YBA vs TCA: A Direct Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 июн 2024
  • Today we're going to be taking a look at 2 games that I've been extremely passionate about in the last 3 years, those games being the Roblox Juggernaut that is YBA, and the small, usually barely 100 player game, TCA!
    Play TCA Here! www.roblox.com/games/96772427...
    0:00 Intro
    1:22 Combat
    3:25 Balance
    4:54 The Map
    6:42 Gamemodes
    8:22 Updates
    9:48 Visuals
    11:44 Staff Transparency
    13:29 Content
    14:27 Future Potential
    15:57 Conclusion
    #roblox #yba #jojo
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 932

  • @felibunn
    @felibunn 8 месяцев назад +586

    Since I feel like this is a good video to put this out here.
    For those of you who don't use discord, since there's some people who don't.
    Feel free to ask me any questions about TCA, since I am the head staff.
    I will try my best to answer everything I can.

    • @aarnikka
      @aarnikka 8 месяцев назад +26

      D-d-d-d-d-do you remember me..?

    • @user-zi9nh2dr6o
      @user-zi9nh2dr6o 8 месяцев назад +11

      Why is star platinum the world’s scarf red

    • @isaiahjoseph7352
      @isaiahjoseph7352 8 месяцев назад +9

      1.Do you think that the game was made longevity in mind?
      2. Are any additional stands planned or just let alone ones that aren't really seen on similar jojo games on the sight (I.E The fool or something like echoes)

    • @normguy5794
      @normguy5794 8 месяцев назад

      Hi, will there be some changes to the 1v1 matchmaking in the future? As for now, practically every game I am have wait too much ping to be able to play and react to attacks (1 second of lag for any move), or it's the enemy that have way too much ping making it not enjoyable too. I know that there are not enough players right now to put a matchmaking based on region right now (I guess), but could this be an option later?
      For exemple I know a game that have an option for players to choose if they want to be matched with anybody for quicker waiting time, or if they want to be only able to be matched with people from the same region only for longer waiting but good ping garanteed. Maybe this could be an option ?

    • @felibunn
      @felibunn 8 месяцев назад +7

      @@aarnikka I do

  • @historicflame972
    @historicflame972 8 месяцев назад +528

    When John Crazy said 'That Adventure Was Crazy' I really felt that

    • @Danyardrat
      @Danyardrat 8 месяцев назад +37

      Crazy? I was crazy once

    • @mettat9062
      @mettat9062 8 месяцев назад +35

      ​@@Danyardratrubber? I was rubber once. They crazed me in a room, a rat room, a rat room with locks, locks made me rubber.

    • @anyaguilar1595
      @anyaguilar1595 8 месяцев назад +8

      ​@@DanyardratThey locked me in a room

    • @dontmindme431
      @dontmindme431 8 месяцев назад +7

      ​@@mettat9062my head hurts

    • @lvl9970
      @lvl9970 8 месяцев назад +23

      ​@@mettat9062rubber? I was a condom once. They kept me inside a packet for months and months. I think my owner was a loser. I was used on a banana and then thrown away 😔💔

  • @j-money753
    @j-money753 8 месяцев назад +99

    Yba in the title? You know what that means. FREE VIEWS!

    • @Danyardrat
      @Danyardrat 8 месяцев назад +1

      @eclipse 😭

    • @homele576
      @homele576 8 месяцев назад +1

      fr

    • @user-kh6hu7fw6r
      @user-kh6hu7fw6r 8 месяцев назад +1

      Why did I have to scroll down so far just to see a comment with a reply

    • @hypergg681
      @hypergg681 7 месяцев назад

      Yba has become trash , shit ass reworks

    • @user-fd8sn3dp1x
      @user-fd8sn3dp1x 2 месяца назад

      Real

  • @drowsyzzzz2055
    @drowsyzzzz2055 8 месяцев назад +282

    I think its because one focuses on visual appeal more, which is the main reason why games made by bigger companies are easier to pick up, because they look stunning. Like think for a sec why skins are popular, its because it makes someone look cooler in that one game, and hence YBA is more of a trading simulator than a fighting game.

    • @MarukaiX
      @MarukaiX 8 месяцев назад +47

      I agree,.yba is a dumpster fire but a polished, golden dumpster fire while TCA is improving but at the same time looks average and basic ngl

    • @friendlyneighborhoodrker8251
      @friendlyneighborhoodrker8251 8 месяцев назад +29

      this is exactly what i was going to say. before eclipses videos on TCA, i joined the game to see what it was like. 10 minutes later i left because it just didnt look good. the gui was crude and i thought it was just a YBA clone. eclipses videos made me give it a second time and i now play it semi-frequently

    • @cengix8850
      @cengix8850 8 месяцев назад +2

      I’d pick yba over tca just because of how rough tca is, feels like release yba

    • @Unita_8869
      @Unita_8869 8 месяцев назад +3

      YBA isn’t a dumpster fire, and neither is it just a trading game, the combat is much more better than TCA’s.

    • @rafnaqi2257
      @rafnaqi2257 8 месяцев назад +5

      ​@@Unita_8869care to explain the dying playercount?

  • @alexiotron
    @alexiotron 8 месяцев назад +78

    seeing eclipse this optimistic is honestly a really nice breath of fresh air. hoping to see this genre(?) go places even though i've already made my peace with it

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад +27

      I can see why you'd feel that way, can only get burned so many times right?

