Intermittent Fasting: A Fast Heart Death?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- 🌱 Use code MIC15 to get 15% off Complement Essential, one multivitamin to rule them all for plant-based peeps: bit.ly/CompMIC
Today we are covering recent news about intermittent fasting increasing heart disease mortality risk. The study is not perfect but there is a bigger picture.
- Links and Sources -
Link Page with eBooks and Socials: linktr.ee/mict...
Support Me Here: / micthevegan
Vegan Bootcamp: vbcamp.org/Mic...
My New Newsletter Sign-Up:
mailchi.mp/278...
Main Study Abstract and AHA Article:
s3.amazonaws.c...
newsroom.heart...
IF Helps Insulin Resistance:
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
IF Men Lower Testosterone:
pubmed.ncbi.nl...
Holiday Times Increased CVD:
www.ahajournal...
Article on Heavy Meals and Heart Attacks Right After:
www.sciencedai...
Study 2 on Heavy Meals and Heart Attacks Right After /
"The ingestion of heavy meals can trigger the onset of an ACS event.":
pubmed.ncbi.nl...
UCI Health Quote on Heavy Meals and Heart:
www.ucihealth....
Studies Encouraging IF and Low Carb:
www.sciencedir...
www.sciencedir...
Skipping Breakfast NHANES Data:
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
2017 JACC Study on Skipping Breakfast and Atherosclerosis:
www.acc.org/ab...
pubmed.ncbi.nl...
Korean Study on Skipping Breakfast and Higher Fat Intake:
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
Meta-Analysis Showing Skipping Breakfast Raises LDL:
www.ncbi.nlm.n...
Meta-Analysis on Skipping Breakfast, Increased CVD:
pubmed.ncbi.nl...
Cause Remains Unresolved:
www.tandfonlin...
Intro/Outro Song: Sedução Momentânea by Roulet:
freemusicarchiv...
Hey Mic! Therapist here: I wanted to correct your comment that bingeing and purging is bulimia; this is a common misconception. Anorexia also has a binge/purge specifier. If someone is bingeing and purging, and have a BMI under 17, they would likely be diagnosed with anorexia with said specifier. With a BMI above 17, they would likely meet criteria for bulimia.
Interesting, thanks for the info!
I spotted this too. Otherwise everything else spot on. Great video. Believe Binge Eating Disorder is known as BED.
Good to know, the message of the video is that there is always nuance and I missed it here lol. Thanks
I did not know that. Thank you!!
For me I showed signs of binge/purge type anorexia but had a BMI above 17 and what I called a binge apparently like didn’t qualify in terms of sheer caloric numbers so I was dx’d with EDNOS
Also worth mentioning the survey data collected is of several years but they did not concluded these people were fasting by looking at the responses of every single day of those years, they only chose 2 days (yes only 2 days) of 15 years (5000+ days) of data and based on those 2 days they concluded these people were fasting because they skipped breakfast or ate only during certain hours, only using this as a reference to conclude fasting caused health problems is strange, it should be more rigorous. Especially since they don't know what these people were eating when not fasting, regardless of anyone's opinion on fasting this conclusion is weak at best. Authors themselves commented these results could be caused by the diet and not fasting, reverse causality. So these headlines make no sense.
But how can they deduce the 15-year results from a two-day sample? I really don't understand how this could possibly be considered accurate. There seems to be a discrepancy between this video and the strange way of doing the study. I saw another video by a doctor who was skeptical because of that brief 2-day window. I admit I am confused about whether to take this study seriously and the assumption that people are dying at a higher rate because of intermittent fasting as opposed to many other factors. Is there not a plethora of studies affirming intermittent fasting? Another example of studies contradicting each other. Which one is it?
Having participants with an average BMI of 30 really scews the results into the direction of Overeating.
If they actually included only people with "normal" meal sizes of below 1000 kcal they'd get vastly different results.
I've been intermittent fasting for almost a year now. These studies could scare me into having a heart attack!
😊
I've been intermittent fasting my whole adult life and am now 50 and in good health. I have been eating predominantly plantbased diet though.
@@samo_sibela Good on ya! I gave up meat many decades ago and became vegan about four and half years ago. So I think the fasting is serving me well. I'm glad it works for you.
I didn't even know that 8 hours count as intermittent fasting. As I simply don't like to eat when I am not hungry. And I am only hungry after a minimum 8 hours. I never knew that I was " fasting". I was simply only eating when hungry. And eating something earlier was uncomfortable.
