My country is India and I would die for it . It should be known to those who have a doubt on my beliefs and those who think we want a different state. My brother said to me when asked do u want a different state he said i dont want be in a small state we live in a large state and it defines me . Never ever have doubt on our loyalty
@HALAKO KHAN as an indian i would request you to keep your opinion to yourself.. please don't come in between when two brothers are discussing..you are not welcome
No need to prove our loyalty to anyone If someone hve any doubt just remember if tommorow war breaks out with Pakistan more Sikhs will die for their country🇮🇳 than anyone else
People who are talking negative I want to tell them that Sikhs are smart enough to understand who is fake and who is ligit. There is not even 1% Sikhs who want khalistan. Majority of other Sikhs are happy going to kartar pur sahib for darshans. Today’s age pakistan can’t be successful if they do anything stupid. Be thankful to imran khan who did best for Sikhs and take it as a positive.
Imran khan want peace between India and Pakistan and best place to start he found kartar our corridor.He spent some money on it to save billions on feature defence budgets.hope people on both sides realize peace is the only way forward. Sikh community can play a big part bringing two nations together
solo rider Punjab have always been a muslim majority area. Hindus used sikhs as their slaves to divide punjab and make it part of indian union. Hahaha You are such a fool to say that. Real punjab is in Pakistan and only small part in india. Punjab belongeg to muslims even before sikh religion came into existence.
@Guru Word They are still killing Sikhs and Hindus. Look at minority number in Pakistan. It has come down from 23% to less than 3%. Yes there is bad history of 1984 and darbar sahab but that was political not religious issues. Still Sikhs voted Congress. Real Hindu understand sacrifices of Sikhs for india. Even guru ji fought against isalm to save india
Being human comes first, then our nation. Raised in the USA but born in Punjab, if needed and allowed, I will fight to the death for my Bharat mata. Jai Hind Jai Bharat!
Hindu is not a religious identity. It's a geographical identity, it doesn't have any belief system. Stop saying things as if Hindus are separate from Sikhs or Jains are separate or Buddhist are separate we share the same heritage. We are the share the same identity and different ways of life and respect each other's way as well. We are not exclusive identities such as -ISMS of the world, or destructive ideological concepts such as "religions". There are no "conversions" either you follow the way of life or not it's your personal pursuit. The attempt to make our civilizational knowledge and history as "religious" exclusive to each other is divisional propaganda. Learn the meaning of the word who were Hindus and why the guru's protected the "Hindus" pr the people of the land against the destructive conquest - they were not non-Hindus, they were Hindus and from Sikh community.
Nor are Muslims or Christians separate, they would have been Hindus as well when they have the same world view that conversion doesn't mean they are not part of the same civilization and no matter who they pray to don't give into dogmatic/exclusive definition of it. Conversion is a foreign concept, personal pursuit and respect to all other ways are the inclusive concept of this land which has allowed many communities to co-exist with each other. Hindus mean people of the land of Hindustan, don't confine its heritage and history into a destructive concept of religion, we don't need more -ISMS in the world.
Kerala gave me education. Bangalore gave me my first job. Madhya Pradesh gave me an opportunity to be part of IIM. Haryana gave me an opportunity to progress my career. India is strong together and we all should realize it. Some of my best friends are not Sikhs. Religion and ethnicity are not the only things binding us. Too myopic a view of humanity
You're so fucking cringe lmao Sikhs aren't protecting shit the Indian army is and the largest states contributing to Indian army by numbers is UP and Bihar...
When we visited Golden Temple, never felt like its different religion. It was beautiful, peaceful and really good. In fact we visited twice in 2-3 days stay.
The majority by 99 percent punjabis uk and Canada love india and I know this as im in the panjabi community. Any issues are never bigger than our house. Aka india. Love these videos everyone covering india helps my understanding of my ancestral home my belonging
@@Wanderer975 Pakistan Jinnah aur Muslim League ke ke zidd se bana tha koi referendum na tha. Kabhi Library jake History Book bhi padh liya karo tussi... 2000000 logo ko apne ghar se bhagaaya tu log Pakistan banaane ke liye.... Aaj bhi har saal 5000 logo Pakistan se bhaagna padta hai har saal apni jaan bachaakar
@@Wanderer975 Not only the hindus of India but also the sikhs, because the power will then be transferred from the Politicians, Civil Servants, Finance ministers to the local Jathedars who are extremely corrupt and they have very little to no brain. Punjab has faced a lot of blood shed because of few assholes in the past. We love living together and would keep on living together. Referendum would just disturb the peace we have been living in. 99% of the sikhs don't want Khalistan, they love this country, have defended it from your Superheroes "Abdali" "Nadir Shah" "Aurangzeb" etc. And keep on protecting it. I belong to a Hindu Family and have a Sikh wife. My sister is married to a Sikh Family who goes to Gurdwara and Temple both. This is the kind of understanding our community has in Punjab. I don't know what you know about it. But we are very happy here.
Being an Indian Sikh living in Canada, My heart only beats for India no matter what people are saying about Khalistan, everybody entitled to their own opinion but for me, I always lived as an Indian will die as an Indian. Jai Hind
But actually Canada is much better than your motherland and you liked it more than India, that is why you settled there. There is nothing like patrotism for a country. God created earth. Its people who divided it in country and nations with borders, walls and fencing and started taking nonsense pride in being a resident of a particular piece of land mass.
@@farhanraza29 what you said is true but if there were no religious or racial or creed realated tensions in the world all borders would be open for everyone and all countries of the world would be equal in all terms . Think about this if there's a war between Canada and India all of a sudden where LL those Sikhs go ? What you are talking only happens when you are highly religious so pls talk on reality . You yourself beilieve in Islam and LL side with a muslim instead of sikh most of the time . Why ? Because it's our ego and identities that we are born into and how it develops . Reality and religion and politics are diff things . Politics only mix reality and religion . That's where conflict arises between normal people . If you can seperate each of them in your mind and then see maybe you can see the reality of things away from all propagandas
I'm from Himachal will talk about that. I belong to district called Chamba. Baba Nanak visited once Chamba during his numerous urs of Himalayan state. The people of Chamba were so very much influenced by his presence that so many tales of him still flow here. The birth anniversary of pratham pita is celebrated here at next level. People start celebrating it 4 days prior of purnima. People wake up at 4 am do Prabhat feri, go to Gurudware Sahib (made at place where babaji stayed 500 years ago himself). Then go to main temple of Chamba and light diyas. Both in mornings and evenings. Then on the last day there's a big langar at atleast 3-4 places (Gurudwaras and temples). Entire town goes for langar. All this considering the fact Chamba is 90% Hindu 7% Muslim 2% sikh 1% Christian. Now why I brought this? Even if dividers win (tho they won't I'm sure) this won't end. They might will take those 2% with them (they can't, it's their land) but they can't take baba Nanak from here. His teachings, his influence, his magic on Chamba is eternal. They can take people, they can't take emotions. They can't take history, they can't take love. All this I'm writing while Shabd going on in Gurudwara Sahib , Amrit wani har har teri sunn sunn Howe Param gatt meri 🙏 Wmk ❤️ PS - it's not just Chamba, there are 100s of such places in Himachal alone, 1000s in India.
I am a Canadian 🇨🇦 Sikh born in Mumbai. Our motherland is India 🇮🇳 and we will give our lives for her. We love our fellow Indian brothers & sisters. India is our ❤️ ‘NO KHALISTAN EVER’ Only a handful of stupid Sikhs demand Khalistan. We will never let it happen 😊
@@DET-o4j Yo! This ain't a fake profile, this is my personal profile. We NRIs try to keep our country's name bright by working hard overseas. People like you, who live in INDIA doesn't respect their nation and still spread hate messages. Who cares if you have so much Anti-BJP shit in your head. Learn to respect the soil who brought you UP in life..
@@neverfallinlove.5801 yes bro, he is NOT an Indian. Such people wear masks & live in our society. They are so jealous of people who are true Patriots. God bless them with good sense.
I m hindu and have lots of faith in Guru and want to travel to kartarpur. But not allowed by Pak for non Sikhs, even im ready to pay Zazia of 20 dollar. That is unfair.
@@arundhar5791 Pakistan is bastard nation we all know why they gave permission for kartarpir corridor but not for hindu in Hingla mata temple etc. But they forget India moves ahead of 1947, 1971 it will back fire. Life of kartar pur corridor is utmost 5 year, as Pak army soon feel india is more united than past And it is failure of their propoganda
@@sarabjitsingh5327 So, in one post you revealed yourself as a bigot, Hindu-hater and a fake Sikh! Must be so hard to be a Pakitard! Your whole identity is a lie! Pretend to be Arab one day, and then Sikh the next! LOL! But do please keep yapping! Let the gullible ones on my side see your true face! There is no peace to be had with you or your ilk! We broke you into 2 parts in 1971! Keep yapping so that BJP rules with Super majorities for at least the next 10 years! We will break Pakiland into another 4 little pieces by that time!