    • @jackthecommenter2768
      @jackthecommenter2768 8 месяцев назад +3

      @@EclipseGameplays❤

  • @drxshock6957
    @drxshock6957 8 месяцев назад +102

    I decided to give TCA a chance the other week because of your videos. In the very short amount of time I've played (probably only about 5 hours in total) I already reached the max level, obtained Made in Heaven (which actually bothers to use effects and voicelines from the Anime), and gotten skins for The World and Star Platinum. Comparing that to YBA where doing the exact same things would take me at least quadruple the time it felt like a breath of fresh air. Perhaps my favourite moment is rolling The World (my favourite stand in JoJo) for the first time after getting the 10 stand arrows from Jotaro and not only discovering that it _isn't_ a broken mess left only as a stepping stone to another objectively more powerful stand, but that a SPTW like evolution would be added into the game later down the line alongside TWOH (with my favourite colour scheme for it as its base form no less which won't be locked behind a terrible, messy rendition of it as a skin) was my deciding factor to stick with the game. I still sometimes play YBA if I want to play stands that aren't in the game yet like TA4 but the moment TCA adds all of those stands in, I'm leaving that dumpster fire behind.

    • @Vinnare
      @Vinnare 8 месяцев назад +4

      This is only like one part of the whole thing you said but the reason YBA "doesnt bother" to use effects from the anime is because it was, yk, added before the anime adaptation of p6 was thing. YBA is eventually going to rework WS, Cmoon, and MIH though which then I assume will make it a lot higher qaulity. It could even be relatively soon cuz the remodels for ws and cmoon have already come out and the mih remodel has been leaked.

    • @gamercentral2417
      @gamercentral2417 8 месяцев назад +5

      @@Vinnarenah that’s gonna take longer than the heaven (peak) update. Heck even then updates only took like 2-3 weeks per stand

    • @drxshock6957
      @drxshock6957 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@Vinnare That's not an excuse. They could very easily update all of that, especially now that the new VAs have voicelines outside the anime itself thanks to ASBR. They just don't out of laziness.

    • @cengix8850
      @cengix8850 8 месяцев назад

      yeah why bother replacing sfx with different sfx even if the current sfx are completely fine?

    • @ginnogianni1980
      @ginnogianni1980 8 месяцев назад

      to be honest i like the asb sfx more. i like the voice actor better idk why

  • @metatrouble
    @metatrouble 8 месяцев назад +70

    7:15 Sbr is literally the reason I haven’t quit yba yet, that gamemode is just so unique and fun, people don’t give it enough credit. Like it’s so awesome to randomly come across some dude getting beat up in a desert, help them and then proceed to team up and take on the rest of the server together. There’s just nothing like it in any other roblox jojo game. Some of my most fun times on yba have been in sbr

    • @ricedolphin7348
      @ricedolphin7348 8 месяцев назад +11

      Exactly. SBR is a gift to mankind, it's honestly insane imagining a battle royale where being last one standing isn't the only way. If it had more mevhanics and options this gamemode would be better than any battle royale in existence

    • @metatrouble
      @metatrouble 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@ricedolphin7348 If I remember correctly sbr is supposed to get a rework of some kind? Which kind of worries me because I don’t want them to fuck up the one good thing in yba

    • @halelolel
      @halelolel 8 месяцев назад

      Sbr reminds me of isle

    • @niturius17272
      @niturius17272 8 месяцев назад +8

      Ong its so fun when i wipe the server but the ''YbaAlt102310'' appears out of nowhere beating me with scripts

    • @Vinnare
      @Vinnare 8 месяцев назад +5

      Well just gonna state the obvious, the reason it gets so much hate is because of the hackers that ruined the gamemode for so long. Obviously the hackers died down and its much more fun now but it still just left a bad image in most peoples eyes so a lot less people will actually give it a shot.

  • @hecmainiac9648
    @hecmainiac9648 8 месяцев назад +83

    Tca is good and I do play it but the deal breaker for some people might be the lack of stands as there is only like 10

    • @felibunn
      @felibunn 8 месяцев назад +28

      That is something that will of course be improved with time.
      TCA is still very much new, compared to YBA, which has existed for years

    • @godkidv666
      @godkidv666 8 месяцев назад

      CAP THE STORY LINE IS TARSH ITS TO HARD but yba is just pliont stand with barrge to win story line LIKE NO ONE WANT TO GRIND THERE LIFE AWAY

    • @syyruppallaround
      @syyruppallaround 8 месяцев назад +18

      ⁠@@godkidv666YBA is literally a grinding game for skins now, and also.. how is it the devs fault if you’re ass at games?

    • @Xone37
      @Xone37 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@syyruppallaroundfr

    • @somemeatball368
      @somemeatball368 8 месяцев назад +8

      @@godkidv666 Skill issue

  • @Ripimaverage
    @Ripimaverage 8 месяцев назад +16

    you should’ve talked about the skin situation in yba to, it’s insane how much people will abandon the core mechanics of a game for a skin

    • @notori-di5et
      @notori-di5et 8 месяцев назад +3

      Happening to aut rn basically every game that release skin ruin the game ngl when it become necessity and become addicted to it

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад +11

      I mean, there's really not much to say that's not already been said. The reason YBAs skins "problem" is so out of hand is because of the constant content droughts. It's all people have to do, and the longer the game doesn't add real content, the more players who are just there for that either turn to skins, or quit

    • @reeedeleeedleeelescreams8756
      @reeedeleeedleeelescreams8756 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@EclipseGameplays The funny thing is that the player count dropped once they stopped adding skins to YBA. The old players left once the game started revolving around skins, and the skin farmers left once there were no more skins to farm for.

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад

      @@reeedeleeedleeelescreams8756 I guess when they learned they couldn't please everyone, they decided to please no one, lol

  • @epicmemay8361
    @epicmemay8361 8 месяцев назад +49

    I played TCA because of your content, the only problem is that i live in AUS so i'm gonna have 200+ ping when i join public servers. other than that i went through the hell of getting the 18 1v1 wins for TWOH while having 400 ping. game was fun.

    • @roberteriksson1248
      @roberteriksson1248 8 месяцев назад +6

      As a fellow Australian I feel your pain, If the game had more players then we could join and fight people in our region rather than having to play in US or Asian servers. Would make getting twoh much easier.