@@sandralison7584 same.
I have done several 9 day dry fasts feeling wonderful and cleared lyme Disease
Great video! Thanks!
I totally agree. I wake up in the morning and make a big plate of carnivorous vegetables for breakfast, and repeat throughout the day. (fiber is my number one focus and in my world is the (king)
I wish the peers had reviewed: Dear peers, please review. Thanks. 🙂. Lots to digest in the video, somehow; probably I shall watch it again reducing the speed. Takeaways for now, for me: another caution on skipping breakfast which I do and on balance shall continue to do but thanks for the cautionary reminder; and heavy meals - albeit fibre rich no sos whole food fully plant based ones - which i shall act on. The thing is, I find my cooking, even without salt, so very delicious, that I eat till I'm stuffed. BMI ok but still, shouldn't eat quite so much at one go. Well thanks, a good video which i shall watch again. I did watch and read some reactions to the study report saying it was self reported and standard diet so not that important, so it's good you gave it a fair hearing, so to say.
"Here's a story....of a man named Brady...."
It entirely depends on what you're eating, not when you eat it. You can't have heart disease if you're living purely on lentils, sweet potatoes, and broccoli, IF or not.
Also how much you eat. Although less likely it's possible to get fat on beans and potatoes. Under eating is also dangerous. You see some of those malnourished raw and fruitarian vegan types they're heart attacks waiting to happen also.
cardiac arrest from malnourishment, is an entirely different story;)@@annoyedaussie3942
Can you name a few that have had heart attacks? Or are they all waiting and waiting for years and years?
Only meat heads get heart attacks...
You can certainly have heart disease eating carbs
Fasting is good in the first place because we remove the foods that cause damage such as high fat ones
High fat is not damaging, provided you don't include carbs.
It was clear fasting wasnt a good strategy for years now.
What about a 50/50 vegan junkfood/healthy diet vs that diet on if but not eating big meals? Works quite well for me, I fast 20hrs regularly but when I break the fast, I have a „normal“ meal as if I wouldn’t have fasted😅 any rythm is dead anyway after almost 14years of shift work😂(24/7, 365)
🌞 Blessings
I’ve eaten within an 8-hour window for years, and am now dead.
Did you write as succinctly in life?
@@KotobukiGirl [curtly] yes
This is his bot that he paid an AI corp to continue spreading his views after he died lol
lol I actually laughed and it snapped me out of my mindless scrolling through the comments. I thank you 🎉
Funny joke but I think people using anecdotes in scientific arguments have already lost the argument.
The study is useless imo. Between the confounders, variables, and known unknowns the only thing you can conclude is that you can't conclude anything from this. Nothing to see here.
less meals are reasonable if portions are the same, not compensating with additional quantities
I just assumed the results were due to poor diet quality of people who do IF. All my friends who do IF live on coffee, cream, steak and low carb tortillas. It’s shocking IF was only linked to heart disease.
yeah makes sense
The shocking thing is that many (most?) people actually think those foods are healthy.
I IF simply because I am almost never hungry in the morning. When I do finally eat my first meal, it is a healthy WFPB vegan diet. Tho I can see how IF can be used by folks with eating disorders or other unhealthy relationships with food.
And don’t forget the eggs and bacon
I eat WFPB vegan often doing 17 to 20h daily fasts depending on how busy. It works well enough but I wouldn't consider fasting any where near as impactful as WFPB or especially exercise
No-one has answered the question on my mind which was whether the "fasting" was associated with later bedtimes or less hours of sleep. Sleep has such a profound impact on heart attack rates.
That's a funny correlation, why do you think it would affect that at all?
It 100 pct. Effects my sleep negatively
@@Fallenangel_85 circadian rythm all of our organs have a biological clock...
@@Conversations-o7n Sleep is a special topic and everybody is different.
For me, my last meal is around 20:00 and I have no issue going to bed that way.
It's even bad for me if I eat after that since I'm used to sleeping when my digesting is no longer very active
@@Fallenangel_85not resting enough while doing constant physical work
When I first got into intermittent fasting it was through a group, "One Meal a Day." What bothered me was that the folks doing this were often eating huge, saturated fat heavy meals after fasting for 16 to 20 hours. IF helped me to lose weight, but I did try to keep my meals fairly balanced and healthy. While I do think that long ago this is how we often ate, being forced to fast during times of scarcity and then chowing down when it became available. But often that food was foraged vegetables or berries or fish/game whose meat was relatively lean. Those following OMAD were instead eating foods full of fat and sugar.
