he can even go much higher than that lol he can sing higher than all of these girls here :) Yes, Dimash is special. And he's the whole package :) He's by far not only about high notes
Females are physiologically equipped to sing those high notes. The fact that a guy can even "battle" against them... Dimash should be given 10 extra points just for breaking physiological boundaries 😄. But if you included dimash's low notes, there would be no battle at all.
🙋♀️but if you look at it that way what about Dimash's vocal cords that are longer then normal? At start that gives him biological advantage even with woman
@@Love_Lara well that's true. Still, his speaking voice is deeply masculine, so it takes constant training to maximise or use those longer vocal cords correctly. Meaning he was born with those vocal cords, but if he didn't train constantly/properly, he wouldn't sound as good.
@@byebye9840 I can't do it and I have an ugly technique (like, no technique), so that already proves you wrong. But please, do what Dough Bennett wrote, do it yourself, record it and let others record you from different angles (for different sound quality to prove you didn't upload a montage), upload it on YT and link it here. Than I'll at least admit that every other idiot can do it
Dimash is out of this world!! I was glad that Nicole was recognized for the talent she is. I've heard many dismiss her, but she's phenomenal. Her Evita performance shows that not only can she sing, she can convey emotions beautifully as well.
Dimash would have to win this one for me because he's a man, the others are women. To even be able to hit those notes is huge, much less make them beautiful. I would have LOVED to hear him sing live with early-mid 90s Mariah. That would have been insane!
@@davidlovata5051 I get what you're saying, but all of them are still incredibly impressive when coming from a man - just like a woman hitting low notes among a bunch of men would make her more impressive.
I can clearly see Dimash can compete (on par and better) with them in the high range, now can the girls compete with Dimash in lower range? For the next battle? :D
@@belindamelissa8801 actually yes 😂 Mariah has shown the ability to stay in the 2nd octave to lower 3rd octave for long periods of time in live performances with control and pitch accuracy...
@Just want the Best voice well duh males are physiologically better in low notes as what most of you preach in these comments about female singers being naturally better in high notes... She can still definitely give a good fight
can h compete tho? he can whistle but can he actually whistle like mariah for example. just because he can hit a A6 and a D8 doesnt mean he can hit a B7 for example
Great moments selection, everyone was amazing. Mariah is just gorgeous and Ariana killed it, Dimash is a man and still nailed all. Thanks a lot for the cool video!
Without taking merit to the female singers, Dimash is a 25 year old man so in my opinion is way more impressive and he alone was "fighting" to the female singers, so he deserves the win of the battle :)
Let's ignore the fact you comprehend a golden apple to some pears 😉 Being the only male contestant Dimash Kudaibergen just crashed that "contest". His voice is outstanding, remarkable full and crisp in the high notes, and his low range is giving me goosebumps... ONE guy against how many girls??? Oh my 😂😂
U do know the original video was made just to try to put dimash above them all💀💀 most of the performances from the others couldve been much better. They put Mariah carey who rarely uses headvoice and then out of MANY great Whitney vocals they put a quick Bb5💀
Gakuto Can you stop being obsessed with his shitty whistle register. Most people don’t want to hear a D8. What’s the use in having a D8 if your tone is so unbearable.
There are several things I don't agree with. for example saying Leona's clip with a tensed tongue and jaw was better, or calling a pop vocal better just because it's a pop vocal instead of a classical one that is more sustainable for the voice and also sounded more clear and healthy... However, all of these female singers are phenomenal :) But it's less impressive for a female singer to do that than for a male singer (who can even also sing lower than the bass range btw). And he can, hands down, do soo many things the others (even though they're aabsolutly (!!!) great, can't, he really is immensely skilled. :) And... Dimash deserves all the praise he gets :) Most voice teachers call him best singer in the world, and he absolutely deserves it. His vocal precision and control, his breath control and management, vocal agility, range, tonal consistency across the range, seemless transitions, his versatility and large array of different techniques, styles and vocal colors is unparalleled. :) Also he sings in almost all musical genres, sings in 14 different languages (and excellently knows how to adapt his placement and embouchure in each one) and is also excellently trained, he for example has university degrees in both classical and contemporary music, with major in vocal. So, yes, he is really extraordinary and deserves all the praise he gets :) Dimash's overall skill is really not comparable :)
You are much too reasonable and well-informed for this "voice teacher". Whenever she reacts to anything with Dimash Kudaibergen's name in the title, either pass it by or just click on the video, hit pause (so it doesn't increase the view count) and give it a dislike. It's one of those things you don't even need to watch to know exactly what she's going to say.
@@hadisha4432 why should she not support it? of course it was supported. But what does that have to do with the tongue tension? Or tension in general? The tongue movements are not shaking, but intentional, controlled up and down movements of the tongue. I don't know why she did it, to fake the vibrato or if it's just a bad, unhealthy habit, but it was intentional... and no, your tongue does generally not "shake" due to vibrato, no matter how strong the vibrato is. And you are not supposed to "create" vibrato with what organ ever but it comes automatically with a correct technique and relaxed vocal cords. You are not supposed to force vibrato, which is not healthy. When you sing a vowel, the tongue shall be flat in the mouth and not moving like that. Leona is a GREAT singer, I love her. It's just not true that this was a good tongue placement
@@belindamelissa8801 larynx vibrato is visible in tongue movements sometimes. and yes it isnt really healthy idk why she doesnt want to learn a healthier vibrato
+50 points for being a male, that makes it what...57 - 7? Sweet!!! xD I mean, just to avoid any misunderstanding, female voice is by default a lot more capable and wonderful on these registers, so Dimash being able to do that with his male vocal instrument is even more impressive.
Mariah's c#6 was polyphonic, also Whitney's tone was just beautiful! 😍 But I have to agree with everyone else, Dimash is a whole galaxy of his own kind. We can't even compare, he's amazing!
I believe that you can not compare male and female vocals. If you are already comparing, then compare not only the top notes but also the lower ones. Then it will be clear what is the range of who.
