Porsche Problem
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 май 2024
- The plaintiff bought a new car and brought the car to the defendant’s business for a repair. She claims the mechanic broke her seatbelt while her car was in for a different reason. Then, someone stole her fuzzy pink dice from her rearview mirror. She’s suing for damages. The defendant argues the mechanic took the dice off the mirror because it’s illegal to have them on, then left them on the seat. She doesn’t think she owes anything.
Subscribe to our channel:
/ @peoplescourttv
Case # 32-005
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court 
Развлечения
I love it when these huge companies know that they are wrong and instead of the owners taking ownership they send a lamb into a den of wolves
They do it every time lol. That’s because the know they were wrong.
Right!! She sounded unknowledgeable and embarrassing!!
Right?! Also this company has lost their mind for agreeing to go to court this way instead of proper court with the necessary documentation and a representative who is aware of the situation as a whole. The office manager is totally clueless as to this case, which may not be her fault but man the company shouldn’t have chosen to represent themselves through her due to that fact
1st if the Shop LIED about where battery is located, they Will LIE about Everything else!!
I think the defendant is just ignorant. She's the office manager, not a mechanic or car person. Someone that doesn't really know anything about cars would automatically assume the battery is under the hood.
STFU, SHE LIED @@deemcgriff4196
The whole response to the suit starting with the dice to the seatbelt was a lie. How dishonest and just awful
Once the judge caught me in a lie I would’ve log off 😂😂😂😂
Regarding the defendant, she was not lying, she just did not know anything and assumed a lot. The owner sent her in to the wolves den because they knew they were in the wrong.
😂😂😂😂😂
Lmao 😂
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
The owners did not want to come to court because they didn't want to expose their business
The defendant probably felt embarrassed when JM corrected her on the battery being under the seat. If the owner is going to b upset that they lost the lawsuit, then he should’ve been there.
I’m almost 100% sure they threw her dice away…
Why?
So your 99% sure?
I bet they just fell out of the car somewhere. Why would they bother to toss them out. Realistically the guy tossed them aside they landed between the seat and door of the passenger and when somebody got in somewhere they flipped out and the person didn’t notice and they’re gone.
Or she just wants new ones and is lying
@@elvickRULESwhy wouldn't the Genius mechanic show up to court! They're incompetent imbeciles and they threw her dice away or misplaced them. That's her sentimental property and if she found them in a dark alley it wouldn't matter. It's hers and reputable businesses know not to touch the clients property. It's not hard to understand.
@@mrshappilymarried1 because the owner decides who goes and they’re sketchy and don’t want to be there with the mechanic which is how it should be.
Why would they care to throw away someone’s dice? I don’t believe the “they placed them on the seat” bs, because I’m sure the mechanic didn’t care and just threw them aside in annoyance. But why would they go out of their way to take them or throw them away? They have no value. So throwing them away would be some petty action for some other reason
The fact that the owner and Eddie wasn’t there showed they knew they were wrong. They sent their office personnel that knew nothing. She didn’t even know the battery was under the seat. They set her up for failure. I’m glad the plaintiff won!
Office puppet 🤨
So they send the person who likely has the least ability to counter the plaintiff's testimony: the office manager.
They took those dice to piss her off, they were sick of her…these mechanics are petty and silly
Yeah.... probly. I wouldve
I agree! Everybody in the comments acting like she’s childish for bringing up but they’re not looking at the bigger picture. It’s some petty ppl out here.
Exactly!
I know she did not sue for fuzzy dice 😂😂😂😂
She be black. She love her some fuzzy dice.
The fuzzy dice, in her words have sentimental value to her. You can’t necessarily sue for sentiment but, that doesn’t mean some items in our lives don’t have value to us, if no one else. I have a poem my sister wrote about me when she was 7. It means the world to me and no one else. If someone damaged with malice, I’d think that I would be entitled to compensation🤷🏾♀️ Although I probably wouldn’t be granted any by courts.
When I heard that I had to play it back. Lmao! People are rediculous!!!
Glad she won!
I usually take everything out my car when leaving it with mechanic
The plaintiff's & her husband seem like really nice people! Well spoken.
The defendant & that company should be ashamed!
Tried putting a baby item in picture to get some sympathy
Stop saying people of color are “well spoken” it’s a back handed compliment!
Ikr! Glad Ms. Misty won! 🎲🎲💞
Well spoken with AXE?! 😂😂😂
If my seatbelt was broken, I’d be back there next day…suspicious
You're a smart lady.