@@truthteller6827 just like me,u also cannot speak for another agenda ..keep in mind..only when one party(pakistan) start poisioning a sect patriotism..then only other party(indian people) start to respond on it..otherwise each one of us in India knows sikh contributions in indian defence and never publicised unnecessarily
kalyan konka I’m afraid this is bull crap how can you say this while you have the Kashmiris under siege, I can easily say you might do this to the punjjabis Sikhs.
@@truthteller6827 kashmiris not under siege if u compare Kashmir blackout regularly for many many months continuously without any solution or outcome and continued infiltration from local parties ..now it is clearing it's fatigue slowly and this is permanent solution from the view of India and only anti national saying it's a mistake..may be u need to cross check ur national priorities..Sikhs are most respected sect through out India pls dont compare it with Islamic infiltrators
Robot Ace Actually I believe that it should open. People should go there, ignore the propaganda, take advantage and worship, and then return, thereby proving to Pakistan that no matter how much they try, they will not be able to divide India. That people of all religion are in India by choice, not because it was forced on them.
@@alwaysrushil Then Indian security forces must take extra precaution, Some plain cloths must travel.with the devotees to make sure any indoctrination isn't carried out once at the Pakistani side. I'm positive as Long as Captain sahab is CM, nothing will happen.
And 1984 was really very unfortunate n saddening. It was handiwork of congress goons like sajjan Kumar n others but iam happy that law it's finally catching up n oNe by oNe these murderers are being taken to task even though very late as congress didn't allow it during their rule n tried to give it Hindu Vs Sikh spin for their electoral benefits ,but it was not hindus rather it was few mad dogs of congress who went wild to please their political masters, it was not religious it was political it was Congressman Vs Sikhs in reality. We should do everything to heal that scar n reach out to our Sikh brothers N sisters as a community. But believe me all Indians are really proud of our mighty Sikh brothers n their uprightness. Wahe Guru ji da Khalsa Wahe Guru ji di Fareh
@@guruword8378 I don't dis agree that those congressman happened to be Hindus n that's a disgrace as a Hindu am ashamed of that . But non of them were doing anything for Hindus or spreading violence in name of or for the religion ,they were doing it as purely as congressman as political workers they were pleasing their masters . And I personally feel they should have been brought to justice much much before only if Congress under Gandhis would have allowed. It was Anti Sikh riot but it was not one community vs another community riot rather it was Workers of The Then Ruling Party attacking The Innocent Sikhs. IT WAS HORRIBLE
@@guruword8378 in India we are already following the same system... Every state has its own CM they decided 95% of their decision own their own... Finance... Education... Health... Food everything is under state run machinery... Even law and order is a state subject. Only border security is under center... Every state has a autonomy of a kind where their own people select who they want to make MLAs and Sarpanchs or MCs.
Vijay Kumar u do realize the ggs insults the Hindu deity Krishna and it also insults most of concept/rituals In sanatan dharm and then it’s says to respect other religion like wtf it’s fully of hypocrisy.
@@anusingh3236 We have arya samaji hindu we have Jains who don't believe in what we believe still we have people from all over the world come to Kumbh mela celebrate holi n other festivals would you believe they are increasing every year so we don't have to worry about Shree Ram n Krishna if you believe they exist
Imran Khan is a toilet paper which is being used by Pakistan Army right now to wage their idea of jIHAD on India. At the end of his tenure he will lose his self esteem and respect all over the world.
punkination due i addition to what you have mentioned IK is also a wild playboy, double divorcee and having illegitimate children around the world. He is also the selected PM ( as said by your people and media). Nowdays he is famously called as international beggar begging in front of China every month, in front of IMF and in front of Arab countries. Keep living in the bubble that world is laughing at India.
punkination well i would definately comment on IKs leadership at end of his tenure as PM. Currently he is called as U turn PM of Pakistan. So will see for another 4 years what he does. Whether he makes pakistani economy stand on its feet rather than taking loans from entire world.
Sikhs are the pride of India. I live in UK since last 28 yrs and the moment I see a Sikh anywhere I know I have met a true Indian😊 Waahe Guru Satnam 🙏🏻
NEHRU HAD OFFERED KHALISTAN TO AKALI LEADER TARA SINGH , real name Nank Chand Malhotra !!! Please read page 269 of book by Durga Das INDIA FROM CURZON TO NEHRU AND AFTER but Tara Singh had REFUSED !!!
Many Sindhi's are followers of Guru Nanak Dev too (my dad used to read the Guru Granth Sahib every day and I still have It in my temple although I can't read Gurmukhi) and by opening up the corridor exclusively for Sikhs only, Pakistan's intentions are transparent for all. Yes, India will react to the Khalistan bogie but Sikhs and Punjabis who experienced the horrors of the Partition will never trust Pakistan. It's only the people living out posh lives in Canada and elsewhere abroad who rattle the Khalistan saber, for political gains no less. If they've found a friend in Pakistan then maybe they should make that their country. Sikhs in India are Indians first.
What exactly makes you think that while Sikh will not trust Pakistan in the remembrance of horrors of partition, but will make India trust able in the aftermath of 1984 and the Sikh genocide that followed afterwards. Is it just a choosy remembrance on part of sikhs or a way for Indians to ensure themselves.
I am an India, Hindu by faith and I have been to Harmandir Saheb, Bangla Sahib, Anandpur Sahib and Gurudwara in Yamunanagar and also in England. I always find peace in sacrifices of Guru ji, forever indebted to all my sikh brothers. Love them to core.
I believe Sikhs are most patriotic part of India.. the nationalism and love for India is unmatched... they are the true religious entity who never discriminate between we and others... Proud that sikhism belongs to this land... and this land is India
If you're true sikh...then u will never demand for different state like khalisthan... cz gurus gave us lesson of unity and to live together for each other with love and respect. Jai Hind
A pro India and a kind of pro Hindu comment from Shekhar Gupta!!!!! Rare for The Print, member of Lutyens!!! Keep it up. You may even become a Hindu one day.
That Pakistan will fail again in instigating the khalistanis may be true. But its attempts will cause enough disruptions in Indian society and polity. As the proverb goes, “ Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty”.
"Partition of British India" into Pakistan and India through a British parliamentary act was nothing more than the Partition of Punjab (East and West) and Partition of Bengal (East and West) so if Punjab and Bengal are going to "reconnect" again by any means (soft or hard) then the purpose of partionting of British India will automatically diminishes. It's a historic moment that today East and West Punjab are reconnecting again after 72 years of divide, I'm looking forward to see similar reconnection between East and West Bengal then "Indian Independence Act July 18, 1947" will die on that moment...that will be a big day and new beginning in Subcontinent.
@@tejadarkar @ this is how British ruled this region - divide and rule. Baloch divided into Iran, Afghanistan, Balochistan and Sindh, Pashtuns divided into KPK, Afghanistan, Balochistan and Punjab, likewise the whole Subcontinent is ripe apart into the way no single ethnic group should be at one place. In my opinion within the Subcontinent, the entire region to be redefined so that each ethnic group should be under one roof and then these groups should make UNION to run the Subcontinent.
It's funny how just a handfull of inconsequential people keep bringing Khalistan . I just have one question to them are you willing to abandon takts which Are not in Punjab . I was born a Sikh and an Indian and hence my loyalty lie to this land where gurunanak travelled and guru Govind Singh gave us the name Singh to protect this land . They traveled all over India . Anyway there is no such Khalistan movement they are just few useless people but giving them media coverage just creates a hoax
I’m a Maharastrian and live in Canada. I am very happy about this development and would like to Thank Imran Khan for opening up access to this holy place for Sikhs... though I m not a Sikh I revere Guru Nanak Deo. I’m proud of my fellow Sikhs and their contribution to India. I regret the alienation some of them feel - as I have heard much misguided propaganda in Canada. My greetings in my personal capacity to the Sikh community. You are an important and integral part of strong prosperous and peaceful India !!
Because they are courageous and patriotic, and above all they have a big heart, as an Indian from NE I can say that many of my NE bros and sis might complain of racism etc against north indians but they have no such complains against the Sikhs, that says a lot about them.
@@Wanderer975 well, Sikhism Buddhism Jainism all came from Hinduism. & People of These religions are existing in harmony without any conflict or hate between them & these people don't put their religion above their motherland unlike some invasive species. Hope you understand pork🐷
@@hector1094 rather than saying Sikhism came from Hinduism,it better to say Sikhism,Buddhism,Jainism ,,Hinduism,Sufism like dharmic religions born in this land.
Sekhar Gupta is a gem. After listening left to right wing journalists for a long I come across that Sekhar Guptat's analysis is more genuine and less partial. Great work sir! Plz maintain the standard. Jai Hind.