I wonder what the results would look like if the subjects ate a whole food plant based diet (or even just a plant based diet) and ate breakfast & lunch, rather than lunch & dinner.
me too
Better
Sounds interesting.
There's a huge amount to parse out here.
Eating vegan seems to matter more IMHO
Why did you ignore the fact that the
He always ignores facts that doesn't fit his agenda. Why are you surprised?
What do you mean by posting this? What is the effect on his conclusions?
Yeah the study has massive flaws.
@@jovotszebb367You sound ridiculous, you clearly didn't watch the video and just react posted when you saw a comment you could jump on. He has no agenda with regard to intermittent fasting.
@@JavedAlam24 omg you're so right, I'm sorry for being ridiculous.
Wow, I'm stunned by this. I never eat breakfast simply because eating that early in the morning make me feel nauseous. I'd like to see a study where they test Vegans and intermittent fasting.
Same. I don’t even begin to feel an appetite until 4-5 hours after waking. 👀
Same. I’ve tried so many times to eat breakfast but I just can’t get through the meal. I have no appetite right after waking. I eat 2-3 hours after waking. But I also eat pretty much right before bedtime at midnight, too. I get a lot of quality sleep :)
Same here.
I drink some chai until about 11 or 12 and don't feel hungry at all.
Then I have my huge vegan breakfast and wait until dinner.
And rarely snack!
No dessert either!
I used to get so much nausea if I ate anything in the morning.
But I realized my body just wasn't used to eating at that time, so I had to train it for a week or two to get my body to realize that it was time to release all the biological digestive signals to prepare for the meal at the new time. (Insulin, Ghrelin, etc.)
Now I eat a massive oatmeal fruit, nut and seed breakfast everyday and I feel terrible if I don't eat breakfast.
The body just needs time to adjust to the new schedule, just like you train your sleep schedule. 👍
Hi Mic, love your work - been a vegan since I was 14, I'm 18 now, I fell into the trap of excessive protein consumption but after reading quite a few studies I've realised that I was eating way too much and that (despite what I thought) too much protein can be harmful (and that in general people overestimate how much they need). Could you possibly make a video on protein consumption (and the risks of overconsumption) since the literature is a bit unclear and difficult to wade through? In any case, thank you for all that you do.
If you're eating plants for protein there is no too much because of their poor bioavailability and amino acid distribution
Studies seem to show that in humans high animal protein consumption is associated with higher mortality while high plant protein consumption is associated with lower mortality. Animal studies though all seem to suggest that low(er) protein consumption leads to longer life although higher protein consumption was associated with higher reproduction rates. A low protein to carbohydrate ratio was associated with the best results. The ratio delivering the best results (in mice) is similar to that in the traditional Okinawan diet associated with longevity. In humans low carb diets also seem to be associated with higher mortality.
If you eat whole foods, you don't have to worry about "protein." It's all fake... foods do not break down into these fake little groups such as protein and fats and carbs etc... foods are whole and must be eaten so... preferably raw.
@@ryanwellington7493Those claims have been widely debunked in terms of relevance to human nutrition.
I have always been a big fan of eating.
You must get over that nonsense. Eating will kill you.
Thanks for sharing. I have been a whole food ethical vegan for many years and fully
believe in intermittent fasting using healthy whole foods. I think the problem is that
some humans may gorge on tons of food at meals, or/and eat the wrong food. Some IF
fans only in a 4 hour window. I do not know how they get enough calories, however...
We humans do not like to feel deprived. I am a personal fan of an 8-9 hour window of healthy
meals and not eating after 4pm.
I also read one study that stated most Americans eat regular meals plus snack several times a day.
I'm very much into fitness culture. The people most likely to do short window intermittent fasting are: Sumo wrestlers, bodybuilders, ketogenic dieters, and very obese people trying to crash diet. Fasting causes stress, stress doesn't cause fasting. I guarantee it has nothing to do with people working "stressful jobs" or whatever, that's pure speculation.