If the mechanic LIE about location of battery, it's SUSPUCIOUS!!
It was the passenger seat she didn’t know until someone sat there
@jeanicelewis510 that lady don't know anything about cars. Anyone would assume it's under the hood. If I ask you where a Sebring battery was I bet you wouldn't say behind the bumper
@@pastathemechanic7536which is exactly why she shouldn’t be there! I own a restaurant, I’m not sending my manager to court if we’re being sued over the food I’m sending a cook, someone who knows wtf they’re talking about. Knowing what the service was for an not knowing the location of the service is DUMB!
The defendant is not the person to be here. There should be a mechanic and the owner she spoke with here not the office lady.
Office manager is more than Qualified to represent the shop. I doubt the owner and a mechanic would take off for a service complaint. Plus the office manger has authority to represent the shop.
@@johnsradios484ANYONE can be an office manager, a mechanic is trained & an owner is expected to know the basics…this office manager didn’t even know where the battery is for the vehicle she’s referring too…I have two BMW’s a year apart batteries are on two different ends I bought them and had no clue 🤷🏾♂️🤣
@@tristyy404 You are correct, we have 2 BMW and 1 has the battery in the front and the other in the rear wheel we'll...😂
The credibility of the defendant was completely devastated when she erroneously contradicted the plaintiff re the battery location.
I’m embarrassed for the defendant
Her voice was shaking when she was talking to Doug
The receptionist looks like the matchmaker from the old tv show
But better
Seems like they hired her from Craigslist or maybe she’s a relative of the owner. She was ill-prepared.
I once helped a co-worker jumped her cadillac seville. After at least 1/2 hr of trying to locate where the battery was, finally found it under the backseat.
That shop set that office manager up for failure and made her look kinda dumb.
So happy she won that ...they were wrong to not fix it !!!
When she didn’t know where the battery went In the car ,the company lost .
JJ would've never taken the defendant's testimony. She didn't even deal with the plaintiff, and her first statement about the battery was invorrect. I would've said BYE. Also, who would want to steal fuzzy dice ??? Come on.
I collect fuzzy dice
JJ is a JJJoke
@@bash547 I'm not saying I don't like fuzzy dice. I just don't think a mechanic would want to steal them but who knows nowadays. Lol
@@bash547😂😂😂😂😂
Milian acts like shes such a feminiat but calls women sweetie and honey. She knows what the gentleman meant when he said car dealerships take advantage when a woman comes in alone. It's true.
The very first words out of the defendant’s mouth made her look like an uninformed fool. Her manager did her no favor by sending her into this case clueless, and no, batteries are not always under the hood. Mine is under a floor panel in my truck.
Male judges never get offended when litigants call them sir but JM loses her shit when called ma'am or miss.
I HAVE RED DICE HANGING FROM MY RED CORVETTE MIRROR...I DEFINITELY WOULD KNOW IF THOSE DICE WENT MISSING... IJS
$300 for 6 gallons of gas I mean know gas is pretty expensive but…… $300 lmao
She wanted a gallon of gas per mile I ain’t think math is her strong suit
@@matthewsalinas8879I think it was for some days not just one day. I hope so anyways.
The woman doesn't even know where the battery is located. Why would they send this woman to represent them? What's worse is the fact that the plaintiff is going to have to keep dealing with these clowns in the future.
The dealership could have just as well sent me to represent them. At least I would have Googled where the battery was and listened to the testimony so I would know what the heck the plaintiff said about that $300🤷🏽♀️
All the mechanics and judges in the comments 😂😂😂😂
Many mechanics are lying stupid scum.. not sceintists
JM really didnt want to award this woman anything. But her hands were tied. This shop is pitiful and the judge knows it.
Let's be honest, it is easy to forget something thats always where you expect to be until you suddenly think about it.
YES EXACTLY HELL IT'S HAPPENED TO ME TIL I REALIZED SOMETHING LOOKED OFF & IT TOOK ME A MIN STILL LOL.....THEY SHOULDN'T HAVE NEVER TOUCHED IT / PUT IT TF BK THEY STOLE IT . THE DEFENDANT DIDN'T EVEN KNOW WHERE THE DAMN BATTERY WAS LOCATED. MY {1} EX CADILLAC HIS BATTERY WAS NEAR HIS BACKSEATS HE HAD TO GO THRU HIS TRUNK NEVER KNEW THAT HELL I FIGURED ALL BATTERIES WERE UNDERTHE HOOD. WHY SEND HER WHEN SHE KNOWS SHIT
It's illegal in a lot of states to have ANYthing that large hanging from your mirror. This woman waited 2 or 3 months until she needed an oil change to bring up the seat belt thing??? I would have gotten out of my car the same day I picked it up and said something. She should never have driven away from the dealership and then waited way so long. She'll win.
