3 Dead Famous People Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
  • Showcasing three minor Red Dead Redemption 2 mysteries revolving around dead famous people.
    Strange Man: Evolutions channel:
    / @strangemanmysteries
    Become my patron:
    / strangemanchannel
    Instagram:
    / strangemanchannel
    Don't forget to like, subscribe and share!
    Music:
    Artist: Whitesand
    Song: The Dark Way - • Emotional Cinematic Mu...
    ---------
    Artist: Whitesand
    Song: Circle of Life - • Sad Emotional Dramatic...
    ---------
    Track: Cinematic Piano [FREE DOWNLOAD] by MokkaMusic / Boat • (No Copyright Music) C...
    Music provided by "MokkaMusic" channel and inaudio.org
    Other videos:
    Pleasance & the Giant Snake Solved (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • Pleasance & the Giant ...
    Pentagram & Butcher Creek Mystery Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • Pentagram & Butcher Cr...
    5 More Secrets You Didn't Know About (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • 5 Secrets You Didn't K...
    5 Secrets You Didn't Know About (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • 5 Secrets You Didn't K...
    Secret in Saint Denis Theater Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2)
    • Secret in Saint Denis ...
    Aberdeen Pig Farm Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • Aberdeen Pig Farm Expl...
    Frozen Cattle Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • Frozen Cattle Explaine...
    Talking Parrot Found in Audio Files (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • Talking Parrot Found i...
    Strange Man Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • Strange Man Explained ...
    The Mystery of Gavin Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • The Mystery of Gavin E...
    All Old Blind Man Cassidy Fortunes Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • All Old Blind Man Cass...
    Emerald Ranch Mystery Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • Emerald Ranch Mystery ...
    Viking Mystery Solved (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • Viking Mystery Solved ...
    How Times Have Changed (GTA 5 & Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • How Times Have Changed...
    Norwegian Manzanita Post Mystery Explained (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • Norwegian Manzanita Po...
    How Bigfoot Connects to the Indian Massacre (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • How Bigfoot Connects t...
    Mount Chiliad Mural Explained (GTA 5 Mystery Solved):
    • Mount Chiliad Mural Ex...
    Evolution of Easter Eggs in GTA and Red Dead Games in 13 Minutes (2020)
    • Evolution of Easter Eg...
    10 Most Interesting Newspaper Articles (Red Dead Redemption 2)
    • 10 Most Interesting Ne...
    True Story Behind the UFO Cult (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • True Story Behind the ...
    All Madam Nazar Fortunes Referencing Red Dead Redemption 2:
    • All Madam Nazar Fortun...
    3 Mysteries Solved/Almost Solved Thanks to Game Files (Red Dead Redemption 2):
    • 3 Mysteries Solved or ...
    Hidden Dreamcatcher Quest Objective? (Mural Explained)
    • Hidden Dreamcatcher Qu...
    Giant Man's Identity Revealed (Red Dead Redemption 2)
    • Giant Man's Identity R...
    The Most Mysterious Ped Models (Red Dead Redemption 2)
    • The Most Mysterious Pe...
    Why Arthur and John Should Never Get Drunk:
    • Why Arthur and John Sh...
    Help, Somebody!!:
    • Help, Somebody!!
    #StrangeMan #RDR2 #RedDeadMysteries

Комментарии • 932

  • @StrangeManChannel
    @StrangeManChannel  4 года назад +225

    Strange Man: Evolutions channel: ruclips.net/user/strangemanevolutions

    • @captainanyonebutteo9126
      @captainanyonebutteo9126 4 года назад +5

      pls do the valentines curse

    • @Ali-Raji
      @Ali-Raji 4 года назад +3

      Do about otis miller the gunslinger

    • @giannicanestro87
      @giannicanestro87 4 года назад +3

      There is also something written on the frozen lake. Maybe it was him??

    • @nathanhails5901
      @nathanhails5901 4 года назад +1

      I think it was the Serial Killer Garrett Mason! He's been mentioned in other Rockstar Games!

    • @anthonyvalentino6557
      @anthonyvalentino6557 4 года назад +1

      Thomas Charron I believe he already did that awhile ago, just look on his channel I’m sure you can find it.

  • @Filmfiend27
    @Filmfiend27 4 года назад +692

    The actors suicide note made me think of something Arthur told John. “I was the prize pony once, but now I’m a work horse.”

    • @carlisleblack5055
      @carlisleblack5055 4 года назад +63

      made me afraid of getting old not gonna lie

    • @jackmarston1426
      @jackmarston1426 3 года назад +5

      I agree

    • @matthewwind7419
      @matthewwind7419 3 года назад +23

      it's kinda like "either you die being useful or live long enough to be useless"

    • @Cyrex64
      @Cyrex64 3 года назад +5

      listen Dutch is but.. but...

    • @Kvs-vf9nt
      @Kvs-vf9nt 3 года назад +4

      I'm 31. I'm getting old..😔

  • @HessSR
    @HessSR 4 года назад +1799

    it's honestly insane how many details there are in this game. i'll be watching these vids 10 years from now and still find new things in the game that i didn't know about

  • @injetavel279
    @injetavel279 4 года назад +1453

    The Ice Skater was a war veteran, maybe he was from the Union and the lemoyne raiders went out of their way just to destroy his grave

    • @davidefina
      @davidefina 4 года назад +106

      Nah, he's in the north, the Union Zone. I think was a rival.

