For getting the Hungarian Halfbred, I was getting killed constantly so I tried the bounty trick and it worked. Just start a bounty mission from any town. I did the Ellie Anne Swan one in Valentine as it was the closest. Capture the bounty and ride into blackwater. Lawmen won't spawn in Blackwater during bounty hunting missions. It was a piece of cake this way. Good Luck.
After a couple of years I’ve decided to play again and this year I want to try to get 100% completion in this game or at least pretty close. It’s such an amazing video game. A master piece. Very cool video bro. Suscribed.
Your "challenge made easy" videos are brilliant. I hadn't thought of crows, ravens and vultures as "birds of prey" and your method of _luring_ them works brilliantly. When I saw that horseman 9 required a trip to Blackwater, I thought I'd have to wait until the epilogue to do it. Using your guide, I made it (although it took a few tries due to running into trees and what not) using _no_ health tonics (although I _did_ use several horse stimulants). I only got a $10.00 bounty. That made barely a dent in the $13,000+ money I had. So I went to Valentine and paid my bounty...which I recovered quickly enough by playing poker in the Valentine saloon. Now I'll see how long it takes to break all the horses to complete the challenge.
I can't believe I didn't come across your channel sooner! Your videos are incredibly helpful and well-edited, so it's easy to follow along and get everything right. RDR2 is my favorite game of all time, and while I've already played it through several times, I'm always looking for new ways to make my experience even more fun every time, and your videos will help me a lot in that regard on my next playthrough! Thanks!
Thanks for the good words, it's really appreciated! Yeah RDR2 is great, im about to start another playthrough, wiating for the eater break to get plenty of time for it!
I found a Hungarian Halfbred with the Tennessee walkers in the heartlands, had the same coat as John's horse. I needed a Nokota, American Paint, American Standardbred and Mustang, this was massively helpful, as are all your RDR2 videos.
By the way, Horseman Challenge #9 still works (October, 2022). I entered Tall Trees crossing the Owanjila dam, went through the road behind Manzanita Post, entered the streets of Blackwater, coming from West, turned North and East again, leaving the Great Plains crossing Lower Montana River and leaving East of Fort Riggs. It was already evening. Arthur was gulping down Potent Health Cure like crazy. My horse was the White Arabian. I am still on Chapter 2. I hope this might help someone.
@@ItsArrwzdidn’t work for me :( I had the red Arabian , idk if I didn’t make it in time , I definitely never touched water and rode straight into black water post office
Just in case folks didn't know - you can find the Hungarian Half-Bred running around Little Creek River. You may have to camp overnight to get them to spawn - but they are there. It will be the Flaxen Chestnut - which can be mistaken for a different horse breed at a glance. I have seen them in the Heartlands as well - but that is more rare and I had to spend more time riding around. Once you have ridden/studied a horse, like stealing one (as in the Half-Bred from the Strauss mission in Chapter 2 at Painted Sky) - the game tends to let you then find that breed in "the wild" a little easier. I found this to be true with Mustang's (and most animals in the Compendium) - once you "ID" them, they seem to spawn more readily. I was in Chapter 2 of the story-mode when I spotted the Hungarian near Little Creek River. I was actually there looking for the American Standardbred when I saw 3 Flaxen Chestnuts - and again, this was _after_ I had ridden the Hungarian during the Wrobel collection mission in Chapter 2.
Wow, Challenge 9 was intense. I'm not sure if it's because of the newest Ultimate Edition, but when I entered Blackwater/New Austin (whatever) all the lawmen spawned _in front_ of me and I while I managed to somewhat evade them and got some distance with my Fox Trotter I still had to use around 25 Fortify II health potions because of the volley of bullets they sent towards me. A volley or two of bullets ripped through my fortify leaving me with around 50% of hp (and I had 9/10 lvl HP) so I really had to spam those potions. Anyway nice video and the route definitely works in June 2024. Just be sure to have loads of FORTIFY potions with you, because a single volley would have most likely killed me even though my full hp is 90% of the full circle. Thanks, nice video!
Bro you don't have to pause the game everytime you want to open the map!! Just hold the pause button and it will take you directly to the map. Just a little more convenent :D
For me the Easiest horseman 5 challange - after entering rhodes (from the 4th challange) just lasso someone from the train station n go back the rail track until u see challange complete.. u might get 1 or 2 witnesses.. but its ok.
Thanks for all the help. Just completed horseman challenge 9 as Arthur. Lots of excitement and gunfire but I just followed your exact route and it worked.
If you have a big enough horse you can just jump into blackwater over the little bridge rather than going up and all around owanjia. Timing is key though otherwise you smash into it and fall down the cliff 😅 so it's more timing and skill but it saves soo much time and you don't have to deal with bounty hunters at all until you have to leave blackwater. Practice it several times on your own before doing the actual run.
I just finished this challenge. On a Belgian, I took the broken bridge shortcut. If you are using keyboard/mouse simply double tap the spacebar to jump. No tonics, just 'pat' your horse constantly, every 10 seconds or so, and the stamina refills for the whole run. I took the southern route through the Bayou.
I've been trying to complete Horseman 10 through all of Chapter 4. I can't stay in the area south of the river for more than 30 seconds without Pinkertons attacking me, no matter how close I stay to the edge of the area. Not sure if this has been patched since this video released or if I'm just having terrible luck, but it seems to be impossible to complete this challenge prior to the Epilogue, now (December 2023).
I'm trying right now. I've found the Hungarian Half Breed closer to Emerald Ranch. Look there. Right now I'm looking for the last one - American Paint.
You actually don't have to fully go to blackwater, go to the area that sticks out just North of Blackwater - cross the tracks at flatneck station and just go as far south as you can along the coast - for some reason that counts as Blackwater - I was able to complete it just last week in Ch 2.
