You are correct! I'm retired Army. You bring different equipment for the needs of the mission. Sometimes small and light is all you can bring. Remember, the J Frame on you is better than the Glock you left at home.
I live just outside of San Antonio. My home is in between two high end neighborhoods. I’ve been accosted twice at the grocery store in the last year. My communication and street savvy skills from being a cop in the LA area helped me to solve the problems.
Wish you well and compliment your negotiant prowess. Luck may have played a part in your success. Perhaps your formidability and potential to render harm if assailed was sensed by the predator's instincts upon sizing you up. For decades I was a licensed armed citizen self employed in the Bronx in a cash 'n carry enterprise. While lucky to never have traded gunfire, numerous customers, competitors, and colleagues of mine were not, though most survived unharmed, some were wounded, and more than a few were killed. Those who went about unarmed were always robbed, beaten, stabbed, or shot.
Excellent points & I agree 100%. I pocket carry either a lightweight J Frame or LCP due to back & hip problems that preclude packing anything bigger or better. I’ve been in a gunfight & understand how fast things can go wrong but I practice w/my EDC and hope for the best as I go about my daily orbits.
The world is round. There are disadvantages to carrying a small snubnose. Just facts. There are many things people do that aren’t optimal. Some folks take in the facts and weigh the pros and cons. Some don’t. We all have our own lives, situations and circumstances. The facts you said are true. Yet I still feel comfortable carrying my Jframe from time to time. I’m just a regular dude who has a daughter I would never want to not come home to. I’m fine with my decision when I walk out the house with it.
From 2020-2023, my main carry was a 442, but a few months ago, I hurried and got a full size 9mm with way more capacity and longevity. I grew up by the border and now live in the DFW area. You speak wisdom, sir.
Being a former Police Officer I can say that an air weight J-Frame rode back up on my vest. And, served as an off-duty weapon A LOT. Served me very well. But it was mainly because of the convenience due to it's size being very easily concealed no matter what I was wearing and it's weight. Still love that little pistol and I still carry it from time to time. But I do agree that your circumstances and surroundings should dictate your EDC. And not your preference. There is truth in the old adage "The Air Weight in your pocket will always be better than the 1911 you left at home". Personally, I would always rather have my Glock 19 strapped with extra mags if @#$% hit the fan. Easier to shoot, better site picture, more rounds, etc. As much as I love my .38 snubbie, I do have to admit it has limitations. And those should be taken into consideration heavily when considering it as your primary.
This I a great video. Real world situation awareness in today’s environment. For example I also have a J frame but as the world turns ugly I stared to ask myself, “ am I out gunned “. ? Once that thought came to my mind I already knew the answer. It’s great to have options. Some jobs require a small hammer for detail finish work and some jobs require a sledgehammer to break up concrete.
Good rebuttal, valid points considering our current times. Shield plus is my fav. I believe the convenience of the jframe is the key that most cling to. Hood stuff I subscribed👍🏻
I have a full size CZ 75, and love it. I was looking at their compact models, and they have a model with an aluminum/alloy frame. Is that the model you're carrying? If so, how has it held up for you?
The amount of rounds carried shouldn't be determined by the likelihood of being in a fight; it should be *if* you are in a fight, how many rounds do you want (not need, want)? The intensity of a fight is not proportional to the likelihood of it happening. I want the best gun i can get away with carrying
Gabriel, excellent, excellent video. People are emotionally attached to certain objects, items, guns. And they are in total denial. More over, they lack total real world experience, as you mentioned. Good video Gabriel. By the way, next time you happen to be in Phoenix, let me know, I would like to have a coup of coffee. Take care and Dios te bendiga.
I normally carry a G19 or G26 when out in public. I wear sloppy oversize clothes and do not carry in federal or school buildings which will put me at odds with some here. I can wear the sloppy clothes because I am retired and do not care what others think of me relative to dress. For deep concealment it would be a small 32 or 380 ACP or next step up one of the smaller single column 9's. With a double column mag fed glock, even only a 26 with red dot I am a lot more deadly than I am with a J-frame. I do have a J-frame in my pocket of wear at home blue jeans for pit vipers loaded with shot and shoot a couple each year around my place. Still carry a full 9 when out and about on my place.
To me, the modern j-frame is the Sig P365 and analogues. J frame size with double or triple the capacity and options to use modern red dots. In light of that, I keep 3 options available, a compact fighting pistol with a dot, 15+1, a modern micro 9 from the same manufacturer, also with a dot, for when circumstances dictate that a smaller gun would be advantageous, and a .32 pocket pistol for when nothing else will work. I don't really see where the j frame fits in that system, so I don't have one.