    • @newweaponssoldier4127
      @newweaponssoldier4127 8 месяцев назад

      EXACTLY. Exact same problem in YBA too. SBR, 1v1’s, none of these things are fun in 400 ping, and it’s the worst that we have to do these gamemodes to obtain stands.

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад +8

      I used to play with an Australian a long time ago, and they said that on YBA they never got below 180 ping, so I feel for you guys

    • @newweaponssoldier4127
      @newweaponssoldier4127 8 месяцев назад

      @@EclipseGameplays Any idea if the devs can implement a system that allows you to queue with other players in certain regions for 1v1's? Even just displaying the region/ping for sbr servers when they release would be awesome too.

    • @Tea12515
      @Tea12515 8 месяцев назад +3

      As a Malaysian with a shit 8 year old computer, I have adapted to fight at 600 ping and praying that I win. 🙏🙏

  • @michaeltrevino7549
    @michaeltrevino7549 8 месяцев назад +16

    30 minutes from when this video released tca has nearly tripled from the average 50 visits.
    Keep up the good work eclipse, were all cheering you on.

  • @mr.inconspicuous.1845
    @mr.inconspicuous.1845 7 месяцев назад +1

    I just watch your videos to support you even if I don't play the games, its just always interesting to hear you praise a game, hate on a game, enjoy a game, or play it with your friends :)

  • @leonardo8888
    @leonardo8888 8 месяцев назад +3

    I started playing TCA yesterday because of you Eclipse, I've been enjoying it!

  • @rocswan600
    @rocswan600 8 месяцев назад +11

    it's sad to see roblox jojo games slowly falling from grace

  • @ar7hur06
    @ar7hur06 8 месяцев назад +4

    9:50 there's clearly an argument to be made here about how less complexity and fidelity in your graohics can help you convey things better, like the reusing of the old break effect in perfect parries, as it was quite literally a reverse block break, even in color. Or in the explosions, which were simplistic but effective on showing their range.

  • @OverYoutube-
    @OverYoutube- 8 месяцев назад +7

    I really enjoy TCA, I thought it was a ton of fun when I binged it! I really think the issue is lack of stands and maybe some VFX. I’d play the game more but life’s busy. But if there was a cool Halloween event, or maybe a big update I think that could do great.

  • @sleepy_6540
    @sleepy_6540 8 месяцев назад +7

    just wanted to say that i love your content eclipse,keep up the hard work man

  • @wizardlizard524
    @wizardlizard524 8 месяцев назад +3

    I actually tried TCA a bit ago and I enjoyed it a lot. It's simple but that's what I like about it. The map is a nice size, the stands have a decent amount of moves, the combat is fun, and there's still more in the game that I haven't got around to trying yet like the specs and other game modes. Overall, I just enjoy the game for what it is.

  • @johnreynaldrala4053
    @johnreynaldrala4053 8 месяцев назад

    This actually relates so hard as back in the day I was all in for Jojo games.from abd and old aut then from old yba,aut:nu,crusaders heaven,world of stands on its beta,tb2, RIU and much more.but ever since yba has been reworking the specs and the realization that yba has bearly any content other then sbr.i didint had the motivation play Jojo games at all cuz I thought to myself that all these Jojo games keeps on getting made but then in a couple of months it will eventually die or it will feel repetitive and it will repeat itself over and over again.

  • @blackholle6841
    @blackholle6841 8 месяцев назад +5

    I can't get used to the combat in TCA, however I do enjoy watching you play it. (even though it's super similar to yba's)
    I loved the combat of yba back then, when the spec's were still "normal", but now I can't even play that.

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад +2

      Old habits die hard I guess lol! I mean you can tell from my god awful YBA gameplay that I just never even tried to adapt my gameplay as YBAs combat turned into "just press buttons" so playing TCA was just like riding a bike

  • @Zemtie
    @Zemtie 8 месяцев назад +3

    Love your vids!

  • @mauron55
    @mauron55 8 месяцев назад +2

    I had thought about this since the vampirism ''rework'' but a way to kinda stop those extreme combos or having to know what 20 keys do could be to add a move limit so you can only have x moves both on specs and stands.
    Anyway Uzu will never do anything that has the word balance in it and I don't even play YBA anymore so, just an idea (that probably many people already talked about).

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад +1

      They won't do this, but it's honestly not a terrible idea. It'd add a lot to build variety too

  • @GagamaruLOCKED
    @GagamaruLOCKED 8 месяцев назад +1

    What an amazing video not gonna lie, might actually make me go back and try both games

  • @henreee5936
    @henreee5936 8 месяцев назад

    Props Eclipse 👏You have made a video where you can mix the fun of TCA with the views of YBA (Seriously though, love to see you having fun with vids again)

  • @MagicalMistro
    @MagicalMistro 8 месяцев назад +4

    thank you for turning people onto TCA, its a much more enjoyable game (and not to mention the staff being really helpful

  • @Loozer__
    @Loozer__ 8 месяцев назад +6

    The main reason I dont play the game is mainly because, it might just be me, the game feels really clunky pvp wise.

  • @IDKTV412
    @IDKTV412 8 месяцев назад

    thanks you got me into tca and I have been having a lot of fun with it

  • @Lesandjoot
    @Lesandjoot 8 месяцев назад +1

    great vid eclipse!

  • @KitCat1908
    @KitCat1908 8 месяцев назад +3

    when i tried out the game, it was great, the issue i had with the game was the performance issues.
    My current assumption is either server region limits or just my personal issue, but i have an average of 300-500 ping in TCA servers.