*Definitely Mariah for whistle notes and Leona for head voice/falsetto!* ✨ He can take on the rest though... *P.S.* Georgina, your head voice is so beautiful! WOW 😍 edit: surprised by the outcome , the ladies held their own!
@@JasminGardenia but those are facts lol. His technique sucks. Even if you are untrained you can still listen to the strain when he goes up to Eb4. His upper belts are literall torture.
Lol the girls have a 'harder' job when hitting the notes in 'popstyle' but not a word that Dimash is the only GUY in this battle :) But its interesting to watch the differences, what I love more about Dimas' high notes is that they sound less screechy , more "full" yet 'light' .
@@ohadmaiman1537 It is far from awful. He should do whatever he wants to, he has been training his voice for over 20 years, so dont tell him what to do please.
@@ragingwarrior8098 But D8 doesn't matter if you can't sing in whistle register as pleasant as mariah does can dimash do D8 in everyshow ? Maybe he can but not everyday sec and plus his technique is ugly he sounds so screamin and nasally mariah still won .
You're for sure not the only one 😊 but I thiiink that most here know him already. He's from Kazakhstan and became internationally known 2 years ago, with 22, when he participated on the biggest Chinese talent show. This was his audition: (He has the biggest vocal range in the world (A1 - D8, he can sing lower than the lowest notes of the bass range and more than 2 octaves higher than the highest notes of the soprano range (which is even higher than musical instruments can play), he's immensely skilled and called best singer in the world by numerous experts, he sings in almost all musical genres and in 14 different languages, he plays 11 different instruments and has university degrees in classical music and contemporary music (pop, jazz) and is also a songwriter) ruclips.net/video/JEz1qGS0T1Q/видео.html
I am a big fan of Mariah Carey and Dimash(Yes, they are my bias, haha) and other singers sound all great here :) I don't think we need to make it as competition.
To be honest: I don't see the sense in giving someone the point FOR applying a pop technique instead of a more healthy classical bel canto technique. Especially considering the fact that the pop one didn't sound very clear.
I couldn't agree more! She's the first person I've heard to say that a classically trained voice that uses proper technique is not better the "pop" singer in this case Mariah. We all know what happened to her voice!!!
Thaaat was really weird. Every single vocal coach I know favors bel canto, because it's more advanced and more sustainable for the voice. She already did the same thing in the Cristina Ramos battle, she said that she personally preferred the pop style... and she seems to be a big Leona Lewis fan
@@natlisan Mariah's technique is excellent though, it's her nodules that made her voice decline but she's still supporting and resonating the lower 5th octave now...
Where's the sustained E6 of Dimash from ogni pietra ??? Really? How unfair. I am sorry to say this again. Pit the women and do any number of battles you want. Tats equal ground. Why do you always drag Dimash and try to compare notes? He has enough haters. You can listen to his songs and analyse them honestly. Any day, when a man is compared on his pitching and notes with the women, what does that mean?
remember it's not her video she is using someone else's video, so the comparison is from the original creator's so if you want to complain go to the original video
Dimash is in a League of his own . This comparison to me is really silly. But what it does is show how extremely talented he is . it's not all about his high notes. It's his TOTAL package .. and Not everyone up there has it in my opinion . They may have a Great voice ? Sure ... but it doesnt mean i'd watch them Live in Concert ..!!!But have you ever heard him sing Acapella ??? Its Absolutely extra ordinary!!! 😍🤩😍🤩
Respect to all the singers but common Dimash is a guy and could do everything that girls were doing, for me all points to him. He’s a genius not only hitting high notes. Interesting to watch though
It seems to me that, firstly, it is not right to compare a man and a woman, and secondly, these comparisons are very subjective, because they depend on the selection of videos. For example,you can find the performances of Dimash, where he uses his range more enchantingly, but you can find where it is more ordinary. And finally, there are different styles that the author himself understands, and comparing them is also the last thing. My opinion is that it is better to do the reactions of each artist separately, you do not need to compare artists, because they are artists, because they are all different.
At the time I am typing this, I think the one who can challenge Dimash is Dimash... I want people to attempt that insane 22 second run Dimash did at the end of Sinful Passion. Then we can have a real vocal battle 😎
Off topic: I love your promo pic for your singing course. You look so lovely in it, the big curls suit you so perfectly :) On the topic XD I don't really understand the reason in giving a pop singer the point because she is a pop singer. Bel canto is the most renowned singing technique, it's kind of the queen among singing techniques. Bel canto is not a disadvantage, it's an immense plus. And I don't agree that pop singing is more difficult... pop singing can be learned more easily and above all takes less time as learning to become a bel canto singer. Bel canto is also more sustainable for the voice. And Mariah's vocals didn't sound really healthy to be honest. I heard she has nodules, maybe this was the reason... But I don't understand how you can say pop singing is better than bel canto singing (and you must have meant "better" to some degree, otherwise you can't give someone the point in a question whose vocals were better). It's not a big deal actually, I just don't understand it :) And I wonder: If you contrarily to other voice teachers prefer pop over bel canto in a way that makes you give someone a point for being a pop singer, then why do you make a "battle" between pop singers and a bel canto singer? :) Would have maybe been better to compare pop singers with pop singers and bel canto singers with bel canto singers. Anyway... I like your videos :) Love from Estonia
clearly Dimash. Dear composers of the world, he is already composing songs for his voice, listen - just Olympico, dear lady: sings the duet with himself. is better than anyone, not just Mariah.
I think you can't compare Dimash with other female vocal because he can flip from lower baritone into highest whistle voice in just split second and no human being ever do that in live concert in every concert he sang!
@@ChristianJaramillo10 He is :) That's also what most voice teachers say. And I personally don't know any other singer with his overall skill level and his abilities
I think u should check Dimash's E6 of Oplimpico song. Full of chest and supporting and equal good as the super females singers. The battle Video footages of Dimash are a little old…Just change something new.
