ipad with our mac through side car feature?
Why did “Media Offline” flash on the screen?
using apple pencil with 'streamline' option ON does not mean that you should use it rather for writing... if you play a little with apps and settings you find that ipad is superior in pencil accuracy, controllability. also ipad's monitor shows a lot of detail in dark colours which you are not able to see on cintiq and it's a sad thing from wacom's side.
I'm honestly so confused... What software is the best for the Cintiq? Everyone seems to have the same thing so I'm not sure if its programmed in the Cintiq or if it is an app...? If so, are these apps free?
The Cintiq is just a monitor that you can use a stylus with. It's not a standalone device like the iPad. So you have to connect it to a computer for it work and it behaves as a second monitor. Then you can use whatever drawing software you want whether you're on MacOS or Windows.
@@TechSummitTV ooohhh ok thanks!
Great video, I am the biggest latency stickler ever. I came with a question and am leaving with an answer. This was very helpful 🤘🏻
What’s all the noise on the b roll shots. It’s so hard to listen to
Jesus, I watch my videos on 1.75 or 2.00 speed and it makes me realize how slow humans speak or maybe it's just my brain. Anyhow, cool video!
What about the ram on the iPad? How many layers can you get? Thanks for the review 🙃
This particular model has 4GB of RAM. As for how many layers, I don't know - but you'll really have to push this iPad hard for it to give you any troubles.
The review is good ! :D some have diff opinions! But great video!
Thank you!!
Three Questions: 1. If your hand touch the screen while drawing, does it move the screen? It seems its not true for Wacom.
2. Does any of those come with related SW? if yes, which SW (App)?
3. What is the best SW (App) to start working with?
Subliminal message at the 1:59 mark? 🤔
The music and sounds in the background are so distracting unfortunately.
Thank you, I have been going back and forth all day and this really helped.
What is that quick flash at 1:59? "Media Offline"
Hello ! I love your help and advice, thanks ! I use Painter on iPad Pro, but I would like to have your recommandation for a 3d application for iPad Pro, I wand to create landscape ( like Bryce use to make on Mac ) or body ( like Poser use to make on Mac ) Any suggestion for SIMPLE 3d applications for iPad Pro ? Thanks a lot
Shapr3D Great app for 2D and 3D modelling, but It's a bit pricey :D
I wish you also compared iPad with paperlike.
It's been suggested to me before. I might have to check it out.
do you charge any of their pens?
Can we use tvpaint of mac or Windows in ipad? Via usb or wireless? How is its response
How about an iPad + Pc using Astropad???
Finally :D great video btw
Thank you! Haha, it did take a while to make.
I wish the iPad Pro had stuff like Sony Vegas Pro, or Toonboom Harmony :(
Buy the new iPad Pro with the pro pencil, you’ll change your mind on the Wacom
I would have preferred not to hear the vocal soundtrack in the background. Being an OG, too much sensory input overloads my circuits and it was challenging to concentrate on the star's speech.
Ipad pro or cintiq?!
_Me: Ipad pro 11 2020 with easy canvas pro...._
Very helpful video
FFXIV nice :-D can’t wait for the 5.3 finally be out soon!
Does it need a computer
Dude, awesome video! Very nice production quality. The only thing you need to work a little on is the cuts - they could be a little sharper. Still, really great job.
Perbedaan wacom cintiq pro dan venus apa yah
Heh, you lost me when claiming the Cintiq is more color accurate and when downplaying the difference in latency.
The Ipad Pro humiliates the Cintiq in terms of both color accuracy and latency. Ipad Pro displays are exceptionally good and well calibrated, with little difference between units, and somehow they even manage to hold that quality for a long time. As for latency, Wacom's latency is very noticeable whereas you'd have to look hard for it on an Ipad Pro.
In regards to the pens/pencils I think Wacom's pen to be comparable to a thin lead mechanical pencil, that wears unevenly and gets scratchy. Wears down both the surface and nib, and feels a bit nasty at times. Apple pencil is more like a fine art pencil, where you can also use the side of the lead to draw with. The tip is a little blunt though, but easy to get used to.
Exactly man. I was wondering what was he having for the review.