And car dealerships do discriminate against women they have been attempting that with my mom for decades to the point they told her one time that "you don't need a van that big " when she was trying to get one big enough to pull the big trailer she had and the fact that they pulled this crap ...she went to another dealership to get one and one of the conditions for her to buy it was that they would call the other dealer and thank them for the sale !!!
Other times when car shopping she had my dad with her and they talked to him like she wasn't there, my dad told them that they were talking to the wrong person and so she did buy one but I'm pretty sure it was on a different day with a different salesman....and by they way salesmen lie almost as much as cops !!!!!
They sent in a ditz that doesn't even know what the heck She's talking about to represent that company
why do you keep taking it back to them if they're not fixing and messing up your car. they were stupid for sending her. they knew they did something wrong
DUMMY IF YOU WERE LISTENING BECAUSE THE WARRANTY THAT SHE BOUGHT SHE HAVE TO TAKE IT THERE . LISTEN, FOCUS & PAY ATTENTION
She was asked that by the judge and she stated that it was part of the contractual agreement when she purchased the car.
It's apart of a contract she signed when she got the car.
I guarantee that the owners of the dealership are foreign…. Enough said
I had someone from ford break my side door panel on a aiebag job , they gave me a free oil change because the part couldn't be replaced. I wasnt angry with him and it settled quickly. If you break something admit it and make it right. Dont just leave it for the owner to find
I got the same animal masks hanging on the wall. Scored em from Dollar General! Classy
Don't lie lol
@@Bebedollie you're right.... it was Big Lots.
Buying an old Porsche is sucks horrible financial decision making 😂
Trying to look richer than she is
What did u say?!
Please provide an analysis of her financial records since you know about her financial status…thanks
@@princesscoles6586 you don’t need to know much about her personal finances to make that comment. An over 15 year old car in that state is a poor financial decision when she could’ve gotten a newer model Toyota or Honda with less issues for cheaper. We all know she bought that car because she wanted a “Porsche” and not bc she wanted a well running car on a budget
Bad decision For you or for her? People buy older cars with no issues all the time.
I can’t wait, after hearing the plaintiffs Ludacris demands, that this ended up being a 22 minute video. That is insane.
Ludicrous and yes, it was a long one and not at all necessary. Considering the age of the vehicle, I had a 2002 truck where the seatbelts would no longer retract and that can happen overnight. This just happened, that the day she picked the car up they no longer worked. Doesn't mean the mechanic wrecked it. Seatbelts wear and that car is no longer a teenager, it's a Senior Citizen. Anything can be on it's last leg and then break the next 5 miles, the next day, etc....
Ludacris, like the rapper, or ludicrous? 🤔
During covid there weren't as many cases being filed so court shows had less to choose from. Before covid most People's Court shows had three cases per episode. During covid this show had mostly two cases per episode.
If I was sitting at home in a comfortable chair talking to my laptop I could surely get my sentences out much better and not be so jerky. This was actually painful to listen to. I would think after so much time has passed that the Plaintiff would have quick, smooth dialogue and this would have been over, done and dusted.
Listening to her was exhausting. I fast forwarded to the verdict Lol
Plaintiff is scamming for sure
You gotta be kidding me, fuzzy dice? 😂
If it’s her property and they stole it broke or misplaced something they are responsible I wouldn’t care if it was a rubber band stolen ITS MINE
Fuzzy dice just may be more reliable than some ppl. 🤣
Once a company screws up the second thing and doesn't fix the first problem they caused, i sure as hell ain't going back there a third time 😅
They must have broke the belt otherwise why wouldn't they just show the work orders. If the work orders had no mention off seatbelt they would have won. Terrible idea to buy an old porche from a regular used car dealership.
The owner threw the manager under the bus. He and the mechanic should've been the ones to be in court, but the owner forced/pressured her to do it. The manager did not have all of the information and did not know where the battery for that specific car was located. I would not have known intuitively either, but it does tell me that she was not given all of the information by the owner. She also could have looked it up herself.