Both Bhindranwale and Indira Gandhi desecrated the shrine of Golden Temple at Amritsar in 1984. Whereas Sikhs have the courage to criticize Indira Gandhi and the Indian army but lack the courage to criticize Bhindranwale and his gang for desicrating the beautiful Golden Temple by taking arms and ammunition to the holy place in the first place. REAL Sikh lion Khushwant Singh was one of the few Sikhs to criticize both Bhindranwale and Indira Gandhi for their unholy acts.
Apparently I belong to hindu family and my sister married into sikh family..Pakistanis will never believe the joy of sikhs while watching gadar-ek prem katha or the movie border for that matter...pak army won't forget one name ever I.e kuldeep singh chandpuri and battle of longewala
Leaders like Imran Khan are exemplary and rare. Sour grapes to those who try to belittle him. It is shameful that this reporter is so blind to someone who cares about peace and justice. Well, justice will prevail and the world will recognise the great leader Imran Khan is.
I am from Hindu community, 1984 was unfortunate, and i was not even born at that time, and neither I belong to Delhi region. I am from bihar, and still you ask me to apologise, i will brother on behalf of every culprit, political parties etc. Agree that we are polytheists, but still Guru Nanak, Guru Govind Singh, Guru Arjan Dev inspire us, gives a big sense of pride to us. Even i am typing this comment from a Sikh's House in Patel Nagar, Delhi. We are brothers from different mothers. Culturally we may be a bit different, but by blood we're one. And a important fact, The great king Maharaja Ranjit Singh has donated kilos of Gold to the Kashi Vishwanath Temple. We're one, and nobody can separate us.
Sikhs the world over are planting trees to help the earth's environment. Wish we would all join them by planting at least a tree for each family member.
Because sikhism preaches secularism. In my history book it is written that guru nanaka sahib visited mecca as well as pandharpur.💗. Love from maharashtra.
@InfoTv so, I am from Hindu community, 1984 was unfortunate, and i was not even born at that time, and neither I belong to Delhi region. I am from bihar, and still you ask me to apologise, i will brother on behalf of every culprit, political parties etc. Agree that we are polytheists, but still Guru Nanak, Guru Govind Singh, Guru Arjan Dev inspire us, gives a big sense of pride to us. Even write i am typing this comment from a Sikh's House in Patel Nagar, Delhi. We are brothers from different mothers. Culturally we may be a bit different, but by blood we're one. And a important fact, The great king Maharaja Ranjit Singh has donated kilos of Gold to the Kashi Vishwanath Temple. We're one, and nobody can separate us.
Punjabi here my guess is it will revive the wounded feeling that punjab holds. Wounds which can not be healed until places like lahore and narowal are united with punjab again
If there is no fear, then why term it as Pakistan's fantasy. For once, can we have the grace to thank Imran Khan for his gesture. He didn't have to do it in the current hostility between the 2 countries but yet he chose to do it. So let's give credit where it is due...
Uno what..... We shouldnt be even talkin about this. Coz if we do then it kinda indicates that v r worried about it. And it puts the sikhs in an uncomfortable position. Coz they be thinkin that we r suspecting our doubting their loyalty...... Think about it.
Sikhs r more patriot nd loyal for India than any other comunity ,i love them i respect my Gurus i first worship Guru gobind Singh ji bfore other gods,if pakistan army/isi have some bad intention they wil never suceed nd will hv to quit kartarpur sahib nd nankana sahib permanently for us
Celebrate our diversity and trust of fellow citizens.... wow... that’s something I have heard after six years.... India is currently afflicted by Pakistannoisis.... an affliction which suspects anybody , who doesn’t confirm to this very narrow definition of Nationalism...India and Indians are much better than that.
India is a much stronger country than before. India is not made of porcelain. Indian nationalism has mastured each other. We must learn to trust each each other. And if we can't trust any group of fellow Indians, because they belong to a certain community, or a linguistic group, etc, I think we do ourselves a great disservice. So this is a time to forget all that, I would say go even beyond our old slogan of 'Unity in Diversity' and say 'Celebrate Diversity'". Shekhar Sir 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Unfortunately a new wave of anti bengali sentiment is growing. Bengalis are equal Indian like any other Indians. Bengalis are most patriotic. Bengalis fought for independence more than any other communities. So in the name of NRC Bengalis should not be tortured. Like Guiratis, Punajbis, Marathis or any other Indians Bengalis has equal right in India. So please stop harassing bengalis in Assam or North East India. When India has been divided on the basis of Religion, Bengali Hindus living in India (fled from Bangladesh) must be accepted as Indian. They never wanted Pakistan. So stop hating Bengalis. Read History and think a lot about the contribution of Bengalis. If India can shelter 20 crore muslims then why not 19 lakh Bengali Hindus of Assam or Bengali Hindus of North East and West Bengal?
Our beloved Sikh brothers are very patriotic and kind hearted, sikhs are jewel in the crown of India, khalistan was instigated by Pakistan to divide India, if Indian Punjab merge, the Punjabi Muslims will kill our Sikh brothers and sisters to snatching the holy land of Baaba Sri Gurunanak Dev hi who blessed India to prosperous and brother hood ...
Isi and Pakistan have come up with an old plan. Since Pakistan has always created hatered towards Hindus and Sikhs from their primary education onwards. Today they are showing long lost love. They forget that it was radical Islam against which the Gurus gave their lives. Their fantasy can never come to reality. Though the ISI has done some work on the expats in Canada, UK and US. Hope these people understand their game can never come to play. Pakistan will break and annexation of West Punjab our capital will be Lahore.
Delhi is historically biggest city of Punjab. It should become capital of Khslistan. Lahore is muslim populated city and it will stay in Pakistan Punjab. Delhi or amritsar are good choices for Khalistan capital
@@kandsa13 😂🤣 No bro there is no fight between muslims and sikhs. United Punjab was divided because hindus wanted sikhs to divide it and make east punjab part of india otherwise it was decided that whole punjab was to be part of Pakistan. Lahore pehle hi punjabiyon ke paas hai. Khalistan ka Capital delhi hai aur East punjab vich khalistan baneda
@@Wanderer975 dude be careful, ye khalistan banane ke chakkar mein kahi balochistan mat kho dena hahahaha since we have good experience of how to break you haha
Sir Ji : Earlier, we had Bell Curve theory within the boundaries of our Nation. Can it be applicable for SAARC countries and later for the Village called GLOBE ?? 🙏🙏
Not really. Bell curve appplies to India since India chose to use it. That's not case with the world overall. Presntly, it is all about anti-globalization or relocalization occuring since globalization has created fear of diluton of native culture amonst many people across the globe (which is partially true). And in case of SAARC, you need to pay attention to addiction of Pak to use state sponsored terrorism as a sub-conventional warfare. That doesn't falls in bell curve pattern.
Im a pakistani in the west and have got loads of indian mates. Man,s are talking on here like pakistan has set a trap up its your religious legacy and it was our honour to help build a bridge. Its 2019 and its a gesture of good will to the punjabi brothers and sisters. Just like any other people if you push us we push back you hug us we take you in. build the bridge between sikhs and pakistan we share alot of history good and bad but were still trying on both sides. I think imran khan is a rare breed hes got alot of ideas. This guys getting it hard from some of the other parties about ventures mainly the skint currency but hes still trying. Its easy to call an entire nation terrorstan but then that nation opens its heart and everyone wants to find faults. Truth is extremists on all religions are destroying the asian continent the party in charge of india will in no way talk to pakistan. It might bring peace to the lands.
We hindus have always degraded ourselves to praise the sikhs to repent for the sins of a political party but it hurts my heart to see khalistanis pouring out vicious islamic propaganda from their mouths.
Khalistan means "land of the khalsa". I don't understand why some want Khalistan. We already HAVE Khalistan. We have India because India is, has been, and always will be the land of the Khalsa
@@rohitroll2119 Well, we asked for it, even we are aware of their nefarious designs, if they ever even TRY to do any nonsense, they'll be hammered to smithereens, let that be clear.
@@rohitroll2119 I don't trust them. I trust our own ability to keep splitting them into smithereens at will and when needed ..let our sikhs have access to their shrine in the meanwhile
We have a lot of love for Sikhs in Pakistan. We are delighted that Kartarpur has opened. I don't think that it's opening has been orchestrated to facilitate the birth of Khalistan. It's not our business. In fact there is no evidence at all to support the idea that Sikhs want a separate State, it is all speculative talk & nothing else. Happy to welcome all Sikhs that come for pilgrimage, and Sikhs of all descriptions, from separatists to hardcore patriotic Indian Nationalists. I repeat it is none of our business, I don't think we have politicised it, nor have we made any declarations of support for Khalistan. Please do not expect us to police the conversations that happen at religious sites, it is not our role. Thank You. .
We have trusted Pakistanis many times to be betrayed later. Problem is Pakistani government is just a puppet of Pakistani Deep State (Pak Army+ISI) and their prime motive is to destabilize India. Because of 3 major reasons: 1. India had been established as an existential threat to Pakistan since Independence by the Pak Army. 2. Pakistan is struggling to gain Kashmir due to its geopolitical importance and water resources. 3. They want to avenge the seperation of Bangladesh, which they consider is planned and done by India. So we can't trust Pakistani civilian Government ever. And yes, Khalistan movement was indeed revived by the efforts of ISI in midst of Punjab political crisis in late 1970s.