LDL vs Fasting There is probably no A1c type test for LDL levels to show long trend LDL levels, but recently I have discovered that fasting will increase LDL. In the same way that eating a few bananas can briefly raise the blood glucose level and yet be perfectly healthy and normal in a primate we must keep in mind that at some point in the fasting there is a proven increase in LDL of maybe up to 30%. My guess is the increase corresponds with autophagy and is part of the repair process, but is this rise in LDL really indicative of damage or long lasting? Not likely. We have seen plenty of research on the benefits of fasting. It would be most interesting to see how transient the LDL rise can be or a graph of LDL vs hours since eating with a strictly whole plant diet. Currently the pre lipid test advice is that fasting is not necessary for lipid tests if I recall correctly. One wonders if fasting may actually skew the results temporarily upward but without harm to the patient..and possibly benefit??? Again, I'm just guessing and quoting McDougall...but "It's the food!" In a control environment eating the exact same whole plant foods and calories WHAT should we expect in our testing and long term results. Obviously, our primate cousins forage and eat mostly in the earlier part of day and are not up late at night stuffing calories watching TV..unless they are zoo chimps eating pizza, and they don't live too long. In humans there has been a LONG tradition of monastic practice in Asia of eating only til noonish on foods donated for alms, and before modernization there were many long lived healthy monks. Nowadays, in Thailand there is an obesity crisis among monks. The eating window the same, but I have seen the locals making merit bringing them burgers, fries, oily fried foods and soda etc and the monks are now dying of diabetes and heart disease at a very young age. Looks like the faithful are actually killing the young holy men with kindness and would do better giving them rice and beans and vegetables as in the old days!!
I'm going to reserve judgement until more info comes available, one thing is intermittent fasting shouldn't mean binge eating lol I can't face breakfast never have been able to have it, I.F always seems to give me a clearer head and more energy when I stick to it so I will be disappointed if all this is true, I'm hoping it's some anomaly such as people combining it with keto or carne which are both terrible in the long term
Yes, I'd dismiss the study. Not snacking until right before bed will not give you a heart attack, period. EVERYONE I know who fasts intermittently does either high fat (you basically have to fast, because the meals are so hard to digest) or skips breakfast and then slams a big meal with a bunch of refined carbs just before bed.
I don't understand how you can't eat in a time window. If I eat before bed I will have stomach aches. My eating window is around 10-12 hours but I sleep 8 hours. Do people eat 24/7?? Everyone does a some form of "fasting" in my opinion.
@@lemonstealer2902 Exactly. I eat dinner at 6 and breakfast at 9, so that's 15 hours of non deliberate intermittent fasting. If I eat before bed, it disrupts my sleep. But that is supposed to increase my likelihood for a heart attack??
The study on people that skipped breakfast having more CV risk also smoked more than the rest of the groups and had the highest BMI.
Studies on this stuff really need track people eating healthy diets with exercise and no obvious risk factors: do whole food vegans (or maybe for the sake of population size mediterranean) who are physically active and dont smoke or drink have greater risk than those that eat more often? Does meal size and saturated fat play a role? Majority of the people I know that intermittent fast or just only eat within a small window or skip breakfast, usually drink tonnes of coffee, smoke, drink a bit, and are eating processed stuff quickly, and definitely not vegan.
Only I can hear is
maybe, maybe, maybe, maybe, maybe, maybe,
Not pear reviewed.
But it is in the news already.
Absolutely disgusting.
This finding makes sense to me. I have been in a lab studying ageing in a model organism, nematodes, for 2 years. It seems clear that hormesis, the beneficial, lifespan-increasing effect of minor stress like nutritional stress (fasting), only seems to appear in early developmental stages in the animals, while the same stress kills adults faster.
Seriously stressing nematodes in the lab - is probably rarely reached in humans though. Most humans self regulate. They know when they get excessively cold or excessively hungry. You may have to be a masochist to push yourself that much. Whereas nematodes - can be easily pushed to the limits - and often are in the lab. It's natural being older they will more likely die when pushed to such extreme limits.
Exercise works via the same principle and is clearly beneficial to humans during all stages of life. I'm sorry, but they're nematodes. Study results with rodents or even monkeys often can't be replicated in humans, so claiming this finding to "make sense" because of worms is just aggressively unscientific thinking.
Longevity can be directly linked to caloric and specifically protein restriction. Time restricted eating (AKA intermittent fasting) is one of the easiest ways to limit calories
I don't get the concept of skipping breakfast. As long as you have a first meal SOME time during the day, that's breaking the fast, as in "breakfast". I am up for 2-3 hours before I eat, so does that mean I'm a breakfast skipper?