I don't know how much of what the plaintiff said is accurate, the delay in addressing the broken seatbelt and with the dice was odd...
NEVER buy a vehicle from any dealer that stipulates the customer pays 50% of repairs.
BATTERY UNDER THE SEAT....THAT'S THE DUMBEST PLACE FOR A BATTERY TO BE...MAKES NO SENSE
Doug always telling somebody what they mad about 😅😂
Why did the Plaintiff keep going back to them?
Because her contract. She explained that
The defendant didn't stand a chance from the first. Shame on the shop owner for setting her up. Methinks he knew he would have to lie if he was there. Excellent plaintiff!!
It doesn't matter what garage I go to whether it's one that I go to all the time or a new one for whatever reason, I always take out anything a value or things that means something to me out of the car. Usually it's just sunglasses because I carry extra pairs in there. It's not that I don't trust my garage, it's just the fact that if something goes missing I don't want to have to go back and say Hey where's my sunglasses they're missing. I just avoid all of that all together and take things out of the car beforehand. But fuzzy dice yeah they probably got rid of them😂
Her boss probably knew he couldn't get away with pretending to not know where the battery is and hoped the judge would believe that it's under the hood rather than research it.
The face the office manager made when she got caught lying about the battery is so funny to me lol. I get that she might not know since her work is clerical, but you don’t speak on something you don’t know except to say exactly that: “I apologize but I’m not certain.” ESPECIALLY in court, especially representing your company. Lordy B
This is why you inspect you car before leaving the lot. Once you drive it away, they'll say they didn't damage anything. I took my car to a dealership once to have some work done and get covers for my driving lights, and when I picked it up they had already put the covers on. I pulled them off and my driving lights had been smashed. I immediately went and got the service manager and pointed it out. They still asked if they were broken when I dropped it off and "That's why you wanted the covers". I told them that's absolutely ridiculous and to look at their video footage because they were not broken when I dropped it off. They ended up replacing them on their dime.
Ten year old pink dice? Yuck. They needed to be replaced!
Dealership tried to charge me 900 bucks to resurface rotters 😂😶 They don't even do that anymore. While on the phone with them, I am online looking at a full new break set for 300. SMH!
You have to be careful and make sure that the person turning right turns into the correct lane.
If the garage changed battery but don't know where it was situated on that car did they really change it? The poor defendant was given false information and hung out there to suffer the consequences.
And why would she keep taking her car back to a business that kept messing her car up???
It’s where here warranty lies
Curious but doesnt the paperwork the defendant gets served with outline what they are suing for? $1 of fuzzy dice and $2499 for seat repair?
When you start your testimony by lying, you likely lose. The defendant is likely the shop owner's girlfriend.
Sounds as if they did damage her car But, she took too long to seriously address the issue. And when she did address the issue, she asked for gas money too. They should correct the damage but they don’t owe her gas money. And with regard to the “fuzzy dice”, they have sentimental value to her…which is fine and dandy; courts don’t necessarily pay for sentiment although in some cases I suspects that courts do.
That office manager was playing in an arena she was not qualified for. Shame they sent her and hid their pitiful faces.
She lost from the time she gave the wrong location for the battery...she's an office Mgr, not a mechanic.
Seatbelts have lifetime warranties, why would they not fix it, they can charge it back to the manufacturer. But this woman comes on here and starts out lying...
🇺🇸❤️🙏🏽defendant should stay in the office and say NO next time her employer is sued. Great job plaintiff🇺🇸❤️🙏🏽
Good call judge on the seatbelt!
I am a woman and that has nothing to do with dealing with cars. It is insulting to hear that.
My question is why didn't the actual mechanic come to court or the shop general manager?
I bet those back seats broke because of who installed those subs. With the amp mounting right on the back of the seat... and seat belts? on a 06 p.o.s porsche GROW UP. with HOW MANY MILES
She should have left the vehicle there so everything was done right.
Those fake eyelashes😂😂😂
I think the Plaintiff was a little too big for that car.
But in the end, evidence weighs out over the flapping gums of the Defendant who has a suspicious attitude and showed up in court with zero evidence to back up her claim.
She never mentioned her dice 🎲 the only mention the seat belt.
Should have bought a rav4
If I read the rule correctly, in California on a multi lane road, you can turn right on red while someone is turning left on green if you turn into the lane closest to the curb. Not 100% sure though.