@@hadisha4432 Also here for you: why should she not support it? of course it was supported. But what does that have to do with the tongue tension? Nothing. Or with tension in general?
The tongue movements are not shaking, but intentional, controlled up and down movements of the tongue. I don't know why she did it, to fake the vibrato or if it's just a bad, unhealthy habit, but it was intentional... and no, your tongue does generally not "shake" due to vibrato, no matter how strong the vibrato is. And you are not supposed to "create" vibrato with what organ ever but it comes automatically with a correct technique and relaxed vocal cords. You are not supposed to force vibrato, which is not healthy. When you sing a vowel, the tongue shall be flat in the mouth and not moving like that. Leona is a GREAT singer, I love her. It's just not true that this was a good tongue placement
My personal ranking (and this is ooonly based on the clips here 😊 I know that all of them can do so much more): 1.) Dimash (we did not only see 1 clip from him but many and aaall for them are excellent. Plus he even seems to be a bel canto singer, aaand he is a guy after all ;) it's not really special for a female singer to be able hit a 5th or 6th octave note) 2.) Ariana 3.) Sohyang 4.) Nicole Scherzinger 5.) Cristina Ramos 6.) Beyoncé 7.) Whitney 8.) Leona (I don't know what she exactly did there, but this is absolutely not what your embouchure is supposed to look like while sustaining a note. I didn't see it well enough, but it was either some rather weird kind of fake vibrato/gospel jaw, or simply tongue tension. When you sing a vowel, your jaw and tongue are supposed to be relaxed and for a vowel that means for the tongue lying relaxed and flat on the bottom of your mouth) 9.) Mariah (that was not clear, that sounded rather "gravely" and a little unhealthy) 10. Christina Aguilera (But once again, this is only based on the clip, aaand it doesn't make "a lor of" sense anyway to compare singers by simoly comparing a few random notes lol plus a clip comparison can only be as objective and fair as the person who chose the clips)
Leona clip is neither gospel jaw or tongue tension. She used her larynx to use vibrato and she deliberately moves her tongue up and down as her singing style. Her note was well support and maybe the most resonance out of all females on this list. If she had tongue tension, her head would be tilted way up more like when Ariana is singing.
Then this would be a battle between Mike Patton and Dimash lol (But Mike can't sing notes higher than the bottom of the 5th octave, his highs are false cords screams). But would be interesting... a neoclassic bel canto trained singer vs a heavy music vocal experimentalist lol would be entertaining. But both sing in several different languages, Dimash in 14 and Mike in 6, so could even let them battle in different languages lol And both sing in various different genres
i really do not like the so and so vs so and so it creates really bad feelings as i see below - we should accept that everyone has their favourite and are naturally biased - it should be done differently to promote different artists to other people
There's nothing wrong with a little friendly competition; plus we have to grow up and face the fact that some are better than other in certain areas. It's time to evolve from this "everyone gets a trophy" mentality.
i'm really sorry to say this. I don't think it's right to make this video. without you knowing you have become a provocateur, this will only cause debate. never compare singers! i know not your attention to make chaos but look at the result this will be a battleground for fans of each singer you compare.
@David S. she's hoarse now because as what a lot of people don't know she's always had nodules since she was little and had to sing her way into her entire career with it...
@@drewm.2790 è vero ma in parte. Prendiamo esempio quando cantava nel 1997 che era molto rauca la sua voce ma in quel caso era costantemente ammalata. Nel 2001 fino al 2003 aveva la voce pulita.
He's a man - end of so-called "comparison"! And as those poor girls are evidently being forced into using that oh-so-tricky "pop" style, it's kinda exploitative too... #popvoicesmatter #belcantostyleiseasier
Dimash is better, because is a Boy!,,,,,, and He can si g in D8.........I enjoy so much your reactions!......greetings from a Mexican Dear!.......🌹❤️🌹❤️🌹❤️🌹. Dimash is the best voice in the world!.......
I would like to see a full comparison with Nicole on high notes because they both can sing opera and for both is their best kind of singing. He was born gifted because his range, I don't think there's any european or american male singer that can go that higher with great support maybe it's an hormones fact too
@@HonestVocalCoach oh you mean like a bit more strain or effort is needed because it's a belt? I guess I can imagine that for a classical singer it would be easier to hit that note with head voice because of training, and hitting it pop-style would be harder if he wasn't trained that way. So it would also be harder for a pop singer without classcal training to hit that note classical-style?
@@HonestVocalCoach "More belt than head voice"? Could you explain that? Because that sounds a little strange... Plus it takes much more time to acquire an advanced bel canto technique in the first place. If something can be done with more ease because you have acquired a specific more advanced technique, this is sth positive, not sth negative
Comparing singers is fun and educational in terms of both the singer and youtuber's thinking and analysis. No one cares about your catfights in the comment section and the RUclipsrs should not censure themselves because you are too insecure to hear a differing opinion.
People say he would win for even being able to compete with these singers, when that's not the point. People, male or female, can be born with very high or low voices, with larger and smaller vocal ranges. For a man with a vocal range like Dimash's these notes aren't difficult to sing, so while it is impressive, it's not because he's a man and he can sing high, it's because the technique he's using in his headvoice is way above average and gets him to sing this gorgeous consistently. Not trying to bash Dimash in any ways, his head voice is memorizing, just thought I'd put my opinion out there.
Mariah Carey’s mom, Patricia Carey, was an opera singer in New York. So I’m surprised she doesn’t use a more bel canto technique in her singing. Perhaps Patricia didn’t teach her about it.
Thanks for the cool reaction. However, to be fair, you are comparing Dimash to girls so him even reaching these notes is almost impossible for a man where it's expected from good female singers.