I use Hungarian Hal breed horse from The "Snake Oil Salesman" bounty as it is big enough to make a jump across the broken bridge on Upper Montana River - way quicker, just practice the jump. A hint Speed isn't a key in the jump, its the precision and timing.
Man, thanks for make this video, you helped a lot, that last one was super difficult, including the hungarian halfbred, but with this video made be possible👍
If you don't want to keep dying trying to find the hungarian halfbred at the great plains, try to go to little creek river. I find the horse there, I even find the american standardbred and appaloosa horse there too.
Speed for this is not a big factor, I've done it with a Tennessee walker, trick is not to fall off or get killed and don't get to far ahead of your pursers it keeps them from respawning so quick. Once they spawn I try to keep them on my radar behind me. Take the north road going into Blackwater and ride towards the river and following the shoreline to safety.
Horseman 10, Hungarian Halfbred, I followed your method 24:01. The Pinkertons always spawn even Arthur is close to water giving absolutely no time to waste. After so many tries, I decided to do it 'unnatural' way, I'm charging the Hungarian with my horse and the collision stunt the horse giving some time for Arthur to get on the Hungarian and break it. Meanwhile the Pinkertons start spawning and shooting at Arthur, while he try to calming the horse "easy boy" in the middle of shootout. Finally the Hungarian break but unfortunately Arthur died in the process. Arthur lost about $100+ plus $5 bounty. Totally worth it.
Oh boy, I'm doing another playthrough right now and I'm going throw the horseman challenge, first time on the playstation so hopefully I have better luck. When i did the video on xbox and pc I got away with staying close to the water so fingers crossed, otherwise yeah, i'll fork the money hahah
bro u saved my life, spent 3 hours in little creek for american paint but ouldnt find one, but went to ur location and i did 2 times :d the first time when i tried to break the house we went of the cliff lol
I’m in chapter three and just took this challenge on! Only horses left to tame is the Tennessee and mustang! Should be an easy finish tomorrow when I’m back on! 👌🏼😁
Huge life hack for anyone seeing this, if you get a wanted level when your passing through strawberry and have a cop or 2 follow you all the way to black water then no Pinkertons will spawn at all
And for the horseman challenge 7 just kill the lemoyne raiders at shady belle while on horseback, that way after finishing that you just go straight for killing alligators
After hours of searching between The Heartlands and Little Creek River I finally found the Hungarian Halfbred casually eating grass with his buddy TW at The Heartlands near Larned Sod Finally finished the horseman challenge!!!
Horseman 10: I've spotted Hungarian Halfbred near O'Creagh's lake (I was not on 10 yet, ive completed as you instructed) and in a few more spots that i dont remember now... There is places with 2-3 different horse breeds together, making it easy to complete the challenge. Thanks alot for the tutorial mister!
Hey, yeah before challenge 10 I spotted the Hungarian near emerald station and flatneck station, but when I reached challenge i spent a lot of time between those places to see if it would spawn and nothing ahah, the most consistent spot was across the river. And yeah you're right, if you go in big valley for example you can find a heard of 2-4 different breed! Cheers
If you don't want to get the law after you during horseman 9, then there is an easier method for you. Ride from vanhorn to flatneck station and cross the bridge now you don't go to tall trees or whatever instead you go to the shore near the Blackwater and the challenge will be completed without any law after you
I hardly entered the wanted zone, 8 pinkertons spawned in front of me, saw me from a mile away, one-shot my horse even tho I used special horse medicine and killed me in three shots while I had special healt cure
When I found the Hungarian Half bred he bucked right up to and off the cliff edge and died before being tamed. 😔 It took real-time days to get another to spawn with several bounty hunter / lawmen interventions. I then replayed the rev Swanson mission and took him with me instead of returning him to camp. Once accross the river I searched for the Hungarian half bred unmolested by law. As you are in a mission supplies are very limited and if you don't find the Hungarian immediately your horses stamina will deplete quickly as it's carrying two, so upon crossing the river grab a npc horse or tame one and place swanson on there, you will then have enough stamina to find and tame the Hungarian. I know this works if you take Swanson or bounty fugitive Allbright with you. I completed the blackwater dash by jumping the broken bridge but you can also avoid the jump by taking Allbright with you to avoid the law shooting at you, it won't work with Swanson replay as you don't have a horse with sufficient stamina or horse stimulants. But that damn American paint just will not spawn for me anywhere 😡 three real weeks later and I'm still sesrching😂
I was in the heartlands looking for the Mustang or Standardbred but ended up finding a Stallion Hungarian Halfbred instead.. I decided to keep it and saddled it for my main horse.
am I even going to be able to complete this challenge as John in the Epilogue? none of the horses are spawning where indicated, all I keep running across are Morgans
lol. Talk about the hard way. Dry run Van Horn to Blackwater follow train tracks through Saint Denis, to Rhodes to Bards Crossing, then jump off left and follow beach to peninsula across from Blackwater. It is that easy.
Funny enough, in challenge 9 I almost did it in the first try but felt, then needed 5 more tries to do it. In the last challenge I was having troubles finding the mustang, hours and hours without success, and when I felt like everything was a waste of time I found the Hulgarian around the heartlands and tame it without an issue. I haven't found the mustang yet.
Horseman 9 Challenge is indeed still possible, but it also felt way harder than how it looks in this video, i had to constantly drink special and potent health cures, like every 2 seconds because i couldn't lose the hunters at all and they shot at me as if they had miniguns from GTA 5... I even had all of the Talismans and Trinkets crafted, as i pretty much picked up all of the accessible collectibles in Chapter 2, so i was about as ready as i could be!
Yeah i feel i had runs without too many pinkertons on my back and some where they destroy it instantly; eating minty big game meat to get some gold cores helps too
In my experience the lasso dragging challenge absolutely had to be one victim. It reset to 0 if he came loose. I just roped a camper at the beach and dragged him up and down the sand though. Pretty easy.
