still mad the glee writers robbed us of actually seeing their relationship develop and grow but instead decided shelby fucking puck would be more interesting
the whole sleeping with puck storyline was trash. I didn't mind Quinn and Puck meeting Beth. The sleeping storyline could have been discarded and used for Shelby and Rachel's mother-daughter relationship.
This was filmed so brilliantly. I remember seeing this when it aired in 2010 and I had chills the whole time. That shot of Rachel watching in awe from the audience is just pure movie magic.
I love this scene because it shows no matter who raised you you will always have a connection to your birth mother Rachel instantly knew Shelby was her mother just by hearing Shelby's voice and seeing her passion and how she walks slowly down to her all while staring at Shelby with awe wonder and admiration
Lady she did hear her voice before but it’s not just her voice she recognizes it’s the way she talked and the passion she showed in her performance it’s just like Rachel’s
Great acting by Lea. I always thought she wasn't a good actress in Glee because no one praised her for it. Now I realize she's just tremendously underappreciated.
The fact that Lea Michele and Idina Menzel aren't actually related is insane. Seriously, Lea looks so much like Idina, and their voices are extremely similar.
she totally hasn't lost her voice in the slightest!! look at videos of her on her 2017 world tour, in particular Defying Gravity (she still sings it amazingly even though its been over 10 years since Wicked), Seasons of Love where she hits that high C and Don't Rain on my Parade/The way we were :) Literally look at any video of Idina over the past few years and you'll see that her voice hasn't gone at all.
Can we just talk about the little kick up at “sense of humor” mimicking the original Broadway poster?! Icon. My very favorite performance on Glee. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
First time I saw Idina was in rent her voice blew me away. Then she did the voice of Elsa n played Shelby on Glee I will watch her in anything her voice is amazing
Its amazing how people in this world find someone who totally look like them with no blood relatives whatsoever. I mean i thought that lea was actually related to idina bcs of this character lol Psstt try to close your eyes and imagine elsa frozen singing lol
Lyrics: Funny Did you hear that? Funny Yeah, the guy said "Honey, you're a funny girl" That's me I just keep them in stitches Doubled in half And though I may be all wrong for the guy I'm good for a laugh I guess it's not funny Life is far from sunny When the laugh is over And the joke's on you A girl, oughta have a sense of humor That's one thing you really need for sure When you're a funny girl The fella said, "A funny girl" Funny, how it ain't so funny Funny girl
I’ve listen to this song like 1 million times but I don’t know what it is maybe it’s because of where I am in my life or something but like the song just makes me wanna smile especially the way that she sings it and yeah
I was just watching this on Netflix yesterday. I can't believe i missed out on this show in my high school days! Almost done with Season 1 and it'll be gone from Netflix next month. I barely started watching this past summer. Anyway, Idina knows how to sing the classics
I wish they included the scene right before this where she is trying to teach her students the importance of theatricality. This is a master class on the subject. Sometimes subtlety is the key to a great performance.
Funny Did you hear that? Funny Yeah, the guy said "Honey, you're a funny girl." That's me I just keep them in stitches Doubled in half And though I may be all wrong for a guy I'm good for a laugh I guess it's not funny Life is far from sunny When the laugh is over And the joke's on you A girl oughta have a sense of humor That's one thing you really need for sure When you're a funny girl The fella said "A funny girl" Funny How it ain't so funny Funny girl
@@salemsalem1440 Yes, I remember that he said something about how he didn't like how Dianna had played Quinn or something. In the first season Quinn was supposed to be a bitch without feelings but Dianna made her "humanized" in some way and instead of hating her they loved her. And then I also remember when Faberry (Quinn and Rachel) won the poll for the favorite couple in the series even when they weren't a real couple in the show. Murphy was very upset about it, he loved Finchel (Finn and Rachel). And then he literally completely ruined Quinn's character.
Funny Did you hear that 들었어요 Funny Yeah, the guy said honey 그래요 남자가 말했죠 You're a funny girl 너 재밌는 여자구나 That's me 그게 나에요 I just keep them In stitches 마구 웃게 만들죠 doubled in half And though I may be 어쩌면 나는 all wrong for the guy 남자한테 안어울릴지 몰라도 I'm good for a laugh 웃음 한번은 줄 수 있어요 I guess it's not funny 생각해보면 재밌지 않네요 Live is far from sunny 인생은 전혀 맑지 않아요 When the love is over 웃음이 끝나고 나면 And the jokes are you 웃기게 된건 나니까요 A girl ought to have a sense of humor 여자는 유머 감각이 있어야하죠 That's one thing 그거야 말로 you really need for sure 꼭 필요한 거에요 When you're a funny girl 재밌는 여자에게는 A fellow said a funny girl 남자는 말하죠 재밌는 여자 Funny, how it ain't so funny 하나도 재밌지 않아요 Funny girl...