The problem for me was unequal songs pitted against each other. Put Dimash with his Bastau Diva Dance up against any of the women and it's hands down Dimash
This wasn’t a good video, because the videos that they used to Dimash were ones that at at the end of the songs, so his tone will be with less volume than the others. I RECOMMEND “TIMES THAT DIMASH HAD FUN WITH HIS VOICE THAT FORGOT THAT HE STILL HUMAN” ❤️❤️❤️
the fact it takes 7 of the best female singers in the world to math Dimash says a lot... the guy is God-tier when it comes to singing. Personally, I'm not a fan of any of these singers, not even Dimash, why? because I think they are abusing the whistle register... I've never did like it much tbw, it's just too over the top. If we recall artists from the 60's, 70's, 80's, and even the 90's and early 00's, most of them didnt have to abuse the whistle register... some of them didn't even use it at all. Sometimes a plain song can be much more better. I would take artists like Pat Benatar, Debrah Harry, Donna Summer, abba's vocalists, Laura Branigan or Dolores O'Riordan, over singers like Mariah, ariana or Dimash; thei music is just much better, even avril lavigne's is much more interesting.
Oh my god!!! How could you think of comparing men and women in high notes ???? It degrades you! I forgive your weakness. .... Vocal Coach?!?!?!?!? I hope not??!! 😂😂😂😂😂
I was totally blown away!! I’ve never heard a guy hit those high notes before!!?? OMG!!
You have to check his songs. You will know more!
he can sing a D8
he can even go much higher than that lol he can sing higher than all of these girls here :) Yes, Dimash is special. And he's the whole package :) He's by far not only about high notes
Dimash is amazing :D
Welcome to the club! You'll love him! :-*
For a male to stand alone against those famous female artists... it's just amazing. He's a whole package
Females are physiologically equipped to sing those high notes. The fact that a guy can even "battle" against them... Dimash should be given 10 extra points just for breaking physiological boundaries 😄. But if you included dimash's low notes, there would be no battle at all.
🙋♀️but if you look at it that way what about Dimash's vocal cords that are longer then normal? At start that gives him biological advantage even with woman
@@Love_Lara well that's true. Still, his speaking voice is deeply masculine, so it takes constant training to maximise or use those longer vocal cords correctly. Meaning he was born with those vocal cords, but if he didn't train constantly/properly, he wouldn't sound as good.
You do know there are women that can sing low as Well? Lol
did you know that countertenors are a thing
if you included Mariah's low notes she should be given 20 extra points and also because she's been singing her entire career with nodules...
note: dimash is a male.... O.o ... and remember, D8 in gakku concert!!! WoW
no one cares about the D8 lmao. thats just a cool trick. no musicality there.
@@Marco-el2he exactly. It was pitchy, uncontrolled and everyone can do it with ugly technique like him.
MilliBelle Literally though
@@milipuga I'd like to see you do it then if "Everyone can do it" 🤦♂️ AND yo have to do it with vibrato like he did.
@@byebye9840 I can't do it and I have an ugly technique (like, no technique), so that already proves you wrong. But please, do what Dough Bennett wrote, do it yourself, record it and let others record you from different angles (for different sound quality to prove you didn't upload a montage), upload it on YT and link it here. Than I'll at least admit that every other idiot can do it
Dimash is amazing!
Dimash is out of this world!! I was glad that Nicole was recognized for the talent she is. I've heard many dismiss her, but she's phenomenal. Her Evita performance shows that not only can she sing, she can convey emotions beautifully as well.
Dimash would have to win this one for me because he's a man, the others are women. To even be able to hit those notes is huge, much less make them beautiful. I would have LOVED to hear him sing live with early-mid 90s Mariah. That would have been insane!
Oooh yes, I fully agree. :) Also a duet with Sohyang would be amazing. Btw, he'll allegedly sing a duet with Lara Fabian next month :)
But its only about the notes, not about be a man or a woman or how hard it can be for each them
@@davidlovata5051 I get what you're saying, but all of them are still incredibly impressive when coming from a man - just like a woman hitting low notes among a bunch of men would make her more impressive.
totally agree!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Males can train their voices to sing as high as females and to make it fair it is all about the notes their hitting
I don't know, but the very fact that you compare 1 Dimash to so many great singers means that Dimash won at the start.
@@kuhlengesi3333 yep!
Now we want to see Mariah vs other artists! 😂❤️
I can clearly see Dimash can compete (on par and better) with them in the high range, now can the girls compete with Dimash in lower range? For the next battle? :D
Mariah can lol
@@drewm.2790 I love Mariah, but nope
@@belindamelissa8801 actually yes 😂 Mariah has shown the ability to stay in the 2nd octave to lower 3rd octave for long periods of time in live performances with control and pitch accuracy...
@Just want the Best voice well duh males are physiologically better in low notes as what most of you preach in these comments about female singers being naturally better in high notes... She can still definitely give a good fight
can h compete tho? he can whistle but can he actually whistle like mariah for example. just because he can hit a A6 and a D8 doesnt mean he can hit a B7 for example
Dimash the BEST😍🙋
Great moments selection, everyone was amazing. Mariah is just gorgeous and Ariana killed it, Dimash is a man and still nailed all. Thanks a lot for the cool video!
Without taking merit to the female singers, Dimash is a 25 year old man so in my opinion is way more impressive and he alone was "fighting" to the female singers, so he deserves the win of the battle :)
She put him alone against all the great female singers yet he still nailled it with a draw😅 HES AMAZING
Let's ignore the fact you comprehend a golden apple to some pears 😉 Being the only male contestant Dimash Kudaibergen just crashed that "contest". His voice is outstanding, remarkable full and crisp in the high notes, and his low range is giving me goosebumps... ONE guy against how many girls??? Oh my 😂😂
wonderful.
Outstandingly annoying?
U do know the original video was made just to try to put dimash above them all💀💀 most of the performances from the others couldve been much better. They put Mariah carey who rarely uses headvoice and then out of MANY great Whitney vocals they put a quick Bb5💀
Mark CC Exactly. His voice is horrible.
Dimash would object. He is a true gentleman.. so ladies first and always better in any ways 😂😂😂
You need more feminism in your comment ha.