Look guys its a positive step and corridor opening should be celebrated. Its just like thousands of temples everywhere but Ayodhya temple is the only one where lord Rama was born and because of this importance there was this long dispute. Same for Kartarpur Sahib. There are many Gurudwaras but only one Kartarpur Sahib where Guru Nanak Dev ji spent last 18 years of his life . So from spiritual point of view its unmatachable and for the first time since independence we are able to visit there which is amazing.
The ambition of a few men should not be taken as the ambition of the masses. India is not India without Sikhs. Sikhs don't want to be Indian, aisa ho hi nahi sakta.
To cut the clutter for you, please watch the video (specially from 3:47 to 3:55). ruclips.net/video/WvnjZMXb5dE/видео.html her words are "im a hindu, married to a christian, visiting a gurdwara in a muslim country" this is a goodwill gesture for the Sikh community. Leave it like that. dont do politics on it. dont try to increase your ratings by spreading hate. i know it would be hard for you to digest good news coming from pakistan. change your perspective of pakistan to declutter your brain.
My Sikh brothers and sisters are a gift to this nation and most patriotic indians.I greatly admire them and who can forget the sacrifice of Guru Tegh Bahadur for protecting hindus.Wahe Guruji Ka khalsa Wahe Guruji Ki Fatah.
Im Tamilian, lived in northern parts of India some time. Sikhs are India's first line of deffence always. Maybe they have opinions and issues but there are no question about their patriotism. I have belive in a Sardar brother then our Congress party leaders.
Whenever India has won a Cricket World Cup , it has had Muslim and Sikh cricketers in the team along with Hindus. 1983 - Syed Kirmani, Balwinder Sandhu 2007 T20 - Yuvraj Singh and Harbhajan Singh, Irfan and Yusuf Pathan 2011- Yuvraj and Harbhajan Singh, Zaheer Khan and Munaf Patel. how many Sikh international cricketers does Pakistan have ? How many did it ever have ? and I'm not going into Hockey, Athletics, other Sports, Bollywood, Army, Bureaucracy, Judiciary, Business etc etc. Jai🇮🇳
Best Wishes on Kartarpur Sahib -Dera Baba Nanak Corridor In their Ardaas Sikhs pray for Reunion with their key gurudwaras " Jehhrey vichhora de gaye " ( in 1947 - came under Pakistan ) The corridor is beginning of ending the " Vichhora " and answer to their Ardaas. In 1947 Sikhs chose to side with India . It was because of this support that MA Jinnah 's tactic , of getting undivided Punjab for Pakistan , was defeated. Not only India got East Punjab but , very crucially , the town of of Pathankot without which India would not have got any connectivity to Jammu and Kashmir.Without Sikhs' support India would have lost not only East Punjab but ,also , Jammu and Kashmir. Sikhs are pride of India. By appearance a Non Sikh could be from any country of South Asia but a Sikh is , for sure , an Indian. ------------------- But Pakistan's Deep State's motives need further study. Example : at Gurudwara Kartarpur Sahib , an Unexploded bomb casing has been prominently displayed in the Gurudwara sahib compound . The message reads that in the 1971 War this bomb was DELIBERATELY dropped by Indian Air Force to DESTROY Gurudwara Kartarpur Sahib !!!!
We have no intention of reviving khalistan movement. Imran khan and his party have stated several times this is to promote tourism in Pakistan. And have a little faith in your Sikh community. They are not children that anyone can convince them to rebel against there homeland. Stop spreading lies.
My country is India and I would die for it . It should be known to those who have a doubt on my beliefs and those who think we want a different state. My brother said to me when asked do u want a different state he said i dont want be in a small state we live in a large state and it defines me . Never ever have doubt on our loyalty
Never ever doubt each other!
Otherwise they will succeed.
Bravo
No one doubts your loyalty bro..
You can move to india. Khalistan is for sikhs who were massacred by hindutva state. No one will force you to stay in Khalistan
@@Wanderer975 Fuck you..
I m Sikh I live in India and die in India ... But I want to go to Pakistan for my gurdwaras ... But live and die for India that's my nation .
We dont have an iota of doubt sir.. i wish our brothers in canda and uk realise that whole India is khalistan
@HALAKO KHAN as an indian i would request you to keep your opinion to yourself.. please don't come in between when two brothers are discussing..you are not welcome
How about get those land back . Like kartarpur , what that piece of land near border doing in Pakistan. That should have been part of India.
@@mohitshukla4911 Well said Bro!
Teri foto mein dikh raha hai, kitna toon sikh hai.
Kyon jabardasti sikh kehla raha hai, hindu ka baana acha lagta hai. To wahi ban jaaa.
No need to prove our loyalty to anyone
If someone hve any doubt just remember if tommorow war breaks out with Pakistan more Sikhs will die for their country🇮🇳 than anyone else
Nicely put bro.
We never should have the need to prove ourselves.
We have nothing to prove to anytime
I am a proud Indian. And i don't ask you to prove anything. U r more patriotic than me. And i am also a modi bhakt☺️.
Exactly! We feel safe in India because we know that our Sikh brothers are on our side! Jai Hindi!
Jai hind
People who are talking negative I want to tell them that Sikhs are smart enough to understand who is fake and who is ligit. There is not even 1% Sikhs who want khalistan. Majority of other Sikhs are happy going to kartar pur sahib for darshans. Today’s age pakistan can’t be successful if they do anything stupid. Be thankful to imran khan who did best for Sikhs and take it as a positive.
Sikhs are the Shaan and jaan of India 🙏🏻
Imran khan want peace between India and Pakistan and best place to start he found kartar our corridor.He spent some money on it to save billions on feature defence budgets.hope people on both sides realize peace is the only way forward. Sikh community can play a big part bringing two nations together
Show me this study where you got 1%?
Pak punjab belongs to Sikhs. People who slaughtered and converted Sikhs are now talking about the legacy of Sikhism😑
solo rider Punjab have always been a muslim majority area. Hindus used sikhs as their slaves to divide punjab and make it part of indian union.
Hahaha
You are such a fool to say that. Real punjab is in Pakistan and only small part in india.
Punjab belongeg to muslims even before sikh religion came into existence.
what about these sikhs and hindus that killed muslims in 1947 it went both ways
@Guru Word They are still killing Sikhs and Hindus. Look at minority number in Pakistan. It has come down from 23% to less than 3%. Yes there is bad history of 1984 and darbar sahab but that was political not religious issues. Still Sikhs voted Congress. Real Hindu understand sacrifices of Sikhs for india. Even guru ji fought against isalm to save india
Punjab is Muslim majority and has been since even before Sikhism existed.
BS jackass shit mentality our jat and Rajput ancestors were muslims long before partition.
Amazing sir, am a South Indian married to a sardarni..... it’s simply amazing....
Nice sir enjoy ❤
Ulta 2 states..
Most welcome sir.....
We shouldn't start doubting each other
If we do, then they win
Mistrust between religion is their aim
Being human comes first, then our nation. Raised in the USA but born in Punjab, if needed and allowed, I will fight to the death for my Bharat mata. Jai Hind Jai Bharat!
I don't think Sikhism is a religion It's part of Indian culture "Guru sisya parampara" like budhhism and Jainism
Hindu is not a religious identity. It's a geographical identity, it doesn't have any belief system. Stop saying things as if Hindus are separate from Sikhs or Jains are separate or Buddhist are separate we share the same heritage. We are the share the same identity and different ways of life and respect each other's way as well. We are not exclusive identities such as -ISMS of the world, or destructive ideological concepts such as "religions". There are no "conversions" either you follow the way of life or not it's your personal pursuit. The attempt to make our civilizational knowledge and history as "religious" exclusive to each other is divisional propaganda. Learn the meaning of the word who were Hindus and why the guru's protected the "Hindus" pr the people of the land against the destructive conquest - they were not non-Hindus, they were Hindus and from Sikh community.
Nor are Muslims or Christians separate, they would have been Hindus as well when they have the same world view that conversion doesn't mean they are not part of the same civilization and no matter who they pray to don't give into dogmatic/exclusive definition of it. Conversion is a foreign concept, personal pursuit and respect to all other ways are the inclusive concept of this land which has allowed many communities to co-exist with each other. Hindus mean people of the land of Hindustan, don't confine its heritage and history into a destructive concept of religion, we don't need more -ISMS in the world.
Kerala gave me education. Bangalore gave me my first job. Madhya Pradesh gave me an opportunity to be part of IIM. Haryana gave me an opportunity to progress my career. India is strong together and we all should realize it. Some of my best friends are not Sikhs. Religion and ethnicity are not the only things binding us. Too myopic a view of humanity
I want every Indian to experience what you have. Inspiring.