If it were 4 hours yes, only 2-3 is borderline. The concept is skipping an early morning meal, assuming you follow a standard "sleep at night" schedule.
eating early breakfast meals is a scam brought to us by big cereal @@wildrice8199
Are you really skipping breakfast when ultimately you're breaking the fast. What exactly makes breakfast different? Eating before 9:00 a.m.? And then getting a little infrared. I think maybe we digest earlier in the day better. But if someone was simply eating whole plant foods, a well-planned variety, and not gorging, why it would matter if they ate within an 8-hour window versus a 10-hour window or 12. Maybe it's indicative of being more active. I wonder what other lifestyle behaviors these people have in common. Is anyone going to tell us what they were eating?
I'm vegan and purposely intermittent fasting. Test me! Test me!
It would be nice to know what these people were eating. It’s funny how that information was not given. I m guessing they were not vegan.
@@KotobukiGirl 😂
Looking at the population of IF eaters it is no surprise, because a lot of sick and fat people do IF for it's (supposed) health benefits and weight loss
Cmon bro, why is your hair like that? Comb is so cheap. Embrace your ageing and hair loss
An obvious confounder is terrible diets, both before and while doing time restricted feeding. Personally, I stop eating in the early evening, but leave it at that.
They claim to have controlled for those.
Well, I guess I will continue to listen to the commentary on this over the coming months. @@tsurutom
Spreading fat intake across more meals will help to reduce the peak lipid concentration in the circulation.
IF took my blood pressure from 188/90
To 135/ 80
Do you think that the kinds of thing you were eating changed? Or your physical activity?
Was this the only thing you did or anything else? And how long do you fast?
Via weight loss, changed food types, added exercise / sleep ... ? Or nothing else changed than eating time window?
I ate Whole Foods, which cut my sodium 🧂 level way down. I cut out caffeine except one cup in the morning.
I have mobility issues, so I did seated 20 minute workouts.
What were these people eating? And it would be cool to control for a time of day. But also in the context of sleeping patterns. Like Dr Greger has said, eat breakfast like a king, lunch like a Prince, dinner like a pauper. But that can be done in an 8-hour window without having to overindulge.
Or can it?
How about you tell us what kind of NONE cultivated plants ARE all totally safe for humans to eat?
Cuz obviously all the food you get from the supermarket is all cultivate! 😝😂
And maybe just for a while! Cavemen MIGHT have been herbivores to begin with but damn right not long after that they REALLY liked eating meat! XD
Intermittent fasting is not done specifically to lose weight - Mic is making a lot of assumptions today.
Plenty of people do it specifically to lose weight. I'm sure you could probably find 100+ videos right on RUclips by searching something like "intermittent fasting for weight loss."
@@sandyn7710 I agree with you, I'm aware that some people do it to lose weight.
This study sounds so disorganized I don't even know where to begin... First off, why haven't they done a large study on intermittent fasting with a large number or people in different groups to compare if this is the case with a whole foods plant based diet, or is it only corpse and egg munchers, and dairy guzzlers, pescetarian and keto diet? Also lifestyle habits. It would have been way more broad and in depth to do that. Wouldn't surprise me if one or more of those researchers were funded by big pharma to skew the results.
12:30 that's an important bit of information. Shame all of it wasn't as on point as that.
Data collected from individuals who were asked how they eat and when, 2 times.
I am on IF and i myself fail to keep my fasting routine, and they asked people who are not committed into IF about their eating habbits.
Bro, people drop off from IF because of lack of willpower, and they are trying to convince me that, those people are legit on IF until their end? xD
Lmao, these people that were asked may as well drink cola, eat dognuts or chips before they eat a proper meal or work so long hours that they only have limited amount of time to eat a proper meal, while living in a stress and snacking on junk.
They may as well ask people what car are people driving and conclude from it which one is safer to drive in, it would have same scientific value.
Guessing they're dying from taking diet pills and caffeine to avoid eating.
Pet peeve: you can never actually skip breakfast. Breakfast literally is "break the fast" that you were on as you slept. So your first meal of the day is always breakfast whether you eat it at 8 AM or 4 PM, or whether you have pancakes or a sandwich.
That's not how the word is used. Words can often have a technical meaning and a colloquial one. I would say 99% of the time breakfast is used to mean a meal in the morning. If it's after that, we refer to it as lunch, and if it's in the evening we refer to it as dinner. You will get more puzzled reactions by saying you're having breakfast in the afternoon or evening, than you would if you said you're having lunch/dinner respectively. So ultimately we can't dictate language and how it evolves.