Came for Dimash vs Mariah vs Whitney. But stayed for Leona and Nicole points, once again just to show how underrated these 2 ladies are 😬
The highest note battled is F6.
Try putting Dimash's D8 in there, 10 points for him. 5 for reaching and 5 for sustain. (4 secs, give or take)
D8 at a live concert for 5 seconds....
Gakuto Can you stop being obsessed with his shitty whistle register. Most people don’t want to hear a D8. What’s the use in having a D8 if your tone is so unbearable.
+15 for d8 with vibrato!
@@byebye9840 like yours is any better
@@byebye9840 некоторых "певцов" я и вовсе слушать не хочу. Это аргумент?
I love all of them. :) All of them are sensational. But my favorite one is Dimash :) His overall skill level is just insane
There are several things I don't agree with. for example saying Leona's clip with a tensed tongue and jaw was better, or calling a pop vocal better just because it's a pop vocal instead of a classical one that is more sustainable for the voice and also sounded more clear and healthy...
However, all of these female singers are phenomenal :) But it's less impressive for a female singer to do that than for a male singer (who can even also sing lower than the bass range btw). And he can, hands down, do soo many things the others (even though they're aabsolutly (!!!) great, can't, he really is immensely skilled. :) And... Dimash deserves all the praise he gets :) Most voice teachers call him best singer in the world, and he absolutely deserves it. His vocal precision and control, his breath control and management, vocal agility, range, tonal consistency across the range, seemless transitions, his versatility and large array of different techniques, styles and vocal colors is unparalleled. :) Also he sings in almost all musical genres, sings in 14 different languages (and excellently knows how to adapt his placement and embouchure in each one) and is also excellently trained, he for example has university degrees in both classical and contemporary music, with major in vocal. So, yes, he is really extraordinary and deserves all the praise he gets :) Dimash's overall skill is really not comparable :)
You are much too reasonable and well-informed for this "voice teacher". Whenever she reacts to anything with Dimash Kudaibergen's name in the title, either pass it by or just click on the video, hit pause (so it doesn't increase the view count) and give it a dislike. It's one of those things you don't even need to watch to know exactly what she's going to say.
leona supported that bb5 there was no tension there.She creates her vibrato with her larynx thats why her tongue shakes like that
@@hadisha4432 why should she not support it? of course it was supported. But what does that have to do with the tongue tension? Or tension in general?
The tongue movements are not shaking, but intentional, controlled up and down movements of the tongue. I don't know why she did it, to fake the vibrato or if it's just a bad, unhealthy habit, but it was intentional... and no, your tongue does generally not "shake" due to vibrato, no matter how strong the vibrato is.
And you are not supposed to "create" vibrato with what organ ever but it comes automatically with a correct technique and relaxed vocal cords. You are not supposed to force vibrato, which is not healthy. When you sing a vowel, the tongue shall be flat in the mouth and not moving like that.
Leona is a GREAT singer, I love her. It's just not true that this was a good tongue placement
@@belindamelissa8801 larynx vibrato is visible in tongue movements sometimes. and yes it isnt really healthy idk why she doesnt want to learn a healthier vibrato
+50 points for being a male, that makes it what...57 - 7? Sweet!!! xD
I mean, just to avoid any misunderstanding, female voice is by default a lot more capable and wonderful on these registers, so Dimash being able to do that with his male vocal instrument is even more impressive.
And how many does he get for a hideous belting voice?
@@SKMRify Ik right his tone winds me up
Only Dimash to compete against those amazing women in the really high tones.
Because he sounds like a woman 😂😂
@@crazycatpetera1404 but that's not a bad thing
@@crazycatpetera1404 he sound like a woman , a man and evreything in between❣
@@crazycatpetera1404 because it's head voice..? Show me a man's head voice that doesn't sound like women smh
Dimash....THE BEST, EVER!!! ❤
Mariah's c#6 was polyphonic, also Whitney's tone was just beautiful! 😍 But I have to agree with everyone else, Dimash is a whole galaxy of his own kind. We can't even compare, he's amazing!
I believe that you can not compare male and female vocals. If you are already comparing, then compare not only the top notes but also the lower ones. Then it will be clear what is the range of who.
great.
Yessssss!!!!!! ❤️
*Definitely Mariah for whistle notes and Leona for head voice/falsetto!* ✨
He can take on the rest though...
*P.S.* Georgina, your head voice is so beautiful! WOW 😍
edit: surprised by the outcome , the ladies held their own!
Oh, here's the guy who always vulgarly insults Dimash and says that he can't support at all and never has resonance in his voice
You forgot about Slayhyang
SoHyang for head voice 😉😊
@@JasminGardenia Facts are facts. lol
@@JasminGardenia but those are facts lol. His technique sucks. Even if you are untrained you can still listen to the strain when he goes up to Eb4. His upper belts are literall torture.
Lol the girls have a 'harder' job when hitting the notes in 'popstyle' but not a word that Dimash is the only GUY in this battle :) But its interesting to watch the differences, what I love more about Dimas' high notes is that they sound less screechy , more "full" yet 'light' .
this "light" in his voice is awful. and he really sounds like an alien, in a bad way. he should stay under A5.
@@ohadmaiman1537 It is far from awful. He should do whatever he wants to, he has been training his voice for over 20 years, so dont tell him what to do please.
@alec Mariah can sing down to F#2, Beyonce can support down to C3 and sing lower than that too...
@@drewm.2790 Natalie Weiss support down to C3. And has B2 recorded
LKoL. Compared with _really_ great operatic sopranos his high notes are laughable.
how much you need the best singers to gather in a heap to try to win one Dimash...1vs1 they don't stand a chance
Prime Mariah would
@@kazbooo4110 Not with the lower notes with wider vocal range that Dimash has and specially the D8 ;)
@@ragingwarrior8098 But D8 doesn't matter if you can't sing in whistle register as pleasant as mariah does can dimash do D8 in everyshow ? Maybe he can but not everyday sec and plus his technique is ugly he sounds so screamin and nasally mariah still won .