    • @injetavel279
      @injetavel279 4 года назад +61

      @@davidefina Maybe he went there because of the snow and the frozen lake, it reminded him of his ice skating days

    • @injetavel279
      @injetavel279 4 года назад +48

      @TaDoMaster Kieran did it because he wanted to be the biggest horse riding ice skater of the world

    • @suskysulky
      @suskysulky 4 года назад +60

      @@injetavel279 how often do you buy a house or land? He probably was skating there before the accident, if he lost his leg he should've move to a better house in a better place

    • @injetavel279
      @injetavel279 4 года назад +8

      @@suskysulky Whatever, that doesn't change anything in my theory, maybe that's where he liked to skate before the accident, who knows, maybe you're right, but whatever man

  • @tomsbrainhurtsalot
    @tomsbrainhurtsalot 4 года назад +535

    "My confidence in all things letters and love fades and grows flaccid as each season passes"
    Damn, that's despairingly beautiful. Whoever wrote that line at Rockstar does not get the appreciation they deserve.

    • @mr.smortguy0-o132
      @mr.smortguy0-o132 4 года назад +15

      My love grows flaccid ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

    • @tomsbrainhurtsalot
      @tomsbrainhurtsalot 4 года назад +32

      @Jared Bradley I was more so praising the rhythm of the sentence, rather than the specific choice of language (other than the half-rhyme, which does lend itself to the rhythm) and whether it was conventional for the period. It feels that the sentence alone has an elegance and flair that is missing from a lot of game writing.

    • @42218102742
      @42218102742 4 года назад +22

      The writing in this game is really something. From the actual story to the random letters you can find around the world. Even minor characters have a story. R* really has some talented and creative minds

    • @winterbalm
      @winterbalm 4 года назад +4

      I associate flaccid with erectile dysfuncton

    • @DerpyDragonful
      @DerpyDragonful 4 года назад +1

      @@mr.smortguy0-o132 def implying he getting a boner.

  • @flitsertheo
    @flitsertheo 4 года назад +351

    That waterfall stunt must have attracted a crowd so it's rather odd that they left Desiree just laying there after her death. And she should look less "fresh" by now.

    • @jurassicparkboy
      @jurassicparkboy 4 года назад +96

      It's totally possible the barrel got caught underneath the roaming falls and over time, Search efforts are established but you know... The late 19th century. They most likely gave up looking for her corpse or her barrel after a few days and by the time John or Arthur find the barrel, Search efforts are long gone and her cylindrical casket quietly floated ashore just a bit before Arthur comes.
      TL;DR. IM OVerexplaining game goofs. It's all good here.

    • @Davo
      @Davo 4 года назад +70

      Could be she was rehearsing it, so no people was present, and went wrong?

    • @flitsertheo
      @flitsertheo 4 года назад +17

      @@jurassicparkboy I don't want to give a detailed description of the process of putrefaction but if she spent a longer while in that barrel either A) her remains would be "sticking" inside that barrel or B) after an ever longer while all that would be left is a skeleton.

    • @flitsertheo
      @flitsertheo 4 года назад +20

      @@Davo It's not the kind of stunt you can rehearse unless trying a smaller waterfall first and she would always require help dragging that barrel around. Sitting in a closed barrel it would be difficult to push herself in the water.

    • @flitsertheo
      @flitsertheo 4 года назад +11

      There is no way you can make this plausible : the crowd would have gathered exactly where she washed ashore, an ideal viewpoint to see her descent. And she would have to look as that family who died from carbon monoxide poisoning or the 2 boys who starved locked up in their home. (RDR2 is such an uplifting, positive game)

  • @pip7468
    @pip7468 4 года назад +1300

    Finally someone who knows that the woman in the barrel isnt a LOTR reference

    • @rere_ig
      @rere_ig 4 года назад +26

      what's lotr?

    • @gob1et
      @gob1et 4 года назад +64

      Reham_is_rare lord of the rings

    • @gob1et
      @gob1et 4 года назад +6

      Reham_is_rare idk either of those

    • @rere_ig
      @rere_ig 4 года назад +4

      @@gob1et ok thx :)

    • @bobbyberro8107
      @bobbyberro8107 4 года назад +44

      Pip your mean a hobbit reference ?

  • @Carlieto91
    @Carlieto91 4 года назад +201

    I'm beginning to think the easter eggs were written to tie in with the main themes of the storyline. You know, knowing when to stop, like this lady dying of one last stunt, this actor dying of being too long "in the game", this ice skater having an accident, his past digging him out ... I think many of these stories can be seen from this angle.

    • @MikrosBeethoven
      @MikrosBeethoven 3 года назад

      How do you connect them with the story?

    • @Carlieto91
      @Carlieto91 3 года назад +19

      @@MikrosBeethoven Arthur, Dutch and the gang were successful for 20 years. But Red Dead games are all about their demise for being too greedy through "one last job", or past actions catching up on them.

    • @yungblaze223s
      @yungblaze223s 3 года назад +14

      Thats exactly what it is. Lessons. Learned through other peoples trials and tribulations

    • @Setanta9089
      @Setanta9089 2 года назад

      jesus man, incredible, great thinking :)

  • @Rafi-gr1cj
    @Rafi-gr1cj 4 года назад +730

    I left the Ubisoft livestream for this I know I am not gonna be disappointed

    • @StrangeManChannel
      @StrangeManChannel  4 года назад +280

      😂👍

    • @samyjackson1857
      @samyjackson1857 4 года назад +8

      There is a ubisoft livestream ??

    • @injetavel279
      @injetavel279 4 года назад +41

      @@samyjackson1857 Yes, and they were giving a free copy of watch dogs 2 (PC only) for the people that watched it. And yes, I'm being serious

    • @Kostaki05
      @Kostaki05 4 года назад +19

      FarCry 6 do be lookin fire doe

    • @vladdietheladdie7345
      @vladdietheladdie7345 4 года назад +4

      Well shit. I saw the live stream but skipped it

  • @dxntcrywxlf
    @dxntcrywxlf 3 года назад +251

    The differences between Arthur's drawings and John's kills me everytime.

    • @ChristianUtama
      @ChristianUtama 2 года назад +27

      That's the proof Jack was John's son.