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад +2

      If the player count is low, odds of finding a sever in a low population region are even lower. And unfortunate side effect that can only be remedied by the game being more popular

  • @itzpotato7060
    @itzpotato7060 8 месяцев назад +3

    yba just feels more solid i dont know what it is though. maybe its the sound feedback, maybe its animation i have no clue

  • @Bushables
    @Bushables 8 месяцев назад

    great video man,
    I've personally fallen out of love with roblox jojo, I still watch your content.
    I think its just time until TCA is recognized as a better game.
    I haven't been playing it due to a lack of content but, the mosh-pit gamemode is definitely a step in the right direction.

  • @MonkeDreemurr2787196339mOnKeY
    @MonkeDreemurr2787196339mOnKeY 8 месяцев назад +2

    Old YBA was honestly so much fun. It kinda sucks to see how much it's digressed from it's actual combat to just make attacks look cooler. Despite that, great memories made from playing this game so I probably won't completely abandon it.

  • @AsvaldoAbidaDergin
    @AsvaldoAbidaDergin 8 месяцев назад +23

    I will never forget how I managed to get the last piece of the corpse to get MIH in YBA. I went into SBR solo and used the world to go on top of the walls to avoid everyone until that last part, then it was down to 3 people including me, there was an Anubis with pluck and a magician’s red. They weren’t able to knock me off my horse and I ran around till the bridge opened and got 1st. Last time I had fun playing YBA

    • @AsvaldoAbidaDergin
      @AsvaldoAbidaDergin 8 месяцев назад +2

      Not related to my original comment but just a side note that is sort of related to the video, so there is this game called build a boat, I really enjoy it but there is just one thing I don’t like about the people who run it. I told the discord about a bug that had been in the game for multiple months and still exists in the game to this day, I think it’s been a year and it still hasn’t been fixed. But guess what some dev said to me, “wait for the next update” so I did, and guess what, wasn’t fixed at all. They lied directly to my face and still haven’t fixed it after a year. Their game is amazing but the way they handle things just isn’t all there.

    • @UppertextBottomtext
      @UppertextBottomtext 8 месяцев назад +2

      ​@@AsvaldoAbidaDerginman that sucks :(

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад +14

      I remember the days back when I was beyond awful, and had nobody to play with. I wanted to get GER so bad, so I'd hide in the tents until stage 3, and then gun it. Used stand jump and plucks old aerial ace to cheese out the win. No matter what they do to the game, those memories will never leave us

    • @reeedeleeedleeelescreams8756
      @reeedeleeedleeelescreams8756 8 месяцев назад +1

      I remember when I was trying to get MiH for the first time - at least a bit. I'd had the same C-Moon for about 2-3 months when they added the Heaven update (I was stoked to see the player count shoot up and see a bunch of C-Moons running around). The process of getting the corpse parts was fun, but not too interesting to talk about; just regular SBR gameplay. I do remember one guy giving me the left arm, though, which made me super excited since it was the last part I needed. I later beat DIO:OH and SO Jotaro and got MiH after about 2 months. I continued to play YBA consistently for another year or so, before eventually shifting away from it as the game became more skin-heavy and less fun. I still have that same MiH in my Stand Storage. I think the reason the game stopped being fun was because of the lack of new content and eventual squandering of the combat. I'm gonna try TCA so I can get some of that fun that I had back in old YBA.

    • @Stando-User
      @Stando-User 8 месяцев назад +1

      I remmeber I was the 3rd last person in SBR. I didn’t have my horse but the last two had horses. They then claimed their prizes. I knew they would try to kill me, so I hid in those black pillars at the sides of the final road. They walked by me and I rushed to the end and won

  • @K00ZR
    @K00ZR 8 месяцев назад +49

    While i do think TCA has a bright future , the main reason people still play yba is just due to the diversity of stands and specs , Tca becomes very boring after you complete the storyline and get the stand you want.
    On the map part:
    I prefer the tca map due to the fact its much easier to learn it compared to the yba map,every building looks.
    Gamemodes:
    YBA has better gamemodes, TCA has pretty boring gamemodes.
    yba's 1v1s just feel much smoother than tca's 1v1s
    Updates:
    As a HW main, i must agree that hw was one of the easiests stands to use due to just being able to throw out moves
    Visual effects:
    Honestly , YBA has much better effects but its indeed extremely annoying barely being able to see due to how many effects are on the screen.
    Animations:
    Most of TCA's stands feel up to date ,YBA's stands feel like a mess of animations , we have animations like beach boy while we have stuff like scary monster
    Transparency:
    As a TCA tester , the tca staff is very friendly and will actually try to help you out.On the yba part i cant comment due to the fact im not active at all in the YBA discord
    Content:
    Yba has way more stands and specs , gamemodes aswell,But TCA indeed has potential to beat yba
    Potential:
    TCA updates every month or so ,while yba takes 5 months for a single stand to come out.
    Conclusion:
    While i do like tca , i must say i do prefer yba due to the fact it feels much smoother.
    Great video eclipse❤

    • @existingpersonyes2028
      @existingpersonyes2028 8 месяцев назад +4

      said everything i felt pretty much, the only addition i could give is more just adding to the point of stand diversity, i really like non humanoids like hermit purple and they arent currently as present aside from 6p

    • @ginnogianni1980
      @ginnogianni1980 8 месяцев назад +1

      i like tca more since... tca feels more like yba than yba currently does. i know its weird but the simple vfx and models and the great combat make it more engaging. yba feels like it lost its soul

    • @itzpotato7060
      @itzpotato7060 8 месяцев назад +1

      yba just feels more solid i dont know what it is though. maybe its the sound feedback, maybe its animation i have no clue

    • @youngsy4604
      @youngsy4604 8 месяцев назад

      Tca is lokey bout to become the best jojo game

  • @Idontknowwhattodowwwwww
    @Idontknowwhattodowwwwww 8 месяцев назад

    as soon as u posted ur first tca video I checked it out and I didn't like it ar first but I eventually warmed up to it way more than I could ever do to yba great idea to make this video to pull people out of the yba wormhole

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад

      Tbh with you, the quality difference in terms of combat between the MIH rework when I made my first video, and the 6P addition is staggering. I wish I'd known, I would have waited.