The Swift Grande yeah plus Mariah’s highest note in that register is F#8 so that’s really enough to say there
Raging Warrior plus Mariah has gotten down to F2 and highest is F#8? Are u sure about that
Sorry, but c#6 at Dimash is very amazing, and sounds better than at mariah, and he won this round 100%.
But his overall voice is so ugly. Someone is even mad enough to compare him with far superior operatic sopranos and tenors.
They should put Leona c#6 in Run. That will probably match him well.
Am I the only one who's hearing Dimash now only...
You're for sure not the only one 😊 but I thiiink that most here know him already. He's from Kazakhstan and became internationally known 2 years ago, with 22, when he participated on the biggest Chinese talent show. This was his audition:
(He has the biggest vocal range in the world (A1 - D8, he can sing lower than the lowest notes of the bass range and more than 2 octaves higher than the highest notes of the soprano range (which is even higher than musical instruments can play), he's immensely skilled and called best singer in the world by numerous experts, he sings in almost all musical genres and in 14 different languages, he plays 11 different instruments and has university degrees in classical music and contemporary music (pop, jazz) and is also a songwriter)
ruclips.net/video/JEz1qGS0T1Q/видео.html
No, you are not alone 😄 me too !
I am a big fan of Mariah Carey and Dimash(Yes, they are my bias, haha) and other singers sound all great here :) I don't think we need to make it as competition.
Well i think dimash will reck the rest 😂😂
Much respect to all though❤
Loay Baqleh Mariah is better
loulou boys yes, because he’s way ahead 🙄
@loulou boys in at 3:57 c#6 at Dimash is much more better and so clear than at mariah, she squeals more in sound for me, IMHO.
@@Jeki_toki In this video, maybe. But his mixed belting is absolutely hideous to listen to.
Dimash is my choice
To be honest: I don't see the sense in giving someone the point FOR applying a pop technique instead of a more healthy classical bel canto technique. Especially considering the fact that the pop one didn't sound very clear.
I couldn't agree more! She's the first person I've heard to say that a classically trained voice that uses proper technique is not better the "pop" singer in this case Mariah. We all know what happened to her voice!!!
Nathan Dixon But that is because of vocal nodes, something that cannot be controlled by the singer no matter what genre, classical or pop.
Thaaat was really weird. Every single vocal coach I know favors bel canto, because it's more advanced and more sustainable for the voice. She already did the same thing in the Cristina Ramos battle, she said that she personally preferred the pop style... and she seems to be a big Leona Lewis fan
Classical technique isnt more Health tho
@@natlisan Mariah's technique is excellent though, it's her nodules that made her voice decline but she's still supporting and resonating the lower 5th octave now...
Leona Lewis’ falsetto is the best I have ever heard! 😍
That's not falsetto, mate :)
@@petercauter9691 that is falsetto
Peter Cauter yes that is falsetto, what else would it be? :D
Who chose that for Mariah...
Ahh come on man that was pretty great!! 👑👑👑
@@speedycomet1692 Not really. I was surprised she got the point. They should have chosen one of Mariah's amazing 90s vocals
Mmm so 1 guy, Dimash, takes on ALL the girls and it's a TIE!
I know lol doesn't make sense
Where's the sustained E6 of Dimash from ogni pietra ??? Really? How unfair.
I am sorry to say this again.
Pit the women and do any number of battles you want. Tats equal ground.
Why do you always drag Dimash and try to compare notes? He has enough haters.
You can listen to his songs and analyse them honestly.
Any day, when a man is compared on his pitching and notes with the women, what does that mean?
remember it's not her video she is using someone else's video, so the comparison is from the original creator's
so if you want to complain go to the original video
Dimash is in a League of his own . This comparison to me is really silly. But what it does is show how extremely talented he is . it's not all about his high notes. It's his TOTAL package .. and Not everyone up there has it in my opinion . They may have a Great voice ? Sure ... but it doesnt mean i'd watch them Live in Concert ..!!!But have you ever heard him sing Acapella ??? Its Absolutely extra ordinary!!! 😍🤩😍🤩
Respect to all the singers but common Dimash is a guy and could do everything that girls were doing, for me all points to him. He’s a genius not only hitting high notes. Interesting to watch though
It seems to me that, firstly, it is not right to compare a man and a woman, and secondly, these comparisons are very subjective, because they depend on the selection of videos. For example,you can find the performances of Dimash, where he uses his range more enchantingly, but you can find where it is more ordinary. And finally, there are different styles that the author himself understands, and comparing them is also the last thing. My opinion is that it is better to do the reactions of each artist separately, you do not need to compare artists, because they are artists, because they are all different.
She's talking about them (artists) just in these clips so I don't see any problem
At the time I am typing this, I think the one who can challenge Dimash is Dimash... I want people to attempt that insane 22 second run Dimash did at the end of Sinful Passion. Then we can have a real vocal battle 😎
Dmash is too iconicn.
Btw
I love your eyeliner
Off topic: I love your promo pic for your singing course. You look so lovely in it, the big curls suit you so perfectly :)
On the topic XD I don't really understand the reason in giving a pop singer the point because she is a pop singer. Bel canto is the most renowned singing technique, it's kind of the queen among singing techniques. Bel canto is not a disadvantage, it's an immense plus. And I don't agree that pop singing is more difficult... pop singing can be learned more easily and above all takes less time as learning to become a bel canto singer. Bel canto is also more sustainable for the voice. And Mariah's vocals didn't sound really healthy to be honest. I heard she has nodules, maybe this was the reason... But I don't understand how you can say pop singing is better than bel canto singing (and you must have meant "better" to some degree, otherwise you can't give someone the point in a question whose vocals were better). It's not a big deal actually, I just don't understand it :) And I wonder: If you contrarily to other voice teachers prefer pop over bel canto in a way that makes you give someone a point for being a pop singer, then why do you make a "battle" between pop singers and a bel canto singer? :) Would have maybe been better to compare pop singers with pop singers and bel canto singers with bel canto singers. Anyway... I like your videos :) Love from Estonia
Mariah had nodules because she sang improperly as a child. Not while her career
clearly Dimash. Dear composers of the world, he is already composing songs for his voice, listen - just Olympico, dear lady: sings the duet with himself.
is better than anyone, not just Mariah.