Then we will have more sense of respect for each other. Great Gurpreet.
Ek bhappa sau syappa
As a tamilian I sleep peacefully when I know my sikh brothers are guarding the country's borders.
You're so fucking cringe lmao Sikhs aren't protecting shit the Indian army is and the largest states contributing to Indian army by numbers is UP and Bihar...
Sikh sovereignty is in full swing now! I respect Tamils but we do not identify with India
@@ajeebdastan1152 Really!! Ranjit Singhs empire went up to Afghanistan!!! So would you be capturing Lahore and Kabul too??
When we visited Golden Temple, never felt like its different religion. It was beautiful, peaceful and really good. In fact we visited twice in 2-3 days stay.
It is different accept it
The majority by 99 percent punjabis uk and Canada love india and I know this as im in the panjabi community. Any issues are never bigger than our house. Aka india. Love these videos everyone covering india helps my understanding of my ancestral home my belonging
Then Why hindutva state is scared of Referendum 2020.
Let it happen and you will see what sikhs want
@@Wanderer975 Pakistan ka referendum krwa pehle chaar hisso mein bat jaayega
@@rahulray9983 Pakistan aik referendum se hi bana tha. india mein referendum nahin hua jo ghalat hai. Referendum hona chahiye
@@Wanderer975 Pakistan Jinnah aur Muslim League ke ke zidd se bana tha koi referendum na tha. Kabhi Library jake History Book bhi padh liya karo tussi...
2000000 logo ko apne ghar se bhagaaya tu log Pakistan banaane ke liye....
Aaj bhi har saal 5000 logo Pakistan se bhaagna padta hai har saal apni jaan bachaakar
@@Wanderer975 Not only the hindus of India but also the sikhs, because the power will then be transferred from the Politicians, Civil Servants, Finance ministers to the local Jathedars who are extremely corrupt and they have very little to no brain. Punjab has faced a lot of blood shed because of few assholes in the past. We love living together and would keep on living together. Referendum would just disturb the peace we have been living in. 99% of the sikhs don't want Khalistan, they love this country, have defended it from your Superheroes "Abdali" "Nadir Shah" "Aurangzeb" etc. And keep on protecting it. I belong to a Hindu Family and have a Sikh wife. My sister is married to a Sikh Family who goes to Gurdwara and Temple both. This is the kind of understanding our community has in Punjab. I don't know what you know about it. But we are very happy here.
If you really a true Sikh then you cannot ask for a country based on religion as our gurus taught us that all are equal. That is what I believe.
Have u ever heard about word "romanticism"?this word can force u do those thing which u even didnt expect to do.
Being an Indian Sikh living in Canada, My heart only beats for India no matter what people are saying about Khalistan, everybody entitled to their own opinion but for me, I always lived as an Indian will die as an Indian. Jai Hind
But actually Canada is much better than your motherland and you liked it more than India, that is why you settled there. There is nothing like patrotism for a country. God created earth. Its people who divided it in country and nations with borders, walls and fencing and started taking nonsense pride in being a resident of a particular piece of land mass.
@@farhanraza29 why you are talking about Canada is better than India are you propagating Pakistan's rubbish agenda?
@@farhanraza29 what you said is true but if there were no religious or racial or creed realated tensions in the world all borders would be open for everyone and all countries of the world would be equal in all terms .
Think about this if there's a war between Canada and India all of a sudden where LL those Sikhs go ?
What you are talking only happens when you are highly religious so pls talk on reality .
You yourself beilieve in Islam and LL side with a muslim instead of sikh most of the time .
Why ? Because it's our ego and identities that we are born into and how it develops .
Reality and religion and politics are diff things .
Politics only mix reality and religion .
That's where conflict arises between normal people .
If you can seperate each of them in your mind and then see maybe you can see the reality of things away from all propagandas
Im Sikh and proud to be Hindustani 🇮🇳Jai Hind
Do you really think you or your bjp IT cell Sikh profiles are fooling anybody?
I'm from Himachal will talk about that. I belong to district called Chamba. Baba Nanak visited once Chamba during his numerous urs of Himalayan state. The people of Chamba were so very much influenced by his presence that so many tales of him still flow here. The birth anniversary of pratham pita is celebrated here at next level. People start celebrating it 4 days prior of purnima. People wake up at 4 am do Prabhat feri, go to Gurudware Sahib (made at place where babaji stayed 500 years ago himself). Then go to main temple of Chamba and light diyas. Both in mornings and evenings. Then on the last day there's a big langar at atleast 3-4 places (Gurudwaras and temples). Entire town goes for langar. All this considering the fact Chamba is 90% Hindu 7% Muslim 2% sikh 1% Christian.
Now why I brought this? Even if dividers win (tho they won't I'm sure) this won't end.
They might will take those 2% with them (they can't, it's their land) but they can't take baba Nanak from here. His teachings, his influence, his magic on Chamba is eternal.
They can take people, they can't take emotions. They can't take history, they can't take love.
All this I'm writing while Shabd going on in Gurudwara Sahib , Amrit wani har har teri sunn sunn Howe Param gatt meri 🙏
Wmk ❤️
PS - it's not just Chamba, there are 100s of such places in Himachal alone, 1000s in India.
True
I am a Canadian 🇨🇦 Sikh born in Mumbai. Our motherland is India 🇮🇳 and we will give our lives for her. We love our fellow Indian brothers & sisters. India is our ❤️ ‘NO KHALISTAN EVER’
Only a handful of stupid Sikhs demand Khalistan. We will never let it happen 😊
Please tell the BJP IT Cell to try and make more convincing fake Sikh profiles. Lol. Also if India is sdo great, go live in India.
@@DET-o4j Yo! This ain't a fake profile, this is my personal profile. We NRIs try to keep our country's name bright by working hard overseas. People like you, who live in INDIA doesn't respect their nation and still spread hate messages. Who cares if you have so much Anti-BJP shit in your head. Learn to respect the soil who brought you UP in life..
@@SatKandhalia if u think bro, he is an indian then ur wrong??
@@neverfallinlove.5801 yes bro, he is NOT an Indian. Such people wear masks & live in our society. They are so jealous of people who are true Patriots. God bless them with good sense.
I m hindu and have lots of faith in Guru and want to travel to kartarpur.
But not allowed by Pak for non Sikhs, even im ready to pay Zazia of 20 dollar.
That is unfair.
Pakistanis are religious fanatics. They see everyone with the eyes of religion. I dont even know how their country are running like this.
@@arundhar5791
Pakistan is bastard nation we all know why they gave permission for kartarpir corridor but not for hindu in Hingla mata temple etc.
But they forget
India moves ahead of 1947, 1971 it will back fire.
Life of kartar pur corridor is utmost 5 year, as Pak army soon feel india is more united than past
And it is failure of their propoganda
You are? Everyone is dude! Just read the MoU for once and if you need any help, find a person with a turban and a beard, they always help :)
@@jazsm5385
Thanks bro but whatever i read in news non sikh r not allowed.
If ur right than my dream to visit kartarpur sahib will come true.
Your statement of zaziya reveals why you are not allowed to go .... Take it with good spirit
I am an Indian Sikh believing in India!!
Sikhs and India together forever!! Sikhs will always protect and be a part of India forever!!
Whenever people talk about *Separatist movement in Punjab* i just laugh...
Because I know what Indian Sikhs are made of.😎
Pakistan can keep trying.
First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win
@@sarabjitsingh5327 and we won! Get on with it!
@@sarabjitsingh5327 So, in one post you revealed yourself as a bigot, Hindu-hater and a fake Sikh! Must be so hard to be a Pakitard! Your whole identity is a lie! Pretend to be Arab one day, and then Sikh the next! LOL!
But do please keep yapping! Let the gullible ones on my side see your true face! There is no peace to be had with you or your ilk! We broke you into 2 parts in 1971! Keep yapping so that BJP rules with Super majorities for at least the next 10 years! We will break Pakiland into another 4 little pieces by that time!
@@neildutta fattu RSS. Sabhi post delete karwa diye.Aise jitoge.Landoo hindus
@@neildutta jo bhi question pooche wo paki ya congressi kyon ho jataa
hai.Hindu religion hijacked
by RS.S.
Nobody can doubt Sikh's patriotism 🇮🇳
Our sikh brothers are too patriotic towards india that pakistan don't even think of this blunder
kalyan konka please you do not speak for Sikhs.
@@truthteller6827 just like me,u also cannot speak for another agenda ..keep in mind..only when one party(pakistan) start poisioning a sect patriotism..then only other party(indian people) start to respond on it..otherwise each one of us in India knows sikh contributions in indian defence and never publicised unnecessarily
kalyan konka I’m afraid this is bull crap how can you say this while you have the Kashmiris under siege, I can easily say you might do this to the punjjabis Sikhs.