  • @Akonocon
    @Akonocon 8 месяцев назад

    I found tca on its release and to put it frankly I enjoyed it! At the time I was watching you play yba and I was like "I would love to see eclipse play tca" and I come back to your channel 1 month later and see this! 😂

  • @The25thSub
    @The25thSub 8 месяцев назад +4

    Ngl I haven’t even finish yba story or touched tca just like watching ur videos
    Maybe majority of tca viewers are just like me and like watching ur vids idk

    • @arandomgamer2433
      @arandomgamer2433 8 месяцев назад +1

      same except i have finnised yba story but it was years ago

  • @The_Hydration_Police
    @The_Hydration_Police 8 месяцев назад +5

    I know killer queen is bad, but it’s very fun to annoy people with

    • @GameMasterDuelist
      @GameMasterDuelist 8 месяцев назад

      if you are a kq main I grantee you have a good move:lag on you're side as anytime kq explosions happen on my pc it wants to explode.

    • @LanceAFate
      @LanceAFate 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@GameMasterDuelistif you think kq is laggy then i hope you dont meet weather report. Frog rain is literally the laggiest move ive seen in my life

    • @kirbs_3378
      @kirbs_3378 8 месяцев назад

      When people forget about the hand for as bad as kq

  • @ninjadefogo1630
    @ninjadefogo1630 8 месяцев назад

    I watch because you are one great guy i stopped play jojo games long time ago

  • @edittakacs6875
    @edittakacs6875 8 месяцев назад

    wow this vid actually convinced me to play tca, thanks for the nice informations!

  • @ameenshams1925
    @ameenshams1925 8 месяцев назад +10

    The reason tca has A LOT less players is because dopamine.dopamine is a centre is the brain that makes us feels good such was when we eat junk food we creat dopamine. Tca doesn’t have crazy graphics and is simple but the combat is amazing but people don’t want that , people want a bunch of graphics ands cool effects and to win by mashing buttons, people don’t want to use skill they just want to button mash and see cool effects and win, this creates dopamine so people keep coming back and back and back and back. And that’s the reason y a is so popular and tca isnt

    • @MarukaiX
      @MarukaiX 8 месяцев назад

      True it's sad though

    • @IrisBread
      @IrisBread 8 месяцев назад

      actually,good combat+ good effects and game being simple is way better then good combat mid effects or good effects bad combat. look at the strongest battlegrounds

    • @existingpersonyes2028
      @existingpersonyes2028 8 месяцев назад

      i dont share the opinion, the visuals play a role but i feel its more in game identity and conveying information to the player, how combat feels and your options play a large role even more so the first stand you get, yba had a lot of stands that id consider "beginner friendly" that are often simple to a fault that eased people in, Mr.President, Sticky Fingers, Aerosmith, The Hand, Crazy Diamond (the old one), Scary Monsters (old),each of them had honestly simple movesets that were of varied utility
      TCA's stands are all more complex with counters, projectiles, stuns and a more complex game plan than others which in theory isnt bad but its just a lot of options to instantly be thrust into not knowing whats good or not to go for when you first join and have limited points to work with, paired with a cast of stands a third the size of yba and almost all humanoids that people new just end up feeling lost which i feel is why people asked for that tca beginners guide from eclipse

    • @stars4772
      @stars4772 8 месяцев назад

      What u saying? Why the strongest battlegrounds has lots of players then?

  • @arandomgamer2433
    @arandomgamer2433 8 месяцев назад +3

    the reason i dont play tca isn't cus i think its worst than yba I just got hooked on souls like games now adays.

  • @ZeroStarAnimations
    @ZeroStarAnimations 8 месяцев назад +1

    I watch these videos because im interested oin seeing games i never played, and enjoy watching you actually have fun. I guess i just dont want to start a whole new game yet

  • @GreatandGolden
    @GreatandGolden 8 месяцев назад +2

    Great vid! Unfortunitly, you forgot to put subway serfers on the side so the yba people wouldn't fall asleep, now they will never see it and open their 1st eye.

  • @BlackFlash36
    @BlackFlash36 8 месяцев назад +4

    Eclipse the reason why TCA isnt getting any players is because its the same as yba just more balanced and less content + most jojo games are unpopular if not advertised by other roblox youtubers such as yourself

    • @Human_that_exists
      @Human_that_exists 8 месяцев назад

      What?

    • @BlackFlash36
      @BlackFlash36 8 месяцев назад

      only reason you know what TCA is because you watched Eclipse right?@@Human_that_exists

  • @rfewer
    @rfewer 8 месяцев назад +7

    1:40 this is one of my biggest complaints with how YBA was when I stopped playing it. I remember the days when you could pair any spec with almost any stand and have a comprehensible idea of what you’re doing. Nowadays every spec and stand that releases has like at least 8 moves each and so the investment of time you need to put into mapping your key binds, learning them + combos takes away from the original fun and simplicity old YBA had. I appreciate the effort they go into making these high quality stands and the impressive graphics design, but from a gameplay perspective the dynamic between old & new move-sets have way too big of a contrast. Personally, I just wish stands released with less moves so there’s a bigger emphasis on unique play styles and skill rather than just mashing inputs…

    • @Vinnare
      @Vinnare 8 месяцев назад +1

      Fr why do specs need to be so complicated now and have so much more moves. A spec should just be there to enhance your stand not be a standalone thing that can practically be used without needing a stand.

    • @alexiotron
      @alexiotron 8 месяцев назад

      i really agree with this one right here. i remember challenging myself by having a slot dedicated to just randomly using an arrow and pairing it with whatever spec i happened to have to just run into 1v1s and try it out. and when i had the itch to do it again, i'd just roka whatever i had in that slot and reroll a new stand. i discovered a ton of cool synergies that way but with how over-complicated things are now you really don't have that level of flexibility anymore.