Just found out, there is an other wild Hungarian Halfbred. I broke it between Hanged Dog Farm and that Hunting Cabin on stilt in woods. Near the place where Antler Knife can be found.
Yeah i found some in the heartlands near emerald station, and near flatneck station as well as in big valley where you mentioned too but never when it was time for challenge 10 haha The only real reliable spawn for me was across the river in west Elizabeth
@@jonoingame And BTW, Thanks for these Challeges made Easy videos. I've given up this game so many times cause it is so huge, even overwhelming sometimes. Your videos has made challenges and achievments possible for me.
When first playing RDR2, I completed Horseman 1 before I even realized challenges were a thing... I had just been trampling rabbits because I thought it was funny the first time I did it by accident.
I was doing the horseman 9, I had failed once by an npc cutting me off on owanjilla dam and had to reload; on the second try I was just outside of blackwater when that blind beggar dude caused my horse to slow down! I killed that dude so brutally that he may have vanished from all my other saves as well :))))
I tried the van horn to blackwater 4 times already. I stepped on a puddle, got knocked off my horse twice because it aimed for a tree on its own and just now I got to Blackwater and it didn't register God knows why. Soon as I crossed the line which marks the city's territory, I got shot by a police patrol. 150% life (because of medicine) to zero in 3 seconds.
I tried beelining from the railroad track near Van Horn to Flatneck station went over the shallowest bit of water while on a horse path and the challenge didn’t register
I felt really conflicted about having to drag some poor sod behind my horse, then I came across a KKK Rally. Such luck! Waited for the newb to set himself on fire, then grabbed the Grand Dragon, heheheh. He literally exclaimed "Oh lord, won't anybody help me?" before he died. No sir. No they won't. Someone did witness me doing it tho, and I got a bounty. Apparently dragging a Grand Dragon of the KKK to his death runs about $10. Worth it.
Another nice choice for Challenge #4 is Jeremiah Compson, the former slave hunter whom asks Arthur to get his pocket watch, his old pistol and his "ledger" back from his house that has been taken by the bank.
I think they changed where the Hungarian Halfbred spawns so that they’re just out of reach, and you’ll be swarmed by Pinkertons. Also tried going over with a bounty, but then no horses spawned. About to give up 🤦🏻♂️
Hey, i did it recently and i found the trick is really to stay closer to the river when approaching the horse. I generally scout from the other side and make sure there’s no trouble on the other side.
@@jonoingame ah, I see. I’d try it, but I lucked out and found the Hungarian Halfbred by Flatneck Station. Remembered you’d mentioned they spawn there occasionally. Was actually a lot faster than attempting to get it near Blackwater. Tried so many times! 🤦🏻♂️😅
Hungarian half bred also can be found on heartlands i was searching for mustang and found hungarian halfbred. First i want to tame halfbred because its tricky to go on black water but everytime pinkertons was on me so i decided to tame other horse first. But then i saw halfbred on heartlands very luck
Haha seems like your game is spawning them everywhere! I saw some Hungarian near flagstaff once on xbox. The mustang spawn rate is low a bit compare to the other horses there though.
17:49 The first time I didn't manage time. The second time was perfect but in blackwater between (GREAT) G and R, a cougar was waiting and the horse dropped me and ran but 3rd time managed somehow and completed
Man i almost had it but then some lawmen found me and while cutting through tall trees i tripped over a rock and fell down 😂 my thumb hurts so bad rn but i'd rather do this than the triathlons in gta 5
Are you playing on PC, Xbox or PS4? I ask because as soon as I set a toe in the Blackwater area I am swarmed by Pinkerton's. The _only_ time I was able to cross was near the cliffs just West of Blackwater (near where the Javier mission to rescue a member of the gang) is waiting for you. If I crossed anywhere else downstream, I didn't make it very far past the shore line/cliffs.
I could never make the jump on my XBox but did it with a level one Arabian on my PS4. On my XBox I tried ever possible horse and leveled them up and they would never make the jump on that broken bridge.
Doing it at night haha you do like a challenge eh!! I've seen the ghost train before but i never to the challenges at night time, was it the first time you saw it?
I totally screwed up horseman challenge 9 somehow, as soon as i got to strawberry the horse slowed down and once i was in tall trees some wildlife spooked the horse and it stopped going full speed (thankfully i wasnt thrown off) I followed the routes as close as i could but i didnt even get it
Hey! You need to stay close to the cliff, if you go too far inland the lawmen will appear, you can still get the hungarian halfbreed thoug, it happened to me once when i was taming it and they just came at me haha, got shot a bit but once calmed i ran away with the halfbreed haha
@@dakine808shooter haha yeah this bit is keeping you on edge, i generally make sure i see the horse first go for it, tame it as fast as i can and run away!! With abit of luck no lawmen will come at you!
Been using your go to vids for well over a year now jono there brilliant ime doing a second play through as want to get the platinum trophy i got the hungarian half bred in big vally to complete horseman 10 " and ime happy to inform you that there is a constant " HUNGARIAN HALF BREAD " sporn in big vally its brown with white main and tail its sporned for me 5 days in a row hope this helps people out 👍
Help please! As soon as I pass the winding stretch of road in Tall Trees, a posse of Pinkertons awaits me. Seven or eight easily. It's impossible to find a way through them. The videos are really great and helpful, I'm just wondering if anyone else has a problem with a group of Pinkertons. I'm so close to finish the horseman challenge and don't want to quit. Any ideas? The tutorial is old, perhaps they fixed it (or made it at least immensely difficult) since it was posted? By the way, I trampled turkeys. They are slower, bigger and also appear in a group - like ducks. As for predators, I simply shot gators in the swamp. Quick and even easier than birds.