I think you can't compare Dimash with other female vocal because he can flip from lower baritone into highest whistle voice in just split second and no human being ever do that in live concert in every concert he sang!
Azenal Hamidon Mariah can tho
Dimash is the best singer in the world 🌎 incomparable...
No, he's not. He's very talented indeed!
Incredibly talented but not the best.
@@ChristianJaramillo10 He is :) That's also what most voice teachers say. And I personally don't know any other singer with his overall skill level and his abilities
Absolutely agree.
@ FiDiMASH I 100% agree Dimasd is the best .This lady is silly . And her video's are childish.
Love Dimsh great reaction I’m waiting for the Beyoncé - Ave Maria Live in Greece reaction 💜
Dimash is amazing and a real performer!
I think u should check Dimash's E6 of Oplimpico song. Full of chest and supporting and equal good as the super females singers.
The battle Video footages of Dimash are a little old…Just change something new.
Why were you so surprised Leona won? Leona’s head voice is incredible
She should not have won to be honest. Tongue tension. Voice teachers usually correct that in lessons
@@belindamelissa8801 OMG ITS NOT TOUNGE TENSION. SHE CREATES HER VIRBATO WITH HER LARYNX THATS WHY HER TONGUE SHAKES LIKE THAT. SHE SUPPORTED THIS BBT
@@belindamelissa8801 bb5*
@@hadisha4432 Also here for you: why should she not support it? of course it was supported. But what does that have to do with the tongue tension? Nothing. Or with tension in general?
The tongue movements are not shaking, but intentional, controlled up and down movements of the tongue. I don't know why she did it, to fake the vibrato or if it's just a bad, unhealthy habit, but it was intentional... and no, your tongue does generally not "shake" due to vibrato, no matter how strong the vibrato is.
And you are not supposed to "create" vibrato with what organ ever but it comes automatically with a correct technique and relaxed vocal cords. You are not supposed to force vibrato, which is not healthy. When you sing a vowel, the tongue shall be flat in the mouth and not moving like that.
Leona is a GREAT singer, I love her. It's just not true that this was a good tongue placement
Belinda Melissa it’s not tension at all.
My personal ranking (and this is ooonly based on the clips here 😊 I know that all of them can do so much more):
1.) Dimash (we did not only see 1 clip from him but many and aaall for them are excellent. Plus he even seems to be a bel canto singer, aaand he is a guy after all ;) it's not really special for a female singer to be able hit a 5th or 6th octave note)
2.) Ariana
3.) Sohyang
4.) Nicole Scherzinger
5.) Cristina Ramos
6.) Beyoncé
7.) Whitney
8.) Leona (I don't know what she exactly did there, but this is absolutely not what your embouchure is supposed to look like while sustaining a note. I didn't see it well enough, but it was either some rather weird kind of fake vibrato/gospel jaw, or simply tongue tension. When you sing a vowel, your jaw and tongue are supposed to be relaxed and for a vowel that means for the tongue lying relaxed and flat on the bottom of your mouth)
9.) Mariah (that was not clear, that sounded rather "gravely" and a little unhealthy)
10. Christina Aguilera
(But once again, this is only based on the clip, aaand it doesn't make "a lor of" sense anyway to compare singers by simoly comparing a few random notes lol plus a clip comparison can only be as objective and fair as the person who chose the clips)
Leona clip is neither gospel jaw or tongue tension. She used her larynx to use vibrato and she deliberately moves her tongue up and down as her singing style.
Her note was well support and maybe the most resonance out of all females on this list. If she had tongue tension, her head would be tilted way up more like when Ariana is singing.
Don’t disrespect Nicole scherzinger like that, she matched/ beat him in every round they faced
3:55 Mariah vs Dimash
Thank me later 🤧
C#6 from Dimash is amazing
anyone remember the name of that alien song that dismah sang?
The diva dance
Diva Dance
the styles are just so different to compare.
Dimash D8!!!!!!!!
Fun video but fair would be to compare him with singers who have the same range as him.
Then this would be a battle between Mike Patton and Dimash lol (But Mike can't sing notes higher than the bottom of the 5th octave, his highs are false cords screams). But would be interesting... a neoclassic bel canto trained singer vs a heavy music vocal experimentalist lol would be entertaining. But both sing in several different languages, Dimash in 14 and Mike in 6, so could even let them battle in different languages lol And both sing in various different genres
Lol! Yeah that would be interesting. Let them sing one song and put their own spin on it.
Georgina, I love your videos!! ❤
i really do not like the so and so vs so and so it creates really bad feelings as i see below - we should accept that everyone has their favourite and are naturally biased - it should be done differently to promote different artists to other people
There's nothing wrong with a little friendly competition; plus we have to grow up and face the fact that some are better than other in certain areas. It's time to evolve from this "everyone gets a trophy" mentality.
👨 VS 👧 👧 👩 👩 👧👧
Yey I knew Leona would get a point she deserves recognition as well. All artist where great on here though
i'm really sorry to say this. I don't think it's right to make this video. without you knowing you have become a provocateur, this will only cause debate. never compare singers!
i know not your attention to make chaos but look at the result this will be a battleground for fans of each singer you compare.
Are you serious? Its the point of the video lol
Mariah is my favourite vocalist of all time.
@David S. she's hoarse now because as what a lot of people don't know she's always had nodules since she was little and had to sing her way into her entire career with it...
@@drewm.2790 è vero ma in parte. Prendiamo esempio quando cantava nel 1997 che era molto rauca la sua voce ma in quel caso era costantemente ammalata. Nel 2001 fino al 2003 aveva la voce pulita.