You are correct. We're often times limited by circumstances, or location when deciding what to carry. When these aren't a concern, why place these limits on yourself? I have a few J frames and I enjoy them, and yes they are often the only thing I can carry. I often carry one as a back up in my offside pocket. I ALWAYS prefer to have a larger more capable pistol on me if I can. It just makes more sense. Do I plan on getting in a gun battle, or going to war? No, but I'd rather not be caught short when I can help it. I've been carrying jumper cables for almost 50 years, every day. I have not needed to use them once for myself, but often for others. The day I don't have them, will be the day I need them...
A person can also get very good with their hands and train years to be lethal, but you won’t convince me that the best hand-to-hand combat practitioner is more lethal than a knife, gun, or beludgeoning weapon. You can also get proficient and deadly with a knife, but would they make the same argument that a knife is better than a gun in a combat situation because it conceals better, it’s easier to deploy and is legal in all 50 states? It’s all context based but I agree that a larger weapon will always be better in a fight than a micro gun. I appreciate the thought provoking content you put out!
Wise words Gabe. But also…what the hell, ya sandbagger! I’m gonna need a good long video on your watch collection!!! First, i notice the Omega Seamaster chrono, and now this!?! A steel & gold Rolex Sub!? I keep saying it, Style for miles…
Thanks bro. That is it for me. I also have a couple of Luminox watches that were gifts from some European associates. Wife has a more extensive collection than I do..LOL
The low-risk lifestyle is found in the grave, everywhere else involves people who want to put you there. I carry the J-Frame as a 2nd gun and to walk down the street to check the mail. These kinds of arguments are usually made by people who've never been in a blow out fight, had a gun pointed at them, or been busted with pipe.
Yep, they’re all tools, we should use the right tool for the job. In the house and the backyard I often have a j frame in my pocket. On a road trip I have a Glock.
I don't NEED anything other than oxygen and sustenance to survive, but it's about THRIVE. I'm going to go stuff a full size SP01 down the front of my pants and go about my day, THRIVING.
Revolvers have been a small part of sales for over 35 years. You are either justified in your defensive shooting or you are not. Semi automatic handguns have been the main weapon of choice since the late eighties. Watch some police involved shootings to see how they react and how different people react to being shot. More criminals are working in pairs or more and will not stand still for a perfect shot. Police have been trained to fire at least three rounds to insure survival against just one person. A five round revolver is a compromise that does not need to be done with all the compact 9mm handguns on market . At least with a compact 9mm you can have more rounds available with a fast reload. A Smith and Wesson shield would be better than a revolver. A couple range sessions will have you doing well with a semi auto and it is not hard to do. This for the people who think a revolver is all they will ever need and think a semi auto is too much. I read of a case in Southern California where an off duty officer was engaged against a gunman with his 5 shot snubbie and ran out of ammo and the gunman came up to him and he was left begging for his life.
I love the j frame and thinks it's a beautiful gun but unfortunately polymer is the trend I hope the metal striker gun phase continues even though it seems slow coming
If I was going to get in a gunfight I would take my AR15. I wish I could take it with me everywhere. When I can I carry my CZ Shadow with a spare mag. When I can’t carry that I carry a S&W carry comp with two speed loaders. When I cannot carry that I carry a j frame.
Many people live in the preconceived notion world. “I’m not going into dangerous neighborhood…if I can’t do it with five I’m in trouble…I carry a .45 because I don’t have to shoot twice…all you have to do is pump the shotgun and they’ll leave the house…revolvers are more reliable; they always bang…and so on. I’m with you Gabe. If my circumstances allow me to carry more than a J frame I’m doing it along with spare magazines. I believe trouble can happen anytime and anywhere.
Good points. You are not the only one that asks “Are you blind, it is right there in front of your eyes?” In a world where gun owners get firearms “education” from Hollywood movies, war games and social media influencers, these type of reactions and posts you got, are expected. It demonstrates just how big the market is for good, “real world”experienced and talented instructors. Now, you do what you need and want to do. There will always be people out there that will listen, learn and appreciate your work. BTW, it is said that a lot of combat veterans, at least the old timers, that would refuse to share their experience with other people and consider it a waste of time, as nobody but similar combat veterans, would comprehend what they are talking about. I find that they are right, regardless what military one served in.