    • @richardson33
      @richardson33 2 года назад +30

      you have to visit all these places as arthur to make your ledger look beautiful

    • @BeautyAmongAshes
      @BeautyAmongAshes 2 года назад +17

      Every single playthrough, I try to get everything I possibly can in the journal as Arthur because he's just so talented. I love to see all his drawings and his penmanship 🥰

    • @ko-rp7ge
      @ko-rp7ge 2 года назад

      😂😂

    • @BazookaGamingGirl
      @BazookaGamingGirl 2 года назад +6

      I literally laughed out loud when I saw John’s drawing of the ice skater lmao.

  • @gildef21
    @gildef21 4 года назад +111

    I think the ice skater actually lived there for a long time and trained to ice skate since his childhood. Because if my ice skater career ended because of an accident I wouldn't leave my ice skating shoes on top of my table just to remind me of the good old days.

    • @sixdaystosanity
      @sixdaystosanity 3 года назад +3

      definitely not. he'd probably wanna get as far away from the ice and skates as possible.

    • @itisfreak
      @itisfreak 3 года назад

      @@sixdaystosanity 💯

    • @gildef21
      @gildef21 3 года назад

      @@sixdaystosanity perhaps

  • @epalacios1502
    @epalacios1502 4 года назад +349

    Maybe you've covered this already but in a random dialogue Mrs Grimshaw mentions how good a man her 1st husband was. I've noticed the town graveyard of Rhodes is dedicated to a MR Grimshaw. Same Man?

    • @eviemorgan1360
      @eviemorgan1360 4 года назад +84

      Cool, I never saw that grave so I'll have to look around and see if I can find it when I play next. Also, Mary-Beths book she wrote that she *spoiler* gives John in the epilogue is definitely about Grimshaw and Dutch.

    • @zachsmith5877
      @zachsmith5877 4 года назад +34

      Also, on the sign for the Rhodes church (I think it’s Rhodes), it says the pastors last name is Grimshaw. Not sure if there’s a connection or not tho

    • @JoleneGov
      @JoleneGov 4 года назад +16

      They were engaged, not married.

    • @nameynamename3758
      @nameynamename3758 4 года назад +13

      @@zachsmith5877 I have a hard time believing R* would give someone the same name as an important character and NOT have them be related.

  • @mikecochrane1437
    @mikecochrane1437 4 года назад +377

    One of the greatest games ever made. Still after getting 100% loads left to do

    • @Andre_Holmes
      @Andre_Holmes 4 года назад +4

      Like what?

    • @maisiemaisie123
      @maisiemaisie123 4 года назад +12

      @@Andre_Holmes you know, all the side missions, hunting legendary animals, finding easter eggs, really theres tons of stuff to do

    • @sladewilson4745
      @sladewilson4745 4 года назад +12

      @@maisiemaisie123 you have to find these stuffs to attain 100%

    • @xiiwolfy
      @xiiwolfy 4 года назад +2

      Maisie O'Connor i did all that stuff before i got micah out of jail. really wanted that guy hanged

    • @Vorbuis
      @Vorbuis 4 года назад +3

      I wonder when RDR 3 will come out RDR 1 was awesome they should had undead nightmare to RDR 2 tho but still amazing games.

  • @jasonromero9481
    @jasonromero9481 4 года назад +256

    Man.. Big respect for you! You the best Rdr2 content creator ever, keep it up bro❤️! Greetings from Honduras🇭🇳 💙!

    • @mental_metal_au2179
      @mental_metal_au2179 4 года назад +5

      That's why I subscribed

    • @abnerfuentes7563
      @abnerfuentes7563 4 года назад +3

      Simon, yo también soy de Honduras 🇭🇳

    • @ambrosherrmann8322
      @ambrosherrmann8322 4 года назад +3

      @@abnerfuentes7563 yo soy de Mexico 🇲🇽

    • @glogang46
      @glogang46 4 года назад +2

      No cap 👍🏽

    • @xymoxhn6476
      @xymoxhn6476 4 года назад +1

      @@abnerfuentes7563 yo también soy hondureño! Impresionado que mas hondureños también miran estos videos. Ok también soy mexicano.

  • @amelsrzn8268
    @amelsrzn8268 4 года назад +96

    With each new video i'm like "it's over, Strange man found and explained every hidden details in the game by now", and the next week you still find something new to tell us about. Both the game and you really impress me.

  • @loretta2539
    @loretta2539 4 года назад +30

    When I found the Nevada hat behind the waterfall I also found a complete map of the otis miller treasure. I dont think I found the letter there but I always go there to get the map.
    I think the ice skater guy who's grave was desecrated was possibly his kid. When you showed the tomb, I saw it said "war verteran, father" so I assume the child desecrated his grave because he left them after knowing he could no longer ice skate. He held ice skating more dearly than his kid who cameback to write "No Ice in Hell" as a way of showing his resentment to the dad.

    • @pjfreeman3586
      @pjfreeman3586 3 года назад +8

      That or the father was so absorbed in his skating career that he never gave his son the time of day. Son stages an accident, figuring that he’d have no career so he’d be forced to spend time with him. Dad instead goes to live on a frozen lake by himself. Son disowns father, and when the father dies the son digs him up.

  • @ivanvega4802
    @ivanvega4802 4 года назад +131

    1:37 I was watching at the video like "oh, poor lady, they didn't even buried her" but that bad drawing killed me 😂

    • @devilous_4374
      @devilous_4374 4 года назад +24

      John draws like a kid compared to arthur

    • @WhoCares-dl8zr
      @WhoCares-dl8zr 3 года назад +19

      @@devilous_4374 And that's pretty cool that they didn't just keep it the exact same style of drawings, makes sense Arthur would be better at drawing since he was alot more into it than John

    • @floppa3166
      @floppa3166 3 года назад +1

      The thing is self taught drawers like me and arthur(I think) are better than ones who are taught

  • @Immanooblolz
    @Immanooblolz 3 года назад +129

    John: *Sees Barrel Rider Poster*
    Also John: Found a body in a barrel, wonder why she did it.