Been doing IF 16/8 since 2016 but not into low-carb or keto stuff, just whole food but with some animal products in the mix. Generally very active and doing it all for the telomeres and autophagy than weight management. Alarming study but didn’t control for diet or lifestyle so I’ll happily continue doing the thing that was considered fine for millennia.
Intermittent fasting was unheard of when this study started twenty years ago. Only 400 were intermittent fasting compared to 20,000. Smaller groups have wider variations and when you adjust for many factors the pool of people tested gets smaller and smaller. Plus the starting age was about 40 when heart attacks are very rare. They looked only at two days on average, who knows what happened in the remaining 15 years.
Great show! I thought it was really funny that when you were talking about the vitamin supplement , a commercial popped up for "30 beef sticks for 30 dollars". The timing of that was funny!
I did intermittent fasting for yeaears. Not that I ever heard of it, I just felt better by not eating through the day and stuffing my face after work in the evening. "For me every day is Ramadan," as I would like to call it "apart from drinking water and coffee with milk".
8:47 "25000 calories over
That's me! 🤰
it's probably a mistake. it should be 2500 kcal.
Another fake study.😂. Like you are going to die if you skip a meal😂.
Nah…. No way this is right…. La La La La , I don’t want to hear it (covers ears while watching the video)
now the keto/carnivore fantasies can blame their health issues on fasting
Most of the people I know who eat in a narrower time window skip breakfast, eat a light lunch, followed by two candy bars and pizza and mozzarella sticks for dinner.
That sounds very healthy 😁
Do not ignore this abstract (different from what a study implies). This abstract is here to remind you that science has become a political tool. And a convincing one at that. But the only thing that applies to you specifically is what you do and how you feel daily. Not what a study says.
So basically this whole thing is a mess. 🥴 It's not at all a study! 🤷🏻♂️
Yup... like most "science" nowadays...
I'm tired of survery studies being spread around the internet. Without actual research finding a cause, all this does is frighten and confuse people. This kind of study should stay within the research world, help guide research to find causal stuff that is worth sharing with the world.
Unfortunately people need the clicks, and anything that sounds counterintuitive will get them... who cares if it leads to harming people? (the Time magazine butter cover should land someone in hell, but probably all it did was increase revenue)
@@andreae. Yup
What is breakfast? Is it a meal eaten at a certain time of the day or is it a meal eaten a certain amount of time after waking up?
There's this thing called the sun, it come up every day and your circadian rhythm is attuned to it.
@@dionysusnow The definitions in the scientific papers are inconsistent as to timing and energy content of 'breakfast'. So I'm not sure why is your comment so passive-aggressive?
It’s breaking a fast. So it doesn’t matter when, it’s when you break your overnight (sleeping) fast.
Technically, if you don’t like to eat when you wake up, “lunch” is actually your breakfast.
It’s just a word indicating a behavior
@@seitanbeatsyourmeat666I used to think that too, but I think most studies define it as the first meal max. 2 hours after waking up and before 10 am.
But then there is the issue of energy content: if I have white coffee does it class as breakfast or does it have to be more calories, etc.
It's one of those things that you think are obvious until you try to define it or do research on it.
@@seitanbeatsyourmeat666but it makes sense linguistically, of course!
If you go to Nutrition Made Simple's YT page the first pinned video is an interview with a doctor who claims you can eat 42 eggs a day and it won't raise your cholesterol levels. Pretty sure their channel isn't a reputable source.
Amen...didn't take long more than 2 videos to figure that out.
Oh no... I thought he was reliable source
That’s Dr. Gil Carvalho’s channel-his video’s are excellent, it’s all about the science and explaining these studies-I think he’s great!
I sometimes watch his channel for the information he covers. The information is good, but a lot of what he says is personal opinion. Read the information yourself and come to your own conclusions. Not even doctors are without bias.
It has long been known that, once dietary cholesterol intake reaches about 400-500 mg per day, any extra dietary cholesterol will not raise blood cholesterol levels. That's how the egg industry knows that, if it funds scientists to investigate whether egg consumption raises blood cholesterol levels, the reserach will find that the answer is "no" as long as they use subjects who are already eating plenty of meat and dairy (ie most Americans).
It depends on what meals you skip. If you skip breakfast and eat big meals at night, it is bad.
I know it is America, but did you mean 25,000 calories in less than 8 hours at 8:44 ?