When the casting god's show us favor we get Lea Michelle and Idina Menzel playing mother and daughter and singing together and every scene was magic, but this performance? Yeah this is a bench mark performance.
I find it strange that they'd make a contract forbidding her from approaching her daughter till she's 18 - I mean she carried her for 9 months and gave birth to her, I think that gives her the right for a birthday visit if nothing else. Why would her dads do that to her, not tell her who her birth mother is?
I'm no great fan of this woman's singing. But considering she's taken on a Streisand "no one else can do it as she does" song like this? This woman hits it our of the park,
still mad the glee writers robbed us of actually seeing their relationship develop and grow but instead decided shelby fucking puck would be more interesting
the whole sleeping with puck storyline was trash. I didn't mind Quinn and Puck meeting Beth. The sleeping storyline could have been discarded and used for Shelby and Rachel's mother-daughter relationship.
Sleeping with Puck is fucked up when you realise that not only is he quinn ex he's also Rachel's
They really did look like mother and daughter
Kat Lu 's AMV I know right Ryan did a great job casting these two beautiful and talented women as mother and daughter
and Katelyn Jenner too?
Don’t forget to mention Obama! His nose is pretty similar so maybe 12.4 percent related
Omg when I first saw Rachel I instantaneously remembered of Menzel
They look alike I love Shelby and Rachel
I love the look in Lea's eyes in this amazement apprehension and love
she's an incredible actress
the gameing wolf g ikr its like she had no doubt that was her mommy
Me too I LOVE that so much!!!
Quinn is so precious “get BACK here”
Idina has the most beautiful voice. I want to cry every time. Incredible
She should duet with either Mariah Carey or Celine Dion
I know I fell in love with her voice in Rent.. She's an amazing talent
I cannot believe i have never heard Idina sing before. Thst is the smoothest, most amazing voice. Wow. It has brightened my day no end.
Is Vic There? Lifestyle, Art and Anxiety You probably did hear Idina sing before. I’m just saying LET IT GOOOOO
@@shadowiviiv 😂 very good!!! Now that's another thing I didn't know - thanks for widening my knowledge 👍
Really she is Elsa from frozen
So you never really looked up who sang Defying Gravity in the early episodes of glee?
Have you never watched frozen or wicked?
This was filmed so brilliantly. I remember seeing this when it aired in 2010 and I had chills the whole time. That shot of Rachel watching in awe from the audience is just pure movie magic.
it was TV bitch
I love this scene because it shows no matter who raised you you will always have a connection to your birth mother Rachel instantly knew Shelby was her mother just by hearing Shelby's voice and seeing her passion and how she walks slowly down to her all while staring at Shelby with awe wonder and admiration
she has heard her voice before, Jessie plantet a tape in a box in Rachels house and she plays it... so she new her voice... :-)
She'd also heard her voice earlier on a recording so...she recognized it....
Lady she did hear her voice before but it’s not just her voice she recognizes it’s the way she talked and the passion she showed in her performance it’s just like Rachel’s
@@smukkelady When i saw Jessie and Shelby in the car talking, I thought to myself if only Anna can see you two now.
Q
Great acting by Lea. I always thought she wasn't a good actress in Glee because no one praised her for it. Now I realize she's just tremendously underappreciated.
wait really? I thought she was the actual star, the face of the series
no one praised her cuz she was a bitch lol
Lara Colobo lmaoo yep
@@shannenlibres2365 she is
@@shannenlibres2365 So did I
The fact that Lea Michele and Idina Menzel aren't actually related is insane. Seriously, Lea looks so much like Idina, and their voices are extremely similar.
I’m more into Idina than Lea
Thank you, someone who thinks like me
Same here, finally someone who can relate
Most underrated glee cover of all time
At 0:57 she sounds exactly like Lea it's crazy
i know she really looks like her too
She's far more talented than Lea.