    • @loucypher333
      @loucypher333 3 года назад +2

      He is wondering the motive

    • @dr.skulhamr3220
      @dr.skulhamr3220 3 года назад

      My guess is she was managed by men who did not necessarily have her best interests at heart. "You can do it sugar!"

    • @Harish-hz9or
      @Harish-hz9or 3 года назад +1

      He is talking about why she tried to do the stunt mate.

    • @siasdandellia
      @siasdandellia 2 года назад

      my man needs reading lesson badly

  • @ChallengerV8
    @ChallengerV8 4 года назад +128

    I'll say it again: I missed so many things in this game...

    • @davycrockett8076
      @davycrockett8076 4 года назад +3

      Me too...and that is really a shame. But, thank to Strange Man, I'm discovering a lot of things that I didn't know had such interesting background stories. I've always treated all of them only as Easter Eggs, and nothing more.

    • @ChallengerV8
      @ChallengerV8 4 года назад +7

      @@davycrockett8076 I played 200+ hours in story mode, I really explored a LOT of places, I've been looking for dino bones and dream catchers. Yet I missed a lot :)

    • @mohammedal-dleimy2175
      @mohammedal-dleimy2175 4 года назад +1

      You know the first two weeks “4-6 hours playing each day” i stopped at chapter 2 and kept exploring! I was astonished and attached to the game

    • @Sam-bd1me
      @Sam-bd1me 4 года назад +3

      I mean I barely found out today you can get robbed in saint Denis at the gunstore some guy will bump into you and Rob you of 300+ dollars

    • @ChallengerV8
      @ChallengerV8 4 года назад +1

      I did the same! :D As soon as we went to Horseshoe Overlook I just dropped everything and went on to explore. I also studied ~90% of animals in chapter 2 :D Now I still have 2 species missing, one bull and something else. I just don't want to check it on the Internet. I want to get everything myself.

  • @kirstypickering3617
    @kirstypickering3617 4 года назад +87

    I like to think for the last one that one of his rivals set him up for the accident and came back to dig him up when he died

    • @martijnstuart95
      @martijnstuart95 4 года назад +12

      I thought so too. Sort of a Tonya Harding/Nancy Kerrigan situation.

    • @altxogershavelayers5166
      @altxogershavelayers5166 2 года назад

      Overly elaborate,we don't know a rival even exists.

    • @babiesdontpaytaxes.16
      @babiesdontpaytaxes.16 2 года назад

      @@altxogershavelayers5166 ......what do you mean? ice skaters compete against each other so there was rival if is was mild or not i dont know.

    • @altxogershavelayers5166
      @altxogershavelayers5166 2 года назад

      @@babiesdontpaytaxes.16 Yes, as is common knowledge Ice skaters not only race each other but would like to kill each other. My bad.

  • @chunkystyle
    @chunkystyle 4 года назад +81

    I love the fact that you kept the continuity of the Nevada hat as you went to the third body,

    • @marloncarbajal5492
      @marloncarbajal5492 4 года назад +4

      The funny thing is that Sheriff Malloy in Valentine also wears the same hat

    • @josh.y
      @josh.y 2 года назад

      @@marloncarbajal5492 What’s funny about that?

    • @marloncarbajal5492
      @marloncarbajal5492 2 года назад +2

      @@josh.y i have no idea

  • @undeaddino1046
    @undeaddino1046 4 года назад +28

    Me and my friend made a theory that the ice skater purposely caused a rival of his to ‘have an accident’ to make sure he wins. After his death, the rival defaced his grave to get the last laugh.

    • @kostasz6258
      @kostasz6258 2 года назад +7

      I'm a bit late here, but this makes perfect sense to me. If you look at the corpse, it seems like the pants are torn on the right foot. If he survived an accident like that a few years ago, he'd still wear normal pants and he might just fold the missing leg part like Mickey the war veteran does with his missing hand and his coat. So maybe this man's rival was the one that had the "accident" and when he heard of his rival's death, he went to deface the grave and took his revenge by cutting the corpse's leg off

    • @daano465
      @daano465 Год назад

      But he was a war veteran, probably lost his leg in war.

  • @glenntierney9578
    @glenntierney9578 4 года назад +19

    The attention to detail in this game is second to none. I remember finding all these mysteries and just thinking this is just things the devs put in just for the sake of it. I love how it all has a back story. Brilliant.

    • @herm574
      @herm574 3 года назад

      second to none means very little but I get what you mean

  • @iii7579
    @iii7579 4 года назад +56

    Maybe the person who did that in felix grave was a war veteran who thinks he was a coward or a traitor, I am not sure, it's a theory

    • @mrblonde609
      @mrblonde609 4 года назад +7

      Possible. Maybe he was chased by one guy, so that could be another reason why he chose this remote cabin. And eventually the guy found him after many years. Or a relative of a guy he killd in the war?

    • @nnnnmhughuuhhjiijj9457
      @nnnnmhughuuhhjiijj9457 4 года назад +1

      Maybe, one of Del Lobos did it...?

  • @gonzothompson412
    @gonzothompson412 4 года назад +18

    I think we all know who wrote on the Ice skaters tombstone...it was that damn GAVIN!

  • @cicadax5886
    @cicadax5886 4 года назад +37

    9:16
    It was Tonya Harding.

    • @Gamesha_Guy
      @Gamesha_Guy 4 года назад +3

      underrated comment. How does it only have 5 likes??

    • @cicadax5886
      @cicadax5886 3 года назад

      @@drapplebees409 google her ...trust me lol

    • @JRSRLN
      @JRSRLN 3 года назад +1

      Lmao underrated as hell, imma go watch I, Tonya now lol.

    • @pjfreeman3586
      @pjfreeman3586 3 года назад +1

      That was my first thought too!