@@truthteller6827 kashmiris not under siege if u compare Kashmir blackout regularly for many many months continuously without any solution or outcome and continued infiltration from local parties ..now it is clearing it's fatigue slowly and this is permanent solution from the view of India and only anti national saying it's a mistake..may be u need to cross check ur national priorities..Sikhs are most respected sect through out India pls dont compare it with Islamic infiltrators
I'm Sikh, and I didn't want Kartarpur corridor to open. I know Pakistan will use it against India.
Robot Ace Actually I believe that it should open. People should go there, ignore the propaganda, take advantage and worship, and then return, thereby proving to Pakistan that no matter how much they try, they will not be able to divide India. That people of all religion are in India by choice, not because it was forced on them.
@@alwaysrushil Then Indian security forces must take extra precaution, Some plain cloths must travel.with the devotees to make sure any indoctrination isn't carried out once at the Pakistani side. I'm positive as Long as Captain sahab is CM, nothing will happen.
@@onion8077 What?🤣 Don't over exert your last two surviving neurons.
Lolva
@@onion8077 did you even read my first comment? Please brother, stop embarrassing yourself like this. It's painful watching this🤣
And 1984 was really very unfortunate n saddening. It was handiwork of congress goons like sajjan Kumar n others but iam happy that law it's finally catching up n oNe by oNe these murderers are being taken to task even though very late as congress didn't allow it during their rule n tried to give it Hindu Vs Sikh spin for their electoral benefits ,but it was not hindus rather it was few mad dogs of congress who went wild to please their political masters, it was not religious it was political it was Congressman Vs Sikhs in reality. We should do everything to heal that scar n reach out to our Sikh brothers N sisters as a community. But believe me all Indians are really proud of our mighty Sikh brothers n their uprightness. Wahe Guru ji da Khalsa Wahe Guru ji di Fareh
hindus supported congress then
@@guruword8378 I don't dis agree that those congressman happened to be Hindus n that's a disgrace as a Hindu am ashamed of that . But non of them were doing anything for Hindus or spreading violence in name of or for the religion ,they were doing it as purely as congressman as political workers they were pleasing their masters . And I personally feel they should have been brought to justice much much before only if Congress under Gandhis would have allowed. It was Anti Sikh riot but it was not one community vs another community riot rather it was Workers of The Then Ruling Party attacking The Innocent Sikhs. IT WAS HORRIBLE
@@guruword8378 So do you want Khalistan?
no autonomy for all states a true federal union of states
@@guruword8378 in India we are already following the same system... Every state has its own CM they decided 95% of their decision own their own... Finance... Education... Health... Food everything is under state run machinery... Even law and order is a state subject. Only border security is under center... Every state has a autonomy of a kind where their own people select who they want to make MLAs and Sarpanchs or MCs.
All 10 Gurus and Guru granth Sahib is equally highly respected
for every Indian
Vijay Kumar - true that 🙏🏻
Vijay Kumar have u read the ggs ?
@@anusingh3236
Yes 2 or three times when I was 12 years old honestly I don't remember it now but I still feel it inside me
Vijay Kumar u do realize the ggs insults the Hindu deity Krishna and it also insults most of concept/rituals In sanatan dharm and then it’s says to respect other religion like wtf it’s fully of hypocrisy.
@@anusingh3236
We have arya samaji hindu we have Jains who don't believe in what we believe still we have people from all over the world come to Kumbh mela celebrate holi n other festivals would you believe they are increasing every year so we don't have to worry about Shree Ram n Krishna if you believe they exist
The cheque Imran wants to cash has already bounced.
He's not very bright in re-presenting it. Haaaa! 🤣
Imran Khan is a toilet paper which is being used by Pakistan Army right now to wage their idea of jIHAD on India. At the end of his tenure he will lose his self esteem and respect all over the world.
punkination due i addition to what you have mentioned IK is also a wild playboy, double divorcee and having illegitimate children around the world. He is also the selected PM ( as said by your people and media). Nowdays he is famously called as international beggar begging in front of China every month, in front of IMF and in front of Arab countries. Keep living in the bubble that world is laughing at India.
punkination well i would definately comment on IKs leadership at end of his tenure as PM. Currently he is called as U turn PM of Pakistan. So will see for another 4 years what he does. Whether he makes pakistani economy stand on its feet rather than taking loans from entire world.
@@harshtur I learned long ago, never to wrestle with a pig. You get dirty, and besides, the pig likes it. 🐽
~George Bernard Shaw 🤣
@@harshturSelf esteem and respect.....
Hmmm....me thinks he's going to make like Bhutto and get the 72 virgins! 🤣😂
" Nutty anxiety neurosis "
- Shekhar Gupta.(2019).
😂😂😂
Yeah that caught my attention too 😁
Sikhs are the pride of India. I live in UK since last 28 yrs and the moment I see a Sikh anywhere I know I have met a true Indian😊
Waahe Guru Satnam 🙏🏻
We, Sikhs, do not identify ourselves with India! Our country is Des Panjab (occupied)
Lots of love to all my sikh brothers from PATNA SAHIB 🙏❤️❤️❤️
Sir,well spoken, india today channel at 8.00pm spreading venom. Teach them some lessons.respect for you.
Imran Khan must watch Tom and Jerry to unwind himself. The fool's talent has not exhausted.
Or he can fart to unwind. lol
@@rmns987 🤣🤣🤣
NEHRU HAD OFFERED KHALISTAN TO AKALI LEADER TARA SINGH , real name Nank Chand Malhotra !!! Please read page 269 of book by Durga Das INDIA FROM CURZON TO NEHRU AND AFTER but Tara Singh had REFUSED !!!
7:47 A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one :)
PS: Comment edited after watching _SWE1: The Phantom Menace_ :D
Many Sindhi's are followers of Guru Nanak Dev too (my dad used to read the Guru Granth Sahib every day and I still have It in my temple although I can't read Gurmukhi) and by opening up the corridor exclusively for Sikhs only, Pakistan's intentions are transparent for all. Yes, India will react to the Khalistan bogie but Sikhs and Punjabis who experienced the horrors of the Partition will never trust Pakistan. It's only the people living out posh lives in Canada and elsewhere abroad who rattle the Khalistan saber, for political gains no less. If they've found a friend in Pakistan then maybe they should make that their country. Sikhs in India are Indians first.
What exactly makes you think that while Sikh will not trust Pakistan in the remembrance of horrors of partition, but will make India trust able in the aftermath of 1984 and the Sikh genocide that followed afterwards. Is it just a choosy remembrance on part of sikhs or a way for Indians to ensure themselves.
I am an India, Hindu by faith and I have been to Harmandir Saheb, Bangla Sahib, Anandpur Sahib and Gurudwara in Yamunanagar and also in England.
I always find peace in sacrifices of Guru ji, forever indebted to all my sikh brothers. Love them to core.
Brilliantly summarised...power of sikhism and patriotism among sikhs is too strong to be maligned by anyone...
Nobody is maligning! We, Sikhs, do not identify with India
I believe Sikhs are most patriotic part of India.. the nationalism and love for India is unmatched... they are the true religious entity who never discriminate between we and others...
Proud that sikhism belongs to this land... and this land is India
Sikh not only living in Punjab they are in Delhi bangal Kerala South India Jammu and Kashmir everywhere
If you're true sikh...then u will never demand for different state like khalisthan... cz gurus gave us lesson of unity and to live together for each other with love and respect. Jai Hind
I am a true Sikh and I want Sikh sovereignty! Khalistan should not be equated with radicalism, we want sovereignty.
They have learned from India that sikhs can be engine of nation building which they had failed.
A pro India and a kind of pro Hindu comment from Shekhar Gupta!!!!! Rare for The Print, member of Lutyens!!! Keep it up. You may even become a Hindu one day.
Your analysis have made the day for me.
Separatist Movement Exists in India: ...
Shekhar Gupta: I have covered it first hand
Like for Respect
Fuck off
That Pakistan will fail again in instigating the khalistanis may be true. But its attempts will cause enough disruptions in Indian society and polity. As the proverb goes, “ Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty”.
Sikhs are the pride of india..
Punjab Sind Gujarat Marata Dravida Utkala Vanga...
Celebrating diversity in world largest democracy!
"Partition of British India" into Pakistan and India through a British parliamentary act was nothing more than the Partition of Punjab (East and West) and Partition of Bengal (East and West) so if Punjab and Bengal are going to "reconnect" again by any means (soft or hard) then the purpose of partionting of British India will automatically diminishes. It's a historic moment that today East and West Punjab are reconnecting again after 72 years of divide, I'm looking forward to see similar reconnection between East and West Bengal then "Indian Independence Act July 18, 1947" will die on that moment...that will be a big day and new beginning in Subcontinent.
@@tejadarkar @ this is how British ruled this region - divide and rule. Baloch divided into Iran, Afghanistan, Balochistan and Sindh, Pashtuns divided into KPK, Afghanistan, Balochistan and Punjab, likewise the whole Subcontinent is ripe apart into the way no single ethnic group should be at one place. In my opinion within the Subcontinent, the entire region to be redefined so that each ethnic group should be under one roof and then these groups should make UNION to run the Subcontinent.