Idk what youre talking about tbh. I have used both and the difference in color accuracy is not true. The wacom is 99 percent accurate RGB. The ipad is 104 percent sRGB which is a more narrow range. So, technically speaking, the wacom has more accurate colors and a wider range. Just blatant lies there. As for the latency i also have absolutely no clue what youre talking about. In terms of latency they are indistinguishable. In terms of the pen - the nibs wear down and need to be replaced. This is by design and not an issue. It doesnt pose a problem or cause any scratching unless you neglect to replace them. This also allows to choose between different nibs to produce a different feel depending on preference. theyre both great, its just preference. Neither is worse than the other in terms of anything mentioned though.
@@jackwinterson9801 The Cintiq Pro has 90% coverage of AdobeRGB (94% area). The Ipad Pro has ~98% Image P3 coverage. Gamut, however, is not accuracy - it's a measure of volume. A 90% coverage of a given color space is not very good to work with, as there'll be a lot of colors in that space that you cannot see.
In terms of accuracy the Cintiq Pro looks OK but is really not accurate enough for critical work. The Ipad Pro, however, is. In fact, whatever algorithm Apple uses to match colors according to ambient light is so darn good you're most likely better off not even profiling it.
For the record, I have owned and measured both devices. The Cintiq is not even close to the Ipad Pro's display quality. The display on the Cintiq is fairly mediocre but decently calibrated, whereas the Ipad Pro's display is stellar.
The Cintiq Pro in particular has fairly high latency. It's higher than on the regular Cintiq, and the regular Cintiq has noticeable latency. The Ipad Pro does not have noticeable latency.
Uneven nib wear is not a feature, it's a bug. The nibs get scratchy real fast so you have to either constantly rotate the pen or file it down (and I have a light touch). It's got nothing to do with the nibs needing to be replaced - it happens within an hour with a new nib.
I'm trying my best to get into this video but there are a few issues. clips still having sound on & background music is too loud
Dude… the tv or whatever it is you got going in the background of the video is very distracting. Not trying to give you a hard time but voice over another voice can be pretty convoluting.
Hey , I just thought of starting graphics animations and Im a beginner . I was wondering what would be a really great and ideal device to start with ? I do have the 13” MacBook Pro 2019 as well
I'd get the Huion KAMVAS 13, actually. I made a review on it if you want more details.
Tech Summit Tech Summit thanks !! Sure , can I get the link to it ? And If I was to go a step higher what would you recommend?
@@peteranderson4251 ruclips.net/video/rCcZHaxWIfU/видео.html
And if I were to go a step above, I'd go for the Wacom Cintiq 16
Does the Wacom need to be connected to the computer and which software work with? I think iPad being all integrated is good. Depends what level. I’m saving for the iPad, probably be good enough for what I’d use it for.
I believe you need pc or laptop for any drawing tablets . That’s why I believe in my case I pad is the best option. It is portable , multifunction, and reliable .
@@ttalah2964 I agree ☺️
Thanks
i tried the surfacebook and the wacom 27 for drawing... both are not soo good for me... i will try the ipad next lol... the surfacebook was basically ok but the touch is kind of laggy and the parallaax of the pen is horrible also im so used to a fast desktop computer the i7 + 16 gb version felt very slow... the wacom is very nice but its too big for me i only want one big 4k screen... i mostly do vektor stuff with the mouse so im glad when there is no big screen on my desk ... i only draw 1-2 times a week... mostly when i want to draw im sitting on the couch.. i think the ipad should solve most of my problems lol im excited to see how it works out as a drawing tablet.. i saw a few clips with this dual app where u basically use it with remote control
@@elliott7070 i waited for the new one LOL i plan on getting one in the next 1-2 month if everyting works out
I would love to start this and am so confused what to buy since I am way out of my element. I do not own a computer, would I also need to have a computer in order to have an ipad or wacom?
You only need a computer to use the Wacom. You don't need one for the iPad - this is it's own device.
@@TechSummitTV of course the one I liked more I have to purchase more lol. Thank you for the quick response!
Nice job
Great ! As usual !