    • @gamercentral2417
      @gamercentral2417 8 месяцев назад

      @@Vinnarethat’s why I love old specs. Felt like genuine addons instead of movesets.
      Boxing was for damage and stun
      Hamon was boxing but a bit more complicated and more for damage
      Vampire was for stun and winning in the short game
      And pluck was for combos and being similar to a actual moveset
      Spin was for range and combo starting

    • @Vinnare
      @Vinnare 8 месяцев назад

      @@gamercentral2417 yeah but now its like you have 2 movesets that can you use completely independent of each other and the specs are actually stronger than the stands

    • @gamercentral2417
      @gamercentral2417 8 месяцев назад

      @@Vinnare exactly. Yba now is just a button mashing contest

  • @illYT-tt2vm
    @illYT-tt2vm 8 месяцев назад

    The grinding does seem as atrocious, I’ll give it a try when I finish today!
    Thanks for recommending a good game I will play with my mates

  • @CorruptTypes
    @CorruptTypes 8 месяцев назад

    i only subbed to you in 2020 cuz you made funny content, i only really watch vids that appear in my recommended as i dont really like yba or tca

  • @muckyesyesindisguise3854
    @muckyesyesindisguise3854 8 месяцев назад +3

    YBA wants to maximize its player count and get as much money as possible (because Uzu has either lost all of his self respect or lost his passion for the game) while TCA wants to make a good game.

  • @bean0241
    @bean0241 8 месяцев назад +5

    Mid vs Mid 😪

    • @slimeybob5294
      @slimeybob5294 8 месяцев назад

      Sir, what?

    • @saint6141
      @saint6141 7 месяцев назад

      Mid vs Mid 😪

    • @bean0241
      @bean0241 7 месяцев назад

      @@slimeybob5294 they're both mid games

  • @Dasupercooldog1234
    @Dasupercooldog1234 5 месяцев назад

    Eclipse thanks for making a great video I’m gonna give tca a try

  • @cryezen
    @cryezen 8 месяцев назад

    i havent played any games like this in awhile but ill probably try this out because of all your videos

  • @tobiasmyhre7888
    @tobiasmyhre7888 8 месяцев назад +5

    A direct comparion, but HEAVILY biased towards TCA

    • @kjiop1103
      @kjiop1103 8 месяцев назад +3

      what? in what way exactly is this biased, maybe im just biased towards eclipse but this video seems pretty objective to me
      if he was biased he would just kinda shit on yba and praise TCA, which is very much not what this video is

    • @hecmainiac9648
      @hecmainiac9648 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@kjiop1103yeah he gave credit where credit was due to yba. it didn’t feel too biased

  • @whyBecause
    @whyBecause 7 месяцев назад +1

    Some people jus don't want to play dead games, and when alot of people think the same the game just doesnt grow

  • @SuB-mt6nv
    @SuB-mt6nv 8 месяцев назад

    Well i have been looking for a new roblox game to play and ive been enjoying your TCA content lately, so ill give it shot.

  • @pycerns6786
    @pycerns6786 7 месяцев назад +2

    I don’t play either but ur actually glazing tca like crazy

  • @GPhoenix18
    @GPhoenix18 5 месяцев назад

    Looking at this video and taking all your points to consideration. I now will probably try out TCA. I’ll let yall know how it goes

  • @coralfishnt7663
    @coralfishnt7663 8 месяцев назад +2

    In updates you forgot to mention the super important yba emergency sKiN updates (If you couldn't tell a skin which you can't see in an average combo is more important than a 1 shot 2 move combo).

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад +3

      Won't lie, I don't think I've ever been more frustrated with a developer than when they came back solely to patch a skin dupe during the content drought, and then couldn't be bothered to fix TA4s infinite combo for a MONTH

  • @justinz2561
    @justinz2561 5 месяцев назад +1

    Thank you eclipse for for absolutely GLAZING "that crazy adventure"

  • @cherry_istrash
    @cherry_istrash 8 месяцев назад

    Hey eclipse I been watching you for years now i don't know why it said I'm not subscribed but i am and i wanted to recommend a game it looks cool I don't know if you have played it but its called Stand Powers!(Keep up the good work)

  • @ishowslow5044
    @ishowslow5044 8 месяцев назад +1

    1:00 I still feel like it's more because many people aren't willing to play another game to get the max level all over again for a game that doesn't have as much content as YBA even if the grinding is way shorter

  • @asmobile6169
    @asmobile6169 7 месяцев назад

    Great video.😊

  • @CorruptedPixelz1954
    @CorruptedPixelz1954 8 месяцев назад +2

    I played a bit of TCA the other night, and it started out great! I reminded me a lot of the good days of YBA and I genuinely enjoyed it. Then I realized I had beat the entire game in 30 minutes more or less. :/ What I feel the game needs right now is a longer story with maybe a way to make some stands harder to get? I literally started with Whitesnake and The World immediately.. I’m not gonna say YBA is necessarily better, but I’m my opinion YBA has a little bit more to do than TCA. (Tbf, my game time on TCA is really only like 2 hours, so maybe I’m missing something.)

    • @roberteriksson1248
      @roberteriksson1248 8 месяцев назад +1

      Just try out a bunch of stands, some stands like twoh can require a bit a grinding, or simply play the game and have fun, you don’t need a grind to have fun. I like that story is short because it means you can fight people a lot easier.