I just finished Horseman challenge 9 with the slowest horse in the game. Even though I got killed in Blackwater after completing the challenge it was worth it . The slowest horse in the game.. and offline which proves the video Horseman Challenge number 9 with the slowest horse is not a fluke. Because we all know that some videos are edited
Oh yeah you have plenty of time to do challenge 9, the real challenge is not to fall of the horse, run into a tree or an NPC haha . I like to do it with an arabian for the superior handling, the turns are a bit more sharp and responsive but yeah like you said timewise, any horse can do!
'DO NOT STUDY HORSE ITS 'I found the half bread after I finish horse backchallenges1-8, then go to Valentie finish the mission do not do the mission in black water. FINISH CHALLENGLE 9 then go up to the Upper Montana River the then go the area Juto shows you would see other animals do not scare them the horse will beter if you did horse the go the Fort Riggs shore look around for a group with dead eye now study each one will be the horse now the rest will be a peace of cake thank you JOTO IN GAME
Hello....for challenge 7, how long do you need to wait before the 2 backup O'driscolls to arrive? I've been waiting for 30 minute now, I even put quite a distance from their place to show up
Hey normally by the time i loot the other O'driscolls is enough for them to show off, but they won't come by 100% of the time, if they don't come just finding another camp in the heartlands is a good solution.
Haha yeah it's another challenge to trample them later on, the game makes a distinction on that point apparently. I got caught too as I ran over some rabbits and thought they counted but nop haha
@@AceGoodheart haha yeah I took me while to realise i took it might be a glitch at some point but after hunting for a bit i realise i had to shoot them.
After completing master hunter challange 1 Get the vermint (small game) rifle and u can complete 2 challange at once. ( master hunter challange 2 - three perfect rabbit pelts i think).
@@deadknightdistrict Oh yeah there are definitely some challenges that you can do at the same and that complements each other, the weapons, herbalist and survival one have some similar ones too.
When I got to black water area there was tons of puddles on the road etc. you have to be real specific about these things. Falling off the horse cancels it. I tried at night. Hit a ditch right before black water. Fell off my horse 😡
I use both. i calm it as i approach, pat, jump on it's back and break it with the left stick and calm it from time to time, when done i continue calming it and feeding it until it reaches level 1 bonding.
All the Timestamps are in the Description to easily jump to the challenge you need. Cheers
The name of Song plz
You deserve two likes for that mate. 👍🏽👍🏽
I'm mighty glad RUclips introduced timestamps 👍🏽👍🏽
@@garrusvakarian3451 Yeah timestamps are the best haha i hate having to navigate a video to find what i'm looking for haha
For getting the Hungarian Halfbred, I was getting killed constantly so I tried the bounty trick and it worked. Just start a bounty mission from any town. I did the Ellie Anne Swan one in Valentine as it was the closest. Capture the bounty and ride into blackwater. Lawmen won't spawn in Blackwater during bounty hunting missions. It was a piece of cake this way. Good Luck.
You can also do this for Horseman 9.
Yeah the Halfbred spawned in the heartlands and flatneck station too for me but not in a consistent way.
Does it still work?
Can you can ride all the way from van horn to blackwater with the bounty on the back of your horse?
@@jonoingame
The Piebald?
I can confirm as of 13th July 2022 that Hungarian half-breds spawn in little creek river area along with American standardbreds
After a couple of years I’ve decided to play again and this year I want to try to get 100% completion in this game or at least pretty close. It’s such an amazing video game. A master piece. Very cool video bro. Suscribed.
Did you get 100%? I know this is a year later but I just wanted to see if you accomplished your goal
Your "challenge made easy" videos are brilliant. I hadn't thought of crows, ravens and vultures as "birds of prey" and your method of _luring_ them works brilliantly. When I saw that horseman 9 required a trip to Blackwater, I thought I'd have to wait until the epilogue to do it. Using your guide, I made it (although it took a few tries due to running into trees and what not) using _no_ health tonics (although I _did_ use several horse stimulants). I only got a $10.00 bounty. That made barely a dent in the $13,000+ money I had. So I went to Valentine and paid my bounty...which I recovered quickly enough by playing poker in the Valentine saloon. Now I'll see how long it takes to break all the horses to complete the challenge.
Keep 'patting' your horse and the stamina refills with no stimulant.
@@stosh64 Yeah. I learnt that later. I _did_ break all the horses...and it was "long and arduous" as the video stated.
Thank You My Friend. A Nicely Put Together Video That’s Useful For Everyone Who Struggles With Finding The Last Few Horses. Your A Diamond Buddy !!!
haha thanks for the good words! Yeah that challenge takes a bit of time to get them all!
For those of ya who are doing this challenge at the same time as me the big purple flower field in big valley is the go to place for horses
I can't believe I didn't come across your channel sooner! Your videos are incredibly helpful and well-edited, so it's easy to follow along and get everything right. RDR2 is my favorite game of all time, and while I've already played it through several times, I'm always looking for new ways to make my experience even more fun every time, and your videos will help me a lot in that regard on my next playthrough! Thanks!
Thanks for the good words, it's really appreciated! Yeah RDR2 is great, im about to start another playthrough, wiating for the eater break to get plenty of time for it!
Thank you. Your Challenges series is the easiest to follow.
Thanks for the good words! cheers
I found a Hungarian Halfbred with the Tennessee walkers in the heartlands, had the same coat as John's horse. I needed a Nokota, American Paint, American Standardbred and Mustang, this was massively helpful, as are all your RDR2 videos.
Me too
By the way, Horseman Challenge #9 still works (October, 2022). I entered Tall Trees crossing the Owanjila dam, went through the road behind Manzanita Post, entered the streets of Blackwater, coming from West, turned North and East again, leaving the Great Plains crossing Lower Montana River and leaving East of Fort Riggs. It was already evening. Arthur was gulping down Potent Health Cure like crazy. My horse was the White Arabian. I am still on Chapter 2. I hope this might help someone.