I wouldn't speculate that Mic is actually dyslexic, but he often makes such mistakes. it should say 2500 cal, but it's actually more accurate to say 2500 kcal.
I always crave fruits when i am fasting. I never crave anything fatty or cooked.
8:46 3000 cal over 12 hours and 25000 cal over
Research into IF in the future is going to be so confuzzled thanks to keto diets, as it is super big in that community. Good luck to anyone trying to untangle that mess.
According to Dr Will Bulseiwcz, Plant based GI doc, the microbiome needs a rest and that TRE has a positive effect on the microbiome.
He had also said to me that it can have a detrimental effect and that faster for 24hrs could kill off all beneficial bacteria as they are very short lived. Maybe it depends on the length of fast?
Good point
@@HenchHerbivore Yeah, the 24-48 hour fasts never made sense to me because in this period the body hasn't switched to famine mode and will break down protein for carb burning
@@HenchHerbivore The positive TRE fasting period he referred to was the standard 12-16 hour fast (most of which is during sleep)
He doesn't recommend fasting because it harms the microbiome. Also, he's now a spokesperson for that muffin company (white flour, eggs and all) so I don't take what he says seriously
I HATE CARNIVORES!!! We are the best!!!!!!!! VEGANZ RULE!!!!! Let's do our best to show we are Right! Can you make fun of the carnivore eatiers again and show proof you are whats correct!!!!!!!!!!!
It’s a shame you don’t do your research
Intermitted fasting the best! and fasting!
Intermittent fasting on a standard American(or chinese) diet is definitely going to be associated with heart disease.
People with
When I fast, I actually eat once in that day so I actually fast for 20-24 hours after that!!! I have never really done the 16:8 the way they say where you might eat a ton of food in an 8-hour window!! If I fasted for 16 hours, I still would eat that one meal only and then fast! Thats actually how your gonna lose weight along with exercise!!!
A lot of people who do IF eat cheeseburger’s during their 8 hour window! That is probably the reason
14:35 On the other hand, the less than 8-h window people have the highest tobacco smoking consumption, and in addition, that group also has the largest percentage of black people (23.2% vs. 8.0% overall), the smallest percentage of white people (50.2% vs. 73.3% overall), the highest average BMI (29.9 kg/m2 vs. 28.7 kg/m2 overall) with the highest standard deviation (0.6 vs. 0.1 overall), and the second largest percentage of men (54.8% vs 50.0% overall) only smaller than in the more than 16-h window people (59.0%).
"Accidental intermittent fasting" - how is that a valid criticism? Like you said, it should make no difference overall. Except maybe for psychosomatic effects because you REALLY believe that you're doing something healthy. But that's a bias that you generally wouldn't want to skew your data.
Personally, I guess I am an accidental intermittent faster because I'm not a morning person AND suffer from reflux problems and stop eating ~4 hours before going to bed. But that's why I also eat 8 200-250 kcal meals, which I suppose doesn't count as "heavy". 😅
Hi Mic, great job as always, but I have a bone to pick with you about your Complement ad. It’s just not remotely true that you pay more buying the vitamins separately, and I think you know this. 50/month plus another 10 for shipping would be 3 times more than what I pay for my multi plus DHA/EPA (I get 90 pills). Let’s keep it honest. I have nothing against the company, they sell a good product, but they cost more when compared to other options.
HUGE TYPO at 08:45, Should be "2500 calories over
Saying intermittenting fasting is bad for you is like saying diet coke is bad for you. Yeah, maybe . But it's still better for you. 🙄 So much better for you that you should. You should have a diet coke if you're gonna drink soda.
Since we are on the topic I ate over 6000 calories today and I feel like a god thanks to seed symbiotic!
I'm cherry picking and giving anecdotes, but there's a lot of 30 year old pharmacists having heart attacks and a lot of them are working 12 hour straight without meals.
For most of human history, people didn’t have the money to eat multiple times daily, let alone eating every day. I really doubt fasting today would be so troublesome for people’s systems to handle it. Even the Bible comments that fasting is a good thing.
I’ve eaten once or twice a day for most of my life since I have been working.
The study in question is low grade data of course. But... the other more reliable studies show a very significant trend showing that skipping breakfast and condensing the eating time frame might be causing more harm than good. I normally skip breakfast, but I will change that idea from now on....because the logic is pretty strong. I've known of cases where people have large feasts like Christmas and have died on boxing day, and that danger is also well documented. The body purposely sends people to sleep after a huge meal, so as to preserve energy and avoid strenuous tasks that might potentially blow the system! Speading things out may be a wiser choice.