  • @foodoftherinnegan1583
    @foodoftherinnegan1583 8 месяцев назад

    personally i dont play either yba or tca have not played either in about half a year my issue is the type of game both are the reason i watch this is while playing isnt my preference watching someone like you makes it a bit more fun

  • @infectetgost7384
    @infectetgost7384 8 месяцев назад

    I tried playing TCA but I don’t have the time, I’ve been incredibly busy with my studies and I watch your videos in the background when I study or if I’m traveling somewhere. So yeah that’s my reason for not playing TCA

  • @Yoaten
    @Yoaten 8 месяцев назад +2

    Eclipse ive been grinding deepwoken but once i get burnt out or bored ill hop on tca just deep is alot of fun rn

  • @scorpz9011
    @scorpz9011 8 месяцев назад

    To be honest I just watch your videos because I'm a fan of your personality in general I'm really not that interested in jojo games but you somehow make them fun to watch so yeah

  • @dollythenoob5069
    @dollythenoob5069 8 месяцев назад

    honestly I don't play tca for a few reasons, 1 I already have a lot of hobbies, 2 I've got significantly less time for said hobbies and 3 I've lost intrest in playing roblox jojo games, however, I still watch your content as you are just a entertaining guy, you are effective at your job is what I'm saying

  • @Chaos_Star
    @Chaos_Star 8 месяцев назад +1

    I play TCA lol, thanks for introducing me to it

  • @izrayelgarcia4445
    @izrayelgarcia4445 8 месяцев назад

    Hey eclipse i know this has nothing to do with the video but another good backround music that you should use (or dont) is called My Castle Town its a nice and chill music.

  • @Clownpissgaming
    @Clownpissgaming 8 месяцев назад

    I never played yba or tca hell i don't know much about jojo yet still watch your videos.

  • @realsupergonks
    @realsupergonks 8 месяцев назад +2

    next you should do a direct comparison between blox fruit & gpo!

  • @JhoJhoScalesandVs
    @JhoJhoScalesandVs 8 месяцев назад +1

    Ngl if TCA would add a SBR mode or any type of battle royale mode I would definitely play it a lot more. As of rn I just really think it lacks stands which while yes it will change in the future *we are living in the present.*

  • @epicebic6188
    @epicebic6188 7 месяцев назад

    Hey did you know paragons spec the light light fruit, is perfect for the map because the map is just giant straight lines, and he was main director for the new map

  • @michael-the-god-gamer6379
    @michael-the-god-gamer6379 8 месяцев назад +2

    U got me to play tca and it was soooo fun the grinding was short and the final boss was fun plus the theme song was good i had so much fun ganking bosses with my friend's plus the 1v1s was get this b-b-b-balanced yba could never anyway tca is a great game and i recommend it.

  • @Rocky-yw1zo
    @Rocky-yw1zo 8 месяцев назад

    To be fair, i just don’t roblox compared to other games atm, I’m working on playing through baldurs gate, elden ring and a few others, i just appreciate the content as its enjoyable and well, its cool to see the game discussed if I’m interested later.

  • @fizarentreacts
    @fizarentreacts 8 месяцев назад +1

    good vid!

  • @the_almightyro3740
    @the_almightyro3740 8 месяцев назад

    This is what a lot of people have been waiting for, I feel like

  • @xdvezei6330
    @xdvezei6330 8 месяцев назад

    love to play TCA Eclipse and also love to watch u have fun in a video in a bit
    dont like the player count tho.

  • @DrTrayCreeper
    @DrTrayCreeper 8 месяцев назад +1

    Love that intro lmao. Tca, Tca, Tca, Tca, Tca, Tca, FREEDON FROM DARK SOULS 2, Tca

  • @kingcobra69756
    @kingcobra69756 8 месяцев назад

    Decided to play the game when i saw you uploading it, and i believe that tca can do what yba wiont be able to do now, and that is neing a good game

  • @CatsHoly
    @CatsHoly 8 месяцев назад

    Honestly I prefer large movesets as they can be used in more creative ways and personally for me it makes the combat more exciting as you always have to be on your toes instead of having to use your 3-5 combat moves then just run around to wait. (of course this would be less of a problem if m1s werent completely useless in yba at the moment)
    The problem with YBA I have though is that fact that too many of these moves in the large movesets are combo starts/extenders and they do WAYYY too much damage. They take all of the fun out of making the combos with a large moveset in the first place.
    tldr;
    I would prefer alot of moves but less damage/one shot potential than just like 4 basic moves

  • @ZaneKami-lp1tq
    @ZaneKami-lp1tq 8 месяцев назад

    Hey eclipse I love your vids on tca I have hope for it,I have a suggestion for next update for tca new stand twau please consider this

  • @MatterOrNot
    @MatterOrNot 8 месяцев назад +1

    7:06 this clips proves your point perfectly. While you are trying to get near the Scary Monster dude to m1 him, he is literally just running until he can get all of his moves back and try to combo you again. Now comparing, TCA's combat is just way better to play, it fells really smooth.
    Also I started playing this game because of your videos, so I am not part of those guys who didn't give the game a chance.

    • @EvenMoreMoney
      @EvenMoreMoney 8 месяцев назад

      The same thing with the scary monsters happens to me when I'm fighting six pistols. I chase them, they run back and get salami until they do over half of my health in a combo.

    • @MatterOrNot
      @MatterOrNot 8 месяцев назад

      @@EvenMoreMoney 6p right now is really broken

    • @EvenMoreMoney
      @EvenMoreMoney 8 месяцев назад

      @@MatterOrNot It has a black breaking, block BYPASSING stunning, not ragdolling heavenly slam💀

    • @EvenMoreMoney
      @EvenMoreMoney 8 месяцев назад

      Its also seemly unmissable

    • @MatterOrNot
      @MatterOrNot 8 месяцев назад

      @@EvenMoreMoney the good thing is that people think its trash so only a few actually use it. The bad thing is that "a few" comparated to TCA's playercount is actually a lot.