Another great EDUCATIONAL VIDEO I am a revolver fan BUT REALITY dictates to select the correct tool for the situation that you NEED to prepare for Hence why - mean my weakness is not a factor (weakness from my cancer medication)- I am EDC my semiautomatics I have been/ still am a Filipino Martial Artist- everything is a tool - is you have the luxury of time to select the correct tool - then do it-!!! Thank you for this video
A J frame in 2024 is equivalent to a Deringer in the 19th century which was replaced upon the introduction of preceeding small revolvers. Better than nothing if that's all that can be had under certain circumstances.
Thank You Gabe, I admit I love a J-Frame Smith. I can only think of 2 or 3 times in the last 25 years I’ve been out in public with only that on me thought. Right or wrong when I put one in my pocket now it’s when I’m doing something different and it becomes backup for my 1911 constant companion. Thank You for sharing Your wisdom, it is informing and enjoyable. Also thank You for lately leaving out the F-Bombs as I am a guy in my 60s with a 12 year old son that I love to share some of this experience and wisdom with. Again Thank You
You are correct! I'm retired Army. You bring different equipment for the
needs of the mission. Sometimes small and light is all you can bring. Remember, the J Frame on you is better than the Glock you left at home.
The question needs to be asked, why on earth would you leave the Glock at home to begin with? Fail.
I have a j frame as a part of my overall system. It’s great for deep concealment over my primary semi auto.
I’m 68 , I have some physical challenges, I appreciate your valuable tips & information. My range shooting has really improved too . Thanks
I live just outside of San Antonio. My home is in between two high end neighborhoods. I’ve been accosted twice at the grocery store in the last year. My communication and street savvy skills from being a cop in the LA area helped me to solve the problems.
Wish you well and compliment your negotiant prowess. Luck may have played a part in your success. Perhaps your formidability and potential to render harm if assailed was sensed by the predator's instincts upon sizing you up. For decades I was a licensed armed citizen self employed in the Bronx in a cash 'n carry enterprise. While lucky to never have traded gunfire, numerous customers, competitors, and colleagues of mine were not, though most survived unharmed, some were wounded, and more than a few were killed. Those who went about unarmed were always robbed, beaten, stabbed, or shot.
That’s why I carry two j frames on me at all times.🤣🤣Cowboy reload
😅😅😅
Excellent points & I agree 100%. I pocket carry either a lightweight J Frame or LCP due to back & hip problems that preclude packing anything bigger or better. I’ve been in a gunfight & understand how fast things can go wrong but I practice w/my EDC and hope for the best as I go about my daily orbits.
The world is round. There are disadvantages to carrying a small snubnose. Just facts. There are many things people do that aren’t optimal. Some folks take in the facts and weigh the pros and cons. Some don’t. We all have our own lives, situations and circumstances. The facts you said are true. Yet I still feel comfortable carrying my Jframe from time to time. I’m just a regular dude who has a daughter I would never want to not come home to. I’m fine with my decision when I walk out the house with it.
*pulls out a $200 claptrap made in Turkey saturday night special* : "i tRUst mY LiFe tO tHiS!!" OK buddy
From 2020-2023, my main carry was a 442, but a few months ago, I hurried and got a full size 9mm with way more capacity and longevity. I grew up by the border and now live in the DFW area. You speak wisdom, sir.
Being a former Police Officer I can say that an air weight J-Frame rode back up on my vest. And, served as an off-duty weapon A LOT. Served me very well. But it was mainly because of the convenience due to it's size being very easily concealed no matter what I was wearing and it's weight. Still love that little pistol and I still carry it from time to time. But I do agree that your circumstances and surroundings should dictate your EDC. And not your preference.
There is truth in the old adage "The Air Weight in your pocket will always be better than the 1911 you left at home". Personally, I would always rather have my Glock 19 strapped with extra mags if @#$% hit the fan. Easier to shoot, better site picture, more rounds, etc. As much as I love my .38 snubbie, I do have to admit it has limitations. And those should be taken into consideration heavily when considering it as your primary.
This I a great video. Real world situation awareness in today’s environment. For example I also have a J frame but as the world turns ugly I stared to ask myself, “ am I out gunned “. ? Once that thought came to my mind I already knew the answer. It’s great to have options. Some jobs require a small hammer for detail finish work and some jobs require a sledgehammer to break up concrete.