I know your neutral to it, and I just need to put it out there that being vegan combined with longer time periods in the evening without food really helps out with a lot of menopausal issues for myself. I don't care if it's fasting or not, it's just helpful at this point not to have food eating after 4pm for me. I still eat 3 meals and my meals actually start at 5 am because of my schedule but it's probably around 14-16 hrs without food just to help with the issues of hormonal changes and the affect on the digestive system. I think it needs to be approached on an individual basis for sure.
There were a number of "studies" lately binding CVD mortality to all (un)possible causes. All, but one. And I'm not allowed to say which one.
Hey Mike! Great video again!
About the stress hypothesis: My experience is that some people do like you suggest Mike - eat all day when they are more stressed, some lose appetite (and don't self-soothe with food) so they eat less and at fewer occasions. So my guess is that both types are in this study and the "ledd than 8 hours"-group probably picks up a bunch of the latter.
About the "better study because of unintentional IF" - I guess it would depend on how well they control for food quality. If they could do that with great certainty it is a nice natural experiment, otherwise there's a big risk that they also had poorer quality of their food.
Another factor which seems important to denote is which time of day where they eating. If there were a lot of shift-workers like Gil suggested, and they had their eating window late in the day or even into the night, their circadian rhythm probably were worse off as well.
I would love it if a bunch of the participants of the Framingham Heart study did IF for a long time. That would be super interesting! ;D
Thanks again!
Cheers from Sweden
It's not fair that you somehow lump together ketolards and carnitards with this study. I'm on a low carb diet and mainly plant based (various LCHF breads, lots of peanut and cashew butters, pea protein pancakes with almond and coconout flour etc.) and not sure why you shit on this.
I do feel like this study is pretty useless for most cases of intermitten fasting.
It really only proofs that being morbidly obese and intermitten fasting is not a good combination.
Which does make perfect sense, given how much calories you need to take in to reach a BMI of 30 while intermitten fasting.
But for normal people, with a healthy BMI, I doubt there would be any correlation to more heart problem. In fact it might be the opposite.
It really helps to go for healthy people if you want to prove something is less healthy...
Fasting has been a thing for literally thousands of years. I think I'll go with the long, long history of success against a study paid for by who knows who that's tell you to eat more (which means buy more food).
No thanks to this misinformation.
I have been trying a time-restricted eating schedule - by skipping breakfast - and haven't noticed feeling any health benefits. Porridge for breakfast tomorrow!
Great video. Again. Thanks. I have a question. is the presumed higher death rate among people who do TRE or intermitted fasting maybe caused by or linked to exercise. If you have eaten to little or to much you might not have the energy to excercise.
I personally don't go along with the intermittent fasting vibe. I think that people like most other living creatures are best suited to grazing - eating little and often. Eating one meal, two meals or three meals a day can put quite a heavy burden on the system. And, where did we get this eating meals idea? I guess the same people who brainwashed us into thinking we need to eat only at mealtimes are the ones who claim that 'snacking' between meals is bad....who says?
This study is awful, embarrassing for you to get sucked into classic media attention grabbing headlines. Maybe learn a bit more about proper scientific method before making a video?
I always feel better when eating less. That says something.
I eat dried mushrooms a lot when I feel like I need to lose weight.
the oyster mushrooms are supposed to be good for weight loss (as well as carnatine and berberine)
Anyone interested in fasting in general should listen to Dr Michael Klaper. He is one of the original doctors on YT to introduce water fasting.
Lmao I’m fasting I’m trying to leave this dream called life
Yes, let’s be careful not to skip breakfast, fried eggs, sausages, and pancakes that will really improve our health
First! No but really, thanks for making awsome content. Will make sure to watch this one thoroughly!
💚🐾🌱💚🐾🌱💚🐾🌱💚🐾🌱
The only way this could be true is if you're already at minimum weight for health, with no fat on your body, so your body will start to use your organs to burn as fuel. Majority of faiths fast.
Every time something comes out, at first its WOW and after no no don't do it. Once again i read this study it makes no sense at all, depending on what you eat during your window, and how can not eating cause heart issues.
Bro, you know how much bad shit in vegggies lol
Stop with the fucking click bait.
Everyone should ignore this study.