  • @nevenneven8159
    @nevenneven8159 8 месяцев назад

    Hey eclipse i was wondering if you are ever gonna come back to AO again? its gonna have a MASSIVE update in October 6th thats gonna add tons of new mechanics to the game including a new infinite randomly generated sea that as far as i know has never been done in roblox before if you could check it out when the update releases that would be great.
    oh and also most of the problems with the sky island storyline quests you mentioned in your first video have already been fixed since now when you talk to the NPC after climbing the mountain for the first time he will automatically teleport you back to the top

  • @dankenstein12
    @dankenstein12 8 месяцев назад +1

    For me i think the main reason im not attached into TCA is because, its practicly YBA but all over again with some upgrades, Its like i like the idea of TCA i like that its YBA but better but at the same time its like i dont wanna play basicly YBA all over again im already prestige 3 on YBA and like im tired i dont wanna replay the same thing again

    • @felibunn
      @felibunn 8 месяцев назад

      Getting to max level in tca takes around 30 minutes to an hour. There is no prestiges so you only have to level up once.

  • @southindianv1nce662
    @southindianv1nce662 8 месяцев назад +1

    For me, It's the optimization, same reason I switched from YBA to RiU. The games good but it's really difficult to play due to being on a laptop.

  • @UppertextBottomtext
    @UppertextBottomtext 8 месяцев назад +1

    Yo eclipse what do you think about AUT's not capped ascension?

  • @cocaine_rabbit4930
    @cocaine_rabbit4930 8 месяцев назад

    Gigachad eclipse strikes again with a banger TCA vs YBA video

  • @JoeMama-jo4dt
    @JoeMama-jo4dt 8 месяцев назад

    this feels like an old yba - aut comparison

  • @nyaatim8482
    @nyaatim8482 8 месяцев назад

    I have a comment to make about kq because it's way more annoying then you think. With the recent changes it allows people to do 130 dmg or so basecally effortlessly with kq by ragdoll chaining you to smithereens. Another major issue i have is the bomb camping issue you can inf regen by posing by simply knocking someone across the map by sitting on either coin bomb or plant bomb which just makes it frustrating to fight against. Again I see your point saying it's bad if you play aggressively but in my opinion it needs some major changes (maybe even a rework of sorts)

    • @EclipseGameplays
      @EclipseGameplays  8 месяцев назад

      If you've seen my KQ video, you'll know that the changes applied were only part of what I suggested, hence the stand still being kinda bad, and still being extremely annoying

    • @nyaatim8482
      @nyaatim8482 8 месяцев назад

      @@EclipseGameplays I see, I must have missed that part

  • @srnova9486
    @srnova9486 8 месяцев назад +2

    I love world of stands ,if they just made the combat more exciting it would be the best jojo game

    • @sumrak_sumarokov_9978
      @sumrak_sumarokov_9978 7 месяцев назад

      I don't get your point. Go play GE and wola. They are going to rework some stands in the future to make them more interesting to play

  • @sekainoowari3267
    @sekainoowari3267 8 месяцев назад

    every since the skin update i quit playing yba and ever since then my life has hit an all time peak

  • @everymanjack8492
    @everymanjack8492 8 месяцев назад

    Old SBR gave me anxiety whenever it reached last stage no other game will ever be like old yba 😭

  • @beffyjeffy21
    @beffyjeffy21 8 месяцев назад

    Ima be honest I just enjoy watching ur content eclipse

  • @Mork799
    @Mork799 8 месяцев назад

    I didn't play the game cause I could never get the games name thanks for getting it for me though! ill see it out

  • @Chardrah
    @Chardrah 8 месяцев назад

    The main thing chaining me to YBA is my friends and my gang and I don't really have anyone I know playing TCA, its tough maining Made in Heaven because it only has 4 damage (6 if you count barrage and heavy) moves while a stand like scary monsters has 10 damage moves with blinding effects, one good nerf for sptw back when it was the best stand was how parryable it was and scary monsters has ONLY blockable, block bypass, and guardbreak abilities, as a mih pluck user I usually try to get rid of their stand before comboing them after they get knocked via unsealed or the hurricane tech I created. but with scary monsters when you enter full dino form you have maxed out sturdiness so you don't even lose your stand to things like heavens judgement and speed slice. Made in heaven and alot of other stands (sp, sptw, tw, twoh, etc.) all suffer from one thing-- being that they aren't as flashy and don't have as many damaging moves as these newly made or reworked stands (stone free, soft and wet, sm, etc.) I still think I'm the best Made in Heaven user though feel free to disagree.
    One more issue I had was the newly reworked specs, Pluck was promising (heartbreaking for me I really enjoyed old pluck) but it contained an easily parryable move with almost no stun, a actually really good move (pierce and unsealed steel) and a few moves you wouldn't ever use in a combo (hurricane and mortal slash) the last move being a block break animation that deals oKaY damage.
    the big difference between pluck and vamp is that all of vamps moves are perfect for stringing together and some are even made exclusively to be used after one another: oblivion of death into space ripper stingy eyes. and unlike Pluck, Vamp has THREE passives-- bloodbar being the best which pluck does have lethal tempo but come on that's not even useful unless you use Anubis.
    I almost forgot to mention the elephant in the room, why does vamp have a counter ability.
    Honestly I think that uzu knows his balancing is awful and these stands are ruining gameplay but him and the rest of the development team are too scared to remove abilities from stands and specs or just even work on them in the slightest because they're too dried out from working on the release of it.
    Make YBA Great Again!

  • @johnreynaldrala4053
    @johnreynaldrala4053 8 месяцев назад

    I wanna see eclipse play UBG(untitled boxing game) it has a very simple combat system and it's not as grindy plus it has frequent updates and each styles has their strengths and weaknesses.

  • @comatix6682
    @comatix6682 8 месяцев назад +1

    Nice video

  • @JaikerfinchNarkolfeet
    @JaikerfinchNarkolfeet 8 месяцев назад

    my only issue is stand variety
    in a while im gonna be addicted to tca like i was old yba
    but rn theres not enough stands to stay playing for a while