It's funny how just a handfull of inconsequential people keep bringing Khalistan . I just have one question to them are you willing to abandon takts which Are not in Punjab . I was born a Sikh and an Indian and hence my loyalty lie to this land where gurunanak travelled and guru Govind Singh gave us the name Singh to protect this land . They traveled all over India . Anyway there is no such Khalistan movement they are just few useless people but giving them media coverage just creates a hoax
Created by that Brahminee bitch Indra Phuddi to misalign Sikhs.
I’m a Maharastrian and live in Canada. I am very happy about this development and would like to Thank Imran Khan for opening up access to this holy place for Sikhs... though I m not a Sikh I revere Guru Nanak Deo. I’m proud of my fellow Sikhs and their contribution to India. I regret the alienation some of them feel - as I have heard much misguided propaganda in Canada. My greetings in my personal capacity to the Sikh community. You are an important and integral part of strong prosperous and peaceful India !!
I don't know why, but I always feels sikhs are the most Patriotic & courageous people in India.
Me too
Because they are courageous and patriotic, and above all they have a big heart, as an Indian from NE I can say that many of my NE bros and sis might complain of racism etc against north indians but they have no such complains against the Sikhs, that says a lot about them.
Sikhs are hired guns used by hindutva state for hindu domination
@@Wanderer975 well, Sikhism Buddhism Jainism all came from Hinduism. & People of These religions are existing in harmony without any conflict or hate between them & these people don't put their religion above their motherland unlike some invasive species. Hope you understand pork🐷
@@hector1094 rather than saying Sikhism came from Hinduism,it better to say Sikhism,Buddhism,Jainism ,,Hinduism,Sufism like dharmic religions born in this land.
People here in india are educated, not like radicalised pakistani people.
well said bro
Sekhar Gupta is a gem. After listening left to right wing journalists for a long I come across that Sekhar Guptat's analysis is more genuine and less partial. Great work sir! Plz maintain the standard. Jai Hind.
Both Bhindranwale and Indira Gandhi desecrated the shrine of Golden Temple at Amritsar in 1984. Whereas Sikhs have the courage to criticize Indira Gandhi and the Indian army but lack the courage to criticize Bhindranwale and his gang for desicrating the beautiful Golden Temple by taking arms and ammunition to the holy place in the first place. REAL Sikh lion Khushwant Singh was one of the few Sikhs to criticize both Bhindranwale and Indira Gandhi for their unholy acts.
To paraphrase Mr. Gupta, Imran Khan's talents as a public figure are quite modest :) :) :)
In truest sense what he means is Imran is a dumb ass not fit for national politics forget preaching at UNGA
"Im the Dim" said politely
anyone who born and lived in India are Indian. With unity we will be stronger and secure.
I am a sikh born in 90s who is still trying to figure out what actually happened in 1984. Where can i read your report on punjab 1984 ?
Search operation blue Star by study iq.
that shows how our sikh leaders are all gaddar
Sikhs are the backbone of India, love and respect from a Bengali brother!
Apparently I belong to hindu family and my sister married into sikh family..Pakistanis will never believe the joy of sikhs while watching gadar-ek prem katha or the movie border for that matter...pak army won't forget one name ever I.e kuldeep singh chandpuri and battle of longewala
Leaders like Imran Khan are exemplary and rare. Sour grapes to those who try to belittle him. It is shameful that this reporter is so blind to someone who cares about peace and justice. Well, justice will prevail and the world will recognise the great leader Imran Khan is.
I am from Hindu community, 1984 was unfortunate, and i was not even born at that time, and neither I belong to Delhi region. I am from bihar, and still you ask me to apologise, i will brother on behalf of every culprit, political parties etc. Agree that we are polytheists, but still Guru Nanak, Guru Govind Singh, Guru Arjan Dev inspire us, gives a big sense of pride to us. Even i am typing this comment from a Sikh's House in Patel Nagar, Delhi. We are brothers from different mothers. Culturally we may be a bit different, but by blood we're one. And a important fact, The great king Maharaja Ranjit Singh has donated kilos of Gold to the Kashi Vishwanath Temple. We're one, and nobody can separate us.
Agree
Sikhs the world over are planting trees to help the earth's environment. Wish we would all join them by planting at least a tree for each family member.
Go to Tamilnadu and you'll see images of Prabakaran in some places in the similar manner you described here. Like you said, got used to it. 😀
if there is any trust issue majority of top army airforce navy positions not given to Sikh ... Sikhs soul of Indian security
I love Prophet Mohammad ji, krishna ji , Jesus christ and Guru Nanak ji same
Because sikhism preaches secularism. In my history book it is written that guru nanaka sahib visited mecca as well as pandharpur.💗.
Love from maharashtra.
Really true , waheguru ji khalsa waheguru ji fateh.
@InfoTv so, I am from Hindu community, 1984 was unfortunate, and i was not even born at that time, and neither I belong to Delhi region. I am from bihar, and still you ask me to apologise, i will brother on behalf of every culprit, political parties etc. Agree that we are polytheists, but still Guru Nanak, Guru Govind Singh, Guru Arjan Dev inspire us, gives a big sense of pride to us. Even write i am typing this comment from a Sikh's House in Patel Nagar, Delhi. We are brothers from different mothers. Culturally we may be a bit different, but by blood we're one. And a important fact, The great king Maharaja Ranjit Singh has donated kilos of Gold to the Kashi Vishwanath Temple. We're one, and nobody can separate us.
@InfoTv 1984 was more political and as Hindu it was a pain to me too. Just visit golden temple u will find 60-70% are Hindu visitors
@InfoTv things have changed so u need to be.......
@@upahardey3478 Why u people are giving reply to him he is Pakistan that's for sure??
Lahore belongs to India.....jai hind
#FreeGilgitBaltistan
Punjabi here my guess is it will revive the wounded feeling that punjab holds. Wounds which can not be healed until places like lahore and narowal are united with punjab again
Maybe Sikhs who feel and think they are treated as second class citizens...should think of moving to Pakistan.......Jai Hind Jai BHARAT
If there is no fear, then why term it as Pakistan's fantasy. For once, can we have the grace to thank Imran Khan for his gesture. He didn't have to do it in the current hostility between the 2 countries but yet he chose to do it.
So let's give credit where it is due...
Print are taking measures to increase their views finally. Keep it up!!
Uno what..... We shouldnt be even talkin about this. Coz if we do then it kinda indicates that v r worried about it. And it puts the sikhs in an uncomfortable position. Coz they be thinkin that we r suspecting our doubting their loyalty......
Think about it.
Sikhs r more patriot nd loyal for India than any other comunity ,i love them i respect my Gurus i first worship Guru gobind Singh ji bfore other gods,if pakistan army/isi have some bad intention they wil never suceed nd will hv to quit kartarpur sahib nd nankana sahib permanently for us
Very true ..
Celebrate our diversity and trust of fellow citizens.... wow... that’s something I have heard after six years....
India is currently afflicted by Pakistannoisis.... an affliction which suspects anybody , who doesn’t confirm to this very narrow definition of Nationalism...India and Indians are much better than that.
India is a much stronger country than before. India is not made of porcelain. Indian nationalism has mastured each other. We must learn to trust each each other. And if we can't trust any group of fellow Indians, because they belong to a certain community, or a linguistic group, etc, I think we do ourselves a great disservice. So this is a time to forget all that, I would say go even beyond our old slogan of 'Unity in Diversity' and say 'Celebrate Diversity'".
Shekhar Sir 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Unfortunately a new wave of anti bengali sentiment is growing. Bengalis are equal Indian like any other Indians. Bengalis are most patriotic. Bengalis fought for independence more than any other communities. So in the name of NRC Bengalis should not be tortured. Like Guiratis, Punajbis, Marathis or any other Indians Bengalis has equal right in India. So please stop harassing bengalis in Assam or North East India. When India has been divided on the basis of Religion, Bengali Hindus living in India (fled from Bangladesh) must be accepted as Indian. They never wanted Pakistan. So stop hating Bengalis. Read History and think a lot about the contribution of Bengalis. If India can shelter 20 crore muslims then why not 19 lakh Bengali Hindus of Assam or Bengali Hindus of North East and West Bengal?
Our beloved Sikh brothers are very patriotic and kind hearted, sikhs are jewel in the crown of India, khalistan was instigated by Pakistan to divide India, if Indian Punjab merge, the Punjabi Muslims will kill our Sikh brothers and sisters to snatching the holy land of Baaba Sri Gurunanak Dev hi who blessed India to prosperous and brother hood ...
Sikhs are 2% of Indian population but 20% of Indian Army .
Isi and Pakistan have come up with an old plan. Since Pakistan has always created hatered towards Hindus and Sikhs from their primary education onwards. Today they are showing long lost love.
They forget that it was radical Islam against which the Gurus gave their lives.