Good rebuttal, valid points considering our current times. Shield plus is my fav. I believe the convenience of the jframe is the key that most cling to. Hood stuff I subscribed👍🏻
Gabe I love the channel. I too love a good revolver it doesnt jam. I want an affordable 3 inch revolver. Thoughts?
I have a full size CZ 75, and love it. I was looking at their compact models, and they have a model with an aluminum/alloy frame. Is that the model you're carrying? If so, how has it held up for you?
The amount of rounds carried shouldn't be determined by the likelihood of being in a fight; it should be *if* you are in a fight, how many rounds do you want (not need, want)? The intensity of a fight is not proportional to the likelihood of it happening. I want the best gun i can get away with carrying
Gabriel, excellent, excellent video. People are emotionally attached to certain objects, items, guns. And they are in total denial. More over, they lack total real world experience, as you mentioned. Good video Gabriel. By the way, next time you happen to be in Phoenix, let me know, I would like to have a coup of coffee. Take care and Dios te bendiga.
I apologize for my ignorance, but could someone please explain the Farnum doctrine that was mentioned? I didn’t get that reference. Thanks in advance?
I normally carry a G19 or G26 when out in public. I wear sloppy oversize clothes and do not carry in federal or school buildings which will put me at odds with some here. I can wear the sloppy clothes because I am retired and do not care what others think of me relative to dress.
For deep concealment it would be a small 32 or 380 ACP or next step up one of the smaller single column 9's. With a double column mag fed glock, even only a 26 with red dot I am a lot more deadly than I am with a J-frame. I do have a J-frame in my pocket of wear at home blue jeans for pit vipers loaded with shot and shoot a couple each year around my place. Still carry a full 9 when out and about on my place.
Great video Gabe. Facts that needed to be said. Not sure if the hard heads will listen but as an educator you have told them the truth.
You simply stepped on a sacred cow Gabe
To me, the modern j-frame is the Sig P365 and analogues. J frame size with double or triple the capacity and options to use modern red dots. In light of that, I keep 3 options available, a compact fighting pistol with a dot, 15+1, a modern micro 9 from the same manufacturer, also with a dot, for when circumstances dictate that a smaller gun would be advantageous, and a .32 pocket pistol for when nothing else will work. I don't really see where the j frame fits in that system, so I don't have one.
It has its place end of discussion. It’s not that it’s good or bad. It works for dif applications.
Thanks
Great advice. J frame is a backup not a primary.
Valid points
Amen, brother. As a retired LEO, I have been thinking about this same thing. The border is wide open and frankly, I lost trust in our government.
You are correct. We're often times limited by circumstances, or location when deciding what to carry. When these aren't a concern, why place these limits on yourself? I have a few J frames and I enjoy them, and yes they are often the only thing I can carry. I often carry one as a back up in my offside pocket. I ALWAYS prefer to have a larger more capable pistol on me if I can. It just makes more sense. Do I plan on getting in a gun battle, or going to war? No, but I'd rather not be caught short when I can help it. I've been carrying jumper cables for almost 50 years, every day. I have not needed to use them once for myself, but often for others. The day I don't have them, will be the day I need them...
A person can also get very good with their hands and train years to be lethal, but you won’t convince me that the best hand-to-hand combat practitioner is more lethal than a knife, gun, or beludgeoning weapon. You can also get proficient and deadly with a knife, but would they make the same argument that a knife is better than a gun in a combat situation because it conceals better, it’s easier to deploy and is legal in all 50 states?
It’s all context based but I agree that a larger weapon will always be better in a fight than a micro gun. I appreciate the thought provoking content you put out!
Your right as a primary weapon carry the jframe as a back up that's what I do
Wise words Gabe.
But also…what the hell, ya sandbagger! I’m gonna need a good long video on your watch collection!!! First, i notice the Omega Seamaster chrono, and now this!?! A steel & gold Rolex Sub!? I keep saying it, Style for miles…
Thanks bro. That is it for me. I also have a couple of Luminox watches that were gifts from some European associates. Wife has a more extensive collection than I do..LOL
@@suareztactics I love it. Pure class, brother.
The low-risk lifestyle is found in the grave, everywhere else involves people who want to put you there. I carry the J-Frame as a 2nd gun and to walk down the street to check the mail. These kinds of arguments are usually made by people who've never been in a blow out fight, had a gun pointed at them, or been busted with pipe.
Not necessarily friend. You're stereotyping people needlessly.
@@LionquestFitness The word "usually" should have addressed your concern.