And thank you! (as usual)
Tech Summit ❤️❤️
Can you mix down the music in your video, it is such a noisance... (especially when rap lyrics kick in)
It should be *back*ground music, here it just feels like you're in a room with too noisy a radio next to you... :-(
Thanks for the comparison. For us it was more iPad Pro vs Cintiq 16, but the requirements of the Cintiq just make it that bit less useful for mobility. BTW, please, please can you have less backround noise and music, it's very distracting and hard for many to listen too clearly. It seems to be compulsory to drown out videos with stuff these days, but really, people appreciate clarity and simplicity when trying to get informative reviews, not going to the cinema!
Can we use grafic Teblet without laptop 🤷🏻♂️cause i've seen every one get laptop attached with it...if not then ipad might be better option Cause with grafic teb you'll have to buy laptop and always need it!
You need a computer to use the Cintiq. But the iPad Pro operates on its own.
is that the 13" Wacom in this video
Sorry man I couldn't watch beyond half way. The music was too distracting and jump cuts were too hard to watch.
Breathe dude, just breathe.
ipad pro still wins the color accuracy since it's use P3, which most of professional use on their macbook and imac.
also the cintiq is using matte etched glass, which reduce even more color accuracy.
cintiq pro 13 lose in so many ways, why are you so biased?
cintiq pro wins a bit with pro 16 since it's 4k,. but if you compare to 12.9 3k display, then cintiq lose again. since 12.9 is cheaper.
cintiq even more lose if you pair ipad with sidecar with macbook pro and use desktop apps.
how many decades do you think they perfected cintiq? and apple just release apple for ipad and kill cintiq companion :/
sorry to say but cintiq is a loser compare to ipad.
Pros use Cintiq and Photoshop, not iPad Pro and Procreate. Nuff said.
work on your audio quality. otherwise great vid
Which is cheaper?
Wacom!
@@shaibungcs not if you include the pc
6:30 what is that app
There are a lot of apps being shown at that moment. Which one are you referring to?
Tech Summit would you mind telling all of them pleasee? Specially the 6:30
Tech Summit i am looking for the apps that can make anime
@@nomi7649 Oh, that would be Procreate.
Tech Summit so what about the others
Honestly the wacom is just slightly better as far as drawing on screen but wacom makes shitty overpriced crap after the 21ux and 22hd. The charging ports is always going bad and that has been a problem for a while so they just don't care. I would just get a intuos and a ipad pro and save the money. The wacom is wonderful if and when it works, but the ipad is far more reliable and portable.
Wacom is not "shitty and overpriced." They are the gold standard.
@@matthewphillips5483 Yes they are. I use and sell them. When they work nothing is better but they don't work as they once did so maybe the product when its working isn't shitty but the build quality sure is and the customer service sucks. They just don't make quality anymore as far as items that should last for artist forking over shit loads of money when other companies are getting 95% there for way less.
MEDIA OFFLINE !
I caught this at 1:58 too. I was like? Is that Tyler Durden or something? Better replay that to see what subliminals are being pushed here...
😂
downvote for that background noise
you sound like jhony depp man.
Can't watch this lol noise is too distracting
Cintiq has worse latency than ipad pro.
dude, you high?
Your speech flow is a bit strange. There are a lot of pauses that make it seem unnatural. I'm an editor, so my professional critique would be to 1. try to avoid talking like that in the first place, but a lot of it can be fixed in editing as well. when you are showing B-Roll, cut out all the pauses in your speech and then nobody would even know you talked like that in the first place. But good info
Thank you for the feedback. I have a pretty bad stuttering problem that even when I'm directly reading off of my script, I still stutter a lot. I try to work around it through my editing, but unfortunately it doesn't always work out perfectly. Thank you for your suggestions.
@@TechSummitTV Big Love Bro!! your doing a great job!! thanks for the great video. . :)
@@TechSummitTV Please keep being yourself. You are doing a wonderful job. 😊
@@TechSummitTV well done! The info is clear and very useful. Thanks a lot.
@taylor brusky LOL “avoid talking like that in the first place” you’re an editor. Not a speech therapist. You know that kind of feedback is not constructive at all, you sound like a prick.
Lol ipad wins,
His nostrils looks like portal to another dimension.
i really annoyed the he talks..