Their fantasy can never come to reality. Though the ISI has done some work on the expats in Canada, UK and US. Hope these people understand their game can never come to play.
Pakistan will break and annexation of West Punjab our capital will be Lahore.
Delhi is historically biggest city of Punjab. It should become capital of Khslistan. Lahore is muslim populated city and it will stay in Pakistan Punjab.
Delhi or amritsar are good choices for Khalistan capital
@@Wanderer975 ha ha ha bhai Pakistan ka Punjab chaida aur Lahore hogi capital. Khalsa karega Islam ka safaya
@@kandsa13 😂🤣
No bro there is no fight between muslims and sikhs. United Punjab was divided because hindus wanted sikhs to divide it and make east punjab part of india otherwise it was decided that whole punjab was to be part of Pakistan. Lahore pehle hi punjabiyon ke paas hai. Khalistan ka Capital delhi hai aur East punjab vich khalistan baneda
@@Wanderer975 dude be careful, ye khalistan banane ke chakkar mein kahi balochistan mat kho dena
hahahaha since we have good experience of how to break you haha
@@steevanroham9178 Khalistan toh sikh banaenge
Sir Ji :
Earlier, we had Bell Curve theory within the boundaries of our Nation.
Can it be applicable for SAARC countries and later for the Village called GLOBE ??
🙏🙏
Yes but but we r nowhere near the bottom of bell curve may be it will take 20-30 years.
Not really. Bell curve appplies to India since India chose to use it. That's not case with the world overall. Presntly, it is all about anti-globalization or relocalization occuring since globalization has created fear of diluton of native culture amonst many people across the globe (which is partially true).
And in case of SAARC, you need to pay attention to addiction of Pak to use state sponsored terrorism as a sub-conventional warfare. That doesn't falls in bell curve pattern.
Im a pakistani in the west and have got loads of indian mates. Man,s are talking on here like pakistan has set a trap up its your religious legacy and it was our honour to help build a bridge. Its 2019 and its a gesture of good will to the punjabi brothers and sisters. Just like any other people if you push us we push back you hug us we take you in. build the bridge between sikhs and pakistan we share alot of history good and bad but were still trying on both sides. I think imran khan is a rare breed hes got alot of ideas. This guys getting it hard from some of the other parties about ventures mainly the skint currency but hes still trying. Its easy to call an entire nation terrorstan but then that nation opens its heart and everyone wants to find faults. Truth is extremists on all religions are destroying the asian continent the party in charge of india will in no way talk to pakistan. It might bring peace to the lands.
We hindus have always degraded ourselves to praise the sikhs to repent for the sins of a political party but it hurts my heart to see khalistanis pouring out vicious islamic propaganda from their mouths.
Khalistan means "land of the khalsa". I don't understand why some want Khalistan. We already HAVE Khalistan. We have India because India is, has been, and always will be the land of the Khalsa
Yes brother waheguru Ji da khalsa waheguru Ji di fateh
Kartarpur corridor will prove to be a blunder for India on the long run.
We don't have to feel so insecure
@@premprasad3511 We should Never ever NEVER! trust the Pakistanis
@@rohitroll2119 Well, we asked for it, even we are aware of their nefarious designs, if they ever even TRY to do any nonsense, they'll be hammered to smithereens, let that be clear.
How? Going for 1 day in 365 5 km in pakistan will be disastrous?
@@rohitroll2119 I don't trust them. I trust our own ability to keep splitting them into smithereens at will and when needed ..let our sikhs have access to their shrine in the meanwhile
We have a lot of love for Sikhs in Pakistan. We are delighted that Kartarpur has opened. I don't think that it's opening has been orchestrated to facilitate the birth of Khalistan. It's not our business. In fact there is no evidence at all to support the idea that Sikhs want a separate State, it is all speculative talk & nothing else. Happy to welcome all Sikhs that come for pilgrimage, and Sikhs of all descriptions, from separatists to hardcore patriotic Indian Nationalists. I repeat it is none of our business, I don't think we have politicised it, nor have we made any declarations of support for Khalistan. Please do not expect us to police the conversations that happen at religious sites, it is not our role. Thank You. .
as a sikh am loyal citizen of india ,,but change our identity in indian constitution, am sikh not hindu
Sick and tired of interference of Delhiites in every matter of the Sikhs. Idiots just appreciate Imran's gesture.
We have trusted Pakistanis many times to be betrayed later.
Problem is Pakistani government is just a puppet of Pakistani Deep State (Pak Army+ISI) and their prime motive is to destabilize India. Because of 3 major reasons:
1. India had been established as an existential threat to Pakistan since Independence by the Pak Army.
2. Pakistan is struggling to gain Kashmir due to its geopolitical importance and water resources.
3. They want to avenge the seperation of Bangladesh, which they consider is planned and done by India.
So we can't trust Pakistani civilian Government ever. And yes, Khalistan movement was indeed revived by the efforts of ISI in midst of Punjab political crisis in late 1970s.
Look guys its a positive step and corridor opening should be celebrated. Its just like thousands of temples everywhere but Ayodhya temple is the only one where lord Rama was born and because of this importance there was this long dispute. Same for Kartarpur Sahib. There are many Gurudwaras but only one Kartarpur Sahib where Guru Nanak Dev ji spent last 18 years of his life . So from spiritual point of view its unmatachable and for the first time since independence we are able to visit there which is amazing.
The ambition of a few men should not be taken as the ambition of the masses. India is not India without Sikhs. Sikhs don't want to be Indian, aisa ho hi nahi sakta.
Thank you Imran Khan the corridor is a peaceful gesture. The Sikhs don’t have to go if they feel like they are betraying India.
Sikhs are the no l and best citizens of India most loyal and patriotic period
Not only Sikhs millions of Punjabi Hindus are happy after opening of kartarpur corridor that perhaps they will also get a chance of Darshan
To cut the clutter for you, please watch the video (specially from 3:47 to 3:55). ruclips.net/video/WvnjZMXb5dE/видео.html
her words are "im a hindu, married to a christian, visiting a gurdwara in a muslim country"
this is a goodwill gesture for the Sikh community. Leave it like that. dont do politics on it. dont try to increase your ratings by spreading hate. i know it would be hard for you to digest good news coming from pakistan. change your perspective of pakistan to declutter your brain.
My Sikh brothers and sisters are a gift to this nation and most patriotic indians.I greatly admire them and who can forget the sacrifice of Guru Tegh Bahadur for protecting hindus.Wahe Guruji Ka khalsa Wahe Guruji Ki Fatah.
Gotta luv how Hindus luv to speak for sikhs. Imran khan is a good man.
Im Tamilian, lived in northern parts of India some time. Sikhs are India's first line of deffence always. Maybe they have opinions and issues but there are no question about their patriotism. I have belive in a Sardar brother then our Congress party leaders.
Whenever India has won a Cricket World Cup , it has had Muslim and Sikh cricketers in the team along with Hindus.
1983 - Syed Kirmani, Balwinder Sandhu
2007 T20 - Yuvraj Singh and Harbhajan Singh, Irfan and Yusuf Pathan
2011- Yuvraj and Harbhajan Singh, Zaheer Khan and Munaf Patel.
how many Sikh international cricketers does Pakistan have ? How many did it ever have ?
and I'm not going into Hockey, Athletics, other Sports, Bollywood, Army, Bureaucracy, Judiciary, Business etc etc.
Jai🇮🇳
I hear Shekhar Gupta often. While I cannot agree with all his views, but he is fact based, and his assessment of Imran Khan is right on the money.
Best Wishes on Kartarpur Sahib -Dera Baba Nanak Corridor
In their Ardaas Sikhs pray for Reunion with their key gurudwaras " Jehhrey vichhora de gaye " ( in 1947 - came under Pakistan )
The corridor is beginning of ending the " Vichhora " and answer to their Ardaas.
In 1947 Sikhs chose to side with India . It was because of this support that MA Jinnah 's tactic , of getting undivided Punjab for Pakistan , was defeated.
Not only India got East Punjab but , very crucially , the town of of Pathankot without which India would not have got any connectivity to Jammu and Kashmir.Without Sikhs' support India would have lost not only East Punjab but ,also , Jammu and Kashmir.
Sikhs are pride of India. By appearance a Non Sikh could be from any country of South Asia but a Sikh is , for sure , an Indian.
-------------------
But Pakistan's Deep State's motives need further study.
Example : at Gurudwara Kartarpur Sahib , an Unexploded bomb casing has been prominently displayed in the Gurudwara sahib compound . The message reads that in the 1971 War this bomb was DELIBERATELY dropped by Indian Air Force to DESTROY Gurudwara Kartarpur Sahib !!!!
Brilliant analysis Sir
Why can't India revive baluchistan freedom movement?
We have no intention of reviving khalistan movement. Imran khan and his party have stated several times this is to promote tourism in Pakistan. And have a little faith in your Sikh community. They are not children that anyone can convince them to rebel against there homeland. Stop spreading lies.