@@TomRussellatAFA I stand on what I stated.
Yep, they’re all tools, we should use the right tool for the job. In the house and the backyard I often have a j frame in my pocket. On a road trip I have a Glock.
💯
But its easier to clear a stove pipe, failure to feed, failure to eject, and no limp wrist with the revolver 😁🤣✌️🍺🇺🇸
The cope is real. Love you content.
I carry both.
You mentioned Joe Rogan, and I suddenly realized that your voice sounds like his(!!!). Agreed on all points. 👍👍👍
We have the same haircut too...LOL
switched from a glock 43 to a glock 19 gen 5
I don't NEED anything other than oxygen and sustenance to survive, but it's about THRIVE. I'm going to go stuff a full size SP01 down the front of my pants and go about my day, THRIVING.
Revolvers have been a small part of sales for over 35 years. You are either justified in your defensive shooting or you are not. Semi automatic handguns have been the main weapon of choice since the late eighties. Watch some police involved shootings to see how they react and how different people react to being shot. More criminals are working in pairs or more and will not stand still for a perfect shot. Police have been trained to fire at least three rounds to insure survival against just one person. A five round revolver is a compromise that does not need to be done with all the compact 9mm handguns on market . At least with a compact 9mm you can have more rounds available with a fast reload. A Smith and Wesson shield would be better than a revolver. A couple range sessions will have you doing well with a semi auto and it is not hard to do. This for the people who think a revolver is all they will ever need and think a semi auto is too much. I read of a case in Southern California where an off duty officer was engaged against a gunman with his 5 shot snubbie and ran out of ammo and the gunman came up to him and he was left begging for his life.
I love the j frame and thinks it's a beautiful gun but unfortunately polymer is the trend I hope the metal striker gun phase continues even though it seems slow coming
okay
If I was going to get in a gunfight I would take my AR15. I wish I could take it with me everywhere. When I can I carry my CZ Shadow with a spare mag. When I can’t carry that I carry a S&W carry comp with two speed loaders. When I cannot carry that I carry a j frame.
Low risk dreck! The Odds vs the Stakes or what is at stake! Thanks Gabe great video I agree 150%.
Many people live in the preconceived notion world. “I’m not going into dangerous neighborhood…if I can’t do it with five I’m in trouble…I carry a .45 because I don’t have to shoot twice…all you have to do is pump the shotgun and they’ll leave the house…revolvers are more reliable; they always bang…and so on. I’m with you Gabe. If my circumstances allow me to carry more than a J frame I’m doing it along with spare magazines. I believe trouble can happen anytime and anywhere.
Good points.
You are not the only one that asks “Are you blind, it is right there in front of your eyes?”
In a world where gun owners get firearms “education” from Hollywood movies, war games and social media influencers, these type of reactions and posts you got, are expected. It demonstrates just how big the market is for good, “real world”experienced and talented instructors.
Now, you do what you need and want to do. There will always be people out there that will listen, learn and appreciate your work.
BTW, it is said that a lot of combat veterans, at least the old timers, that would refuse to share their experience with other people and consider it a waste of time, as nobody but similar combat veterans, would comprehend what they are talking about. I find that they are right, regardless what military one served in.
Another great EDUCATIONAL VIDEO
I am a revolver fan BUT REALITY dictates to select the correct tool for the situation that you NEED to prepare for
Hence why - mean my weakness is not a factor (weakness from my cancer medication)- I am EDC my semiautomatics
I have been/ still am a Filipino Martial Artist- everything is a tool - is you have the luxury of time to select the correct tool - then do it-!!!
Thank you for this video
Excellent video. People who post stupid comments like what this man is responding to are absurd.
A J frame in 2024 is equivalent to a Deringer in the 19th century which was replaced upon the introduction of preceeding small revolvers. Better than nothing if that's all that can be had under certain circumstances.
Crazy you had to make this video after the last one. Sacred cows and hornet's nests.
If you don't care, why are you making the video?
Thank You Gabe, I admit I love a J-Frame Smith. I can only think of 2 or 3 times in the last 25 years I’ve been out in public with only that on me thought. Right or wrong when I put one in my pocket now it’s when I’m doing something different and it becomes backup for my 1911 constant companion. Thank You for sharing Your wisdom, it is informing and enjoyable. Also thank You for lately leaving out the F-Bombs as I am a guy in my 60s with a 12 year old son that I love to share some of this experience and wisdom with. Again Thank You