Still working february 2023
@@ItsArrwzdidn’t work for me :( I had the red Arabian , idk if I didn’t make it in time , I definitely never touched water and rode straight into black water post office
@@santi_super_stunts2573 did you fall of horse at any time as if you fall or dismount horse you have to start again
@@sprockylock391 Thanks for this info
@@santi_super_stunts2573 it definitely still works.
Thank you so much for all of these videos! After finally having the opportunity to replay this game I am going for 100%!
Made it thanks to your excellent video. For me, the last 4 horses all spawned next to little creek.
Oh that's nice, i like when they all bunched together, makes it easier.
Just in case folks didn't know - you can find the Hungarian Half-Bred running around Little Creek River. You may have to camp overnight to get them to spawn - but they are there. It will be the Flaxen Chestnut - which can be mistaken for a different horse breed at a glance. I have seen them in the Heartlands as well - but that is more rare and I had to spend more time riding around. Once you have ridden/studied a horse, like stealing one (as in the Half-Bred from the Strauss mission in Chapter 2 at Painted Sky) - the game tends to let you then find that breed in "the wild" a little easier. I found this to be true with Mustang's (and most animals in the Compendium) - once you "ID" them, they seem to spawn more readily. I was in Chapter 2 of the story-mode when I spotted the Hungarian near Little Creek River. I was actually there looking for the American Standardbred when I saw 3 Flaxen Chestnuts - and again, this was _after_ I had ridden the Hungarian during the Wrobel collection mission in Chapter 2.
YEah I found that too!! I've seen the hungarian near emerald ranch and flatneck station too but that was after completing the challenge.
@@jonoingame just a tip but you can also lure horses with the herbivore bait if its a common horse spawn spot.
Wow, Challenge 9 was intense. I'm not sure if it's because of the newest Ultimate Edition, but when I entered Blackwater/New Austin (whatever) all the lawmen spawned _in front_ of me and I while I managed to somewhat evade them and got some distance with my Fox Trotter I still had to use around 25 Fortify II health potions because of the volley of bullets they sent towards me. A volley or two of bullets ripped through my fortify leaving me with around 50% of hp (and I had 9/10 lvl HP) so I really had to spam those potions. Anyway nice video and the route definitely works in June 2024. Just be sure to have loads of FORTIFY potions with you, because a single volley would have most likely killed me even though my full hp is 90% of the full circle. Thanks, nice video!
Bro you don't have to pause the game everytime you want to open the map!! Just hold the pause button and it will take you directly to the map. Just a little more convenent :D
haha yeah I learnt about it late in my gameplay but I'm too used to go by the pause menu haha I don't even think about it haha
I'm glad I know now
Great video. I got all of them, and had a shootout after breaking the Hungarian. I still love this game after all these year’s.
For me the Easiest horseman 5 challange - after entering rhodes (from the 4th challange) just lasso someone from the train station n go back the rail track until u see challange complete.. u might get 1 or 2 witnesses.. but its ok.
Oh that's a good one too, the less witnesses the better haha
Thanks for all the help. Just completed horseman challenge 9 as Arthur. Lots of excitement and gunfire but I just followed your exact route and it worked.
Thanks glad it helped and yeah haha once near blackwater they shoot at you like there’s no tomorrow haha
If you have a big enough horse you can just jump into blackwater over the little bridge rather than going up and all around owanjia. Timing is key though otherwise you smash into it and fall down the cliff 😅 so it's more timing and skill but it saves soo much time and you don't have to deal with bounty hunters at all until you have to leave blackwater. Practice it several times on your own before doing the actual run.
That rave too black water had my heart pumping and I’ve beat the game at least 5 times
I just finished this challenge. On a Belgian, I took the broken bridge shortcut. If you are using keyboard/mouse simply double tap the spacebar to jump. No tonics, just 'pat' your horse constantly, every 10 seconds or so, and the stamina refills for the whole run. I took the southern route through the Bayou.
I've been trying to complete Horseman 10 through all of Chapter 4. I can't stay in the area south of the river for more than 30 seconds without Pinkertons attacking me, no matter how close I stay to the edge of the area. Not sure if this has been patched since this video released or if I'm just having terrible luck, but it seems to be impossible to complete this challenge prior to the Epilogue, now (December 2023).
I'm trying right now. I've found the Hungarian Half Breed closer to Emerald Ranch. Look there. Right now I'm looking for the last one - American Paint.
You actually don't have to fully go to blackwater, go to the area that sticks out just North of Blackwater - cross the tracks at flatneck station and just go as far south as you can along the coast - for some reason that counts as Blackwater - I was able to complete it just last week in Ch 2.
I use Hungarian Hal breed horse from The "Snake Oil Salesman" bounty as it is big enough to make a jump across the broken bridge on Upper Montana River - way quicker, just practice the jump. A hint Speed isn't a key in the jump, its the precision and timing.
You can also put a bounty person in your horseback and go to blackwater without the law to react put it won't stop the sniper in south
Man, thanks for make this video, you helped a lot, that last one was super difficult, including the hungarian halfbred, but with this video made be possible👍
If you don't want to keep dying trying to find the hungarian halfbred at the great plains, try to go to little creek river. I find the horse there, I even find the american standardbred and appaloosa horse there too.
Yeah i found it too near flatneck station, but never when i need too for the challenge hahah
@@jonoingame you know it's been a year and I just realized that I fucked up my comment, I meant the big valley, not the great plains 😂
Regarding the Hungarian halfbred, the reason no law came after you is because of the Javier escuela mission
Speed for this is not a big factor, I've done it with a Tennessee walker, trick is not to fall off or get killed and don't get to far ahead of your pursers it keeps them from respawning so quick. Once they spawn I try to keep them on my radar behind me. Take the north road going into Blackwater and ride towards the river and following the shoreline to safety.
I completed this on a Belgian using the broken bridge.