I see dimash I click.... Over to dears..
Dimash's thrill is not hitting the notes, but offering us a smorgasbord of notes and methods :D
Like the reactor/reacter said MARIAH'Snotes are more harder🍭❣
Just saying!!
Which "reactors" said that? Never heard it
Ari 💙💙💙
Ariana's F6s 😍
He's a man - end of so-called "comparison"! And as those poor girls are evidently being forced into using that oh-so-tricky "pop" style, it's kinda exploitative too... #popvoicesmatter #belcantostyleiseasier
When you did the high note you made it look easy haha wish I could do that xx
WHO CHOSE THAT CLIP FOR MARIAH
nathan RIGHT
Only you
Dimash is better, because is a Boy!,,,,,, and He can si g in D8.........I enjoy so much your reactions!......greetings from a Mexican Dear!.......🌹❤️🌹❤️🌹❤️🌹. Dimash is the best voice in the world!.......
You didn't expect Leona to be that good? SHE'S THE QUEEN OF THE HIGH C!!!
Ha davvero una voce bellissima
I would like to see a full comparison with Nicole on high notes because they both can sing opera and for both is their best kind of singing. He was born gifted because his range, I don't think there's any european or american male singer that can go that higher with great support maybe it's an hormones fact too
But what did you mean by the "pop kind of style is actually harder" (than classical)?
@@HonestVocalCoach oh you mean like a bit more strain or effort is needed because it's a belt? I guess I can imagine that for a classical singer it would be easier to hit that note with head voice because of training, and hitting it pop-style would be harder if he wasn't trained that way. So it would also be harder for a pop singer without classcal training to hit that note classical-style?
@@HonestVocalCoach "More belt than head voice"? Could you explain that? Because that sounds a little strange... Plus it takes much more time to acquire an advanced bel canto technique in the first place. If something can be done with more ease because you have acquired a specific more advanced technique, this is sth positive, not sth negative
@@HonestVocalCoach What has this to do with belting? Nrither Dimash nor Mariah belted in their clips
@@HonestVocalCoach Classical singing is much more complicated. Sorry, but this has been taught for many, many years.
Comparing singers is fun and educational in terms of both the singer and youtuber's thinking and analysis. No one cares about your catfights in the comment section and the RUclipsrs should not censure themselves because you are too insecure to hear a differing opinion.
Wow Georgina, I love the way you rich the high notes
That was fan. But famous Dimash' D8 I am really missing here Lol
Ariana is the best
On social networks Dimash only follows Mariah among all these singers, so he recognizes and respects her talent.
Yaaaasssss
People say he would win for even being able to compete with these singers, when that's not the point. People, male or female, can be born with very high or low voices, with larger and smaller vocal ranges. For a man with a vocal range like Dimash's these notes aren't difficult to sing, so while it is impressive, it's not because he's a man and he can sing high, it's because the technique he's using in his headvoice is way above average and gets him to sing this gorgeous consistently. Not trying to bash Dimash in any ways, his head voice is memorizing, just thought I'd put my opinion out there.
The battle should be 1 on 1.....
how can you compare dimash with girls?
do you know what voices Dimash sings, Madam? don't be embarrassed.
Fyi,this is just battle who singing more highest note..Its not failed..can you react like who more Hardest voice style..?
Mariah Carey’s mom, Patricia Carey, was an opera singer in New York. So I’m surprised she doesn’t use a more bel canto technique in her singing. Perhaps Patricia didn’t teach her about it.
The Official Andy Saenz nah Mariah only uses breath techniques and didn’t want to take a classical approach to her singing
D6 Sohyang! Just love her :)
Thanks for the cool reaction. However, to be fair, you are comparing Dimash to girls so him even reaching these notes is almost impossible for a man where it's expected from good female singers.
The problem for me was unequal songs pitted against each other. Put Dimash with his Bastau Diva Dance up against any of the women and it's hands down Dimash
I didn’t realize Nichole had those notes! I also liked her tone slightly better than Dimash’s. 👍
Leona 😍😍😍😍😍😍 u have to look into her more shes amazing
Kagesume yes. Her tone is so full of colour and I love it
I agree
This wasn’t a good video, because the videos that they used to Dimash were ones that at at the end of the songs, so his tone will be with less volume than the others. I RECOMMEND “TIMES THAT DIMASH HAD FUN WITH HIS VOICE THAT FORGOT THAT HE STILL HUMAN” ❤️❤️❤️
Mariah is the eternal Queen.
Dimash is definitely the winner for me. No contest.
They could’ve used God Is A Woman by Ariana at the Eb6, like the bbc, the F6 could ofc stay
The first note is A5.... i was expecting it started with C5 (high belt).... hahaha
Dimash has some COURAGE to hit all these high notes! WOW
so happy ariana tied it!
the fact it takes 7 of the best female singers in the world to math Dimash says a lot... the guy is God-tier when it comes to singing.
Personally, I'm not a fan of any of these singers, not even Dimash, why? because I think they are abusing the whistle register... I've never did like it much tbw, it's just too over the top. If we recall artists from the 60's, 70's, 80's, and even the 90's and early 00's, most of them didnt have to abuse the whistle register... some of them didn't even use it at all. Sometimes a plain song can be much more better. I would take artists like Pat Benatar, Debrah Harry, Donna Summer, abba's vocalists, Laura Branigan or Dolores O'Riordan, over singers like Mariah, ariana or Dimash; thei music is just much better, even avril lavigne's is much more interesting.
Dimash wins because it took umpteen other singers to even get close to the full package he brings to the table.
Came cuz Mariah name. Great vid
This is so silly for you to compere Dimash with only woman . And why are you calling it a Battle they are all singers . It is not a war. From England
Oh my god!!! How could you think of comparing men and women in high notes ???? It degrades you! I forgive your weakness. .... Vocal Coach?!?!?!?!? I hope not??!! 😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂👍👍