  • @cryoshotgaming3640
    @cryoshotgaming3640 4 года назад +57

    I love that "Donner" in my language, means to hit something exceptionally hard. Kinda how she hit the bottom of the waterfall.

    • @seantanzey1129
      @seantanzey1129 4 года назад +20

      Donner where I'm from (Nevada) means a group of pioneers who got snowed and took to cannibalism to survive

    • @cryoshotgaming3640
      @cryoshotgaming3640 4 года назад +14

      @@seantanzey1129
      That is... Oddly spesific

    • @mrg8317
      @mrg8317 4 года назад +2

      Donnor is a meal from east of stripes of meat with salad or chips.

    • @Slider6294
      @Slider6294 4 года назад +5

      @@seantanzey1129 And to think we can now cruise I-80 in comfort with 4 wheel drive vehicles and not break a sweat. I love that whole area. Lot of pioneer history.

    • @dreaminginvalhalla1914
      @dreaminginvalhalla1914 4 года назад +11

      "Donner" means "Thunder" in my language. Thunderfalls, get it?

  • @aapojaula9773
    @aapojaula9773 4 года назад +123

    Could you do something about Otis Miller the gunslinger?

    • @baf8189
      @baf8189 4 года назад +5

      Yes this is a very Good Idea!

    • @iii7579
      @iii7579 4 года назад +5

      Interesting

    • @user-tz5vr1vv4n
      @user-tz5vr1vv4n 4 года назад +2

      He got betrayed.

    • @spunky6692
      @spunky6692 4 года назад +2

      otis is based off Jesse James.

    • @theprinceoforder
      @theprinceoforder 4 года назад

      The Hermit Cowboy shot him.

  • @crossbonez1028
    @crossbonez1028 4 года назад +10

    Not only do I want more single player content for MY sake...but my goodness do I want it so I can watch more of your videos! Seriously dude, your editing is tremendous

  • @simple-commentator-not-rea7345
    @simple-commentator-not-rea7345 3 года назад +4

    With the missing leg and the apparent depression the ice skater felt, I can't help but think of real life Nancy Kerrigan. She was a proffessional ice skater who almost couldn't participate in the 1994 Winter Olympics when a friend of her rival nearly broke her leg before the Olympics. Don't worry though, she recovered and won Silver.
    Maybe whoever defaced that grave was a rival who lost against him year prior? Maybe someone who lost against him while he lived, caused the accident in which he lost his leg, and then defaced the grave as an added insult.

  • @vDullahan
    @vDullahan 4 года назад +12

    This has more gameplay than the entirety of the Ubi stream. Thanks for the awesome content!

  • @artgoupil3776
    @artgoupil3776 4 года назад +10

    Your videos are so gooood!
    "No ice in hell" : maybe he killed himself. No paradise for those who have committed suicide. The gravestone mentions "father" ... perhaps it was his family or a member of his family who was mad with rage at having been abandoned. After having found him, having noticed his death, in a burst of anger, the family member would have written this words...

    • @alexm7627
      @alexm7627 2 года назад +2

      No paradise for any other sort of sinner as well, which according to the bible, all of us are, especially those who think they aren't and that they're "not that bad"

    • @alexm7627
      @alexm7627 2 года назад

      Just thought i should mention this

  • @anandaanandaminfinitebliss6826
    @anandaanandaminfinitebliss6826 4 года назад +62

    and you know what Inside a shack near the Van Horn Trading Post, you’ll find a creature that looks like a frankly upsetting splice of man, bear, and pig chained to the wall. This is the Manbearpig, which you'll recognise from one of America's more subversive cartoons.

    • @user-tz5vr1vv4n
      @user-tz5vr1vv4n 4 года назад +13

      When I found it I was like "wtf is this " ...i even shot it few times just to be sure it wasn't alive 😂.

    • @elliottblackwell1747
      @elliottblackwell1747 4 года назад +4

      Lol South Park.

    • @R3fug333
      @R3fug333 4 года назад +4

      @@elliottblackwell1747 It's probably a rival ice skater who felt cheated.

    • @Cubs1719
      @Cubs1719 4 года назад +2

      Believe strange man has already covered this

    • @loretta2539
      @loretta2539 4 года назад +2

      manbearpig cracked me up because when I seen it my first thought was "south park" 😂

  • @kirkhutchins4989
    @kirkhutchins4989 4 года назад +5

    I've found the Nevada hat(one of my favorites)and note. Never found the woman in the barrel in all my play thrus. Found the cabin and the ice skater. I've always wondered who desecrated his grave. Wife or child due to him being gone so much. Ice skating competitor because they believed he sold his soul to win. Or a veteran on his side or enemy from the war. Who knows who did this, not enough clues to figure out.

    • @imjessietr29
      @imjessietr29 4 года назад +1

      Maybe someone who thought a famous athlete would be buried with money. It’s not like Arthur won’t loot bodies.

  • @ricardoehernandez1071
    @ricardoehernandez1071 4 года назад +2

    just started my second play through of one of my favorite games of all time. I'm still finding stuff that I would never find - thank you so much for your dedication to the fans and the game we love!

  • @bighoss7603
    @bighoss7603 4 года назад +3

    Only Strange Man has the ability to make you feel sadness and remorse for a character in a game. You are the best at what you do!!

  • @mr.joshua1979
    @mr.joshua1979 4 года назад +2

    That build up sequence from 4:53 to 5:27 is just absolutely amazing, gave me chills. Very well done and beautiful score as usual.