Horseman 10, Hungarian Halfbred, I followed your method 24:01. The Pinkertons always spawn even Arthur is close to water giving absolutely no time to waste. After so many tries, I decided to do it 'unnatural' way, I'm charging the Hungarian with my horse and the collision stunt the horse giving some time for Arthur to get on the Hungarian and break it. Meanwhile the Pinkertons start spawning and shooting at Arthur, while he try to calming the horse "easy boy" in the middle of shootout. Finally the Hungarian break but unfortunately Arthur died in the process. Arthur lost about $100+ plus $5 bounty. Totally worth it.
Oh boy, I'm doing another playthrough right now and I'm going throw the horseman challenge, first time on the playstation so hopefully I have better luck. When i did the video on xbox and pc I got away with staying close to the water so fingers crossed, otherwise yeah, i'll fork the money hahah
bro u saved my life, spent 3 hours in little creek for american paint but ouldnt find one, but went to ur location and i did 2 times :d
the first time when i tried to break the house we went of the cliff lol
I’m in chapter three and just took this challenge on! Only horses left to tame is the Tennessee and mustang! Should be an easy finish tomorrow when I’m back on! 👌🏼😁
Oh yeah you should find them quite easily, the mustang might pop up less but it wont be too much trouble.
Huge life hack for anyone seeing this, if you get a wanted level when your passing through strawberry and have a cop or 2 follow you all the way to black water then no Pinkertons will spawn at all
The second i got into tall trees, 6 Pinkertons beamed me and i died within seconds even with potent miracle tonic:(
The fastest/easiest way I found to do horseman 8 was killing gators in the swamps. it’s super easy either way though.
Oh yeah that's a good tip right there, thanks for sharing!
And for the horseman challenge 7 just kill the lemoyne raiders at shady belle while on horseback, that way after finishing that you just go straight for killing alligators
After hours of searching between The Heartlands and Little Creek River I finally found the Hungarian Halfbred casually eating grass with his buddy TW at The Heartlands near Larned Sod
Finally finished the horseman challenge!!!
Horseman 10: I've spotted Hungarian Halfbred near O'Creagh's lake (I was not on 10 yet, ive completed as you instructed) and in a few more spots that i dont remember now...
There is places with 2-3 different horse breeds together, making it easy to complete the challenge.
Thanks alot for the tutorial mister!
Hey, yeah before challenge 10 I spotted the Hungarian near emerald station and flatneck station, but when I reached challenge i spent a lot of time between those places to see if it would spawn and nothing ahah, the most consistent spot was across the river. And yeah you're right, if you go in big valley for example you can find a heard of 2-4 different breed! Cheers
@@jonoingame I’ve made a trip from valentine to emerald ranch and completed 4 breeds on the way 😂
@@lucascorreadl haha yeah in the heartlands it's a good spot for that, especially if you get a mustang on the way!
Great videos always! So easy to follow along. Consistent results. Keep up the great work.
Thanks for the good words, it's really appreciated!
twenty hundred lol I love how you talk my brutha!! It's my new 2grand now tyvm ;)
Jono,you’re a legend!! Thank you!
fantastic upload Jono In Game. I broke the thumbs up on your video. Continue to keep up the outstanding work.
Haha thanks for the good words, it's greatly appreciated!
If you don't want to get the law after you during horseman 9, then there is an easier method for you.
Ride from vanhorn to flatneck station and cross the bridge now you don't go to tall trees or whatever instead you go to the shore near the Blackwater and the challenge will be completed without any law after you
Really like your videos mate 👍🏼
Mint guide 🤙🏼
haha thanks for the good words!
I hardly entered the wanted zone, 8 pinkertons spawned in front of me, saw me from a mile away, one-shot my horse even tho I used special horse medicine and killed me in three shots while I had special healt cure
Woa ruthless, normally you can get away with being shot quite a bit!
yup same here got two shots every time
When I found the Hungarian Half bred he bucked right up to and off the cliff edge and died before being tamed. 😔 It took real-time days to get another to spawn with several bounty hunter / lawmen interventions. I then replayed the rev Swanson mission and took him with me instead of returning him to camp. Once accross the river I searched for the Hungarian half bred unmolested by law. As you are in a mission supplies are very limited and if you don't find the Hungarian immediately your horses stamina will deplete quickly as it's carrying two, so upon crossing the river grab a npc horse or tame one and place swanson on there, you will then have enough stamina to find and tame the Hungarian. I know this works if you take Swanson or bounty fugitive Allbright with you.
I completed the blackwater dash by jumping the broken bridge but you can also avoid the jump by taking Allbright with you to avoid the law shooting at you, it won't work with Swanson replay as you don't have a horse with sufficient stamina or horse stimulants.
But that damn American paint just will not spawn for me anywhere 😡 three real weeks later and I'm still sesrching😂
I was in the heartlands looking for the Mustang or Standardbred but ended up finding a Stallion Hungarian Halfbred instead.. I decided to keep it and saddled it for my main horse.
am I even going to be able to complete this challenge as John in the Epilogue? none of the horses are spawning where indicated, all I keep running across are Morgans
lol. Talk about the hard way. Dry run Van Horn to Blackwater follow train tracks through Saint Denis, to Rhodes to Bards Crossing, then jump off left and follow beach to peninsula across from Blackwater. It is that easy.
Funny enough, in challenge 9 I almost did it in the first try but felt, then needed 5 more tries to do it. In the last challenge I was having troubles finding the mustang, hours and hours without success, and when I felt like everything was a waste of time I found the Hulgarian around the heartlands and tame it without an issue. I haven't found the mustang yet.
Horseman 9 Challenge is indeed still possible, but it also felt way harder than how it looks in this video, i had to constantly drink special and potent health cures, like every 2 seconds because i couldn't lose the hunters at all and they shot at me as if they had miniguns from GTA 5... I even had all of the Talismans and Trinkets crafted, as i pretty much picked up all of the accessible collectibles in Chapter 2, so i was about as ready as i could be!