Olives08 maybe in her hey day but she's long lost her voice. Lea blows her out of the water now vocally.
she totally hasn't lost her voice in the slightest!! look at videos of her on her 2017 world tour, in particular Defying Gravity (she still sings it amazingly even though its been over 10 years since Wicked), Seasons of Love where she hits that high C and Don't Rain on my Parade/The way we were :) Literally look at any video of Idina over the past few years and you'll see that her voice hasn't gone at all.
ricky bobby Tell that to Elsa. 😂
For any theatre/movie buffs, has anyone noticed how the stage is set exactly the same as this songs ending shot for Barbra Streisand's Funny Girl?
Merryn Cuff k
Haven’t seen the movie yet. I’m a musical theatre nerd
And she signing directly from the score from the film.
I THOUGHT IT WAS JUST ME THAT NOTICED THAT!
I've only seen the movie twice yet and have not figured it out until now
Can we just talk about the little kick up at “sense of humor” mimicking the original Broadway poster?! Icon. My very favorite performance on Glee. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
unbelievable I'm in tears
Okay, it's not just me.
She sings so errorlessly
She has such a fantastic voice
The first time i heard Idina sing was the Wicked OBC recording.
Idina is a goddess!
First time I saw Idina was in rent her voice blew me away. Then she did the voice of Elsa n played Shelby on Glee I will watch her in anything her voice is amazing
I first heard her sing on the Wicked OBC recording. It took me 3 years after Frozen came out to finally watch Rent.
one of the best scenes in the entire show.
Maturing is realizing how many icons and iconic moments when I was watching this in middle school. Oh my God.
Quinn at 1:08 “get BACK here!” 😂
If they do a revival with the original "Wicked" cast I will go, watch, cry, scream and die happy. I LOVE HER SO MUUUUUUUUCH!!!
Wicked has been on Broadway for almost 20 years. I doubt it'll happen at this rate
Its amazing how people in this world find someone who totally look like them with no blood relatives whatsoever. I mean i thought that lea was actually related to idina bcs of this character lol
Psstt try to close your eyes and imagine elsa frozen singing lol
1:59 I love it. Breathtaking
edit: LOL WHY DID I TYPE LIKE THAT
it really is
YES couldn’t agree more
This performance always moves me, i cant explain it but her voice it so beautiful it just moves me to tears.
Idina has an amazing presence and the character insertions are perfect, just like you want from a Broadway superstar. What a stunning voice.
I was so happy when Idina came on Glee I fell in love with her voice in Rent 🥰🥰🤩🤩
I first heard her sing on the Wicked OBC recording
I just wait for the Rachel starts singing with her mother in this scene 😓
I almost had that same feeling
Such an underrated song.💕
This is my favorite scene from glee. Idk why
India menzel voice was so beautiful
You mean is since she’s still alive
Her voice gives me life
YASSSSS
Lyrics:
Funny
Did you hear that?
Funny
Yeah, the guy said
"Honey, you're a funny girl"
That's me
I just keep them in stitches
Doubled in half
And though I may be all wrong for the guy
I'm good for a laugh
I guess it's not funny
Life is far from sunny
When the laugh is over
And the joke's on you
A girl, oughta have a sense of humor
That's one thing you really need for sure
When you're a funny girl
The fella said, "A funny girl"
Funny, how it ain't so funny
Funny girl
me trying to sing along with the lyrics😂
What magic. Idina singing from the track from the film. Good lord.
I didn’t know who Idina was when I started watching Glee but boy was I blown away when she did this !
I’ve listen to this song like 1 million times but I don’t know what it is maybe it’s because of where I am in my life or something but like the song just makes me wanna smile especially the way that she sings it and yeah
I am really a very big fan of idina menzel
Makes me cry every time
oh my god her cover of funny girl is just true bliss T^T
What a stunning Voice!!!!💚
Major goosebumps… Beyond words…
Idina 😍
I was just watching this on Netflix yesterday. I can't believe i missed out on this show in my high school days! Almost done with Season 1 and it'll be gone from Netflix next month. I barely started watching this past summer. Anyway, Idina knows how to sing the classics
I think the most powerful and amazing voice in Glee. I'm sorry Rachel, Mercedes and Kurt etc...
We needed more Rachel/Quinn/Mercedes trio moments.
The last time I listened to this I was going to watch Funny Girl lol
I wish they included the scene right before this where she is trying to teach her students the importance of theatricality. This is a master class on the subject. Sometimes subtlety is the key to a great performance.
we're in the audience of a masterclass
She is a pure talent
I wish glee did more songs from rent !!!