  • @jotarokujo7780
    @jotarokujo7780 4 года назад +7

    8:46
    The guy who did it: my goals are beyond your understanding

  • @ModerPlus
    @ModerPlus 4 года назад +3

    Can we just thanks him for ending the video in 9:57 and not 10 that he could easily do, wow he is a legend

  • @Redaulse
    @Redaulse 4 года назад +6

    This content is truly amazing. Can't wait for Strange Man's vids on future R* games

  • @ctwhalerman
    @ctwhalerman 4 года назад +2

    As for who defaced Felix Hawley's grave, his body is missing his right leg, from his accident in 1874, and we can assume he was wealthy and famous enough to have a decent prosthetic leg made for himself in the years following his accident. Now who else in the game is missing his right leg? One is Hamish Sinclair, a fellow Union veteran who sports a fake leg nicer than any a normal Civil War vet would have, and who when we meet him has lost it in his horse's stirrup. Maybe Hawley served with Hamish in the army and for whatever reason was to blame for Hamish losing his leg, so when Hawley died years later (I think the stone says 1888) Hamish came by for his revenge, got a nice fake leg out of Hawley's grave, and still isn't totally proficient in its use by 1899 when Arthur comes by. Another possibility could be Joe Butler, the Confederate veteran hanging out at the Rhodes general store, who also lost a bunch of brothers in the war, and is also missing his right leg, though he does not have a prosthetic. Did he stop bitching about the Grays long enough to travel to the Grizzlies to avenge his dead brothers?

  • @wolfsburg8572
    @wolfsburg8572 4 года назад +3

    Very cool! I will say it seems weird that Desiree LeFlamme's corpse would've been left there to rot when presumably there would've been people all around to watch her death "defying" stunt.

  • @merrinarasauce
    @merrinarasauce 4 года назад

    Not gonna lie, i started watching you a week ago, and i am not disappointed!
    In every video, you put so much detail and hours of research, unlike other content creators who just steal content from each other. You are very underrated, and i really hope you'll get to 500K or even 1M!

  • @michaelgaunya9102
    @michaelgaunya9102 4 года назад +5

    I love all of these videos. They give so much depth and there's clearly a lot of effort in them. Great content by a great creator. Keep it up!

  • @Unku.
    @Unku. 2 года назад

    I watch this channel because i think of it as a video game version of “Mr. Ballen” you tell the strange, deep and mysterious about red dead and i binge watch the heck out of these! Keep up the work man!

  • @rtc2112
    @rtc2112 4 года назад +6

    This is some amazing Red Dead content. Where did he get the music for this video? If anybody has a source I'd be very grateful. A simple reading of the description answered my question. Again this is killer content!

  • @donaldbrown5655
    @donaldbrown5655 4 года назад +1

    this could be a story about Valentine Bialas He qualified for the 1936 Olympic team as an alternate, but could not participate in those Olympics because he was injured in an auto/train collision which occurred in an icy downpour on the way home from a skating meet. He lost his leg in the collision.

  • @gabrieleeleeel
    @gabrieleeleeel 4 года назад +7

    Hey strange man can you do a video on a theory of How Elias Green ( A story mode bounty) can be the WolfMan ( A legendary bounty in RDR2 online) They look the same and both threaten to bite the player and Elias Green wears a bear hat and The WolfMan has a bear in his cave with him. But that’s just my theory 👍

    • @biggie1309
      @biggie1309 4 года назад

      Amazing theory 👏

    • @boochie-yj7un
      @boochie-yj7un 4 года назад +2

      Elias is a skinner brother, while the wolf man doesn’t have a name, you literally capture or kill him, and he lives with WOLVES. And guess how many scripted wolves are with Elias? None.

  • @user_7083
    @user_7083 4 года назад +1

    Strange man I am Brasilian but I really love your videos, please keep with the good work and bring to us more red dead misteries :D

  • @ethanabramov6345
    @ethanabramov6345 4 года назад +5

    Damn I didnt know that woman in the barrel had a backstory this game is just packed with stuff

  • @willotter4503
    @willotter4503 4 года назад

    Your content is so high quality that unlike other rdr2 you tubers, u do not have to rely on clickbait, I know that u will deliver high quality content that I will enjoy even if I am not interested by the video topic

  • @YourDeadMommy
    @YourDeadMommy 4 года назад +23

    Please can you explain the strange statues and who built them and why they are built

  • @anandaanandaminfinitebliss6826
    @anandaanandaminfinitebliss6826 4 года назад +1

    and another easter egg is about Roanoke Ghosts
    If you head into Roanoke Valley late in the night, you might hear disembodied voices calling to you. This is a reference to the colony of Roanoke, where it’s said that everyone disappeared overnight, without a trace.

  • @GlazgoEDIT
    @GlazgoEDIT 4 года назад +6

    Beacause Felix was a war veteran mabye a friend of him died beacause of felix in the war and the man who died maybe his son wrote that beacause he knew his father died because felix

  • @mullemeck5015
    @mullemeck5015 4 года назад +2

    Even if you touch on subjects that have already been covered (not this one)
    You still manage to find new secrets! Spectacular!

  • @janmichael4643
    @janmichael4643 4 года назад +6

    Can you make a video and take a closer look who "Boadecia", Arthur's horse before the game, really was?

    • @Takokujin07
      @Takokujin07 4 года назад +6

      I’m not sure what kind of horse she was, but I am pretty sure that the horseshoe that Arthur keeps next to the picture of his father, his dog, and him with Hosea and Dutch at his camp belonged to her.

    • @41_orizaferishpriyono99
      @41_orizaferishpriyono99 4 года назад +1

      Maybe it's the horse we see on the rdr2 trailer ?

    • @khayreespencer7448
      @khayreespencer7448 3 года назад

      @Louis Cypher they say during the blackwater masscare while arthur was trying to help the gang escape arthur horse was shot down and he was pinned with mac and mac give boadecia his horse to arthur to escape while mac hold off the pickertons also the gunslinger coat arthur wears used to be macs its cut content look it up

  • @philfury6709
    @philfury6709 4 года назад

    Great video as usual Mr Strange Man. My one and only complaint is that it's pretty obvious that ice skater had lived in the cabin for a very long time. The cabin has a frozen lake wouldn't it make more sense that he skated on it rather than 'he moved here to painfully remind himself of the good ol' days', no one does that. I'm paraphrasing of course but you get the idea.
    It really makes you want to know who dug him up and what the accident was, it's very interesting. Rockstar is phenomenal at painting just enough of a picture without spelling out the poetry in these stories, it really makes content of your videos great and makes the game feel alive.