Yeah i feel i had runs without too many pinkertons on my back and some where they destroy it instantly; eating minty big game meat to get some gold cores helps too
In my experience the lasso dragging challenge absolutely had to be one victim. It reset to 0 if he came loose.
I just roped a camper at the beach and dragged him up and down the sand though. Pretty easy.
Yeah they become ennemis too when you lasso off their horses haha the victim can die too, if you look at the progress it will still continue to count.
Just found out, there is an other wild Hungarian Halfbred. I broke it between Hanged Dog Farm and that Hunting Cabin on stilt in woods. Near the place where Antler Knife can be found.
Yeah i found some in the heartlands near emerald station, and near flatneck station as well as in big valley where you mentioned too but never when it was time for challenge 10 haha The only real reliable spawn for me was across the river in west Elizabeth
@@jonoingame And BTW, Thanks for these Challeges made Easy videos. I've given up this game so many times cause it is so huge, even overwhelming sometimes. Your videos has made challenges and achievments possible for me.
@@tippikuppi Thanks a lot, glad it helped! YEah there's a lot to do for sure even just outside the main story, and it's tough to know where to start!
When first playing RDR2, I completed Horseman 1 before I even realized challenges were a thing... I had just been trampling rabbits because I thought it was funny the first time I did it by accident.
I was doing the horseman 9, I had failed once by an npc cutting me off on owanjilla dam and had to reload; on the second try I was just outside of blackwater when that blind beggar dude caused my horse to slow down! I killed that dude so brutally that he may have vanished from all my other saves as well :))))
Fun fact
Most breeds can be found along little creek river near hanging dog ranch
haha true, i found a bunch of 5 nakotas there, out of the blue, it's really random though.
Somehow managed to find a Hungarian Halfbred in the safe side of West Elizabeth
I tried the van horn to blackwater 4 times already. I stepped on a puddle, got knocked off my horse twice because it aimed for a tree on its own and just now I got to Blackwater and it didn't register God knows why. Soon as I crossed the line which marks the city's territory, I got shot by a police patrol. 150% life (because of medicine) to zero in 3 seconds.
Just did this today and unfortunately I had the warped brindle Arabian at level 2. It was a success first try. Thanks 🙏
Wow! i found 7 horse breeds in the in the first location except american standardbred and mustang.. thank you sir!
I always end up falling off my horse at challenge 9, it’s so frustrating
I tried beelining from the railroad track near Van Horn to Flatneck station went over the shallowest bit of water while on a horse path and the challenge didn’t register
I felt really conflicted about having to drag some poor sod behind my horse, then I came across a KKK Rally. Such luck! Waited for the newb to set himself on fire, then grabbed the Grand Dragon, heheheh. He literally exclaimed "Oh lord, won't anybody help me?" before he died. No sir. No they won't. Someone did witness me doing it tho, and I got a bounty. Apparently dragging a Grand Dragon of the KKK to his death runs about $10. Worth it.
haha nice one, and well worth the bounty to bring some justice in this world.
Another nice choice for Challenge #4 is Jeremiah Compson, the former slave hunter whom asks Arthur to get his pocket watch, his old pistol and his "ledger" back from his house that has been taken by the bank.
I found the Hungarian Halfbred first try luckily
Challenge 8 is super easy in bluewater marsh. Gators galore
I found a Hungarian halfbred near Wallace station and mustangs
I think they changed where the Hungarian Halfbred spawns so that they’re just out of reach, and you’ll be swarmed by Pinkertons. Also tried going over with a bounty, but then no horses spawned. About to give up 🤦🏻♂️
Hey, i did it recently and i found the trick is really to stay closer to the river when approaching the horse. I generally scout from the other side and make sure there’s no trouble on the other side.
@@jonoingame ah, I see. I’d try it, but I lucked out and found the Hungarian Halfbred by Flatneck Station. Remembered you’d mentioned they spawn there occasionally. Was actually a lot faster than attempting to get it near Blackwater. Tried so many times! 🤦🏻♂️😅
@@andyscott5277 hahah oh yeah if you can get it to spawn at Flatneck go for it, way easier!
Yhank you dude I finished the challenge 💪🏻💪🏻
Just got a 300 dollar bounty jus to hear you can also get a hungarian halfbred at flatneck station too thanks for everything really
Hungarian half bred also can be found on heartlands i was searching for mustang and found hungarian halfbred. First i want to tame halfbred because its tricky to go on black water but everytime pinkertons was on me so i decided to tame other horse first. But then i saw halfbred on heartlands very luck
I found the Hungarian half-breed right next to where you said the mustang would be. I am however still searching for the mustang.
And another Hungarian Half-breed where the American Standerdbred should be... instead of the American Standardbred.
And another one right next to the Nakota, and ANOTHER one when I went back looking for the mustang.
Haha seems like your game is spawning them everywhere! I saw some Hungarian near flagstaff once on xbox. The mustang spawn rate is low a bit compare to the other horses there though.
17:49 The first time I didn't manage time. The second time was perfect but in blackwater between (GREAT) G and R, a cougar was waiting and the horse dropped me and ran but 3rd time managed somehow and completed
Great video ! Thanks
ThankS!
Thanks u just earned a new sub
Thanks! Like the name and profile pic haha
The best! Thanks!
I appreciate your work Big fan 😉
Thanks very much for the good words. it's really appreciated.
I can’t do number 9 I tried like 4 times but there’s always that one rider who you don’t see and bumps you off
4 times isn't really enough, took me hours to do
Man i almost had it but then some lawmen found me and while cutting through tall trees i tripped over a rock and fell down 😂 my thumb hurts so bad rn but i'd rather do this than the triathlons in gta 5
Was so close to black water than a dam Pinkerton literally charged my horse with his and knocked me off of my horse had to start all over
Challenge 9, Entered Tasse and 8 pinkertons spawn directly infront of me and made me a bullet sponge....
oof
Are you playing on PC, Xbox or PS4? I ask because as soon as I set a toe in the Blackwater area I am swarmed by Pinkerton's. The _only_ time I was able to cross was near the cliffs just West of Blackwater (near where the Javier mission to rescue a member of the gang) is waiting for you. If I crossed anywhere else downstream, I didn't make it very far past the shore line/cliffs.