To all the people that keep asking “why keep going back?” listen with your ears and not
your eyes 😒
The Defendant Is Just LOUD and WRONG! 😂😂 " The Battery is Under The Hood" Then She Said that's Why she Wanted to Settle Out of Court...As JM said If She Was Listening she would have heard what she said. It would have took a hour for the manager and Ed to show up...but they sent the Receptionist who clearly doesn't know cars 🤦🤦🤦🤦. Do better people 😂😂
Ooh missus manager thinks she knows everything she doesn't know nothing about anything she should not have been their shoes that number could pretty
How was the plaintiff able to get Dolemite to testify?
Very "sentalmental"? I'm sure😂
Every time the defensent tried to make a point, looked stupid.
And why is the Judge touchy about how she is addressed however she addressed ppl often unprofessionally? Your degree is no better than another's.
Douglas laughing, that's when you know the case is ridiculous 😂
The fuzzy dice was the .80 cents on lawsuit 😂 🎲🎲🎲🎲
Why does the judge act like sexism isn't real!!!!
DO NOT USE SLANG and expect everyday people to know what you mean....you have to speak REGULAR. INTELLIGENTLY...THEN YOU WON'T BE IN QUESTION. GOOD FOR THE PLAINTIFF THOUGH ❤
She agreed to go there for the necessary rountine maintenance, not back and forth for the unnecessary as she stated.... I stopped watching Judge Milan bc she is unfair and emotional vs. being law abiding.
I always find it perplexing when owners or managers delegate representation to a third party who had no prior interaction with the plaintiff; it just doesn't add up to me. In this case, the defendant seemed abandoned, left to fend for herself as if she were thrown to the wolves without any protection. While the plaintiff presumably presented her case diligently, the judge couldn't properly question the defendant due to her complete lack of involvement. At the end, when asked by Doug what the owner/manager would think, she responds, 'He thinks it's wrong and they are not going to agree with it and they're going to be unhappy with it'. This begs the question: Why didn't he attend or send individuals who had interacted with the plaintiff? It's hard to complain when you fail to send the right representatives to defend your business in a favorable light.
Thrown under the Porsche, she was.
He (the owner) didn't want to be on TV, and was confident if he sent his secretary/this woman (who knows nothing about cars, ev en something simple/trivial as knowing that in some cars usually sports cars and minivans and station wagons coincidentally, the battery is under the driver seat etc. so she's there for eye candy/to be pretty smh lol,) she would do the talking for him. Yeah no lol. He thought this was a wise decision, that turned out to be unwise, but yeah. lol.
Those dice are so tacky
The plaintiff wants $300 for gas? Seems to me each time she went she had something else that was fixed, so why does she want the $300 (which seems high for even a few 50-mile round trips -- what does she get, one mile per gallon?) back. That's gouging.
So beautiful ❤
A sucker is born every minute.
I understand sentimental value, but we can never put a price on that unfortunately. She didn't notice them missing for 2 weeks, someone could have just taken them out of her vehicle
As for the gas, it didn't sound like she drove to the shop repeatedly just to have the seat belt fixed. She was going there for different repairs assuming the seat belt would be fixed as well.
You can clearly tell by the cowardice of the owners that they're Republican 😅
Didn't have the courage to face the situation when faced with what they've done 😅
My question is how do the defendant did know that the plaintiff did do it
1700 is what that car worth
Not the best witness and also, he talked way too much on the video instead of simply documenting the damage... All that extra commentary did not help. Made her claims less believable in terms of the timing of her complaints.
Manager, I don't know why he sent her/Defendant was worse, and sending basically this woman who didn't even know like something pre-k/kindergarten that some cars, (usually foreign cars, station wagons, minivans etc.) have the battery under the driver seat. Everyone knows that, I don't know anything about cars and knew that. I know dealerships sometimes hire eye candy receptionists, but at least these women know their cars. This woman is basically clueless and a model/there to look good smh lol.
I don’t know why but this episode appears long.
The judge is foolish if she doesn't think having a man at the mechanics is more beneficial.
She's such a feminist.
But I also agree with Milian that there are some women that know their cars, and can even fix and repair cars etc. But yes ladies having your boyfriend/Husband go to car dealers/mechanics would probably be sound advice in some cases.
@taralen1101 True they can know but it's still in mechanics nature to screw women over. I think they take some kind of vow for it.
Early squad wassup
🙋🏻♀️
Hey!!
😎