  • @dennishuang7764
    @dennishuang7764 4 года назад +32

    RDR2 > TLOU2
    It's been over a year and there's still more content being discovered

    • @sammcgee9456
      @sammcgee9456 4 года назад +3

      Better story and characters in rd!

    • @geymahundr659
      @geymahundr659 4 года назад +3

      @@sammcgee9456 better everything

    • @dragonkamran
      @dragonkamran 4 года назад +4

      TLOU 2 was shit.
      Coming from a guy who thinks TLOU1 is the best game in the world.

    • @lightyagami8645
      @lightyagami8645 4 года назад

      GOW : ( chuckles ) kids

    • @geymahundr659
      @geymahundr659 4 года назад +1

      @@lightyagami8645 i can smell you through the screen. do you also own a fedora by any chance?

  • @dclong693
    @dclong693 4 года назад

    The musical scores in your vids are epic. Keep killing it bro.

  • @mikefire7928
    @mikefire7928 3 года назад

    you are the best one who can explain video games ive ever seen ur a miracle KEEP GOING

  • @Iukaz
    @Iukaz 4 года назад +3

    Your videos are always so captivating to watch. Keep them up :D I dont even play RDR2 anymore but these videos are too good :)

  • @TheShake-N-BakeBoy
    @TheShake-N-BakeBoy Год назад

    I love the difference between Arthur’s drawings and Johns, Arthur’s is more detailed where as Johns is more quickly scratched together

  • @martindaskalov3140
    @martindaskalov3140 4 года назад +1

    Dont mind me, just a random viewer here to say, how much i like your videos and your style. Keep up the quality work!

  • @stevena1982
    @stevena1982 2 года назад

    I had been to that cabin and not realized his grave was near it... lol. Awesome video strangeman

  • @brittanymeredith5242
    @brittanymeredith5242 4 года назад

    I’ve started my third playthrough this week, and I’m always finding new things thanks to your channel! Best RDR2 channel out here 🤘🏼

  • @Mescalero-Raider-12
    @Mescalero-Raider-12 3 года назад +1

    If you ask me Rockstar made the barrel rider is a two in one reference to LOTR and Annie Edson Taylor because the ‘Mysterious Hill’ home or the “Hobbit House” is not too far from Donner falls and obviously the woman and the poster represents Annie Edson Taylor.

  • @noway_josue28
    @noway_josue28 4 года назад

    Bruh, the last 2 famous people had me tearing up 🥺
    Awesome content. Keep it up!

  • @EmilyE2003
    @EmilyE2003 4 года назад +1

    I found the ice skating one myself, I was just exploring the map and stumbled soon that cabin. I thought his accident was that his leg was cut off while he was skating but I’m not sure.
    (Also, the difference between Arthur’s and John’s drawings is a nice detail, Arthur’s are better than Johns, the more detail he puts into it makes his drawing seem mature/older while John’s seem younger.)

    • @anonymous1hahaa
      @anonymous1hahaa 4 года назад

      i was just about to say the same thing about the sketches.

  • @sophiestauffer
    @sophiestauffer 4 года назад +1

    I found the barrel rider one day while in a canoe and I couldn’t find a video explaining it, thank you so much! :)

  • @lucabrito
    @lucabrito 2 года назад +1

    What if Old Hamish, the sweet war veteran, was in the other side of this ice skater battlefild a long time ago? and they had some beef between them? And after hearing about his long time enemy death, he went up the mountain and got the leg for himeself and wrote "No Ice in Hell" on the grave. If you think about it, Hamish have a prostetic leg aswell. And those are expensive as HELL.

  • @scottgainey602
    @scottgainey602 4 года назад

    You know, I've gone to that cabin and picked up that card and newspaper clipping numerous times through multiple playthroughs, and I never once looked over and saw his grave. Even after all my playthroughs I still learn or find something new.

  • @who7755
    @who7755 4 года назад

    Every time I start a new game I notice a new detail that blows me away

  • @SMScorx89
    @SMScorx89 4 года назад +1

    If you do a long-form video of the Civil War secrets in the game, it'd be cool. The Lemoine Raiders are just the tip of the iceberg in that department. There are also characters like Major Hobart Crawley (encountered in Saint Denis. He has a statue dedicated to him and those who served under his command in Rhodes), Joe Butler, Hayden Russell, and Hamish Sinclair. Events that could be covered are the Battle of Fort Brennand (with items left over at the site), the Battle at Scarlett Meadow (the Civil War battle, not the fight against the Lemoine Raiders), and the actions of General Quincy T. Harris (as well as everything surrounding this unseen character: his cigarette card, grave, the memorial hall named after him, newspaper clippings, his statue, and the NPC who says Harris who showed cowardice in the face of the enemy). There's also the corpse of a Corporal Garfield that can be found at the site of Scarlett Medow and the letters from his lover, Martha. This Martha is the same Martha who can be found in Martha's Swain in Ambarino. You could also throw in characters from the main story like Dutch's father being killed at Gettysburg or Henry Favour's dubious war record.

  • @landonricketts7140
    @landonricketts7140 4 года назад +1

    A idea video:
    The old veteran which is still in service after the war, maybe mickey or the old veteran at rhode.
    A mixe red dead redemption/ red dead redemption 2 ( accrodin to news/newpaper/rumor), exemple
    a place: fort mercer, tumbleweed, the church at armadillo...
    character: macfarlane's family, marshal leigh johnson, nigel west dicken...
    Red dead revolver?
    john's daugther?
    Walton's band/ bollard twin's band?