Bro i lost my mind with this I started killing anything that ain't the horse I want
I could never make the jump on my XBox but did it with a level one Arabian on my PS4. On my XBox I tried ever possible horse and leveled them up and they would never make the jump on that broken bridge.
So was just me that ran into the ghost train then doing this at night 🤣
Doing it at night haha you do like a challenge eh!! I've seen the ghost train before but i never to the challenges at night time, was it the first time you saw it?
I totally screwed up horseman challenge 9 somehow, as soon as i got to strawberry the horse slowed down and once i was in tall trees some wildlife spooked the horse and it stopped going full speed (thankfully i wasnt thrown off)
I followed the routes as close as i could but i didnt even get it
idk how you got that Hungarian Halfbreed, as soon as I cross the river there's 10 lawman on me
Hey! You need to stay close to the cliff, if you go too far inland the lawmen will appear, you can still get the hungarian halfbreed thoug, it happened to me once when i was taming it and they just came at me haha, got shot a bit but once calmed i ran away with the halfbreed haha
@@jonoingame I'll try the cliff approach, however I just seemed to get smoked so fast hahaha.
@@dakine808shooter haha yeah this bit is keeping you on edge, i generally make sure i see the horse first go for it, tame it as fast as i can and run away!! With abit of luck no lawmen will come at you!
@@jonoingame dude alot of luck. I quit lol
Been using your go to vids for well over a year now jono there brilliant ime doing a second play through as want to get the platinum trophy i got the hungarian half bred in big vally to complete horseman 10 " and ime happy to inform you that there is a constant " HUNGARIAN HALF BREAD " sporn in big vally its brown with white main and tail its sporned for me 5 days in a row hope this helps people out 👍
I was lucky enough to find an Hungarian in The Heart lands.
Great help thanks 👍
Help please! As soon as I pass the winding stretch of road in Tall Trees, a posse of Pinkertons awaits me. Seven or eight easily. It's impossible to find a way through them. The videos are really great and helpful, I'm just wondering if anyone else has a problem with a group of Pinkertons. I'm so close to finish the horseman challenge and don't want to quit. Any ideas? The tutorial is old, perhaps they fixed it (or made it at least immensely difficult) since it was posted? By the way, I trampled turkeys. They are slower, bigger and also appear in a group - like ducks. As for predators, I simply shot gators in the swamp. Quick and even easier than birds.
Update... I made it!!!! Don't give up when a bunch of bounty hunters greet you. Eventually you will get lucky and run across a manageable number.
thanks! i try 3 times to go to blackwater and success
I just finished Horseman challenge 9 with the slowest horse in the game. Even though I got killed in Blackwater after completing the challenge it was worth it . The slowest horse in the game.. and offline which proves the video Horseman Challenge number 9 with the slowest horse is not a fluke. Because we all know that some videos are edited
Oh yeah you have plenty of time to do challenge 9, the real challenge is not to fall of the horse, run into a tree or an NPC haha . I like to do it with an arabian for the superior handling, the turns are a bit more sharp and responsive but yeah like you said timewise, any horse can do!
'DO NOT STUDY HORSE ITS 'I found the half bread after I finish horse backchallenges1-8, then go to Valentie finish the mission do not do the mission in black water. FINISH CHALLENGLE 9 then go up to the Upper Montana River the then go the area Juto shows you would see other animals do not scare them the horse will beter if you did horse the go the Fort Riggs shore look around for a group with dead eye now study each one will be the horse now the rest will be a peace of cake thank you JOTO IN GAME
Can I lasso then break? Or I need to walk and call for the horse then break it?
Hello....for challenge 7, how long do you need to wait before the 2 backup O'driscolls to arrive? I've been waiting for 30 minute now, I even put quite a distance from their place to show up
Hey normally by the time i loot the other O'driscolls is enough for them to show off, but they won't come by 100% of the time, if they don't come just finding another camp in the heartlands is a good solution.
Is there a problem I got the nokota blue roan before starting the challenge? LOL
Oh... so kill rabbits WHILE ON horseback. Silly me, I ran them over with the horse. Took a good little while. 😂
Haha yeah it's another challenge to trample them later on, the game makes a distinction on that point apparently. I got caught too as I ran over some rabbits and thought they counted but nop haha
I trampled them too. Grrrr. It was a bit time consuming.
@@AceGoodheart haha yeah I took me while to realise i took it might be a glitch at some point but after hunting for a bit i realise i had to shoot them.
After completing master hunter challange 1 Get the vermint (small game) rifle and u can complete 2 challange at once. ( master hunter challange 2 - three perfect rabbit pelts i think).
@@deadknightdistrict Oh yeah there are definitely some challenges that you can do at the same and that complements each other, the weapons, herbalist and survival one have some similar ones too.
I got it thanks your video is very helpful
Nice, glad the video helped!
When I got to black water area there was tons of puddles on the road etc. you have to be real specific about these things. Falling off the horse cancels it. I tried at night. Hit a ditch right before black water. Fell off my horse 😡
Hey, the puddles dont matter nor those the rain, it’s more the rivers and streams. It’s more of a speed run where you have to take bridges.
I like videos straight to the point
question - if you have already broken some of the wild horses before Q10 - does it "Credit" those.... or do you still have to go out and re-do them?
I think you have to redo them
When breaking a horse, do you use the joysticks any, or just calm the horse when indicated?
I use both. i calm it as i approach, pat, jump on it's back and break it with the left stick and calm it from time to time, when done i continue calming it and feeding it until it reaches level 1 bonding.
Great videos!!!
Thanks!