I would of love to see Adam pascal on glee !!!
this is song is JAZZY IN A RELAXING SOOTHING WAY
Funny
Did you hear that?
Funny
Yeah, the guy said
"Honey, you're a funny girl."
That's me
I just keep them in stitches
Doubled in half
And though I may be all wrong for a guy
I'm good for a laugh
I guess it's not funny
Life is far from sunny
When the laugh is over
And the joke's on you
A girl oughta have a sense of humor
That's one thing you really need for sure
When you're a funny girl
The fella said "A funny girl"
Funny
How it ain't so funny
Funny girl
Now I listen Rachel sings this song on broadway, I was waiting for this moment my entire life
Never watched Glee other than maybe 3 clips on RUclips. I like this though. But then, I've always like that song.
when I first saw Lea I automatically thought she looked like a younger Idina
Quinn was so amazing too bad Ryan Murphy hated her
Sanele Msiza Yea
He did?
@@salemsalem1440 Yes, I remember that he said something about how he didn't like how Dianna had played Quinn or something. In the first season Quinn was supposed to be a bitch without feelings but Dianna made her "humanized" in some way and instead of hating her they loved her. And then I also remember when Faberry (Quinn and Rachel) won the poll for the favorite couple in the series even when they weren't a real couple in the show. Murphy was very upset about it, he loved Finchel (Finn and Rachel). And then he literally completely ruined Quinn's character.
Quinn be like: "gEt BaCk hErE"
damn rachel really said in front of all the other school's glee club members alkfskljfg
Eu tenho medo do quanto elas se parecem kkk
Am I the only one trying to imagine that Elsa is singing this? 😂
J Creative Space nope me too
Fun fact: Idina Menzel played Fanny Brice on Broadway in the early 2000's
I don't remember reading about a Funny Girl revival from 2 decades back
@@manuelorozco7760 there wasn't one.
@@GA-fn8hr I was not fooled a bit
No. She played Elphaba on Broadway’s Wicked.
Funny
Did you hear that
들었어요
Funny
Yeah, the guy said honey
그래요 남자가 말했죠
You're a funny girl
너 재밌는 여자구나
That's me
그게 나에요
I just keep them In stitches
마구 웃게 만들죠
doubled in half
And though I may be
어쩌면 나는
all wrong for the guy
남자한테 안어울릴지 몰라도
I'm good for a laugh
웃음 한번은 줄 수 있어요
I guess it's not funny
생각해보면 재밌지 않네요
Live is far from sunny
인생은 전혀 맑지 않아요
When the love is over
웃음이 끝나고 나면
And the jokes are you
웃기게 된건 나니까요
A girl ought to have a sense of humor
여자는 유머 감각이 있어야하죠
That's one thing
그거야 말로
you really need for sure
꼭 필요한 거에요
When you're a funny girl
재밌는 여자에게는
A fellow said a funny girl
남자는 말하죠 재밌는 여자
Funny,
how it ain't so funny
하나도 재밌지 않아요
Funny girl...
my 10yo ass was so gagged when I watched it before lmaooo
My daughter is in this 🎉
God she’s good
Hope is the tallest inn uppon me, luck hjigh allso 😊
epic
When the casting god's show us favor we get Lea Michelle and Idina Menzel playing mother and daughter and singing together and every scene was magic, but this performance? Yeah this is a bench mark performance.
I find it strange that they'd make a contract forbidding her from approaching her daughter till she's 18 - I mean she carried her for 9 months and gave birth to her, I think that gives her the right for a birthday visit if nothing else. Why would her dads do that to her, not tell her who her birth mother is?
Being a surrogate involves a contract so neither party gets screwed over
i love lea s acting
Hey guys
Um, anyone knows wich episode was this scene? I just can't remember
What is this? It’s indina Manziel is this a movie or something?
Haddie Harris *Idina Menzel and it’s a series called Glee
OK WO W
Are you there Elsa?
Does she say “FUNLY” multiple times?
I'd say sisters but yes they look alike
😳
Why has Lea Michele never been in Wicked? (She hasn't, right?)
I'm no great fan of this woman's singing. But considering she's taken on a Streisand "no one else can do it as she does" song like this? This woman hits it our of the park,
I won’t forget when Idina sang Don’t Rain On Parade in 2008
Horrible !