  • @truthhurts3524
    @truthhurts3524 2 года назад

    Pretty good zinger in the headline of the newspaper clipping of the skater. “Career cut short”.

  • @chimerastudio634
    @chimerastudio634 4 года назад

    this guy is pretty good. Great content and he actually shows people messages asking him to do videos.

  • @theworksho3947
    @theworksho3947 4 года назад +1

    If I may suggest: You should go to the journal locations as Arthur. I'm fairly certain his drawings are much better than John's scribbles haha! Great content as always!

  • @TheBattleMaster100
    @TheBattleMaster100 4 года назад +1

    I love your channel and your rdr2 content. I have the game and I'm always in awe when you release deeper meaning to things we never knew the background of. Please keep up the great work you do!

  • @totalcreativegaming6681
    @totalcreativegaming6681 3 года назад

    I think on the dead ice skater's tombstone it says "father" underneath the red painted message, so perhaps a scorned lover or an abandoned child he may have ditched when he went to live in the mountains after his accident, might have come back to vandalise his grave later on. or maybe a bitter skating rival or family member of a war victim (possibly from the opposing side) came to get revenge.

  • @edelweiss-
    @edelweiss- 4 года назад +2

    9:20 an competitor who was envious on Felix's success.

  • @akumasiouxpreme
    @akumasiouxpreme 4 года назад

    YES!!! my comment got put in the video, thank you Strange Man, you the REAL Legend of the West...awesome video as ALWAYS!!!

  • @somberstricken4424
    @somberstricken4424 4 года назад

    My favorite hat is the Nevada Hat. My Arthur is always clean shaving, hair slicked back, the best clothes, and his Nevada hat

  • @ehsra6535
    @ehsra6535 4 года назад

    You should do an entire rdr 2 storyline video only the important parts, and edit it together with that Music and everything because all your Videos are so tranquilizing

  • @sage3093
    @sage3093 4 года назад +1

    Given that the skater was a war veteran, maybe he killed someone in the war and that person’s family member swore vengeance. It would make sense as to why they think he’s in hell.

  • @vansmoken4172
    @vansmoken4172 3 года назад

    When I first played I found a lot of this stuff and thought “I hope a RUclipser finds out for us”. And you did. And still do. This is fine place

  • @novakan33
    @novakan33 4 года назад +1

    What was the music you used for the ice skater that sounded so beautiful I stopped watching your video for a second and zoned out and missed the whole segment I had to rewind to watch it again 🤣

    • @novakan33
      @novakan33 4 года назад

      Nvm I looked in the description 🤡

  • @TheFunctioningInsomniac
    @TheFunctioningInsomniac 4 года назад +1

    Got a video idea that I haven't seen anyone else touch: According to what I have read, you can find the cheats scattered in the world all across the map (the abandoned Native American site has one on the wall and the shipwreck on the very eastern tip of the map near Annesburg also has one) but those are the only two that I have been able to stumble across. A video listing out where all of them are located would be really cool. If you think that is a dumb idea then so be it, but keep being awesome regardless Strange Man!

    • @vDullahan
      @vDullahan 4 года назад +3

      Yeah they're scrawled into various drawers and even into the ice up in the mountains, there's lists of them already online though so I don't know if a video would be worth doing exactly, though I suppose knowing their locations would be a good excuse to explore again!

    • @TheFunctioningInsomniac
      @TheFunctioningInsomniac 4 года назад

      @@vDullahan For sure, I know that the lists are out there but I think it would be a video that would be a good showcase into the crazy shit that R* puts into their games.

    • @KristianD3
      @KristianD3 4 года назад

      "cheat code meanings explained" maybe?

  • @maisiemaisie123
    @maisiemaisie123 4 года назад

    Such a great channel, full of info and 0 clickbait! Thanks

  • @George_Oterson
    @George_Oterson 4 года назад

    His videos are so well put together.

  • @doubtfulme8504
    @doubtfulme8504 4 года назад

    I love your videos strange man and the music in the background

  • @gtafanboy4569
    @gtafanboy4569 4 года назад

    I found that skating card and wondered if you ever made a video about it and Here we are

  • @offroadoverlords
    @offroadoverlords 2 года назад

    Felix probably lived at the cabin so he could train on the lake prior the accident.
    And the vandalism and missing leg are likely references to Tony Harding trying to end Nancy Kerrigan's Career with a blow to the leg.

  • @Frank074
    @Frank074 4 года назад

    30 minutes online, already 380 likes. This channel is ace! No clickbait, no annoying talk, just the epic stuff that triggers our curiosity

  • @YoungCine
    @YoungCine 4 года назад

    godamn the video is so epic with that music and all. subbed

  • @seanhuds229
    @seanhuds229 3 года назад

    I remember hearing that allot of people tried going over Niagra falls in barrels, one of them tried it, they never found his body or the barrel, just his leg.

  • @heyitsromanletsgobowling7895
    @heyitsromanletsgobowling7895 4 года назад

    Your best you tuber that i see in my lifeyou deserve more than this

  • @mikea214
    @mikea214 4 года назад

    Nice, the day just got better with a new Strang Man video. Spectacular like always.

  • @admitrashchuk6411
    @admitrashchuk6411 4 года назад +1

    9 minutes 57 seconds is the highest point of not making your videos longer than they need to be

  • @cagnusmarlsen2571
    @cagnusmarlsen2571 4 года назад +1

    Maybe this is completely not relevant but maybe the story of the suicide note is linked to sheriff Malloy of Valentine since he is also wearing the Nevada hat and even changes the model to an older looking person during the rdr2 story.
    Also don't forget about his relationship with his wife which might depress him.

  • @AviJonker
    @AviJonker 4 года назад

    Very well put together video, good job.